ranking nct ot23 in different categories (vocal, pt.1)

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ม.ค. 2025

ความคิดเห็น • 209

  • @minhoskitten
    @minhoskitten  3 ปีที่แล้ว +15

    after checking many more videos, I think I made a fair and good ranking but keep in mind this is also based on my PREFERENCES not biases but preferences that means what I like to hear better or for me who I think is better as well, feel free to comment yours.
    the only mistake is jeno was supposed to be before hendery, editing mistake ❤️
    and also taeyong I made my mind after hearing his songs on SoundCloud, so I think he has improved a lot now and has a better vocal

    • @chauqueteva
      @chauqueteva 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      so, taeyong in top 10 right now? I think he has excellent vocal technique for moonlight. still far from top 5 like taeil-xiaojun-doyoung-haechan- renjun. but soon or later I think he could put his ranking above jaehyun, yuta, jungwoo, chenle and kun.

    • @avril5757
      @avril5757 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@chauqueteva Taeyong can never close to Top 4 (Taeil, Doyoung, Xiaojun, Jaehyun). Even Renjun or Haechan can't touch Top 4 anytime soon.

  • @ThaoThu-sr3uk
    @ThaoThu-sr3uk 3 ปีที่แล้ว +60

    Jaehyun is only Baritone in NCT. His technique is incredible. He is in top 4 with Xiaojun
    And the most importantly, he is Main vocal with Doyoung and Taeil in 127

    • @katr_i_na
      @katr_i_na 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Jaehyun is not a Baritone, common misconception. Tenor w/ a lower register.

    • @not4e1
      @not4e1 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Jaehyun is a Baritone, but he’s not the only baritone in NCT. I’d say he’s the best baritone singer in NCT though.

  • @badguy-ym5mo
    @badguy-ym5mo 3 ปีที่แล้ว +91

    ranking Jaehyun at 11 is unbelievable. tbh, he has the most stable voice during their live performances. his visuals just overshadows his vocals. he has a very good tonal quality and that lower register of his voice is something that stood out in every vocalists in NCT. probably, my top five would be Doyoung, Taeil, Jaehyun, Haechan and Yuta. YES YUTA!

    • @thelastgigachad7994
      @thelastgigachad7994 3 ปีที่แล้ว +14

      What about xiaojun he's undoubtedly top 3 after doyoung and taeil

    • @Heyguhh
      @Heyguhh 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Didnt they say this was based on preference THEIR?

    • @Creamy326
      @Creamy326 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      I agree

    • @ellenblue3138
      @ellenblue3138 2 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      I agree with you with jaehyun but not with yuta! Technique wise:Taeil=Doyoung>> jaehyun>>xiaojun>>Haechan>>Jungwoo>>the rest

    • @avril5757
      @avril5757 2 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      @@ellenblue3138
      technically, there is no gap between Jaehyun and Xiaojun. They are interchangable in 3 or 4 place. Xiaojun's supported range E3-F4/F#4 is even wider than Jaehyun that supported C#3-C#4/D4. Taeil is better than Doyoung these day. Doyoung is better than Taeil above G#4/A4 only. Taeil takes the rest like low register, agility, placement, tonality, resonance, etc.
      The rank kinda :
      Taeil>Doyoung>>Xiaojun>/=Jaehyun>>>Haechan>/=Jungwoo>>Yuta
      I prefer to give little edge to Xiaojun and Haechan because of his vocal range, but they and their tier are obviously interchangable.

  • @dddn3149
    @dddn3149 3 ปีที่แล้ว +52

    Ten being a main vocalist and main dancer at the same time is so sexy of him

  • @alienworld5009
    @alienworld5009 3 ปีที่แล้ว +60

    i'm sorry that i laughed so hard to see jaehyun in 11. he's a baritone so ppl often overlook him, but honestly his technique is one of the best in nct although ofc he needs a lil bit more of improvements; so he actually deserves the 4th rank (or at least get in top7). regardless, thanks for ur opinion and hard work tho💚

    • @jenniepark4094
      @jenniepark4094 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      agree, people used to forget that jaehyun is one of nct's main vocalist since their debut in 2016. honestly his voice, technique, and vocal range are one of the best in nct but also always so underappreciated by this fandom, so yeah he deserves higher place tho
      anyways, thank you for the video, creator-nim

  • @s_4444x
    @s_4444x 3 ปีที่แล้ว +43

    but chenle's voice really improved this year. he deserves in top 5 imo

  • @matealeko8274
    @matealeko8274 2 ปีที่แล้ว +15

    I just love how there are so many different ranking but everyone collectively agrees that taeil deserves that number one spot

  • @ten10ten48
    @ten10ten48 2 ปีที่แล้ว +24

    My top 5 for me
    1.Taeil
    2.Doyoung
    3.Jaehyun,Haechan,Xiaojun
    4.Renjun,Chenle
    5.Kun,Ten,Jungwoo

  • @caedwinred2103
    @caedwinred2103 2 ปีที่แล้ว +11

    Technique-wise:
    1. Taeil
    2. Doyoung
    3. Jaehyun
    4. Xiaojun
    5. Jungwoo
    6. Haechan
    7. Ten
    8. Chenle
    9.Renjun
    10. Kun
    My preference:
    1.Taeil
    2. Doyoung
    3. Haechan
    4. Xiaojun
    5. Jaehyun
    6. Renjun
    7. Chenle
    8. Ten
    9. Kun
    10. Yuta
    11. Jungwoo
    12. Yangyang
    13. Taeyong
    14. Mark
    15. Jisung
    16. Lucas
    17. Sungchan
    18. Hendery
    19. Johnny
    20. Jeno
    21. Winwin
    22. Jaemin
    23. Shotaro

  • @flwrsyy9533
    @flwrsyy9533 3 ปีที่แล้ว +24

    yangyang is the best vocalists among the rappers-

  • @sueda6247
    @sueda6247 3 ปีที่แล้ว +21

    For me:
    1. Xiaojun
    2. Taeil
    3. Doyoung
    4. Renjun
    5. Haechan
    6. Chenle
    7. Ten
    8. Jaehyun
    9. Jungwoo
    10. Jisung

  • @faye7348
    @faye7348 2 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    i think one of the most interesting things about nct vocally is seeing jisung grow into his deep voice and transition from a rap position to a vocalist in dream. of course he doesn’t have the abilities of the main vocals but it really shows how hard he has worked and how well sm vocal trainers are at their job

  • @alisonthai9912
    @alisonthai9912 3 ปีที่แล้ว +24

    My top
    1. Xiaojun
    2. Taeil
    3. Haechan
    4. Doyoung
    5. Renjun
    6. Chenle
    7. Ten
    8. Kun
    9. Jaehyun
    10. Yuta

  • @skzluvies
    @skzluvies 2 ปีที่แล้ว +20

    My personal ranking:
    23. Shotaro - we honestly don't get to hear his vocals a lot, so that's why he's ranked last :<
    22. Hendery - I think most of his "vocal" parts are him rapping but at a slower pace.
    21. Johnny - not a very huge fan of Johnny's vocals, probably cause I've not heard it a lot.
    20. Winwin
    19. Jeno
    18. Sungchan - his vocals are so so good for a rapper and he definitely deserves more vocal parts
    17. Taeyong
    16. Jaemin
    15. Mark - his covers are always so exciting
    14. Lucas
    13. Yangyang - 2yang's still with you cover >>>
    12. Jisung - his deep voice ahhhhh
    11. Ten
    10. Kun
    09. Yuta
    08. Jungwoo
    07. Jaehyun
    06. Chenle
    05. Renjun
    04. Haechan
    03. Doyoung - hits high notes like no other
    02. Xiaojun - I love his covers so so much and xj definitely has a lot of potential as a soloist
    01. Taeil - our vocal king

    • @annafefia3174
      @annafefia3174 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      I agree with this more, to be honest

    • @sn00ra
      @sn00ra 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      strongly agree. but personally Ten rank higher than Kun.

  • @Sfxfreestyle
    @Sfxfreestyle ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Jaehyun at 11 is crazy bro. In terms of crazy riffs and runs, Jaehyun isn’t a tenor. His mixed is possibly the best in the group, and he might have the best breath support and the best initiation out of any vocalist. Putting him at 11 would be like putting ten at 11 for best dancers in the group

  • @bundashafanya5459
    @bundashafanya5459 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Taeil is always be the best vocalist in NCT because of :
    1. The most agile/flexible/versatile voice in NCT
    2. The most sustaining highest and longest notes in every NCT song where he is included.
    3. Handle the most difficult vocal part in NCT song where he is included.
    4. Have widest supported range C#3/D3 - G#4/A4. He can support down C3 but barely singing in that range. He can also support higher up to Bb4 occasionally. Check this video for his supported range th-cam.com/video/2Eex2E1QWO0/w-d-xo.html
    5. Have widest vocal range G#2 - G5. Check this video for his vocal range th-cam.com/video/JxIO9AXQlEU/w-d-xo.html
    6. The only one NCT vocalist who has produced resonance.

  • @villainroughlvertae7799
    @villainroughlvertae7799 2 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    My Opinion:-
    1.Taeil
    2.Doyoung
    3.Xiaojun
    4.Haechan
    5.Chenle
    6.Jaehyun
    7.Renjun
    8.Kun
    9.Ten
    10.Jungwoo
    11.Yuta
    12.Jisung
    13.Mark
    14.Yangyang
    15.Hendery
    16.Lucas
    17.Sungchan
    18.Taeyong
    19.Jeno
    20.Johnny
    21.Winwin
    22.Jaemin
    23.Shotaro

  • @khurtchmyzaccharry2251
    @khurtchmyzaccharry2251 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    An update for NCT's supported range:
    •Taeil is now had C#3 and up to A4. However, his A4 is not fully consistent.
    •Doyoung is now had Eb3 and up to B4. Doyoung Bb4 and B4 are not fully consistent, although he had more materials for Bb4, some of it is full of tension and other may sound passable. And his Eb3 sometimes are airy.
    •Jaehyun had B2 up to G#4. Nonetheless, his G#4 supported remained unexplored for me and not consistent.
    •Xiaojun had F3 up to G#4. On the contrary, he is lack of material for his G#4 but still not that bad.
    •Haechan is now had E3 supported, still lack of material but not that awful.
    •Jungwoo had now F4 supported, but it is inconsistent.

  • @riyantotimika8923
    @riyantotimika8923 2 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Taeil best vocalist from NCT with who has big support from low note C#3 up to belted note G#4/A4.

    • @khurtchmyzaccharry2251
      @khurtchmyzaccharry2251 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Both Doyoung and Taeil has wider supported range in NCT, Doyoung had Eb3-B4. But Doyoung at his best around Eb3-A4/Bb4.

  • @chauqueteva
    @chauqueteva 3 ปีที่แล้ว +28

    xiaojun could take doyoung usual position, but no one can't take taeil position. xiaojun more better day by day

    • @chenseanctzens3535
      @chenseanctzens3535 3 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      This is your opinion, but in reality Doyoung is far beyond better than Xiaojun. In Universe we heard, how Xiaojun's high note is so powerful. But, Doyoung's belted note for this song is much more technical than him. And during their recording, probably Doyoung has a problem with his vocal because since December 2020 until 2021 Doyoung has a lots of projects. That's why we see the tiredness of his vocal. But we are lucky that this year end of 2021 or in the mid of December, Doyoung's vocal is getting back to be okay.

    • @tin_4207
      @tin_4207 3 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      @@chenseanctzens3535 I know I'm a Doyoung stan and of course I'll like his voice better. But yeah, what you said is true. Xiaojun's voice is amazing, like super amazing. But they can't deny the fact that doie's vocal range is super hella impressive that he can pull off any genre and still sound amazing.

    • @tin_4207
      @tin_4207 3 ปีที่แล้ว +9

      Maybe if just talking about pure vocal ability then xiaojun can be on top cuz he can hit high notes with ease and hit them beautifully. But when it comes to the skill, technique and range, I'll go with Doyoung 😅

  • @zulapeeps3532
    @zulapeeps3532 3 ปีที่แล้ว +10

    Im talking about whos the best vocally top 5
    1. Taeil (Obviously)
    2. Xiaojun
    3. Doyoung
    4. Jaehyun
    5. Haechan
    Jae and Doyoung are on the same level vocally, jae is a baritone so he gets to shine less than doyoung.
    Although Haechans fans make him seem like the best singer in the world, thats not the case. He has a unique voice, but he still lacks in technique

    • @chenseanctzens3535
      @chenseanctzens3535 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Doyoung is now better than Taeil. Obviously stated. Taeil's support is not comfortable for him, the strained of his vocal is overheard. And he is only supported with A4. Unlike to Doyoung, he can support with Bb4, his support is not strained than Taeil. Not because Doyoung's vocal register is not on the same level with other members, it does not mean he is not a really good vocalist.In reality, Doyoung has wider range compared them. Doyoung is not on the same level of Jaehyun since 2020, maybe you can't moveon about that. I think Jaehyun is still better than Xiaojun, technicqlly. Jae has consistent support and stable than him. And even vocal analyst says that.

    • @zulapeeps3532
      @zulapeeps3532 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@chenseanctzens3535 i don't agree, keep on talking

    • @chenseanctzens3535
      @chenseanctzens3535 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Watch their recent performance and you will find what i mean

    • @chenseanctzens3535
      @chenseanctzens3535 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      how could you conclude that Dejun is better than Doie, in what aspect that he is better than him?

    • @zulapeeps3532
      @zulapeeps3532 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@chenseanctzens3535 we get it you bias doyoung, now leave

  • @joseeroldan2754
    @joseeroldan2754 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    creo que debería ser:
    6.- jaehyun
    5.- chenle
    4.- renjun
    3.- haechan
    2.- doyoung
    1.- taeil
    esto es basado en la trayectoria de cada uno y en sus habilidades, doyoung tiene mucha mas técnica que xiaojun obviamente.

  • @emil_yo
    @emil_yo 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    NCT have such strong diverse vocals !
    Expected from SM ofc

  • @bentenv7524
    @bentenv7524 3 ปีที่แล้ว +25

    What I think is the correct ranking based on skills (not taking vocal color into consideration):
    1. Taeil
    2. Doyoung
    3. Xiaojun
    4. Jaehyun
    5. Haechan
    6. Chenle
    7. Renjun
    8. Jungwoo
    9. Ten
    10. Kun
    11. Yuta
    12. Yangyang
    13. Jisung
    14. Taeyong
    15. Sungchan
    16. Johnny
    17. Mark
    18. Shotaro
    19. Winwin
    20. Lucas
    21. Jeno
    22. Hendery
    23. Jaemin

    • @minhoskitten
      @minhoskitten  3 ปีที่แล้ว

      thats a good rank thank u!

    • @Kj-im8nm
      @Kj-im8nm 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      I am curious to how taeyong is higher than mark

    • @bentenv7524
      @bentenv7524 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@Kj-im8nm Have you never heard Taeyong's song called Blue? If you haven't, be sure to check it out on his soundcloud

    • @bentenv7524
      @bentenv7524 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@Kj-im8nm Or you could also check out Dark Clouds, Rose, Long Flight or pretty much any of his solo songs for that

    • @Kj-im8nm
      @Kj-im8nm 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@bentenv7524 I have seen mark go into a mix voice ,but taeyong's upper range is underexplored and isn't showcased much, also I don't know how am I suppose to judge accurately when it is studio ver. .Also mark has a better pitch and have better control when he goes a bit up

  • @biswamitrabhattacharjee2119
    @biswamitrabhattacharjee2119 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Xiajoun is actually a find of NCT.....the way he's hitting the lower and higher notes....he's a god level vocalist
    Moreover I think after Jaehyun.....Xiajoun has the best lower notes.....he's absolutely a gem

    • @avril5757
      @avril5757 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Yes, i agree that Xiaojun has the best lower after Jaehyun who has the best lower after Taeil.
      The order in lower register kinda like this :
      Taeil>Jaehyun>Xiaojun=Doyoung
      Taeil has the best lower because as a tenor, he can support down C3 and D3 consistently. The next is Jaehyun who can support B2 and C#3 consistently, but he is bariton and expected support more down. Both Doyoung and Xiaojun are tier in low register coz they can support down Eb3 and E3 consistently

    • @khurtchmyzaccharry2251
      @khurtchmyzaccharry2251 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@avril5757 nope, the best low register is Jaehyun>Taeil>Doyoung>Haechan. Xiaojun is still airy from his low notes approach.. He is still at F#3.. Haechan had E3, Doyoung Eb3, Taeil C#3, and Jaehyun Bb2.
      *Jaehyun is a tenor..

    • @avril5757
      @avril5757 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@khurtchmyzaccharry2251 you again lol
      No, Jaehyun is not the best in lower. He is baritone and expected to support down to A2. But, he can only support B2 at best. Meanwhile Taeil as tenor can support C3 at his best.
      Haechan F3 lol
      Xiaojun and Doyoung are tier in low.
      Even if Jaehyun is tenor, his below C#3 lacks fullness compared to Taeil.

    • @khurtchmyzaccharry2251
      @khurtchmyzaccharry2251 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@avril5757 Let me emphasize you Jaehyun is actually a Tenor considering he can carry support to G#4. Xiaojun is at F#3 nonetheless. The low-supported range of them goes like these:
      *Jaehyun - B2/C3
      *Taeil - D3
      *Doyoung - Eb3/E3
      *Haechan - F3
      *Xiaojun - F3

    • @avril5757
      @avril5757 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@khurtchmyzaccharry2251 some vocalist can support higher out of their voice type range if they give more effort.
      Jaehyun is baritone who can support higher because he gives more effort to engage support. He can actually support F4/F#4 for safe.
      Taeil support down D3 consistently and Jaehyun C#3 for consistently. They are close each other in low register. But, Taeil is considered better because he is tenor and his below D3 fuller than Jaehyun below C#3. Atleast, Taeil can support C#3 sometimes. There are no more C3 from Taeil because he is barely singing that lower.

  • @Veda98480
    @Veda98480 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    My ranking would be (based on what pleasing to listen, not techniques) :-
    Taeil
    Chenle
    Xiaojun
    Haechan
    Jaehyun
    Renjun
    Ten
    Doyoung
    Kun
    Yuta
    Yangyang
    Jisung
    Jeno
    Mark
    Johny
    Lucas
    Jungwoo
    Sungchan
    Hendery
    Jaemin
    Taeyong
    Shotaro
    Winwin

  • @Nunofyobiz
    @Nunofyobiz 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Vocally speaking,
    1) Jaemin is better than Winwin.
    2) you can't really compare recordings with live vocals. Mark and Jisung is better than Taeyong.
    3) Jaehyun is atleast in the top 4.
    4) Doyoung is better than Xiaojun.

  • @emil_yo
    @emil_yo 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Jaehyun has the 3rd best technique tho 😧 wow we have very different opinions but I respect yours :)

  • @delatoba
    @delatoba 3 ปีที่แล้ว +20

    Great list!
    My top 10 favourite NCT vocalists are:
    1. Haechan
    2. Taeil
    3. Doyoung
    4. Jaehyun
    5. Renjun
    6. Chenle
    7. Xiaojun
    8. Ten
    9. Jungwoo
    10. Kun
    and I feel that this list changes all the time! :D

    • @minhoskitten
      @minhoskitten  3 ปีที่แล้ว

      love the rank thanks for commenting, I have more videos like this in my channel just in case u interested❤️

    • @alisonthai9912
      @alisonthai9912 3 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      Xiaojun 7 💀

    • @biswamitrabhattacharjee2119
      @biswamitrabhattacharjee2119 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      The worst ranking....Putting Xiajoun in the 7th....he's definitely top 3 material

    • @jennielawrence8809
      @jennielawrence8809 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@biswamitrabhattacharjee2119 its their opinion so stfu

  • @enriqegonsalez8083
    @enriqegonsalez8083 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    My ranking would be:
    1. Taeil
    2. Xiajun
    3. Doyoung
    4. Haechan
    5. Jaehyun
    6. Renjun
    7. Chenle
    8. Ten
    9. Jungwoo
    10.Kun
    11. Yuta
    12. Yangyang
    13. Jisung
    14. Mark
    15. Jaemin
    16. Lucas
    17. Taeyong
    18. Songchan
    19. Jeno
    20. Johnny
    21. Hendery
    22. Shotaro
    23. Winwin

  • @yilianlaria8371
    @yilianlaria8371 2 ปีที่แล้ว +10

    No one can beat Taeil. 😌😌😌

  • @flwrsyy9533
    @flwrsyy9533 3 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    jaehyun is great y'all just obsessed with high notes

    • @minhoskitten
      @minhoskitten  3 ปีที่แล้ว

      nah that’s just really my preference

    • @flwrsyy9533
      @flwrsyy9533 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@minhoskitten I respect it ^^

  • @이타도리현재
    @이타도리현재 3 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    dang how can anyone rank nct vocals the vocalists line are too good

  • @luv_chlo
    @luv_chlo 3 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    my top 10:
    1. taeil
    2. haechan
    3. renjun
    4. jaehyun
    5. chenle
    6. xiaojun
    7. doyoung
    8. kun
    9. mark
    10. jungwoo
    i think they are all great singers but these are my favorites

  • @sof5611
    @sof5611 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    my ranking
    1. taeil
    2. xiaojun
    3. doyoung
    4. chenle
    5. ten
    6. haechan
    7. renjun
    8. kun
    9. jaehyun
    10. jungwoo

  • @michelleler5984
    @michelleler5984 3 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    My top 10:
    1. Haechan
    2. Doyoung
    3. Chenle
    4. Taeil
    5. Jisung
    6. Xiaojun
    7. Jaehyun
    8. Jung woo
    9. Renjun
    10. Ten
    It’s not about being the best

  • @farydecazares826
    @farydecazares826 ปีที่แล้ว

    My vocal ranking
    1 - Taeil
    2 - Doyoung
    3 - Jaehyun
    4 - Xiaojun
    5 - Ten
    6 - Jungwoo
    7 - Chenle
    8 - Renjun
    9 - Haechan
    10- Kun

  • @gabitaluna4490
    @gabitaluna4490 3 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    I agree ❤ ❤. TAEIL IS THE MOSTRAR BEAUTIFUL VOICE OF THE WHOLE KPOP

  • @hadlinrodriguezfuentes6642
    @hadlinrodriguezfuentes6642 3 ปีที่แล้ว +9

    My top: Taeil
    Doyoung
    Xiajun
    Haechan. 💚

  • @rose.tte_c
    @rose.tte_c 9 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    jaehyun is literally top 5 vocalists. this is a joke😂

  • @thaodam5039
    @thaodam5039 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    hey guys after knowing a little bit 'bout music, i've been wondered if Haechan and Doyoung had nasal?

    • @minhoskitten
      @minhoskitten  3 ปีที่แล้ว

      oh idk about that sorry

    • @thaodam5039
      @thaodam5039 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      tks for replying me :

    • @chenseanctzens3535
      @chenseanctzens3535 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      In terms of nasal issue, probably Haechan. But in Doyoung's case, it is a rare to happen. Since debut of NCT, Doyoung has the less nasal issue and praise by vocal analyst for having NCT's vocalist with a better placement. Placement refers to having good vocal and breathing control. But, nasal issue is common for a singer.

    • @avril5757
      @avril5757 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Haechan's nasality and Doyoung's placement in the backward. They are trouble in that issue. That is why they can't be #1.

  • @xiuyanh
    @xiuyanh 3 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    nice ranking

  • @КираТрифонова-и7ш
    @КираТрифонова-и7ш 3 ปีที่แล้ว +13

    1. Taeil / Doyoung
    2. Xiaojun
    3. Jaehyun
    4. Jungwoo
    5. Haechan

  • @channelfani9063
    @channelfani9063 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    jaemin should be first then jeno

  • @ChewGiao
    @ChewGiao 3 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    I think the vocal of Doyoung is Strong and Clear better than Xiaojun then
    1.Taeil
    2.Doyoung
    3.Xiaojun
    4.Haechan
    5.Jaehyun
    6.Renjun
    7.Ten
    This is my top7 vocal of NCT

    • @santos3897
      @santos3897 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Nice rank would only change jaehyun and put chenle

    • @ChewGiao
      @ChewGiao 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@santos3897 now vocal of chenle is much better than the time that i ranked it .Is so awesome!

  • @moonshin8269
    @moonshin8269 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    May I ask? What is your criteria to rank Xiaojun higher than Doyoung?
    Based on my observation Xiaojun didn't improve a lot for past year. I did not see him with massive growth of his vocals. He is still nasal, inconsistent of his support, pushy and even airy with his low range. His mixed voice is the only thing that I could say he improves.
    More or less, talking the gap between Doyoung and Xiaojun are really huge. If the basis of who is the best main vocalist of NCT, it could be Doyoung rather than Taeil or Xiaojun. Because Doyoung has better upper register than the rests.
    In terms of best vocalist, Taeil and Doyoung could be a par. They are both technically better. Taeil can support down to C#3 while Doyoung can go up to B4. Due to Doyoung is lack of stylistic choice, people often misjudge him.

    • @avril5757
      @avril5757 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Doyoung is lack stylistic choice?
      LOL
      He is very stylistic in singing. His style is soft singing that blocked his support for being stronger.

  • @ooaa8545
    @ooaa8545 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I mean if you’re gonna take winwin’s vocals into consideration I feel like it’s a crime not to include king of hearts which is probably his most impressive showcased vocal I would’ve put Winwin higher than hendery and Jisung over Mark but besides that I agree with this ranking

    • @minhoskitten
      @minhoskitten  3 ปีที่แล้ว

      lmao it’s hard to put clips of him singing because of the small amount of lines, but the videos are just to show up who am talking to even tho I always try to give the best ones and about that idk this was just an overall I believe I wouldn’t change it atm❤️

  • @zuchanbenikikon5938
    @zuchanbenikikon5938 3 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    My top ten ''preference'':
    1)Xiaojun
    2)Haechan
    3)Jaehyun
    4)Doyoung
    5)Taeil
    6)Ten
    7)Renjun
    8)Chenle
    9)Jungwoo
    10)Jeno

  • @Faeriecorener
    @Faeriecorener 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    I believe this is the right ranking based on technique/support and other skills not subjective things like range, tone etc.
    Taeil
    Doyoung
    Xiaojun
    Jaehyun
    Haechan
    Jungwoo
    renjun
    Ten
    Chenle
    kun
    yuta
    Yangyang
    Mark
    Jisung
    Taeyong
    Johnny
    Sungchan
    Jeno
    Hendery
    Jaemin
    Lucas
    Winwin
    Shotaro

    • @楓紅葉-z2m
      @楓紅葉-z2m 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      YUTA…

    • @Faeriecorener
      @Faeriecorener 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@楓紅葉-z2m omg youre so right i forgot him!!!

  • @holdup1058
    @holdup1058 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    3:05 what song is Yangyang singing

  • @vinadaa7709
    @vinadaa7709 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    whats the song Yangyang's singing at 3:05

  • @putrisila5391
    @putrisila5391 3 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    I agree with this rank

  • @Maryy05k
    @Maryy05k 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    in my opinion Jungwoo is better than Ten, Renjun, Chenle and Kun so he is too low on this ranking

  • @kimanid.929
    @kimanid.929 3 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    jaehyun deserves better than 11

  • @VT-ng7tc
    @VT-ng7tc 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    You did NOT put Jaehyun at 11 lol. He's def top 5

  • @tanayamondal9278
    @tanayamondal9278 2 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Xiaojun ❤️

  • @rosieyves
    @rosieyves 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    king taeil

  • @Creamy326
    @Creamy326 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I don't think Xiaojun can be that high ranking, you can see the recording behind scene of universe, his high note is not that stable and i think his singing technique is not that perfect enough to be ranked as 2.
    Also Jaehyun definitely deserves a higher ranking, he is one of the vocal line in NCT127 !!!
    I think he sings better than Yuta and Jungwoo

    • @khurtchmyzaccharry2251
      @khurtchmyzaccharry2251 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      You have that point Xiaojun can't be ranked two as of this era. The distance between him to Taeil and Doyoung is extremely wider. But he has so much potential and need to fix his low supported range and his nasal issue. These are the most common issue that I have heard from him.

  • @Daewonn
    @Daewonn 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    LMAO JAEHYUN IN 11, hes the third better vocalist of nct

  • @vanshika2135
    @vanshika2135 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Jaehyun 11????? He's easily like 6/7 in the group.

    • @user-nu3lo8hl9k
      @user-nu3lo8hl9k 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      he’s actually 3/4

    • @vanshika2135
      @vanshika2135 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@user-nu3lo8hl9k top 4 are Taeil, doyoung, xiaojun and haechan so not really

    • @user-nu3lo8hl9k
      @user-nu3lo8hl9k 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@vanshika2135 nah technique wise he’s literally 3/4 in overall nct. i get having preference but when we talk about techniques he’s 3/4. there’s a reason why he has always been a main vocalist since debut.

    • @vanshika2135
      @vanshika2135 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@user-nu3lo8hl9k haechan is now a technically better singer than him and xiaojun is better than haechan so clearly jae's not in the top 4 anymore but he's still one of the best in the group

    • @avril5757
      @avril5757 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@vanshika2135 No, Haechan might better singer than Jaehyun. But, when talking about vocalist, Jaehyun is better vocalist than Haechan. Coz, Jaehyun has better technique in vocal than Haechan.

  • @halehvafai8700
    @halehvafai8700 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    For me:
    1.tail
    2.hyuk
    3.xioujun
    4.chenle
    5.renjun
    6.ten
    7.kun
    8.jungwoo
    9.doyoung
    10.jaehyun
    11.jisung
    12.jeno
    13.yang
    14.johnny
    15.others are the same.

  • @Magmax101
    @Magmax101 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    What song 5:57 and 5:39?

  • @Nana-tb1ez
    @Nana-tb1ez 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Part 2 dance

    • @Nana-tb1ez
      @Nana-tb1ez 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      And rap

    • @minhoskitten
      @minhoskitten  3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@Nana-tb1ez already done those!

  • @chenseanctzens3535
    @chenseanctzens3535 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Doyoung is now better than Taeil. Taeil's vocal is fully developed, while Doyoung shows more capabilities. I'm sightly disappointed with Jaehyun's rank. Jaehyun is stilll rank 3 in good vocal technique. But, Jaehyun's problem only is hitting high notes. Xiaojun's problem is inconsistent with his technique and he has nasal issue. Idk who will come next, some says Haechan, Chenle or Jungwoo. According to a vocal analyst. The rank 5 best vocalists of NCt today Doyoung and Taeil with a big gap following Jaehyun and Xiaojun and another gap then Jungwoo. Some nctzens is looking forward to another units to have strong vocals.

    • @avril5757
      @avril5757 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Low Register
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil support C#3/D3, Doyoung support Eb3/E3
      Mix Register
      Doyoung = Taeil
      Taeil support G#4/A4, Doyoung support A4 and had Bb4 occasionally. Taeil is better than Doyoung up to G#4, Doyoung is better than Taeil above G#4
      Upper Register
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil connected headvoice up to E5, Doyoung relaxed to connection headvoice/falsetto below E5
      Agility
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil is the most agile/flexible voice in NCT.
      Placement
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil is less nasal and tight nowadays with forward placement. Doyoung remained in his stuck placement (backward placement).
      Resonance
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil has achieved resonance. Doyoung still unable to produce resonance.
      Taeil is still the best vocalist in NCT nowadays.

  • @p1nktae912
    @p1nktae912 3 ปีที่แล้ว

    Oooo!!!

  • @luizizn165
    @luizizn165 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Based on technique:
    1. Doyoung
    2. Taeil
    3. Jaehyun
    4. Haechan
    5. Xiaojun
    6. Ten
    7. Jungwoo

    • @avril5757
      @avril5757 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Low Register
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil support C#3/D3, Doyoung support Eb3/E3
      Mix Register
      Doyoung = Taeil
      Taeil support G#4/A4, Doyoung support A4 and had Bb4 occasionally. Taeil is better than Doyoung up to G#4, Doyoung is better than Taeil above G#4
      Upper Register
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil connected headvoice up to E5, Doyoung relaxed to connection headvoice/falsetto below E5
      Agility
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil is the most agile/flexible voice in NCT.
      Placement
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil is less nasal and tight nowadays with forward placement. Doyoung remained in his stuck placement (backward placement).
      Resonance
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil has achieved resonance. Doyoung still unable to produce resonance.
      Taeil is still the best vocalist in NCT nowadays.

    • @avril5757
      @avril5757 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Low Register
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil support C#3/D3, Doyoung support Eb3/E3
      Mix Register
      Doyoung = Taeil
      Taeil support G#4/A4, Doyoung support A4 and had Bb4 occasionally. Taeil is better than Doyoung up to G#4, Doyoung is better than Taeil above G#4
      Upper Register
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil connected headvoice up to E5, Doyoung relaxed to connection headvoice/falsetto below E5
      Agility
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil is the most agile/flexible voice in NCT.
      Placement
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil is less nasal and tight nowadays with forward placement. Doyoung remained in his stuck placement (backward placement).
      Resonance
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil has achieved resonance. Doyoung still unable to produce resonance.
      Taeil is still the best vocalist in NCT nowadays.

  • @riv475
    @riv475 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    my top 10:
    1- Taeil
    2- Doyoung
    3- Xiaojun
    4- Renjun
    5- Chenle
    6- Haechan
    7-Jaehyun
    8- Ten
    9- Kun
    10- Yangyang

  • @chenseanctzens3535
    @chenseanctzens3535 3 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Doyoung is now better than Taeil. Taeil's vocal is fully developed, while Doyoung shows more capabilities. I'm sightly disappointed with Jaehyun's rank. Jaehyun is stilll rank 3 in good vocal technique. But, Jaehyun's problem only is hitting high notes. Xiaojun's problem is inconsistent with his technique and he has nasal issue. Idk who will come next, some says Haechan, Chenle or Jungwoo. According to a vocal analyst. The rank 5 best vocalists of NCt today Doyoung and Taeil with a big gap following Jaehyun and Xiaojun and another gap then Jungwoo. Some nctzens is looking forward to another units to have strong vocals.

    • @avril5757
      @avril5757 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Low Register
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil support C#3/D3, Doyoung support Eb3/E3
      Mix Register
      Doyoung = Taeil
      Taeil support G#4/A4, Doyoung support A4 and had Bb4 occasionally. Taeil is better than Doyoung up to G#4, Doyoung is better than Taeil above G#4
      Upper Register
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil connected headvoice up to E5, Doyoung relaxed to connection headvoice/falsetto below E5
      Agility
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil is the most agile/flexible voice in NCT.
      Placement
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil is less nasal and tight nowadays with forward placement. Doyoung remained in his stuck placement (backward placement).
      Resonance
      Taeil > Doyoung
      Taeil has achieved resonance. Doyoung still unable to produce resonance.
      Taeil is still the best vocalist in NCT nowadays.

    • @khurtchmyzaccharry2251
      @khurtchmyzaccharry2251 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@avril5757 mixed and upper register Doyoung better than Taeil. Doyoung is more relaxed on his upper register than Taeil.

    • @avril5757
      @avril5757 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@khurtchmyzaccharry2251 that is because of Doyoung's singing approach in soft side. It doesn't mean he is stronger than Taeil.

    • @khurtchmyzaccharry2251
      @khurtchmyzaccharry2251 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@avril5757 you don't understand what I am pointing out. Soft voice versus relaxed tone is different.

    • @avril5757
      @avril5757 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@khurtchmyzaccharry2251 u cant said relaxed when he is struggle to place the notes due to his stuck placement.

  • @gabrielamayamaya4170
    @gabrielamayamaya4170 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    My top 10 :
    1. Taeil
    2. Xiaojun
    3. Doyoung
    4. Jaehyun
    5. Renjun
    6. Chenle
    7. Haechan
    8. Ten
    9. Yangyang
    10. Lucas