Taylor Swift - "Red" Album Comparison (2012 vs Taylor's Version)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ย. 2024
- © Republic Records / © Taylor Swift
All music, clips, animations, overlays, textures, photos, etc. belong to all respective artists.
No copyright infringement intended. This video was just made for fun and NO profit. I don't own anything!
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use"
for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research.
Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. NON-PROFIT,
educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
What song do you think improved the most? Let me know!
State of Grace,Red, Treacherous,I Almost Do, Stay 3x,The Last Time,Sad Beautiful Tragic, Everything Has Changed,Begin Again,all the deluxe tracks just to name a few 😉
All too well
all too well, state of grace, holy ground, red, better man, the last time, everything has changed, begin again, starlight, i almost do... the list goes on
Holy Ground and Girl At Home
state of grace acoustic and ronan too
I prefer Taylor's Version cuz of clean production and better vocals
Stolen ver. Sounds weird for me now 😭😭😭
@@ehh9938 Same
@@ehh9938 SAMEE
Off course Taylor old vocal nailed it.
+ Matured
When it comes to 'All Too Well' i cant choose between old or new.
The old one sounds so pure, raw and it felt many stories about a woman who's heart just got brokened yesterday.
Meanwhile, the new one sounds like a fully mature woman, who's looking back at her painful heart brokened memories from years ago, but sings it with a more brave & bold heart.
Idk what to choose.. They're both sounds perfect to me
These were my exact thoughts when I first listened to “Red (Taylor’s Version)”!!! I described the stolen version of her actually living through the pain, while the re-recorded version is her reflecting on that pain.
I got the same feeling 😅
Agree.
Me too.. There songs is good.. But the old version i can feel more emotion than new version... 😅. But i will always love Taylor so much❤
It's hard to choose I Knew You Were Trouble the stolen version is nostalgic and her version is good too, but WANEGBT is hard too
As a newer swiftie, I forgot that All Too Well was this old and hearing it in her young voice for the first time almost broke me dear god
i heard somewhere that the reason why the "weEE"s in WANEGBT TV are so high pitched is cuz she originally wanted them to sound like little kids sliding down a slide, but her manager talked her out of it
i know she work hard but the "weEE" 😭
weeÈ
Her manager knew best 😂
“weEE”
“gorgeous” in a baby voice
and
“hey kids spelling is fun”
Why are all my least favorite parts of Taylor Swift songs all child related? 😆😅
Bro but the Wee in the original version sounds exactly like that to me, I always pictured the kids sliding on the slide every time I heard that part
ronan feels even more emotional now bc taylor is older and it sounds as if she's grieving her own child....
Her vocals have matured so much and the TV version of everything sounds SO much better!! She also has clearer diction.
not wanegbt and ikywt lmao
@@chaigneau6981 They literally are
@@colin2590 22 TV is better than the original but IKYWT TV and WANEGBT TV sound so bad
@@chaigneau6981 I'm agree with you
@@chaigneau6981 22 tv sounds bad too
those transitions were SMOOOOOTH 😩😩😩
I'm so glad she changed girl at home even tho now it sounds more like a 1989 track it's much better
From what I heard, it is also actually how she intended it to sound like. But her old label decided to not put another pop song on it, so they just sent out the demo version of it.
@@OfficialDeanAdler makes sense bc it does sound like a demo which is why i never fully liked it
I can honestly say that I prefer every single TV over the original :) especially Red, Wildest Dreams, Holy Ground, Stay Stay Stay, Come Back Be Here and Girl at home. You can hear how much love she put in the re-recordings.
The Way I Loved You (Taylor's Version) is the best grow up of the TV so far
@@johnnyboooy21 Tell Me Why (Taylor's Version) and Change also!
Someone mentions come back be here 😭
@@johnnyboooy21 in my opinion it's hey Stephen
State of Grace the drums on it sound amazing
Aside from some bits, it’s astounding how similar the two recordings are. The five minute All Too Well on the re-recording sounds really odd to me though.
That's bc the production is slightly different but the same but also bc we were used to the stolen version
@@hunniii2356 Well, her vocals sound really weird at certain points. I feel like that’s one track on the re-recording that mixed/recorded poorly.
@@elizaanderson8909 true but overall I love the rerecording
@@hunniii2356 I like to think they purposefully recorded it poorly to force the listener to rely on the ten minute 😂
@@elizaanderson8909 😂💀
I prefer Taylors versions on all she has re-released coz I think her voice has matured just a bit more and to be honest I don't care coz I love all that she's done anyway ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
For me some songs I like the older one better and some I like the newer version it just depends on which song fit her more mature and less mature voice but I only stream Taylors Version
This video made me realize most of these rerecordings sound the same, its crazy well done!
Agree.
I don't want to sound snarky or condescending at all but anyone who has experience producing music can hear all of the differences pretty clearly (though admittedly some songs are more altered than others.) They absolutely do sound super similar, they are supposed to but there are subtle differences, especially vocally. How she puts emphasis on different syllables, how she holds certain notes, how she enunciates, etc. That said, it is definitely extremely difficult to hear some of the differences when it plays different parts instead of the same part both times back to back.
@@DeadSezSo Yeah I know what you mean. I hear all the differences too, especially the syllables. I can tell everything is much more up front. I meant that she did a good job of keeping the soul of the song and the overall vibe. Someone who isn't aquatinted with the original songs would not be able to tell whether it was OG or TV if played separately, but I could. Even if you produce music, you couldn't deduce whether it was 22 OG or 22 TV playing in the mall for instance, but I could for sure. I prefer TV so its a bummer hearing the originals knowing there's a version of the song I'd rather hear
22, WANGBT, and IKYWT are way better on the original, but all the rest are massively improved
Lol I like the original more, the new ones sounds lazy
yeah. the TVs are all better for me but the og/stolen version of these three are better imo.
We really need Max Martin back
Totally specially for WANEGBT TV omg I'm so In shocked when I first stream the TV like yeah I really don't feel the vibe I used to feel on the og one:( and my 22 baby:( but I still love the TV of 22 but WANEGBT TV, ummmm kinda no but I love the RED (TV) album ❤
Totally specially for WANEGBT TV omg I'm so In shocked when I first stream the TV like yeah I really don't feel the vibe I used to feel on the og one:( and my 22 baby:( but I still love the TV of 22 but WANEGBT TV, ummmm kinda no but I love the RED (TV) album ❤
I'm still not over red TV (the song), everything in that song sounds much better on the TV and listening to the original, it sounds worse than Taylor's Version, like even the Re-e-e-eed sounds so much better
i just miss the banjo from original! idk why she cut the banjo part is so cool!
But not with IKYWT & WANEGBT sound weird
@@geynarokangiras I never really listened to WANEGBT AND IKYWT before the re-recordings because I found them boring so when Red TV came out I got used to listening to them and when I listened to the original to remember what it sounded like it seemed so weird and ugly to me 😭😭
@@sateliteschinos Hence why Taylor’s versions are better. They only think the ogs are better bc of nostalgia but the ogs are quite frankly bad mix wise and vocally
Have to disagree but I respect your opinion.
I'm really upset with IKYWT final production. Her vocals are so much better but they removed the guitar riffs or something and it sounds more poorly , like stripped from music. It also more quieter and have some problems with loudness 😭
TV to me feels like a studio live version
I think it's mainly because Taylor wanted to make it "timeless" or something. A lot of people consider IKYWT's production to be dated/have not aged well since it's dubstep (Though, personally, I don't see it as dated. I like it as is).
IKYWT TV's production is fine to me but it doesn't hit same and it lost some of its edge and intensity. It feels so watered down to be honest.
@@StarstruckAxolot i think it cause her new label wants to save money on the re-records. They sound cheaper and have problems with loudness and it sounds like it's demo version. And there is no such problems with new songs on TV albums. I'm really worried if they are not hire Max Martin for the 1989 and Reputation re-records.
@@Azoria_J yeah i noticed that too. All the vault tracks have significantly better quality than the rerecords. To be fair, these rerecords are gonna be costly to her.
I kinda have faith in 1989 since Wildest Dreams TV was decent and This Love TV was far better than I expected. I think it's reputation I have the most concerns for 🥲
@@StarstruckAxolot I really like Wildest Dream TV but This Love TV not quite as good as the original though pretty decent( It doesn't have guitar picks in the beginning of the song, same problems with loudness and mixing
Wow, they are all so close to the original but at the same time, so much better.
Taylor sounds like she is in tears singing I Almost Do in the original. I love how raw it is.
Oh Man... This album brings me back so many memories from when I was 20. I just feel nostalgic 😢
I like 22 (Taylor’s Version) and I Almost Do (Taylor’s Version) way more because her vocals improved so much in the originals her voice kinda cracks
Idk, 22 tv sounds so lazy and deprived of energy unlike the original. Especially the chorus
@@aryaveer.8 yeah, no hate to the rerecorded album.... But I prefer the old 22 and WANEGBT for some reason
To me, it's missing the "happy, free, confused, and lonely at the same time" feeling. Yk, the feeling of being literally 22
i LOVE how I Almost Do sounds in the re recording, i never really listened to the original but 🤩🤩🤩
SAME
Whyyyyy it used to be so amazing, I always thought about it as all too well part 2. And the lyrics are so good
i do prefer some tracks from the stolen one (WANEGBT im looking at you, and ATW 5min) but also prefer overall the re-record. ATW 10min SENT ME but also, i didn’t like everything has changed first but the re-record was an experience. overall im really glad tay got to own her music as she should.
Yeah WANEGBT is very much giving Kids Bop 🥴
@@jessnelson8094 FR but i still stream the hell out of it bc its iconic. at the eras tour the "WEEEEE" sounded like the stolen version so like-
Awesome transition.!!! It made me realized that re-recorded and stolen version sounds pretty the same. I thought the TV is more raw and better.
girl at home really got the upgrade she deserved
more like a downgrade 😭😭 why does it sound like multiple taylors singing the same thing without harmony
It got yassified 😍
And somehow, this is an unpopular opinion??? Girl At Home (Taylor’s Version) is soooo much better
@@marcus.taylorsversion8448 it’s okay to be tasteless ❤
Yep, 100%
I miss her lisp in Stay Stay Stay and how happy she sounded. Still happy in the remake but I can hear her uncontrollable smile in the original
I love both, I'll only listen to the ethically sourced version now but both versions are good 👌
Didn’t realize The Last Time have improved “ A LOT “ 🤩
the original *exile* 😌
@@homidjohn that's so true
The og version is so nostalgic but the TV is more better imo
People talk about the taylor’s versions being more “clean, well just because it’s clean doesn’t mean you don’t miss it haha. But besides the bad joke, i really believe in that, some time has passed and There’s still songs I can’t say i like them… starlight, wangbt and holy ground specially, and believe me when i say that needed a loot of time for me to like the og starlight and then i get that re-recording…
I really miss the dirty base on all too well. All too well will forever be an electric guitar song.
I’m so glad you put Better Man!!!!
The only songs for which I prefer the og are State of Grace, 22 and begin again
I still listen to Taylor's version, but in my heart I still have that original sound 🥹
The clarity in the new recordings that better accentuate your voice, instruments, a more creative and balanced mix, etc. WELL DONE!
I prefer the Tv versions they sound so much clearer
Everyone who says the old ones are better is deaf. Struggling to hit the notes isn’t the same as putting in emotion…
emotion > robot voice
The Lucky One coming from an older, wiser Taylor feels meant to be ❤
Im a proud swiftie! Waiting for speak now tv
i have good news for you lol
spntv is gonna be amazing i fear
YUH
Taylor’s version because it sounds cleaner although her old vocals will definitely give me nostalgia always
The Moment I Knew changed so much in a better way
gitl at home is the only nonvault rerecorded song that has been given a new production. that's one interesting twist in her rerecording process
i might be crazy but does ed sheeran sound slightly flat to anybody in everything has changed tv??? it makes it nearly impossible to listen to the song for me and i’m sad bc it’s one of my faves from the album :((
YES ESPECIALLY THE BRIDGE
Ed ruined it all. Taylor was doing so well
he is definitely a bit flat, but for some reason i really like that. it adds some dissonance that i weirdly enjoy 😂
State Of Grace - TV
Red - TV
Treacherous - Tie
I Know You Were Trouble - Stolen
All Too Well - TV
22 - Stolen
I Almost Do - TV
We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together - Tie
Stay Stay Stay - Tie
The Last Time - Tie
Holy Ground - Tie
Sad Beautiful Tragic - Stolen
The Lucky One - TV
Everything Has Changed - TV
Starlight - Tie
Begin Again - TV
The Moment I Knew - Stolen
Come Back... Be Here - TV
Girl At Home - Tie (Both have their own vibes, so i can't compare)
State Of Grace (Acoustic) - Stolen
Ronan - TV
Better Man (FTV) - TV
i prefer old treacherous, ikywt and all too well, 22 and wanegbt the stolen version like omg i don't know why tv has been released for 7-8 months now but i still think that they're much better, but the rest of the tracks tv is better than the stolen, i love the production of treacherous on stolen specially the 2nd bridge and backing vocals, ikywt production has the same + she put some bang/rocky like from the "the joke is on me yeah!" 2nd pre-chorus and the bridge pre-last chorus the long notes, all too well the stolen is just much sadder for me like since the wound that she has while singing that song at that time it's more angrier and sadder + it has more electric guitar and the drums are heavier than the tv, on tv she already move on it still hurts but you cannot hear the sadness from her voice (this goes same with tmik but i like the tv more than the sv) 22 feels like shes more happy on singing it since because of what happened when she was 21 + when she was 22 and the song really fits on her age at that time + it's more fun, wanegbt are just about the "weEEh!" part it annoys me sm on tv i always listen to wanegbt on stolen when the tv wasn't release yet but now i always skip wanegbt :(
Stay stay stay is also very different. I do miss the country accent though.
All too well sounds amazing Taylor's version. love it!
That was awesome to watch the 2012 compare to Taylor's Version.of red.
In my opinion:
Best Instrumental: Stolen Version
Best Vocals: Re-recorded Version
But Taylor's Version is still the winner
Instrumental: Taylor's Version
for all too well i like the 10 min version better. i think the background music just makes everything feel sad. also i love that it’s so long
i honestly prefer the og version of 22 because it gives a more freedom feeling
Is it only me or holy ground TV is faster??
i think is just you it is the same bpm!
To me it sounds slower. It used to be a favorite on the album and now I don't like it.
I love both versions
Hmm I must go with the original hands down. I feel like as an artist you can only feel feelings and display them properly once. Although the intention of the new one is amazing. Emotions just can’t be reproduced like that and Taylor is all emotion
Original version: Wanegbt and The Moment I Knew sound better
Taylor's Version: I Almost Do, Stay Stay Stay and Ronan are the ones that improved the most
My Fav Red Album
1. All too well 2012
2. Holy Ground (TV)
3. Red 2012
4. State Of Grace (TV)
5. Treacherous (TV)
6. IKYWT (TV)
7. 22 (2012)
8. Better Man (TV)
9. I almost do (TV)
10. State of Grace Acoustic 2012
11. WANEGBT TV
12. Stay3 2012
13. The Last Time TV
14. Sad BT ( TV)
15. The Lucky One TV
16. Everything HC TV
17. Starlight TV
18. Begin Again 2012
19. The Moment IK ( TV)
20. Come Back BH (TV)
21. Girl at Home (TV)
22. Ronan (TV)
Hope you like it.. But im really love taylor so much. ❤
The original will always be but TV is amazing! Much clearer vocals
IMO, all of the tvs are so much better than the og version (except for some like style and btr) she put so much effort in the tvs and it shows!!
stay stay stay improved so much ❤❤
I really love her all songs by idol Taylor ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ but my answer your question is song. ❤️❤️❤️ALL TO WELL ❤️❤️❤️
Red TV as a whole> BUT Red stolen version singles>>>>>
Red original is pure nostalgia but the original has better production and vocals
Girl At Home got a complete revamp
I relly love her incomparable voice😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
I love Begin Again TV and The Moment I Knew TV❤ cuz The Moment I Knew sounds sad in OG, but angry in TV and I love that
anyone else notice the banjo going crazy wasn’t there in red (taylor’s version)?
I can't believe i never noticed the voice crack in 22 lmao
22 and wangbt is soo weird on TV
least staystaystay and begin again is listenable now
TV is basically live studio version and somehow i can sing with it? OG was bit pitchy for me to sing
i love girl at home tv because of the improved vocals and the upbeat music!!!❤❤❤❤❤
the versions i prefer:
state of grace - SV
red - TV
treacherous - tied
IKYWT - TV
ATW - TV
22 - SV
I almost do - TV
WANEGBT - SV
stay stay stay - TV
the last time - TV
holy ground - tied
SBT - TV
the lucky one - SV
everything has changed - TV
starlight - tied
begin again - TV
the moment i knew - tied
come back be here - TV
girl at home - TV
state of grace (acoustic) - tied
ronan - tied
better man - TV
i like WANGBT 2012 version, i dont like sounds of taylor’s version
im a critic swiftie
the one i would prefer 2012 version is only WANGBT, and I knew you were trouble.
the rest TV for sure
i dont like some too and i noticed they are singles (ikywt, 22, wanegbt). It might just be a me problem since i'm so used to the old version since i've been listening to them for years
Though her voice pitched down still it's beautiful ♥️
o modo que a ponte de red og tava sem vida alguma e na tv ela virou O MOMENTO.
Kinda wish you remembered to use the Deluxe cover art on the bonus tracks for the og. But this is great work and the visual is so pretty 🤩👏✨
The way stay stay stay sounded… bad in the original version and it’s so good in the Taylor’s version… wow.
Red sounds SO different
If i ever get a glow up, i want it that to be like State Of Grace TV. Holy molly, the og feels like a demo now cause the goodness of the the TV
the original is a classic.
I know we're all swifties here but its okay not to lie to ourselves... some of these are bad we can admit it lol
The old is better tbh has a more natural sound
I think I'm just gonna listen to the original versions illegally so the money doesnt go to Scooter Braun 💀
originals sound laughable after the TVs, though some people prefer the nostalgia
@@JackToTheA1No they sound better, natural and emotional (with the shaky voice flaws)
TV can never match the stolen version of 22, WANEGBT, IKYWT, Holy ground, Girl At Home
She’s clearly a better artist now and using better production on every song, Taylor’s version is objectively better
I dunno but now I hear Stolen Version kinda weird
girl at home notably sounds different
different genre!
I Like Both, To Be Honest
the original vocals of 22 and we are never getting back together are still featured on taylor's version, also, girl at home at taylor's version is no longer country compared to the original
I knew you were trouble SHINES on Taylors Version
Better production, more harmonic and better treatment to the high vocals
YESS
the different is
Taylor's version
The song is more towards Taylor Swift's heaviness and maturity
Red deluxe
Taylor's voice is more towards the voice of teenagers and children
22 sounded so like a phone voice memo but she delivered
Better Man sounds way better. Is actually one of her best songs
the mix of the taylor's version is way vetter for sure.
I almost do TV is brilliant
I love this
Ngl i prefer both of them idk why i luv both of them
Songs I prefer on the original version are I Knew You Were Trouble., 22, WANEGBT, The Last Time, Holy Ground, The Moment I Knew, and Girl at Home.
WAITING FOR SPEAK NOW IN 2 DAYS
i knew you were trouble is so appalling 😭
Girl at home really got that upgrade in TV
as a long lived swiftie i prefer the og, taylor will forgive me but this new version's vocal are likely read lyrics and not sung, and also the aesthetic of the 2012 version was so over, this new one just looks like evermore
SOG - Tie
Red - TV
Treacherous - TV
Ikywt - Conflicted
All too well - Stolen
22 - Tie
I almost do - TV
WANEGBT - Stolen
Stayx3 - Tie
The Last Time - TV
Holy Ground - Stolen
Sad Beautiful Tragic - Tie
The Lucky One - Tie
Everything has changed - Tv
Starlight - TV
Begin Again - Tie
The Moment I knew - TV
Come back....be here - TV
Girl at home - TV
Tbh I just don’t like the way she says “WEEE” in Taylor’s Version if We Are Never Getting Back Together in Taylor’s Version