We all think this is geddy's finest bassline. Complex at times and it in the pocket banging rock n roll other times but always tightly locked with Neil.
You are absolutely right TJ, it is not only Geddy's finest creation, but one that I have always longed to play on bass myself. Thanks for the attention, care and expertise afforded to even attempt to play this track....😁
I started playing bass when i was 14, played until i was 23,,,,then marraige and all that chit happens....anyway got out of it! today i find myself married again, only to my highschool sweetheart! She loves it when i play (and yes never sold my bass). for my birthday she bought me new strings and your videos have inspired me too play again at 52. thanks dude!
@@freemandiaz5123 I don't really like to sing, but I've dabbled a bit. I'm more of a decent mimic than a good singer. Check out my "Collaborations" playlist for an example.
Thanks again Troy. I was just working in Delaware City De. and was thinking, man I want to jam w/him. Have a great day. Song never gets old!!! You nailed it✌👊😎
Seeing Rush broken down like this..makes you realize awesome Geddy REALLY is..(gotta factor in the vocals & keyboards too!!) But sheesh,the fact you can duplicate his bass note for note so effortlessly..sheesh,man..just amazing!!! enjoy your videos!
Incredible job! In 1978, at the age of 16 studied this in my my bedroom using a cassette tape recorder. It took me 2 months straight to get it. But back then, I knew the magnificence of Rush, and the creativity they put into their music.
Former bassist of approx 12 years, switched to singing after I busted my arm up in a football injury. I think I need to buy another bass and start up again. I miss this sh!t. Great stuff TJ!
I don't really remember how long it took to learn but, knowing me, probably the better part of a summer vacation from high school. I am self-taught and learned to play by ear.
I am so happy to be born in the age of TH-cam where not only can I listen to the remnants of the musical gods but I can see people like you from across the world to help convey what maybe it was once like. Thanks. And brilliant. Been playing for a year and just got a 4003 😎 mapleglo
Just listened to about 5 of your covers, been watching you for a few years now, and I have to say your playing is a joy to listen to every time. Your covers showcase the huge library of the best Rock bassist to grace this planet. Nobody has a bigger library of interesting, intense, complex, melodic rock bass lines then The Ged. Thanks for highlighting and bringing the casual Rush fans into the endless Rabbit Hole of beautiful Geddy Lee bass. This is my favorite Rush piece, almost 40 yrs of listening to it and never bored of it. Keep slapping these out. Thanks
The bass line of this song is phenomenal and can be seen as a work of art that deserves to be appreciated. I can say that Geddy know do those "tricks" at the right time. Begins with low notes and goes down for acute ones, ending in a melody that Alex wanted to do with his the base guitar, clarifying with the bass. And it always watching the battery Neil, the bass notes always accompanied by a beat. Really, this song is one of the best of them, in the sense the guys actually studied and they put into practice.
Man, I wrote my comment halfway, but after watching the whole thing I have to agree with BaldJohnnyRhythm, you make it look like it is a walk in the park...
I just discovered your channel, and this is the first time I have ever commented on TH-cam. I've been a Rush fan practically my whole life since I first heard Tom Sawyer in 1980, always been amazed by Geddy's bass and ability to sing at the same time, but to see you play it note for note, wow, just astonishing. You are am amazing player, Thank you for the channel and videos. Makes me wish that I would have stuck with it. You have some really beautiful bass guitars BTW.
Welcome aboard and thanks for making your first comment on one of my videos! There's a lot to see here, so take your time. It's never to late to pick it back up and play for your own enjoyment as I've been doing. Thanks again and take care, Glenn.
I have actually started downloading your videos just for the audio and putting them on CD...It's the Rush mix I have always wanted.....everything turned down except the bass..and you play and sound like Geddy...A compliment I would NEVER have given to anyone...I hail thee!
Someone said it earlier, but the basspart between 10.57 en 11.38 indeed is f. great! Things like that set Geddy Lee apart from all those other fantastic bassplayers on this planet. I can listen to it over and over again.
Thks for the quote..yes Geddy uses the F a lot , particularly on those old recordings...Now I thinks he plays much A in his new stuff.(scales I mean) Thks because you help me that I´m not getting mad about my ear listening!!
The thought of singing and playing this is just insane, your rendition alone makes me think perhaps I could take up golf, outstanding as usual Troy. well done mate.
OMG,TRULY AWESOME Cover Troy!!! Hemispheres has ALWAYS (and I DO MEAN "ALWAYS") been my FAVORITE Rush-Album!!! I NEVER hear the end of it from all the "2112 is the BEST ONE Duuuude!!! " MORONS who think THAT album is better?? Are they KIDDING ME? THIS ONE outshines 2112 and is NOT even on the same creative-LEVEL as that one! (both conceptually and musically!!) So I gotta hand it to You on THIS ONE My Friend!! You OUTDID yourself with it and should be EXTREMELY "PROUD" of it too!!!
the change at 6:30 really shows highlights the way (in a trio) the rhythm section has to step up during a lead guitar solo. Eric Clapton is quoted as saying "playing in a trio is the hardest thing i ever had to do".
Thanks. I don't enjoy recording the videos. Even though I'm here by myself, I still feel a lot of pressure. I put a lot of work in ahead of time so when I sit in front of the camera I can sort of go on auto pilot. Of course some songs give me a harder time than others and I never know which songs those will be until I start recording.
This is the one for me! I used to muddle along with it on my Fender Jazz copy in the early 80s. Not in your league, but felt pretty proud of myself back then. Thanks for posting.
Yahoo! Fantastic as always! I listened through Hemisphere's to end my after noon at work (graphic design) finishing several ads on my plate. As I shut down for the day I made a note to myself to check your site for Hemispheres when I got home. PRESTO! (well, that came later....). This piece the boys did back in the day just cruises along with such deliberately vibrant consistency. Still blows me away, long past the red vinyl album I wore almost flat and hundred years ago! Thanks again.
I used those exercises to develop my alternate plucking skills as well as build up strength, endurance, reach and speed. I only did them from the 5th fret down because I figured, if I could do them there, I could easily do them anywhere further up the neck.
Amazing, and that's not said with any amount of exaggeration. Can't believe how well you've learned and memorized this song (and all the others on your channel), let alone how flawless this performance was. I assume it was a long time in the making to get it down as well as you have... years, perhaps? I'm so impressed. Also, I have to add: much respect to ol' Ged for writing/performing such an amazing bass part... and at only 25 years old.
Evening my dear friend. Im in the same boat as Giuliano. About a month ago I stumbled across this and your "Seven Cities of Gold" covers. And I was sold. I purchased a Squire Vintage Modified Jazz Bass in a natural finish with a maple neck with black inlays. And now about 2 months later I have a 70RI Fender Jazz thats black and with a rosewood neck with pearloid inlays. Im polishing up some songs, but I should have about 5 videos up within the next few weeks. Looking forward to a good youtube friendship!
The bass from 10:57 to 11:38 is absolutely awesome!! Not just because of your inspiring performance but the fact that Geddy Lee actually conceived it - truly amazing!!
I play bass righty, and just picked up a lefty bass to mess around with. I decided to make this the first song that I learn. This video will help immensely. Thanks for posting....I'll let you know how I make out...I'm sure it will be a while, unless I get frustrated and just stop trying.
The part from 6:25 is one of the best sections in all of rock n roll and the bassline is absolutely sick. You played that and the entire song brilliantly! Truly inspiring.
YOU are the main reason of why I know 60 RUSH songs off the top of my head. For me, if learning a RUSH song gets a little difficult to learn by ear, I always go to the reliable Troy for the answer. I just wanted to thank you for posting these covers, they've helped me and countless amounts of others along the way. If you can post covers of "Clockwork Angels" and "The Garden" I will love you forever (no homo). And I almost forgot, listening to you nailing my favourite RUSH epic is indescribable
I didn't think it possible but I have even more respect for Mr. Lee now. That he plays such intricate lines while singing and playing the pedals is mind boggling and you nailed the bass parts. Good, good show!
Great performance. I just am reminded that Geddy Lee does more than just play bass live and the bass parts are just incredible - especially this album. It takes dedication to these videos and they serve as great tutorials for aspiring musicians.
Hi Troy, this video is art... thank you very much, with your work i increase my knowledge about how play the bass with rush songs. Every day I see your videos no all but somes, but all about rush. I am a Civil Engineer but everyday i play the bass. Thank a lot, Regards from Panama City central america
I have no idea how I kept missing this one, but this is flat-out hardcore. I've been listening to the original cut for some time; I was particularly looking forward to how you were going to handle my favorite sequence in this song (10:40-11:57), and I have to say it was a bloody success. Geddy settles into such a cosmically solid groove there, and you absolutely stand shoulder to shoulder with him. That was a real treat, Professor. Many, many thanks.
I believe this is rush at their peak. You covered this PERFECTLY. im amazed, humbled, and inspired. Ive always wanted to learn this song, and hearing how delicate intricate this song really is... And how it literally doesn't repeat at all with all of the different phrasing... I was so intimidated and discouraged. I want to say im going to tackle this thing the old fashioned way with vinyl and headphones, but im just going to use your video to learn and enjoy the heck out of it. Bravo sir, standing ovation for this performance. And thank you for doing the dirty work!!
Imagine being at your "peak" at around 25 years old? I learned this on vinyl and I'd recommend something with a slider. You're going to develop carpal tunnel from moving that needle back. Take your time. I think it took me the better part of a summer to learn it and many more years to be able to play it somewhat fluently. Have fun and be patient!
I'm always excited when I see you have posted a new video, I know I'm in for a treat. This time your playing is truly in a different league. Really, Really well done. I could only wish one day I could even come close to your playing. Outstanding work Troy. Thanks for sharing with us.
My God, what an accomplishment to play this piece of music with such grace and effectiveness. I can understand why its one of your favorites. As for Geddy Lee, this sort of says it all.
Thanks so much. Yes, I'd been chipping away this song since the early 80's at the time I recorded this video. As you do, I also think it's a masterpiece. Yeah, Geddy threw in the kitchen sink on this one.
Great job Troy. The bass sound is a whole 'nother world from the way you used to do it. I think you have no choice but to re-do them all :-} Love the stuff in the section starting right before the 11 min mark
Up until a month or so ago I was uploading at 480p which was fine. Then recently, TH-cam was playing around with a "slow-down" feature which allowed you to slow the clip down but hear it at regular pitch. This maxed the quality out at 360p which is borderline, so I started uploading at 720p and have also started recording my bass direct, through GarageBand. I will be sure to check out your covers, promise. I'm glad that you started posting. Thanks and take care.
Thanks for watching the whole piece, I think it's one of his finest bass lines. One of many. Enjoy the show and thanks.
We all think this is geddy's finest bassline. Complex at times and it in the pocket banging rock n roll other times but always tightly locked with Neil.
Ok that was an impressive and enjoyable 15 minutes. But can you drive and play Geddy Lee air bass guitar at the time? 😃
You are absolutely right TJ, it is not only Geddy's finest creation, but one that I have always longed to play on bass myself. Thanks for the attention, care and expertise afforded to even attempt to play this track....😁
I started playing bass when i was 14, played until i was 23,,,,then marraige and all that chit happens....anyway got out of it! today i find myself married again, only to my highschool sweetheart! She loves it when i play (and yes never sold my bass). for my birthday she bought me new strings and your videos have inspired me too play again at 52. thanks dude!
If there was an option for loving this comment rather than just liking it, I would gladly press that button :)
That first guitar solo always gives me the chills dude!
Me too!
The fact that Geddy can play this and sing it is pretty fucking crazy tbh...
10/10 cover by the way
Yep. Thanks.
@@TJH3113 Ever sing brother?
@@freemandiaz5123 I don't really like to sing, but I've dabbled a bit. I'm more of a decent mimic than a good singer. Check out my "Collaborations" playlist for an example.
@@TJH3113 Thanks! I'll check it out!
That is why he is the best and don't let anyone tell you else
My fiance had a stroke 2 yrs ago ...u brought him him back to his musical appreciation 4music....thank you ❤ he loves listening to you...
Wow, I'm so sorry to hear that. I hope he's doing better and getting stronger. Tell him I send my very best regards... to you as well.
Only Rush can tell a story about Greek gods and still make it a rock masterpiece
Truth.
Thanks again Troy. I was just working in Delaware City De. and was thinking, man I want to jam w/him. Have a great day. Song never gets old!!! You nailed it✌👊😎
As always, it's my pleasure Don. Feel free to stop by anytime you're in the area. Take care!
The bass guitar is such an underrated instrument. You make me want to pick one up.
I think you should.
It isn't underrated here... :)
You are totally right.
Then do it haha
Dude. You are killing it! Right ON!!!!!!!
Thanks a lot!
So good, at a loss for words. This song means so much to me, and to see someone nail it so perfectly brings tears to my once young eyes.
+skumotube Thanks a lot.
TJH3113 what key is this song in?
E Major
Cameron Jackson. Thank you doo much, but out of curiosity are you sure?
It shifts keys a bunch of times so it depends what part of the song you're in.
This is almost better than listening to the album, my brother, as the bass is even more up front and you nailed it.
Thanks a lot.
@@TJH3113 just awsome
Thank you for the high praise. And to think, Geddy was crafting this stuff in his mid-twenties.
Don't be sad, be glad that he/they made all this great music for us to listen to.
Back in 1977-79 I was addicted to Rush.....After seeing your video covers, my addiction appears to be returning. A delicious addiction:)
Cool.
Seeing Rush broken down like this..makes you realize awesome Geddy REALLY is..(gotta factor in the vocals & keyboards too!!) But sheesh,the fact you can duplicate his bass note for note so effortlessly..sheesh,man..just amazing!!! enjoy your videos!
As a drummer I am loving your playing. Drummers love this shit
Very cool. Thanks.
Incredible job! In 1978, at the age of 16 studied this in my my bedroom using a cassette tape recorder. It took me 2 months straight to get it. But back then, I knew the magnificence of Rush, and the creativity they put into their music.
Thanks. Same here.
Former bassist of approx 12 years, switched to singing after I busted my arm up in a football injury. I think I need to buy another bass and start up again. I miss this sh!t. Great stuff TJ!
Do it!
I don't really remember how long it took to learn but, knowing me, probably the better part of a summer vacation from high school. I am self-taught and learned to play by ear.
10:40 to 12:00 is one of my all time favorite bass passages.
Mine too!
Great passage 👍
I fast forwarded to that , so I could listen along. Great choice.
Geez, sing in 4/4 time while playing that...😲😲😲, crazy..
Mine too. And Troy nails it here.
You played it with ease Troy
Thanks Afaf
I am so happy to be born in the age of TH-cam where not only can I listen to the remnants of the musical gods but I can see people like you from across the world to help convey what maybe it was once like. Thanks. And brilliant. Been playing for a year and just got a 4003 😎 mapleglo
Thanks for watching and taking the time to leave such a great comment. Take care Hayden!
Thank you for watching it and commenting.
I just bought a bass yesterday because OF YOU. You own me 530$ buddy XD
Send me the bill. Congratulations, I hope you enjoy it.
TJH3113 get the action set low so it doesn't hurt your hands and you don't struggle playing
1:48, one of my favourite bass lines🙌🏻🙌🏻
That is a great part, isn’t it?
SIR U R SPOT ON MY FAVORITE RUSH ALBUM THANK U!!!!!!!!!!
Wow, thanks!
watching you play always elevates the awe factor of their music.
Very kind of you to say. Thanks!
7:38 is one of my all time favorite bass fills.
Jonathan Sefcik Mine too. Geddy Lee is a true master in making great bass lines. So is Chris Squire R.I.P.
Jonathan Sefcik i thought i was the only one! i cant get over how amazing of a fit it is into the song
Thank you Valerie. I'm glad that you watched it.
Thanks a lot for letting me know that you find my videos helpful. No, regrettably I've never been considered a "pro".
I honestly prefer watching your covers than just listening to Rush except if I'm on my bike.
That's interesting. Thanks.
Just listened to about 5 of your covers, been watching you for a few years now, and I have to say your playing is a joy to listen to every time. Your covers showcase the huge library of the best Rock bassist to grace this planet. Nobody has a bigger library of interesting, intense, complex, melodic rock bass lines then The Ged. Thanks for highlighting and bringing the casual Rush fans into the endless Rabbit Hole of beautiful Geddy Lee bass. This is my favorite Rush piece, almost 40 yrs of listening to it and never bored of it. Keep slapping these out. Thanks
Thank you for the nice compliment.
The bass line of this song is phenomenal and can be seen as a work of art that deserves to be appreciated. I can say that Geddy know do those "tricks" at the right time. Begins with low notes and goes down for acute ones, ending in a melody that Alex wanted to do with his the base guitar, clarifying with the bass. And it always watching the battery Neil, the bass notes always accompanied by a beat. Really, this song is one of the best of them, in the sense the guys actually studied and they put into practice.
This is like listening to the original with the bass way more prominent. I wouldn't know a difference between this and Geddy Lee's playing, man.
This is what I am currently working on at present. You, sir, are a true treasure. Thank you.
Man, I wrote my comment halfway, but after watching the whole thing I have to agree with BaldJohnnyRhythm, you make it look like it is a walk in the park...
you are incredible, this is a testament to your ability, wow
Thanks a lot.
"Thumbs Up" does not even come close to my like level for this! This is off-the-charts amazing!!
Wonderful to hear. Thanks so much!
Thanks you, that was very nice of you to say.
Thank you very much for the kind and generous compliment, I appreciate it. I'm glad that you enjoyed it.
I just discovered your channel, and this is the first time I have ever commented on TH-cam. I've been a Rush fan practically my whole life since I first heard Tom Sawyer in 1980, always been amazed by Geddy's bass and ability to sing at the same time, but to see you play it note for note, wow, just astonishing. You are am amazing player, Thank you for the channel and videos. Makes me wish that I would have stuck with it. You have some really beautiful bass guitars BTW.
Welcome aboard and thanks for making your first comment on one of my videos! There's a lot to see here, so take your time. It's never to late to pick it back up and play for your own enjoyment as I've been doing. Thanks again and take care, Glenn.
Thank you for the generous compliment.
I have actually started downloading your videos just for the audio and putting them on CD...It's the Rush mix I have always wanted.....everything turned down except the bass..and you play and sound like Geddy...A compliment I would NEVER have given to anyone...I hail thee!
Thank you for checking it out.
Someone said it earlier, but the basspart between 10.57 en 11.38 indeed is f. great! Things like that set Geddy Lee apart from all those other fantastic bassplayers on this planet. I can listen to it over and over again.
Agreed.
It was me, and you are of course quite right.
Thks for the quote..yes Geddy uses the F a lot , particularly on those old recordings...Now I thinks he plays much A in his new stuff.(scales I mean)
Thks because you help me that I´m not getting mad about my ear listening!!
Indeed, the 15 minutes seem to pass like just a few moments. I sincerely forgot I was watching a cover. Great!
TH-cam "recommend" this video to me tonight. I was spellbound. Amazing performance!
The thought of singing and playing this is just insane, your rendition alone makes me think perhaps I could take up golf, outstanding as usual Troy. well done mate.
Can you imagine? Thank you Ian.
OMG,TRULY AWESOME Cover Troy!!! Hemispheres has ALWAYS (and I DO MEAN "ALWAYS") been my FAVORITE Rush-Album!!! I NEVER hear the end of it from all the "2112 is the BEST ONE Duuuude!!! " MORONS who think THAT album is better?? Are they KIDDING ME? THIS ONE outshines 2112 and is NOT even on the same creative-LEVEL as that one! (both conceptually and musically!!) So I gotta hand it to You on THIS ONE My Friend!! You OUTDID yourself with it and should be EXTREMELY "PROUD" of it too!!!
the change at 6:30 really shows highlights the way (in a trio) the rhythm section has to step up during a lead guitar solo. Eric Clapton is quoted as saying "playing in a trio is the hardest thing i ever had to do".
thank you...your videos nudge me back into picking my bass up when I'm uninterested ...
My main reason for uploading it again was to get it on one video and to correct the sync issues in the other cover. Thanks a lot.
Man, you are fantastic! There are probably a lot of RUSH loving bass players that are benefiting from your channel!
IMO the finest bass cover on the web, all aspect considered.
Tim Starace is equally amazing.
Thanks. I don't enjoy recording the videos. Even though I'm here by myself, I still feel a lot of pressure. I put a lot of work in ahead of time so when I sit in front of the camera I can sort of go on auto pilot. Of course some songs give me a harder time than others and I never know which songs those will be until I start recording.
10:41 the way that the bass line develops here from the original motiv is totally GENIUS
Truth!
This is the one for me! I used to muddle along with it on my Fender Jazz copy in the early 80s. Not in your league, but felt pretty proud of myself back then. Thanks for posting.
Among the all time top TH-cam bass performances? Thank you!
Richard Gudino Thanks.
Thanks. I always find it satisfying to learn a challenging piece too.
Yahoo! Fantastic as always! I listened through Hemisphere's to end my after noon at work (graphic design) finishing several ads on my plate. As I shut down for the day I made a note to myself to check your site for Hemispheres when I got home. PRESTO! (well, that came later....). This piece the boys did back in the day just cruises along with such deliberately vibrant consistency. Still blows me away, long past the red vinyl album I wore almost flat and hundred years ago! Thanks again.
I used those exercises to develop my alternate plucking skills as well as build up strength, endurance, reach and speed. I only did them from the 5th fret down because I figured, if I could do them there, I could easily do them anywhere further up the neck.
Keeping IT Alive! Simply the greatest album of all time.
I hope you liked it.
Amazing, and that's not said with any amount of exaggeration. Can't believe how well you've learned and memorized this song (and all the others on your channel), let alone how flawless this performance was. I assume it was a long time in the making to get it down as well as you have... years, perhaps? I'm so impressed. Also, I have to add: much respect to ol' Ged for writing/performing such an amazing bass part... and at only 25 years old.
I sure hope you do upload the entire Rush catalog, that wold be too sweet
7:20 - 7:23... Wow. I would almost believe you arranged these bass parts, and then showed Mr. Lee how to play them.
Evening my dear friend. Im in the same boat as Giuliano. About a month ago I stumbled across this and your "Seven Cities of Gold" covers. And I was sold. I purchased a Squire Vintage Modified Jazz Bass in a natural finish with a maple neck with black inlays. And now about 2 months later I have a 70RI Fender Jazz thats black and with a rosewood neck with pearloid inlays. Im polishing up some songs, but I should have about 5 videos up within the next few weeks. Looking forward to a good youtube friendship!
The bass from 10:57 to 11:38 is absolutely awesome!! Not just because of your inspiring performance but the fact that Geddy Lee actually conceived it - truly amazing!!
I play bass righty, and just picked up a lefty bass to mess around with. I decided to make this the first song that I learn. This video will help immensely. Thanks for posting....I'll let you know how I make out...I'm sure it will be a while, unless I get frustrated and just stop trying.
The part from 6:25 is one of the best sections in all of rock n roll and the bassline is absolutely sick. You played that and the entire song brilliantly! Truly inspiring.
Yes, it is definitely one of them, isn't it? Thanks a lot!
Not sure how I missed this one, but awesome! Part IV. Armageddon is probably my favorite part of any Rush song to play. Nicely done!
YOU are the main reason of why I know 60 RUSH songs off the top of my head. For me, if learning a RUSH song gets a little difficult to learn by ear, I always go to the reliable Troy for the answer. I just wanted to thank you for posting these covers, they've helped me and countless amounts of others along the way. If you can post covers of "Clockwork Angels" and "The Garden" I will love you forever (no homo). And I almost forgot, listening to you nailing my favourite RUSH epic is indescribable
Best Geddy bass performance... You nailed it.
Thanks so much.
Anything's possible.
Thanks. I hope you do learn it, I've always found it to be an enjoyable play.
amazing,great mask collection
I didn't think it possible but I have even more respect for Mr. Lee now. That he plays such intricate lines while singing and playing the pedals is mind boggling and you nailed the bass parts. Good, good show!
Great performance. I just am reminded that Geddy Lee does more than just play bass live and the bass parts are just incredible - especially this album. It takes dedication to these videos and they serve as great tutorials for aspiring musicians.
Hi Troy, this video is art... thank you very much, with your work i increase my knowledge about how play the bass with rush songs.
Every day I see your videos no all but somes, but all about rush. I am a Civil Engineer but everyday i play the bass. Thank a lot, Regards from Panama City central america
I have no idea how I kept missing this one, but this is flat-out hardcore. I've been listening to the original cut for some time; I was particularly looking forward to how you were going to handle my favorite sequence in this song (10:40-11:57), and I have to say it was a bloody success. Geddy settles into such a cosmically solid groove there, and you absolutely stand shoulder to shoulder with him.
That was a real treat, Professor. Many, many thanks.
Oxnard Montalvo Thanks a lot. I love this song...album side.
Thank you for the kind words, I appreciate them. And I'm very glad that you find the videos helpful.
I'll give those song some consideration.
Your Geddy Lee and Dee Murray stuff is my favorite. You, Sir are an amazing musician.
Thanks, that was very nice of you to say!
Thank you very much for the very kind words. I'm really glad if you like the videos and possibly get something out of watching them.
HOLY CRAP friggin awesome
Not my first time here, mindblowing bassline from Geddy and a superb interpretation by Troy. Musically deliciuos.
Many thanks!
I could watch Troy all day long .. incredible
Thanks Dean!
I believe this is rush at their peak. You covered this PERFECTLY. im amazed, humbled, and inspired. Ive always wanted to learn this song, and hearing how delicate intricate this song really is... And how it literally doesn't repeat at all with all of the different phrasing... I was so intimidated and discouraged. I want to say im going to tackle this thing the old fashioned way with vinyl and headphones, but im just going to use your video to learn and enjoy the heck out of it. Bravo sir, standing ovation for this performance. And thank you for doing the dirty work!!
Imagine being at your "peak" at around 25 years old? I learned this on vinyl and I'd recommend something with a slider. You're going to develop carpal tunnel from moving that needle back. Take your time. I think it took me the better part of a summer to learn it and many more years to be able to play it somewhat fluently. Have fun and be patient!
Superb performance Troy. You have brilliant articulation and great 'chops.' It is an inspiration watching you play bass!
Thank you very much.
Thanks. It's a Geddy Lee model with the pick guard removed.
This Blows me Away! Your playing is So accurate to Geddy and just to memorize this!!
Thanks a lot.
I'm always excited when I see you have posted a new video, I know I'm in for a treat. This time your playing is truly in a different league. Really, Really well done. I could only wish one day I could even come close to your playing.
Outstanding work Troy.
Thanks for sharing with us.
Love your channel, but especially love the Rush covers. Your respectful precision of Geddy’s playing is appreciated and admired. Thanks!
Thank you so much Jeff. That was very nice of you to say and I’m sure I will get back to some Rush at some point in the near future.
And one more time I'm here again! Mesmerized.
Thanks!
My God, what an accomplishment to play this piece of music with such grace and effectiveness. I can understand why its one of your favorites. As for Geddy Lee, this sort of says it all.
Thanks so much. Yes, I'd been chipping away this song since the early 80's at the time I recorded this video. As you do, I also think it's a masterpiece. Yeah, Geddy threw in the kitchen sink on this one.
dude I am at loss for words except that was the best playing I have ever seen other than Geddy himself
droppinplates84 Thanks a lot. I just have a lot of time on my hands.
Thanks for bringing Geddy's genius to the forefront, and the excellent lesson.
Thanks.
Yes! Thanks absolutely enjoyed that! So much feeling there 😊
I'm really glad that you liked it! Thanks for stopping by. Take care!
This might be my favorite video that you have uploaded thus far. Thanks for sharing it with us!
That tone is fucking spot on
Top effort mate
Thanks a lot.
Great job Troy. The bass sound is a whole 'nother world from the way you used to do it. I think you have no choice but to re-do them all :-} Love the stuff in the section starting right before the 11 min mark
Up until a month or so ago I was uploading at 480p which was fine. Then recently, TH-cam was playing around with a "slow-down" feature which allowed you to slow the clip down but hear it at regular pitch. This maxed the quality out at 360p which is borderline, so I started uploading at 720p and have also started recording my bass direct, through GarageBand.
I will be sure to check out your covers, promise. I'm glad that you started posting. Thanks and take care.
Thank you very much. I agree with you that "they no longer make music" like this.