Modern Islam with Muhammad Hassan Ilyas | Mooroo Podcast
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.พ. 2025
- Muhammad Hassan Ilyas is a young theologian, researcher, and expert in ancient Arabic literature and language. He was born in Karachi in July 1988 and is a member of a scholarly family in the Indo-Pak region. His grandfathers, Mawlana Ishaq Alvi (Deoband) and Allama Muhammad Tahseen (Amroha), are both considered great academics of the Deobandi School of thought. Ilyas is inspired by the famous Islamic scholar Javed Ahmed Ghamidi. He is the Director of Research at Ghamidi Center in the USA.
00:00 Intro
01:44 Does Hassan want to take authority of Islam?
04:40 Traditional vs Modern Islamic Interpretation
12:09 The power of questioning in Islam
14:36 Equality & Abuse of Power
27:57 Polygamy in Islam
31:18 Freedom of Belief in Islam
37:05 Intellectual Pursuit of Religion
44:34 Islam’s Perspective on Psychedelics
52:02 Importance of Religion
56:00 Science & Islam
01:09:21 Hassan’s Opinion on Javed Ahmad Ghamidi
01:18:50 Hassan’s relationship with Javed Ahmad Ghamidi
01:22:15 Hate Speech in Jummah Khutba
01:25:04 Outro
This podcast really hit me emotionally. I agreed with almost everything he uttered. I'm so glad that religious people like him exist in some capacity. I have cancer, and this podcast has given me the closure I desperately needed.
May God bless you with good health ❤
This is one of the most effective podcast anyone having big questions can listen to, Salute to Hassan Sahab and Mooroo.
شُکر اُس رَب کا کہ جس نے مُجھ ناچیز کو استادِ محترم غامدی صاحب جیسی عظیم نعمت سے نوازا! 😍 💕
What an amazing, insightful and thought provoking conversation!
53:51
50:43 I have been searching for this answer for so long and after years only this part catered it the best. What a view!
Mooro bhai mai kuch din pehlay soch rahi thi k kash ap ghamdi sahab ya ilyas bhai k sath podcast karen aur rat ko ilyas bhai nay apnay Chanel per per podcast share ki to mera khushi ka thikana nhi raha.. Allah ap ko haq bat ka ajar ata karay Ameen
I was thinking too, but with Ghamidi sb
Vote for ducky bhai
To be honest very thankful and also proud to be hearing a podcast full of controversial questions am truly honored to be listening and yas to the dawn of the age of climax and no holding back on your inner conflicts
👏👏👏👏
بہت عمدہ گفتگو ۔ سوالات آپ نے بہت اچھے کیے۔ اور مہمان نے جوابات بھی بہت تحمل اور علمیت کے ساتھ دیے۔
جزاکم اللہ خیرا کثیرا
very very interesting podcast. I like how you are learning and questioning what you have experienced and still learning about the realties of this world and religion.
More of such insightful podcast required .
Long time Mooroo, but your Guest is always amazing.
Such a insightful podcast totally hooked me to the screen.
Such a nice choice of questions and what intellectual answers. Worth listening
A Beautiful Podcast ❤
Will see this whole podcast in parts daily ❤
One of the best podcast
We need a part 2 of Mooroo podcast with Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza.
Yaar Mooroo .. Impresive work boss! Keep it up.
Very nice choice of questions. Amazing podcast.
Mooroo asking all the right questions!!
so light and nice peace full for mind
Mooroo knows how to extract the best from his guest.
&
Hassan bhai is explaining things at his best. ❤
Mooro questions were very insightful and on point. Totally impressed and as I get inspired by ghamidi sahb I was expecting a more detailed and insightful explanation from ilyas. But I'm not very satisfied with the answers. Mooro's questions are still valid and still answered.
Beg to differ ، Hassan was so voluble and cogent in explaining everything
Please invite sahil adeem❤
Moroo I always admire your work and I have a really humble request please sir Javed Ahmad Ghamidi ke sath bhi aik podcast kare discuision about why Islam is the truth as I am a truth seeker I am much more of agnostic nowadays aajkal jo extremist bare huwe hai wo mujhe sensible, logical nahi lagte kindly invite sir Javed Ahmad Ghamidi on your podcast as he is the only one I admire and I can not meet him personally so it is a humble request and yess keep this work as our society need it really
Kya aap depressed ho Mazhab ki wajah se ?
Mazhabi activities ki wajah se ?
@ 5 April 2024
Mooroo Such Hardworking Man ! 💯
What a knowledgeable personality! ♥️
Best podcast ever. Ghamidi sb is a great scholar
Says who?
@@prowest6715only ignorant liberals
@@prowest6715
Every sane person who has a mind.
@ 5 April 2024
@@comparativereligiondailynews Unfortunately by saying that you display the same propensity for gross generalisations that afflicts most desis, and the secular liberals in particular.
Allow me to express why I asked the question. Islam exists beyond the borders of Pakistan, and you will see that elsewhere scholars, in general from the mainstream, from different fiqh schools have a mutual respect as they recognise the calibre and respect the others point of view. You will see this if you go and sit with scholars from other countries, and even in the west. However, of these who I have mentioned Ghamdi to and know him, on learning of his opinions have been bluntly scathing of his methodology and his flawed opinions. So even outside of the peculiarities of the Pakistani circles, Ghamdiyat does not have the respect of the wider body of scholars.
As a general rule, in life, one will view a person's calibre in their work by what their peers say about them. Ghamdi does not have that level of endorsement from his peers. These peers would be people who have studied the scared texts as well. If Ghamdi cannot convince them, in my mind that means he should be viewed with suspicion. It amazes me then to find people who have no qualifications other than what they have inclinations and whims towards judge anyone like Ghamdi to a 'true great scholar'.
I do not find the reason for following him that people give in of themselves convincing at all.
lol man your so called ghamidi sir should go back to school and only just learn about the basic islamic knowledge cuz that guy says false things wo har haram cheez ko halal kr deta legit that guy he selling quranic ayats for fame and money, he should not be called a scholar he is a guy talking on his made up false and ill beliefs and ignorant people are literally worshiping it. period!
Healthy conversation.
That was a good podcast thanks ❣️
such a wonderful show
Love the new look Mooroo
Very well answered by Muhammad hassan.
We need a part 2 of podcast with Scholar Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza Sahab in Jhelum please 🥺🙏.
Please don't propagate any MODERN Islam. There is no such modernism in Islam, Nasus / Aqeedah remains same.
Again no such modernism is acceptable in Islam if we go back to history, Christianity started to be disobeyed with same way of modernism.
Please it's a humble advice read some materials before making such videos.
Beautiful podcast ❤ speechless
every podcast is better than previous one
A very tough discussions I liked it
Msshalllllahhhhh behtreeen podcast
The whole point of this podcast is to seek justification of Islamic rulings through logic. We can't take this approach because only Allah is All knowing and our knowledge is a work in progress. Hence, just because we can't understand something, it doesn't mean it is wrong.
The right approach is to reach Allah and Islam through His signs by pure Logic. Once you're certain that there is One True God and Islam is His Deen. Then submit your will to whatever the rulings of Islam are. Our efforts should be put in use to best 'understand' what's being instructed by Allah and apply it in our lives instead of challenging what's being said through Logic. That's what Iblees did when he thought he was better than Adam because he is made of fire and Adam is made of clay. He used his logic against Allah's commandment.
May Allah guide us all to the right path. Ameen
We have to submit But before we have to understand what are the rulings and on what bases they are given. Then we follow and submit our will to them in true ways according to the will of God, with faith and trust. Otherwise, if we go blindly there are high chances of going against God’s will.
Healthy conversation. welldone
I like the hairstyle of Mooroo. Such a humble and cute❤
Deen Allah k hukam ko rasool saw ka tareeko sa pura krna ka naam hai koshish krain k aj kl k dor mei ziada sa ziada waqt quran k sath guzarain Allah apki duniya or akhirat dono bana dai ga
Kia zabardast podcast tha
Watched Superficially On 5 April 2024 ❤ Right Before Jumah Prayer.
Friday ( Jummatul Wida of Ramadan 2024 )
I am relaxed
Loved it❤
Mooroo should've invited @muhammad hijab on his podcast.
Yes he should have because then we would have a clash of viewpoints - desi liberal vs strong western Muslim who deals with hostile questioning a lot.
Ghamdi khud ahadees Ka munkir ha
You should invite Sahil Adeem for more intellectual discussion on these topics
I would love to talk to hassan ilyas bhai. How will it be possible
very nice. bohat khoob moro, dont go on numbers views see what difference you have made in 3208 lives.
i cant like this video enough
Importance of Darood e Ibrahimi.....Please read..
A Sahabi asked the Messenger of Allah (sal Allahu alaihi wa sallam): “O Messenger of Allah, Allah has commanded us to ask blessings on you but how should we invoke blessings on you?” The Messenger of Allah (sal Allahu alaihi wa sallam) kept silent. The Sahabah were much perturbed over his silence and wished that he had not asked him this question. Finally, the Messenger of Allah (sal Allahu alaihi wa sallam) said: “Say, ‘O Allah, bless Muhammad and the family of Muhammad as You blessed Ibraheem and the family of Ibraheem. O Allah, give baraka to Muhammad and the family of Muhammad as You gave baraka to Ibraheem and the family of Ibraheem. Surely You are worthy of Praise and Glorious,’ and then give the tasleem as you have learnt.” [Muslim; Kitab as-Salat]
There is no such bifurcation as Archaic Islam or Modern Islam. Plz change the thumbnail, every word has imprint-effect. Thanks❤
انتہائی بوگس دلائل ، بے ہنگم شور شرابا
اللہ رب العزت غامدیت جیسے ناسور سے امت مسلمہ کو محفوض فرمائے ، اور ان حضرات کو راہ راست دکھائے
بغض سے بالاتر ہو کر بتائیں کس بات سے اختلاف ہے، شائد کوئی رہنمائی کر سکے وگرنہ بغض کا علاج بہت مشکل ہے
Aameen
@@Uninformed2.0pehley ap search kren k Ghamdi k khilaf kya kha gya ha because he is a munkir of Shab e Mairaj
@@secretsecret8551
منکریت کے سرٹیفکیٹ بانٹنے سے پہلے اگلے کی پوری بات سن لینی چاہئے جو کہ یقیناً آپ نے نہیں سنی ہوگی۔ آپ براہ کرم انکی 3 گھنٹے کی مکمل بات سن لیں، پھر سرٹیفکیٹ بانٹ لیجیئے گا
Assalam O Alaikum, ustad Hassan Ilyas sb.
Apne animated videos ki baat ki es podcast me, hum kahan se deikh sktay hai ye. Ap zara bata sktay hai?
*Allah Mooroo ko istqamat de. Ameen!*
I want Part 2
Get Mufti Kamran Shehzad on your podcast
Mufti Kamran is a good person.
Bring Javed Ahmed ghamidi please,on your podcast,if not possible, please take him online,and ask questions of Richard Dawkins and Christopher hitchens to him
Need more
On 12:46, Mr Hassan said that if women is not comfortable with his husband, she have to say his husband "Give me Talaak". What if her husband will not give him? Why women need from him? She should say, I can't live with you and here is my divorce.
then thats the same as any gf-bf relation, whats the point of the institute of marriage?
@@abdulrafay1384 Islam has no GF BF relationship. Equality is when anyone can give talaaq. You Muslim will not understand.
@@vermasattu apart from you negating every aspect of my intellectual abilities just like that, the point i wanted to make was that in a gf-bf relation both parties have the authority to enter and exit the *contract* on free will. They are not bound by any certain set of rules. Whilst the institution of marriage imposes a lot of responsibilities on both parties especially the on the man such as providing and protecting etc. for both the wife and children even if he has to work without resting at all cuz thats his *fardh*. And any sane man would do that actually cuz thats how the chemistry of a high testosterone dependent person works. Another aspect of his chemistry/psychology is critical decision making and hence he has provided the ultimate responsibility of that matter of household as explained by the scholar in the pod that eventually they would be required to have a singular decision maker in critical matters(that doesnt mean no to consulting). And the woman can ask for talaaq for the minutest of reasons which are against that certain contract of marriage(shari'i reasons) and would have to be granted. But if after all the back breaking faraidh imposed on the man if a woman is allowed to walk out just when she feels like it *like an bf-gf relationship* then that won't be a balanced contract(of marriage) and the benefits she'll get from the man as established in the most modern cultures is just a cherry on top. And trust me if i were an avg man after all these impositions, i'd prefer having gfs over marrying ever.
Just a simple answer for your long long long comment. If Both parties are happy, its ok. But if One person is not happy, he have complete right to do anything which he wants. There is no point of carrying dead man on your shoulder while walking. So, Quraan and his 1400 years old teachings are useless in modern day world. If you want to adapt, its your choice. But, don't comment over my comment. I was telling my point to Host and Guest. You can walk away with your 1400 years old rule book.@@abdulrafay1384
If someone's not happy, then talk to someone first, if no one can convince you to stay, walk away.
But women don't just "walk away", they turn into very selfish beings before walking away, wanting to make an example of the man before "walking away", taking everything from him , they don't even want the man's children to think good of their father.
I am thankful for the 1400 year old rules because they prevent women from doing that to men. Today's women are just grown up unhappy irresponsible babies. If you think about it , babies lack empathy and sympathy, cuz they only understand what they want, not what their caretakers want.
Yes
I’m from Lahore, Pakistan ❤✅🇵🇰 I left Islam after reading Quran and listening Zafar Heretics, Adam Seeker, Sahil Bhai and Harris Sultan. I’m happily Ex-Muslim Now….❤🇵🇰✅….❤
❤
2:45 yahi par sara masla shuru ho jata hai janab ne kaha ILM HASIL KRNE KA MAQSAD KYA HAI tu sath he janab ne restrictions laga di k in k ilm hasil krne ka maqsad will always be prerequisite k ap ki ankhon par emaan ka parda para hua ho how is this reasonable and justified when they are trying to learn absolute truth through ILM i have no idea you always have to try to see the reality without any existing ideology without any glasses already on your eyes
Muhammad Ilyas Sahib is a brave man for facing tough questions from his host. That being said, I believe that if you're a Muslim, better follow the same mindset that he carries. I noticed that when it comes to the subject of science and evolution, his knowledge is completely lacking. That's the case in which all the clergy around the world turns a blind eye. Genetic mutation is not just an "error", it's a scientific fact. It happens today and has been happening for a really long time.
When its a complete Deen ,it cant be interpreted as conservative, moderate or extreme . But yes a follower can be conservative, moderate or extremist accorsing to his/her interpretation of Deen . So i do disagrees with title modern islam .
Moroo Bhai Main Ap Ke Sari Videos Watch Karta Hu. Please Ek Heart De Do
Who wants sahil adeem in moroo's podcast
No one..
He has no place in the world of intellectuals . He’s a clown
Who said clown?
Sahil Adeem apni podcast pe hi rahay thanks bye
ek minute bhi podcast me inho ne fizool bato me zaya nahi kia is podcast ko zyda views kiu nahi hai?
Moro bhai AP ki ghamaidi sahab se bat hoi
Mooroi please imvite sahil adeem.
Moreover bhai na Sahih zor sa?swaal kiy hn. Thanks.
Invite sahil adeem
Please don't invite that clown
Hassan Sahib.
Allah aap ki khidmat Qabool farmaye.
If you hit some one, than what is next?
Nothing
Relationship is unsustainable at this point.
Yr mooro Sahil Adeem ko bula na yar
Gr8 G man protege
Ya Allah munafiqon se hifazat farma. Ameen.
So for a very specific reason is when men are allowed to marry to more than one
Kabhi mufti wajid ko bhi podcast m bulai
Waaqeatan kamana AIK mushkil kam Hai lekin Hum mard Ghar ke kaamon KO recognise hi Nahi karty Hain aur, kyun nah Zindagi main Kuch waqt ke Liye akela Raha jaae taakeh dono ki aqal thikaane ajae
Second part of podcast with eng Muhammad Ali Mirza
Been in 10 minutes of the video. Not convinced by the argumemt. Mutual agreement naam ki bhi cheez hoti hai sir. Not watching the video anymore.
Majority Germans were mutually agreed for Hitler and ww2 was cooked
ab ye sawalat kisi typical molvi se kryn to aap py kufr k fatwy lag chuky hoty
34:48
Hasan sahab nein dandi maari hai atheism ko leke, atheist koi paida nahin hota saari dunya mein amuman, har koi apna religion hi deta hai apni aulad ko, lok shaqs atheist bana hai to wo isi process sey nikal key bana hai jiska zikr aap kar rahe ho.
To hindu, Christian, islam key sath atheism ko khada na Karein, atheism alag cheez hai.
Nah bro atheism me b andhi taqleed hai zayada honest position agnosticism hai
Mooroo good at explaining things with dramatic background music, yet when engaged in real conversations, his lack of logic becomes apparent. It's irresponsible to speak openly without doing proper research.
Jo Ahmaddiya jammat ne in per video B'nai hain in ka jwab tu dain. Bat Karna asan hota hai jawab Dena mushkil
ایک آدمی کہہ رہا ہے کہ بیس سال ہوگئے شادی کو آج تک کوئی بڑا مسئلہ نہیں آیا کہ میں کوئی فیصلہ کروں🥹
Morro bhai k sth kis kis ne cs2 kheli ha
Denying evolution won’t get Islamic scholars anywhere. They will have to come to peace with it. Disappointed to see Hassan Ilyas confronting Science.
Finding 15 different ways to mould Islam and Allah to allow/question more liberal feminist viewpoints. Looked like Hassan held back in the interest of a wider audience. 'Empirical evidence or science and statistics' aisay boltay hain Mooroo jesay khud quantum physicist hon. History and the present is littered with studies that were pushed under the rug due to committees and their agendas - specifically with respect to publication journals. Any scientist worth their weight and who does not have an agenda or follows a leftist cult like atheism will tell you that if there is a study explaining something, there are several others refuting it with same levels of care going into study design. Unfortunately, the people in charge of which studies get published are the ones who dictate public narrative around 'science'.
This felt like a new-age atheist 'toddler' (in philosophical terms) is posing questions to a daee/student of the religion.
Dicussion from freedom of belief and on words went downhill! Not very satisfied with the justifications and explanations. Rest was great as always❤
Freedom that goes with false choices is not freedom. Someone has to correct you. For example 2 + 2 makes 4. If you belive it 5, you'll be called fool. First prove it 5 and then belive it for sure. Islam has the answers to the very fundamental questions of human like purpose of birth and death. Science or theories can't answer this.
Or maybe you didn’t understand.!
@@oye214 can be the case!
But again it's my opinion, if you are satisfied with the answers good for you ❤️
Maybe you don't want to understand...
@@meerhussainalimoosvi1171 Thank you for telling me what's in my heart 🌝 and
What i do or don't WANT to do👍
Bhai kehna kya chah raye ho
Islam islam hota hy ye nai pakh modern islam kia hy . Ap islam wo mt samjhen jo hamary haan follow kia jata hy khud parhen research karen or samjhen islam ko. Islam shru sy he modern hy.
Modify as you want .......
It should be acc. to your perspectives...
Mannn...dont be childish the reality is beyond
ye DMT wali baat mai saalo se sunna chah raha tha... @mooroo
@mooroo podcast
Your color grading looks strange. It is too blue and unnatural.
mooro looks like a trans w/this new hairstyle.
Questions Were Excellent but answers were not that Satisfactory and Reliable and a feeling Of Rudness in behavior of Host
science and islam ke section me hassan sab kella khaa gy :)