This Rabbi was a breath of fresh air and should be the type of person people listen to and take from his wisdom. Even at his age he is so elegant and on point and sounds like a wonderful human being.
I just had to play the impossible game with how it would make me feel and what reality would teach me, if they need help in the games where was their input or advice?
@tzvischonthal6589 if anything he is the most rabbi. We on the other hand are sinful to the ignorance to the crimes zionist terorists are inflicting on humanity
Personally, I prefer the Dalai Lama. Speaking of which, I wonder why the world's most powerful dictator Xi hasn't received a warrant for Uyghurs and Tibetans? ;)
@@leelhasa6294 condoning the arrest warrant of netanyahu doesnt mean youre condemning the hypothetical arrest of other world leaders who have industrialised human rights abuses under their administration. unconditional support for western leaders simply because they are western is a grossly simplified way to “care” about geopolitics. and pointing fingers at your enemies to downplay a situation a western superpower is solely responsible for is deluded levels of what-about ism.
I don't know why I will ask, is it possible to be Zionists and still believe in 2 states solution and give Palestine the right to exist as an equal state? Or is it that all Zionists want the whole land only for themselves? I am asking because from what I read there were many places where the first Zionists wanted to create a Jewish state ( including Siberia) so I assume as long as Israel exists there shouldn't be an issue for traditional Zionist to other states existing next to them?
@@tataritkaZionism has gone through different levels of evolution but the common factor is ethno supremacy. Now we have revisionist Zionism which such as Givr and Smootrich subscribe to. Not all Jews support this ideology and it's losing its appeal in the united states among Jews but then the US has right wing fundamentalist Zionist Christians that outnumber Jewish zionists
It's not so much that they have an issue of states existing next to them, it's that they want certain parts of close to all countries that are around them right now. Its a project called "Greater Israel" and it includes parts of Egypt, Syria, Lebanon...by some accounts parts of Saudi Arabia as well. So no, zionists will never accept Palestinian state because it stands in opposition to plans for greater Israel. Based on international law West Bank belongs to Palestinian people but they will annex it next year as well as north of Gaza or maybe the whole Gaza.
@@tataritka yes u could be a zionist and advocate for the 2 state solution which are referred to as liberal/progressive zionists , the only problem here is that the 2 state solution in how its presented denies the palestinians the right of return , as in : u have ur sovereign country now so no more talk abt refugees going back home , which is a constant demand and aspiration a of the palestinian people , inbeded in them , and many would percieve giving up that right that palestinians yearned and fought for for yers a big concession , and then there s israel ofc categorically refuses the right of return of the palestinians because that would automatically compromise its jewish identity , so people have a genuine problem with the concept of issrael as an ethno religious state and it strikes them that any random european jew is given free pass and free citizenchip ans sometimes a house while ur're adament to never let pals set foot in there , i mean some say palestinians now are the weaker side , and whatever autonomy they get its better than wats happening here
Posting a comment to boost the algorithm. There are plenty of us who agree with the rabbi. I wish more people could see this instead of the other stuff put out there.
Rabbi Geoffrey/Jeffrey is the loveliest thing I've experienced all year! Wisdom, compassion, humor, intellect. I could have listened to him all day. ...and I'm agnostic!!
I've heard Orthodox Jews in New York saying similar things. These people are all that keeps me thinking that there might be a very small light at the end of the tunnel❤
Brilliant conversation. The rabbi was marvellous and James did a great job in his responses and in his choice of questions. Both skilled speakers and nice fellows.
What a beautiful soul the Rabbi caller has. Love pours out of every word that leaves his mouth.He is a wonderful example for me and no doubt many others.♥♥♥
Isn't it more reasonable to suspect authoritarians are coordinating against democracies? You know, like Russia in Ukraine; China preparing for Taiwan and er, Iran using its proxy to provoke strong response and hide behind its people - thus weakening Western support for only democratic outpost in Middle East? I can't help but feel like that might be a much stronger voice of reason.
Cue the collective howl of 'Kapo' that will reverberate across northwest London as word of this Rabbi's phone call gets out. If I'd have had a Rabbi like this in my formative years, I might have ended up being a lifelong attender at shul instead of the secular Jew that I am. Respect to you Rabbi for your bravery in speaking up on such a public platform.
My biggest concern with this particular clip, is that it's titled extraordinary. Why would this rabbi's opinion be considered extraordinary? That is a shameful indictment of society that respect for the rule of international law is extraordinary.
"The Palestinian struggle is not just a cry for justice. It’s a blistering battle for the most fundamental human rights that every living soul on this planet should inherit by birthright. It’s an unyielding resistance against the oppressive, suffocating grip of occupation and the callous denial of the most basic human dignity ... The battle for justice in Palestine is not merely a political struggle. It's an elemental moral battle ... If you're not careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed and loving the people who are doing the oppressing. I implore every person of conscience, regardless of their origins or beliefs, to stand steadfast with the Palestinian people in their unwavering quest for justice." - attributed to Malcolm X
Because it might be a sham trial somewhat? You know, what with the world's biggest tyranny and human rights abusers in Beijing warping global institutions in their favour? That might be the reason Winnie Xi Pooh doesn't get a warrant for Uyghurs and Tibetans? Do yus think?
Over here in Indonesia it's common knowledge of the distinction between Judaism and Zionism regardless of our religion and ethnicity. The latter being basically the anithesis of Judaism and rejected by those truly faithful to Judaism, if not by most people in the world. Unlike the majority western consensus view, we don't assume every Jewish person to agree nor support the Zionist state of Israel.
I would’ve never felt such humanity between two men if I hadn’t watched until the end. The respect/love we can show each other on the progressive side is incomparable on the right. Proud to be a fan of James here in cold Minnesota USA💙
I think TH-cam does it on purpose...They either crackle the sound or cut to commercial at the juiciest part of conversations that bare the truth ✌🏻✌🏻✌🏻
@@itcouldbelupus2842 i keep getting jenovah witness ads even though I'm not very religious and don't go to church much. Don't know how their ad system works
Cute that no matter how old you are, the respect and admiration of someone older than you creates the same reaction. For a moment James seemed like a young man basking in the pride of a father. 😊
That was beautiful. I'm sure he represents many, many other Jewish people too. In fact I've heard others speaking in a similar way. Fear is the easiest of all emotions to stoke up and fear so very quickly turns into anger if not understood. We've seen it used to stir up people here many times in the last few years. Thank you to this lovely fella and the many others like him, whose voices are crowded out my mainstream media and the public debate, as if they don't matter.
I grew up in Los Angeles , adjacent to a Jewish neighborhood and my christian single-parent father was employed by a jewish pharmacy owner.this man helped my father buy his first and only house because, ‘children need a home to grow up in’. Like this Rabbi, this is always how I saw jewish people. Gaza has been a profiund shick to me and I struggle now to resist painting world jewry with Israels actions. And the thing that helps me most with that are my jewish brothers & sisters who oppose Gaza and Zionism and Netanyahu, its High priest.
So nice to hear from the rabbi. Just wish that the Americans and other western leaders would listen to respected individuals like this and realise that being anti zionist isn't anti semitic
Hmmm, will James call on his buddies Starmer and Lammy to actually do anything about this? Maybe some sanctions and actual consequences for Israel? Remember when Starmer said “I think Israel does have that right”, he is complicit and works against peace at every turn.
I would think he will soon; seeing how even the RW Governments of Italy and the Netherlands have said they will uphold the ICC arrest warrant. I have a feeling Starmer will try his best to sit on the fence.
@@readwithcareplease22 And Starmer has been backing Israel since before he was in power, what does that matter. He is in power now and he is bought but the Israel lobby and people like James never ever call out Labours continued support of Israel.
Blessed are the peacemakers
❤❤❤
I think you mean cheesemakers
@@FahadAyaz don't think it's specifically cheesemakers, but any manufacturer of dairy products.
@@davidseago cheese is delicious though 😋
@@FahadAyaz Cheesemakers who can make peace or peacemakers who can make cheese equally welcome
This Rabbi was a breath of fresh air and should be the type of person people listen to and take from his wisdom. Even at his age he is so elegant and on point and sounds like a wonderful human being.
He's not a rabbi at all
@@tzvischonthal6589 And why is that? Because he doesn't support the government?
I just had to play the impossible game with how it would make me feel and what reality would teach me, if they need help in the games where was their input or advice?
@@tzvischonthal6589 🤡
@tzvischonthal6589 if anything he is the most rabbi. We on the other hand are sinful to the ignorance to the crimes zionist terorists are inflicting on humanity
"I'm a rabbi" You're also a human being, which is why you were trying to help other humans.
What a lovely guy, this is how spiritual leaders should sound. Thank you Rabbi.
Personally, I prefer the Dalai Lama. Speaking of which, I wonder why the world's most powerful dictator Xi hasn't received a warrant for Uyghurs and Tibetans? ;)
@@leelhasa6294 condoning the arrest warrant of netanyahu doesnt mean youre condemning the hypothetical arrest of other world leaders who have industrialised human rights abuses under their administration. unconditional support for western leaders simply because they are western is a grossly simplified way to “care” about geopolitics. and pointing fingers at your enemies to downplay a situation a western superpower is solely responsible for is deluded levels of what-about ism.
@@leelhasa6294 same reason why Joe Biden, Obama, Putin, Modhi, Mohammed Bin Salman, and Emanuel Macron didn't
@@leelhasa6294Try again.
Bless him, what a lovely human ❤
Speaks volumes when the Israeli government would not allow a Rabbi to assist Palestinian refugees.
what a fantastic man!!!!! more people like this the world needs!!!!!
Mind Begs the Question:
▪︎If in a World
▪︎Imposing Apartheid - Democratic
▪︎Opposing Apartheid - Terrorism
▪︎Civilized World or Dystopian World?
The Rabbi made me tear up a little...ok cry
"We are a traumatized people"
I am an Afro-Brazilian who understands that perfectly
What a gentleman!
Completely!!
❤
Completely!!
❤
Obviously the Rabbi is not a Zionist.
I don't know why I will ask, is it possible to be Zionists and still believe in 2 states solution and give Palestine the right to exist as an equal state? Or is it that all Zionists want the whole land only for themselves? I am asking because from what I read there were many places where the first Zionists wanted to create a Jewish state ( including Siberia) so I assume as long as Israel exists there shouldn't be an issue for traditional Zionist to other states existing next to them?
@@tataritkaZionism has gone through different levels of evolution but the common factor is ethno supremacy.
Now we have revisionist Zionism which such as Givr and Smootrich subscribe to.
Not all Jews support this ideology and it's losing its appeal in the united states among Jews but then the US has right wing fundamentalist Zionist Christians that outnumber Jewish zionists
It's not so much that they have an issue of states existing next to them, it's that they want certain parts of close to all countries that are around them right now.
Its a project called "Greater Israel" and it includes parts of Egypt, Syria, Lebanon...by some accounts parts of Saudi Arabia as well.
So no, zionists will never accept Palestinian state because it stands in opposition to plans for greater Israel.
Based on international law West Bank belongs to Palestinian people but they will annex it next year as well as north of Gaza or maybe the whole Gaza.
@@tataritka yes u could be a zionist and advocate for the 2 state solution which are referred to as liberal/progressive zionists , the only problem here is that the 2 state solution in how its presented denies the palestinians the right of return , as in : u have ur sovereign country now so no more talk abt refugees going back home , which is a constant demand and aspiration a of the palestinian people , inbeded in them , and many would percieve giving up that right that palestinians yearned and fought for for yers a big concession , and then there s israel ofc categorically refuses the right of return of the palestinians because that would automatically compromise its jewish identity , so people have a genuine problem with the concept of issrael as an ethno religious state and it strikes them that any random european jew is given free pass and free citizenchip ans sometimes a house while ur're adament to never let pals set foot in there , i mean some say palestinians now are the weaker side , and whatever autonomy they get its better than wats happening here
Not necessarily. Zionism means different things to different people as it has no universally accepted definition.
Blessed Thankyou Rabbi Peace Gdspeed
Posting a comment to boost the algorithm. There are plenty of us who agree with the rabbi. I wish more people could see this instead of the other stuff put out there.
What a magnificent human being. A breath of fresh air.
U know the mans spitting fire and facts when James doesnt interrupt
Fantastic call what a lovely man!
What an inspiring man. I could listen to his perspective on the world all day.
Rabbi Geoffrey/Jeffrey is the loveliest thing I've experienced all year! Wisdom, compassion, humor, intellect. I could have listened to him all day.
...and I'm agnostic!!
I am agnostic also, Love what he says❤❤❤❤❤
The ICC's issuance of an arrest warrant for Netanyahu could not be more justified.
I've heard Orthodox Jews in New York saying similar things. These people are all that keeps me thinking that there might be a very small light at the end of the tunnel❤
It's a strange place to be where we're relying on the mercy of some random New Yorkers rather than the swift arm of justice.
Because: Anti-zionism ≠ anti-semitism
A wonderful and articulate contributor
This is my experience of the wonderful Jewish community in London what a joy to listen to Jeffery thanks so much
@@bridgetthornton8292 because Anti-zionism ≠ anti-semitism
Brilliant conversation. The rabbi was marvellous and James did a great job in his responses and in his choice of questions. Both skilled speakers and nice fellows.
He's just saying what any sane person would. It's wild that a person saying those things is seen as radical.
I guess now we all know why they closed that TV station down in Isreal… History would speak louder
And took control of social media. Facebook is useless now that it's being blocked for saying anything supportive of Palestine
Thank you, Rabbi and James ❤❤🙏🏻🙏🏻
What an amazing gentleman.
Rabbi Jeffrey, you are a beautiful human. This world desperately needs more gently wise people like you.
I wish you much health and happiness.
Congratulations James on getting the Rabbi on your show-what a refreshing contribution.Thankyou
Many Israelis support that. Like me.
What a beautiful soul the Rabbi caller has. Love pours out of every word that leaves his mouth.He is a wonderful example for me and no doubt many others.♥♥♥
❤❤❤ Again my admiration for James, the wonderful Rabbi who understands true humanity.
Admiration for James o Brian..!!!
Hahahahahahah😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Great conversation, important perspective 👏🏼
"That's when I realized I'm a rabbi, not a politician" This was a beautiful call, thank you.
What a wonderful caller
beautiful, truthful and compassionate conversation between two men of goodwill
Voice of reason...
Isn't it more reasonable to suspect authoritarians are coordinating against democracies? You know, like Russia in Ukraine; China preparing for Taiwan and er, Iran using its proxy to provoke strong response and hide behind its people - thus weakening Western support for only democratic outpost in Middle East? I can't help but feel like that might be a much stronger voice of reason.
Many thanks James.This was one of the finest hours I've ever heard on radio. I'm in my 60s.
What a decent human being. Not a fan of any type of religion, but this man sounds like a lovely person.
Yes, never again meant for anyone.
What a pure soul of a gentleman this rabbi is
Refreshing
Cue the collective howl of 'Kapo' that will reverberate across northwest London as word of this Rabbi's phone call gets out. If I'd have had a Rabbi like this in my formative years, I might have ended up being a lifelong attender at shul instead of the secular Jew that I am. Respect to you Rabbi for your bravery in speaking up on such a public platform.
This man really does embody the Biblical saying "Blessed are the peacemakers".
Where is Sangita?
Can we have her back please.
Exactly 💯 %
My biggest concern with this particular clip, is that it's titled extraordinary. Why would this rabbi's opinion be considered extraordinary? That is a shameful indictment of society that respect for the rule of international law is extraordinary.
You are 100% right!
"The Palestinian struggle is not just a cry for justice. It’s a blistering battle for the most fundamental human rights that every living soul on this planet should inherit by birthright. It’s an unyielding resistance against the oppressive, suffocating grip of occupation and the callous denial of the most basic human dignity ... The battle for justice in Palestine is not merely a political struggle. It's an elemental moral battle ... If you're not careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed and loving the people who are doing the oppressing. I implore every person of conscience, regardless of their origins or beliefs, to stand steadfast with the Palestinian people in their unwavering quest for justice."
- attributed to Malcolm X
The rabbi needs to be careful, otherwise the Israeli government will accuse him of being antisemitic.
This was really touching.
A man of immense wisdom, lets hope someone is listening!..
Seems like a very nice old gent to have a conversation with
We are blessed to have such a human being on this earth. Humanity is alive !!
Rabbi is a lion of men.
hear hear, sir!!!! 👏👏
A Remarkable caller 👏
How do We Never Learn from those who came before us ?
Nice mr rabbi words of peace and international law
When humanity, decency, and sanity are seen as "progressive" or radical. . .the world is in big big trouble.
If Netanyahu et al are innocent then they shouldn't be afraid to be arrested and prosecuted where their innocence can be proven
Because it might be a sham trial somewhat? You know, what with the world's biggest tyranny and human rights abusers in Beijing warping global institutions in their favour? That might be the reason Winnie Xi Pooh doesn't get a warrant for Uyghurs and Tibetans? Do yus think?
Over here in Indonesia it's common knowledge of the distinction between Judaism and Zionism regardless of our religion and ethnicity. The latter being basically the anithesis of Judaism and rejected by those truly faithful to Judaism, if not by most people in the world. Unlike the majority western consensus view, we don't assume every Jewish person to agree nor support the Zionist state of Israel.
We need more people like this
Respect and love to all real Jews who stand against Zionism
Such a lovely warm hearted human being 💜
May Allah bless this wonderful man. His heart is in the right place.
What a lovely human being.
a great contributor.
We have a hope until some honest people like this Rabbi exists in this world.
Lovely man
Your channel is not just a source of information, it is a source of inspiration and motivation. Thank you for your creativity and effort!🥝✊🌎
A breath of fresh air, thank you Rabbi!
I would’ve never felt such humanity between two men if I hadn’t watched until the end. The respect/love we can show each other on the progressive side is incomparable on the right. Proud to be a fan of James here in cold Minnesota USA💙
Great Rabbi🎉Keep it up man❤
What a wonderful human being that rabbi is.
People like this rabbi gives me faith in people.
Love this Rabbi, thanks for your humanity.
A sane and decent Rabbi, who can see whta Netanyahu is doing,
What a lovely Rabbi❤ Respect👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
That gentleman doesn't need religion, he is more humane, and wiser than anything found in any 'holy book'
Top guy. Love this
Thank you Rabbi for restoring my faith in humanity
James, the Rabbi paid you a much deserved complement.
Really really inappropriate time for an ad to interrupt a video...
I think TH-cam does it on purpose...They either crackle the sound or cut to commercial at the juiciest part of conversations that bare the truth ✌🏻✌🏻✌🏻
It's YT, they control where, when and how many
@@itcouldbelupus2842 i keep getting jenovah witness ads even though I'm not very religious and don't go to church much. Don't know how their ad system works
Cute that no matter how old you are, the respect and admiration of someone older than you creates the same reaction. For a moment James seemed like a young man basking in the pride of a father. 😊
The type of person who should lead, full of wisdom and calmness. But yet look at the types of people we elect the world over
Wondeful man
I'm not religious, but I recognise a deeply "spiritual" man
That was beautiful. I'm sure he represents many, many other Jewish people too. In fact I've heard others speaking in a similar way. Fear is the easiest of all emotions to stoke up and fear so very quickly turns into anger if not understood. We've seen it used to stir up people here many times in the last few years. Thank you to this lovely fella and the many others like him, whose voices are crowded out my mainstream media and the public debate, as if they don't matter.
This was refreshing to hear. Thank you for sharing a perspective that we don't really hear in maintream media.
What a beautiful man.❤
What a don. Sounds like a top man in all respects.
Well said Rabbi.
I grew up in Los Angeles , adjacent to a Jewish neighborhood and my christian single-parent father was employed by a jewish pharmacy owner.this man helped my father buy his first and only house because, ‘children need a home to grow up in’. Like this Rabbi, this is always how I saw jewish people.
Gaza has been a profiund shick to me and I struggle now to resist painting world jewry with Israels actions. And the thing that helps me most with that are my jewish brothers & sisters who oppose Gaza and Zionism and Netanyahu, its High priest.
almost any criticism, no matter how slight, that i make of israel on utoob is sencored and deleted by utoob.
You're using the wrong setting
@strandedstarfish , wrong spelling maybe but wrong setting?
Same.
So nice to hear from the rabbi. Just wish that the Americans and other western leaders would listen to respected individuals like this and realise that being anti zionist isn't anti semitic
America and Britain have blood on their hands for funding, supporting, arming and defending this grotesqueary
“Best We Forget”.
I agree with the Rabbi
Hmmm, will James call on his buddies Starmer and Lammy to actually do anything about this? Maybe some sanctions and actual consequences for Israel?
Remember when Starmer said “I think Israel does have that right”, he is complicit and works against peace at every turn.
No he won't...
I would think he will soon; seeing how even the RW Governments of Italy and the Netherlands have said they will uphold the ICC arrest warrant. I have a feeling Starmer will try his best to sit on the fence.
This has been happening before they were in power... change the record will you
@@claudioricci1just been done
@@readwithcareplease22 And Starmer has been backing Israel since before he was in power, what does that matter.
He is in power now and he is bought but the Israel lobby and people like James never ever call out Labours continued support of Israel.
I dare you to arrest him, and breach the Vienna Convention. I wanna see where that goes.
What wonderful man
Thank you Rabbi.
Bless this Rabbi. 💕