P.S. while Modi Story was banned in college campuses and kids beaten up by right wing groups, Kerala story was peacefully aired in the very same college. So, saying there is no propagand looks too simplistic view of the issue.
Tere saath problem ye hai kya ki tu apnae aap ko bhaut zada technically sound prove karna chahta hai. Hai tu Lund. Aukaat main reh, Hindi medium ka kutta, dont fake it bro.
Ur such a hypocrite man terko kuch bola to tu muh utha ke bakwas krne aa gya abusive b ho gya ab smjhaya to ek shabd ni bc terko genuine smjha tha re mai but u r just an egoistic person bro....😂😂😂😂 I feel sorry for u man
Or merko pta h tu ab aaega b to fir abusive hi hoga kyuki Teri real personality hi whi h 😂😂 and thats why i feel sorry for u....sbko criticize krne wala apni 1% criticism ni sun skta lol
In my school there were two muslims girls who always used talk high about their own religion and in every topic they used to bring their religion , so in movie whatever they have shown is totally a reality.
See ex muslim chennal and ask them questions about thier religion they will shut thier mouth. Ask about what is kafir Kafir ke sath kya Krna chahiye Why they are mostly radical why hizab Why no right for women in muslim country Afghanistan and iran
same here but in college … she always used to tell about the the rights of women under islam and she used to send religious videos and lectures on our whtsapp grp … she was very religious used to wear niqab and gloves ..but not everyone is same .. i have 2 muslims frnd they are very nice nd sweet but i have to mention they are not very religious and belongs to other sect like ahemadi or something..
What u failed to understand, there is a difference between religion and people, I saw on the trailer, Muslim guy saying if you have to sleep with them and make them pregnant then do it, in Islam it's forbidden to look at random women who is not ur wife or mom or sis and others within these relationships, let alone sleep with them. When I saw Islam is getting presented like this, it's a sad and false image. So first y'all need to separate Islam from terrorist culture this movie is portraying.
I'm from Tamilnadu here very very few theaters have this movie.. guess what it's also only in Hindi.. in entire vellor district only 2 theaters have this movie that too only one show each theater.. even if ppl wants to see they have only Hindi option.. majority of ppl here don't know Hindi.. ppl are waiting to see the movie in OTT in Tamil.. Entire DMK government is anti Hindu government they openly say its against minority we won't allow.. guess what 90% of theaters owned by DMK.. only God have to save us from these monsters
As a Pakistani, I was a victim as well. I was born as a Muslim, but I was not religious. I used to ask critical questions about religion. My mother then joined Islamic Organisation, Al-Huda, when I was just 11 years old. I was forced to wear hijab and chadar, which I literally hate it. To cut it short. Now I have become agnostic. As a film student, I agree with Shan that this film could become better if they have shown balanced screenplay with good cast like Khuda Ke Liye and My Name is Khan. In such sensitive topics, we need to highlight what real religion is and what people practice rather than showing radicalization, which Shan highlighted too. Though I am agnostic but I have respect for all religions.
THE REAL PROBLEM IS Dichotomy of Islam - Medina vs Mecca Islam where Religion of peace and love is Mecca Islam and Taliban & ISIS style Islam is Medina Islam - both preached and propagated by Prophet Muhammad
Bhaiya tum kaun si movie dekh ke aaye Kerala story ke naam pe....the movie i saw was housefull to a crying audience...it's brilliantly made unlike what u claim...the acting, screenplay plot everything was spot on I hope u weren't expecting something that had songs n daces
I loved the fact that you criticised the movie instead of attacking the story or plot. I saw many mallu youtubers slandering the movie just because of political differences. Wish we had more youtubers like you in kerala. 😌
@@arya5094 Kerala is one of the top 3 states in India with max number of Isis recruits and sleeper cells. There is rapid islamisation that is aided by govt in order to protect their vote bank. There are demographic changes. Shah Rukh saifi got local help from malayalis for the recent train burning incident and i hope you remember professor Joseph being brutally attacked for alleged blasphemy. The ariyum malarum slogans raised by a kid. So many incidents can vouch for the fact that there is growing radicalisation in the state. As someone who loves my state I want movies like this to spread awareness instead of trying to maintain a fake secular image in order to prove that we're superior to others.
@@arya5094 Do you have any idea about PFI and their Mission 2047 to push India into Islamic rule?? This organisation originated and has been most active in Kerala. So yeah this is definitely Kerala Story
@@arya5094 wake up. You do not know how much Islamic radicalisation is rooted in Kerala. Just because you aren't aware you think Kerala is being targeted. In my case, my college senior who was a christian is in an Afghan jail. Whole families from my native place went to Syria. I fear for the future of my state, and therefore I support the movie completely. Calling out the truth is not 'targetting'.
Thank you Shan, for reminding people that the gore-ness in the movie is not to appease anyone or for brownie points. I have seen many TH-camrs are saying, makers have shown too much of voilence. Not too much, I still remember, all this used to be release by ISIS a few years ago. I salute you for standing on reality, being NRI. We all have comfort, still we shouldn't ignore the sufferings other feel by just labeling it as market selling points - some did and it disappointed me. Good job, buddy.
I was blown away by the series "Caliphate" on Netflix , the way it dealt with the same theme set in Sweden n wondered when it would be made in Indian but sadly what we got is an amateur attempt to earn money through shock value. Throwing numbers like 32000 converted Indian women joining Isis which acc to un had at its peak a total membership of 40k, hiring incompetent actors and a screenplay so simplistic as if a 5th standard student is explaining grooming gangs to their juniors - it's just going to make the film look like a propaganda and help push the narrative of western media indirectly. Compare it even with the homegrown TKF, the treatment, the complex storyline, the nonlinear screenplay, the outstanding acting performances, which made it worthy of being showcased to international audience.
Girls and women who were trapped, converted and sent to these monsters camps are the ones who knows the truth about these things. I don't think any privilege person who know nothing about it can believe in this type stories.
Becoz competent people will never make such movies they are busy making movies like pathaan , tiger which white washes isi . Karan johar made my name is khan based on usa 🤣 treatment of peaceful community , but never had the guts to make something on hindus in pak or bang . So , we have to support whatever we are getting.
I have watched the film in theatre today. I have to say it was hard hitting. Everyone should watch it to know about the vicious snakes around us. Some performances were a bit lacking which can be ignored as the story is gut wrenching. As a matter of fact the number of such love jihad cases are around 50,000 mentioned in the post credit scene. Why the figure is approximately correct? - coz not all of them went to syria but most of them are staying in India and dying a silent death
Monotheistic faiths have special hatred for other faiths.. India was always a society which accepts various forms of the divine and hence doesn't believe in superiority whereas Monotheism Cannot live without imposing their will on others.. That's the difference between Monotheism and Polytheism..
@@motorcyclesdream6921 Monotheism breeds fanaticism, kindly see religious intolerance is more rampant in monotheistic breeds. And yes it made the Gujarat story, show how Muslim burned train
What research? He claims Akhila was a victim of 'Love Jihad' , when she converted voluntarily. He's basically peddled half baked conspiracy theories and exaggerations.
Can we accept the fact that shan is pro BJP and has been endorsing such movies that spread hatred against Muslims... Every other biopic or real life bollywood movie, he debunks and shits on...but something like this, suddenly he thinks bollywood is always true
And our own state govts r banning it n politicising it earger than helping adress the issue. Mamta Banerjee has banned it in west bengal and its also banned in Tamil nadu. ... Such a shame that they want to stop ppl frm gathering the true information and saving themselves in future. Ignorance is a bliss inke hisab se... Nahi manoge to issue exist hi nahi hota. Minority bol bol ke india ke majority victimised hote hain salon se and its the sad butter fact! Thanks Shan for your review!
This movie is less about acting or screenplay but more about presenting the ugly truth before audience & it ll encourage other genuinely talented makers & actors to create such contents which addresses such real issues..🙄 And that's the reason I might let go of the below average casting & technicalities of movie making... This was much needed subject & must have been a risky venture so 10/10 for showing the courage & would love to watch a movie based on "Ajmer case" but this time I ll expect a talented/experienced crew...😏
@@divyanshsingh7458 Well that's the least we can do to encourage such movies to come on theater otherwise one can always watch movies from great production houses like Dharma or Yeshraj or red chillies production who have grand budget for all the cast,location or cinematic technicalities...🤷♀️
True but imagine the impact it would have if it was actually a well made movie with much better dialogue execution and acting !! The viewing experience would be much more elevated. Films like Rang De Basanti or Kashmir Files had such a massive impact on audience because of effective storytelling and performances. If one is making a film on a true incident, I feel makers need to treat the subject more responsibly
@@asp11177 I agree & we can recommend such type of movies to international audiences without any hesitation but one need to understand movies like Rang de Basnati & TKF had massive impact because the former one was star studded with big budget & the later one even if didn't have huge budget it managed to impress us due to national award winning actors(For which one either has to have money or good networking to hire such legendary actors) So both had massive impact... So I am impressed despite having lack of Massive budget & absence of such renowned actors TKS team did put active effort to push the story & not to forget the constant treats they are facing right now, despite all that they were hell bent to release the movie... So for once let's js forget the cinematic experience & focus on the real issues this movie is trying to tell... Story is a story even if the storyteller is not so good at narrating it since it's based on true incidents I ll respect that effort Otherwise we do have really good story tellers who are so good at lying with movies like "Shikara" which is not the truth... Sorry for the essay but I think if we can excuse & watch cringe Bollywood movies then what's the harm in watching this movie for awareness...😌✌️👋
I appreciate the approach you have taken, addressing the fact that this is a problem but also calling the makers out where they have been irresponsible
as a Keralite , i have heard the things exactly like what was said in this movie , I was mentioning How They Talk about Ram and Krishna and they literally says I'm worshipping stones . as a leftie I pretended i like their religion and I'm concerned about the Days of Dajjal . and one day the person invited me to go to their mosque Gladly one of my Muslim friend prevented me from doing it , The Person told me that The Things You have Doing right Now is So Wrong . The Days Passed By I Started Ignoring The Radical Groups ( They Are Very Large in Number To Be Honest )
How naive! There was bomb attack on Maniratnam because he has shown love between Hindu male and Muslim female in Bombay movie. And here you are thinking there won’t be outrage when a movie shows how Muslims radicalise and convert people.
Liked the review very much.. only problem I felt about the movie as a keralite is the name.. it felt like the whole kerala's story is this😢.. when it's not.. also a request can u review the movie 2018? That is also kerala's story .. about 2018 flood..
This is my BIGGEST issue with movies that focuses on Hindu issues. None of the big film makers in Bollywood who are Hindu in real life like Bhansali or Sekhar Kapur don't want to be involved in such topics for fear of being "cancelled". Instead we have below average film makers handling such sensitive topics and as you said makes a "kichidi" of it.
For years pop culture was dominated by narrative set up by political patronage in Academia and Media.. It's only since 2014 that significant changes have come.. People have realised that there are economic incentives and similar markets for such movies.. Do you think movies like Tanhaji, Kashmir files, Kerala story would have been made before?
The movie is a text book on how cinematography should be done..how make up and stunts can be executed the girl abha has done a lot of body language variation chk her gait when she walks like a pregnant women also the messaging is so clear and yet the director has kept it entertaining ao in all the impact of the film is great absolutely as it throwa up many questions like why we hindus dont talk anout the glory of our religion with our kids?
Brother it focuses on Hindu issues coz first Hindu audience is the large audience in this county secondly facts that has happened with our Hindu women!! You make a movie on minority issues trust me no one with bother much. Movies are mainly for monetary reasons!!
Hindu issues ? How is this a Hindu issue? If moronic women convert to become radicals it's THEIR issue , the rest of us Hindus are not involved in it. Two of the girls that this movie is supposed to be based on were Christian and only one was Hindu.
Forced conversations do exist, but not at the level shown by positions or this movie. Thats the problem. Ruling party is going to use this as their tool and people will make these kind of half truth films and andhbhakt will watch them
Excellent review Shan Bhai, you kept it to the point and your frustration with this movie being a lost opportunity is clearly visible. I think the marketing of this film is aimed at striking a very base emotional chord of the audience- Ye agar wahan hua toh kal tumhaare saath bhi ho sakta hai. Regardless, the issue and the movie cannot be brushed aside as mere propaganda, thanks for acknowledging that shan bhai.
Every time he mentions kashmir files I get goosebumps and every time the Anupam Kher face come to mind that he was so helpless and. Couldn't get a justice 😭😭
I'm a Keralite, hindu staying in Malappuram. Here there is a dharka, for the yearly festival of 10 days, they will host a flag. This is kept in Zamoodiris temple. There is a temple and mosque nearby. Temple will contribute to Ramdan fasting rice sacks, the mosque will provide rice sacks for the temple festival. When people walk to sabarimala Muslims provide water in front of a mosque for those Hindu devotees. Mosque has a big entry arch board, temple recently build nearby don't have place, so the mosque committee gave the half portion for the temple and half is mosque name. Other minority people are getting converted to Hindusim as well. There is no such forced conversion to any religion over here. Like all other parts of the world in Kerala also there are extremists in all religions, compared to all other states we have pretty less. If you try to convert any girls over here, our girls are literate, independent , bold , discriminatory. They won't just run and convert like fools. BJP want to take Kerala and spoil in the name of religion. All the hindus and BJP followers please to understand their propaganda. Don't let someone enslave you in the name of religion and politics. Other states Indians, please don't ask about all these to BJP followers. They even don't know what they are saying. Anthbhakth.
I think the issue this movie raises is absolutely attention worthy, at the same time , I'd say that this movie is and will be used as a propaganda tool, and will be used to spread already widespread hate towards a particular community, at the same time putting up posters of osama bin laden at the campus of a nursing clg in a state in india(which is arguably the most progressive and peaceful state) gives clear red flag to the intention of the makers of this movie
Nice review Shan bhai i thought u might be a bit radicalised by the movie but your review was on point. The topic of the movie was on point and it is an issue but the route it chooses to express it and the astonishing number it says it makes it very radicalising and in the movie also it tries to radicalise the issue many times…..while this should target the wrong people in a community it kind of targets a whole community is what I think
@@siddharthverma8975 not entire community is bad but are majority of this particular community even Criticize this islamic terrorism,conversion? They will stand and cry for Palestinians and muslim population in and out of india. will they stand for the same suppression bad happened to Kashmiri pandit? or do they even stand for kanhaiya lal who was killed by their beloved community Man?!
@@chiragparsoya3754 all criminal activities should be condemned, but your research is quite biased. BTW are u aware how many police officers and bsf soldiers are killed every year by naxalite?? Probably not cos ur hatred towards one community is quite strong. Chhattisgarh govt had released 130 odd names of naxalite, all were Hindus. Also when Aekhlaq was tied to a pole on his wedding night and continously beaten by multiple men forcing him to chant "Jai Shree Ram", he died that night though. But nobody called these acts as hindu terrorism. Ur hate towards Muslim Community is so strong, that no matter what happens ull just blame muslims
They don't have the budget , the support , the stars or the marketing all they have is the public sentiment we can't blame them bollywood people never took these topics so now people are portraying these topics in the most simplistic and cheapest manner . At least they are not showing isi as insaniyat ke khidmatgar or pak terrorist doing business in india .
I had a Muslim friend who has told me there is only one god, Allah. They don't believe in existence of Hindu god or nationalism. He said we never say Bharat mata ki jai because here we are referring to our motherland as a goddess, and it's not acceptable to them. And it shook me to see how deeply they identify and differentiate things which are appropriate to them or not. We are so blinded by secularism that we refuse to see what is really happening infront of us. Please watch this movie. It will educate you and help you to come out of the fairytale stories that we were watching all this while. I am not being Islamophobic here but just supporting my own people.
What does not suit one’s agenda is brushed off as propaganda. One should think objectively and decided for oneself instead of being left sided or right sided .
Hats off man! Everything is not black or white!! There are many gray areas and that's what you exactly cover! Even if there is a single case and not 32000 cases. It must be covered and should be in the limelight!!
First time i disagree with your review, the movie is highly impactful and will not be forgotten for a long time . Hats off to ppl for bringing the conversion issue in open - nobody believes it but it happens
Liked your review and Nicely said Shan bhai but i think that number 32k is difficult to track could be right as well. as many of these girls were not directly taken to isis, syria locations so might be thats why even GOI also dont have the exact number or number is less. As they were taken to other saudi nations or srilanka type countries and from thr they were taken to these locations so how a missing girl will be tracked.
Absolutely right. I personally know girls age 15 and above from different states who were brainwashed, converted, and disappeared or were sold as wives to multiple Muslim men. The anti- Hindu DMK has banned the movie in Tamil Nadu today. Hindi states must ban Tamil movies in their states
great review. all kinds of stories should be told, doesnt matter how uncomfortable they are. I think the problem with this movie is the title coz its a global issue. Systematic brainwashing is not only faced by non-muslims but muslims as well. I think it would be interesting to listen to your take on a movie named Khuda ke liye.
Hi Shan, can say this is the only review of yours I disagree with! Yes screenplay is not comparable to TKF but we need to understand who does the grooming and conversion? Isn’t it Muslims? Or is it people from some other community who do it? I know you have a considerable chunk of Muslims viewers where you won’t like to lose them too, but I will honestly disagree on this take, and yes most of people cried in cinema hall we went to and I talked to few Keralite girls and they said yes it infact happens like this and it’s no hate but it’s just touching the surface! Will wait for your other reviews!
before pointing to the movie’s bad acting and story writing , which I think is good enough, we should support these kind of logical movies. when PK or OMG released nobody found there tobe ashamed of talking illogical ,directly pointing to our religion, where in this film they only shows a topic never accused the whole religion.
i like your reviews in general so no offense but if u think 32 from a state ko 32000 from a state bolke state of defame karna or fear create karna towards specific community is not propaganda then i disagree bro
Nobody is denying the fact that conversions and forced conversions happen. But adding the name 'Kerala' in the title makes no sense. More such conversions have happened in Aditya Nath's UP than in Kerala. So naming this film like this and exaggerating the conversion numbers is nothing but propaganda to tarnish Kerala's image and spread more fear about Kerala among north Indians. Kerala is one of the best states in India when it comes to communal harmony, yet many north Indians think that it is some ISIS hub where Hindus are unsafe. But in reality, we live in harmony here, except a few bad eggs from every religion.
32k was not mentioned in way of all 32k girls were from India 2k plus girls were from India and kerela the name was given becoz the director had some research over there , may be the original women who told this story was from Kerala or multiple women who told their stories were from Kerala. This doesn't tarnish any image of Kerala , Kerala still holds our traditions and culture really vibrant. We can't blame the people of Kerala for this , we just have to be more vigilant and strict about what's going on in colleges and universities.
The Hindus instead of appreciating the Kerela story team for taking up such a risky venture r now talking Abt the nuances of the film what a joke ....no so called big producer/ director / actor wanted to b a part if this film due to the topic ..we r discussing Abt the small mistakes tht have been done in the film ... pathetic .. atleast we shld b happy tht we r getting such films & Vivek Agnihotri kind started this trend & saying the directors as nt of top level really speaks of people's sick mind .
Until sometime ago I used to watch TRP reviews thinking he s best unbiased reviewer out there( maybe cause of his dialect of speaking english made me convincing) but his review of kerala story has proved me wrong. Plus his orgasmic videos about a mediocre pathan movie. But u r genuine bro❤️
See he has grown up in a fairly urban elite area where people are surrounded by coconuts.. These people don't have ground reality experiences mostly.. Also the whitewashed Secularised history effected the elites who have already grown up in comfortable areas..
I just watched this movie today in DC and I am still shaking being a father of 2 girls ( One of them is going to College in another state). Movie is great and I want this movie should be in English and reach to the global audience.
I watched the film i agree with you but the other two girl did great acting mainly in the last. I honestly feel like they could have go in deep and the bgm would have been better and honestly i cried in the hall feel like being a girl i getting raped and forced to chng my religion. I really want every non hindu girl to watch this movie
Movie has a poor screenplay, casting, etc (like you mentioned) because it needed to be released at particular time. Serious topic but not justified by the filmmakers just for the sake of upcoming elections in Karnataka. Now Karnataka people can be scared with a line dekho apke sath bhi aisa ho sakta hai. Sab ch*tiya bana rahe hai.
To those claiming this movie as a propaganda or islamophobe need to realise this is not a recent case ,since 2009 several Christian organisations have repeatedly filed cases in court against this conversions in Kerala . Those barking for the inaccurate no also need to shut the faak up because why even a single girl needs to go through this trauma harassment This movie in a blunt way has ruffled this leechs of the society
Well i knew these things about 5 years ago its not a surprise for me coz i have been avidly following these issues so just kudos to the people who thought of making it a mass movie......
The Kashmir Files mein jis topic par baat kiya gaya tha, woh convincing lagaa by the script, actors, cinematography, writing and the colour palette. But Kerala Story mein kuch bhi acha nahi hain
It is not appropriate to criticize the technicality of the move given that it is raising a topic that helps improve lives. Encourage everyone to watch this movie rather raising patty points. Thing greater good
It would have been better if they didn’t used such misleading figures and if would have been better if they keep more neutral balance between 2 communities in the movie they are not telling the story of 3 girls but using it as a tool 🔨 to target the entire community koi ek single aware Banda nhi dikha muslim jo ishe galat bata reha ho every single Muslim character in the movie 🍿 is acting like crazy extremist as a evil and this movie is also promoting political ideology.
@@pratikdas6133 Yes bhai hmare up mein Ram Ram aur Jai Shree Ram blkr hi greet hti h bht jgh to bhai mera ph mera cmnt bhai tjhe blna h to bol le wrna bhai hr jgh tang mt ghusa
Actually abhi mujhe lagta hai ai BJP ka slogan ban gaya hai. Isi liye sri ram ko bhi achha nehi lagega k unke naam ka koi mis use kare. Har har mahadev bolo Jay sri krishna bolo Jay durga ma bolo.
Only 3 women's converted in ISIS from kerala (2 Christian & 1 Hinduism) 🇮🇳my United India (shik + Muslim + Hinduism + Christian) Don't be selfish on politics
What about the disclaimer that says cinematic liberty has been taken in the movie. So how do we know how much of it was the truth and in which parts cinematic liberty has been taken? When dealing with important sensitive issues disclaimers like these just dilute the entire seriousness...
The motive of the film is not to give you information about the case. The motive is to attract your attention to the issue . Now as an educated citizen it's your responsibility to investigate and research for more information.
U need not to depend on movie to know the truth .. just get the idea ki asa kch ho raha hai … fir different sources se dekho na ki kitna kya intensity hai … abhi m.p. Se retired police hai unhone b btya tha ki rate card hote hain … jaise agar brahimn ko convert kroge toh jada paise milnge , different rates for different girls ..
@@soorajtr6692 that's your assumption after seeing udta Punjab nobody started hating Punjab . Uttar Pradesh and Bihar everyday we see in bad light but that doesn't mean the rest of the country started hating those states or boycotted those states . If that is so why UK , US news channels show such news . Does that mean they themselves are defaming their own countries. When films webseries shows Pujari from mandir as rapist pedophile does everyone start saying that pujari are defamed . Till date Brahmans were targeted in every second movie does that defamed bramhans? Army was soft target of Bollywood from mission Kashmir to Haider . Even sympathized with terrorists. Army didn't say it is defaming them. And if a movie targeting ISIS , a terrorist organization why are people of Kerala getting offended ? Show me people who said a word against Kerala State or its people after watching this movie.
@@MsCvb85 Exactly.. when u r drawing attention of general public towards such an important and sensitive topic u cannot take cinematic liberty. 95% of the cinegoers are not going to go back and read more abt the topic. They r just going to believe what was shown n u cannot deny this fact. So the team has to be more responsible in getting entire story right. Cannot take liberty in such topics at least which are so important...
before making movie reviews u should study more and do more research about how the film was made 😡 no good actors and even technicians was ready to work with sudipto sen in this movie . so how can u expect good casting ???? 😡
The प्रॉब्लम is that.. कर्नाटक चुनाव सामने hai.. The इशू is that.. की is time पे मूवी रिलीज़ करने का रीज़न ही पोलिटिकल hai.. रह गयी बात 32000 लड़कियों की...its फेक... i have नो पोलिटिकल agression or favourism....you हैंडलेड it d बेस्ट वे.... Always with you... शान sir🙏
It's propaganda not because of Hindus forced conversion but because of incorrect marketing causing hype as in 32k. That number was solely mentioned to create mass hysteria among people. Shan could've easily reviewed the BBC documentary on Modi as he's in Canada but chose not to. Playing safe? Yogi adityanath and sadhvi pragya giving hate speeches against other communities?? Just to be clear I don't support forced conversions, The perpetrators responsible even for one forced conversion should be punished
Subscribe to Honestly Saying Podcast - youtube.com/@HonestlySayingPodcast
P.S. while Modi Story was banned in college campuses and kids beaten up by right wing groups, Kerala story was peacefully aired in the very same college. So, saying there is no propagand looks too simplistic view of the issue.
Bro is desh ki current politics ko samajho fir aisi movies ko us context me dekho
Tere saath problem ye hai kya ki tu apnae aap ko bhaut zada technically sound prove karna chahta hai. Hai tu Lund. Aukaat main reh, Hindi medium ka kutta, dont fake it bro.
Ur such a hypocrite man terko kuch bola to tu muh utha ke bakwas krne aa gya abusive b ho gya ab smjhaya to ek shabd ni bc terko genuine smjha tha re mai but u r just an egoistic person bro....😂😂😂😂 I feel sorry for u man
Or merko pta h tu ab aaega b to fir abusive hi hoga kyuki Teri real personality hi whi h 😂😂 and thats why i feel sorry for u....sbko criticize krne wala apni 1% criticism ni sun skta lol
In my school there were two muslims girls who always used talk high about their own religion and in every topic they used to bring their religion , so in movie whatever they have shown is totally a reality.
See ex muslim chennal and ask them questions about thier religion they will shut thier mouth.
Ask about what is kafir
Kafir ke sath kya Krna chahiye
Why they are mostly radical why hizab
Why no right for women in muslim country Afghanistan and iran
Happened in my class too, also whenever a new student took admission into our class, they'll ask him/her if they were Hindu or Muslim.
Same here I also meet a Muslim South Indian girl in my colleg who used to act same like u hv described
same here but in college … she always used to tell about the the rights of women under islam and she used to send religious videos and lectures on our whtsapp grp … she was very religious used to wear niqab and gloves ..but not everyone is same .. i have 2 muslims frnd they are very nice nd sweet but i have to mention they are not very religious and belongs to other sect like ahemadi or something..
What u failed to understand, there is a difference between religion and people, I saw on the trailer, Muslim guy saying if you have to sleep with them and make them pregnant then do it, in Islam it's forbidden to look at random women who is not ur wife or mom or sis and others within these relationships, let alone sleep with them. When I saw Islam is getting presented like this, it's a sad and false image. So first y'all need to separate Islam from terrorist culture this movie is portraying.
The Biggest joke of this Century.
"Islam is a Peaceful Religion"😂😂😂😂😂😂
Yes and another best joke is that praying stone is religion😂
Yeah those jokers pray to a big black stone in m a c c a
@@Kushiiiiiiiiiiii lol we did not pray to the macca we pray to God who created that
@@naziachhipa go marry 9 year olds and ur cousins😆
I'm from Tamilnadu here very very few theaters have this movie.. guess what it's also only in Hindi.. in entire vellor district only 2 theaters have this movie that too only one show each theater.. even if ppl wants to see they have only Hindi option.. majority of ppl here don't know Hindi.. ppl are waiting to see the movie in OTT in Tamil.. Entire DMK government is anti Hindu government they openly say its against minority we won't allow.. guess what 90% of theaters owned by DMK.. only God have to save us from these monsters
What like are you prosecuted, stopped from going to temples, not allowed to celebrate your festivals in school.
Stop whining.
They are like Congress generation after generation enjoy power and you all are responsible for your misery. Don't vote that bakwas party.
Brother you don't know how lucky you are. One day you are gonna realise it.
You can by not voting for them
Thought Kerala people were most religious shame on them to suppress this
As a Pakistani, I was a victim as well. I was born as a Muslim, but I was not religious. I used to ask critical questions about religion. My mother then joined Islamic Organisation, Al-Huda, when I was just 11 years old. I was forced to wear hijab and chadar, which I literally hate it.
To cut it short. Now I have become agnostic.
As a film student, I agree with Shan that this film could become better if they have shown balanced screenplay with good cast like Khuda Ke Liye and My Name is Khan. In such sensitive topics, we need to highlight what real religion is and what people practice rather than showing radicalization, which Shan highlighted too.
Though I am agnostic but I have respect for all religions.
Whether women want to wear hijab or not is a POV. There are many women who want to wear it and many who dont. Forcing anyone to do anything isnt goodm
I am agnostic and I don't hate people just because they belong to a particular religion. But I hate the concept of religion
Hey..Islam is always there..if you like it or hate it..same like another religion..
THE REAL PROBLEM IS Dichotomy of Islam - Medina vs Mecca Islam where Religion of peace and love is Mecca Islam and Taliban & ISIS style Islam is Medina Islam - both preached and propagated by Prophet Muhammad
@@nabeelbhattacharya2633 Quran 98:6
Non muslims (kaafirs) are the worst of all beings ....
Watch ex muslim sahil
“Silence is a lie that screams at the light.” ― Shannon Alder.
Dream is a lie that sleeps in a utter darkness😢😢😢
@@viveksingh-eo6pu Teri bhen k saath kuch aesa hoga tab boliyo funny movie h librandu kahi ke
@@viveksingh-eo6pu madarchophet madarhammmad
Bhaiya tum kaun si movie dekh ke aaye Kerala story ke naam pe....the movie i saw was housefull to a crying audience...it's brilliantly made unlike what u claim...the acting, screenplay plot everything was spot on
I hope u weren't expecting something that had songs n daces
I loved the fact that you criticised the movie instead of attacking the story or plot. I saw many mallu youtubers slandering the movie just because of political differences. Wish we had more youtubers like you in kerala. 😌
@@arya5094 Kerala is one of the top 3 states in India with max number of Isis recruits and sleeper cells. There is rapid islamisation that is aided by govt in order to protect their vote bank. There are demographic changes.
Shah Rukh saifi got local help from malayalis for the recent train burning incident and i hope you remember professor Joseph being brutally attacked for alleged blasphemy. The ariyum malarum slogans raised by a kid. So many incidents can vouch for the fact that there is growing radicalisation in the state. As someone who loves my state I want movies like this to spread awareness instead of trying to maintain a fake secular image in order to prove that we're superior to others.
@@arya5094 Do you have any idea about PFI and their Mission 2047 to push India into Islamic rule?? This organisation originated and has been most active in Kerala. So yeah this is definitely Kerala Story
@@arya5094 Only Kerala is the home to organizations like SIMI, PFI, etc.
@@arya5094yes
@@arya5094 wake up.
You do not know how much Islamic radicalisation is rooted in Kerala. Just because you aren't aware you think Kerala is being targeted. In my case, my college senior who was a christian is in an Afghan jail. Whole families from my native place went to Syria. I fear for the future of my state, and therefore I support the movie completely.
Calling out the truth is not 'targetting'.
Thank you Shan, for reminding people that the gore-ness in the movie is not to appease anyone or for brownie points. I have seen many TH-camrs are saying, makers have shown too much of voilence. Not too much, I still remember, all this used to be release by ISIS a few years ago. I salute you for standing on reality, being NRI. We all have comfort, still we shouldn't ignore the sufferings other feel by just labeling it as market selling points - some did and it disappointed me.
Good job, buddy.
It actually happened to a family member of mine... Luckily we got her just in time...
I was blown away by the series "Caliphate" on Netflix , the way it dealt with the same theme set in Sweden n wondered when it would be made in Indian but sadly what we got is an amateur attempt to earn money through shock value. Throwing numbers like 32000 converted Indian women joining Isis which acc to un had at its peak a total membership of 40k, hiring incompetent actors and a screenplay so simplistic as if a 5th standard student is explaining grooming gangs to their juniors - it's just going to make the film look like a propaganda and help push the narrative of western media indirectly. Compare it even with the homegrown TKF, the treatment, the complex storyline, the nonlinear screenplay, the outstanding acting performances, which made it worthy of being showcased to international audience.
Girls and women who were trapped, converted and sent to these monsters camps are the ones who knows the truth about these things. I don't think any privilege person who know nothing about it can believe in this type stories.
Agreed kerla story was cheap
TFK was good movie
Becoz competent people will never make such movies they are busy making movies like pathaan , tiger which white washes isi . Karan johar made my name is khan based on usa 🤣 treatment of peaceful community , but never had the guts to make something on hindus in pak or bang . So , we have to support whatever we are getting.
Stupid person(not wasting much mental capacity on you)
I’m India, it needs a lot of guts, the makers/actor already death threats so you need to appreciate whatever you got which has its heart in place
I have watched the film in theatre today. I have to say it was hard hitting. Everyone should watch it to know about the vicious snakes around us. Some performances were a bit lacking which can be ignored as the story is gut wrenching. As a matter of fact the number of such love jihad cases are around 50,000 mentioned in the post credit scene. Why the figure is approximately correct? - coz not all of them went to syria but most of them are staying in India and dying a silent death
Monotheistic faiths have special hatred for other faiths.. India was always a society which accepts various forms of the divine and hence doesn't believe in superiority whereas Monotheism Cannot live without imposing their will on others..
That's the difference between Monotheism and Polytheism..
@@motorcyclesdream6921 Monotheism breeds fanaticism, kindly see religious intolerance is more rampant in monotheistic breeds.
And yes it made the Gujarat story, show how Muslim burned train
Can we admire the fact that Shan puts in his research to make us aware of all entire things ❤❤ Love your hardwork!!
R
ghanta, 32k number is bullshit.
Dhruv rathee ka video dekh k research karni chahiye thi aur ab to director ne movie k description me 32000 no. Hata diya
What research? He claims Akhila was a victim of 'Love Jihad' , when she converted voluntarily. He's basically peddled half baked conspiracy theories and exaggerations.
Can we accept the fact that shan is pro BJP and has been endorsing such movies that spread hatred against Muslims... Every other biopic or real life bollywood movie, he debunks and shits on...but something like this, suddenly he thinks bollywood is always true
First The Kashmiri Files and now The Kerala Story. Good to see someone have a courage to make a film on this issue.
And our own state govts r banning it n politicising it earger than helping adress the issue. Mamta Banerjee has banned it in west bengal and its also banned in Tamil nadu. ... Such a shame that they want to stop ppl frm gathering the true information and saving themselves in future. Ignorance is a bliss inke hisab se... Nahi manoge to issue exist hi nahi hota. Minority bol bol ke india ke majority victimised hote hain salon se and its the sad butter fact! Thanks Shan for your review!
Great Shan bhai! Finally a youtuber who isn't afraid of getting cancelled by the lutyens lobby.
This movie is less about acting or screenplay but more about presenting the ugly truth before audience & it ll encourage other genuinely talented makers & actors to create such contents which addresses such real issues..🙄
And that's the reason I might let go of the below average casting & technicalities of movie making...
This was much needed subject & must have been a risky venture so 10/10 for showing the courage & would love to watch a movie based on "Ajmer case" but this time I ll expect a talented/experienced crew...😏
It's a one time watch movie
@@divyanshsingh7458 Well that's the least we can do to encourage such movies to come on theater otherwise one can always watch movies from great production houses like Dharma or Yeshraj or red chillies production who have grand budget for all the cast,location or cinematic technicalities...🤷♀️
True but imagine the impact it would have if it was actually a well made movie with much better dialogue execution and acting !! The viewing experience would be much more elevated. Films like Rang De Basanti or Kashmir Files had such a massive impact on audience because of effective storytelling and performances. If one is making a film on a true incident, I feel makers need to treat the subject more responsibly
@@asp11177 I agree & we can recommend such type of movies to international audiences without any hesitation but one need to understand movies like Rang de Basnati & TKF had massive impact because the former one was star studded with big budget & the later one even if didn't have huge budget it managed to impress us due to national award winning actors(For which one either has to have money or good networking to hire such legendary actors) So both had massive impact...
So I am impressed despite having lack of Massive budget & absence of such renowned actors TKS team did put active effort to push the story & not to forget the constant treats they are facing right now, despite all that they were hell bent to release the movie...
So for once let's js forget the cinematic experience & focus on the real issues this movie is trying to tell...
Story is a story even if the storyteller is not so good at narrating it since it's based on true incidents I ll respect that effort Otherwise we do have really good story tellers who are so good at lying with movies like "Shikara" which is not the truth...
Sorry for the essay but I think if we can excuse & watch cringe Bollywood movies then what's the harm in watching this movie for awareness...😌✌️👋
I appreciate the approach you have taken, addressing the fact that this is a problem but also calling the makers out where they have been irresponsible
Well rounded approach Shan bhai! That is exactly why people follow you. Keep it going!
as a Keralite , i have heard the things exactly like what was said in this movie , I was mentioning How They Talk about Ram and Krishna and they literally says I'm worshipping stones . as a leftie I pretended i like their religion and I'm concerned about the Days of Dajjal . and one day the person invited me to go to their mosque Gladly one of my Muslim friend prevented me from doing it , The Person told me that The Things You have Doing right Now is So Wrong . The Days Passed By I Started Ignoring The Radical Groups ( They Are Very Large in Number To Be Honest )
If someone says you guys worship stones.
Simple reply
You guys pray a imagination of 57 year old guy .
@@divi406 🎉hard hain
If they had not included Kerala in the film title, there would hardly be any controversy 😂. The same way Udta Punjab caused trouble.
So true man 😂😂 soo true !!!!!?
No true
How naive!
There was bomb attack on Maniratnam because he has shown love between Hindu male and Muslim female in Bombay movie. And here you are thinking there won’t be outrage when a movie shows how Muslims radicalise and convert people.
ya kerla ki jaga pakistan daalte hena 🙄
By your logic the controversy had been only in Kerala and not in the whole country
Liked the review very much.. only problem I felt about the movie as a keralite is the name.. it felt like the whole kerala's story is this😢.. when it's not.. also a request can u review the movie 2018? That is also kerala's story .. about 2018 flood..
I have watched it and literally that one is well made movie
This is my BIGGEST issue with movies that focuses on Hindu issues. None of the big film makers in Bollywood who are Hindu in real life like Bhansali or Sekhar Kapur don't want to be involved in such topics for fear of being "cancelled". Instead we have below average film makers handling such sensitive topics and as you said makes a "kichidi" of it.
For years pop culture was dominated by narrative set up by political patronage in Academia and Media..
It's only since 2014 that significant changes have come.. People have realised that there are economic incentives and similar markets for such movies..
Do you think movies like Tanhaji, Kashmir files, Kerala story would have been made before?
The movie is a text book on how cinematography should be done..how make up and stunts can be executed the girl abha has done a lot of body language variation chk her gait when she walks like a pregnant women also the messaging is so clear and yet the director has kept it entertaining ao in all the impact of the film is great absolutely as it throwa up many questions like why we hindus dont talk anout the glory of our religion with our kids?
Brother it focuses on Hindu issues coz first Hindu audience is the large audience in this county secondly facts that has happened with our Hindu women!! You make a movie on minority issues trust me no one with bother much. Movies are mainly for monetary reasons!!
Hindu issues ? How is this a Hindu issue? If moronic women convert to become radicals it's THEIR issue , the rest of us Hindus are not involved in it. Two of the girls that this movie is supposed to be based on were Christian and only one was Hindu.
@@Canyouseemeanna true. i m glad that these movies are getting a platform.
Forced conversations do exist, but not at the level shown by positions or this movie. Thats the problem. Ruling party is going to use this as their tool and people will make these kind of half truth films and andhbhakt will watch them
More than any other reviewer, I believe Shan Prasher. He is building a subscriber base of loyal people because of his quality writing.
Thanks Shan bhai. I had faith that you would give an honest opinion on the film instead of catering to any side. Love you bro because of this ❤❤
Your opinions are unbiased and savage, keep it up Shan 🙏
Excellent review Shan Bhai, you kept it to the point and your frustration with this movie being a lost opportunity is clearly visible. I think the marketing of this film is aimed at striking a very base emotional chord of the audience- Ye agar wahan hua toh kal tumhaare saath bhi ho sakta hai. Regardless, the issue and the movie cannot be brushed aside as mere propaganda, thanks for acknowledging that shan bhai.
Every time he mentions kashmir files I get goosebumps and every time the Anupam Kher face come to mind that he was so helpless and. Couldn't get a justice 😭😭
Bhai anupam kher is a seasoned actor. It would be unfair to compare novices in this movie. ...
Problem was filmmaker marketed as some bullshit number and too much masala showed it's a propaganda
I'm a Keralite, hindu staying in Malappuram. Here there is a dharka, for the yearly festival of 10 days, they will host a flag. This is kept in Zamoodiris temple. There is a temple and mosque nearby. Temple will contribute to Ramdan fasting rice sacks, the mosque will provide rice sacks for the temple festival.
When people walk to sabarimala Muslims provide water in front of a mosque for those Hindu devotees. Mosque has a big entry arch board, temple recently build nearby don't have place, so the mosque committee gave the half portion for the temple and half is mosque name.
Other minority people are getting converted to Hindusim as well. There is no such forced conversion to any religion over here.
Like all other parts of the world in Kerala also there are extremists in all religions, compared to all other states we have pretty less. If you try to convert any girls over here, our girls are literate, independent , bold , discriminatory. They won't just run and convert like fools. BJP want to take Kerala and spoil in the name of religion. All the hindus and BJP followers please to understand their propaganda. Don't let someone enslave you in the name of religion and politics. Other states Indians, please don't ask about all these to BJP followers. They even don't know what they are saying. Anthbhakth.
I think the issue this movie raises is absolutely attention worthy, at the same time , I'd say that this movie is and will be used as a propaganda tool, and will be used to spread already widespread hate towards a particular community, at the same time putting up posters of osama bin laden at the campus of a nursing clg in a state in india(which is arguably the most progressive and peaceful state) gives clear red flag to the intention of the makers of this movie
Problem is they say it's 32000, extreme exaggeration and generalisation of all Muslims!! This is why it is controversial
Nice review Shan bhai i thought u might be a bit radicalised by the movie but your review was on point. The topic of the movie was on point and it is an issue but the route it chooses to express it and the astonishing number it says it makes it very radicalising and in the movie also it tries to radicalise the issue many times…..while this should target the wrong people in a community it kind of targets a whole community is what I think
Issue should've been raised, but painting an entire community with the same color makes the intention of the makers absolutely clear
@@siddharthverma8975 not entire community is bad but are majority of this particular community even Criticize this islamic terrorism,conversion? They will stand and cry for Palestinians and muslim population in and out of india. will they stand for the same suppression bad happened to Kashmiri pandit? or do they even stand for kanhaiya lal who was killed by their beloved community Man?!
@@chiragparsoya3754 all criminal activities should be condemned, but your research is quite biased. BTW are u aware how many police officers and bsf soldiers are killed every year by naxalite?? Probably not cos ur hatred towards one community is quite strong. Chhattisgarh govt had released 130 odd names of naxalite, all were Hindus. Also when Aekhlaq was tied to a pole on his wedding night and continously beaten by multiple men forcing him to chant "Jai Shree Ram", he died that night though. But nobody called these acts as hindu terrorism. Ur hate towards Muslim Community is so strong, that no matter what happens ull just blame muslims
They don't have the budget , the support , the stars or the marketing all they have is the public sentiment we can't blame them bollywood people never took these topics so now people are portraying these topics in the most simplistic and cheapest manner . At least they are not showing isi as insaniyat ke khidmatgar or pak terrorist doing business in india .
Always unbaised and speaks facts .
That's why your style of review is best 🙌🙌🙌🙌 🙏
I had a Muslim friend who has told me there is only one god, Allah. They don't believe in existence of Hindu god or nationalism. He said we never say Bharat mata ki jai because here we are referring to our motherland as a goddess, and it's not acceptable to them. And it shook me to see how deeply they identify and differentiate things which are appropriate to them or not.
We are so blinded by secularism that we refuse to see what is really happening infront of us.
Please watch this movie. It will educate you and help you to come out of the fairytale stories that we were watching all this while.
I am not being Islamophobic here but just supporting my own people.
Absolutely correct and said with the good words 👍 This is how I feel too.
What does not suit one’s agenda is brushed off as propaganda. One should think objectively and decided for oneself instead of being left sided or right sided .
Hats off man! Everything is not black or white!! There are many gray areas and that's what you exactly cover! Even if there is a single case and not 32000 cases. It must be covered and should be in the limelight!!
First time i disagree with your review, the movie is highly impactful and will not be forgotten for a long time . Hats off to ppl for bringing the conversion issue in open - nobody believes it but it happens
Liked your review and Nicely said Shan bhai but i think that number 32k is difficult to track could be right as well. as many of these girls were not directly taken to isis, syria locations so might be thats why even GOI also dont have the exact number or number is less. As they were taken to other saudi nations or srilanka type countries and from thr they were taken to these locations so how a missing girl will be tracked.
Shan review is always spot on and clear cut 👏🏻
Dude!! On point!!!! u spoke like true reviewer....isko film ki tarah dekha aur review kiya na ki bhavnao mein behkey .....bht hi sahi review ❤
Absolutely right. I personally know girls age 15 and above from different states who were brainwashed, converted, and disappeared or were sold as wives to multiple Muslim men.
The anti- Hindu DMK has banned the movie in Tamil Nadu today. Hindi states must ban Tamil movies in their states
great review. all kinds of stories should be told, doesnt matter how uncomfortable they are.
I think the problem with this movie is the title coz its a global issue.
Systematic brainwashing is not only faced by non-muslims but muslims as well.
I think it would be interesting to listen to your take on a movie named
Khuda ke liye.
u r one in million.
Strongly support the Kerala story ...saare desh ko and specially all d indian girls should watch this movie
OTT pe achi perform karegi. While all shows of the movie are housefull in theaters 😂
Clearly disagree with your review! Adah Sharma has acted well. Screenplay wasn’t great but the movie made its impact
Hi Shan, can say this is the only review of yours I disagree with! Yes screenplay is not comparable to TKF but we need to understand who does the grooming and conversion? Isn’t it Muslims? Or is it people from some other community who do it? I know you have a considerable chunk of Muslims viewers where you won’t like to lose them too, but I will honestly disagree on this take, and yes most of people cried in cinema hall we went to and I talked to few Keralite girls and they said yes it infact happens like this and it’s no hate but it’s just touching the surface! Will wait for your other reviews!
before pointing to the movie’s bad acting and story writing , which I think is good enough, we should support these kind of logical movies.
when PK or OMG released nobody found there tobe ashamed of talking illogical ,directly pointing to our religion, where in this film they only shows a topic never accused the whole religion.
i like your reviews in general so no offense but if u think 32 from a state ko 32000 from a state bolke state of defame karna or fear create karna towards specific community is not propaganda then i disagree bro
This is true, we have to stop this global problem
Kerala Story movie will go global
It should be released globally ....
More than film i wait for your Review Shan bhai.. unbiased, honest and up to the mark review. Thank you for all of it✨
32,0000 is global number of girls not the number of girls only from india. The UN estimates is around 45k plus..
Nobody is denying the fact that conversions and forced conversions happen. But adding the name 'Kerala' in the title makes no sense. More such conversions have happened in Aditya Nath's UP than in Kerala. So naming this film like this and exaggerating the conversion numbers is nothing but propaganda to tarnish Kerala's image and spread more fear about Kerala among north Indians. Kerala is one of the best states in India when it comes to communal harmony, yet many north Indians think that it is some ISIS hub where Hindus are unsafe. But in reality, we live in harmony here, except a few bad eggs from every religion.
32k was not mentioned in way of all 32k girls were from India 2k plus girls were from India and kerela the name was given becoz the director had some research over there , may be the original women who told this story was from Kerala or multiple women who told their stories were from Kerala. This doesn't tarnish any image of Kerala , Kerala still holds our traditions and culture really vibrant. We can't blame the people of Kerala for this , we just have to be more vigilant and strict about what's going on in colleges and universities.
Each & every point is bang on shan. every time you prove that how a real review should be keep doing this
The Hindus instead of appreciating the Kerela story team for taking up such a risky venture r now talking Abt the nuances of the film what a joke ....no so called big producer/ director / actor wanted to b a part if this film due to the topic ..we r discussing Abt the small mistakes tht have been done in the film ... pathetic .. atleast we shld b happy tht we r getting such films & Vivek Agnihotri kind started this trend & saying the directors as nt of top level really speaks of people's sick mind .
Respect+++ for Shan 👑🙏🏽
he is the same person who praised pathaan lol
You taking more time to upload this video itself proves that you prioritize quality and truth over propaganda and false review.
Until sometime ago I used to watch TRP reviews thinking he s best unbiased reviewer out there( maybe cause of his dialect of speaking english made me convincing) but his review of kerala story has proved me wrong. Plus his orgasmic videos about a mediocre pathan movie. But u r genuine bro❤️
Anupama Chopra ka kutta hai bhai vo.... Just bcoz you know the Language doesn't mean you have the knowledge ( referring TRP)!
Same here . The day he collaborated with Anupama Chopra I understood his game. So I withdrew myself .
He's a very clever guy, tries to play both sides but he is oversmart, thinks the people can't catch the way he subtly slips in his biased narrative.
@@MsCvb85 He is anupama chopra's lapdog
See he has grown up in a fairly urban elite area where people are surrounded by coconuts..
These people don't have ground reality experiences mostly.. Also the whitewashed Secularised history effected the elites who have already grown up in comfortable areas..
Love your reviews brother, you are genuinely honest and unbiased as always. Mudda thik tha par gimmicky portray kiya gaya hai. 👍
What's meaning of ur name
Pathaan ka screenplay pasand aaya tha tumhe but isme issue hai
Bro one question. How did u watched this movie if u r living outside india. Is it released outside also?
Thank you bro, for not looking the other way and ignore the film.
I just watched this movie today in DC and I am still shaking being a father of 2 girls ( One of them is going to College in another state). Movie is great and I want this movie should be in English and reach to the global audience.
I watched the film i agree with you but the other two girl did great acting mainly in the last. I honestly feel like they could have go in deep and the bgm would have been better and honestly i cried in the hall feel like being a girl i getting raped and forced to chng my religion. I really want every non hindu girl to watch this movie
If you think that the cast didn’t even cry then pls watch original interview.. they were not even sorry
Movie has a poor screenplay, casting, etc (like you mentioned) because it needed to be released at particular time. Serious topic but not justified by the filmmakers just for the sake of upcoming elections in Karnataka. Now Karnataka people can be scared with a line dekho apke sath bhi aisa ho sakta hai. Sab ch*tiya bana rahe hai.
It is true but the number they shown is false which can lead to serious issue....only 3 were victims and in the movie is shows 32000.....
Still some modern hindu girls love Abdul
It's a global issue . Swedish people are not fools to make Caliphate.
Monsters are hiding under Mask of islamaphobia.
To those claiming this movie as a propaganda or islamophobe need to realise this is not a recent case ,since 2009 several Christian organisations have repeatedly filed cases in court against this conversions in Kerala .
Those barking for the inaccurate no also need to shut the faak up because why even a single girl needs to go through this trauma harassment
This movie in a blunt way has ruffled this leechs of the society
Well i knew these things about 5 years ago its not a surprise for me coz i have been avidly following these issues so just kudos to the people who thought of making it a mass movie......
The Kashmir Files mein jis topic par baat kiya gaya tha, woh convincing lagaa by the script, actors, cinematography, writing and the colour palette.
But Kerala Story mein kuch bhi acha nahi hain
That's why I love ur reviews 🙌🏻👌🏻
Number is only prb for me .
Without that it's a great great movie for conversation case ❤
Thank you Shan honestly saying for your honest review. Keep it up.
I have watched this movie in police protection of 50s. So thats enough to tell about peacefuls.
Please watch in theatres to encourage producers for making this type of fim
It is not appropriate to criticize the technicality of the move given that it is raising a topic that helps improve lives. Encourage everyone to watch this movie rather raising patty points. Thing greater good
But that is literally his job. As a reviewer he needs to speak about all aspects of the filmmaking
It would have been better if they didn’t used such misleading figures and if would have been better if they keep more neutral balance between 2 communities in the movie they are not telling the story of 3 girls but using it as a tool 🔨 to target the entire community koi ek single aware Banda nhi dikha muslim jo ishe galat bata reha ho every single Muslim character in the movie 🍿 is acting like crazy extremist as a evil and this movie is also promoting political ideology.
Does OTT versions will include 10 scenes which are deleted by censor board ?
Shan bhai Jai Shree Ram!
Jai Shree Ram!
Now a days all is saying jai shree ram any time anywhere. May j know the reason??
@@pratikdas6133 Yes bhai hmare up mein Ram Ram aur Jai Shree Ram blkr hi greet hti h bht jgh to bhai mera ph mera cmnt bhai tjhe blna h to bol le wrna bhai hr jgh tang mt ghusa
@@pratikdas6133 Btw Pratik bhai Jai Shree Krishna......
Actually abhi mujhe lagta hai ai BJP ka slogan ban gaya hai. Isi liye sri ram ko bhi achha nehi lagega k unke naam ka koi mis use kare. Har har mahadev bolo Jay sri krishna bolo Jay durga ma bolo.
I think people should also talk about Christian missionaries.they are doing conversions all over the world too. Specially adivasi
Waiting for your review.. Bhai👍👍🤗
Only 3 women's converted in ISIS from kerala (2 Christian & 1 Hinduism)
🇮🇳my United India (shik + Muslim + Hinduism + Christian)
Don't be selfish on politics
I love you Shan, thank you for being honest. love you 30000
What about the disclaimer that says cinematic liberty has been taken in the movie. So how do we know how much of it was the truth and in which parts cinematic liberty has been taken? When dealing with important sensitive issues disclaimers like these just dilute the entire seriousness...
The motive of the film is not to give you information about the case. The motive is to attract your attention to the issue . Now as an educated citizen it's your responsibility to investigate and research for more information.
U need not to depend on movie to know the truth .. just get the idea ki asa kch ho raha hai … fir different sources se dekho na ki kitna kya intensity hai … abhi m.p. Se retired police hai unhone b btya tha ki rate card hote hain … jaise agar brahimn ko convert kroge toh jada paise milnge , different rates for different girls ..
@@MsCvb85 more like targeting on taking down kerela by showing kerela as a muslim supporting and hindu hating state
@@soorajtr6692 that's your assumption after seeing udta Punjab nobody started hating Punjab . Uttar Pradesh and Bihar everyday we see in bad light but that doesn't mean the rest of the country started hating those states or boycotted those states . If that is so why UK , US news channels show such news . Does that mean they themselves are defaming their own countries. When films webseries shows Pujari from mandir as rapist pedophile does everyone start saying that pujari are defamed . Till date Brahmans were targeted in every second movie does that defamed bramhans? Army was soft target of Bollywood from mission Kashmir to Haider . Even sympathized with terrorists. Army didn't say it is defaming them. And if a movie targeting ISIS , a terrorist organization why are people of Kerala getting offended ? Show me people who said a word against Kerala State or its people after watching this movie.
@@MsCvb85 Exactly.. when u r drawing attention of general public towards such an important and sensitive topic u cannot take cinematic liberty. 95% of the cinegoers are not going to go back and read more abt the topic. They r just going to believe what was shown n u cannot deny this fact. So the team has to be more responsible in getting entire story right. Cannot take liberty in such topics at least which are so important...
before making movie reviews u should study more and do more research about how the film was made 😡 no good actors and even technicians was ready to work with sudipto sen in this movie . so how can u expect good casting ???? 😡
Great review.... Now it is time for godhra kaand story....
Shan bhai never disappoints
First time i am disagree with u, movie was awesome and acting was also awesome
The प्रॉब्लम is that.. कर्नाटक चुनाव सामने hai.. The इशू is that.. की is time पे मूवी रिलीज़ करने का रीज़न ही पोलिटिकल hai.. रह गयी बात 32000 लड़कियों की...its फेक...
i have नो पोलिटिकल agression or favourism....you हैंडलेड it d बेस्ट वे.... Always with you... शान sir🙏
EXACTLY!!! Shan u r spot on as alwaysss
It's propaganda not because of Hindus forced conversion but because of incorrect marketing causing hype as in 32k. That number was solely mentioned to create mass hysteria among people. Shan could've easily reviewed the BBC documentary on Modi as he's in Canada but chose not to. Playing safe? Yogi adityanath and sadhvi pragya giving hate speeches against other communities?? Just to be clear I don't support forced conversions, The perpetrators responsible even for one forced conversion should be punished
there is a difference between a film and a documentary numb nut