not saying pledis doesnt suck at promoting AS (bc they do), but isn't member rotation this group's concept? Members are supposed to "graduate" and be replaced by newer generations
Sigh I can never properly explain to newer kpop fans the talent rookies had when they debut back in the day. There was no such thing as "they're rookies. Let's wait for them to improve" back then.
OK but nowadays the new rookies also have a lot of talent. I feel like y'all are forgetting the (almost) inhumane training and rules kpop idols had back then. So obviously they were much more practiced and well versed. I honestly don't see the problem in newer groups having to adapt to the idol life at first. I'd much rather watch a group improve over time knowing that they were allowed to have a life than seeing perfect machines (not meant for their personality of course) that had to suffer to get where they are. That's no hate to older gens tho. I love groups like after school, rania and kara but I can't help but feel sad for their living conditions back then. So keep that in mind next time before you complain. (Also, is it really necessary to tear others down to bring your fave up? Why can't we just apprechiate what we had instead of comparing? This is about after school and no one else so we shouldn't bring up other groups constantly. We don't like that when new groups do it either)
I miss the 1st gen of after school, even the 2nd gen was something special to. They were different to the generic groups. Kahi is truly something special. JungAh & bekah stood out so much because of their skill set & appearance. Kahi made after school different, the record label i feel didn't really know how to push & develop the group after she left.
Oh shit. Bekah and Kahi might as well have been a duo after they left. they're so damn charismatic with so much stage presence. I also have to agree with so many other comments that this was the best lineup amongst all years.
I was thinking the same which sent me in a nostalgia trip and then i saw Girlicious singing Like Me live which has an aesthetic really similar at times
This performance was so good. After School has always been a great band. It’s amazing how good they were at their debut, especially when you think their 4 best members weren’t even there yet: Uee, Raina, Nana and Lizzy.
I wish today’s Kpop would have group members with different age ranges, it brings more variety to the group. I don’t know when this trend of only debuting super young group members started. So many people are talented but are told they’re “too old” to be in a group just because they’re in their late 20s. Kahi was amazing
@@dream2020as the standards in all categories changed so it may become a problem in the group if the age gap is big since every small thing these days blows up
This After School line-up with a shoe-string budget nearly upstage SNSD. That was how dope they were......Not to say today's After School line-up isn't good but 2009/2010 After School was best.!
They came out with a concept that was so different from what other girl groups were putting out at the time 😭 They were literally were ahead of their time smh they would’ve been as big as SNSD if Pledis wasn’t so shitty… Same with Pristin
@@Clefaeriii no the actual issue was when they started adding more members after Nana. People started getting less interested because they kept adding new girls & then bekah left, lost their main rapper of the group. That’s when their music started going downhill along with their popularity.
@@karinaaii It was also definitely that, but everyone hated the guts of Uee for her weight and acting, and Lizzy for her attitude and odd sense of humour. There’s lot’s of reasons why the group failed but let’s not turn this into a debate lol
In the 2000s people knew what they were doing. They were the real cvnty legends and the real baddies. They knew who they were. The gold chains, The clothing, The rapping, Screaming, And the dancing, Even the sexiness. Giving the i don’t care vibe. Nowadays people cannot even try one bit to do this. Instead they are left with basic beats to rap with. This is what we call legends forever and ever. -2000s forever
Can you believe this was their debut?? They sound amazing, the dance is on point and they look gorgeous on stage. Such great performers you could never tell they were rookies.
A time when each member of girlgroup has their own unique personal beauty and characters. And they don't mind messy flowing hairs on stage..what made them incredible. Forever After School!
exactly :( Bekah was my fave. after she graduated, i moved to Kahi. then SHE graduated T-T now, my bias is Jung Ah. Original After School still have my heart
this is the original after school. i really love kahi she's very charming and multitalented one. jeoyoon she's such a sweet lady. love both of 'em. wish they could be together like this again. or maybe make a new group with different group name but sama member as this.
They seem to have so much more personality back then. People were able to focus on each and every one of them. Right now they are all styled to look the same and you can't even differentiate who is who anymore. They used to do Jooyeon justice. Right now they just put her at the back
is any after school playgirlz or playboyz still watching this after seeing how kaeun ended up in produce 48 not able to sing in her own group and seeing how kahi has grown so much , seeing her junior put in such situations . idk , seeing how after school grew from this and end up .. underrated af , it's just fucking sad to me
After school has always been one of my faves back then..so sad that most of them already graduated and kahi even got married already. I MISS THIS TIME OF KPOP..BRING THIS ERA OF KPOP BACK TO ME
After School brought the "cool & sexy" game. Now the core members have all left. Such a shame that Pledis didn't take care of the group well. :(
I agree!
not saying pledis doesnt suck at promoting AS (bc they do), but isn't member rotation this group's concept? Members are supposed to "graduate" and be replaced by newer generations
Doesnt matter anyway, I've been following Lizzy on the news and her statements indicates they're getting disbanding soon.
Sigh.
aw fuck thats depressing
So many girl groups disbanding this year. It's a pity!
Sigh I can never properly explain to newer kpop fans the talent rookies had when they debut back in the day. There was no such thing as "they're rookies. Let's wait for them to improve" back then.
And yet they still did like.....I miss the old gen
OK but nowadays the new rookies also have a lot of talent. I feel like y'all are forgetting the (almost) inhumane training and rules kpop idols had back then. So obviously they were much more practiced and well versed.
I honestly don't see the problem in newer groups having to adapt to the idol life at first. I'd much rather watch a group improve over time knowing that they were allowed to have a life than seeing perfect machines (not meant for their personality of course) that had to suffer to get where they are.
That's no hate to older gens tho. I love groups like after school, rania and kara but I can't help but feel sad for their living conditions back then. So keep that in mind next time before you complain.
(Also, is it really necessary to tear others down to bring your fave up? Why can't we just apprechiate what we had instead of comparing? This is about after school and no one else so we shouldn't bring up other groups constantly. We don't like that when new groups do it either)
@quit The Internet exactly....i know who you're talking about and i fully agree there🤐
@quit The Internet i love a few of the members, i used to stan them but i can't lie about vocals
@@gracefire9067 facts everything sounds so auto tuned these days even when they sing live...
kahi served so hard. I love this stage.
I miss the 1st gen of after school, even the 2nd gen was something special to. They were different to the generic groups. Kahi is truly something special. JungAh & bekah stood out so much because of their skill set & appearance. Kahi made after school different, the record label i feel didn't really know how to push & develop the group after she left.
Well said
With Jung Ah's graduation we can sadly say goodbye to the first generation of After School!! Thank u very much for everything!!
+DieSe Lencina Jung Ah left AS?! :O:(
+Josh Collas (Tha Infamous J) yes,she left now. I'm so sad
Yeah that sucks, she was a great singer! One of the best in AS fursure
so sad :'(
Oh shit. Bekah and Kahi might as well have been a duo after they left. they're so damn charismatic with so much stage presence. I also have to agree with so many other comments that this was the best lineup amongst all years.
한국판 푸시캣돌스가 모티브인 팀이었고 가희가 백댄서 출신인 탓에 이갈고 만들었던 팀이었지 몸치, 박치, 음치 3박자였던 이주연을 이 정도까지 끌어올린 것도 다 박가희 덕분
애프터스쿨은 딱 이 멤버가 좋았음. 아니면 유이까지,, 미국 하이틴스쿨 언니들 느낌나고 저 컨셉이 저때는 진짜 획기적이었는데......저때 베카 인기없었는데 막내인데도 진짜 섹시하고 미국배우느낌 개쩜
한국에 푸시캣돌스 컨셉잡고 나와놓고 사장이 갑자기 일뽕 맞았는지 일본 아이돌 졸업 시스템 도입해서 하나둘씩 내보낸거 아직도 웃음벨
Pledis was so brave back then
아직도 애프터스쿨하면 이 노래가 젤 먼저 떠오름.. 역대급 컨셉이었는데ㅠㅜㅜㅜ
The end of 2023 popping in, and gotta say it's so great to see AS rocking it live on debut.
It was such a fun time.
'Ah' was their debut song ?
@@LeeChaeryeong-vv2mr January '09, yes
Unzipping you’re. Benzene Izmir haziness buzzing. Haziness unzipping unzipping you’re. Umbrella
I can see that their core concept was heavily influenced by the pussycat dolls...
yup.They said that in one of their vids.
I love Pussycat Dolls but they didn't invent being sexy
I was thinking the same which sent me in a nostalgia trip and then i saw Girlicious singing Like Me live which has an aesthetic really similar at times
@@multifandomedbutgirlsgener8913 no one said they did but they were famous for it
One of the most iconic debut stage in kpop
This performance was so good. After School has always been a great band. It’s amazing how good they were at their debut, especially when you think their 4 best members weren’t even there yet: Uee, Raina, Nana and Lizzy.
Can we talk about how Kahi was 29 in this performance yet...
Jungah was 27, Jooyeon 22, Sooyoung 23 and Bekah 19 😊
I wish today’s Kpop would have group members with different age ranges, it brings more variety to the group. I don’t know when this trend of only debuting super young group members started. So many people are talented but are told they’re “too old” to be in a group just because they’re in their late 20s. Kahi was amazing
Lianne Barolo I can’t believe Bekah is the youngest in here, her charisma is just wow
@@dream2020as the standards in all categories changed so it may become a problem in the group if the age gap is big since every small thing these days blows up
This After School line-up with a shoe-string budget nearly upstage SNSD. That was how dope they were......Not to say today's After School line-up isn't good but 2009/2010 After School was best.!
LMAO NOT SHOE STRING 😭
That’s what I missed about 2nd Gen groups… a lot of them had a low budget and had to rely on pure talent to sale.
They came out with a concept that was so different from what other girl groups were putting out at the time 😭 They were literally were ahead of their time smh they would’ve been as big as SNSD if Pledis wasn’t so shitty… Same with Pristin
@@karinaaii their budget wasn't really the issue - most of the members, especially Lizzy and Uee, got into way too many reputation-ruining scandals
@@Clefaeriii no the actual issue was when they started adding more members after Nana. People started getting less interested because they kept adding new girls & then bekah left, lost their main rapper of the group. That’s when their music started going downhill along with their popularity.
@@karinaaii It was also definitely that, but everyone hated the guts of Uee for her weight and acting, and Lizzy for her attitude and odd sense of humour. There’s lot’s of reasons why the group failed but let’s not turn this into a debate lol
진짜 연습량 상상이상일것같다 ㅠ 무대만 봐도 보인다 와 …..
In the 2000s people knew what they were doing. They were the real cvnty legends and the real baddies. They knew who they were. The gold chains, The clothing, The rapping, Screaming, And the dancing, Even the sexiness. Giving the i don’t care vibe. Nowadays people cannot even try one bit to do this. Instead they are left with basic beats to rap with. This is what we call legends forever and ever. -2000s forever
지금봐도 세련됨…!!
앺스는 진짜 이때가 레전드였음 잘노는 누나들컨셉
난 진짜 주연누나 실물보고 심정지 올뻔했는데 와 실물 미쳤다 속으로그러면서
어떻게 진짜 그렇게 이쁠수가있지이러면서
진짜이쁨 이주연 누나 다른멤버도이쁜데
They're not old by any means now, but they look soooo young in this vid.
3:16 Yay i can properly hear the amazing adlibs
애프터스쿨 데뷔무대인데 인트로도 파격적으로 주고 넋놓고 보던 기억나는데 벌써 10년 전이네..
they should've stayed like this srsly. what a shame.
I couldn't agree more.
hyunsick Then we'd never have the goddess nana
yesss!!! I guess they could have added Nana as Soyoung and KaEun as Bekah and just go with that
Agreed. The OG After School was the best lineup and should never have changed.
Ok but the orange caramel members are iconic
And plus, Jungah didn't cut it as a main vocal so thank god we had Raina
back then when u could listen to any Kpop song and it would just sound so good ......
이거 생방으로 본게 아직두 기억나네,, 비오던 날이었는데
하나도 안 촌스럽고 이 때 컨셉으로 돌아갔으면 좋겠다ㅠㅠ
이 무대를집에서 보고있던 때가 잊혀지지않는다... 여느때오ㅏ 다름없이 음중을 보고있엇는데 정말 앺터스쿨의
데뷔무대는 놀라웠고 어느새 빠져들고 있었다
가희선생님...너무 멋있다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ괜히 프듀에서 연생들한테 내일이면 할수있겠냐는 말을 한게 아니었어...그건 그렇고 다들 걸크 장난아님 이런 그룹 없었다 증말 ㅠㅠㅠㅜ
이때 부터가 진정한 푸시켓돌스 컨셉인가! 인트로 저 음악 진짜 좋아 했는데 근데 데뷔였네
Can you believe this was their debut?? They sound amazing, the dance is on point and they look gorgeous on stage. Such great performers you could never tell they were rookies.
진짜 멋있다. 노는 언니들의 제대로 무대 너낌쓰.
이정도는 돼야 땡끄탑 입는거구나.... 마른거랑 몸매 좋은거랑 다른건데 까먹고있었다
Loved Afterschool I still miss 2nd generation era. Thank you Kahi and all the members
One of my favorite kpop choreographies ever!
A time when each member of girlgroup has their own unique personal beauty and characters. And they don't mind messy flowing hairs on stage..what made them incredible. Forever After School!
The best lineup of After School ever. The lineup in Because Of Your era was also good though. But this will be always the best lineup of AS.
ga hee's abs are everything
I MISS THE FIRST GENERATION OF AFTERSCHOOL IM SO EMOTIONAL
No group can match the charisma and sexiness of this group.
진짜 추억여행 간만에 하고간다...
다이어트 자극영상
I love After School so much. I miss this style and talent so much
the MELANIN gosh.... I miss when idols weren’t covered in paper white makeup and allowed to embrace the melanin they have, it’s beautiful
Wow, After School debut stage rocks!!
damn bekah's body is banging
I MISS THEM SO MUCH. THEY ARE MY GIRLGROUP
so sad that all of them left afterschool :(
and now jungah is the only 1st generation left :")
Plus Jooyeon
Candy Too Jooyeon graduated.
can u believe, only two of the members still in the group now. !!!
exactly :( Bekah was my fave. after she graduated, i moved to Kahi. then SHE graduated T-T now, my bias is Jung Ah. Original After School still have my heart
Yeah. But I think the group is so much better not, except the fact that Kahi isn't there any more. :(
WHAT?!!! Who is it?
Really. MOG, I didn't know, so sad!):
+iduncare21 I've got bad news for you...
이때가멋잇엇는뎁ㅠ!!!노래도 컨셉도 세련됫어!ㅋ
Kahi has an incredible stage presence that sometimes the other members looks like back dancers :/
This was the best line-up of afterschool
This makes me miss old kpop more… please bring this music back. Is it because they want to follow the gen or they just aren’t allowed to 😭
Unzipping you’re. Benzodiazepines haziness. Umbrella umbrella. Haziness unzipping unzipping you’re. Haziness unzipping unzipping you’re unzipping unzipping haziness unzipping unzipping you’re. Gnocchi’s. Haziness unzipping unzipping you’re haziness. Unzipping unzipping. You’re
Bekah I miss you! :(
투애니원이랑 앱스가 여돌 레전드 데뷔무대같음..
Seeing it on 2016 like goddamn, none of them still in the group, miss 1st gen of as!
This was my favorite grouping of them. When Kahi, Jung ah and Bekah was in together!
I think this is the “cool and sexy” concept base. Afterschool had it. Shinee and Super Junior had it back then.
i love after school member kahi she is so sweet looking
2 rappers and the rest are vocals, best group ever! Miss this old team!
진짜 멋있어 오늘도 오랜만에 보고감 가희 언니 한국 들어 왔다는 기사보고 드릉드릉 중
Kpop needs another group like this
I discovered them when I was 11 years old (2011). Now I'm 20 and I love them forever.
One of the best things that happened to kpop ♡
Jungah's rap is ♥.
Amazing debut stage! After School #1
for me uee,nana,raina and lizzy are original members because uee nana and raina debuted in 2009 and lizzy are froom 3rd generation too
The debut days of After School ❤️
This was the reason they were known as the pussycat dolls of Korea. Miss them
can u believe that this stage is from 10 years ago? damn why i old so fast
no one can do it like kahi and bekah did
Kahi still has the best abs in Kpop
Quite good for their debut song. Some debut sogns are so lame xD
so true! love this song. they came out with a wow and a bang
I'm here because Yerin said she wanted to try this concept
주연이 훗날 이거 보고 카메라 원샷 한번이 없어서 충격받았다고 했는데 정말 원샷 자체가 없네....?
Happy aniverssary 7°
13th now
This song has been stuck in my head and it’s 2020
wow I can actually here their live voices in this performance, the background vocals are not loud and obscuring the live voices.
this is the original after school. i really love kahi she's very charming and multitalented one. jeoyoon she's such a sweet lady. love both of 'em. wish they could be together like this again. or maybe make a new group with different group name but sama member as this.
Sooyoung was my bias this gen.....i really pity her TT TT she should have stayed for at least 2 years TT TT
After school started a TREND that no one else had seen before e
They seem to have so much more personality back then. People were able to focus on each and every one of them. Right now they are all styled to look the same and you can't even differentiate who is who anymore.
They used to do Jooyeon justice. Right now they just put her at the back
Sun-kissed skin era. 🌞
Jooyeon !!!!!!!!!!!!
is any after school playgirlz or playboyz still watching this after seeing how kaeun ended up in produce 48 not able to sing in her own group and seeing how kahi has grown so much , seeing her junior put in such situations . idk , seeing how after school grew from this and end up .. underrated af , it's just fucking sad to me
orjust watching this clearly cus they miss after school
I miss so much this after school😭😭😭
POWER
Love their tan skin.
After school has always been one of my faves back then..so sad that most of them already graduated and kahi even got married already. I MISS THIS TIME OF KPOP..BRING THIS ERA OF KPOP BACK TO ME
cvnty from debut
Kahi is body goals
KAHI, is all I gotta say lol She looks so good in this performance!
이때로 돌아와줭 ㅠㅠㅠ
this is still on my current and popular playlist.. i miss afterschool ;a; and og groups
1:09 저 볼터치를 왜 저따구로 해놨노.... 사람을 바보로 만들어놓고
Kahi's a badass
they really are ab goals
I love this ..bcz the confidence on their face,💖💖💖💖💖
They were rookies but this confidence is 💖