Yes lakin Mari search ma mutabak ya bi confirm ni ka Osman ki sirf ak bati thi. Mana chatgpt sa is question ka ana posha to pata Chala ka Kai jaga par ya bi likha ha ka Osman ki ak bati halima bi thi lakin confirm ni is Lia hum ya yaqeen sa ni kah sakta ka halima name ki Osman ki koi bati thi hi ni
Bala fans want fairy tales , that's why there is fictional daughter , Halime . Children want Rapunzel , so Bozdag gave the children some fun. The scriptwriters have nothing to extend the series and they write nonsense. 😂😂😂
Yes lakin Mari search ma mutabak ya bi confirm ni ka Osman ki sirf ak bati thi. Mana chatgpt sa is question ka ana posha to pata Chala ka Kai jaga par ya bi likha ha ka Osman ki ak bati halima bi thi lakin confirm ni is Lia hum ya yaqeen sa ni kah sakta ka halima name ki Osman ki koi bati thi hi ni
Halima ki kahani rapunzel se milti julti h jaise ki prensses ko chori kar leti h apne faide ke liye wase hi sufiya ne chori kar liya halima ko apne faide ke liya
o pagaloo malhoon ki bati fatima or bala ki bati halima ja ka h fatima hold halima proof in this vedio th-cam.com/video/DwrAOTrVTGs/w-d-xo.htmlsi=aGfKOFoBOhsxfXqk
Bhai galat history kyu bata rahe ho ottman empire ki pehli shehzadi ka naam halima tha or unki daadi ka naam bhi Halima sultan tha mere paas saboot hai iska
Gunduz had a daughter named Halime Bala and Osman grew her Bala had three sons Ahmet - oldest adopted Alaeddin Orhan Sultan Everyone believes that Orhan is Malhun Hatuns child and accepts it in the series Malhun Hatun is the only mother Sultan Orhan had alive for two years of being Sultan He never gave Malhun the Valide Sultan title because she is not his mother Nulifer was the first Valide Sultan Giving Bala another child in the series Boy or girl Why is it unacceptable
Malhun was the mother of Orhan. You are liying. I have already written to you that there is historical document of Orhan foundation from 1324 which mentions his mother Mal Hatun , Umer's Bey daughter and her children Fatma / only one Osman's daughter/ Pazarli, Melik, Hamid and Coban . There is no Bala or Aladdin in this Orhan's documentary. Bala lived with Osman for only 10 years , then with her father Sheihk Edebali for the rest of her life. Bala had only Aladdin who was a dervish , not first vizier . The first vizier was Aladdin Pasha , son of Haci Kemaladdin from the city of Cendere . Check out The viziers of the Ottoman Empire. . If Orhan was the Sultan , then Malhun was the Valide , but the Valide titles were later granted.
@ So why wasn’t she given Valide Sultan by Orhan She was the only parent alive when he became Sultan Nulifer in history is the first Valide Sultan She was Murat 1 mother You accept or stay in denial If you check Suleiman Sultan’s records It is written there that Bala is Orhans mother
@@christinereynolds4376 I am talking about Orhan's historical documents, with HIS SEAL /TUGHRA/ from 1324 . Document found by historian Ismail Hakki Uzuncarsili and approved by the Turkish History Society. Either you accept it or you don't. Tell me, what historical document of Suleiman , where it is written that Bala is Orhan's mother? You rely only on medieval historians who wrote legends. Me on historical documents. Don't write if you have nothing to rely on.
@ Back then there were no records Mongols Byzantine and Dervish had records of Osman and Bala It was thought Malhun was Osman first wife and Alaeddin was eight years younger than Orhan too It not just about Malhun not being Orhans mother The whole thing on Bala was wrong She was Osman first and only love Orhan was born when he married Malhun It is assumed that Malhun was his mother Well Orhan cleared it when she was not given the Valide - mother of the Sultan title She was the only one alive Bala and Osman Sheikh Edibali passed within three months of each other
@@christinereynolds4376 I wrote to you that the title Valide was first used later. Only in the 16th century for the mother of Suleiman, Ayse Hafsa Sultan. There was no such title before . Orhan could not give this title to his mother because there was no such title.
@renatabrutel-tuczko1461 you learn history from fake documentaries I learnt history from sultan Abdul Hamit han's grand daughter and she cleared it that there was no character of malhun in history separately. This was the full name of bala as Rabia Bala Malhun hatun. And even if you watch old kuruluş Osman series you can see they show malhun as sheikh edabli's daughter. Even there is no grave of malhun. And that's why series start without malhun and series will end without malhun. In history it's clearly written that sheikh edabli use to call her malhun and Osman use to call her bala. And her childrens call her as malhun ana. She was one and only wife of Osman and mother to all his childrens and first valide sultan of Ottoman Empire.
@user_11jsgduwka0 Orhan's historical document from 1324 from his seal /Tughra/. This is very important document . This is Act of Fundation for the Dervish Monastery in Mekece , in which Orhan mentions his father Osman , his mothe Mal Hatun , daughter Umer Bey and their children Fatma, Pazarli, Melik, Hamid, Coban.
Good video, there is no halima. I knew it❤
Yes Halima hatun Or Fatima hatun bala hatun ye 3 actors Favourite hain
Yes halima favrt hai
Yes halime ❤❤is my favourite
Yes Halima is my favourite character ❤
Yes lakin Mari search ma mutabak ya bi confirm ni ka Osman ki sirf ak bati thi. Mana chatgpt sa is question ka ana posha to pata Chala ka Kai jaga par ya bi likha ha ka Osman ki ak bati halima bi thi lakin confirm ni is Lia hum ya yaqeen sa ni kah sakta ka halima name ki Osman ki koi bati thi hi ni
Video start at 1:50
😂😂
Yes Halima hating Or Fatima hatun bala hatun ye 3 actors Favourite hain
Bala fans want fairy tales , that's why there is fictional daughter , Halime . Children want Rapunzel , so Bozdag gave the children some fun. The scriptwriters have nothing to extend the series and they write nonsense. 😂😂😂
Right brother 🔥
True 😂
malhuns fictional and halime is aswell so take those words back bozdag gave unnecessary importance to malhun nowonder he never replaced her back
@user_11jsgduwka0. Go and research. Malhun is state mother. Mother of orhon. Not only in series but in reality..
Halima❤❤❤🥰🥰👍
Fatima is best ❤❤
Yes halima is my favorite
Yes❤
Yes
Halime tha
Fatma halima dono achi hai or bala hatun laaagawab
I like her! I think when she remembers everything all of Osman’s children will be unstoppable!
I love bala I love old halima miss you altan❤
تحریک لبیک پاکستان زندہ باد سعد حسین رضوی زندہ باد پاکستانیوں کی امید تحریک لبیک پاکستان زندہ باد
Yes Halima is my favourite❤❤❤❤. please jaldi aplode ker dai video jis mai Halima ko Bala ka pata lag Jata Hai
Tarikhi beti Fathima
Yes lakin Mari search ma mutabak ya bi confirm ni ka Osman ki sirf ak bati thi. Mana chatgpt sa is question ka ana posha to pata Chala ka Kai jaga par ya bi likha ha ka Osman ki ak bati halima bi thi lakin confirm ni is Lia hum ya yaqeen sa ni kah sakta ka halima name ki Osman ki koi bati thi hi ni
❤❤❤❤
Halima ki kahani rapunzel se milti julti h jaise ki prensses ko chori kar leti h apne faide ke liye wase hi sufiya ne chori kar liya halima ko apne faide ke liya
This is not correct that halima is not real there is her grave in Turkey halima and Fatima both are real.
How do u know??
Halime hatun was osman ghazis mother that's why there is another grave
Halima ❤❤❤❤
Bhai direct btadety yyehe btana tha to itni lmbi kyunn ki. Ek video ayse dikhake paise bnaogy to log achi videos bhi dekhna chordengy.
Yaar ho sakya hai ki halime sachme ho bala ki beti tarikdaan uska history likhna kisi wahah se bhool gaye ho kuch bhi possible ho sakta hai
Toh Bozdag Saaab Ko kaisy History PATA chal gayi?😁
@@Razdaartvhe goes in time travel 😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
1:50 story start
Nhi thi halima bi🤪🤪🤪🤪🤪😂😂😂
Halima nam ki koi beti nhi thi sirf fatima aik hi beti thi history may ,ye production walo ki creation hy sirf drama may drama peda krne k lye ok
Yes, exactly.
Video starts at 2:30 hahaha
Yes it's really history
Fictional character 😂
Bakwas band karne Bhoonk ra hai
th-cam.com/video/A5bAlw3AW-Q/w-d-xo.htmlsi=LzzP_MD_S5DosrWm
o pagaloo malhoon ki bati fatima or bala ki bati halima ja ka h fatima hold halima proof in this vedio th-cam.com/video/DwrAOTrVTGs/w-d-xo.htmlsi=aGfKOFoBOhsxfXqk
Jhoot bolre tu
fake daughter
Bhai galat history kyu bata rahe ho ottman empire ki pehli shehzadi ka naam halima tha or unki daadi ka naam bhi Halima sultan tha mere paas saboot hai iska
???
Are you mad?
To saboot ka link bhjeo
Tumhe kuch pata bhi hai
Season 4 mein halim ke bachpan ka character dikhaya jaaye
Jhooth bolraha hai re tu
Gunduz had a daughter named Halime
Bala and Osman grew her
Bala had three sons
Ahmet - oldest adopted
Alaeddin
Orhan Sultan
Everyone believes that Orhan is Malhun Hatuns child and accepts it in the series
Malhun Hatun is the only mother Sultan Orhan had alive for two years of being Sultan
He never gave Malhun the Valide Sultan title because she is not his mother
Nulifer was the first Valide Sultan
Giving Bala another child in the series
Boy or girl
Why is it unacceptable
Malhun was the mother of Orhan. You are liying. I have already written to you that there is historical document of Orhan foundation from 1324 which mentions his mother Mal Hatun , Umer's Bey daughter and her children Fatma / only one Osman's daughter/ Pazarli, Melik, Hamid and Coban . There is no Bala or Aladdin in this Orhan's documentary. Bala lived with Osman for only 10 years , then with her father Sheihk Edebali for the rest of her life. Bala had only Aladdin who was a dervish , not first vizier . The first vizier was Aladdin Pasha , son of Haci Kemaladdin from the city of Cendere . Check out The viziers of the Ottoman Empire. . If Orhan was the Sultan , then Malhun was the Valide , but the Valide titles were later granted.
@
So why wasn’t she given Valide Sultan by Orhan
She was the only parent alive when he became Sultan
Nulifer in history is the first Valide Sultan
She was Murat 1 mother
You accept or stay in denial
If you check Suleiman Sultan’s records
It is written there that Bala is Orhans mother
@@christinereynolds4376 I am talking about Orhan's historical documents, with HIS SEAL /TUGHRA/ from 1324 . Document found by historian Ismail Hakki Uzuncarsili and approved by the Turkish History Society. Either you accept it or you don't. Tell me, what historical document of Suleiman , where it is written that Bala is Orhan's mother? You rely only on medieval historians who wrote legends. Me on historical documents. Don't write if you have nothing to rely on.
@
Back then there were no records
Mongols
Byzantine and
Dervish had records of Osman and Bala
It was thought Malhun was Osman first wife and Alaeddin was eight years younger than Orhan too
It not just about Malhun not being Orhans mother
The whole thing on Bala was wrong
She was Osman first and only love
Orhan was born when he married Malhun
It is assumed that Malhun was his mother
Well Orhan cleared it when she was not given the Valide - mother of the Sultan title
She was the only one alive
Bala and Osman Sheikh Edibali passed within three months of each other
@@christinereynolds4376 I wrote to you that the title Valide was first used later. Only in the 16th century for the mother of Suleiman, Ayse Hafsa Sultan. There was no such title before . Orhan could not give this title to his mother because there was no such title.
Fake video
Malhun and halime both are fictional
Malhun is first Osman's wife , the mother of Orhan. Halime is fictional.
@@renatabrutel-tuczko1461 Proof? Malhun and Halime are both fictionap
@renatabrutel-tuczko1461 you learn history from fake documentaries I learnt history from sultan Abdul Hamit han's grand daughter and she cleared it that there was no character of malhun in history separately. This was the full name of bala as Rabia Bala Malhun hatun. And even if you watch old kuruluş Osman series you can see they show malhun as sheikh edabli's daughter. Even there is no grave of malhun. And that's why series start without malhun and series will end without malhun. In history it's clearly written that sheikh edabli use to call her malhun and Osman use to call her bala. And her childrens call her as malhun ana. She was one and only wife of Osman and mother to all his childrens and first valide sultan of Ottoman Empire.
@user_11jsgduwka0 Orhan's historical document from 1324 from his seal /Tughra/. This is very important document . This is Act of Fundation for the Dervish Monastery in Mekece , in which Orhan mentions his father Osman , his mothe Mal Hatun , daughter Umer Bey and their children Fatma, Pazarli, Melik, Hamid, Coban.
@renatabrutel-tuczko1461 🤦🏻bala's full name was Rabia Bala Malhun
Yes Halima hating Or Fatima hatun bala hatun ye 3 actors Favourite hain
Fatima is best❤
1:50 story start
Halima❤❤❤❤❤❤
Yes Halima hating Or Fatima hatun bala hatun ye 3 actors Favourite hain