Thank you for having Haviv on again. His perspective is important. It has been a rough year, for sure. G-d willing, all of the remaining hostages will be returned swiftly and soon. Amen.
There's a lot of people on TH-cam who speak on this topic, and I've spent countless hours watching, but if I had to pick only one to recommend to someone it would be Haviv. He's been incredible, anyone interested in this conflict must watch his two lectures "The great misinterpretation" and "The Jews who lived through history". The first explains the Palestinian side and the second the Israeli one, and by the end you really feel that finally you start to understand where both are coming from, and maybe how you would feel in their shoes, in true human terms, instead of just historical and legal facts. Highly recommended.
100% agree. I check TH-cam daily to see if any new conversation was posted with him. He is incredible and fair and so knowledgeable and articulate. His soft spoken manner and voice is so therapeutic… ✡️🇮🇱
Haviv has earned tremendous regard in many educated circles for a reason. Here he is at his best. Although taped prior to Nasrallah 's demise. Stay well, dear Haviv. שנה טובה.
This was incredible. The first interview with Haviv got me to subscribe and read the Times of Israel every day. I could hear you two talk for hours and hours. Thank you!
Cannot wait for the third installment - I could listen to Haviv for hours and something about being on this particular podcast brings out the best in him..
Jack, you should have Einat Wilf and Natasha Hausdorff on your show. Two brilliant Israeli women that explain the situation. Natasha is an expert on International law and Einat used to be one of those Leftists that supported the Oslo Accords and woke up to the reality of Palestinian society and extremism.
She is very good and speaks well, but again she is part of the 'Ha Elita' (The elite class) and that perspective has been given to much influence and exposure already. Would love to hear from people that were of the left and 'WOKE UP' like 'Gadi Taub' or 'Irit Lenor'.
I just discovered Natasha Hausdorff yesterday somehow, and I’m so impressed. I’ve been learning as much as I can for a year, and I feel like she’s wildly increased my knowledge just since last night.
@StormDAleph Natasha Hausdorff is British. @@modify.d7160 Taub and Linor are not "right wing", They're both self proclaimed pro-Bibi propagandists, what in Israel we call "Bibistim". They are known to spread mis/disinformation meant to make the Israeli public hate the oposition to the current government, and prevent Bibi from being forced to take responsibilty for his failures that led to Oct 7 and resign.
Thank you for the interview with Haviv Rettig Gur. I try to follow all of his interviews. This was a particularly good interview. “People only see war when it fits their politics.” - Haviv Rettig Gur
Great interview. Would love you to interview Zvi Yehezkeli. He is a famous Journalist who has intimate knowledge of not only the Arab world, but the Muslim world in general. He is famous for his documentary series going undercover into the Muslim world in Europe and America.
Incredible interview. I can't find a lot of Haviv's interviews in Hebrew. Sadly, a lot of what you're explaining to English speaking auditory, needs to be explained to many people in Israel in plain Hebrew. Lots of us just don't know or just tend to ignore history and facts.
Excellent interview. I’ve watched many interviews with Haviv and I find him to be thoughtful, balanced and empathetic in his approach. Not sure if you realize Jack, but at the 1:45:58 mark, your Outro is over the audio of Haviv’s voice for about 15 seconds.
The end was the only positive thing i have heard in a year about this situation. I have never hear about Ra'am (United Arab List), but this seems like the best path. Violence get you no where, a hard lesson to learn. Democracy and Demands.
33:10 ... Nothing happened ? Pretty sure that America was threatening to withhold weapon shipments and currently are ... Unfortunately maybe Bibi thought that by playing nice with the Americans he could secure a better setup for the future ... Unfortunately that was a bad gamble in his last time but it's still very understandable that one would try to make sure their supply lines don't get disrupted prior to entering the war
19:15 Haviv is wrong. 17 y.o Aisha al Zyadna, and her 18 y.o brother Bil'al, of the Israeli Bedouin community in the Negev, were released from Hamas captivity on November 30 2023 as a part of the exchange deal. Their father Youssef and older brother Hamza are still in Hamas captivity.
@@Bigredfitnessmoshe Haviv is extremely intelligent and insightful. His opinions about Bibi are very mild compared to the opossition camp in Israel. His opinions seem to be very weighed and calculated. I wouldn't call it an "anti Bibi bias" at all.
@@talkfmn I disagree with you. Obviously there are people who have stronger opinions than he does, but he’s made it very clear where he stands on bibi . He was writing articles about how evil BB was long before October 7
@@Bigredfitnessmoshe I'm not familiar with stuff he wrote about Bibi before Oct 7, I based my assertion on this video and other videos I've seen of him lately on youtube. I'll have to look that up, but I have to say I find it hard to believe Haviv would use such language, based on how calculated and mild he is in what I've seen of him.
@@talkfmn he speaks with a gentle voice .. but his narrative is extremely anti bibi. That means people are not getting neural Israeli opinion . They are getting the opinion of someone who is staunchly left leaning , anti bibi . If you don’t get it, then it’s only because you don’t actually understand Israeli inner workings and politics .
Israel needs to address urgently "catastrophic conditions" among Palestinian civilians in the besieged Gaza Strip and stop "intensifying suffering" by limiting aid deliveries, its ally the United States told the U.N. Security Council on Wednesday.
Cheap shot! Mr. Gur's thoughtful remarks are an inspiration to the millions of people in the West who solidly support Israel's fight for self preservation and domestic peace.
hes a is a veteran Israeli journalist and the Senior Analyst at The Times of Israel for the last 20 years. Plus he's done the army and lives in the country. I think he knows something.
Excellent interview. I’ve watched many interviews with Haviv and I find him to be thoughtful, balanced and empathetic in his approach. Not sure if you realize Jack, but at the 1:45:58 mark, your Outro is over the audio of Haviv’s voice for about 15 seconds.
![[DRIP] ‘Love, Maybe’ PREVIEW](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/U7hwHp95m1k/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you for having Haviv on again. His perspective is important. It has been a rough year, for sure. G-d willing, all of the remaining hostages will be returned swiftly and soon. Amen.
There's a lot of people on TH-cam who speak on this topic, and I've spent countless hours watching, but if I had to pick only one to recommend to someone it would be Haviv. He's been incredible, anyone interested in this conflict must watch his two lectures "The great misinterpretation" and "The Jews who lived through history". The first explains the Palestinian side and the second the Israeli one, and by the end you really feel that finally you start to understand where both are coming from, and maybe how you would feel in their shoes, in true human terms, instead of just historical and legal facts. Highly recommended.
Absolutely seconded.
100% agree. I check TH-cam daily to see if any new conversation was posted with him. He is incredible and fair and so knowledgeable and articulate. His soft spoken manner and voice is so therapeutic… ✡️🇮🇱
I haven't watched this video yet....
Wondering...I read that Hamas attacked because Israeli soldiers had been harassing women at the mosque.
@@serpentines6356
lol don't be gullible
@@serpentines6356 dount it, this was not the kind of attack that could be launched spontaneously, it took years of planning.
Haviv has earned tremendous regard in many educated circles for a reason. Here he is at his best. Although taped prior to Nasrallah 's demise. Stay well, dear Haviv. שנה טובה.
This was incredible. The first interview with Haviv got me to subscribe and read the Times of Israel every day. I could hear you two talk for hours and hours. Thank you!
Excellent conversation, I appreciate the candor.
What a fantastic interview... thank you!!!
Cannot wait for the third installment - I could listen to Haviv for hours and something about being on this particular podcast brings out the best in him..
Jack, you should have Einat Wilf and Natasha Hausdorff on your show. Two brilliant Israeli women that explain the situation. Natasha is an expert on International law and Einat used to be one of those Leftists that supported the Oslo Accords and woke up to the reality of Palestinian society and extremism.
She is very good and speaks well, but again she is part of the 'Ha Elita' (The elite class) and that perspective has been given to much influence and exposure already. Would love to hear from people that were of the left and 'WOKE UP' like 'Gadi Taub' or 'Irit Lenor'.
Both great guest ideas!
@@modify.d7160I love Gadi Taub and his weekly show with Mike Doran
I just discovered Natasha Hausdorff yesterday somehow, and I’m so impressed. I’ve been learning as much as I can for a year, and I feel like she’s wildly increased my knowledge just since last night.
@StormDAleph Natasha Hausdorff is British.
@@modify.d7160 Taub and Linor are not "right wing", They're both self proclaimed pro-Bibi propagandists, what in Israel we call "Bibistim".
They are known to spread mis/disinformation meant to make the Israeli public hate the oposition to the current government, and prevent Bibi from being forced to take responsibilty for his failures that led to Oct 7 and resign.
Have this guy on every month.
Thank you for the interview with Haviv Rettig Gur. I try to follow all of his interviews. This was a particularly good interview. “People only see war when it fits their politics.” - Haviv Rettig Gur
Don’t apologize for pointing out the incompetence of our government. Incompetence is about all the US Government is good for lately.
Great interview. Would love you to interview Zvi Yehezkeli. He is a famous Journalist who has intimate knowledge of not only the Arab world, but the Muslim world in general. He is famous for his documentary series going undercover into the Muslim world in Europe and America.
very excited for this. Haviv is one of the most thoughtful voices in Israel
Yes. 100%. Very fair and knowledgeable and so intelligent and articulate. Great reporter
I could listen to Haviv for hours…. thank you for this interview gentlemen
This Haviv guy is awesome
Excellent interview 🙏
"We lean on each other or we fall" true!
Incredible interview and guest. I’ve never heard of him before, but will certainly listen out for his voice!
I am reading Black Saturday after watching your interview with Trey.. excellent book! This interview is packed full of excellent facts !
Wonderful interview. Thank you.
My prayers to IDF and the victims of horrific 10/7 🙏 Standing with Israel 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇺🇲
Yes. ! Einat Wilf.
Incredible interview. I can't find a lot of Haviv's interviews in Hebrew. Sadly, a lot of what you're explaining to English speaking auditory, needs to be explained to many people in Israel in plain Hebrew. Lots of us just don't know or just tend to ignore history and facts.
Excellent interview. I’ve watched many interviews with Haviv and I find him to be thoughtful, balanced and empathetic in his approach.
Not sure if you realize Jack, but at the 1:45:58 mark, your Outro is over the audio of Haviv’s voice for about 15 seconds.
Oh my, I'm too old for this.
Thank you❤
Feels like this was recorded a month ago. A lot has changed in a month.
Might get a strike from woke YT, but I say this! Standing with Israel 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇺🇲🇺🇲
Those predictions about Lebanon and the cost of fighting hizbollah haven't aged well :)
Thank you for posting this. However, it seems to be a month old in a very rapidly developing situation.
This must have been recorded weeks ago
👏👏👏👏
When was this recorded?
Because he speaks of Lebanon as if the campaign hadn't yet begun there. Before operation Grim Beeper.
Good Interview
The end was the only positive thing i have heard in a year about this situation. I have never hear about Ra'am (United Arab List), but this seems like the best path. Violence get you no where, a hard lesson to learn. Democracy and Demands.
Thank you Mr. Rettig Gur. Very wise perspective.
Well said sir. God bless Israel
Sounds like this was recorded awhile back. How current events changes so quickly?
33:10 ... Nothing happened ? Pretty sure that America was threatening to withhold weapon shipments and currently are ... Unfortunately maybe Bibi thought that by playing nice with the Americans he could secure a better setup for the future ... Unfortunately that was a bad gamble in his last time but it's still very understandable that one would try to make sure their supply lines don't get disrupted prior to entering the war
Is there a transcript of this somewhere?
Which of jack’s books should a newcomer start with?
19:15 Haviv is wrong.
17 y.o Aisha al Zyadna, and her 18 y.o brother Bil'al, of the Israeli Bedouin community in the Negev, were released from Hamas captivity on November 30 2023 as a part of the exchange deal.
Their father Youssef and older brother Hamza are still in Hamas captivity.
"Wikipedia is your friend" Early life never lies
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱💛💛💛🙏🙏🙏
Rumble
VIVE LA RESISTANCE ✊ 💚🤍❤️🖤
Rape and slaughter of civilians is not resistance. Disgusting and shameful to portray massacre of Jews as such
OMG, the hasbara is also going on here. I thought at least this journalist would give an honest interview
Haviv is great , but he has a very strong anti bibi bias . People should be aware of this very strong negative bias.
@@Bigredfitnessmoshe Haviv is extremely intelligent and insightful.
His opinions about Bibi are very mild compared to the opossition camp in Israel.
His opinions seem to be very weighed and calculated. I wouldn't call it an "anti Bibi bias" at all.
@@talkfmn I disagree with you. Obviously there are people who have stronger opinions than he does, but he’s made it very clear where he stands on bibi . He was writing articles about how evil BB was long before October 7
@@Bigredfitnessmoshe I'm not familiar with stuff he wrote about Bibi before Oct 7, I based my assertion on this video and other videos I've seen of him lately on youtube. I'll have to look that up, but I have to say I find it hard to believe Haviv would use such language, based on how calculated and mild he is in what I've seen of him.
@@talkfmn he speaks with a gentle voice .. but his narrative is extremely anti bibi. That means people are not getting neural Israeli opinion . They are getting the opinion of someone who is staunchly left leaning , anti bibi . If you don’t get it, then it’s only because you don’t actually understand Israeli inner workings and politics .
His newspaper did very well in covid and very well during this war, nuff said.
Israel needs to address urgently "catastrophic conditions" among Palestinian civilians in the besieged Gaza Strip and stop "intensifying suffering" by limiting aid deliveries, its ally the United States told the U.N. Security Council on Wednesday.
Haviv Gur🤡 the self proclaimed Expert.
One might say that he has an insight and a right to that insight considering he is an Israeli who lives there.
That’s a weird comment 😊
Cheap shot! Mr. Gur's thoughtful remarks are an inspiration to the millions of people in the West who solidly support Israel's fight for self preservation and domestic peace.
hes a is a veteran Israeli journalist and the Senior Analyst at The Times of Israel for the last 20 years. Plus he's done the army and lives in the country. I think he knows something.
Says "Vladimir Putin" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
The irony !
Excellent interview. I’ve watched many interviews with Haviv and I find him to be thoughtful, balanced and empathetic in his approach.
Not sure if you realize Jack, but at the 1:45:58 mark, your Outro is over the audio of Haviv’s voice for about 15 seconds.