What Makes This Song Great? "Enter Sandman" METALLICA
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- In this episode of "What Makes This Song Great?" we explore the song the music of Metallica.
💫 The Beato Ultimate Bundle - $99 FOR ALL OF My Courses: ⇢ rickbeato.com/
📘- The Beato Book Interactive - $99.00 value
🎸 - Beato Beginner Guitar - $159.00 value
👂- The Beato Ear Training Program - $99.00 value
🎸- The Quick Lessons Pro Guitar Course - $79.00 value
… all for just $99.00
Get it here: rickbeato.com/
My Beato Club supporters:
Justin Scott
Terence Mark
Farren Mahjoor
Jason Murray
Lucienne Kilpatrick
Alexander Young
Jason Wagner
Todd Ladner
Rob Kline
Nicholas Long
Tim Benson
Leonardo Martins da Costa Rodrigues
Eddie Perez
David Solomon
MICHAEL JOYCE
Stephen Stubbs
colin stead
Jonathan Wentworth-Linton
Patrick Payne
MATTHEW KARIS
Matthew Barouch
Shaun Samuels
Danny Kurywchak
Gregory Reedy
Sean Coleman
Alexander Verbitskiy
CL Turner
Jason Pappafotis
John Fulford
Margaret Carno
Robert C
David M Combs
Eric Flatt
Reto Spoerli
Herr Moritz Adam
Monte St. Johns
Jon Beezley
Peter DeVault
Eric Nabstedt
Eric Beggs
Rich Germano
Brian Bloom
Peter Pillitteri
Rick Beato in 2018: After the verse comes the chorus. Check out the chorus.
Rickt Beato in 2020: It is that dissonant 7th major chord that really gives the harmonic part of the bridge section that extra blues feeling of despair, which is not really what the band is known for, but defines this genre throughout the 90s and is a trademark of this producer who actually takes his coffee with two sugar and no cream, which I found really interesting.
Love the channel man, keep up the crazy in-depth stuff!
2018 was the buzzy fuzzy, 2020 is the hindsight
The 2020 Rick actually knows how many times it took James to record the vocals
You forgot to mention that time that he met X Y Z person involved in the record
Sugar and no cream hahahaha
@@markoobradovic148🤣🤣🤣bruh this comment section
You know its Hetfield when every word ends with a "-eh" or "ah" sound, i.e; "Hand-eh," "Bed-ah."
Thank yeeehh
Greatah commentah yeahah
Ooooh-ah!
that all started with this album.
They were initially going to be called metallic but James couldn't pronounce it
Metallica became a heavy metal (no longer thrash metal) band with this record. A lot of bands should be thankful that the Black Album came out because it essentially opened the floodgates of metal to innumerable people who hasn't experienced metal in their lives yet. This album is a masterpiece in metal recording .
That was the album that meant the era of metal was over and music is just a commercial enterprise.
@@thunkjunk They can make music the way they want, there is no hidden agenda to make money...Black has the best sound of all the albums because of their success before it.. and then they started to experiment more, after they passed their prime in mid 30s...
@@jutjub22 I disagree with most of what you said.
@@thunkjunk I know :)
@@jutjub22 I agree with everything you said :)
Jason is so underrated. He's top 5 pick style bass players all time, it's so heavy but outrageously clean for a pick.
Yup, along with Dave Ellefson, Andy West, Carl-Cadden James. D.D. Verni ain't too shabby, either.
When this album dropped Metallica basically took over the galaxy.
@Lucas Lucas Lucas it may not be thrash but it sounds fucking good
nah. The universe shifted when the video for 'one' dropped .... they becamse the undisputed masters of metal after that, I remember it well.
@Lucas Lucas Lucas I like Metallica and ABBBA LOL
in 1991 it didnt drop. it was released, the internet didnt even exist.
Next time use "," so we can understand you.
I hate how people attack Bob Rock. Years after JUSTICE people complained that you couldn't hear Jason. I love that album but you can't hear him. All Bob did was come in and take the songs Metallica had and made them sound perfect as far as the recordings. But for some reason they hate him because of the songs. All he did was take the songs that Metallica brought to the sessions and make sound perfect. He didn't write the songs. If you hate the album for the music blame Metallica. If you hate the record for production quality, you're an idiot. I admit it's not my favorite record musically by them, but the quality of the recordings is masterful. Respect to Bob Rock.
NumB sKuLL yes no big blame to him. It's just a bit dull, really.
I have to agree... And I think Bob Rock said it best about the hating on him when he said "If you think I EVER could have pushed THOSE guys into something that they didnt already want to do, then you know nothing about Lars or James or Metallica." Granted, the fleas come with the dog with what everyone wanted, but all Bob did was EXACTLY what James and Lars wanted. James wanted massive-sounding layers of tight guitar tracks, and Lars wanted a more basic but wide-spectrum sounding drum sound that could fill a planet. I would say they achieved all.
I know, the production of this album can be compared to the production of "The Dark Side of the Moon". Youc can't pretend that Metallica was gonna be Thrash or Speed even in the late 80's, that is called "evolution".
.
True but Bob is pretty much responsible for James developing the whole "Ooo Ooo ooo" "Yeah Yeah" style that he didn't do in their earlier albums
@@AdamYoudell adam, I havent seen the movie for a long time, but how can you say that Bob is responsible?? Was that in the movie?
Halfway through the intro, a wah guitar enters...and it never left.
Joel Rodely This deserves more upvotes!
michel jonasson this isn’t reddit
@@johnnybgood774 and jagmeat for all
Kirk actually used wah way before the Black Album
@@gyulagyorffy5937 he always used it.
The God That Failed is the absolute hidden gem on that album.
And don’t tread on me
Through The Never
Of Wolf And Man
Struggle within
The whole album is awesome
I am addicted to Rick's videos. He is so stunningly knowledgeable about music - the history and personalities, production techniques, instrumentation, melody and harmony, music theory - is there any facet of the field that he doesn't intimately understand? This guy is a goddamn national treasure.
Loved listening to the isolated bass. Great sound and recording.
Spector NS2...no other tone like it.
You mentioned the simplicity of the fills. Simplicity is a beautiful thing when executed perfectly...and that's true with everything.
The most well produced metal album ever. The tone, drum , bass sound super great
Dear commentators, the title is not “what makes this Metallica’s greatest song.”
Agree haha 90% didn't got the point this video it's about sound and production. Some can like more Master of puppets or even St. Anger that would be just a personal opinion. But not change the fact that the Black Album it's a milestone for the recordings, every sound engineer dream to produce such top notch quality recording (and still sound great nowdays too).
Hey Rick, throw me a bone here, where the hell do you get the individual tracks, learning these songs would awesome with isolated tracks!!!
@Austin Lucksted Pro Tools or cake walk cannot really break a cooked mix into its different tracks like that. Rick has access to those tracks if he ask for them. He's in the business of studio production ya know? Connection...
It kind of is though :P
(Whether they made better isn't important)
No that's unforgiven
This song is written just like a roller coaster. There is the foreboding of the lift hill, the delivery of the first drop, some ancillary thrills before a low section and the grand finale right before a brake run. The precision of the song is what is impressive. They aren't going for high art here. It's supposed to be entertaining. It delivers everything it aims to deliver.
I too like Metallica's older stuff better, but comparatively speaking, the recording and production quality went WAY UP on this record. The instruments sounded more distinctive, the bass was fuller without being boomy, and the stereo imaging was better on high-end equipment like Proceed, Krell Linn, Naim, and Audio Research which I sold at the time.
I'm sure the fact that they unmuted the bass this time around also helped! :)
I agree...this album was a huge leap for them.
I never liked the drum sound on "...and justice for all." To me it sounded like Lars was hitting his drums with twigs, and the guitars were just to fat compared to the rest. And they muted Newsted on that one? Is that true?
iseeu1980 look for Justice for Newstead
Metallica´s old stuff? Like Load and ReLoad wich are already old albums? or what? XD
Yeah, musically they were much better on the first 4 albums, but you have to be delusional or deaf to claim that Justice sounds better than the Black Album
While master of puppets and justice are probably my two favorite albums from these guys, musically, you can’t touch this album, sonically. To date, I’m not sure a fuller, more realistic heavy guitar tone exists. You can tell that bob and his engineers really went for broke. It sounds enormous through any system.
Nah, I prefer the Marshall rhythm guitar tone of Puppets way better. More authentic sounding than the Boogies.
@@alienrefugee51 master of puppets uses a mesa boogie mark iic+ not Marshalls
Even on my phone speaker it sounds badass
Y’all are trippin Ride the Lightning is the best and most complete Metallica Album
Skeptical Narratives - MOP is just an 80s generic guitar tone. RTL and black album have the best tones, as well as justice, but justice’s tone is sort of brittle
I love this kind of in depth break down analysis of music. Especially songs that are very popular. To hear parts of these songs isolated along with expert analysis is in my opinion a great way to learn how the art of music composition is generated/created. Having these analysis done by a genuine master musician is such a great lesson in song structure
The sound of this album was absolutely insane; it's been one of my trusted reference discs for evaluating new audio equipment for almost 3 decades now.
Such a great sound on those drums. And the drum parts may be simple but they're so clear and effective.
9:00 doesn't sound double tracked at all. But then it doesn't sound pseudo double tracked either. There's no duplicate of the main track underneath that I can hear. No phasing caused by adding a copy of it. Just a loud, bad-ass vocalist and some reverb. But maybe there is some chorus type thing added in very subtlely.
VERY possible. Bob Rock brought in a heap of effects processing units, and knew how to use them effectively.
There was no double track, James was just that good
Rick, you know how everytime you hear a song you hear different things? you just brought back so many memories.Thanks.
All of the singles on this album are worthy of analysis.
Thw whole album indeed, Amazing album and one of the greatest of Metal
Rick I've learned a lot about music with this series, really love your channel, please do some Rush song!
Kirk went Jimi Hendrix on that wah solo. This is awesome Rick! Thank you Sir.
Rick,
I recently discovered your channel and absolutely love it. I’m not a musician but really appreciate music. My three kids are learning piano and we really enjoy watching your detailed analysis. Keep it up! You rock!
Watched 2 videos. Subscribed. Your musical knowledge and explanations of this type are so much fun to listen to. Great content!!
"I call these caveman fills" And I add, because Lars IS a f*cking caveman XD
So, first you watch BigMacDavis and now you listen to Metallica. Are you following me?
@Ryan Kelly 22 (STUDENT) XD
To be fair, it's a guitar band, first and foremost...if you had a prog drummer overplaying and not hitting hard enough, the material would immediately fall apart. Needs a concrete foundation. Play to the music
@@danymalsound Nobody says it sounds bad. In fact, it perfectly suits the band as you said
@@danymalsound i think the closest Lars ever got to "progressive" was on the "Justice" album. On songs like "Eye of the Beholder" & even though his drums, cymbals & hi-hat were apparently recorded on different tracks, at times. I think that's kind of cheating, though it sounds cool.
Plus it helped me get better by trying to literally play double bass, hi-hat "splashes" & cymbal chokes to the recorded song. I was playing it myself in high school, thanks to Lars & my lack of knowledge regarding how the album was recorded at the time.
Immense production on this album! People still accuse them of "selling out" on the record, well I'm unable to make comment on that but what I do know is that it was this record that was my gateway to everything that came before it...and for that I'll always be thankful!
This song is ominous yet so danceable too and no one can tell me otherwise. Especially Jason Newsted's bass parts.
Please do Paranoid android
Ben Young he did eventually it was amazing
James’ vocals are CRAZY good!!!
I like this comment, not only because I agree with it, but also because anyone who knows how to use apostrophes this correctly is a friend!
Shaped my teens, this did. Incredibly well produced. Thanks.
A great breakdown study of an iconic rock classic. This is the song that turned Metallica into to superstars and it still sounds glorious.
Really loved this video! I must have watched the "A year and a half" videos a hundred times, and it still blows my mind how tight and punchy Jasons bass was, and how the rhythm guitars can get so chunky. Everything on this album is fantastic, and I love it to death. Awesome video, thank you!
Hetfield plays the open "G" string, instead ot the 5th fret of the "D" string in the intro. That gives it a whole different sound. Try it out! Edit: thx for the comments :)
The fifth fret on the A string is D not G and it's called open, not empty
@@felipedromundo8861 you are right :)
Live performances say otherwise
Here's a vote for The Mars Volta, Tetragrammaton. Should be fun to dissect.
My favorite episode so far.
The voice from James never ceases to amuse me. What a singer!
Keep up the great work Rick, big fan
This was GREAT!
I was 15 in 92, and this was one of the first songs my first band played. We did pretty good at it too, but I rushed the hell out of this song, and added a sixteenth note double bass run on the section right before the outro. I also played a ride cymbal during the pre-chorus sections.
The closest I ever came to that snare sound acoustically was with my 5×14 1960's Slingerland chrome over brass snare, with a clear Remo C.S. Batter head, and Ambassador snare side.
Thanks, Rick. A lot of memories there. I have some great memories with that album, and sort of growing up with Metallica in general.
Hi Rick! any thoughts on Kirk Hammet's solo? It was like "ok so that's the solo, let's move on" lol
This song was so over-played that it quickly went out of favor with me- I really began to dislike it. It became my "Stairway to Heaven" unfortunately. Thanks for making me listen to this in a new way and enjoy it again, Rick!
Right there with you man
It's always nice to hear things with new ears again. Took me a bit to realise what a great, classic song Sandman is.
10:58 sounds like a hi-hat, not a crash cymbol.
I am 99.99% it is a bassdrum/crash there. However the snare/crash combination does happen quite a few times throughout the song.
i love the snare sound off this album im not experienced in music production but i LOVE how the drums sound (especially the snare)
The sound of this album still amazes me.
Pink Floyd!!!
Apoorva Anand he said in other videos that Pink Floyd are blockers and would take down the video. Which stinks cause it would be great.
I want to see " Sheep ( 3 different ones ) explained !! What a tune
I LOVE METALLICA, THEY'RE MY ALL TIME FAVORITE BAND, ALWAYS WILL BE, AND I LISTENED TO THIS ALBUM A MILLION TIMES WHILE IN HIGH SCHOOL! I ACTUALLY WORE OUT TWO CASSETTES BEFORE UPGRADING TO THE CD!!! PROUD TO SAY THAT I'VE SEEN THEM LIVE AND THEY ARE BEYOND AWESOME LIVE! I FEEL LUCKY THAT I WAS BORN AT EXACTLY THE RIGHT TIME TO EXPERIENCE THE BEST MUSIC IN THE ENTIRE GALAXY!
I remember discovering this song and the Black album when I was 14. The album was 5 years old at the time and to me it felt like an old record lol. It single handedly introduced me into the word of rock.
Happy that you mentioned AC/DC about the drums because it was exactly what i thought when i first heard it.
I love the first 4 but the black album is on another level.
I remember when this came out. I remember being disappointed. I understand that they had probably gone as far as they could in thrash, but I didn't expect such a dramatic shift toward pop metal. It took about 20 years for me to appreciate this album. I use it regularly to setup my audio system, just like with Dark Side of the Moon. But if I want to listen to Metallica, it's Lightning, Puppets or Justice. Much like Rick says he goes to Rubber Soul and Revolver for the Beatles.
The tone always blows me away.
another 15 minutes of fun. thank you. how about doing something on some old jazz standards?
David Flint I would love that too but idk how much of that stuff was even multitracked. I think a lot of those old records were all about careful mic placement (and levels, eq etc) and then just recording the whole thing live to tape
prufrockrenegade that is true. But I was thinking more of an analysis of arrangements somehow. I’m not sure. Just a thought
I worked at A&M studios when this was mixed and worked with Bob on some other stuff. Spoiler alert, the bass would have been edited with pro tools. This was the very early days and Bob had a pro tools guy, they were using it all the time on this and Motley, etc. I had spent several all nighters with the pro tools guy as he worked on the list Bob left from the days recording. It was a combination of analog, then bounced to digital on Sony 3348 which also had the ability to sample and fly parts around as well as pro tools for editing.
Best produced rock metal album ever. Awesome production, awesome album
Can you do Darude Sandstorm next please ?
Claudio Bear & Co. LOL XD ROTFL TROLLOLOLO
Oh Yes.
only the finest of song yes
i get that Metallica are popular, but .... Rick, I'd really dig it if you covered THE SMITHS. Johnny Marr is/was a real force on the guitar. Okay, not the most mainstream group, but I don't believe they recorded a single bad song. So lots to choose from. Thanks Rick.
The smiths are one of the most famous bands of all time lmao. Theyre about as underground as Nirvana is.
Johnny Marr is an amazing guitar player.
30 years ago , still sounds fresh and a brilliant analysis by Rick.
"...And that snare that doesn't sound like anything you've heard before" st. anger causes a very similar feeling on me, but for different reasons
Hetfield's caveman drawl became the template for much of the 90s post-grunge artists (Creed, Days Of The New, etc.)
Listening to the isolated Kirk Hammett solo its amazing how its pieced together. Its clearly recorded section by section and then blended together
David Lee Roth told Joe Rogan that Eddie Van Halen would go in the studio and record a solo several times, improvising each take. He would choose the best parts and piece them together, and then practiced to learn the solo he created. Perhaps Hammet works this way too.
That’s pretty common when writing any solo. You write sections, piece them together, then play the thing together as a whole solo. I’m saying in this case you can clearly hear sections were recorded and then pieced together with no thought to learn the solo entirely and play it straight through
@@shadesofgold24 Eddie Van Halen did what you describe. The recorded solo was never played straight through. But he had to learn it to play it live. David Lee Roth said that is why you sometimes see Van Halen going from very low on the neck to very high and vise versa. He just pieced together the solo not caring how hard it would be to actually play it.
So the same way all guitar solos and songs are recorded? Gotcha.
One of the best produced albums of all time. That's probably why Rick even acknowledged any song from it. The albums that preceded it are far more classic and worthy of analysis than any song from this one but the production is just unreal. That's definitely the main reason why I liked it so much back when it came out...more for the sound than the songs.
I'm BEGGING you sir. Please do Nightrain by Guns N' Roses.
PLEASE!!!! We need it.
That that you've done Metallica. Do Megadeth. Their song Holy Wars...The Punishment Due is a masterpiece.
but don’t mention the vocals
Just all of Rust is good with me. That whole album is just brilliant.
lars managing to keep in time perfectly? wonder how many takes that took.
Why do you think the drum parts were pieced together bar by bar lol
I love the that you breaking it down and show this music is actually composed and not just bunch of guy in a garage making noise.
I will never forget listening to The Rock Show (BBC Radio 1) back in '91, just before the Black Album came out. The show started with that first part of the track before cutting off to the late and great, Tommy Vance, It then cut back to the track and back to Vance and so on until the track kicked in. Me and my bro were like "WHOOOOOOOOOOOAAAAAAAAA........."
One of the BEST albums ! I love METALLICA !!
Do Something off appetite for destruction please
I saw an interview with Kevin James Hetfield and Kirk Hammett and they were talking about the lead to Enter Sandman and Kirk said he thought it only took him about 45 minutes or an hour to write the lead to it and James said no I think it was more around 30 minutes. I've been playing guitar for 34 years, I can't do that. Is truly awesome
"HAMMETT: We were drinking at the Carlson house one night, and Lars turned on the tape deck: "Listen to this, man. Forstex Multitrack Mesa/Boogies with James playing the heaviest riff ever!" It was the main riff to "Master of Puppets", which had been quadrupled on all four tracks and sounded super heavy. And I knew it immediately as this joke riff that James would always play on the D string. He just dropped it down to the low E string and it was suddenly this whole other thing."
this album had a bass track? :) nice to hear the bass parts from this album.
It was their first album that had bass :)
Rick Beato fourth record not first.
And Jason for all
What a gem on TH-cam! Thanks Rick, a lot. I love analyzing songs and playing along by ears. This really helps a lot.
By the way, can you (or anyone would be pleased to help...) tell me which software you use to split tracks into fully seperated ones??? I would be thankful to know!
I enjoyed your show. Your a true musician brother. And i thank you for your knowledge passion and hard work..
Rick, how do you get access to the master tracks? That is amazing. (Armature audio engineer here)
Exactly what I was about to ask
He puts out
Probably used spectralayers or RX? to separate the tracks out
He knows someone in the business. He says in some other video that it has nothing to do with plug-ins separating tracks.
they're on youtube already so...
I would love to see a video on Seanons in the Abyss by Slayer. The drum fills are so good!
Bob Rock did a great job capturing tones and takes and making a sonically big and clear sounding record. I also like some of the concise melodic songwriting but for instance in Holier Than Thou I’m not thrilled at some of the talk box ‘gimmicky” stuff he added it covers up the riffage underneath which in the verse particularly is pretty f’in badass look up the Black album Holier Than Thou demo
I heard Bob Rock said sometime in the recording of the album something in the lines of: its gonna sound like we doubled the vocal tracks but we won’t. I ´m not sure if they did so or not
rick. you gotta do some FAITH NO MORE!!!
Best thing I have seen on TH-cam all day 🤘
I remember going out on my lunch break working on an assembly line 2 buy the album on vinyl 4 myself and the CD 4 my mate. I listened 2 Sandman on the rock show before Metallica were about 2 support AC/DC on the Monsters of rock Donington which I and a bunch of friends went 2...
Why do you not mention where you got the split out tracks for your vids? Maybe you mention it in another vid but I'd like to know that. Is it one of those Rock Band games or something?
Yeah- you can use the Clone Hero Spreadsheet to find every song from Guitar Hero’s individual tracks.
Rick your latest "Late Night" video is blocked. At least in Italy. I hate TH-cam.
David RF I thought it might be. That’s why wanted to test them out. It saved me the time of making a video
I told Mr. Beato to stop using copyrighted material in his videos!
Don't see the harm when used for educational purposes.
VPN my dude. Works like a charm.
And the battle rages?
One error for sure, at 10:55 - Lars doesn't hit crash and snare there, it's the usual bass drum and crash.
soberek that’s what I thought too, thanks for clarifying!
Love the squeak on the guitar solo or whatever you call it
Hetfield and Ulrich are the Lennon & McCartney of Metal
Hell no
Burton, not Ulrich
Yup. Lars is not the greatest drummer, but he’s genius composer. Without him, Metallica wouldn’t be on top
think you mean Iommi & Butler..
Idt so, if they had better drummer maybe would sound far more powerful, but drummer formed this band together with James so, guess he had to be part of band, Lars isnt near greatest
please do Aerosmith!
I love these analytical break downs, Rick! Excellent work! Subscribed.
Goosebumps!!
I love the part when Kirk's solo ends, and then... not a word, moving on, nothing to see here :D
I hate his lead tone on the Black album
Hahahaha I was scrolling down the comments looking for this
Listening solo alone I realized how bad it is Uhhh, I used to admire this song
@@turbopelex what do you mean?...it fits perfectly in the song... actually all solos in this album are perfect for the songs
@@yoguimasterof69 I know they fit perfect but I expect something more when I listen the solo without distortion. At the end, so be it!
I’ve been following you for a while and I haven’t seen anything on Five Finger Death Punch. I think Jason Hook is and incredible guitarist and I’d love to see you do an episode on What Makes this Song Great with their tune Hard To See. I think you’d appreciate it, it has a killer solo.
If I'm not mistaken, the clean sounds were done with a Roland JC120 amp.
Do Cirice by Ghost! From Meliora's album
How did you get hold of these tracks? Or how did you decompile them? (Not a joke, if there's a way to decompile songs, I want to know) thanks! I'm sorry if this is a stupid question for some reason, but I honestly do not know any better :)
Wesley Beernaert Some of the tracks he probably got from Rock Band/Guitar Hero Games... You can almost find any isolated track of Metallica songs online!
I would love it if music was released such that the individual tracks or parts could be listened to separately as Rick does in these videos. Great stuff. We analyzed Enter Sandman lyrics in my grade 9 English class when it was at its peak of popularity.
Rick, dude, Metallica is the reason I started playing guitar (way back in 1989!). Once I heard Puppets and Justice, I was hooked...
Fast forward to when the Black album was released, I was just as obsessed with it.
Kirk does some extremely amazing lead work and he has all of these little eerie sounds that are haunting throughout the album.
And of course, the production is awesome.
I think the reason some didn’t care for this album is simply because they expanded their audience with this album. So you had metalheads that were upset that other people (non-metalheads, if you will) listening to their music! So that was more of a psychological turn off to some die hard metalheads. Hopefully that makes sense.
But it’s a phenomenal album!
Have never clicked something so fast
Do you know the recent cover by "The Warning", the amazing three-sister rockband from Mexico? It's amazing!
I would love to see an episode on their song "Fade To Black"
One can think whatever of the Black album, but damn the sounds on this album are still - to this date - exceptionally great.
The Bass!! When it comes in with the Drums! Ooohhh! So good!
Would you be able to do something from Pantera's Far Beyond Driven? That's an amazing album.
Hell yea man. "I'm Broken" would be my favorite from that one.