The Tanks of World War II - Episode 1: Polish TK-3 and TKS
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 พ.ค. 2018
- / tankandafvnews
This is the first episode of a new series by Tank and AFV News examining the tanks used in the Second World War.
Series Description:
This series will be the first to document almost every model of tank that saw service in World War II in roughly chronological order. We will start with the Polish campaign of 1939 and work our way through until we reach the end of the conflict in 1945, with a tentative schedule of 90 episodes. The emphasis of each video will not only be a technical description of the tank, but more importantly, we will attempt to put the vehicle within its proper historical context.
We will try to explain how each tank came into being, looking at the various factors that went into its design and production. Questions such as how did a countries particular military doctrine influence the design of the tank they decided to build? How did their industrial capabilities, or perhaps more importantly, how did their industrial limitations affect the design? And of course, what larger political and strategic demands affected the design, production and introduction of these tank designs?
We will evaluate these tanks as well, doing our best to present a nuanced judgement looking at a variety of criteria. Of course, first and foremost is the combat history of the vehicle. Did it perform on the battlefield as hoped for? Also, we need to look at whether or not the vehicle fit the particular needs of the military force that it was issued to. Was this design a technological dead end or did it provide a basis for future development? And finally, was this particular tank design one that helped shape the outcome of the war, either in a positive or a negative way for its user?
These are the types of questions we hope to answer on The Tanks of World War II. We think the story of these armored behemoths is a fascinating bit of history and we are excited to tell it. If you find these machines as interesting as we do, then please, follow us as we embark on this journey through the The Tanks of the Second World War.
Recommended by The Chieftain , and well worth watching.
Worth noting that the tankette concept is not completely dead even in the modern era. The Wiesel (technically an Armored Weapons Carrier, which is essentially a tankette in all but name) is a small air-transportable AFV that provides armored support to airborne forces that would otherwise have absolutely no armor of any kind. It's armor is just good enough to protect against small arms and shell fragments, but otherwise would probably be destroyed even by something as small as a 40mm grenade launcher. It is small and easy to conceal (by the standards of an AFV), highly mobile, and versions equipped with the TOW missile can provide effective anti-tank support, while versions equipped with the 20mm autocannons provide effective anti-personnel support.
Also, like the TKS, it's just the most adorable little AFV ever! Unlike the TKS it fills a clearly defined role that can't easily be filled by heavier tanks or IFVs.
Good point, I have often thought the Wiesel looks a good deal like those old British light tanks of the 1930's. Airborne forces are usually the exception to the rule when it comes to AFV trends.
This is exactly the sort of series I need right now. I'm playing through all of my realistic wargames in chronological order right now and this series is just the thing to be keeping up on as I make my way through WW2.
Very extensive knowledge base on this interesting vehicle which often punched above its weight. A better Q card position and maybe a desk would help to relax the hands. Great pics. Thanks for the hard work. Very good. RPM and IBG and others do kits of this tankette,mostly 1/35 thank goodness and gamers have them in resin models. Gave Germany's blitzkrieg a battering in the early stages of its Polish invasion.
Thanks for this great serie !
Very good info sir, thank you very much!
Very informative and detailed.
Can't wait for 7tp.
@Polish Hero Witold Pilecki correct Nazi Germany faced bancrupcy already in late 1935 hence the program of taking over Jewish property was started under Nuremberg Laws. The only reason why III Reich and USSR were able to afford this race to industrialization was their government willingness to engage in genocide.
This series might be improved by having a desk to lean on, facing the camera directly and being placed somewhat off-centre, in the corner, with more pictures in the background. There's some green screen anomalies on your right cheek, right forearm and the tank on your shirt.
Looking forward to more in the series. Thanks!
Hi James, Thanks for the input. Yes, we are working on the technical issues. The greenscreen for this episode was not as evenly light as I would have hoped, making keying a bit tricky. Expect to see changes with each episode as we figure out the optimum way to shoot them.
And I thought it was just me that found it a bit animated? Brilliant info and a great t-shirt but it's true there's a lot to TH-cam video presentation. We are getting spoilt he says 4 years after this video was posted!
Man, that's a sweet hat! Awesome video, I learned stuff!
Heh inaccurate info presented in bias way. I an happy host did not touch the topic of Polish Cavalry attacking German panzers.
Hello, I loved your video, will you cover in the next series the Italian tanks and self-propelled guns? It would be great a competent and in English video about the unjustly abused Italian armored forces.
It will be a while until I get to the Italian tanks. I will cover them when I get to my series on the fighting in the Mediterranean. Honestly, I will need the time to work on finding some good English language sources on Italian armor.
Hello, thank you very much for responding, if you might be interested Nicola Pignato is considered the most reliable author and it seems to me that his books can be found in English.
Good video, interesting how you mentioned Poland had more tanks than the Soviets and Germans in 1933
Thanks for the video! Super informative. What books do you recommend on the tankettes?
The base tankette was equivalent to the Panzer 1. They both only had machine guns and about the same armor thickness.
Too bad Poland couldn't produce more than 24 with the 20mm autocannon. This was equivalent to the Panzer 2(20mm cannon too).
Maybe some credits at the end to know who is involved. Looking forward to more episodes!
It's a one man show. I like to say "we' when I refer to Tank and AFV News, but its really just me doing everything.
Good video, now i wait to see the others tankettes by Italy, Russia, France and Japan.
M M don't forget the ultimate evolution of the tankette, the universal carrier. I'd love to see detail on the early variations before standardisation. Bren gun carrier vs cavalry carrier vs scout carrier vs machine gun carrier. I know they're not strictly tankettes but they are the closest thing that actually proved useful.
Kinda curious why they didn't mount a coaxial type anti-tank rifle to at least give them a bit of TvT capability.
20 mm cannon with an auto 5 round loader came along in a few (30ish) Could even penetrate Panzer IV flank armour and take out Panzer 35(t)s. Panzer IIs would be fair game too
Beginning with the russian tanks only after Operation Barbarossa, you get the impression that the USSR has not been actively involved in the war so far. In fact, by June 22, '41, the USSR had invaded or annexed forcibly territories from 8 countries and was fighting Japan.
Good point, but I needed some way to organize the series and addressing Soviet tanks in the Barbarossa section made the most sense. The individual episodes will cover the history of each vehicle in these earlier conflicts.
More videos , diagrams , and pictures of the tanks and less of you would be great.
I agree.
Very interesting topic, however, the narrator literally pot me to sleep, so bland and unenthusiastic he might as well be talking about best ways to tie a neck tie.
This video contains many historical mistakes is inaccurate and lacks proper historical context. Host is condescending and clearly favours Nazi Panzers. To start statement that Poland did not existed as a country before 1918 is not accurate as it existed and rose to prominent position and fall between 966 and 1795. Further more host contradicts himself talking about reinstatement of the country. Host shows no understanding of the means by which Nazi Germany and Soviet Union got industrialized and shows no knowledge of COP and forgets about the fact Nazi spending almost bankrupted the country. Speaking about technical details host forgets to mention that reversible periscope on TKS was a breakthrough Polish design by eng Gundlach that was later given to Brits who had in turn provided it to Soviets and Americans. That design, known as MK4 periscope, was used on every major allied tank designs since then. Further speaking about Edmund Orlik host fails to state one of the destroyed tanks destroyed during the battle of Pociecha was Panzer IV commanded by Count Von Ratibor. Overall pronunciation of Polish names is wrong and is not even close to proper. Overall good idea poor execution.
Pointing out that the German Panzers of 1939 were superior to the Polish TK series of tankettes is a historical fact, not a mere preference on my part.
@@thetanksofworldwarii-tanka4368 TKS with NKM had superior firepower to Panzer I had lower profile and was able to take out Nazi armor of all types starting with Pz I to Pz IV as shown in battle of Pociecha. I will argue as well the field of vision statement since Pz I had vision slits and TKS used MK4 periscope. Further my statement about host bias towards Nazi armor is confirmed by the amount of research time he put into videos RE panzers and the lack of thereof in videos about 7TP and TKS. Just for your info Poland had a group of projects underway that were in different stages of development in September 1939 like 10TP and 14TP cruiser tanks or 25TP .
TKS with NKM made up a very small percentage (less than 5%) of the TK series fleet.
@@thetanksofworldwarii-tanka4368 yes but was superior to PS I and II while 7TP was superior to anything but Pz IV standing toe to toe with Pz III. 10TP and 14TP would be superior to anything Nazis fielded in Poland.
@@thetanksofworldwarii-tanka4368 your acclamation to the industrialization of Soviet Union and III Reich makes me wonder if you approve of the means by which those countries got there as well.