John was one of the main reasons TBS is what they are today. If it werent for his part in the song writing they may not have taken off like they did. Where as tell all your friends is pretty epic the new stuff is more mature in the lyrical sense. They arent writing about highschool romances and friend fights and what not. but either way I love them.
I don't know how much songwriting John did for TBS, but I definitely like Fred's voice more. But, considering their success with the other albums, John wasn't the whole band. I mean, the way Adam moves on stage, his lyrics, his voice. I don't think there's gonna be another guy like him for a longgg time. He's one-of-a-kind.
woah i agree with you completly! Everytime i heard something of louder now i complain and say its good but not like the only tbs! and all my stupid friends are like 'what i don't understand' and i say 'ahhhh thats because you don't know who the legendary John Nolan is! and you havn't heard tell all your friends!' :D
finaly some one who agrees with me lol! iv waited 2 years for this =D john nolan was by far the best singer/screamer and without him they have just turned into the everyday typical emo band =S have you heard anything by straylight run?? john nolan is the singer for them and there kool =D
dudes, accept fred he is a great singer, he screams well, i have to accept that john is great too, but tbs is not the same, but it stills good, in my opinion the best album of TBS is here u want to be, tell all your friends is a master piece but is not all becuz of nolan, is about all the guys that worked together
in my opinon tell all ur firends, was singinficantly better then where u want to be...their lyrics and songs mean more. i also perosnaly like John Nolan more then fred, due to that after John left, the screamming aspect of taking back sunday kind of ended.....its all opinions tho :]
Are you serious? I agree that they are best suited for the music from their era, but if you listen to John, he always has a rasp in his voice... unless he is very quiet... Fred has a rasp a lot too... but it sounds less like screaming and more like singing. I personally like Nolan more, but I like both of them a lot.
well i personally like john better but fred was good too and they both left, and toured together with their own bands, i found that pretty ironic. without them i think taking back sunday is really gonna go downhill
Just by claiming you have more respect than anyone on this page for the band, proves you aren't. You don't brag over respect, you just have it. But clearly, you don't.
I dunno it anyone’s gonna read this in 2023 but god damn dude this is such a time capsule
I read it in 2025 and it’s even more of a time capsule now!
John was one of the main reasons TBS is what they are today.
If it werent for his part in the song writing they may not have taken off like they did.
Where as tell all your friends is pretty epic
the new stuff is more mature in the lyrical sense. They arent writing about highschool romances and friend fights and what not.
but either way I love them.
taking back sunday A.K.A best band ever
There is no I in team A.K.A best song ever
fred rock so good i love this guy
whoa. i was here...this was like 7 years ago right. calstate fullerton. holy shiz.
Ya, Its also a shame that i never got to see them preform this song live. My favorite song.
one of my fav songs...nolan is hot even when all blurry and pixelated
I don't know how much songwriting John did for TBS, but I definitely like Fred's voice more.
But, considering their success with the other albums, John wasn't the whole band. I mean, the way Adam moves on stage, his lyrics, his voice. I don't think there's gonna be another guy like him for a longgg time. He's one-of-a-kind.
woah i agree with you completly! Everytime i heard something of louder now i complain and say its good but not like the only tbs!
and all my stupid friends are like 'what i don't understand'
and i say 'ahhhh thats because you don't know who the legendary John Nolan is! and you havn't heard tell all your friends!'
:D
johns voice is so awesome :)
very awosme band =D granted there first album was the best one, aspecialy becuase it has john nolan on and hes shot hot at music!!
finaly some one who agrees with me lol! iv waited 2 years for this =D john nolan was by far the best singer/screamer and without him they have just turned into the everyday typical emo band =S have you heard anything by straylight run?? john nolan is the singer for them and there kool =D
yes i was
wrong. you spoke too soon, dude..the new guitarist is Matt Fazzi from Facing New York.
nolan is a god
thats exactly what i was typing/shit i did
John and Jesse are ok now, They dealt with the problem. But its a shame john left Fucking old Tbs Kicks ass
Adam messes up the words. It's "Everything i KNOW" Not Everything i learned. Silly Adam :D
It's ok. i'll forgive you this time :P
And liking Fred more is totally just my own opinion.
i know and there goes my dreams of having a reunited TBS with john nolan
i love john nolan, but straylight run is an amazing project, accept all tbs, its all good.
Oh. I see. Well. Good luck. Hope that outlook serves you well.
dudes, accept fred he is a great singer, he screams well, i have to accept that john is great too, but tbs is not the same, but it stills good, in my opinion the best album of TBS is here u want to be, tell all your friends is a master piece but is not all becuz of nolan, is about all the guys that worked together
You're like...one of the guys on youtube that fight over comments and shit aren't you.
post yours then!
in my opinon tell all ur firends, was singinficantly better then where u want to be...their lyrics and songs mean more. i also perosnaly like John Nolan more then fred, due to that after John left, the screamming aspect of taking back sunday kind of ended.....its all opinions tho :]
Are you serious? I agree that they are best suited for the music from their era, but if you listen to John, he always has a rasp in his voice... unless he is very quiet... Fred has a rasp a lot too... but it sounds less like screaming and more like singing.
I personally like Nolan more, but I like both of them a lot.
bahahahhahaha i swear ppl crack me up.
well i personally like john better
but fred was good too
and they both left, and toured together with their own bands, i found that pretty ironic. without them i think taking back sunday is really gonna go downhill
Just by claiming you have more respect than anyone on this page for the band, proves you aren't.
You don't brag over respect, you just have it. But clearly, you don't.
No no no. Fred is not better than John. TAYF was their best album
mines more high res than this.
Live, they don't sound half a good as Brand New. #Seventytimeseven