They still think there was no alcohol after it was proven in vet records? They did it, and the witness was super annoying, her facial expressions were so irritating.
@@Sylvia-Storm My sister-in-law is exactly like the witness here. I live with her. Same age, and personality. Can’t stand her because she doesn’t care about anybody other than my brother, and herself. And pretends nothing’s going on by looking at her phone even if the world goes down around her. And she greets me just to please my brother. But other than that, she barely speaks a word to you. Rude as heck!
Of course, they did. One day, something tragic is going to happen to the defendant and his witness, and they'll be tearing up, like the poor plaintiff did in court.
it was probably his friend that did it, and he was drunk and thought it was funny and no big deal. The witness definitely knew, but 'pretended' to know nothing by scrolling on her phone and ignoring everything
"They've been trying to put me out." Hmmm, probably because you wake up at 12 noon and contribute nothing to the house. I can't even sleep in until noon on my days off.
Defendants have zero remorse even though they know what they did could have killed the dogs. Sick psychopaths. Don't fall for that "dumb" or "too drunk" horseshit.
@@lorirogers9304 Why do you say that? What are you going to a courthouse for? Not everyone goes before a judge. Or were you criticizing a 20yo for not acting more grown up & worldly and that she is somehow indicative of her age group as a whole? Where have I heard that before? According to all previous generations, the next generation has always been full of stupid, lazy kids that will bring about the end of humanity. Old people, and the past, suck.
Did ya'll cath his witnesses smirking and eye rolling. And that she ignored the aunt with her face on social media. I think she did it. Sociopaths arent so hard to spot.
I have a strange feeling that Mrs Ticktock brain was the one that did it and I also have a suspicion the defendant knew exactly who did and when but thought it was funny to get the dogs drunk like the idiot he looked like.
I really feel badly for the plaintiff. Unfortunately, people are becoming more apethetic, closing themselves into their own little worlds. Can understand JJ's reaction to the defendant's witness because I've seen it so often myself.
The witness was very likely involved. Stupid drunks being stupid drunks together, egging each other on. Because otherwise why would she insist, after the vet records, that she thought they didn’t have any alcohol? She is in some major denial.
She's the most disgusting person I have ever witnessed on this show. I hope she gets everything she deserves in life. Her parents should blame themselves.
What a terrible thing to do. I'm surprised the dogs drank it though, at least enough to get drunk. You think they'd be turned off from the taste of straight vodka or tequila.
That eye roll tells me all I need to know about how smug and self-absorbed the defendant’s friend is. Neither of them gave a damn to how dangerous their little joke was.
The defendants are stupid and have 0 remorse for what happened to the 3 dogs and the man looks like he is already a drunk in court while his witness just smiles throughout the episode. Evil people, I'm glad the plaintiff took her dogs in to get emergency treatment and she's right, that could've killed them if she didn't get them to the vet on time, glad she won the case against these two stupid people.
"I didn't even know the dogs were there." He's on a roll with the lies. It's simply not possible to be in a small space without knowing dogs are present.
I’m actually curious as to how the dogs consumed that much alcohol. I put alcohol in a bowl once to see if she would drink it (I wouldn’t actually allow her if she tried) and she sniffed it and looked at me like wtf is that!? I guess I assumed all dogs would smell alcohol and know it’s not something to be consumed.
I'm not sure I agree with her decision on this one. There have been so many episodes where JJ holds a pet owner or a child's parent responsible for bringing them over to someone's home and keeping track of their activity when they're present, unlike being gone and leaving them under the custodial care of the homeowner. Judging that the dogs consumed alcohol, because someone spiked their water bowl, because someone spiked their water bowl is assumptive. Dogs can and do get into food and beverages on their own, left unattended. The plaintiff should have been watching her dogs.
Witness is as useless as a four turn left sign on an only one way road. 🤨 She and defendant definitely knows who did it, if not them, and costs them $$$! 🤔
I feel bad for her, but why would you bring 3 dogs (pitmixes are large) to another person's home. Maybe I missed something but I would at least keep an eye on them not destroying another person's property.
So the young dude is a loser... he allowed one of his friends to put alcohol in the waterbowl of a relatives dogs... shame on him... and that 304 of a witness... well... dress for court next time.
Love JJ but her explanation of things at 1:45 or so is shaky. I could absolutely see burying my head in my phone if some awkward family drama was going on in front of me and I'm just renting a room there
The tattoo on the neck of wanna-be-a-thug defendant says it all about his character. Not man enough to admit to his wrong doing. Plaintiff on the other hand is over dramatic too, why no asking for the reimbursement for the bills without all the intense emotion?!
I don’t think he was the one who actually did it but i do believe one of the friends did. He said he had abt 10 coming and going throughout the day so yea. And personally i would do the same thing the witness did if family members are arguing I’m minding my business i stay away from drama so not really any red flags there…feel bad for the dogs hope she keeps their bowls in sight at any future events around people who are not in the right head space. Also surprised JJ awarded without evidence he was guilty she had no evidence other than the fact that he was outside at the time she smelled the bowl…hope this doesn’t ruin their relationship as nephew and aunt
They still think there was no alcohol after it was proven in vet records? They did it, and the witness was super annoying, her facial expressions were so irritating.
Yes she looked like a nasty piece of work that young girl
Looked like she had a screw loose.
@@Sylvia-Storm My sister-in-law is exactly like the witness here. I live with her. Same age, and personality. Can’t stand her because she doesn’t care about anybody other than my brother, and herself. And pretends nothing’s going on by looking at her phone even if the world goes down around her. And she greets me just to please my brother. But other than that, she barely speaks a word to you. Rude as heck!
They absolutely did it!
My mother always said "the greatest threats to a person's health and safety are not from malevolent people, but from stupid people"
She should have just shown you a picture of the witness and it would have made the same point, because she was ...
She is correct
She should have got more for having to deal with these idiots🤦♀️
The defendant is fighting his instinct (and sometimes losing) to smirk and his witness is brain dead.
The WITNESS IS THICK AS A PLANK 😮
No his GF, she was smiling and giggling about the alcohol and making the dogs drink it to almost death.
Every time they say they don't know or understand, they smirk.
They knew what happened to those dogs
They surely do
poor lil doggos ...
Of course, they did. One day, something tragic is going to happen to the defendant and his witness, and they'll be tearing up, like the poor plaintiff did in court.
Poor dogs 🐕🐕🐕🐕
it was probably his friend that did it, and he was drunk and thought it was funny and no big deal. The witness definitely knew, but 'pretended' to know nothing by scrolling on her phone and ignoring everything
Defendant: “She always brings her dogs with her to the house”
Also Defendant: “I didn’t know the dogs were there”
Good catch!
I was looking for this comment! When I heard him saying that at the end I was like wait a damn minute! 😂
And he also said that he loves the dogs like they're his nieces
Defendants seem like sociopaths. They are trying hard not to smirk or laugh.
I don't think they were trying hard, they were smirking. They don't even care.
Anybody else catch that quick smirk @2:43. He ain’t slick. He’s sick. 😒
I believe he was in on the entire thing and thought it would be hilarious to see the dogs as drunk as him. Hence the smirk.
Yep, acting confused but accidentally let it slip.
I did, they did it because they thought it would be funny
No evidence, the smirk said it all. JJ didn't miss it😊⚖️
I can not imagine being at a family gathering & not having a reaction when someone is accusing someone of trying to poison the dogs that are there.
I don't believe for a second that Rita wasn't drinking - she only said that cuz she's 20
"They've been trying to put me out."
Hmmm, probably because you wake up at 12 noon and contribute nothing to the house.
I can't even sleep in until noon on my days off.
Defendants have zero remorse even though they know what they did could have killed the dogs. Sick psychopaths. Don't fall for that "dumb" or "too drunk" horseshit.
Her eye roll at the end 😂😂😂😂
ha yea caught that 'tude
Yeah she's beyond help. Either a sociopath or hasn't suffered enough in life yet.
Poor girl, does she even know she’s at a courthouse?
This is our future unfortunately
@@lorirogers9304oh please, there are plenty of terrible Boomers too. Just look at Jan 6.
😂 I know dressing for the night club smh 🤦♀️ this generation is doomed
@@lorirogers9304 Why do you say that? What are you going to a courthouse for? Not everyone goes before a judge. Or were you criticizing a 20yo for not acting more grown up & worldly and that she is somehow indicative of her age group as a whole? Where have I heard that before? According to all previous generations, the next generation has always been full of stupid, lazy kids that will bring about the end of humanity. Old people, and the past, suck.
Idiocracy (2006).
Does the defendant 's witness even know where she is? The smirk on her face and how she is dressed is inappropriate 😒😑
Did ya'll cath his witnesses smirking and eye rolling. And that she ignored the aunt with her face on social media.
I think she did it.
Sociopaths arent so hard to spot.
100% spot on, they are both sociopaths and they both did it. She didn't look up cuz she already knew what it was about!
Poor lady and puppers 😢.
I have a strange feeling that Mrs Ticktock brain was the one that did it and I also have a suspicion the defendant knew exactly who did and when but thought it was funny to get the dogs drunk like the idiot he looked like.
Drunks are a big threat to society because they behave irrationally.
"I didn't know what was going on."
I'm sure that happens a lot
Unfortunately you can’t choose your relatives.
Be safe everyone and guard your pet food bowls.
And sometimes you have to distance yourself from your relatives, case in point.
The dogs are like his nieces, but he didn’t know they were there. Sir, you have to have been stupid drunk.
Judge Judy didn't spell out the reasons for her decision. She didn't need to.
Maybe they need to stop drinking. It's saturated their brains.
You could tell she was telling the truth bc she admitted to being on her phone looking up about alcohol poisoning.
While driving!
@margaretwade Yes! I got interrupted while writing that and didn't finish what I meant to say. Thank you for saying that. 😊
those who can judge me. 1) God ; 2) Judy
I’m surprised the penalty wasn’t higher. Should likely have been a criminal case
I really feel badly for the plaintiff. Unfortunately, people are becoming more apethetic, closing themselves into their own little worlds. Can understand JJ's reaction to the defendant's witness because I've seen it so often myself.
The witness was very likely involved. Stupid drunks being stupid drunks together, egging each other on. Because otherwise why would she insist, after the vet records, that she thought they didn’t have any alcohol? She is in some major denial.
Are they sociopaths or simply representatives of how bad society has become? 😢😢😢
Imagine being RELATED to those people....this is why I just mind my business and have like 3 friends.
Girlfriends dress highly inappropriate for court with thigh high boots, judge judy look said it all 😂
Her only interest was in looking good on T.V.!!
He is stupid sober too lol
3:33 JJ just smoke the Defendant friend on the side their 😲😳. Lol lmao XD #hahahaha 😭😂💀
The young girl is smooth and already knows how play others like a fiddle.
I thought she was super daft
Leave your dogs home people!
She’s 20, gen z are always on their phones 😂
She's the most disgusting person I have ever witnessed on this show. I hope she gets everything she deserves in life. Her parents should blame themselves.
Well he did brought a good witness but lost and has to pay 1500 for dogs being drunk and i feel bad for the dogs
The show pays the judgment. He's not out a dime.
What a terrible thing to do. I'm surprised the dogs drank it though, at least enough to get drunk. You think they'd be turned off from the taste of straight vodka or tequila.
It was flavored tequila, I wonder if they might have liked that.
Watered down alcohol was all the dogs had to drink and they were thirsty, it’s not the poor dogs fault, nephew and his witness look and act high.
Looks like the defendants may have drunk out the same bowl as the dogs. They both look like they on something.
JJ should’ve called her out for rolling her eyes at her 😂
That eye roll tells me all I need to know about how smug and self-absorbed the defendant’s friend is. Neither of them gave a damn to how dangerous their little joke was.
Poor Dogs,and all three.She really should have gotten more for her medical expenses.In my opinion but,JJ makes the rules.
The defendants are stupid and have 0 remorse for what happened to the 3 dogs and the man looks like he is already a drunk in court while his witness just smiles throughout the episode. Evil people, I'm glad the plaintiff took her dogs in to get emergency treatment and she's right, that could've killed them if she didn't get them to the vet on time, glad she won the case against these two stupid people.
our younger generation keeps getting more and more stupid…duhh
As a licensed vet for 40 years, I agree with the judges decision. She was 💯 right
They should be in jail
I would've been like.Let me smell the bow Cause I would've been able to tell.
NOT A BIG DEAL!!!!!!!!!
oh that girl is somethink......................🤦♂
I wouldn't think dogs would like the taste of alcohol, especially something like vodka. Regardless, that was a stupid thing to do.
"I didn't even know the dogs were there." He's on a roll with the lies. It's simply not possible to be in a small space without knowing dogs are present.
Even a larger space is hard to imagine. Dogs tend to at least greet people in the same space as them.
I’m actually curious as to how the dogs consumed that much alcohol. I put alcohol in a bowl once to see if she would drink it (I wouldn’t actually allow her if she tried) and she sniffed it and looked at me like wtf is that!? I guess I assumed all dogs would smell alcohol and know it’s not something to be consumed.
I wish i could tell you who all did it but...
I was stupid drunk 😂
Rita and the defendant are guilty as all get out. They still think it’s a funny joke. It was the little psychopath Rita‘s idea.
I'm not sure I agree with her decision on this one. There have been so many episodes where JJ holds a pet owner or a child's parent responsible for bringing them over to someone's home and keeping track of their activity when they're present, unlike being gone and leaving them under the custodial care of the homeowner. Judging that the dogs consumed alcohol, because someone spiked their water bowl, because someone spiked their water bowl is assumptive. Dogs can and do get into food and beverages on their own, left unattended. The plaintiff should have been watching her dogs.
Why does she talk like that. It’s annoying
Time to grow up Jake. Enter the adult world.
Witness is as useless as a four turn left sign on an only one way road. 🤨
She and defendant definitely knows who did it, if not them, and costs them $$$! 🤔
I feel bad for her, but why would you bring 3 dogs (pitmixes are large) to another person's home. Maybe I missed something but I would at least keep an eye on them not destroying another person's property.
Lies!
She's not normal.
So the young dude is a loser... he allowed one of his friends to put alcohol in the waterbowl of a relatives dogs... shame on him... and that 304 of a witness... well... dress for court next time.
Wow, such rude, young people, Not a very good testimonial for drinking!
Love JJ but her explanation of things at 1:45 or so is shaky. I could absolutely see burying my head in my phone if some awkward family drama was going on in front of me and I'm just renting a room there
🤦♀️😢🤦♀️
The witness too kinda dumb too rolling your eyes please ! You talk like your 17 years old grow up
The tattoo on the neck of wanna-be-a-thug defendant says it all about his character. Not man enough to admit to his wrong doing. Plaintiff on the other hand is over dramatic too, why no asking for the reimbursement for the bills without all the intense emotion?!
I think she’s very tender hearted and can’t believe someone would hurt her sweet animals
The plaintiff needs some therapy. Not because of the dogs but because she seems to have a personality disorder
I don’t think he was the one who actually did it but i do believe one of the friends did. He said he had abt 10 coming and going throughout the day so yea. And personally i would do the same thing the witness did if family members are arguing I’m minding my business i stay away from drama so not really any red flags there…feel bad for the dogs hope she keeps their bowls in sight at any future events around people who are not in the right head space. Also surprised JJ awarded without evidence he was guilty she had no evidence other than the fact that he was outside at the time she smelled the bowl…hope this doesn’t ruin their relationship as nephew and aunt
What do you mean she had no evidence? She had the vet’s report that all three dogs were intoxicated!
First
Nope, You were 2nd, yours said 58 secs ago and ravchohan9985 said 38 secs ago
Im on ritas side. I would keep my head down and dont get involved. L for JJ
Did the vet breathalyze the dogs?
Is this supposed to be funny? Have you ever heard of a blood alcohol test?
Toxicity, refers to blood tests
this is sad but she brought her dogs to the house.
And??
So what? What does that have to do with legal culpability when it comes to damaging someone's property?
Her mom's house.... dogs don't deserve to get hurt your sick man 👾💔
So he has the right to poison her dogs? Are you ok?
I’m on the guys side, KEEP YOUR DOGS AT HOME! DONT TAKE THEM TO ANYONES HOUSE WITHOUT INFORMIN THEM FIRST!
It was her PARENTS house! And only a moron would give alcohol to animals. You’re an idiot 🤦🏾♀️
Bad judgment but of course it’s judge Judy. There’s no proof that his friends did anything.
Right. A dog hating alcoholic ghost did it.
Smooth-brained comment 😅
Exactly, and if the friend did it then why did he have to pay?
Right, let me see if I’ve got the facts right : so there’s a bottle of tequila and the « reliable » witness is called… Margarita. Yep 😅