I am impressed of how controlled you are and with how much patience you are talking... because to be honest, I have been traumatized since two days. This novel ruined my mental health.
Same… I started reading mala last year when I was in deep depression and was going through extreme anxiety, so much that I couldn’t even go to work! Mala slowly started healing me… but now I feel so hopeless and down…
@@sparklingf4149 وہ ناول میں چول مارنے کے بعد پروڈک کی پرموشن کر رہی ہیں اپنے انسٹا پر ان کو پیسہ کمانا ہے😂 لوگ جائیں بھاڑ میں۔ اپنی لکھائی پر بڑا غرور ہے نمرہ باجی کو۔
Rabia you've put all the points really well. Two cents from my side: 1. Zareena was spared and didn't face the repercussions of her wrongdoing (as you've already mentioned) and got the dove pendent that she wanted. The way her character ended was unfulfilling. 2. What about Maalik and his ongoing placebo treatment? Did he die, or did he get cured? 3. What was the significance of Hilal's tapestry? 4. If happy birthday couldn't protect Mala's life, then why was it mentioned repeatedly? 5. Why Moeed wasn't there at Mala's funeral? 5. Last but not least, WHERE IS HEALING? HOW AM I SUPPOSED TO HEAL KNOWING THAT THE CHARACTER WHO SUFFERED THE MOST WAS MUR*ERED AND DIDN'T GET THE SECOND CHANCE? Why so many loose ends?
@@anooshatabassum375 I don't know. This ending made a kind of mess in our minds. And yes that hilal tapestry and Malik treatment thing was left incomplete.
I agree with you.. hm logo sy hope nahi leni chahie at least itna sb hony k bad acha hi hona chahie tha.. insan ka achai sy har cheez sy iman khatm ho jata hai
Being a mother to autistic kid, I was so happy she made Mala a mother who was a hero, but her death disturbed me as a mother, especially when Badar finally said MAMA only when Mala died..😢
I've been continuously crying since the last episode has came. Nemrah told us this was a healing journey but she left us all Traumatized. I learned alot alot from MAALA but nemrah did injustice to the character of maala and mahir.
Your review was true depiction of our feelings. Nemrah didn't do justice to the story. Bcz what i got from ending was literal sadness and disappointment that everything in the end will be destroyed. We demand a new ending.
Traumatised from 3 days..... mainay apni zindagi kai 3 saal Mala aur Mahir kai saath guzaray hain ab main chahti thi,hm sb chahtay thay kai Mala aur Mahir ko in sb traumas kai baad kch acha milay........Nemrah is such a wonderful writer, un k kitabain umeed daiti hain magar yahan main totally disappoint ho chuki hun.......hm readers itna zada un sai emotionally attached thay to ab hm deserve krtay thay kai humay happy ending milay......❤️🩹💜🤎🩶
Har episode sy phle hum suntay thay ziada tang kia to birbal ki garden py churi phair don gi. Phair daiti behan ap churi uske marnay sy ye trauma na milta. Maalik ko bacha lia jo chand din ka mehman tha. Maala ko out of no way maar dia. I have always defended nemrahs writing and her sayings but this time i am kinda hating nemrah her writings and all the time i wasted in reading maala
kash itna dard haqeeqat main martey hue apne muslims logon ka hota😢😢 mjhe bs is baat se takleef hui hai k novel k fake character ki death per itna gham aur apne Muslims k marne per zubaan band. pakistani hone per ab mjhe sharam ati hai😢
Thank u rabia ap ne hum sab k jezbad ko ache se bayan kia ap yaqeen kere 3 se 4 din mera hur cheez se dil ajeeb ho gaya is novel k end se yani sab lahasil? Mei tu chup chup k gher k kono mei khoob roi haha even mere husband ne tu mere novel hi band ker liye perhna
"When I heard rumors that Mala had died, I felt very sad. After reading a few pages, I became even sadder, so I skipped to the last pages. Then, I felt even more sorrowful. I kept wondering why Mahir had to survive through so much. He deserved a happy ending. I believe that people who endure so much in life are blessed by Allah with something beautiful in the end. I just didn’t have the courage to read the last episode completely because I felt so sad about Mahir."
Uff Rabia i can relate with you so much. The way maala was so soothing and so relatable for me end me wo umeed hi cheen li nemrah ahmed. The last epeisode just dissapointed us, atleast i wanted an ending wich would have been justified. I don't understand how the story after maala's death would progress, he will live alone, such a trauma honestly. You are right ''har mushkil k sath asani hoti hai'' but nemrah ahmed ne wo umeed jo unho ne khud di thi wo cheen li. We cannot change the words but jahan maala was my favourite novel and still holds a precious place in my heart, wahin maala ki death ne bus wo cherry on top mujhsele liya.
Rabia don't you think that this message(that how many women die from the hands of their husbands or exes) could've been given without killing Maala? We could've seen that Ziyad attempted to kill her but she survived.
After reading the episode I realized what my mother akways said " jinki zindagi dukhon se start hoti hai wo hamesha dukhon mai hi rehtay hain" and I always replied her that "mama buray k bd achay din ajatay hain" but the end proved my mother right and you're right always gives hopes to reader💔
Look it's just a fictional story. Written by a Human who is exactly like u and me. "Jinki Zindagi dukhon SE shuru Hoti ha wo dukhon main hi Marty hn" ye har bar sach Nahi hota. Agr fictional books SE hi inspiration Leni ha Tu instead of maala give a Try to Usri yusra (the best healing book) or manyyy others are here having a perfect happy ending. Maala ki ending SE ma bhi Relate Nahi kr saki lakin remember ye insna NE likhi ha or asal main kismat Allah hi Likha ha hum Allah ke faisle main ikhtear Nahi rakhty agr Zindagi dhukh main shuru hokr dukh main khatam ho bhi Jaye Tu ye zindagi humesha ke liye Nahi ha right?? Iska ajar Allah dega he dukh a ajar mile. Iski explanation ke liye Quran prhain. Asal umeed Quran hi dilaye ga Maala novel Nahi.
@@farzanajaved821 I agree. But Maala ka main purpose tha har us shaks k Liye Jo healing k rah or gamzan hai. Otherwise I always have hope whether it's tiny or big that at the end everything gonna be okay.
@@farzanajaved821I just don't understand what happened with her she always used to talk about hope, second chances in her every book. She introduced me with Quran contemplation. Namal ki wajah sy hy main pehli baar quran tadabbur sy introduce huwi thi. I just hope she started writing those inspiring stories again.
Nemrah is a great writer who mesmerized us by her words. I have read all her novels and she has always excelled to impress us. Mala has kept us hooked die to its grappling storyline but the ending has totally shaken me off. Did she not think about Badr?? Does any kid in the world deserve this.
I've been reading novels since I was in sixth grade, but I've never cried after reading a sad ending-until now. Nemrah is my favorite writer, and I really enjoy her novels. It feels like a journey I've gone through with her characters, but this ending... ugh. I recently read "Dana Pan,i" with a sad ending, but this one hit me personally. I feel so alone and empty; it's truly traumatizing. Why, Nemrah, why? Not everyone is meant to be together, but this ending has broken my heart. It feels like I’ve lost a loved one. I just want to see them together.
After reading last episode of mala I realized Nemrah hmein 3 saal se aik tragedy k liye tyar kr rahi thi aur hm Besabri se hr episode ka wait kr rhy thy….. 3 saal hm ne kahin na kahin mala bn k jiya aur end pe tragedy…. Mein 4 din se novel ki bat hi nahi kr paa rahi …. Mein bhoolna chahti hun sb ….. mein naan khatai waly scene ko Lahore ko hr cheez ko bhulna chahti hun I was waiting k kb mala khtm ho aur kb mein dubara se prhna start krun pr ab mein kbhi b dubara mala ka nam b ni Sunna chahungi… is mein sirf dukh hain….kuch characters hoty hain jo mr k zinda ho jatyy hain …. Mgr nemrah ne mala ko maar k usko hmesha k liye hi maar dya hai …. Mala novel mr gya h koi b dubara ni prhna chahy ga…
Mein ny apni friend k saath maala date rakhi thi hum mil k different Candles paint karty art piece banaty brown and purple. And what we got red blood. Hmary dukh ka rang to laal nikla.
I totally agree.. Even before the episode came i knew there would be no happy ending. I was sure Mala would say i am not ready yet maybe someday you know like Alif ended. There scenes were so beautifully written but all the characters were so out of their own zone, Like, Mahi why did she oppose on Mahir when he proposed? but we got a beautiful scene out of it. Mahir and Mala deserved some peace finally.. but.. I hated it that birble didn't change. People change when they loose someone. i didn't like how she ended it. it was rushed.. I didn't feel anything when Mala died.. When Umar Jahangir from Amarbail died i cried for days.. i still feel that pain i felt that day when i read that day.. but for Mala i felt bad that it was not at all needed when i was reading it. I did not like the last episode. so many loopholes.
You’ve done an excellent job as both a reader and a reviewer. I agree with your points, particularly that the trauma seems exaggerated and that Badar didn’t necessarily need to meet his father. For your next video, I would love for you to discuss the following points: 1- How does Asif know about the future and the manner of Mala’s death? She has been hearing the birthday sounds for such a long time. If these sounds are linked to her death, how does Asif know Mala will die in a bakery, especially when she says, “Nobody knows the future except Allah”? 2- What is the meaning of the "halal tapestry"? 3- Is Malik Fareed cured? Apologies if I missed any mention of his cancer therapy.
@@farzeensheikh2090 remember when they were taking mahir to mental asylum, hilal said , jb aap wapis aaen ge me yahn nhi hon gi...she predicted future back then too.. And when she used to say that badar will save me..though she had never met or known mala..that was also future..how?
100000% agreed with u rabia.... No doubt i m a big fan of Nemrah's writings but but but i m totally disappointed from the last episode maala nd mahir deserved happy ending...😢
Usne apne ammi ko shams se Buchanan ho ye Maala ko ziyad ki haqiqt btani ho usne hmeshs dair hi ki he, or usk bad Yasmeen k recaliner pe lait k afsos kiya he, therapy is important action ki kya zrurt he logon ko ghare me girne do
Completely honest review..... Bohat saarey loose points th, and I think mahir knows about Zara.... Last episode m jaha bohat saarey traumas ki BAAT hui h but healing nhi hui.... Nimrah ne jaha divorce ko nara bnya JB k zyaad totally criminal type person or us jese insaan se divorce pr shukr krna chahye... Healing in the way of Mala mahir wedding,ya birbal Sahi hojata ... Kahi tw healing milti but honestly nemrah give us trauma 😢
Even after Maala’s death, should have shown some effect of that on other people. Like her brother regretting not supporting her .Mahi or other girls feeling sad or scared . Murder was a big thing , it passed like nothing.There was no message at the end .
There was a silent message at the end. Everyone moved on in life, mahi stopped fighting for the custody of badar, birbal ignored mala's suggestions in a second and that social media comment scene after mala death. We spent 3 years with mala and we know what she went through and that scene shows that people will judge your whole life in minutes without being a part of it. NO ONE CARES except the real ones. Like Mahir.....
@@riazrabiaThe purpose of novel is not only to tell harsh reality of life as in Namal injustice was harsh reality but they got punishment in the last because of the divine justice. So, maybe people not caring much is harsh reality but was there any message such as why we need to support our family members against toxic partners . Look highlighting the reality we already know made no difference. We all forgot Noor Mukadam case within months. That is the reality We needed a strong cause ,strong message in the end to highlight the importance of why toxic partners should be confronted or why we should have strong law against them . Everyone knows Pakistani women go through this alot . Maala’s mental struggle shown in the start was very heartbreaking and real but this end made it feel like no matter what noone can escape a toxic partner , so eventually there is no point of trying to.😓
@Summiya-6 I don't know may be you are right. Actually, the ending of this novel sometimes makes sense to me and sometimes it doesn't. It's an unexplainable feeling for me. Well, Nemrah said that she will share her Harf-e-akhir in the end of book 2 and then we will understand. Let's see.
It's been more than a week since I read the last episode, and still, whenever someone mentions mala, it breaks my heart. It disturbed me in the worst way. All the lessons that we learned from mala don't feel the same now. This novel was my comfort zone, but now I can't even talk about it without crying. You're absolutely right. As dedicated readers, we didn't deserve this ending. This review was exactly what I needed, and we need a part 2!!
Put my thoughts into the right wordsss! Absolutely agree with Zarina's point. Plus that agar mala aur mahir waisy hi alag raastay ikhteyar karlete, that was still bearable. Mala's death was so unnecessary, she deserved to be loved, and feel loved after all the harshness she had been through her life😢
بہترین تبصرہ کیا ہے جیسے ھمارے تمام احساسات کو زبان مل گئی ہو تقریبا پورا ناول زندگی اک تشنگی کی مثال تھا اس لیے اختتام اچھا بنتا تھا تمام کرداروں کو تشنہ رکھا اور خاص طور پر مرکزی کرداروں کا بہت افسوس ہے ماہر کو پورے ناول تہی داماں رکھا خیر کہانی میں ٹوئسٹ زبردست تھے نمرہ احمد یقینا پڑھنے والوں کے دلوں سے انکے احساسات سے کھیلنا جانتی ہیں 💔😥
Agreed to the over exaggeration of divorce trauma thing. Not undermining anyone's experience if they experienced it in real life, but the novel shoul show that it is okay rather than scaring women out there so much.
Rabia you spoke my heart ! admiring thrill writing scenes/ her way of story telling / mala mahir k scenes love them// , mala badar ka ziyad k sath milaana bht wrong he is a serial killer / totally agree with rabia / zarina free q phir rahi hai / again sad very traumatized 3 years ka sath totally fiction ban gaya / messages in novel love them///
Totally agree. If there was a point for the death of mala i would've accepted but there was none. It was so pointless that in my head i could easily change the ending because it was so changeable. Also. Presenting a novel for someone on a healing journey and giving them harsh reality that there's no hope makes no sense. (Not a hater but a fan of Nemrah ahmed)
I was waiting for your review I like it m praying to God plz heal me my niece also disturb my faimly disturb already we have a lot of challenges in our life never think about that k ab novel ka end b heal karna ho ga...Allah hum sbko heal Kary ab Ameen. But history to ban Gai r mjhy ni lgta koi sari life bhul pay ga ab .
Rabia What a Beautiful review! & thank god someone raise that father figure point in the whole process I was thinking he is a serial killer howw like howww she is allow him to meet ??? Whats the point .. he don't even want that child
Teen saal sey ye novel hamary zindagi ka ik hisa Raha agr happy ending bhi hoti to bhi hum udas they key novel khatam horaha hai lekin yrr ye mala ko Maar Dena ye unexpected tha Nimra Ahmed ney Dil iee tor Diya ye novel to healing key liye thi na phir ye humay Trauma q dey Diya bhalay app un ko na Mila deti Kum s Kum Mar to na deti hum to abhi tuk dj ko bhi nahin bhula paie or app ney ye ik or trauma dey Diya bhut asha tufa Diya hai app ney humay 2025 ka q ki ab shyed poora saal humay ye truma bhulaney main lug jaiega Bhut Bhut shukriya apka or Bari baat ye hai ki menay srif suna ki mala ki death hogaiee hai ab Meri himmat iee nahin horahi key main ye episode parhoon
I think Mala's death was unnecessary. There were many loopholes. Maalik is so influential and wanted to kill ziyad. Still he had no men following him. Everybody could find ziyad. Even zaarina found him but Maalik's men didn't know he met zara or he was hiding in the bakery. You are right Rabia trauma should have been normalized. I understand it is the writers choice but sorry, I am not convinced and that is Nemrah's failure
Nimrah Ahmed is the classic example of an author losing herself to praise and fame. She got lost in the spiral of her own mind as refected in her recent writings loke Halim and mala, which is very sad😢
Superb review yhy batta mera mind me the no doubt bht he zardast noval lhka h bht kuch seekhna ko mila h but still bht se cheeza adhori or end jo hua is ne sb kuch blank kr dia blkl thk ap ne huma umeed ke ek kiran chahiya huti h ke nhi agr hum ne itna sb face kiya to rab huna zaroor sila da ge yh to quran me lhka h ran bashke hr mushkil ke Seth asani h bhttttt cheeza missing bht he cheeza additional the epi ke strt mid bht he khubsurt tha bht he pyri batta ke jb wo yaad aati anso aata h ke ku asa end kr dia kuch be kr daty agr nhi milna tha lakin marna nhi chahiya tha😢yh dukh rha gai
Aaj k dour meh jo log novel reading karte hain un meh 99 percent log bohat senstive or depressed hote hain novel ki story se unki sarey dreams and emotions jurre hote hain nimra ne aise logon ko jeete ji maar dala h jo duniya ki sochon se dr kr khud ko kisi dream characters k sath relate karte hain aaj un sab ko nimra ne un k khouf fikrat or andehery wapis louta diye hain kitni umeeden tooti hain nimra shumar krr sakti hain 😢😢😢
Rabia i am totally agree with your review novel healing process se guzrny waly logon ky liye tha ab ending ye feel krwa rahi hai ap kabi heal nahi ho skty truma or toxic log kabi ap ki zindagi se nahi nikl skty chahy jitni bhi koshish kr lo sereal killer se or feminine main larkian auratien roz hr das minute baad mar jati hain ye baat kl se mery dimag main is sab kabhi koi survive nahi kr skta to koi larki ab koshish bhi na kry kya??
I tnink nemrah api ny ya ending is ly lekhe ha taky log mentally disturbed hon or phir un ka Hair fall ho us k bad log Un ky recommended THERAPIST k pas jy or Hair fall k ly MUNAWAR HAQ OIL use kary🙄😂😂😂
Just read the last episode, it's 3 am and I'm in tears rn . I finished this novel in 3 weeks. Though I already got the spoiler that mala will die , still am traumatized. Mala's death was sooo unnecessary. Mahir suffered a lot throughout the novel . And even mala. They deserved their happy ending . I really respect nemrah ahmads writing but I have to say this felt as it was just for attention. And you are absolutely right instead of healing and uplifting message she gave trauma and depression. Really really disappointed. Though the whole last episode was very well written with perfect twist , I'll still say nemrah ahmad ne bongian mari hain. Bohot bohot gussa a raha.
Such an honest & accurate review. Totally agree with you on so many points. NA has been loved by her readers for always giving us something meaningful from her books but unfortunately this book felt like a waste of our energies & time, because what hope & message do we get here by killing Mala? That ultimately your ex will come & kill you if you take a second chance at life after suffering your entire life? Why was a strong & beautiful character like Mahir’s shown as the one in regret & his purpose in life was to take care of Mala’s kid?? Where is the logic jn all this? No one wanted an emotional happy ending, everyone wanted a very logical ending. & we are highly disappointed. Totally ruined the entire book for us, i dont think i will ever be able to reread this book, my heart is in so much pain
The ending is not justified to me... On the front page of Novel it is written that Maala is for those who are on the way of Healing... then where is Healing?? It is least expected ending Ending should be satisfied atleast I would be fine if they didn't get married or be just friends or in contact with eachother and Mala could raise his son as a single independent mother My heart break at the scene of Badar atleast he didn't deserve this The novel was superb until the episode 20.. I didn't feel the same energy as i felt in the whole novel The ending should be more with emotions
That was in last pages where mala said my happy ending started when I ended relationship with Zahid when I raised my son all alone I lived as a strong independent woman was my happy ending! And nemrah mentioned almost in every episode that one can never be completely healed ! It's a journey you have to go through like literally every morning
@barkaatahmed8137 Of course, it's true, but if life gave you a second chance, then why not... and where is mahir happy ending where is his healing.. his feelings ?? He became a robot after Mala's death and raised two children ... whatever it is it's not justifying
😢😢😢 waqai itna realistic hone k lye toh asal zindagi hum guzr hi rhe han maala ki ending kahi se bhi perfect nhi hai jis bacho k lye struggle kiya end wo bhi hurt hogaye or yah toh phr hmara eman bhi k Allah har azmaish k bad asani zarur deta hai or duniya m hi deta hai yah insan ki neiki hi hoti k duniya achi ho jati hai😢😢😢 it's very sad ending 😭
Yes I agree with you. This review was very pure ,full of feelings. And I have the pain also that Mahir didn't meet mala. Yes they deserved a life together after all that and yes writers should keep in mind that readers have connections with characters while reading and they also want healing through these stories and happy endings . At least acceptable endings if they're not happy.
Maala is my literal babyyyyy she suffered ALOTTTT nothing was ever okay for her like kabhi to achi hoti he zindagi uski to kabhi bhi nai huiiii i cried not because she died i swearrrr because she got nothing in life she was never relaxed she deserved better more than anyone deserved uff allahhhh Maala was such a sensitive kindest human she didn’t deserve this🙏
Nobody talking about that Ziyad kidnapped Badar and took him to Turkey. So that Maala come to Turkey and be there with Mahir . Even though he didn’t wanted that to happen. Maala was in Canada so far from Mahir . Then why would Ziyad do that . This makes no sense .
@@shah____heenYes , it’s obvious that she changed the ending. Unfortunately, novel lost all its potential due to writer’s decision of making it different.
As a mother of an autistic kid my heart breaks for,nobody else can understand the language and needs of autistic child,how can be you so cruel nemrah,ending effects me badly,my heart is broken and my brain can’t process it,worst ending I have ever read
Mera bhi yahi khayal hai bilkul theek asay he...her mushkil kybad asani hai...itne dukh utha kr kuch na milay to insan depress hojata hai.... M very sad😢
As always a very balanced review. As a reader I am very sad to see Malala die but I have a question for you Rabi, what do you think should be the ending? Realistically this is what happens to most women in toxic relationships and as Ziyad was a serial killer, I did not expect any better. The only ending I can think of is that Malala after the accident could have been in coma and then get better after a few years. I couldn't think of Mahir KILLING Ziad or Ziad leaving them alone. We really need a second part Rabia of this video.
Even before the last ep came i had that somewhere in mind that there are many many chances of mala dying , 2,3 hints were already given in previous some eps ... The only problem i felt while reading the last ep was that the ep felt like it's not even written by Nemrah , or maybe like she just wanted to finish it ... Killing the character was ok if it was in someother way , i read someone's cmnt that if Nemrah wanted to show about femicide by killing Mala then she shouldve done it in the container episode why drag it such long? And what sense did it made that a whole serial k*ller was present in the city , usne Mahir ko 2,3 bar dhmki b di and Mahir was like thek h thek h dekha jayega ... WHAT??? I read someone else's cmnt that agr to Zayd khi gaib hgya hta or kuch saal bd achnaq aa k marta to it wouldve made some sense but what hapend was ....
Agr life mein divorce our break up sey guzro gay to smj lo mar kr hi skoon milay ga.... Waoooo... Enough Allah har mushkil k bad asani deta hai... Mahir ki Zindagi mushkilo sey bri thi... Us ki asani waqt Aya hi nai!!!! 😢
you spoke my heart out ....they need to understand that people already have to much going on in their heads and its not okay if as a writer you can write what heal people heart ...not to traumatize them more ive read it while i am having my final exams in few days and it ruined my mental health
So trueeeee and correct about traumas. Iss novel ko parhnay ke baad i was scared of getting out of toxic relationships kyunke lagta tha ill go through trauma but ure right book ne bohat exaggerate kiya
19:52 I solely agree,Sirf is leay Ky aik harsh reality batani thi she crossed the limits Secondly I can't understand this concept hum novels kuin parhty hain Asal zindagi Ky maslon sy thori dair Dor hojany kyleay na lkn agar wahan bhi yhi SB hoga wahan bhi mohabat krny wala juda hojain gy to real life aur usmn Ki hi diff rrh jaye ga Hate Nemrah for doing this Never gonna read any of her novel again neverrrrrrr 💔
but there was no logic of connecting meri Zindagi to mala, because ziyad said this dialogue When mala was her wife and even ziyad 's truth was not revealed yet
Nemrah ahmed just ruined my mental health last episode parhne k bad se I have been traumatized I know wo bohat khobsurat likhti hain par yeh jo unho ne Kia samjh se bahir hai mala k character se jis qadar sab connected thy os ki healing bohat se logon k liye healing thi inspiration thi jo os k death k sath trauma ban gai hai .
Mentally health destroyer karny k liye nhi hoti reading heal karny k liye hoti relaxing k liye hoti ajkl ka jo mahol hy light way mey hona chahiye traumatize nhi hona chahiye hadd hy
I am a fan of nemrah's writing, but it's clearly shows she just wrote it to b a viral. She tried to create a masterpiece by tragic end, but she failed successfully.
she explained all our grudges in such a respectful way.
I am impressed of how controlled you are and with how much patience you are talking... because to be honest, I have been traumatized since two days. This novel ruined my mental health.
Us💔🙂🥺
Same
Same… I started reading mala last year when I was in deep depression and was going through extreme anxiety, so much that I couldn’t even go to work! Mala slowly started healing me… but now I feel so hopeless and down…
Same, i have been depressed since 2 days after reading the last episode
I was actually very sad
Same here
Very honest review Rabia . I just wannna say Nemrah killed all the Characters in last episode .
ab ye nimra baji kahan chupi bethi hain
ap stories post kren na defend kren sb ??
hm kb sy waitt krry hn
she is waiting k zyada se zyada log parhlain novel 😢
She will give vague justifications
@@sparklingf4149
وہ ناول میں چول مارنے کے بعد پروڈک کی پرموشن کر رہی ہیں اپنے انسٹا پر ان کو پیسہ کمانا ہے😂 لوگ جائیں بھاڑ میں۔ اپنی لکھائی پر بڑا غرور ہے نمرہ باجی کو۔
Exactly
Rabia you've put all the points really well. Two cents from my side:
1. Zareena was spared and didn't face the repercussions of her wrongdoing (as you've already mentioned) and got the dove pendent that she wanted. The way her character ended was unfulfilling. 2. What about Maalik and his ongoing placebo treatment? Did he die, or did he get cured? 3. What was the significance of Hilal's tapestry? 4. If happy birthday couldn't protect Mala's life, then why was it mentioned repeatedly? 5. Why Moeed wasn't there at Mala's funeral? 5. Last but not least, WHERE IS HEALING? HOW AM I SUPPOSED TO HEAL KNOWING THAT THE CHARACTER WHO SUFFERED THE MOST WAS MUR*ERED AND DIDN'T GET THE SECOND CHANCE? Why so many loose ends?
Kisi character ko closure nahi mila
@@anooshatabassum375 I don't know. This ending made a kind of mess in our minds. And yes that hilal tapestry and Malik treatment thing was left incomplete.
As for zara, in my opinion the author wanted to show that, wrongdoers dont always get the result of their actions in this world..
@@anooshatabassum375 your point is sooooooo valid where is healing? So good
Exactly my points. Mala ko to mara so mara.. lekn itni adhoori ending expect ni kr rhi thi me
رابعہ آپکا ریویو اچھا ہے ،میں سمجھ رہی تھی کہ آپ نمرہ کو unreasonably defend کریں گی لیکن جیتی رہیں ،ہمارے دل کی بات کر دی آپ نے😊
Exactly what you said there are so many loopholes in last episode. And maala didn't deserve that
I agree with you.. hm logo sy hope nahi leni chahie at least itna sb hony k bad acha hi hona chahie tha.. insan ka achai sy har cheez sy iman khatm ho jata hai
Being a mother to autistic kid, I was so happy she made Mala a mother who was a hero, but her death disturbed me as a mother, especially when Badar finally said MAMA only when Mala died..😢
😢😢
That's more heartbreaking than mahir's side
Oh God. May Allah swt create ease
😢i can.feel.this.pain.dear
I know right! I can feel you on this
I've been continuously crying since the last episode has came. Nemrah told us this was a healing journey but she left us all Traumatized. I learned alot alot from MAALA but nemrah did injustice to the character of maala and mahir.
I was soo traumatized, and my brother was like: ab tum "sanso ki mala" nahi keh saktin kiunke usme sansein hi nahi bachi. Wtf😭😭😭
Bro you cracked me up in this despair :D
Bruhh😭😭
Well he was right😂😂😂😭😭😭
Ur brother nailed it 😂😂
Damn😂😂
Your review was true depiction of our feelings. Nemrah didn't do justice to the story. Bcz what i got from ending was literal sadness and disappointment that everything in the end will be destroyed. We demand a new ending.
Mujhe bhi mahir maala ki happy ending chiye
Vote for happy ending
Please no more torture 🙏 no more waiting for the episode
100% no more waiting@@zuhairadnan.9297
Ak fan na happy ending likhi ha wo prh le ap thora sa sakun mily ga 😅
Traumatised from 3 days..... mainay apni zindagi kai 3 saal Mala aur Mahir kai saath guzaray hain ab main chahti thi,hm sb chahtay thay kai Mala aur Mahir ko in sb traumas kai baad kch acha milay........Nemrah is such a wonderful writer, un k kitabain umeed daiti hain magar yahan main totally disappoint ho chuki hun.......hm readers itna zada un sai emotionally attached thay to ab hm deserve krtay thay kai humay happy ending milay......❤️🩹💜🤎🩶
Har episode sy phle hum suntay thay ziada tang kia to birbal ki garden py churi phair don gi. Phair daiti behan ap churi uske marnay sy ye trauma na milta. Maalik ko bacha lia jo chand din ka mehman tha. Maala ko out of no way maar dia. I have always defended nemrahs writing and her sayings but this time i am kinda hating nemrah her writings and all the time i wasted in reading maala
bhai where to watch it? Like the episode? Is this an adaptation from the book or is she talking about the last chapter of the book? Tell me please
Agreed 💯
@@Mariyaaa._.19it's the last episode dear...u can read in the pdf form
kash itna dard haqeeqat main martey hue apne muslims logon ka hota😢😢 mjhe bs is baat se takleef hui hai k novel k fake character ki death per itna gham aur apne Muslims k marne per zubaan band. pakistani hone per ab mjhe sharam ati hai😢
Thank u rabia ap ne hum sab k jezbad ko ache se bayan kia ap yaqeen kere 3 se 4 din mera hur cheez se dil ajeeb ho gaya is novel k end se yani sab lahasil? Mei tu chup chup k gher k kono mei khoob roi haha even mere husband ne tu mere novel hi band ker liye perhna
"When I heard rumors that Mala had died, I felt very sad. After reading a few pages, I became even sadder, so I skipped to the last pages. Then, I felt even more sorrowful. I kept wondering why Mahir had to survive through so much. He deserved a happy ending. I believe that people who endure so much in life are blessed by Allah with something beautiful in the end. I just didn’t have the courage to read the last episode completely because I felt so sad about Mahir."
Uff Rabia i can relate with you so much. The way maala was so soothing and so relatable for me end me wo umeed hi cheen li nemrah ahmed. The last epeisode just dissapointed us, atleast i wanted an ending wich would have been justified. I don't understand how the story after maala's death would progress, he will live alone, such a trauma honestly. You are right ''har mushkil k sath asani hoti hai'' but nemrah ahmed ne wo umeed jo unho ne khud di thi wo cheen li. We cannot change the words but jahan maala was my favourite novel and still holds a precious place in my heart, wahin maala ki death ne bus wo cherry on top mujhsele liya.
_لاہور نے تو دل توڑا،🥺 استبول تو ماہر کی پوری مالا کھا گیا_ 💔💔💔
Bilkul
😭😭😭
😢 me to padhunga hi ni last episode
😢😢😢
Rabia don't you think that this message(that how many women die from the hands of their husbands or exes) could've been given without killing Maala? We could've seen that Ziyad attempted to kill her but she survived.
Yessss this is what I've been thinking all this time
Yeahhh sooo trueee
After reading the episode I realized what my mother akways said " jinki zindagi dukhon se start hoti hai wo hamesha dukhon mai hi rehtay hain" and I always replied her that "mama buray k bd achay din ajatay hain" but the end proved my mother right and you're right always gives hopes to reader💔
Look it's just a fictional story. Written by a Human who is exactly like u and me. "Jinki Zindagi dukhon SE shuru Hoti ha wo dukhon main hi Marty hn" ye har bar sach Nahi hota. Agr fictional books SE hi inspiration Leni ha Tu instead of maala give a Try to Usri yusra (the best healing book) or manyyy others are here having a perfect happy ending. Maala ki ending SE ma bhi Relate Nahi kr saki lakin remember ye insna NE likhi ha or asal main kismat Allah hi Likha ha hum Allah ke faisle main ikhtear Nahi rakhty agr Zindagi dhukh main shuru hokr dukh main khatam ho bhi Jaye Tu ye zindagi humesha ke liye Nahi ha right?? Iska ajar Allah dega he dukh a ajar mile. Iski explanation ke liye Quran prhain. Asal umeed Quran hi dilaye ga Maala novel Nahi.
@@farzanajaved821 I agree.
But Maala ka main purpose tha har us shaks k Liye Jo healing k rah or gamzan hai.
Otherwise I always have hope whether it's tiny or big that at the end everything gonna be okay.
@@kinzashafiq5yes true. Ab Tu yehi keh sakty ke maala KO jannat mili hogi 😂 or jannat SE barh KR Kia hosakta ha??
😂😂😂😂😂@@farzanajaved821
@@farzanajaved821I just don't understand what happened with her she always used to talk about hope, second chances in her every book. She introduced me with Quran contemplation. Namal ki wajah sy hy main pehli baar quran tadabbur sy introduce huwi thi. I just hope she started writing those inspiring stories again.
Nemrah is a great writer who mesmerized us by her words. I have read all her novels and she has always excelled to impress us. Mala has kept us hooked die to its grappling storyline but the ending has totally shaken me off. Did she not think about Badr?? Does any kid in the world deserve this.
No but this happened to
Us all at some point ab har larki koi b fasla lay say phly 100 bar sochay ge happy endings kisi ko yaad nahi rahti
I've been reading novels since I was in sixth grade, but I've never cried after reading a sad ending-until now. Nemrah is my favorite writer, and I really enjoy her novels. It feels like a journey I've gone through with her characters, but this ending... ugh.
I recently read "Dana Pan,i" with a sad ending, but this one hit me personally. I feel so alone and empty; it's truly traumatizing. Why, Nemrah, why? Not everyone is meant to be together, but this ending has broken my heart. It feels like I’ve lost a loved one. I just want to see them together.
After reading last episode of mala I realized Nemrah hmein 3 saal se aik tragedy k liye tyar kr rahi thi aur hm Besabri se hr episode ka wait kr rhy thy….. 3 saal hm ne kahin na kahin mala bn k jiya aur end pe tragedy…. Mein 4 din se novel ki bat hi nahi kr paa rahi …. Mein bhoolna chahti hun sb ….. mein naan khatai waly scene ko Lahore ko hr cheez ko bhulna chahti hun I was waiting k kb mala khtm ho aur kb mein dubara se prhna start krun pr ab mein kbhi b dubara mala ka nam b ni Sunna chahungi… is mein sirf dukh hain….kuch characters hoty hain jo mr k zinda ho jatyy hain …. Mgr nemrah ne mala ko maar k usko hmesha k liye hi maar dya hai …. Mala novel mr gya h koi b dubara ni prhna chahy ga…
A line "Kuch characters aesay hotay hain Jo mar k bhi zinda hojatay hain , magr nemrah ne maala ko maar kr usko hamesha k Liye maar diya" 💯
Absolutely agreed
totally agree
Mein ny apni friend k saath maala date rakhi thi hum mil k different Candles paint karty art piece banaty brown and purple. And what we got red blood. Hmary dukh ka rang to laal nikla.
Im literally crying again while reading your comment 😢
I totally agree.. Even before the episode came i knew there would be no happy ending. I was sure Mala would say i am not ready yet maybe someday you know like Alif ended. There scenes were so beautifully written but all the characters were so out of their own zone, Like, Mahi why did she oppose on Mahir when he proposed?
but we got a beautiful scene out of it.
Mahir and Mala deserved some peace finally.. but..
I hated it that birble didn't change. People change when they loose someone. i didn't like how she ended it. it was rushed.. I didn't feel anything when Mala died.. When Umar Jahangir from Amarbail died i cried for days.. i still feel that pain i felt that day when i read that day.. but for Mala i felt bad that it was not at all needed when i was reading it.
I did not like the last episode. so many loopholes.
"Mala ki death ne umeed leli."
To sum it all up.
I felt so bad for Badar 😞
You’ve done an excellent job as both a reader and a reviewer.
I agree with your points, particularly that the trauma seems exaggerated and that Badar didn’t necessarily need to meet his father.
For your next video, I would love for you to discuss the following points:
1- How does Asif know about the future and the manner of Mala’s death? She has been hearing the birthday sounds for such a long time. If these sounds are linked to her death, how does Asif know Mala will die in a bakery, especially when she says, “Nobody knows the future except Allah”?
2- What is the meaning of the "halal tapestry"?
3- Is Malik Fareed cured? Apologies if I missed any mention of his cancer therapy.
@@farzeensheikh2090 remember when they were taking mahir to mental asylum, hilal said , jb aap wapis aaen ge me yahn nhi hon gi...she predicted future back then too..
And when she used to say that badar will save me..though she had never met or known mala..that was also future..how?
Yes you R right we deserve happy ending nimra we need justice
100000% agreed with u rabia.... No doubt i m a big fan of Nemrah's writings but but but i m totally disappointed from the last episode maala nd mahir deserved happy ending...😢
Nemrah said in her community that its 2024 and it's our time to read about femicide..
Nimra Ahmed give this msg k mala jaise achhe logon k sath bura hta h
Mera ro ro k bura Hal hai.... Nimrah Ahmad nay Dil tora.... Mahir deserves better. 😢
No Maala deserved better Mahir was just a person jo hmesha darust hota he lakin hmesha dair kr deta he..😅
Usne apne ammi ko shams se Buchanan ho ye Maala ko ziyad ki haqiqt btani ho usne hmeshs dair hi ki he, or usk bad Yasmeen k recaliner pe lait k afsos kiya he, therapy is important action ki kya zrurt he logon ko ghare me girne do
😂😂 Haan yeh bat apne bilkul thek kahi mahir ki isliye to aj tanha reh gya hy
th-cam.com/users/shorts7YgCTxepjyc?si=_B8YRwMVMixOb3ow
@@amnaqayyum4804that's the literal definition of human being. Mahir was a good "Human"
Mala couldn't find anyone better than Mahir.
Unexpected ending 😢 Mahir and Mala both deserve better,both deserve each other😟😟
Feeling bad for MAHIR
😟😟
Nemrah ahmad broke my heart....i am still crying 😭😭
You spoke my heart Rabia.. Its such a genuine review.. I wish Nemra watch this
Completely honest review.....
Bohat saarey loose points th, and I think mahir knows about Zara.... Last episode m jaha bohat saarey traumas ki BAAT hui h but healing nhi hui.... Nimrah ne jaha divorce ko nara bnya JB k zyaad totally criminal type person or us jese insaan se divorce pr shukr krna chahye...
Healing in the way of Mala mahir wedding,ya birbal Sahi hojata ... Kahi tw healing milti but honestly nemrah give us trauma 😢
Even after Maala’s death, should have shown some effect of that on other people. Like her brother regretting not supporting her .Mahi or other girls feeling sad or scared . Murder was a big thing , it passed like nothing.There was no message at the end .
Agreed.. no solid impact was shown!! too disappointed
There was a silent message at the end. Everyone moved on in life, mahi stopped fighting for the custody of badar, birbal ignored mala's suggestions in a second and that social media comment scene after mala death. We spent 3 years with mala and we know what she went through and that scene shows that people will judge your whole life in minutes without being a part of it. NO ONE CARES except the real ones. Like Mahir.....
@@riazrabiaThe purpose of novel is not only to tell harsh reality of life as in Namal injustice was harsh reality but they got punishment in the last because of the divine justice. So, maybe people not caring much is harsh reality but was there any message such as why we need to support our family members against toxic partners .
Look highlighting the reality we already know made no difference.
We all forgot Noor Mukadam case within months. That is the reality
We needed a strong cause ,strong message in the end to highlight the importance of why toxic partners should be confronted or why we should have strong law against them . Everyone knows Pakistani women go through this alot . Maala’s mental struggle shown in the start was very heartbreaking and real but this end made it feel like no matter what noone can escape a toxic partner , so eventually there is no point of trying to.😓
@Summiya-6 I don't know may be you are right. Actually, the ending of this novel sometimes makes sense to me and sometimes it doesn't. It's an unexplainable feeling for me. Well, Nemrah said that she will share her Harf-e-akhir in the end of book 2 and then we will understand. Let's see.
@@riazrabia Waiting for harf- e akhir 🙌
Hope so that she will present strong reason behind Maala’s death and her message behind it
Very honest review. I really enjoyed your discussion.
It's been more than a week since I read the last episode, and still, whenever someone mentions mala, it breaks my heart.
It disturbed me in the worst way. All the lessons that we learned from mala don't feel the same now.
This novel was my comfort zone, but now I can't even talk about it without crying.
You're absolutely right. As dedicated readers, we didn't deserve this ending.
This review was exactly what I needed, and we need a part 2!!
Put my thoughts into the right wordsss!
Absolutely agree with Zarina's point. Plus that agar mala aur mahir waisy hi alag raastay ikhteyar karlete, that was still bearable. Mala's death was so unnecessary, she deserved to be loved, and feel loved after all the harshness she had been through her life😢
بہترین تبصرہ کیا ہے جیسے ھمارے تمام احساسات کو زبان مل گئی ہو تقریبا پورا ناول زندگی اک تشنگی کی مثال تھا اس لیے اختتام اچھا بنتا تھا تمام کرداروں کو تشنہ رکھا اور خاص طور پر مرکزی کرداروں کا بہت افسوس ہے ماہر کو پورے ناول تہی داماں رکھا خیر کہانی میں ٹوئسٹ زبردست تھے نمرہ احمد یقینا پڑھنے والوں کے دلوں سے انکے احساسات سے کھیلنا جانتی ہیں 💔😥
Agreed to the over exaggeration of divorce trauma thing. Not undermining anyone's experience if they experienced it in real life, but the novel shoul show that it is okay rather than scaring women out there so much.
Right Rabia 😭😭😭😭mala k Sath aisa nai hna chaiye tha r Maher Akela rahy gaya 😭😭💔
Rabia you spoke my heart ! admiring thrill writing scenes/ her way of story telling / mala mahir k scenes love them// , mala badar ka ziyad k sath milaana bht wrong he is a serial killer / totally agree with rabia / zarina free q phir rahi hai / again sad very traumatized 3 years ka sath totally fiction ban gaya / messages in novel love them///
Totally agree. If there was a point for the death of mala i would've accepted but there was none. It was so pointless that in my head i could easily change the ending because it was so changeable. Also. Presenting a novel for someone on a healing journey and giving them harsh reality that there's no hope makes no sense.
(Not a hater but a fan of Nemrah ahmed)
I was waiting for your review I like it m praying to God plz heal me my niece also disturb my faimly disturb already we have a lot of challenges in our life never think about that k ab novel ka end b heal karna ho ga...Allah hum sbko heal Kary ab Ameen. But history to ban Gai r mjhy ni lgta koi sari life bhul pay ga ab .
Rabia What a Beautiful review! & thank god someone raise that father figure point in the whole process I was thinking he is a serial killer howw like howww she is allow him to meet ??? Whats the point .. he don't even want that child
19:04 very well said reality shouldn't be presented in such a brutal way..
She healed something she didn't break ❤.....luv you Rabia ...🎀❤️🫀
100% agree with you 👍
Bss iss BAAT ka dukh hai Jo ending Mala aur Mahir deserve krty thy apni life Mai itna suffer Kai Baad wo unhe nhi Mili🥺😔
Teen saal sey ye novel hamary zindagi ka ik hisa Raha agr happy ending bhi hoti to bhi hum udas they key novel khatam horaha hai lekin yrr ye mala ko Maar Dena ye unexpected tha Nimra Ahmed ney Dil iee tor Diya ye novel to healing key liye thi na phir ye humay Trauma q dey Diya bhalay app un ko na Mila deti Kum s Kum Mar to na deti hum to abhi tuk dj ko bhi nahin bhula paie or app ney ye ik or trauma dey Diya bhut asha tufa Diya hai app ney humay 2025 ka q ki ab shyed poora saal humay ye truma bhulaney main lug jaiega Bhut Bhut shukriya apka or Bari baat ye hai ki menay srif suna ki mala ki death hogaiee hai ab Meri himmat iee nahin horahi key main ye episode parhoon
I can feel your pain. Jese Apki feeling same meri bhi hain m ab tak kuch b aesa Dekho jo in Sy related ho to roti hon
I think Mala's death was unnecessary. There were many loopholes. Maalik is so influential and wanted to kill ziyad. Still he had no men following him. Everybody could find ziyad. Even zaarina found him but Maalik's men didn't know he met zara or he was hiding in the bakery.
You are right Rabia trauma should have been normalized. I understand it is the writers choice but sorry, I am not convinced and that is Nemrah's failure
Aapne last bt bht sahi kahi k agar aap logo ko itna effect karsakhte hain tou uske sahi se istemal karein itni aqal honi chahiye writers mai
I have been traumatized for five days. Nemrah disappoint us. We expect so much from her.
It was an amazing outstanding but end was so sad 😭😭😭 i was not expecting Rabia you explained very well❤
Nimrah Ahmed is the classic example of an author losing herself to praise and fame. She got lost in the spiral of her own mind as refected in her recent writings loke Halim and mala, which is very sad😢
Walaikum Assalam ❤ you said as i said to my friend k Har mushkil k sath asani h Allah itna bura nai krta kisi k sath🥺❤🩹
I love your all reviews💓......I was literally waiting for your review from 3 days🤌🏻
Superb review yhy batta mera mind me the no doubt bht he zardast noval lhka h bht kuch seekhna ko mila h but still bht se cheeza adhori or end jo hua is ne sb kuch blank kr dia blkl thk ap ne huma umeed ke ek kiran chahiya huti h ke nhi agr hum ne itna sb face kiya to rab huna zaroor sila da ge yh to quran me lhka h ran bashke hr mushkil ke Seth asani h bhttttt cheeza missing bht he cheeza additional the epi ke strt mid bht he khubsurt tha bht he pyri batta ke jb wo yaad aati anso aata h ke ku asa end kr dia kuch be kr daty agr nhi milna tha lakin marna nhi chahiya tha😢yh dukh rha gai
After reading Mala last episode I can't forget it I am not focused on my study it destroyed my mentally health.
Sach ma 😢😢😢😢
Bilkul bilkul
Very interesting review! Thanks Rabia! I really enjoy listening to your reviews! I ll wait for second review!
Aaj k dour meh jo log novel reading karte hain un meh 99 percent log bohat senstive or depressed hote hain novel ki story se unki sarey dreams and emotions jurre hote hain nimra ne aise logon ko jeete ji maar dala h jo duniya ki sochon se dr kr khud ko kisi dream characters k sath relate karte hain aaj un sab ko nimra ne un k khouf fikrat or andehery wapis louta diye hain kitni umeeden tooti hain nimra shumar krr sakti hain 😢😢😢
😢😢AP nay bilkul sahi baat ki..
Rabia aap ne hamaray dil ki baat ki hai .... Thank you 😊
page 280 i literally cried varna main kbhi nhi rota last 2021 mein ammi jb hospital mein thi tb beytahasha roya tha rozzzzzzz bina ruky
19:05 ek maala discussion with nemrah ahmad please. Like you did for namal
A little off topic but rabia looks so gorgeous.
Bilkul rabia ap thk kh rhi hamaray dill ki awaz hay 😢😢😢😢😢
This novel was meant to heal us and maala died at the end after suffering alot so this traumatised us instead of healing
Such a beautiful review ❤
Your choice of words is the best
Rabia i am totally agree with your review novel healing process se guzrny waly logon ky liye tha ab ending ye feel krwa rahi hai ap kabi heal nahi ho skty truma or toxic log kabi ap ki zindagi se nahi nikl skty chahy jitni bhi koshish kr lo sereal killer se or feminine main larkian auratien roz hr das minute baad mar jati hain ye baat kl se mery dimag main is sab kabhi koi survive nahi kr skta to koi larki
ab koshish bhi na kry kya??
So so sos so accurate review that was 10000999990% my thiught k Tensn mn hi mar jna maqsd nai hta
I tnink nemrah api ny ya ending is ly lekhe ha taky log mentally disturbed hon or phir un ka Hair fall ho us k bad log Un ky recommended THERAPIST k pas jy or Hair fall k ly MUNAWAR HAQ OIL use kary🙄😂😂😂
I was soo disappointed when maala said I don't need mahir for my happy ending
Main apke review ka intezaar kr rhi thi
Just read the last episode, it's 3 am and I'm in tears rn . I finished this novel in 3 weeks. Though I already got the spoiler that mala will die , still am traumatized. Mala's death was sooo unnecessary. Mahir suffered a lot throughout the novel . And even mala. They deserved their happy ending . I really respect nemrah ahmads writing but I have to say this felt as it was just for attention. And you are absolutely right instead of healing and uplifting message she gave trauma and depression. Really really disappointed. Though the whole last episode was very well written with perfect twist , I'll still say nemrah ahmad ne bongian mari hain. Bohot bohot gussa a raha.
15:04 maahir heard birbal n zara talk. But jab mala nhi toh he let everything go.
Such an honest & accurate review. Totally agree with you on so many points. NA has been loved by her readers for always giving us something meaningful from her books but unfortunately this book felt like a waste of our energies & time, because what hope & message do we get here by killing Mala? That ultimately your ex will come & kill you if you take a second chance at life after suffering your entire life? Why was a strong & beautiful character like Mahir’s shown as the one in regret & his purpose in life was to take care of Mala’s kid?? Where is the logic jn all this? No one wanted an emotional happy ending, everyone wanted a very logical ending. & we are highly disappointed. Totally ruined the entire book for us, i dont think i will ever be able to reread this book, my heart is in so much pain
The ending is not justified to me... On the front page of Novel it is written that Maala is for those who are on the way of Healing... then where is Healing??
It is least expected ending
Ending should be satisfied atleast I would be fine if they didn't get married or be just friends or in contact with eachother and Mala could raise his son as a single independent mother
My heart break at the scene of Badar atleast he didn't deserve this
The novel was superb until the episode 20.. I didn't feel the same energy as i felt in the whole novel
The ending should be more with emotions
That was in last pages where mala said my happy ending started when I ended relationship with Zahid when I raised my son all alone I lived as a strong independent woman was my happy ending! And nemrah mentioned almost in every episode that one can never be completely healed ! It's a journey you have to go through like literally every morning
@barkaatahmed8137 Of course, it's true, but if life gave you a second chance, then why not... and where is mahir happy ending where is his healing.. his feelings ?? He became a robot after Mala's death and raised two children ... whatever it is it's not justifying
@@barkaatahmed8137that would’ve been healing if she had lived without any fear for 4 years.
She was in fear, constantly.
Same to me...mje lga khwab hoga...mje lga abi znda ho jae gi...toba toba
Mktoob😢
😢😢😢 waqai itna realistic hone k lye toh asal zindagi hum guzr hi rhe han maala ki ending kahi se bhi perfect nhi hai jis bacho k lye struggle kiya end wo bhi hurt hogaye or yah toh phr hmara eman bhi k Allah har azmaish k bad asani zarur deta hai or duniya m hi deta hai yah insan ki neiki hi hoti k duniya achi ho jati hai😢😢😢 it's very sad ending 😭
Yes I agree with you. This review was very pure ,full of feelings. And I have the pain also that Mahir didn't meet mala. Yes they deserved a life together after all that and yes writers should keep in mind that readers have connections with characters while reading and they also want healing through these stories and happy endings . At least acceptable endings if they're not happy.
Maala is my literal babyyyyy she suffered ALOTTTT nothing was ever okay for her like kabhi to achi hoti he zindagi uski to kabhi bhi nai huiiii i cried not because she died i swearrrr because she got nothing in life she was never relaxed she deserved better more than anyone deserved uff allahhhh Maala was such a sensitive kindest human she didn’t deserve this🙏
it was just a novel fox on your own success relationship and read some better books
Allah mehrban Hy Mgr hmary writers zalim Hain Allah hi heal KRTA Hy hmary zkhm
Nobody talking about that Ziyad kidnapped Badar and took him to Turkey. So that Maala come to Turkey and be there with Mahir .
Even though he didn’t wanted that to happen. Maala was in Canada so far from Mahir . Then why would Ziyad do that . This makes no sense .
That’s a great point
She has changed the ending. Wasnt mahir supposed to go to UK in the end....she did dirty....
I agree.. I was thinking the same.. nemra has created that unavoidable mess Advertently
@@shah____heenYes , it’s obvious that she changed the ending. Unfortunately, novel lost all its potential due to writer’s decision of making it different.
She was definitely trying to be different
I'm traumatized rabia. I'm hopeless now. It feels like you will never heal from traumas. I'm literally hopeless rabia😢
As a mother of an autistic kid my heart breaks for,nobody else can understand the language and needs of autistic child,how can be you so cruel nemrah,ending effects me badly,my heart is broken and my brain can’t process it,worst ending I have ever read
Mera bhi yahi khayal hai bilkul theek asay he...her mushkil kybad asani hai...itne dukh utha kr kuch na milay to insan depress hojata hai....
M very sad😢
As always a very balanced review. As a reader I am very sad to see Malala die but I have a question for you Rabi, what do you think should be the ending? Realistically this is what happens to most women in toxic relationships and as Ziyad was a serial killer, I did not expect any better. The only ending I can think of is that Malala after the accident could have been in coma and then get better after a few years. I couldn't think of Mahir KILLING Ziad or Ziad leaving them alone. We really need a second part Rabia of this video.
Even before the last ep came i had that somewhere in mind that there are many many chances of mala dying , 2,3 hints were already given in previous some eps ... The only problem i felt while reading the last ep was that the ep felt like it's not even written by Nemrah , or maybe like she just wanted to finish it ... Killing the character was ok if it was in someother way , i read someone's cmnt that if Nemrah wanted to show about femicide by killing Mala then she shouldve done it in the container episode why drag it such long? And what sense did it made that a whole serial k*ller was present in the city , usne Mahir ko 2,3 bar dhmki b di and Mahir was like thek h thek h dekha jayega ... WHAT??? I read someone else's cmnt that agr to Zayd khi gaib hgya hta or kuch saal bd achnaq aa k marta to it wouldve made some sense but what hapend was ....
Thanks Rabia for an honest review and I agree with your opinion you presented at the end!
Didn’t expect such a sad and depressing end!
Agr life mein divorce our break up sey guzro gay to smj lo mar kr hi skoon milay ga.... Waoooo... Enough Allah har mushkil k bad asani deta hai... Mahir ki Zindagi mushkilo sey bri thi... Us ki asani waqt Aya hi nai!!!! 😢
Sahi kaha hai ksi ny.
غریب کے جب اچھے دن شروع ہونے لگتے ہیں تو موت سامنے آکھڑی ہوتی ہے ۔۔ 😢😢😢
Feeling Sad for Mala 😭😭😭
😢
you spoke my heart out ....they need to understand that people already have to much going on in their heads and its not okay if as a writer you can write what heal people heart ...not to traumatize them more
ive read it while i am having my final exams in few days and it ruined my mental health
So trueeeee and correct about traumas. Iss novel ko parhnay ke baad i was scared of getting out of toxic relationships kyunke lagta tha ill go through trauma but ure right book ne bohat exaggerate kiya
Mujhai kashmala ki yaad arahi hai😭
Same to you.mala so nice
19:52 I solely agree,Sirf is leay Ky aik harsh reality batani thi she crossed the limits
Secondly I can't understand this concept hum novels kuin parhty hain Asal zindagi Ky maslon sy thori dair Dor hojany kyleay na lkn agar wahan bhi yhi SB hoga wahan bhi mohabat krny wala juda hojain gy to real life aur usmn Ki hi diff rrh jaye ga
Hate Nemrah for doing this
Never gonna read any of her novel again neverrrrrrr 💔
but there was no logic of connecting meri Zindagi to mala, because ziyad said this dialogue When mala was her wife and even ziyad 's truth was not revealed yet
Mala last epi makes me cry 😭😭😭
Nemrah ahmed just ruined my mental health last episode parhne k bad se I have been traumatized I know wo bohat khobsurat likhti hain par yeh jo unho ne Kia samjh se bahir hai mala k character se jis qadar sab connected thy os ki healing bohat se logon k liye healing thi inspiration thi jo os k death k sath trauma ban gai hai .
Same
بالکل صحیح تبصرہ کیا ہے زبردست
Mentally health destroyer karny k liye nhi hoti reading heal karny k liye hoti relaxing k liye hoti ajkl ka jo mahol hy light way mey hona chahiye traumatize nhi hona chahiye hadd hy
Exactly sb sy close to heart character Mahir e ta
Os k liye boht dukh hoa
Omar's death in amarbel and mala's death in mala, never heal........heart breaking💔
much awaited review. Beautifully reviewed
I am a fan of nemrah's writing, but it's clearly shows she just wrote it to b a viral. She tried to create a masterpiece by tragic end, but she failed successfully.