I feel that David Robinson is wildly underrated on your list. I enjoyed seeing a very different methodology and prioritization used in your list, as I think Bird, Magic, Steph, and Kobe are all outside the top ten. Incredible offensive impact doesen't matter as much to me as the incredible defense and offense of guys like David Robinson, Kevin Garnett, Hakeem, and even Jerry West (who I view in a similar tier to Kobe, Steph, Bird, and Magic).
he needs to win another ring for this to happen and he needs to be SUPER dominant for the next few years. I mean break his 3point record of 402 in a season. I think it's unlikely. But he'll def go down top 10 all time.
@@admiralaokiji7889 Huh? No man. If Steph can win another chip and FMVP then he's top 5. Bruh he's not gonna break that record due to him letting the other guys take 3s. Klay and J Poole will be much better. He is already Top 10 right now bruh (Top 7) IMO. If Steph can retire with 25,000-30,000K points, with 7,000K assists and 6,000K rebounds then he's Top 5 when it is all said and done as the GOAT PG, and GSOAT. Steph has all the shooting records, and Steph 3pt record will be out of reach for a minute who knows? Top 5 easy and that's gonna be hard for a lot of niggaz to accept but it's the truth!! This guy list was garbage. I could argue Steph > Bird, Shaq, Hakeem and Wilt right now lol. Magic, Kobe, Duncan, Kareem, Bron and MJ are the only ones above Steph realistically. In this time Shaq would be a defensive liability. Magic played with Kareem off the bat, and IF you plug in anyone from the top 10 list into Magic position then they'd win a chip too fam but let's continue hyping Magic up. Magic is a glorified Ben Simmons. The wings in this era puts clamps on him, and those bs basic handles ain't doing nothing but hey I'm an eye test kind of guy. Bird would be ight, but not better than Luka. Bird is slower and can't create his shots like Luka. Let's keep it a buck dawg KD, Bron, Ingram, Butler, Kawhi, PG13 and Luka, would torch him no cap. It's like Stockton's overrated defense lol. You know that on the perimeter Stockton ain't locking up none of these PGs today. Rookie AI and Mahmoud Adhul Rauf torched him, so I could just imagine what Steph, Dame, Trae, Ja, Melo, Jrue, Kyrie and Fox would do to him!!! He'll have to see them game in and game out on that schedule too lol. Straight BBQ 🍗
@@savonsanders3955 Bro half this post is missing the point. This is a list of the GREATEST, not the best. Ofc a lot of the older player would be nowhere near as dominant today as they were back then. How can steph be above bird when he hasnt been the best player in the league for a dominant strech, if at all? Bird was by far the best player for 3+ years straight. How can he be above shaq when shaq was great on both sides of the ball for a long time and was the best player on 3 finals. Ill give you wilt russell and hakeem but the rest nah. He's probably 9th right now and if he retires today thats around where he'd be ranked. Yall are overrating his rings a bit when he faced a trash team his first ring, wasnt even the best player for 2 and 3. He has to do a lot more for top 5 as this is not just a resume list but ACTUALLY how good they were. Steph was maybe the best player in the world for 4-5 months in 2016 but besides that he's never shown to do what lebron and other legends have.
curry is a better defender. people assume magic was better because of his play style and size but he was often a liability on defense while steph has bulked up enough in recent years to be an above average defender as well as having led the league in steald
I like your list. Imo the first tier should be unanimous with Russell Kareem MJ Lebron. In the second tier to complete the top 10 I would have Shaq Hakeem Bird Curry Magic Duncan, and to complete the top 15 Wilt West Robinson Garnett Kobe. I value peak more than overall career, hence West above Oscar, or Kobe outside the top 10. I am only missing Robinson in your chart, and KD might be too high given his lack of leadership and accomplishements.
This kid lost all credibility talking basketball when he said he was a teenager. He didn't see Kobe or Bron out the gate or anyone in his top 10. Steph's coming but we'll see. Bird is my favorite player AT but he's not greater than Steph if we're keeping it a buck. The only niggaz ahead of Steph right now is MJ, Kareem, Bron, Magic, Duncan and Kobe. With another chip and FMVP Steph moves ahead of everyone except for MJ, Kareem and Bron. Yes it's hard for a lot of niggaz to accept a 6'2 non athletic, non freak of nature light skinned nigga to be Top 5, when it's said and done, but he's gonna be qualified. GOAT PG. the GSOAT. 5X champion, 2X FMVP, 2X MVP (the only unanimous MVP), 25,000-30,000K points, 7,000K assists, 6,000K rebounds, and he revolutionized the game. He has all the 3pt records which too lol he's gonna put so far out of reach for a minute? Idk how you not put him in the top 5 AT if he accomplishes this but we will see. He has another 3 years at an elite level to win again.
I guess for me it’s Bird and Shaq having more accomplishments and being better on defense. Also I’m taking Shaq’s peak over Curry’s. But they’re in the same tier to me so if you have Steph higher than I understand.
Do you seriously rate bill Russell no4, hell no, he's averaged 40+% FG% and he's a centre, you may think he got 11 rings but think about his hall of fame teammates, bill definitely not deserved no4, and also if you have to compare, Wilt in his ara is better than Russell as a player. so don't overrated a player if he died just like Kobe and Bill
In my mind, Curry has 2 Finals MVPs..there is simply no LOGICAL explanation you can give for why he did not get the 2015 Finals MVP Award. He wasn't the best player in that series..but he was CLEARLY 2nd best player in the series behind LeBron and the best player on the Winning team..that won in 6 games. If you include the 2015 FMVP on Curry's CV, he jumps ahead of Larry Bird and Kobe on my list
2:21 I made a mistake Steph has 1 FMVP
I feel that David Robinson is wildly underrated on your list. I enjoyed seeing a very different methodology and prioritization used in your list, as I think Bird, Magic, Steph, and Kobe are all outside the top ten. Incredible offensive impact doesen't matter as much to me as the incredible defense and offense of guys like David Robinson, Kevin Garnett, Hakeem, and even Jerry West (who I view in a similar tier to Kobe, Steph, Bird, and Magic).
He might be top 5 when he retires 👀
he needs to win another ring for this to happen and he needs to be SUPER dominant for the next few years. I mean break his 3point record of 402 in a season. I think it's unlikely. But he'll def go down top 10 all time.
@@admiralaokiji7889 Thats 5 threes a game, very hard
That's a huge stretch
@@admiralaokiji7889 Huh? No man. If Steph can win another chip and FMVP then he's top 5. Bruh he's not gonna break that record due to him letting the other guys take 3s. Klay and J Poole will be much better. He is already Top 10 right now bruh (Top 7) IMO. If Steph can retire with 25,000-30,000K points, with 7,000K assists and 6,000K rebounds then he's Top 5 when it is all said and done as the GOAT PG, and GSOAT. Steph has all the shooting records, and Steph 3pt record will be out of reach for a minute who knows? Top 5 easy and that's gonna be hard for a lot of niggaz to accept but it's the truth!! This guy list was garbage. I could argue Steph > Bird, Shaq, Hakeem and Wilt right now lol. Magic, Kobe, Duncan, Kareem, Bron and MJ are the only ones above Steph realistically. In this time Shaq would be a defensive liability. Magic played with Kareem off the bat, and IF you plug in anyone from the top 10 list into Magic position then they'd win a chip too fam but let's continue hyping Magic up. Magic is a glorified Ben Simmons. The wings in this era puts clamps on him, and those bs basic handles ain't doing nothing but hey I'm an eye test kind of guy. Bird would be ight, but not better than Luka. Bird is slower and can't create his shots like Luka. Let's keep it a buck dawg KD, Bron, Ingram, Butler, Kawhi, PG13 and Luka, would torch him no cap. It's like Stockton's overrated defense lol. You know that on the perimeter Stockton ain't locking up none of these PGs today. Rookie AI and Mahmoud Adhul Rauf torched him, so I could just imagine what Steph, Dame, Trae, Ja, Melo, Jrue, Kyrie and Fox would do to him!!! He'll have to see them game in and game out on that schedule too lol. Straight BBQ 🍗
@@savonsanders3955 Bro half this post is missing the point. This is a list of the GREATEST, not the best. Ofc a lot of the older player would be nowhere near as dominant today as they were back then. How can steph be above bird when he hasnt been the best player in the league for a dominant strech, if at all? Bird was by far the best player for 3+ years straight. How can he be above shaq when shaq was great on both sides of the ball for a long time and was the best player on 3 finals. Ill give you wilt russell and hakeem but the rest nah. He's probably 9th right now and if he retires today thats around where he'd be ranked. Yall are overrating his rings a bit when he faced a trash team his first ring, wasnt even the best player for 2 and 3. He has to do a lot more for top 5 as this is not just a resume list but ACTUALLY how good they were. Steph was maybe the best player in the world for 4-5 months in 2016 but besides that he's never shown to do what lebron and other legends have.
W vid
curry is a better defender. people assume magic was better because of his play style and size but he was often a liability on defense while steph has bulked up enough in recent years to be an above average defender as well as having led the league in steald
I like your list. Imo the first tier should be unanimous with Russell Kareem MJ Lebron. In the second tier to complete the top 10 I would have Shaq Hakeem Bird Curry Magic Duncan, and to complete the top 15 Wilt West Robinson Garnett Kobe. I value peak more than overall career, hence West above Oscar, or Kobe outside the top 10. I am only missing Robinson in your chart, and KD might be too high given his lack of leadership and accomplishements.
I said the same thing, how can you not have The adrmiral top 15, obsolutely rediculous. Hakeem is way too low also...
Common Max W
🔥
This vid is fantastic, great quality, you are gonna be massive on TH-cam
I Appreciate it!
I'm not a fan of curry but i respect him and I think he is top 10, kobe is top 5. not sure if I would rank lebron #2 but he is top 5 as well.
My top 10
1. Jordan
2 Lebron
3 Kareem
4 Magic
5 Bird
6 Kobe
7 Duncan
8 Shaq
9 Bill Russell
10 Curry
The problem here is i think we should not count in people like bill russel that is like dinosaur the game was waaaaaaaaay diffrent in that time.
curry is better than magic but magic has more accomplishments
My top 10 is
10: Steph
9: Wilt
8: Kobe
7: Hakeem the dream
6: magic
5: Larry Bird
4: Tim Duncan
3: Kareem
2: lebron
1: mj
Finally someone putting Timmy over Kobe. I don't understand why so much people disrespect the man.
This kid lost all credibility talking basketball when he said he was a teenager. He didn't see Kobe or Bron out the gate or anyone in his top 10. Steph's coming but we'll see. Bird is my favorite player AT but he's not greater than Steph if we're keeping it a buck. The only niggaz ahead of Steph right now is MJ, Kareem, Bron, Magic, Duncan and Kobe. With another chip and FMVP Steph moves ahead of everyone except for MJ, Kareem and Bron. Yes it's hard for a lot of niggaz to accept a 6'2 non athletic, non freak of nature light skinned nigga to be Top 5, when it's said and done, but he's gonna be qualified. GOAT PG. the GSOAT. 5X champion, 2X FMVP, 2X MVP (the only unanimous MVP), 25,000-30,000K points, 7,000K assists, 6,000K rebounds, and he revolutionized the game. He has all the 3pt records which too lol he's gonna put so far out of reach for a minute? Idk how you not put him in the top 5 AT if he accomplishes this but we will see. He has another 3 years at an elite level to win again.
Didn't understand what makes shaq, bird better than Curry? Steph not dominant? He's dominating from the 3pt line....
I guess for me it’s Bird and Shaq having more accomplishments and being better on defense. Also I’m taking Shaq’s peak over Curry’s. But they’re in the same tier to me so if you have Steph higher than I understand.
Do you seriously rate bill Russell no4, hell no, he's averaged 40+% FG% and he's a centre, you may think he got 11 rings but think about his hall of fame teammates, bill definitely not deserved no4, and also if you have to compare, Wilt in his ara is better than Russell as a player. so don't overrated a player if he died just like Kobe and Bill
I had Russell top 5 in my video from a year ago
Where is David Robinson on the list? he should be top 15... Also, you're disrespecting tf out of Hakeem
Elaborate
It says here you think curry has 2 finals mvps?
2:21
Yeah my mistake I meant to write 1 😅
In my mind, Curry has 2 Finals MVPs..there is simply no LOGICAL explanation you can give for why he did not get the 2015 Finals MVP Award. He wasn't the best player in that series..but he was CLEARLY 2nd best player in the series behind LeBron and the best player on the Winning team..that won in 6 games.
If you include the 2015 FMVP on Curry's CV, he jumps ahead of Larry Bird and Kobe on my list
Steph is a bum 😎
wilt is not top 10.
Why not?