Phenomenal work. As a suggestion, it may be very interesting to throw the iPhone 14 pro max in there or the premium iPhone of the day when comparing Android flagship cameras. It would add a little context to the overall landscape of the market.
@@alischanHello, thank you for your video. I'm currently deciding whether to buy a Samsung 23 ultra or the Magic 5 Pro. Have you perhaps noticed that at 11: 10 min there is a jerking in the video on Honor Magic 5 Pro. At least that's how it's shown to me on TH-cam on my TV, whereas it's not the case on Samsung. Do you perhaps have an explanation for this? In addition, the 15 minute 4k video limit on the Honor is said to have been lifted with the last patch, can you confirm that for me? Thank you in advance for your answer.
Generally the video was quite good from my experience, so it could have been a one off mishap here. Unfortunately I do not have the Honor 5 Pro with me anymore, since I wanted to test other phones as well and can't really buy and keep each and every phone. :D
Thanks for this fantastic comparison that really helps understand the difference between the two flagships. It was comprehensive and well worth the time you took. I've ordered the Honor Magic Pro 5, and it's going to replace my old (and too small) iPhone 12. I'll be subscribing to your channel. Thanks again!
Thank you very much, really appreciate your comment. I am sure you will have a really good time with your Honor Magic 5 Pro, it's an overall great device. Have a nice day!
Very good real world comparison, I chose the Magic 5 Pro over the S23U, only a couple of things I dont like is you are limited to 15 mins in 4K video recordings, the camera doesn't change ISO very quickly when recording video in low light when you zoom in from main camera lens to tele lens so it goes very dark for a while when it switches lenses, and its LED torch is pretty dim compared with my last phone Pixel 6, which could light up a room, these issues do matter to me cause I make ghost hunting videos so I do alot of low light videos, and like to leave my camera recording in a room but 15 mins limit is restricting. Other than those issues it's almost perfect, battery life is amazing, low light vids and photos are great!
Thank you for a very good realistic camera comparison. For the cost in my country the Honor being about 26% less in cost than the Samsung I felt that the Honor is good value for its performance even though the Samsung performed better in some instances. The other points I like with the Honor is its PWM screen performance and 3D face ID.
Thank you, really appreciate your comment. Yeah, overall you won't make a mistake with either phone, especially if you can save that much in comparison!
Thank you for the nice comment. I think both phones are excellent. There are some areas where each one is a bit better, but overall you won't make a mistake with buying either one. I can't recall the version number anymore, sorry.
I have the S23 U, magic 5 Pro and the Xiaomi 13 Ultra, and i can say, with full confidence, that X13U and Magic 5 Pro out the water to samsung in camera departament. Believe me. I tested in day, night, zoom, and very difficult scenarios ( like concerts) and clearly both phone are better. This year samsung are overhype, and until they don´t change the sensor size i won´t recommend the ultra line. Worst ! i compared the S23U agaisnt Pixel 7 Pro in very challenger scenarios and the google is far better to samsung ( incredible, in the zoom department too where the S23U have better hardware)
Awesome camera comparison. Thanks for all your efforts. Pakistan is such an amazing country even better when you have family there. Keep up the great work! Thumbs up and subbed
@@alischan You're most welcome Dude! You're very lucky to visit Pakistan, fingers crossed you can go there again and do another brilliant camera comparison maybe with a S24 Ultra and Honor Magic 6 Pro?! lol
Hi, just to ask, in case you were able to take photos at the wedding, which phone did a better job in your opinion? Either way, great video. Thank you in advance. :)
Thanks. I honestly didn't take many pictures myself, especially not side by side except of those in the video. So can't definitely tell, which one is clearly doing a better job here.
So basically s23 ultra is oversharpening the video and had washed out colors, also oversharpening photos which can't be fixed and that's the best camera?? 😅 Like on the really first redmi series, it's terrible. Honor is pure optics which is priceless. S23 ultra is only good for flexing and 10x zoom
Tbh there's not much of a difference between them. It's just a matter of preference and choice where do you want your data "safely" to be stored. Interesting and entertaining review.
The percentage of men in this country seems to be much higher than that of women, and most of them are elderly. They all look at you as if you had descended from space.😂
How did you like this kind of camera comparison and which phone did a better job for you?
Phenomenal work. As a suggestion, it may be very interesting to throw the iPhone 14 pro max in there or the premium iPhone of the day when comparing Android flagship cameras. It would add a little context to the overall landscape of the market.
@@d-bread7722 good suggestion, I never had an iPhone though. Will probably change it next month and try to get my hands on the 15 Pro Max!
@@alischanHello, thank you for your video. I'm currently deciding whether to buy a Samsung 23 ultra or the Magic 5 Pro. Have you perhaps noticed that at 11: 10 min there is a jerking in the video on Honor Magic 5 Pro. At least that's how it's shown to me on TH-cam on my TV, whereas it's not the case on Samsung. Do you perhaps have an explanation for this?
In addition, the 15 minute 4k video limit on the Honor is said to have been lifted with the last patch, can you confirm that for me?
Thank you in advance for your answer.
Generally the video was quite good from my experience, so it could have been a one off mishap here. Unfortunately I do not have the Honor 5 Pro with me anymore, since I wanted to test other phones as well and can't really buy and keep each and every phone. :D
Thanks for this fantastic comparison that really helps understand the difference between the two flagships. It was comprehensive and well worth the time you took. I've ordered the Honor Magic Pro 5, and it's going to replace my old (and too small) iPhone 12.
I'll be subscribing to your channel.
Thanks again!
Thank you very much, really appreciate your comment. I am sure you will have a really good time with your Honor Magic 5 Pro, it's an overall great device. Have a nice day!
I m using HM 5 pro and believe me it's an awesome phone.
Best of luck for your channel growth. This is pretty good and detailed comparison.
Thank you very much and glad that you liked the video!
You put a lot of work into that bless you,, thumbs up for the honor
Thank you very much :)
Very good real world comparison, I chose the Magic 5 Pro over the S23U, only a couple of things I dont like is you are limited to 15 mins in 4K video recordings, the camera doesn't change ISO very quickly when recording video in low light when you zoom in from main camera lens to tele lens so it goes very dark for a while when it switches lenses, and its LED torch is pretty dim compared with my last phone Pixel 6, which could light up a room, these issues do matter to me cause I make ghost hunting videos so I do alot of low light videos, and like to leave my camera recording in a room but 15 mins limit is restricting. Other than those issues it's almost perfect, battery life is amazing, low light vids and photos are great!
Thank you for a very good realistic camera comparison. For the cost in my country the Honor being about 26% less in cost than the Samsung I felt that the Honor is good value for its performance even though the Samsung performed better in some instances. The other points I like with the Honor is its PWM screen performance and 3D face ID.
Thank you, really appreciate your comment. Yeah, overall you won't make a mistake with either phone, especially if you can save that much in comparison!
This is a really pleasant camera review. Thanks
Really appreciate it, glad you liked it!
Спасибо за видео! Хорошее сравнение двух смартфонов. Мой выбор Honor.
Excellent review sir 🙏
Which device was appealing to you more?
And what software number on honor when you made this video? Is it 151 ?
Thank you for the nice comment. I think both phones are excellent. There are some areas where each one is a bit better, but overall you won't make a mistake with buying either one. I can't recall the version number anymore, sorry.
what an awesome and useful comparison! Nice work
...and surprisingly, i turned out to prefer Honor most of the time.
Thank you very much for this nice comment, means a lot to me.
Don't you want to upload those screenshot pictures on a site with full res images?
I have the S23 U, magic 5 Pro and the Xiaomi 13 Ultra, and i can say, with full confidence, that X13U and Magic 5 Pro out the water to samsung in camera departament. Believe me. I tested in day, night, zoom, and very difficult scenarios ( like concerts) and clearly both phone are better. This year samsung are overhype, and until they don´t change the sensor size i won´t recommend the ultra line. Worst ! i compared the S23U agaisnt Pixel 7 Pro in very challenger scenarios and the google is far better to samsung ( incredible, in the zoom department too where the S23U have better hardware)
What about videos, Sire?
better on S23U for a narrow space@@technitz
Excellent reviews lots of work went im to it
Thank you, really appreciate it. It indeed was a lot of work but at least the same amount of fun, too.
Very good job ! The Honor is very good but too big. Congratulations from Marseille in France 👌
Merci, greetings back to you 😊
👍🏻Danke, für den tollen Vergleich. Das Magic 5 pro hat mir insgesamt besser gefallen
Freut mich dass es dir gefallen hat. :)
I think the automatic fps option is enabled on your S23 Ultra, it degrades the video quality at night, adding a lot of noise.
I seriously cant recall it being on, but it could very well have been turned on. Thanks for pointing this out.
Awesome camera comparison. Thanks for all your efforts. Pakistan is such an amazing country even better when you have family there. Keep up the great work! Thumbs up and subbed
Thank you very much, really appreciate your nice words. I always enjoy my stays in Pakistan and hope to visit again next year. Thanks for subbing :)
@@alischan You're most welcome Dude! You're very lucky to visit Pakistan, fingers crossed you can go there again and do another brilliant camera comparison maybe with a S24 Ultra and Honor Magic 6 Pro?! lol
Haha, I'll which devices I have my hands on by that time, but a video will surely come then too :D
@@alischan So true! I look forward to seeing what devices you are able to get hold of from in the near future 😀
Hi, just to ask, in case you were able to take photos at the wedding, which phone did a better job in your opinion? Either way, great video. Thank you in advance. :)
Thanks. I honestly didn't take many pictures myself, especially not side by side except of those in the video. So can't definitely tell, which one is clearly doing a better job here.
Watching in my Honor Magic 5 Pro
Nice video bro, damn too many ppl staring in the street thought you was gonna get robbed 😅
Thanks mate. Most people are actually very nice, but you never know 😀
My phone is honor magic 5 pro
Honor mg5 pro outstanding
❤❤
Excellent and very comprehensive comparison of the Magic5 Pro and S23 Ultra! Great job!
Glad you liked it!
Bro pakistan me pta approve kitny me mil jaye ga
Sorry, I don't know this.
maybe for samsung video quality honor audio quality, honor photo even if red color is better on samsung
I still not sure which one should i take.. i want samsung.. but i do like honor camera... Its good
It's a tough question because both are rather close. Keep in mind, that the S23 Ultra will get many of the AI features of the S24 Ultra soon too.
Nice sharing ❤love from pakistan ❤
Thank you very much ☺️
Can you upload real photos here in a link?
I will see what I can do.
My phone Honor magic 5 pro. ❤
So basically s23 ultra is oversharpening the video and had washed out colors, also oversharpening photos which can't be fixed and that's the best camera?? 😅 Like on the really first redmi series, it's terrible.
Honor is pure optics which is priceless.
S23 ultra is only good for flexing and 10x zoom
Tbh there's not much of a difference between them.
It's just a matter of preference and choice where do you want your data "safely" to be stored.
Interesting and entertaining review.
The percentage of men in this country seems to be much higher than that of women, and most of them are elderly. They all look at you as if you had descended from space.😂
Yeah, I get these looks quite often there 😁
@@alischan 😁😁
Well he's also walking around filming with 2 phones lol
Even though this is true, it also happens without them lol.