FragDieAlex it's not a joke I couldn't see FA. Waste of time. I had to google who got killed and what happened and I have a top of the line television.
Brienne's feeling of floating above herself watching the horror as if it was happening is a real thing, its a coping mechanism of a brain called dissociation. Its a out of body experience where brain tries to keep your consciousness safe from extreme trauma by pulling it away from the present. Absolutely golden writing G.R.R.
It has nothing to do with your 'brain keeping your consciousness safe..." Who the F comes up with such a dumb explanation.... Your brain cannot project your consciousness, and if it could, 'sending it outside' would do nothing to protect it, as your brain can easily be destroyed, and there goes your 'consciousness.' No; consciousness is external to the brain to begin with; it is more fundamental than physical reality itself. out of body experiences are super weird and we have no idea how or why they work. People can achieve them in a number of different ways, and in each way, new information is gained from being outside your body, so it cannot be a construction of the brain, as people claim. That is, something can be behind something from your point of view, but when you go 'out of body,' you can see it, and later, when you return to your body, you can rely what you saw. You can obviously control for this, and people report back information it was impossible to know unless they literally really left their body It goes beyond t his to when people 'died' in a hospital, or went OOB during surgery. They would report what cars drove by, what color a car was when something happened, or report on events that were going on outside the room, or outside the hospital, and obviously reported back exactly what happened in the hospital room. There is just to much evidence of consciousness existing as a primary 'substance,' while the brain is a mere anchor for our consciousness to interact with the physical world. SO no, your brain doesn't "project your consciousness" to protect it.... that makes no sense, because under this materialistic worldview, your consciousness would still die once your brain gets caved in
@@pyropulseIXXI So do you have anything to base your opinions on or is this a "dude trust me bro" situation? I see your point and your worldview, but as an mental healthcare professional who has studied this subject and brain's coping mechanics for years, i gotta call BS on most of what you just said.
@@TheNarghes firstly, i highly respect your work as a mental professional and trust you know what you're talking about, so i hope this doesn't come across as argumentative at all. but out of curiosity, what was wrong with what op said? i'm not a professional, but i myself have been in and out of psychiatric help since i was a teenager (i'm in my late 20's now). when my therapist was helping me understand my dissociative episodes, this is how she described them to me, especially when i dissociated when experiencing the trauma. when going through the tougher moments in my life i frequently experienced the "floating above" myself feeling too. personally, during my episodes i always feel as though i'm looking in on myself from a third perspective or "watching myself through a screen". perhaps op's comment is leaving out context, but it is factual that dissociation can be a reaction to the trauma in order for the psyche to protect itself.
Some of these make sense, Like Tyrion's nose, not important to the story, and not worth the CGI budget, and Lady Stoneheart, she would require a shitton of CG. ...but for Euron, there's no excuse.
Tbh, having read the chapters involving Lady Stoneheart before seeing the later series, I was still expecting her to show up at some point and was curious what she'd look like in the show. Alas, I guess it won't happen now. I always envisioned her to look far more corpse-like than the art shown in the vid.
I heard the reason they didn't do Lady Stoneheart was because George himself hadn't come up with a way to conclude that storyline yet, and God knows that man is not quick about resolving shit, so the showrunners decided not to risk starting something they'd have no way of finishing in time. Honestly, one of the smarter moves on their part, as cool as it would have been.
Don't think Lady Stoneheart would require lot of CG, makeup morelike, SFX makeup and prosthetics to be specific. The Night King is mostly done this way, too.
@@nastassjaloots4717 Really they should've just changed his name to Victarion because show Euron is much more closer to Victarion, even though book victarion is much more badass than this piece of joke.
The scene involving Bran gets worse. After Bran is done warging into Summer he wakes up to find that Coldhands had come back with pork meat because he had "found a sow". I find it hard to believe that after them all being hungry for a long time Coldhands had found a sow right after killing a bunch of Night's Watch deserters. And we know from Sam's chapters that human flesh when cooked looks and smells a lot like pork. So I think Bran ate human flesh in human form too.
@@kennethbryant5819 I missed it too. Yikes! I imagine I'll be paying more attention to that scene after I do the re-read, which I intend once the series is finished.
I think it would have been gross/awesome if they would have put that scene of Lady Stone heart having to close her throat w/her hands to speak, GRRM has some imagination.
With Martin's skill at transporting you into the world, it can make for a sometimes uncomfortable experience. Those moments stay with you long after you experience it. So many Arya moments bring to light just how dark things can get. Bran chapters come to mind, and anytime you learn more of what Qyburn is up to. Thinking about being below Kings Landing is nightmare inducing to say the least.
bakoos lol Yeah it was already a horrible place of pain and despair. I feel like you could have a chapter down there from some random unfortunate person down there. It would be like a horror story.
O yeah for sure or when Arya is listening to a story about The Mountain and what he did to a poor defenseless inn keep's daughter, while the father had watch and keep serving The Mountain and his men. Nothing uncomfortable about it at all.
If you read the books before watching the show, it takes a couple chapters before you realize who Reek is. The first Reek chapters are absolutely horrifying. Also, although it isn't technically released yet, there's a Victarion chapter that's out as a preview that's pretty twisted too.
Its implied almost right away. When he remembers that girl with the keys. (Keira maybe?) Anyway.....when he remembers the conversation and how she wouldn't leave his side. Even when he said he'd bring back a host of Ironborn to rescue her if they followed her. It only could have been Theon.
@@fgcpeak9591 There's an Aeron chapter where he's been imprisoned by Euron and reflects on how Euron abused him as a child while he witnesses a massive human sacrifice being prepared. It's horrifying.
What should've happened is Sansa returning home to wed Ramsay, only to find her former best friend- Jeyne Poole- already locked up and kept as a tortured concubine... Alongside Theon. Ramsay would boast about what he did to "fake Arya" to Sansa, and Sansa would have to perpetuate the ruse and pretend that Jeyne is in fact Arya. Now that would've been brilliant and more loyal to canon.
I'd really have wanted show Euron to be more like book Euron, he's a pretty wild character and it's also implied that he's actually a pretty big deal in the story of the books, while in the show he's little more than a sadistic horndog with a hard on for Cersei, i really hope they're going to juice his character up a bit before the end of the show and make him tie into the plot a bit more in the last episodes as i still really like him as a character, he does have some good scenes and i like his antics in the show but i just think they could do the character more justice.
Yep. Of course it's not good that he knocked his son's teeth out, but imagine the shock of your young son presenting you with a disemboweled cat, and seeing the dead sacs of kittens. I'd probably do it too
I stumbled across the book series (Storm of Swords was the newest at the time) when I was in 6th grade at the local library. The most disturbing scene to me was when Arya was being death marched by the Mountain and a 4 year old boy wouldn't stop crying for his dead mother. So, he was smashed in the head (or face) with a mace. Something about brutality of innocents chills me to the bone. Sadly this isn't fantasy. People brutalize innocents in real life every single day.
Good example, just the way it was described so matter-of-factly. It's actually a little worse than you described it lol. The boy was screaming for his dad, got face-maced, and then his mother started screaming.
if you do like at that brutalization you basically came to the conclusion of whyte violence,like literally people were not as brutal as we are(esp after colonizing the entire planet)
Joffrey murdered a pregnant cat around the age of 6-7. Yet we're led to believe by Barristan that a 6-7 year old Viserys was like Aerys. The inconsistency is getting on my nerves
I fully agree I belive Viserys just physically looked more like his father and so he was labeled mad before he even did anything his story is a tragedy and Barristan is still a good knight but I don't trust him fully because he was the only one not to stay loyal to the Targs while the others died being loyal even Jamie was more loyal. Plus he only went to Dany because he got fired nothing more nothing less
Wolfsbane Alphas Jaime is just as bad as Barristan. He let Rhaegar's children die, he didn't even try to save them. And only when he's lost his hand and confronted by the ghost of his betters and Rhaegar himself, does Jaime display some form of guilt over not saving the children. Barristan decided to Label Viserys a second mad king and yet he goes looking for him after Joffrey discharges Barristan from the Kingsguard. Jaime is trying find and protect Sansa when the only way he can redeem himself is to protect a Targaryen, more specifically a living of Rhaegar's, (Jon Snow or fAegon/Young Griff) you can't betray one family and get redeem by doing something right by a whole different family. Both are falsely loyal to the targaryens and they both deserve to die gruesome deaths in the books. Barristan is going to betray Dany and join fAegon/Young Griff And I can only Hope that StoneHeart leaves Jaime with less than what he has already
@Jesse Ling him being nearby isn't the point. The point is that absolutely no thought or effort was put in on their account. He had A complete lack of concern for their well being and displays zero remorse or regret. Not even when confronted with Rhaegar's ghost he still displays a complete lack of guilt. yeah he's ready to go to hell and back to Rescue Sansa, as if that's supposed to make up for before. Saving and protecting Sansa by no means compensates for the three lives he blatantly disregarded and dismissed. I'm sure he was there when the bodies were presented, yet nothing symbolizing that oh Jaime is really ruined by this and he's going to deeply regret this and carry the guilt for the rest of his life.
Well, in one of the books, the mountain and his men were taking women ond by one into the bushes to rape them until one girl, after being raped 7 times tried to fight back and bit one of the mountain's men or something. He made everyone watch as he split her in half witj his sword then left her body for the crows and wolves
also, when roose bolton took harrenhal, he ordered the serving women to be bound up to a wooden structure (cant recall the exact name of the thing), naked, for every men to use them as they pleased.. for having served lannister men... That was so fucked up... as if the poor women had a choice... they were raped countless time by the mountains men only to get even more raped by the northerners...
"traumatized"??.....it's fictional!!, if you got traumatized by words on paper than you need to be kept wrapped in a bubble inside the house or else you'll be literally traumatized for life
Shireen burning Alive in front of many is the most disturbing scène i think i ever saw in any movies/TV shows ever. I can watch all other brutal deaths and i can see people skin removed but a child screaming in pain while burning? Thats a big nope
that is non canon... in the books Shireen is alive and well... she is protected at all times and costs because Stannis has made clear that if he dies, his cause must continue with Shireen as his heir... his supporters are commanded to put her on the Iron Throne at all costs..
The worst parts and character is definitely Ramsey. He’s so realistic and that’s what makes it scary. He gets off by inflicting pain and misery on people. He gets joy from instilling fear and destroying someone’s identity. It’s terrifying how he can totally seem like a friend but then turns out to be the devil in disguise. Him cutting off the theons penis was way too much I felt so bad for him during that episode. He totally destroyed him and he was never the same.
I think the way Joffrey's childhood was portrayed was moreso a way for us to see that the abuse that Robert gave to him turned him down a road of needing to please him in anyway he can. Knowing Robert loves hunting, he took the opportunity to try and show Robert what he had 'hunted' (albeit very cruelly) and Robert responds with more abuse. That's just my SUBJECTIVE perception of it. Banger video, king
One thing this show did right was illustrate the brutality humans performed on one another during Medieval times. Makes you realize how we have it easy today with lethal injections or firing squads.
it only tasted good because he was in summer's mind and it tastes good to a wolf. it's like werewolves when they eat people it doesn't make them a cannibal.
Maybe in the show it wouldn't have shocked me, cause I would've just seen a wolf eating a man. But in the books it's quite disturbing, since you are in Bran's head when he explains "how good the meat was".
Good compilation but surprised you didn't mention some of the darker dragon related scenes as well, like when the "cute" baby dragons began eating the severed heads of the other leaders of his mercenary band that Dario brought to Dany. I expect that in the future books we will see the adult dragons eating a lot of enemy soldiers while on campaign described in vivid detail as they also do in Fire and Blood.
jack bran what happened there? And WoW mercy sample chapter spoiler********* It's a bit wierd what happens in that chapter with her being so young and sexual with the man I forget his name, but that's more uncomfortable than gruesome.
I always forget just how descriptive some books can possibly become. There's so much fucking detail it's beautiful! Maybe I need to start reading again.
So basically GRRM is even a bigger sadist (in writing at least) than is portrayed in the series! 🤣 Well good to know if I ever decide to start reading those books as well!
I hate how the show and others depicts Hodor as some fat cow. In the books he is tall as hell, younger, and extremely fit...and Strong. Why do they keep depicting him as this fat tube of Meat Loaf?😒 It bugs me that no one can even get the little things right.
Honestly, I have the same problem with showCraster....another fat old man in the show. He is supposed to be a scary huge muscled old guy, the kind who looks like someone you don't want to piss off.
@@gooby1673 I agree, a guy who deals with freaking walkers and has the balls to live alone and keep control over his "daughters/wifes" has to be some guy, not just any random old geezer.
He's extremely strong but he isn't described as like a toned bodybuilder-type, is he? (and I'm not trying to say you think he's a roided out lump of muscle, it's just that 'strong men' typically don't have an aesthetic physique. A big kind of fat guy seemed accurate to me).
Joffery presenting that kitten to his father always struck me as more so trying to imitate his father (Robert loved hunting) and earn his approval than some malicious act.
There's one scene that I remember vividly: In AFFC in one of briennes chapters she sees a man in a cage on the air. The guy is described with too much detail. I remember him asking for water and worms on his body. Fucking grose
Bran is 10 or 12 in the books. He’s starving and only eating berries/nuts. I don’t think he’s thinking about morals, when Summer is hungry too and feasting on flesh.
They dialed down a heck and a lot. The Mountain is dialed down and his men is absent, the Bastard's boys, Ramsay only had bitches from what I have read of his dogs so that must have been non-penetration stuff, I would say Shagwell and the others from the Brave Companions are to no surprise lacking, Reek the necrophiliac is gone, Pretty Pia is absent to zero surprise due to the hell she goes through, I still would have preferred that to Super-Bronn and Brienne and Tripod. The plot in Dorne taking more time.
I remember in one of the books it was said that when famine struck a city in Essos under Daenerys, men would gather to draw stones and the one who drew the black sone was eaten by the rest. Does anyone remember where I can find this?
It's funny how in the books you have stuff like the Boltons wearing pink capes and shit.. but if you had to live in the ASOIAF world you're much more likely to die a horrible slow death
TV Tyrion still has his nose for the same reason a certain TV The Walking Dead character didn't lose his hand. Too much effort to keep up the appearance.
I'm so glad the show didn't include Joffrey being cruel to cats and kittens. I can deal with most things the show throws at us but not animal cruelty, even if it's not real.
From what I’ve read in the comments and the videos I’ve watched about the book version of GoT characters I’m glad they didn’t include everything from the books because there’s a lot of child abuse involved. But I’m also not happy with the way the writers seemed to have gone to the other end of the extreme and diluted Euron’s character too much. There was a lot of potential to tell the story of a character who is arguably more wicked than Ramsey Bolton, who was also threatening enough to provide a sustained threat beyond the Night King and Cersei imo and seeing him being finally overcome would’ve provided untold levels of joy and satisfaction.
In the show Gregor was really tall, brutal, and mean to his younger brother, until he became a zombie who's... pretty much just tall. In the books, he actively goes out of his way to cause misery and delights in the pain and suffering of others, to the same extent of Ramsay or Vargo if not worse, only difference being that Gregor isn't smart enough (or in the right position) to have any political power.
while some of the stuff in here is maybe more immediately disgusting than anything in the show, I think the show had some pretty dark stuff... a brother raping his sister next to their son's dead body, and Cersei's revenge on Ellaria was one of the most horrifying ideas I'd seen on TV, all without any gore.
In the book Jamie never raped her.... she resisted for like 3 seconds then gave in. Plus Daenerys is like 14 in the last book. All of the young ones were a lot younger in the books
@@TinToeTimmyTime I know, I'm just pointing out the converse of what this video talks about. Things the show did differently from the book which *were* very dark, perhaps even darker than the books
After winds of winter and dream of spring, someone should try and make a show called a song of ice and fire that will do a much better job of adapting the books
In season 2 when the King, Sansa and other nobles are attacked in the streets of King's Landing there's a woman called Lollys Stokeworth (the woman that Bronn was supposed to marry in the show) who was cornered by the mob and raped more than fifty times.
I see the villains get more bold as the series go on. Joffery is bad but never fights. Ramsay is evil and only uses trickes and torture to fight. Euron greyjoy is a little more direct but would still lose on land. I wonder who will be after Euron. A character who is bad and will fight and cant be stopped. We still have teo books. I hope its someone like the white walkers but more dangerous
And I'm sure that, since Martin feels he has to have each new villain "one up" the previous gold medal winner for "sickest motherfucker in the world", the next big bad human villain Martin introduces will get a chapter or two devoted to how he only eats live human infants and babies.....just because.
A psycho torturer who is also unstoppable in battle? Why not Zombiemountain? Though it isn't clear if he still has a mind and a will of his own, if not, he can't really count as "evil".
@@lordvlogemort3793 he is more of a beast controlled by qyburn. He was in constant pain alive with those head aches and was screaming in terror and had to be moved. He is a monster to kill but not his own in control. Some say he even has robs head under his visor. I feel the faceless men will do something crazy like kill many up and coming leaders at the same time to create a huge chaos or dany could be the next villain as George hates typical villains so a hero turned villain sounds nice. Cersie may even turn to the good guy if she has to clash with the dokiraki rapist and aegon with his invading army. Could be fun to see
For the show to just quickly tie up condense screen time and actually make the fake arya switch places with sansa i actually agreed with that. It made Theons rescue more valid. And helped his character arc. And the Vale part with Littlefinger still tied in nicely. I even think in the show they had Littlefinger convince sansa too basically go in spy status and marry bolton?? I might be wrong alil. But I'm more in verse with the literature then the HBO adaptation.
Interesting fact, first signs of frost bite is your skin gets a waxy white color an hour before it turns black.....so if you're in that situation pay attention so it doesn't go that far.
Cant believe they left out rorge and biter. I hope we get more of them in winds. I wonder if theres anything supernatural about them with how long biters tongue is and how his skin is so doughy. Reminds me of gluttony from full metal alchemist lol.
@@bitterfox518 I think biter did I'm not sure about rorge. Idk why I didnt think of that when I wrote this comment though. I guess we probably wont learn anything new
I assumed that Ramsey had flayed and chopped off her fingers the same as Theon. Her eating her fingers was just an excuse for why her corpse was missing them.
Euron was WAAAY more badass in the books. Like legit a man to be feared. In the show he was just an asshole that made sexual jokes all the time, pretty disappointing.
To me Tyrion’s scar not being that bad is fine because Cersei said she heard he lost half his nose so that implies the books and really it’s easy to exaggerate someone’s scar to worse than it actually is
1) you forgot vargo hoat burns jaimie's hand until he passes out, left it rot and surrounded by pus for days before cutting it off. 2) Tyrion's first love and wife. The one that breaks my heart more than anything. Jaimie decides to introduce Tyrion to a virgin whore (i forgot her name) when they were younger. But when Tywin found out about this he summoned his men and raped her by turn, Tyrion's turn is the last. I hope in the end of the story Tyrion will meet her again, not that i expected a happy ending though. 3) Somebody mentioned about the unsullied training when they was child. Yes, they were told to kill a puppy which has been their partner for quests and stuff, and then murder a newborn infant infront of their mothers. 4) Patchface. Myb he's more to disturbing than dark, or myb both. A dimwitted clown character who often sing some disturbing stuff to shreen that actually come true for the following few chapters. His backstory also mysterious af, which makes him more creepy. If i'm not mistaken stannis' men found him (used to be a very genius dude) from far east but their fleet crushed by storm. 3 days later they found patchface ashore.. with a new character.
Anyone else wish they would hire this guy to do the audio books I feel like his voice would make the sex scenes less awkward than some old British dude hahaha
Ah George... always vividly describing food, even when its a wolf eating a man.
I remember I was tired of reading about foods...
Even Tyrion's puke was described so vividly I was starting to think it's delicious
vitaliphotos there is always a whole paragraph donated to foods at feasts
@@avarielle1582 Those paragraphs always made me so friggin hungry.
I remember another warg, I waa reading the description of how he ate a baby and how the meat was more tender.
After watching S8E3 I think nothing is too dark for Game of Thrones... because I didn't see shit in that episode
Then don't watch it on a phone or a cheap screen. It was fine.
@@nerobruno It was just a joke 😅
Dammit, I was gonna post this comment.
Lmaooo
FragDieAlex it's not a joke I couldn't see FA. Waste of time. I had to google who got killed and what happened and I have a top of the line television.
Brienne's feeling of floating above herself watching the horror as if it was happening is a real thing, its a coping mechanism of a brain called dissociation. Its a out of body experience where brain tries to keep your consciousness safe from extreme trauma by pulling it away from the present. Absolutely golden writing G.R.R.
Whoah, that's genius
It has nothing to do with your 'brain keeping your consciousness safe..." Who the F comes up with such a dumb explanation....
Your brain cannot project your consciousness, and if it could, 'sending it outside' would do nothing to protect it, as your brain can easily be destroyed, and there goes your 'consciousness.'
No; consciousness is external to the brain to begin with; it is more fundamental than physical reality itself.
out of body experiences are super weird and we have no idea how or why they work. People can achieve them in a number of different ways, and in each way, new information is gained from being outside your body, so it cannot be a construction of the brain, as people claim.
That is, something can be behind something from your point of view, but when you go 'out of body,' you can see it, and later, when you return to your body, you can rely what you saw. You can obviously control for this, and people report back information it was impossible to know unless they literally really left their body
It goes beyond t his to when people 'died' in a hospital, or went OOB during surgery. They would report what cars drove by, what color a car was when something happened, or report on events that were going on outside the room, or outside the hospital, and obviously reported back exactly what happened in the hospital room.
There is just to much evidence of consciousness existing as a primary 'substance,' while the brain is a mere anchor for our consciousness to interact with the physical world.
SO no, your brain doesn't "project your consciousness" to protect it.... that makes no sense, because under this materialistic worldview, your consciousness would still die once your brain gets caved in
@@pyropulseIXXI So do you have anything to base your opinions on or is this a "dude trust me bro" situation? I see your point and your worldview, but as an mental healthcare professional who has studied this subject and brain's coping mechanics for years, i gotta call BS on most of what you just said.
@@TheNarghes firstly, i highly respect your work as a mental professional and trust you know what you're talking about, so i hope this doesn't come across as argumentative at all. but out of curiosity, what was wrong with what op said? i'm not a professional, but i myself have been in and out of psychiatric help since i was a teenager (i'm in my late 20's now). when my therapist was helping me understand my dissociative episodes, this is how she described them to me, especially when i dissociated when experiencing the trauma.
when going through the tougher moments in my life i frequently experienced the "floating above" myself feeling too. personally, during my episodes i always feel as though i'm looking in on myself from a third perspective or "watching myself through a screen". perhaps op's comment is leaving out context, but it is factual that dissociation can be a reaction to the trauma in order for the psyche to protect itself.
@@raptatta Narghes was responding to the comment above him that spouted some esoterical bs.
Some of these make sense, Like Tyrion's nose, not important to the story, and not worth the CGI budget, and Lady Stoneheart, she would require a shitton of CG.
...but for Euron, there's no excuse.
involuntaryanalysis Right?! Book Euron legit terrifies me. GOT Euron is a joke. I feel stupid for telling people “This guy is way worse than Ramsay”
Tbh, having read the chapters involving Lady Stoneheart before seeing the later series, I was still expecting her to show up at some point and was curious what she'd look like in the show. Alas, I guess it won't happen now.
I always envisioned her to look far more corpse-like than the art shown in the vid.
I heard the reason they didn't do Lady Stoneheart was because George himself hadn't come up with a way to conclude that storyline yet, and God knows that man is not quick about resolving shit, so the showrunners decided not to risk starting something they'd have no way of finishing in time.
Honestly, one of the smarter moves on their part, as cool as it would have been.
Don't think Lady Stoneheart would require lot of CG, makeup morelike, SFX makeup and prosthetics to be specific. The Night King is mostly done this way, too.
@@nastassjaloots4717 Really they should've just changed his name to Victarion because show Euron is much more closer to Victarion, even though book victarion is much more badass than this piece of joke.
The scene involving Bran gets worse. After Bran is done warging into Summer he wakes up to find that Coldhands had come back with pork meat because he had "found a sow". I find it hard to believe that after them all being hungry for a long time Coldhands had found a sow right after killing a bunch of Night's Watch deserters. And we know from Sam's chapters that human flesh when cooked looks and smells a lot like pork. So I think Bran ate human flesh in human form too.
And if not then, there's always the paste. I wonder how many other 'Bran eats people' mysteries there are.
wow that never occurred to me even though they ask multiple times where he got it. pretty dark.
Oh yeah I agree that its not dark meat (human is red meat just like sow lol)
I see you two survive the long, night, slowly chewing down each others fingers... 😂
@@kennethbryant5819 I missed it too. Yikes! I imagine I'll be paying more attention to that scene after I do the re-read, which I intend once the series is finished.
I don't judge Bran for eating human meat at all. The men were already dead, and he was hungry.
Meh
Bran didn't have control over Summer at that point. Whenever he slipped to Summer's skin, he became Summer almost completely.
Yeah. It's not MY fault grandma's funeral was so awkward. I was hungry and they didn't have any snacks.
If I had to choose between dying of starvation or eating human flesh, I'd probably die from food born illness because I can't cook for shit!
Smoking Samoria That’s fucked up, you could’ve gotten food poison
I think it would have been gross/awesome if they would have put that scene of Lady Stone heart having to close her throat w/her hands to speak, GRRM has some imagination.
Ooft why do i feel like I've read this somewhere in another bokk in like a snowy place in the past its annoying me now
@@AmmaraSHAH773377 it makes me think of smokers who have lost their voice and use an external device to serve as their larynx.
Ahhh GRRM, always producing such uplifting and heartwarming content for the masses 😅
It's almost like the man made compilations of all the horrible things humans can do to each other then made a book series out of it.
@@ipromisethatserendipityisa9656 Yea... *_oh wait_*
😂😂
@@ipromisethatserendipityisa9656 You are in fact right, A song of ice and fire is an anti war story.
Martin is very descriptive
With Martin's skill at transporting you into the world, it can make for a sometimes uncomfortable experience.
Those moments stay with you long after you experience it. So many Arya moments bring to light just how dark things
can get. Bran chapters come to mind, and anytime you learn more of what Qyburn is up to. Thinking about being below
Kings Landing is nightmare inducing to say the least.
Even cersei didnt want to think of what qyburn was doing down in the dungeons so you know its fucked up
bakoos lol Yeah it was already a horrible place of pain and despair. I feel like you could have a chapter down there from some random unfortunate person down there. It would be like a horror story.
FitzChivalry Farseer yeah raff the sweetling sticking his tounge into aryas mouths was a comfy read
O yeah for sure or when Arya is listening to a story about The Mountain and what he did to a poor defenseless inn keep's daughter, while the father had watch and keep serving The Mountain and his men. Nothing uncomfortable about it at all.
@FitzChivalry Farseer I think you just don't have enough imagination. That's okay. Not all people can deeply immerse themselves in what they read.
If you read the books before watching the show, it takes a couple chapters before you realize who Reek is. The first Reek chapters are absolutely horrifying. Also, although it isn't technically released yet, there's a Victarion chapter that's out as a preview that's pretty twisted too.
Its implied almost right away. When he remembers that girl with the keys. (Keira maybe?) Anyway.....when he remembers the conversation and how she wouldn't leave his side. Even when he said he'd bring back a host of Ironborn to rescue her if they followed her. It only could have been Theon.
the victarion part of how he unalived his wife for cuking him with euron? with his bare hands?
@@fgcpeak9591 There's an Aeron chapter where he's been imprisoned by Euron and reflects on how Euron abused him as a child while he witnesses a massive human sacrifice being prepared. It's horrifying.
I'm expecting the whole video to just have ramsay Bolton scenes
Biter vs Brienne was dark AF. 😰😬🤕
What about Aryas sample chapter in winds of winter
Hey... It's tough enough that Brienne isn't the best-looking woman, but now she's even worse looking.
@@swedefromtwitt they are sooooo dark!!! Sad samples is all we gotta get it seems like.
It never happened at the show right?
They're eating her... then they're going to eat me!
Oh my Gooooooooooooooooooooood !!!
What should've happened is Sansa returning home to wed Ramsay, only to find her former best friend- Jeyne Poole- already locked up and kept as a tortured concubine... Alongside Theon. Ramsay would boast about what he did to "fake Arya" to Sansa, and Sansa would have to perpetuate the ruse and pretend that Jeyne is in fact Arya.
Now that would've been brilliant and more loyal to canon.
I'd really have wanted show Euron to be more like book Euron, he's a pretty wild character and it's also implied that he's actually a pretty big deal in the story of the books, while in the show he's little more than a sadistic horndog with a hard on for Cersei, i really hope they're going to juice his character up a bit before the end of the show and make him tie into the plot a bit more in the last episodes as i still really like him as a character, he does have some good scenes and i like his antics in the show but i just think they could do the character more justice.
He’s literally the Antichrist in the books
yeah about that
Ha
Hearing that Robert beat his son for killing those cats made me so happy. That's why I like Robert
He's a true man
Yep. Of course it's not good that he knocked his son's teeth out, but imagine the shock of your young son presenting you with a disemboweled cat, and seeing the dead sacs of kittens. I'd probably do it too
@Ajok Ajing i didn't say he was good
What son?
@@BoundInChains lol
Lol.... He liked to rape and beat Cersei when drunk, part of why she was such a misanthrope. And he killed helpless children. Yes, what a man.
I stumbled across the book series (Storm of Swords was the newest at the time) when I was in 6th grade at the local library. The most disturbing scene to me was when Arya was being death marched by the Mountain and a 4 year old boy wouldn't stop crying for his dead mother. So, he was smashed in the head (or face) with a mace. Something about brutality of innocents chills me to the bone. Sadly this isn't fantasy. People brutalize innocents in real life every single day.
Good example, just the way it was described so matter-of-factly. It's actually a little worse than you described it lol. The boy was screaming for his dad, got face-maced, and then his mother started screaming.
if you do like at that brutalization you basically came to the conclusion of whyte violence,like literally people were not as brutal as we are(esp after colonizing the entire planet)
Lmaoooo what are you talking about? Please read a history book, educate yourself and stop commenting such absolute nonsense
This one's full of terrors
whycreate can you make a videos about the unsullied please...... because they aren't as great in the show compared to books
whycreate May the Lord of Light be with you, my friend
Ze book iz bettur 😈👌
Just like my childhood
So is the night
Joffrey murdered a pregnant cat around the age of 6-7. Yet we're led to believe by Barristan that a 6-7 year old Viserys was like Aerys. The inconsistency is getting on my nerves
I fully agree I belive Viserys just physically looked more like his father and so he was labeled mad before he even did anything his story is a tragedy and Barristan is still a good knight but I don't trust him fully because he was the only one not to stay loyal to the Targs while the others died being loyal even Jamie was more loyal. Plus he only went to Dany because he got fired nothing more nothing less
Wolfsbane Alphas Jaime is just as bad as Barristan. He let Rhaegar's children die, he didn't even try to save them. And only when he's lost his hand and confronted by the ghost of his betters and Rhaegar himself, does Jaime display some form of guilt over not saving the children.
Barristan decided to Label Viserys a second mad king and yet he goes looking for him after Joffrey discharges Barristan from the Kingsguard.
Jaime is trying find and protect Sansa when the only way he can redeem himself is to protect a Targaryen, more specifically a living of Rhaegar's, (Jon Snow or fAegon/Young Griff) you can't betray one family and get redeem by doing something right by a whole different family.
Both are falsely loyal to the targaryens and they both deserve to die gruesome deaths in the books.
Barristan is going to betray Dany and join fAegon/Young Griff
And I can only Hope that StoneHeart leaves Jaime with less than what he has already
Hasan Wilson barristan tells himself that to make himself feel better about betraying Viserys.
He is speaking purely in hindsight
Speaking of barristan preston Jacobs just posted another part of his story
@Jesse Ling him being nearby isn't the point. The point is that absolutely no thought or effort was put in on their account. He had A complete lack of concern for their well being and displays zero remorse or regret. Not even when confronted with Rhaegar's ghost he still displays a complete lack of guilt. yeah he's ready to go to hell and back to Rescue Sansa, as if that's supposed to make up for before. Saving and protecting Sansa by no means compensates for the three lives he blatantly disregarded and dismissed. I'm sure he was there when the bodies were presented, yet nothing symbolizing that oh Jaime is really ruined by this and he's going to deeply regret this and carry the guilt for the rest of his life.
Well, in one of the books, the mountain and his men were taking women ond by one into the bushes to rape them until one girl, after being raped 7 times tried to fight back and bit one of the mountain's men or something. He made everyone watch as he split her in half witj his sword then left her body for the crows and wolves
Good guy mountain
also, when roose bolton took harrenhal, he ordered the serving women to be bound up to a wooden structure (cant recall the exact name of the thing), naked, for every men to use them as they pleased.. for having served lannister men... That was so fucked up... as if the poor women had a choice... they were raped countless time by the mountains men only to get even more raped by the northerners...
Based biting woman
Worst thing happened in ASOIAF is Ramsey’s wedding night
Squirrelcake but Ramsey’s wedding night traumatized me the most because we read a whole chapter about it, not heard it from other characters
Or Ramsay raping girls he's hunted before killing them and letting Reek rape their corpse.
"traumatized"??.....it's fictional!!, if you got traumatized by words on paper than you need to be kept wrapped in a bubble inside the house
or else you'll be literally traumatized for life
chicken legs TV damn chill I was exaggerating
chicken legs TV it's a figure of speech...
Shireen burning Alive in front of many is the most disturbing scène i think i ever saw in any movies/TV shows ever. I can watch all other brutal deaths and i can see people skin removed but a child screaming in pain while burning? Thats a big nope
that is non canon... in the books Shireen is alive and well... she is protected at all times and costs because Stannis has made clear that if he dies, his cause must continue with Shireen as his heir... his supporters are commanded to put her on the Iron Throne at all costs..
The Real Euron Greyjoy...apparently.
I'm half hoping that we find out This Euron, is a decoy, and the REAL Euron Greyjoy shows up in season 8.
@@involuntaryanalysis hahahahahahhahahahahaha
The worst parts and character is definitely Ramsey. He’s so realistic and that’s what makes it scary. He gets off by inflicting pain and misery on people. He gets joy from instilling fear and destroying someone’s identity. It’s terrifying how he can totally seem like a friend but then turns out to be the devil in disguise. Him cutting off the theons penis was way too much I felt so bad for him during that episode. He totally destroyed him and he was never the same.
I think the way Joffrey's childhood was portrayed was moreso a way for us to see that the abuse that Robert gave to him turned him down a road of needing to please him in anyway he can. Knowing Robert loves hunting, he took the opportunity to try and show Robert what he had 'hunted' (albeit very cruelly) and Robert responds with more abuse. That's just my SUBJECTIVE perception of it. Banger video, king
Personally I have zero sympathy for Joffrey, like, at all. He deserved much worse.
One thing this show did right was illustrate the brutality humans performed on one another during Medieval times.
Makes you realize how we have it easy today with lethal injections or firing squads.
it only tasted good because he was in summer's mind and it tastes good to a wolf. it's like werewolves when they eat people it doesn't make them a cannibal.
Maybe in the show it wouldn't have shocked me, cause I would've just seen a wolf eating a man. But in the books it's quite disturbing, since you are in Bran's head when he explains "how good the meat was".
Good compilation but surprised you didn't mention some of the darker dragon related scenes as well, like when the "cute" baby dragons began eating the severed heads of the other leaders of his mercenary band that Dario brought to Dany. I expect that in the future books we will see the adult dragons eating a lot of enemy soldiers while on campaign described in vivid detail as they also do in Fire and Blood.
that isnt dark...
What about Arya killing the tickler. I think an eleven year old repeatedly stabbing a man in a craze is more grewsome than some of these
But in the show she did stab Ser Meryn Trant a lot of times right. I didn't read the book so I don't know how crazy it was there though
Shane O'Leary more grewsome than which?
gruesome. the word you're looking for is gruesome.
jack bran what happened there? And WoW mercy sample chapter spoiler*********
It's a bit wierd what happens in that chapter with her being so young and sexual with the man I forget his name, but that's more uncomfortable than gruesome.
Oh ye I thought you meant like the boat journey
I always forget just how descriptive some books can possibly become. There's so much fucking detail it's beautiful! Maybe I need to start reading again.
Grrm has a sick imagination
Unless it's from experience, you never know...
Well the funny thing is he didn't have to make any of this stuff up, all he had to do was open a history book.
Save us, R'hllor; for the books are dark and full of terrors.
Hey man, thanks for keeping long wait for Season 8 bearable
Season 8 is gonna be trash lol I'm sure we'll all prefer content like this in the end
I dont give a crap about any new season. All i care about is Winds of Winter
Ironside Bear fuck off
@@AJ0223 you were right
@@vvsparis yea bitch what now lmao
Some of these scenes should have been included into the show.
@unknowning unknown that was a bit harsh
Every scene was too dark in that last episode
I could see it fine, turn up the brightness on your TV
So basically GRRM is even a bigger sadist (in writing at least) than is portrayed in the series! 🤣 Well good to know if I ever decide to start reading those books as well!
Lady donella went crazy and “got a little hungry”?
Lololol
It’s just such a funny and dumb thing to say in the context of her situation.
It was a fuckin joke mate
I hate how the show and others depicts Hodor as some fat cow. In the books he is tall as hell, younger, and extremely fit...and Strong. Why do they keep depicting him as this fat tube of Meat Loaf?😒 It bugs me that no one can even get the little things right.
Honestly, I have the same problem with showCraster....another fat old man in the show. He is supposed to be a scary huge muscled old guy, the kind who looks like someone you don't want to piss off.
@@gooby1673 exactly.
@@gooby1673 I agree, a guy who deals with freaking walkers and has the balls to live alone and keep control over his "daughters/wifes" has to be some guy, not just any random old geezer.
He's extremely strong but he isn't described as like a toned bodybuilder-type, is he? (and I'm not trying to say you think he's a roided out lump of muscle, it's just that 'strong men' typically don't have an aesthetic physique. A big kind of fat guy seemed accurate to me).
Natilie E. S. nevertheless, the actor who played hodor has done a pretty god job
Joffery presenting that kitten to his father always struck me as more so trying to imitate his father (Robert loved hunting) and earn his approval than some malicious act.
You mean the entire Battle of Winterfell episode? It was so dark that we couldn't see anything
Knowing about the child fighting pits in HotD, I wonder if biter is a product of those same fighting pits.
There's one scene that I remember vividly: In AFFC in one of briennes chapters she sees a man in a cage on the air. The guy is described with too much detail. I remember him asking for water and worms on his body. Fucking grose
I seem to recall a scene in AFFC where a woman is being raped on a pile of corpses. That was pretty rough.
Bran is 10 or 12 in the books. He’s starving and only eating berries/nuts. I don’t think he’s thinking about morals, when Summer is hungry too and feasting on flesh.
You reminded me of Robert's greatest failure as a "father" - not Randyll Tarly-ing Joffrey after the incident with the cat.
Well one thing about Euron is much worse than "The silence". It is his history with Areon the Damphair.
Me: why shouldn't I watch this before going to bed.
Me(after): WHY DIDN'T YOU WARN ME?!!!
there was a scene where they described a castrated man in a under sized cage, and the maggots and what not on it.
“How did a crippled boy survive for years beyond the wall?”
Bran: “People, man, people”
They dialed down a heck and a lot. The Mountain is dialed down and his men is absent, the Bastard's boys, Ramsay only had bitches from what I have read of his dogs so that must have been non-penetration stuff, I would say Shagwell and the others from the Brave Companions are to no surprise lacking, Reek the necrophiliac is gone, Pretty Pia is absent to zero surprise due to the hell she goes through, I still would have preferred that to Super-Bronn and Brienne and Tripod. The plot in Dorne taking more time.
Tyrion's nose is probably like that for same reasons his hair and eyes are. The same could be said about Daenerys and Viserys. (Edit: I added Viserys)
No one remembers, the torture killing scenes in Harrenhal, I mean that "neck cracker" and "rat bucket" device is too gruesome.
Jesus, Brianne has it rough
Add s08e03 to this list as well... We cannot see anything anyway.
I remember in one of the books it was said that when famine struck a city in Essos under Daenerys, men would gather to draw stones and the one who drew the black sone was eaten by the rest. Does anyone remember where I can find this?
A dance with dragons, when mereen was sieged by Quarth after Dany rejects Xharo's proposal.
@@lunayen Thank you kind ma'am
@@HaydenLau.
*ma'am.
But you're welcome. Glad to help.
Euron Greyjoy is definitely the most interesting character in the books.
If Peter Dinklage was really dedicated to the part he would have cut off his own nose
Too dark for game of thrones is that possible
Ethan Stark of winterfell careful what you wish for
Yes, yes it really is with ASOIAF
I read the books trust I know what I'm asking for
It's funny how in the books you have stuff like the Boltons wearing pink capes and shit.. but if you had to live in the ASOIAF world you're much more likely to die a horrible slow death
True
TV Tyrion still has his nose for the same reason a certain TV The Walking Dead character didn't lose his hand. Too much effort to keep up the appearance.
people in the comments scaring me not to read the books tbh
No one:
Not a single soul:
Book Caitlyn Stark: *survives the red wedding*
r/uselessnobody
Cerseis and Qyburns torture of the Blue Bard fucking hell...
The purple wedding was the best part of the shows and a pretty good read in the books
I'm so glad the show didn't include Joffrey being cruel to cats and kittens. I can deal with most things the show throws at us but not animal cruelty, even if it's not real.
Species traitor!
I stand with my feline friends.
The torture of the blue bard makes me shudder every time I reach that part
From what I’ve read in the comments and the videos I’ve watched about the book version of GoT characters I’m glad they didn’t include everything from the books because there’s a lot of child abuse involved.
But I’m also not happy with the way the writers seemed to have gone to the other end of the extreme and diluted Euron’s character too much. There was a lot of potential to tell the story of a character who is arguably more wicked than Ramsey Bolton, who was also threatening enough to provide a sustained threat beyond the Night King and Cersei imo and seeing him being finally overcome would’ve provided untold levels of joy and satisfaction.
This isn't really dark. .but strong belwas taking a dump outside Meereen after defeating their hero warrants a mention. Lol
In the show Gregor was really tall, brutal, and mean to his younger brother, until he became a zombie who's... pretty much just tall. In the books, he actively goes out of his way to cause misery and delights in the pain and suffering of others, to the same extent of Ramsay or Vargo if not worse, only difference being that Gregor isn't smart enough (or in the right position) to have any political power.
while some of the stuff in here is maybe more immediately disgusting than anything in the show, I think the show had some pretty dark stuff... a brother raping his sister next to their son's dead body, and Cersei's revenge on Ellaria was one of the most horrifying ideas I'd seen on TV, all without any gore.
In the book Jamie never raped her.... she resisted for like 3 seconds then gave in. Plus Daenerys is like 14 in the last book. All of the young ones were a lot younger in the books
@@TinToeTimmyTime I know, I'm just pointing out the converse of what this video talks about. Things the show did differently from the book which *were* very dark, perhaps even darker than the books
After winds of winter and dream of spring, someone should try and make a show called a song of ice and fire that will do a much better job of adapting the books
grrm will die before he even starts a dream of spring tbh r hell be too weak
Apparently the actual ending was too extreme for TV.
Game of Thrones is like a children's show, compared to the books
In season 2 when the King, Sansa and other nobles are attacked in the streets of King's Landing there's a woman called Lollys Stokeworth (the woman that Bronn was supposed to marry in the show) who was cornered by the mob and raped more than fifty times.
I see the villains get more bold as the series go on. Joffery is bad but never fights. Ramsay is evil and only uses trickes and torture to fight. Euron greyjoy is a little more direct but would still lose on land. I wonder who will be after Euron. A character who is bad and will fight and cant be stopped. We still have teo books. I hope its someone like the white walkers but more dangerous
And I'm sure that, since Martin feels he has to have each new villain "one up" the previous gold medal winner for "sickest motherfucker in the world", the next big bad human villain Martin introduces will get a chapter or two devoted to how he only eats live human infants and babies.....just because.
A psycho torturer who is also unstoppable in battle? Why not Zombiemountain? Though it isn't clear if he still has a mind and a will of his own, if not, he can't really count as "evil".
@@lordvlogemort3793 he is more of a beast controlled by qyburn. He was in constant pain alive with those head aches and was screaming in terror and had to be moved. He is a monster to kill but not his own in control. Some say he even has robs head under his visor. I feel the faceless men will do something crazy like kill many up and coming leaders at the same time to create a huge chaos or dany could be the next villain as George hates typical villains so a hero turned villain sounds nice. Cersie may even turn to the good guy if she has to clash with the dokiraki rapist and aegon with his invading army. Could be fun to see
Its adorable you think theres 2 more books lol if winter ever drops I'll be surprised
@@AJ0223 we got fire and blood this year and then if we are lucky winds of winter in 2019
For the show to just quickly tie up condense screen time and actually make the fake arya switch places with sansa i actually agreed with that. It made Theons rescue more valid. And helped his character arc. And the Vale part with Littlefinger still tied in nicely. I even think in the show they had Littlefinger convince sansa too basically go in spy status and marry bolton?? I might be wrong alil. But I'm more in verse with the literature then the HBO adaptation.
I think something else that should have been included is what happened to Tysha (Tyrion's wife) in the book.
Vargo Hoat's fate made me sick when I read it.
question for anyone that reads the books , are they worth getting into? i haven’t done any research on them but have been thinking about reading them
Definitely. They're great books, and given how long and heavy they can be, and also packed with several characters, it's not a tedious read at all.
Thanks! I’ve started reading them since I posted this, I’m a few chapters into my first one
I'm glad I didn't see Tyrion's nose get lopped off in the show.😳 That nasal scar looks horrendous.🤢
Honestly Robert is a W for beating Joffrey after Joff hurt the cat.
The most evil act was Done by stannis when he sacrificed hes own daughter settings her on fire .. for power . That shit fucked me the most
Why did they dial back Euron Grejoy's look? He seems more menacing here.
This is awesome, thanks for making this man.
What an idea this was, to watch this before going to bed...
My throat feels tight when I read The Purple Wedding too
Interesting fact, first signs of frost bite is your skin gets a waxy white color an hour before it turns black.....so if you're in that situation pay attention so it doesn't go that far.
tribequest9 Idk what you could do though. It’s not like o my nose is white better make some hot cocoa
Ramsay worse in the book📕
Too dark for game of thrones? Oh I don’t think so.
I probably would've put Brienne's misfortune closer to #1... I mean, damn!
Cant believe they left out rorge and biter. I hope we get more of them in winds. I wonder if theres anything supernatural about them with how long biters tongue is and how his skin is so doughy. Reminds me of gluttony from full metal alchemist lol.
Didn't they die fighting Brienne in aFfC?
@@bitterfox518 I think biter did I'm not sure about rorge. Idk why I didnt think of that when I wrote this comment though. I guess we probably wont learn anything new
hey, cool video, but it's pretty obvious that lady hornwood tried to eat her fingers because she was starving...
I assumed that Ramsey had flayed and chopped off her fingers the same as Theon. Her eating her fingers was just an excuse for why her corpse was missing them.
To this day Im mad we missed out on Lady Stoneheart
I thought this video was referring to the lighting lol
Euron was WAAAY more badass in the books. Like legit a man to be feared. In the show he was just an asshole that made sexual jokes all the time, pretty disappointing.
I think that Bolton soldier 'Locke' is a combination of Amory Lorch, Cargo Hoat 'the goat' and maybe another
To me Tyrion’s scar not being that bad is fine because Cersei said she heard he lost half his nose so that implies the books and really it’s easy to exaggerate someone’s scar to worse than it actually is
That last episode with the battle against the white walkers was literally to dark. I couldn't see shit on my screen.
Plus it sucked the show is fucked now
Maybe i shouldnt have been eating when I decided to watch this
I'm eating just fine.
1) you forgot vargo hoat burns jaimie's hand until he passes out, left it rot and surrounded by pus for days before cutting it off.
2) Tyrion's first love and wife. The one that breaks my heart more than anything. Jaimie decides to introduce Tyrion to a virgin whore (i forgot her name) when they were younger. But when Tywin found out about this he summoned his men and raped her by turn, Tyrion's turn is the last. I hope in the end of the story Tyrion will meet her again, not that i expected a happy ending though.
3) Somebody mentioned about the unsullied training when they was child. Yes, they were told to kill a puppy which has been their partner for quests and stuff, and then murder a newborn infant infront of their mothers.
4) Patchface. Myb he's more to disturbing than dark, or myb both. A dimwitted clown character who often sing some disturbing stuff to shreen that actually come true for the following few chapters. His backstory also mysterious af, which makes him more creepy. If i'm not mistaken stannis' men found him (used to be a very genius dude) from far east but their fleet crushed by storm. 3 days later they found patchface ashore.. with a new character.
shouldve never named that joke from the show, Euron. I really hope D&D have dreams of the real Crowseye everynight.
Anyone else wish they would hire this guy to do the audio books I feel like his voice would make the sex scenes less awkward than some old British dude hahaha
typical american ego centrism :)