No, he's not feeling ill -- he's doing it exactly as it should be done. The movement is a swan singing about his fate while being roasted on a spit. It's supposed to sound comically pathetic. Many tenors miss that point and sing it too operatically.
tienes un buen punto realmente, pero en la voz se nota muy tensa... tal vez si la soltara un poco más juntando esa interpretación haría que el aria fuera hermosa
I don't want to join the bullying, but he was very wrong. He confused the third verse with the second. In addition, I also mix sentences. The director was surprised and turned to look at him immediately, but nothing could be done. The orchestra also noticed. It's a shame because I liked his interpretation. I hope it hasn't affected his reputation.
If you look carefully, you will see he is in the choir for the rest of the time - this is not usual, but is definitely true here. Also, how would you sing if you were being roasted and eaten? Its called acting, and is totally appropriate for this song.
même idée. on croirait qu'il n'arrive pas à monter et qu'il se force pour le faire. Suis déçu. (pour l'avoir moi-même interprété). (en prime, un mélange des paroles dans les couplets.. :/ )
Absolutely amazing!!!
Brilliant interpretation, going all in.
Amazing interpretation. Though couldn't get over the lyrical mix up. The look of the conductor when he fudges the 2nd verse opening lol.
No, he's not feeling ill -- he's doing it exactly as it should be done. The movement is a swan singing about his fate while being roasted on a spit. It's supposed to sound comically pathetic. Many tenors miss that point and sing it too operatically.
tienes un buen punto realmente, pero en la voz se nota muy tensa... tal vez si la soltara un poco más juntando esa interpretación haría que el aria fuera hermosa
es que en verdad se escucha y se ve tenso... y eso repercute en la voz...
The fact they use a tenor instead of a countertenor really speaks to the intention. They want the strained falsetto. This performer was great.
EXACTO!
Wait what is that imitation bassoon?
Presumably the organ.
I don't want to join the bullying, but he was very wrong. He confused the third verse with the second. In addition, I also mix sentences. The director was surprised and turned to look at him immediately, but nothing could be done. The orchestra also noticed. It's a shame because I liked his interpretation. I hope it hasn't affected his reputation.
Se le estaba yendo la voz de a de veras.
Some thing tragic must had happened that very day :(
Yep. His poor feathers were plucked and he was cooked over a fire.
@@Rhewin exactly.
This performance cannot cast the concert into shadow, even though it seems so.
Pietà
:))
Sorry but this singer is out of his depth.
Sounds like he's trying something "different" to compensate the fact that he simply can't sing this cantata
la pire version à mes yeux. dommage.
Il n'a pas de voix! Le ténor n'est engagé que pour ce solo, il faut quand même pouvoir le chanter! Là, le cygne est déjà rôti!
I thought I was the only one thinking that.
If you look carefully, you will see he is in the choir for the rest of the time - this is not usual, but is definitely true here. Also, how would you sing if you were being roasted and eaten? Its called acting, and is totally appropriate for this song.
Read the explanations, simple culture, on these comments and you'll understand.
même idée. on croirait qu'il n'arrive pas à monter et qu'il se force pour le faire. Suis déçu. (pour l'avoir moi-même interprété). (en prime, un mélange des paroles dans les couplets.. :/ )
This song is Male Chorus... Why Female Singing it?