I'm really happy they cut this. I love the movie to bits, been watching it at least half a dozen times each year since it's release. It was always clear in the movie, for me at least, that he doesn't age. The whole point of the heart of a star is that it keeps you youthful. Rather than eating it, he has it through love. "No man can live forever, except he who possesses the heart of a star". Him ageing makes no sense, and it's kinda creepy.
I would have to disagree. Yvaine, was not human, but Triston was. Him aging was realistic and makes sense to me, in my opinion of course. However, I too am glad they cut this scene. The "farewell to my children," was well acted out by any of the characters. AND, I personally never liked the competition of retrieving the stone. Because even with Triston saying "we're doing it my way, [you still have to find the stone to be queen/king]." This can bring out the worst in someone still, where they will go as far as they can to ensure they receive the stone first before anybody else - meaning deceit, hatred, negativity. So it's better to leave the ending open to the viewer, to make their own story of how the kingdom was ruled after they parted. I never saw this alternate ending until now, and I always believed that Yvette and Triston grew old together, and when they were at a time where they felt their health is slipping, and they are soon to pass away, they lit the candle and went to the universe to became stars. As for earth, the children banded together to create a democracy or some sort, and ruled the kingdom together.
Tristan should have been youthful when they left I really felt it would have been better and again that same race to retrieve the stone , it could have been avoided. their sons and daughters didn't kill anyone it shows the way they parented and taught them to love each other. So they themselves could have divided responsibility of kingdom between themselves and all could have ruled.
@@davideferrari1194 OMG! Just finished the book, and...holly cowcrap! The movie is fenomenal! The book is like reading the newspaper, no drama or excitement, just explaining in details how the characters piss...:0 very much disappintment. I hope the rest of his books are better as I bought tons of them at once just because of this movie 😄
Not a great scene but I like how when the necklace flew in the beginning, the sons were going crazy looking for it, but this time, the children don’t even care. They stay with their parents.
In the book Tristran (Renamed Tristan in the movie) dies of old age and Yvaine rules as an immortal queen, but the author Neil Gaiman prefers the movie ending over the one written in the book, but in the book Tristan isn't a human, he's a fae and therefore that explains why he survived A) Yvaine using her powers to kill Lamia and B) Why he becomes a star at the end of the movie. He's already a magical being.
Mrs. Apple No, Tristran/Tristan is half-mortal due to his mother, Una being an elven Princess of the kingdom of Stormhold in the realm of Faerie. In the book, it’s even mentioned that Tristran/Tristan’s younger sister Louise makes fun of him due to his elven features.
The movie ending was nice. The book's ending was more beautiful and meaningful. It ended on such an achingly beautiful note: "She says nothing at all, but simply stares upwards into the dark sky and watches, with sad eyes, the slow dance of the infinite stars." With that one simple sentence, you're left to wonder what she could be thinking - about how long 'eternity' will be, for her; about whether she has regrets and if she feels guilt for having those regrets; about whether she continues to love him, or loves him less with each passing year. The movie ending sews things up neatly, and the viewer never has to think about anything more. Years later, I bet readers still put themselves in Yvaine's place and try to empathise.
Supposedly, Neil Gaiman himself suggested the movie's ending after reading the script and feeling his original ending was too bittersweet for the film.
Watch this every year since it was released never gets old. It taught me never to chase. To always progress and be better, to do it not for the one you want to impress but gain for your own self worth. The right woman will be with you through hardship and good days and the right woman will find you stay sigma.
+Kane Domican I'm not. This was a special scene to me that portrayed Yvaine and Tristan reaching the end of their long rule and passing the torch to their adult offspring. In my honest opinion as a viewer, it would have made the film stronger.
yeah, with movies they only have so much screen time and have to pick scenes that would be most beneficial to telling the story and is not too time consuming. the last thing they want is a person to get bored or the story to slow down because they included unimportant or long winded scenes.
Love this film Interesting to see an older Tristan with Yvaine looking as amazing as ever Liked the ending on the cinematic release but did enjoy seeing this Cool post
shastapurpledaisy I could sense some tradition change, but I couldn't hear his darn words. How is the next ruler determined this time? I only know that no actual killing is involved.
@@Raximus3000 Not really. Whoever is able to locate a single gem in an entire kingdom, while competing with half a dozen others at least is a perfect way to have the new monarch prove they can organise, plan, and that they know their kingdom. Also, whoever the new monarch is, they will have loyal servants willing to help them, since there won't be a direct competition for the throne, so able participants can still serve the kingdom. There's a reason why fratricidal kings in the real world rarely ruled for long, or stably.
@@theshadowling1 Hardly in the real world it was looked down upon while it was the norm to avoid bad blood. Also if you have stones that literaly tell you anything if the answer is a yes or no, then it hardly becomes a competion of skill, not to mention if someone tried underhanded methods and won it would still create bad blood.
Ah Shucks! I'm teary eyed now but delighted to have seen this scene. That said I can understand why they used the other one but still, its good to see this.
Moral of the story: if Charlie Cox gets prosthetics, then the scene will be deleted... He had scenes as Caligula in Dracula Untold, but then it got cut from the final version But I do agree it was better to delete this one, that ending with both of their young profile silhouettes lighting the Babylon candle made it look like they'd live forever like that, despite the fact that this ending added a more 'human' look to everlasting love, at least from Tristan's point of view
I just finished stardust and it's my first time in years to google related Abt a movie, when I found outhow the book ended I totally felt how Yvaine feels. Bye
Daniella Mccallum Yeah but I thought she'd choose to age with him, like she had power over it and as soon as it was necessary she'd be young again. Not aging in body but aging in appearance.
They definitely should have kept this one! But somehow, there's this comedic tone to this scene that's why they cut it out. I've read somewhere that in the book, Tristan died and Yvain ruled forever (since she's immortal) and neve went back to the heavens.
I don't understand how the comedic tone would be unfitting considering that their predecessor had burst out laughing after using the tossing of the gem to lead one of his sons to a death plunge out the window.
I cannot believe that it is only now, in the year of our most favorite Jew 2018, that I'm seeing this scene. It's so touching. But also with a slight comedic aspect as another commenter mentioned. Like, '*sniff* Mummy and daddy are going into the sky and now who can I whine to when my sister wears my dresses without permission? 😢' Lol. But doesn't that encapsulate the movie tho? Touching with a comedic aspect. Beautiful.
Good job they cut it. It's awful. Why are they old, when supposed possession of the heart of a star makes you immortal? The witch got young again with the heart of a star, so why is the king old? This is the issue with many films.... lack of basic attention to detail. This is a film I really like (book too, though very different). It was fine so well. In fact the only detail I am not happy with is how Tristan has the power of knowing exactly where everyone is in Stormhold. If they hadn't eluded to it with the scene "How do you know ....I just do" it wouldn't have been an issue. But they did, then failed to allow an explanation. This scene would have made everything worse. Good job I understand that everything is an evolution. A process. Everyone should remember this lesson. 🎉
I wish that they kept this in the Ending of Stardust because it was beautiful and sad and it actually showed how Yvain and Tristan went to the Star-World :') :') :') :') :') : ) :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'(
But the movie shows how they went to. It explains they kept the candle and once they were old and ready, they lit it up and went to the stars. You need to re-watch it and pay attention to the ending perhaps! I understand it might seem confusing if you don't look to the details
This is by far a superior ending both from the book and film. In the film the witch is killed (films need a big scene) but in the book Yvaine kisses the witch from pity when she has lost her power. The book is by far a better rendition than the film imo.
Tristian died of old age in the book and he and Y'vaine never had children. She ruled stormhold for all eternity and was beloved by the people. Y'vaine was unable to return to her mother the moon and her sisters the stars. Babalyon candles created miracles, they couldn't teleport a person or star for that matter. Yvaine slept in the highest tower of the castle with an open roof ceiling to look among her mothers and sisters with burning longing. Truthfully, she lived in agony for eternity.
June 3 2020 He never getting old and i feel alone right now becuase im the only one its hard to be adopted and never know your true family no one love's me i can only to do is cry in my room😢😭😭😭😭
BUt i have already thought of the fact that Yvaine does not age while watching the movie so I have already suspected that this would be the deepest ending of their love story yet I ignored it because I wondered how would tristan look and now I really remembered the reason why I have ignored it after watching this :-)
I wonder why this extended part scene of the ending was deleted from the ending of this movie of (StarDust)? The reason why I am wondering is because I really like seeing this part that I have never seen before; Now when I saw this movie in the theaters it was great, but I think that the ending might of been even better with this extended scene part left in the ending of the film.
"This time we'll do it my way. Whoever is the next to hold this jewel will be the new king or queen." But, isn't that exactly how the last king did it?
This is kinda like the end of the book, cause Yvaine is inmortal and Tristan gets old. But in the book Tristan dies and Yvaine became the inmortal queen of stronhold
I like the ending in the movie better. In the book, she rules the kingdom forever after he dies. But it’s like... the movie one does a good job of having an ending where it looks like their love goes on in the stars.
![Me Before You [Behind the Scenes]](/img/n.gif)
I'm really happy they cut this. I love the movie to bits, been watching it at least half a dozen times each year since it's release. It was always clear in the movie, for me at least, that he doesn't age. The whole point of the heart of a star is that it keeps you youthful. Rather than eating it, he has it through love. "No man can live forever, except he who possesses the heart of a star". Him ageing makes no sense, and it's kinda creepy.
JulZ 97 I agree, I like how they did it in the movie. In the book Tristan dies and yvaine rules eternally
@JulZ 97: Tristan is still mortal where as Yvaine is not- even Tristan's Uncles [ the Ghosts] are mortal.
However, there is a difference between ethernal youth and ethernal life.
I would have to disagree. Yvaine, was not human, but Triston was. Him aging was realistic and makes sense to me, in my opinion of course. However, I too am glad they cut this scene. The "farewell to my children," was well acted out by any of the characters. AND, I personally never liked the competition of retrieving the stone. Because even with Triston saying "we're doing it my way, [you still have to find the stone to be queen/king]." This can bring out the worst in someone still, where they will go as far as they can to ensure they receive the stone first before anybody else - meaning deceit, hatred, negativity.
So it's better to leave the ending open to the viewer, to make their own story of how the kingdom was ruled after they parted. I never saw this alternate ending until now, and I always believed that Yvette and Triston grew old together, and when they were at a time where they felt their health is slipping, and they are soon to pass away, they lit the candle and went to the universe to became stars.
As for earth, the children banded together to create a democracy or some sort, and ruled the kingdom together.
Tristan should have been youthful when they left I really felt it would have been better and again that same race to retrieve the stone , it could have been avoided. their sons and daughters didn't kill anyone it shows the way they parented and taught them to love each other. So they themselves could have divided responsibility of kingdom between themselves and all could have ruled.
Cool to see but def was not needed. The way the movie actually did the ending was just perfect
Yes "and they live happily ever after" suited best
Zssza
For once better the movie than the original book.
@@davideferrari1194 OMG! Just finished the book, and...holly cowcrap! The movie is fenomenal! The book is like reading the newspaper, no drama or excitement, just explaining in details how the characters piss...:0 very much disappintment. I hope the rest of his books are better as I bought tons of them at once just because of this movie 😄
Not a great scene but I like how when the necklace flew in the beginning, the sons were going crazy looking for it, but this time, the children don’t even care. They stay with their parents.
"What your mother is trying to say is, well done not killing each other. " 😂😂😂
"well done for not killing each other"
😅🤣🤣
I wonder how many parents have said that to their kids for real.
It's 2023 and still haven't found any beautiful movie like "star dust". Star dust is still the best in its gern.
I thought Tristan will be immortal like Yvaine because he has her full heart... But this looks beautiful too! Emphasizes on what true love should be
In the book Tristran (Renamed Tristan in the movie) dies of old age and Yvaine rules as an immortal queen, but the author Neil Gaiman prefers the movie ending over the one written in the book, but in the book Tristan isn't a human, he's a fae and therefore that explains why he survived A) Yvaine using her powers to kill Lamia and B) Why he becomes a star at the end of the movie. He's already a magical being.
I thought it was thought maybe he would never age.
@@cthonisprincess4011 just wondering why he is a fae? Both of his parents are mortals...right?
Mrs. Apple No, Tristran/Tristan is half-mortal due to his mother, Una being an elven Princess of the kingdom of Stormhold in the realm of Faerie. In the book, it’s even mentioned that Tristran/Tristan’s younger sister Louise makes fun of him due to his elven features.
@@cthonisprincess4011 ohh.. i haven't read the book so i didn't know. Thank you for clearing that up☺☺☺
“Does anyone have a light?” *Surrounded by candles*
😁😁👌
To be fair, she is like really old
Right... 😂😂😂
rightfully deleted
iwantcoolname yes
Hi where from you
@@StephaniePage-ss9nm wow u to late 4 years
@@xiaosulsham9290 I am after you
@@meditationmusicchannel14ghh
It's great to see it, but it's certainly an 'extra' scene not needed for the movie. The ending was a true fairy tail ending, it's why it's good
just found this and yeah... kind of glad they left it out.
sorry for those actors in it that didn't make the cut though
The movie ending was nice. The book's ending was more beautiful and meaningful.
It ended on such an achingly beautiful note: "She says nothing at all, but simply stares upwards into the dark sky and watches, with sad eyes, the slow dance of the infinite stars."
With that one simple sentence, you're left to wonder what she could be thinking - about how long 'eternity' will be, for her; about whether she has regrets and if she feels guilt for having those regrets; about whether she continues to love him, or loves him less with each passing year.
The movie ending sews things up neatly, and the viewer never has to think about anything more. Years later, I bet readers still put themselves in Yvaine's place and try to empathise.
Supposedly, Neil Gaiman himself suggested the movie's ending after reading the script and feeling his original ending was too bittersweet for the film.
We watched the movie last night. They were right to leave this scene out.
her last words to them would have been "does anyone have a light?"
and if that's not funny i don't know what is
Watch this every year since it was released never gets old. It taught me never to chase. To always progress and be better, to do it not for the one you want to impress but gain for your own self worth. The right woman will be with you through hardship and good days and the right woman will find you stay sigma.
So glad this wasn't in the movie
+Kane Domican I'm not. This was a special scene to me that portrayed Yvaine and Tristan reaching the end of their long rule and passing the torch to their adult offspring. In my honest opinion as a viewer, it would have made the film stronger.
thank god it is not in the movie
It was ok but I'm kind of relieved they left it out
yeah, with movies they only have so much screen time and have to pick scenes that would be most beneficial to telling the story and is not too time consuming.
the last thing they want is a person to get bored or the story to slow down because they included unimportant or long winded scenes.
That moment where you love both endings, the official one and the deleted one
this ending is rightfully deleted...it would have ruined the beautiful perfect ending
I love this movie I love that they had a different ending choice
Love this film
Interesting to see an older Tristan with Yvaine looking as amazing as ever
Liked the ending on the cinematic release but did enjoy seeing this
Cool post
I love that they showed that tradition was changed but removing this scene was good. It may have been the lack of music and editing but it was boring
shastapurpledaisy I could sense some tradition change, but I couldn't hear his darn words. How is the next ruler determined this time? I only know that no actual killing is involved.
@@thefirstbourne149 Whoever found the ruby. Same way Tristan became king. It's why he threw away the ruby.
@@theshadowling1
Yep, so things became worse. Whichever of these find it even if he does not posses intelligence or cunning will rule the kingdom.
@@Raximus3000 Not really. Whoever is able to locate a single gem in an entire kingdom, while competing with half a dozen others at least is a perfect way to have the new monarch prove they can organise, plan, and that they know their kingdom. Also, whoever the new monarch is, they will have loyal servants willing to help them, since there won't be a direct competition for the throne, so able participants can still serve the kingdom. There's a reason why fratricidal kings in the real world rarely ruled for long, or stably.
@@theshadowling1
Hardly in the real world it was looked down upon while it was the norm to avoid bad blood. Also if you have stones that literaly tell you anything if the answer is a yes or no, then it hardly becomes a competion of skill, not to mention if someone tried underhanded methods and won it would still create bad blood.
There was a reason they removed this from the final cut. Had they included it, Stardust might not have had an epic ending.
Tristan then froze up and suffocated in the cold vacuum of space...
Aakash Vadher 😒
Stapppp XD
i don't think it works that way in a fantasy film
LOL
Aakash Vadher such a joyful ending
Ah Shucks! I'm teary eyed now but delighted to have seen this scene. That said I can understand why they used the other one but still, its good to see this.
I LOVE this ending
Same
I'm happy that they cut this scene ))))
Imagine the Men In Black theme playing during that final cut to the stars.
it would awesome with they did a sequel for this movie with their kids rulings the kingdom.
Daunte Yohey yasssss
Angel Rose I will total watch it with they did
I have such a strong feeling about this ending that when they are gone their kids will start killing each other to get the pendant. Is it just me?
Yes
I wish too 😍 its alovely movie
Is good that they did this scene. They could use it to start a sequel
My favorite movie ever, and it has been sence 2007
😭i love this movie pls make more like this
So thats how the star of neverland was created 😂
I'm so glad they deleted this scene. The ending in the movie was perfect
Moral of the story: if Charlie Cox gets prosthetics, then the scene will be deleted... He had scenes as Caligula in Dracula Untold, but then it got cut from the final version
But I do agree it was better to delete this one, that ending with both of their young profile silhouettes lighting the Babylon candle made it look like they'd live forever like that, despite the fact that this ending added a more 'human' look to everlasting love, at least from Tristan's point of view
Clare Danes looks like gwyneth potrow however you spell it lmao
Yes but her eyebrows (or the lack of it) bothers me..
Thus was, the second star to the right (and straight on til morning!)
Good Thing this was cut from the Movie.
I saw this so many years ago and thought it was a fever dream. Nice to know it was real
Aw!!! They should have used this ending!!! So beautiful 😍
Oh god beautiful.i love to watch this.
I just finished stardust and it's my first time in years to google related Abt a movie, when I found outhow the book ended I totally felt how Yvaine feels. Bye
I would've thought that yvain would've grown old with tristan....
Remember the 3 witches stayed young by eating the last fallen star heart. As stars don't age like humans.
Daniella Mccallum
Yeah but I thought she'd choose to age with him, like she had power over it and as soon as it was necessary she'd be young again. Not aging in body but aging in appearance.
Why? She's a star remember? A source of immortality.
domidium
I know that, I thought she'd use her power to age with Tristan and then make him young again with her when it was time.
crowdpleasa4495 Well...she didn't age in the book, so I guess they were just keeping true to that.
They definitely should have kept this one! But somehow, there's this comedic tone to this scene that's why they cut it out. I've read somewhere that in the book, Tristan died and Yvain ruled forever (since she's immortal) and neve went back to the heavens.
Also in the book Tristan and Yvian couldn't conceive any children.
What is the name of the book?
+PETRAKOS007 Stardust by Neil Gaiman, a great artist.
I don't understand how the comedic tone would be unfitting considering that their predecessor had burst out laughing after using the tossing of the gem to lead one of his sons to a death plunge out the window.
Oh that’s kinda depressing... I don’t want to read it now
I cannot believe that it is only now, in the year of our most favorite Jew 2018, that I'm seeing this scene. It's so touching. But also with a slight comedic aspect as another commenter mentioned. Like, '*sniff* Mummy and daddy are going into the sky and now who can I whine to when my sister wears my dresses without permission? 😢' Lol. But doesn't that encapsulate the movie tho? Touching with a comedic aspect. Beautiful.
wow, this ending is cute
I wish they had used this ending!! Especially the part where any of their children could be king or queen! And Tristan’s aging made sense to me!
The movie ended fine as it was. This did not need to be in it.
Good job they cut it. It's awful.
Why are they old, when supposed possession of the heart of a star makes you immortal? The witch got young again with the heart of a star, so why is the king old?
This is the issue with many films.... lack of basic attention to detail.
This is a film I really like (book too, though very different). It was fine so well.
In fact the only detail I am not happy with is how Tristan has the power of knowing exactly where everyone is in Stormhold. If they hadn't eluded to it with the scene "How do you know ....I just do" it wouldn't have been an issue. But they did, then failed to allow an explanation.
This scene would have made everything worse.
Good job I understand that everything is an evolution. A process. Everyone should remember this lesson. 🎉
Goosebumps all over.
I wish that they kept this in the Ending of Stardust because it was beautiful and sad and it actually showed how Yvain and Tristan went to the Star-World :') :') :') :') :') :
) :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'(
But the movie shows how they went to. It explains they kept the candle and once they were old and ready, they lit it up and went to the stars.
You need to re-watch it and pay attention to the ending perhaps! I understand it might seem confusing if you don't look to the details
i dont see why people dont like this scene, its literally just what the narrator said happened.
why is there a final to this beautiful story? It's amazing!
This is by far a superior ending both from the book and film. In the film the witch is killed (films need a big scene) but in the book Yvaine kisses the witch from pity when she has lost her power. The book is by far a better rendition than the film imo.
What happened to the witch.
a real tear dropper
Good thing this was cut
Best the in movie stardust .. tngk bnykali jlan cerita tetap tok bosan ! Hahah...
I don't want to see all of them killing each other
So glad they cut this! What a downer ending to an otherwise charming film.
I'm gonna cry
If they became stars in distance space at the end, man, they are far away from each other.
Tuesday 19th December 2023. I love Stardust! Thank you. Bless you. From Virginia Clark.?! ;) :( :) 😎🎄🎁🐦🐶
I always thought that there should've been more to the ending !
That ending could have ruined this amazing movie.
true
This ending was perfect!!! They should've used this in the final cut indeed :)
Tristian died of old age in the book and he and Y'vaine never had children. She ruled stormhold for all eternity and was beloved by the people. Y'vaine was unable to return to her mother the moon and her sisters the stars. Babalyon candles created miracles, they couldn't teleport a person or star for that matter. Yvaine slept in the highest tower of the castle with an open roof ceiling to look among her mothers and sisters with burning longing. Truthfully, she lived in agony for eternity.
June 3 2020 He never getting old and i feel alone right now becuase im the only one its hard to be adopted and never know your true family no one love's me i can only to do is cry in my room😢😭😭😭😭
"Aim low." Was so funny to me
I used to think the actor for Tristan was an awful actor. But there he starred in Daredevil, and he was phenomenal in that.
her last words would have been "does anyone have a light?" ats mad craic at is.
Love this movie good story...😍
What STAR do best❓ SHINE‼
"Low. Aim low" lolololol
I'm so glad this scene was not included!
I love this wholesome scene, wish they added it to the movie but it's still wonderful to know it exists.
His creepy face would’ve ruined it. Thank god they ended it the way they did
I am always curious the ending now I see it . it really good at least she never leave him.
BUt i have already thought of the fact that Yvaine does not age while watching the movie so I have already suspected that this would be the deepest ending of their love story yet I ignored it because I wondered how would tristan look and now I really remembered the reason why I have ignored it after watching this :-)
Muchos Hermosa Familia!! Empire is mucho gusto like
I wonder why this extended part scene of the ending was deleted from the ending of this movie of (StarDust)?
The reason why I am wondering is because I really like seeing this part that I have never seen before; Now when I saw this movie in the theaters it was great, but I think that the ending might of been even better with this extended scene part left in the ending of the film.
Part of the reason is that he was not supposed to age because he had the heart of the star
This is one of the very few times I liked the movie better than the book.
"This time we'll do it my way. Whoever is the next to hold this jewel will be the new king or queen."
But, isn't that exactly how the last king did it?
Glad it was deleted but it is kind of adorable.
This is kinda like the end of the book, cause Yvaine is inmortal and Tristan gets old. But in the book Tristan dies and Yvaine became the inmortal queen of stronhold
Awwww it's so beautiful... So sweet!
Why it was deleted?! 😢
THANKS GOD THIS WAS DELETED!!!
I dont understand the ending in the movie.Someone can explain it ??
Imagine if they had lost the candle
So glad this scene didn't make it to the final product
I like the ending in the movie better. In the book, she rules the kingdom forever after he dies. But it’s like... the movie one does a good job of having an ending where it looks like their love goes on in the stars.
It’s beautiful but yes, thankfully it was cut.
Shouldve kept this in the movie
Thank god this ending was deleted
I do like this scene but I feel like it was a good decision to cut it out as it would of oversold the point they made at the end.
Wow Charlie Cox in old age makeup and Claire Danes is still young
I can see why they cut it.
Glad they deleted this, but I do love Yvaine at 0:46 😅
Ainda bem que foi cortado
This scene could be a teaser if they make a sequel
i like this ending better!!!! we know a all more with this one.
Same