Hi bro, just fyi, at the time of our prophet muhammad (s.a.w), persians were not muslim, they were zoroastrianism. Only after muslim conquest of Persia(Iran), later on that most convert to islam willingly & not based on forced. But do note that current state of Iran, they are practising Shia, and not of sunnah’s teaching which we follow closely like our prophet.
I guess you have not read any Islamic history found for example in the sira literature, or in the histories written by Muslim scholars. Only in your imagination did most convert to Islam willingly. Your comment shows a gross lack of historical knowledge.
@@theastronomer5800 You are right, military combat can be counted as force even if there is voluntary acceptance afterwards, I am Muslim and if I were a person living in that era then I would not agree to Muslims conquering Persia, but if I were in that era with the values and culture of that era then I would definitely agree to it.
@@weknowyou777 Again, you have not studied history. People converted after being conquered because they were a significant social and economic disadvantage for not being Muslims (this is explained in Sharia manuals, have you not read them?). Do you think this is fair? Take the Roman Empire, when they conquered a people they allowed ALL of them to worship their local religions and they became citizens, with equal rights. Islam does not do that. Many of the places that Islam conquered had much more ancient cultures and values. Most places figured out thousands of years before Islam that killing, stealing, lying, r@ping, etc are not things you want to do if you want to live next to other people in peace. Islam has nothing new to say on that, in fact, it is more backwards than some other cultures because it allows multiple wives (the women are rarely in favour of this), child marriage, consummation of marriage before puberty (65:4 - explained by the tafsirs), r@ping married females slaves, slaver etc. Just take slavery for example - is that something that we should have today, since Allah and Muhammad clearly allow it? Top Muslims scholars argue that is is part of Islam. Saudi Sheikh Saleh Al-Fawzan, member of the Senior Council of Clerics said: "Slavery is a part of Islam...(those who argue that slavery is abolished are) ignorant, not scholars. They are merely writers. Whoever says such things is an infidel."
@@theastronomer5800 It is undeniable that conquest was often followed by political and social pressure on the indigenous population. However, the extent to which these pressures were a major factor in religious conversion is still a matter of debate among historians. While there are some cases where religious conversion was associated with economic benefits, there is no strong evidence to suggest that this was a major factor in mass conversion in Persia. The cultural and religious similarities between Islam and some groups in Persia, such as Zoroastrianism, may have facilitated the process of assimilation and conversion. The process of Islamization in Persia was not an instantaneous event, but took place over several centuries. Many complex factors influenced this process, including the political, social, and cultural policies of the various Islamic dynasties that came to power. I don't know where you are from, but I live in a country that was colonized by Christians, they even equated the natives with dogs and it was even written in an inscription, while Muslims came by trading, they came first in a peaceful way. Polygamy is still practiced because Saudi Arabia has few human resources and then on the other hand the situation requires them to fight because natural resources are also few, Islam came to reduce the number of wives that can be married, so actually Islam gives a sign that we must have 1 wife. The opinion of Sheikh Saleh Al-Fawzan represents an extreme minority view among Muslims. It is in stark contrast to the majority of modern scholars' understanding of Islam and universal human values. My advice you don't learn from people who don't like Islam, it's the same as learning a right-wing group from a left-wing group, perfection from humans is impossible, you will definitely find weaknesses in each group.
I would like to add/ correct on the fact that 1:3 was the ratio of Muslims (which video ref) was in battle of trench which was between muslim arabs & non-muslim arabs. Persian and Byzantine empire were in far greater numbers, as in the battle of Ohad. Predicting that muslim will soon take over two major super powers of that time during a losing battle is more incredible
11:49 a little rectification: he was outnumbered 3 vs 1 by his enemies while he was predicting the conquest of Persia and Roma. Like it was during a battle, people weren’t even sure they will survive because they were just a little group, but he said they will defeat the great empires of Persia and Roma. But yeah obviously they were also outnumbered by Persia and the Romans, and it was a lot more than 3v1 lol, historians say it was as if the Eskimos defeated Usa and Russia (impossible)
Anas b. Malik reported that a person asked Allah's Apostle (ﷺ): When would the Last Hour come? Thereupon Allah's Messenger (way peace be upon him) kept quiet for a while. Then looked at a young boy in his presence belonging to the tribe of Azd Shanu'a and he said: If this boy lives he would not grow very old till the Last Hour would come to you. Anas said that this young boy was of our age during those days. - Sahih Muslim 2953b There are many narrations of this in the authentic hadith collections, and other such "prophecies", which obviously did not come true. They should make a video on these. As for the ones mentioned here, read my comments I posted - they exclude all and any historical evidence which shows that these things either were going on before Muhammad, or are so vague they are meaningless as they can be fit to anything.
Bro this the one problem we have in our ummah and what the prophet warned about which is judging others and calling others kafir. If one calls another a kafir and it turns out he wasnt, that means the person who called him a kafir is one.
Don't press on him. Take your time and it is okay. Don't forget that some of the best Muslims in history came later to Islam like Khalid Ibn Al Waleed. Take your time. You being convinced is a must and nothing is wrong in studying things carefully as long as they aren't with pride. I don't see pride there. May God guide you and all of us
Really great reaction! May Allah bless both you guys! Prophet Muhammad made many more prophecies never proven wrong and based on those and the Quran Muslims had begun to excel in all studies (science, health, history, etc) and have discovered many great things SUBHANALLAH Allahu akbar 💗
Anas b. Malik reported that a person asked Allah's Apostle (ﷺ): When would the Last Hour come? Thereupon Allah's Messenger (way peace be upon him) kept quiet for a while. Then looked at a young boy in his presence belonging to the tribe of Azd Shanu'a and he said: If this boy lives he would not grow very old till the Last Hour would come to you. Anas said that this young boy was of our age during those days. - Sahih Muslim 2953b There are many narrations of this in the authentic hadith collections, and other such "prophecies", which obviously did not come true. They should make a video on these. As for the ones mentioned here, read my comments I posted - they exclude all and any historical evidence which shows that these things either were going on before Muhammad, or are so vague they are meaningless as they can be fit to anything.
Anas b. Malik reported that a person asked Allah's Apostle (ﷺ): When would the Last Hour come? Thereupon Allah's Messenger (way peace be upon him) kept quiet for a while. Then looked at a young boy in his presence belonging to the tribe of Azd Shanu'a and he said: If this boy lives he would not grow very old till the Last Hour would come to you. Anas said that this young boy was of our age during those days. - Sahih Muslim 2953b There are many narrations of this in the authentic hadith collections, and other such "prophecies", which obviously did not come true. They should make a video on these. As for the ones mentioned here, read my comments I posted - they exclude all and any historical evidence which shows that these things either were going on before Muhammad, or are so vague they are meaningless as they can be fit to anything.
Interest was a common feature of the ancient world if you wanted to borrow money. They ancient Babylonians talked about it and calculated what would happen if you let it compound. The Bible speaks of interest.
Assalamu Alaykum brother May Allah keep you firm and bless you I'd recommend you watch a muslim lantern video (i like the agnostic asking about islam one), or a one message foundation video
hi Julian, important note they did find Pharaoh's body in a secret royal cache and then years later Maurice Bucaille examined it and found remains of sea salt stuck in his body and that's how it was concluded that it was the body of Pharaoh mentioned in the Quran. all love to you and your brother
His body was preserved because of the high salt content im the water, i The salt in that sea is more higher than any other sea in the world,, hence why you can float if you go and swim in there, you will never sink unless of course if you weighed down👆☺️
React to Mohammed is the greatest man in history | mindblowing. May Allah keep you in truth and strengthen your faith and may Allah guide your brother.
An illiterate caravan robber who had many wives, including a child wife, ordered assassination of people who made fun of him (including women - details in the Sira), allows child marriage (Q 65:4), r@pe of captures women (Quran, tafsirs, sahih hadiths), started ~100 raids and battles (Ibn Ishaq), forced people to accept his made-up religion (Quran, sahih hadiths), tortured people (Sira), etc etc. Really swell guy! Al-Aawad and Hammam reported Aisha as saying: I used to scrape off the (drop of) semen from the garment of the Messenger of Allah - Sahih Muslim 288b
The hour won't be established until mountains are moved? The ancient Egyptians cut up mountains to make building blocks for their monuments. The Incas, known for their remarkable engineering skills, modified the Andean landscape significantly. They built extensive road networks that included tunnels and cuttings through mountains. Roman engineers were adept at modifying landscapes for infrastructure projects. They built extensive road networks, some of which required cutting through hills and mountains. Notable examples include the Via Claudia Augusta, which involved tunneling through the Alps. The Chinese worked on large-scale projects such as the Grand Canal, which required cutting through various types of terrain, including mountains. They also built impressive mountain roads and tunnels. Most of these were BEFORE Muhammad, why not mention any?
You are right, but moving mountains in the past was relatively more difficult, it is possible that the hadith was revealed because of the drastic changes in the earth in the last days, Islam needs people like you to sharpen the understanding of the hadith.
@@weknowyou777 The hadiths does not say that it will be easy or difficult, simply that it will happen. You could argue that today doing so is difficult because it requires a lot of advanced technology, but in the old days you could use manpower. If you study apocalyptic religions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam), they expected the "end" to happen at any time. There are many narrations is these that speaks of events which were interpreted by "experts" of those religions as being signs of the imminent end over the last 2000+ years, yet, in never came. So, what do you mean by last days? Is it days, weeks, months, years, decades, centuries or millennia? Since you have a sharp understanding of hadiths, please let us know as all the Islamic scholars (and scholars of other religions) over the last 2000+ years have so far been wrong.
Bro they didn’t have information like we do lol they didn’t have someone from the deserts of Arabia 1400 years ago leave for a long journey which would literally take years and go to China come back and tell people about it lol you are thinking of how the world works today and using that to understand the prophecy.
@@theastronomer5800this is very stupid of you im gonna be VERY honest, the egyptians only cut blocks and mainly used limestone, they didn't physically remove mountains from their place, theres no way you actually misread whst you learned this bad, the first cases of mountains being moved were during the construction of transnational and transcontinental railroads in the 1800's after the growing use of TnT, it was literally impossible to do what you claimed, they either dug around or carved out structures, thats not the same as literally blowing a mountain out of its place and forming something new
@@weknowyou777hes not right dont agree with him, the hadith specifically mentioned mountains and this loser is trying to add extra things to confuse you, yes they cut through verious terrain but they did NOT move mountains out of their former places, carving through a structure is not the same thing as completely rearranging its position
The biggest prophecy of Muhammad was that if he was a false prophet,his aorta would be cut and behold in sahih Al Bukhari and in many hadith ,Aisha narrated his aorta was cut and he breathe his last Alhamdulillah,Allah is just ❤❤❤
Why not mention many of the prophecies that did NOT come true? For example, in Sahih Muslim 2953a (an authentic hadiths in one of the most important hadith collections, found in several narrations), we read: Anas b. Malik reported that a person asked Allah's Apostle (ﷺ): When would the Last Hour come? Thereupon Allah's Messenger (way peace be upon him) kept quiet for a while. Then looked at a young boy in his presence belonging to the tribe of Azd Shanu'a and he said: If this boy lives he would not grow very old till the Last Hour would come to you. Anas said that this young boy was of our age during those days. And, of course the boy died and the end did not come. Ooops.
Surah Al-A'raf (7:187) and Surah Luqman (31:34) contain verses about only Allah knowing when the Day of Judgment will occur, both verses were revealed in Mecca, while Sahih Muslim Hadith 2953a was narrated in Medina, meaning that the Hadith was narrated after the 2 surahs were revealed. How could the prophet Muhammad PBUH seem to know when the doomsday would occur after the revelation of the 2 verses, if literally the hadith failed to predict the doomsday then it means that the prophet Muhammad PBUH could be wrong, and that is not a new thing, Allah even rebuked the prophet Muhammad PBUH many times in the Quran, but if the hadith had a spiritual meaning then it would not contradict the timing of the revelation of the 2 verses, our common sense would say how could someone with such great dedication do something inconsistent between the revelation of god and his own words unless the hadith had a spiritual meaning.
@@weknowyou777 I agree, Muhammad, being a simple person like you and I, was wrong many times. But did you not watch this video? The Muslim dude claims that EVERYTHING that Muhammad said came to be true. So again, you need to message your Muslim friends and let them know NOT to use these silly hadiths as prophecies that came true. If this one has "spiritual meaning", then why don't all the other ones mentioned in this video also have "spiritual meaning"? Also, the hadiths is vague - it simply says that it would come before a boy would die, so that does not contradict the Quran. Muhammad never claimed to know the day or hour when he said this, only that it would happen in a not to distant future. Jesus follower have the same issue, because Jesus was an apocalyptic prophet and expected the imminent end, he told his follower that truly the end will come before his follower taste death, and before "this" (his) generation passes. This didn't come true of course, so now Christians, like Muslims, have to perform mental gymnastics to explain this. You cannot claim that some hadiths are factual/legal/instructive etc, while others (at random, because they cause you problems) are "spiritual". What criteria are you using to distinguish them, other than simply being a Muslim who cannot accept any error in your theology? Be honest.
@@theastronomer5800 You are right, but there is a point where the hadith must have a literal meaning such as the hadith about the rules of worship, fiqh laws and social rules, other than that then the hadith can have a literal and spiritual meaning.
Memories ALWAYS fail as we get older, and few had good memories. You can just looks at all the "sahih" hadiths, which have authentic isnads from "reliable" followers, but, they very often disagree on the details. Even Quranic recitations disagree on meaning, as there are ~30 different Arabic Qurans today that people recite/print, which contains different Arabic words and structures that give different meaning (I'm NOT talking about dialects here!). This is well documented by Islamic scholars.
@@theastronomer5800 That's a significant oversimplification of a complex issue. While it's true that memory can decline with age and there may be variations in hadith narrations, those differences don't invalidate the core teachings. The claim that there are 30 different versions of the Quran is simply unfounded. The Quran has been meticulously preserved throughout history, and any variations you may have heard of are likely related to different dialects, recitations, or translations, not different versions of the actual text.
Right from the beginning you have serious issues and show how anyone can interpret super vague statements to fit almost anything. He said that they will make tall building, not tallest in the world. The Arabs around him were caravan traders who lived in tents or small buildings but they travelled, traded and interacted with other cultures that had cities and tall building. Might it be possible that he simply meant that one day his people will also have such building (thinking of 2, 3, 4 story building....)??? Also, right now the tallest building is in a Muslim country but there are plans to build taller ones in other countries. And, who actually built that tallest building in Dubai? They hired non-Arab non-Muslim engineers - Samsung C&T from South Korea in a joint venture with BESIX from Belgium. Why not mention this?
The problem is that you view Muslims based on the Arab race, Muslims are not about Arabs, in fact the largest Muslim population in the world is non-Arab. The Hadith was narrated when oil was not so valuable, in fact it is only in this era that oil has become so valuable and made Dubai rich. You even compare Arab Muslims with non-Arab engineers where they still use Arabic numbers, algorithms and scientific methods, the first scientific method was invented by Arab Muslims and is still used today.
آية: 12 وَلَقَدۡ خَلَقۡنَا ٱلۡإِنسَٰنَ مِن سُلَٰلَةٖ مِّن طِينٖ 12. And indeed We created man (Adam) out of an extract of clay (water and earth). آية: 13 ثُمَّ جَعَلۡنَٰهُ نُطۡفَةٗ فِي قَرَارٖ مَّكِينٖ 13. Thereafter We made him (the offspring of Adam) as a Nutfah (mixed drops of the male and female sexual discharge and lodged it) in a safe lodging (womb of the woman). آية: 14 ثُمَّ خَلَقۡنَا ٱلنُّطۡفَةَ عَلَقَةٗ فَخَلَقۡنَا ٱلۡعَلَقَةَ مُضۡغَةٗ فَخَلَقۡنَا ٱلۡمُضۡغَةَ عِظَٰمٗا فَكَسَوۡنَا ٱلۡعِظَٰمَ لَحۡمٗا ثُمَّ أَنشَأۡنَٰهُ خَلۡقًا ءَاخَرَۚ فَتَبَارَكَ ٱللَّهُ أَحۡسَنُ ٱلۡخَٰلِقِينَ 14. Then We made the Nutfah into a clot (a piece of thick coagulated blood), then We made the clot into a little lump of flesh, then We made out of that little lump of flesh bones, then We clothed the bones with flesh, and then We brought it forth as another creation. So Blessed is Allâh, the Best of creators.[1] (V.23:14) See the footnote of (V.22:5). آية: 15 ثُمَّ إِنَّكُم بَعۡدَ ذَٰلِكَ لَمَيِّتُونَ 15. After that, surely, you will die. آية: 16 ثُمَّ إِنَّكُمۡ يَوۡمَ ٱلۡقِيَٰمَةِ تُبۡعَثُونَ 16. Then (again), surely, you will be resurrected on the Day of Resurrection. Holy Quran ❤
Quran is copy of Torah and Bible (3:3) He has revealed this Book to you, setting forth the truth and confirming the earlier Books, and earlier He revealed the Torah and Gospel (3:4) for the guidance of mankind;2 and He has also revealed the Criterion (to distinguish truth from falsehood).
If Allah is all-knowing, why doesn't he say WHEN exactly the Romans will be defeated? The verse is vague and gives a long time window. Given the fact that they were at war with each other and won battles on opposite sides, how is this an amazing/convincing prediction? You win some and you lose some. According to Yusuf Ali the Arabic word for "a few years," Bidh'un, signifies a period of three to nine years; yet according to some scholars the victory did not come until nearly twelve years later. The Persians defeated the Byzantines and captured Jerusalem at about A.D. 614 or 615. The Byzantine counter-offensive did not begin until A.D. 622 and the victory was not complete until A.D. 625, making it a period between ten to eleven years, not "a few years" alluded to in the Quran. In fact, the Romans did not become "permanently victorious" until the signing of the peace with Khosrow’s son in 628, since Khosrow rallied his forces in 626 and was defeated and executed in 628. This means that it took the Romans 15-16 years to permanently conquer the Persians. Read Surah 30. Using the Quran, WHEN were the Romans defeated (so what date can we count 3-9 years), and WHO defeated them? In WHAT land were they defeated, and nearer to WHAT? Then, WHOM will they be victorious over? You take this as a prophecy, but it is a very vague statment that can be fit to numerous instances in history, especially since the Roman Empire lasted for over about 1500 years and has fought and won/lost many battles, but the Empire as a whole was not defeated any time during the early years of Islam. The Roman empire in the East lasted (as the Byzantine Empire) into the 15th century, so what "defeat" is the Quran talking about??? The Quran is supposed to be eternal, but it cannot even mention a precise date to show how "divine" it is supposed to be. More importantly, when the Quran was initially written it was written as a consonantal text, with no vowel markings. Without these, you can read/translate the texts as "The Romans have conquered, and in a few years they will be defeated".
It's important to understand that the Quran is not a history book that provides specific chronological details like dates, times, and locations. It's a guidebook for life, offering universal messages and miracles as signs of God's greatness. The Purpose of the Verse: The verse isn't intended to provide detailed information about the Roman-Persian war, but rather to give good news to Muslims who were facing difficult times. It's part of a series of verses that explain God's power and His promises to the faithful. Historical Context: The period was marked by great upheaval and rapid changes in power. Victory and defeat were common in wars. It's essential to view the verse in its historical context, as a source of encouragement for Muslims facing significant challenges. The Meaning of "Bidh'un": The word "Bidh'un" has a relative meaning and can be interpreted within a specific time frame. There's no need to force a very narrow interpretation. It's crucial to consider the cultural and linguistic context at the time the verse was revealed. Permanent Victory: The verse doesn't speak of permanent victory but of a victory that will occur after a period of defeat. This victory is part of the dynamics of history and shouldn't be interpreted as a final and total victory. The Essence of the Quran: The Quran isn't a history book that provides detailed information about world events. It's a guidebook for life, offering universal messages about monotheism, ethics, and God's promises to humanity.
@@weknowyou777 You should send you comment not to me but to all the Muslims who make videos and write websites/articles about this particular verse and claim that it is EXACTLY speaking about specific historical events.
9:27 I’m sorry but your brother is a bit skeptical, like the other video also very insane. Obviously he is looking those through the current science lens, but bro, that Quran was revealed 1400 years ago, and you think people at this era could figure out those thing. Au contraire they believed in crazy things, like the earth is maintain by some bulls, the sun is static etc.. And the Quran literally came with stuff we discover now. Trust me Tristan, if you were in this era, or just 1000 years ago, you wouldn’t guess none of this thing, you would just be dumb like everyone 😹
when you learn Islam just from TH-cam maybe there any chance to missguide the understanding. search real moslem educated teacher Islam who follow Sunnah prophet Muhammad SAW like ahlussunah wal jamaah.
Mistakes are possible. It is important that we correct the mistakes of our new Muslim brothers. No one knows everything, especially religion. There are Muslim scholars who also make mistakes.
Your brothers comprehension skills ain’t the best I’ll be honest😂😂. I know you want the best for your family but sometimes when your new to Islam it’s hard to explain things just because your not too knowledgeable on the religion. I suggest you gain more knowledge brother and recommend your bro to watch simple dawah videos such as Muslim lantern or uthman ibn Farooq. Having little knowledge and saying wrong things can make ppl run away from the deen but I know you want the best ultimately ahki ❤
TBH... You don't explain him well. Example: Persian and Rom. They were not Muslim at that time. Islam just begins. 20 yrs. So young religion compared to Christian 2000 years and Sun worshipper longer than that. OFC, now they are Muslim after Muslim conquered. But not Muslim at the time the prophet prophecy it. No one will believe at that time Islamic State were just less than 10,000 army. Persian and Rom were more than a million army in total. Second... you must bring your friend back to 1400 yrs ago and let him see from that point. Let him feel what would he live at that time. You failed to bring him back to that time. Your friend still putting himself at this time. So, he won't feel that much impact on the prophecies. Just my opinion. Another example: The high-rise buildings on the desert. You failed to explain to him what the condition in Arab was 1400 yrs ago. Poverty and almost no life in the desert. Even to get a water was so difficult and how the prophet can imagine in that condition. Forget about the economy and standard of living the Badwin people compare the life styes of Roman and Persia.
That's what I was trying to explain. The Arabs were great caravan traders at this time and interacted with other more advanced cultures. Muhammad was most likely imagining that one day his people might live in stone buildings just as tall as those that his people would see on their travels to cities. BTW, Christianity was only ~600 years old at this time, however, Muhammad did not seem to be very familiar with orthodox Christianity given the content of the Quran, which contains many fairy tales told by heretical Christian groups who loved in Arabia, which are found in the Infancy Gospels, Protoevengelium of James, etc.
😂 Interesting thing about orbit stuff. You are spoiled by technology and information and economic as-well. Makes you think it’s common knowledge. Even few years ago in my village almost everyone uneducated because economic factors they didn’t know if earth is round or flat. And when astronomical phenomenon happened in the sky they will link it to supernatural stuff. Almost no one has access to internet. it happened just about 15 years ago.😂 Imagine illiterate civilisations 1500 years ago🙃
Yes, this is true. That's why the Quran contains so many local man-made myths, legends and ideas of its time. It also borrows from pre-Islamic superstitions, things such a jinn, night journey (found in Persian mythology), creation myths like the one in 21:30 and many others. Such religious texts must be viewed in historical context, otherwise one must perform high-level mental gymnastics if they try to relate them to the physical world as we know/understand it today. Most religious people cannot do that and cannot admit that their texts are based on myths and contain mistakes though, because their entire theology would fall apart.
Hi bro, just fyi, at the time of our prophet muhammad (s.a.w), persians were not muslim, they were zoroastrianism. Only after muslim conquest of Persia(Iran), later on that most convert to islam willingly & not based on forced. But do note that current state of Iran, they are practising Shia, and not of sunnah’s teaching which we follow closely like our prophet.
I guess you have not read any Islamic history found for example in the sira literature, or in the histories written by Muslim scholars. Only in your imagination did most convert to Islam willingly. Your comment shows a gross lack of historical knowledge.
@@theastronomer5800 You are right, military combat can be counted as force even if there is voluntary acceptance afterwards, I am Muslim and if I were a person living in that era then I would not agree to Muslims conquering Persia, but if I were in that era with the values and culture of that era then I would definitely agree to it.
@@weknowyou777 Again, you have not studied history. People converted after being conquered because they were a significant social and economic disadvantage for not being Muslims (this is explained in Sharia manuals, have you not read them?). Do you think this is fair? Take the Roman Empire, when they conquered a people they allowed ALL of them to worship their local religions and they became citizens, with equal rights. Islam does not do that.
Many of the places that Islam conquered had much more ancient cultures and values. Most places figured out thousands of years before Islam that killing, stealing, lying, r@ping, etc are not things you want to do if you want to live next to other people in peace. Islam has nothing new to say on that, in fact, it is more backwards than some other cultures because it allows multiple wives (the women are rarely in favour of this), child marriage, consummation of marriage before puberty (65:4 - explained by the tafsirs), r@ping married females slaves, slaver etc.
Just take slavery for example - is that something that we should have today, since Allah and Muhammad clearly allow it? Top Muslims scholars argue that is is part of Islam. Saudi Sheikh Saleh Al-Fawzan, member of the Senior Council of Clerics said: "Slavery is a part of Islam...(those who argue that slavery is abolished are) ignorant, not scholars. They are merely writers. Whoever says such things is an infidel."
@@theastronomer5800 It is undeniable that conquest was often followed by political and social pressure on the indigenous population. However, the extent to which these pressures were a major factor in religious conversion is still a matter of debate among historians.
While there are some cases where religious conversion was associated with economic benefits, there is no strong evidence to suggest that this was a major factor in mass conversion in Persia.
The cultural and religious similarities between Islam and some groups in Persia, such as Zoroastrianism, may have facilitated the process of assimilation and conversion.
The process of Islamization in Persia was not an instantaneous event, but took place over several centuries. Many complex factors influenced this process, including the political, social, and cultural policies of the various Islamic dynasties that came to power.
I don't know where you are from, but I live in a country that was colonized by Christians, they even equated the natives with dogs and it was even written in an inscription, while Muslims came by trading, they came first in a peaceful way.
Polygamy is still practiced because Saudi Arabia has few human resources and then on the other hand the situation requires them to fight because natural resources are also few, Islam came to reduce the number of wives that can be married, so actually Islam gives a sign that we must have 1 wife.
The opinion of Sheikh Saleh Al-Fawzan represents an extreme minority view among Muslims. It is in stark contrast to the majority of modern scholars' understanding of Islam and universal human values.
My advice you don't learn from people who don't like Islam, it's the same as learning a right-wing group from a left-wing group, perfection from humans is impossible, you will definitely find weaknesses in each group.
I would like to add/ correct on the fact that 1:3 was the ratio of Muslims (which video ref) was in battle of trench which was between muslim arabs & non-muslim arabs. Persian and Byzantine empire were in far greater numbers, as in the battle of Ohad. Predicting that muslim will soon take over two major super powers of that time during a losing battle is more incredible
11:49 a little rectification: he was outnumbered 3 vs 1 by his enemies while he was predicting the conquest of Persia and Roma. Like it was during a battle, people weren’t even sure they will survive because they were just a little group, but he said they will defeat the great empires of Persia and Roma.
But yeah obviously they were also outnumbered by Persia and the Romans, and it was a lot more than 3v1 lol, historians say it was as if the Eskimos defeated Usa and Russia (impossible)
May Allah guide all of us ❤
We need part 2!
Anas b. Malik reported that a person asked Allah's Apostle (ﷺ): When would the Last Hour come? Thereupon Allah's Messenger (way peace be upon him) kept quiet for a while. Then looked at a young boy in his presence belonging to the tribe of Azd Shanu'a and he said: If this boy lives he would not grow very old till the Last Hour would come to you. Anas said that this young boy was of our age during those days. - Sahih Muslim 2953b
There are many narrations of this in the authentic hadith collections, and other such "prophecies", which obviously did not come true. They should make a video on these. As for the ones mentioned here, read my comments I posted - they exclude all and any historical evidence which shows that these things either were going on before Muhammad, or are so vague they are meaningless as they can be fit to anything.
Bro this the one problem we have in our ummah and what the prophet warned about which is judging others and calling others kafir.
If one calls another a kafir and it turns out he wasnt, that means the person who called him a kafir is one.
May Allah guide you❤
1400 years ago Persian Wher Fire Worshipers......
Super power of that time alongside with Rome
Thanks ❤
Take your time, keep learning.
Don't press on him. Take your time and it is okay. Don't forget that some of the best Muslims in history came later to Islam like Khalid Ibn Al Waleed.
Take your time. You being convinced is a must and nothing is wrong in studying things carefully as long as they aren't with pride. I don't see pride there. May God guide you and all of us
Really great reaction! May Allah bless both you guys! Prophet Muhammad made many more prophecies never proven wrong and based on those and the Quran Muslims had begun to excel in all studies (science, health, history, etc) and have discovered many great things SUBHANALLAH Allahu akbar 💗
Studies were acquired through conquest 😅all stolen
Quran Muslims only Excel in warr and Slaves.
Anas b. Malik reported that a person asked Allah's Apostle (ﷺ): When would the Last Hour come? Thereupon Allah's Messenger (way peace be upon him) kept quiet for a while. Then looked at a young boy in his presence belonging to the tribe of Azd Shanu'a and he said: If this boy lives he would not grow very old till the Last Hour would come to you. Anas said that this young boy was of our age during those days. - Sahih Muslim 2953b
There are many narrations of this in the authentic hadith collections, and other such "prophecies", which obviously did not come true. They should make a video on these. As for the ones mentioned here, read my comments I posted - they exclude all and any historical evidence which shows that these things either were going on before Muhammad, or are so vague they are meaningless as they can be fit to anything.
Persia was not muslim at that time
Loves.. ❤ ❤
❤❤❤
please watch part 2 of this video!
Anas b. Malik reported that a person asked Allah's Apostle (ﷺ): When would the Last Hour come? Thereupon Allah's Messenger (way peace be upon him) kept quiet for a while. Then looked at a young boy in his presence belonging to the tribe of Azd Shanu'a and he said: If this boy lives he would not grow very old till the Last Hour would come to you. Anas said that this young boy was of our age during those days. - Sahih Muslim 2953b
There are many narrations of this in the authentic hadith collections, and other such "prophecies", which obviously did not come true. They should make a video on these. As for the ones mentioned here, read my comments I posted - they exclude all and any historical evidence which shows that these things either were going on before Muhammad, or are so vague they are meaningless as they can be fit to anything.
Interest was a common feature of the ancient world if you wanted to borrow money. They ancient Babylonians talked about it and calculated what would happen if you let it compound. The Bible speaks of interest.
Great video brother,
Please react to this Video next,
"Smile To Jannah, Numerical Miracle, Ready to Covert??"
Love you brother..
Assalamu Alaykum brother
May Allah keep you firm and bless you
I'd recommend you watch a muslim lantern video (i like the agnostic asking about islam one), or a one message foundation video
watch and learn. just it. ignore what people judging. your life is your decision.
hi Julian, important note they did find Pharaoh's body in a secret royal cache and then years later Maurice Bucaille examined it and found remains of sea salt stuck in his body and that's how it was concluded that it was the body of Pharaoh mentioned in the Quran. all love to you and your brother
His body was preserved because of the high salt content im the water, i The salt in that sea is more higher than any other sea in the world,, hence why you can float if you go and swim in there, you will never sink unless of course if you weighed down👆☺️
there are part 2 and part 3 of these videos as well
Please react to the meaning of life by spoken word with ur friend.. maybe he Will have a different view
The building in the right bottom corner is familirs to me, it seems to me it is Dubai
Pharo's body was recovered after the split of the Red Sea and momofied and his momy was discovered in the 19th century.
They found his mom?!
I meant his mummy @@theastronomer5800
Brother react to muslim lantern videos too.
please react to project zam zam videos (mainly for you to grow ur faith and let your friend know about the quran)
10:41 no Persian were Zoroastrian also called as (Parsi) they workship fire
The Muslims at the time of the prophecy were fighting the the united Quraish and the other tribes not the Persians
React to Mohammed is the greatest man in history | mindblowing.
May Allah keep you in truth and strengthen your faith and may Allah guide your brother.
An illiterate caravan robber who had many wives, including a child wife, ordered assassination of people who made fun of him (including women - details in the Sira), allows child marriage (Q 65:4), r@pe of captures women (Quran, tafsirs, sahih hadiths), started ~100 raids and battles (Ibn Ishaq), forced people to accept his made-up religion (Quran, sahih hadiths), tortured people (Sira), etc etc. Really swell guy!
Al-Aawad and Hammam reported Aisha as saying: I used to scrape off the (drop of) semen from the garment of the Messenger of Allah - Sahih Muslim 288b
The hour won't be established until mountains are moved? The ancient Egyptians cut up mountains to make building blocks for their monuments. The Incas, known for their remarkable engineering skills, modified the Andean landscape significantly. They built extensive road networks that included tunnels and cuttings through mountains. Roman engineers were adept at modifying landscapes for infrastructure projects. They built extensive road networks, some of which required cutting through hills and mountains. Notable examples include the Via Claudia Augusta, which involved tunneling through the Alps. The Chinese worked on large-scale projects such as the Grand Canal, which required cutting through various types of terrain, including mountains. They also built impressive mountain roads and tunnels. Most of these were BEFORE Muhammad, why not mention any?
You are right, but moving mountains in the past was relatively more difficult, it is possible that the hadith was revealed because of the drastic changes in the earth in the last days, Islam needs people like you to sharpen the understanding of the hadith.
@@weknowyou777 The hadiths does not say that it will be easy or difficult, simply that it will happen. You could argue that today doing so is difficult because it requires a lot of advanced technology, but in the old days you could use manpower.
If you study apocalyptic religions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam), they expected the "end" to happen at any time. There are many narrations is these that speaks of events which were interpreted by "experts" of those religions as being signs of the imminent end over the last 2000+ years, yet, in never came. So, what do you mean by last days? Is it days, weeks, months, years, decades, centuries or millennia? Since you have a sharp understanding of hadiths, please let us know as all the Islamic scholars (and scholars of other religions) over the last 2000+ years have so far been wrong.
Bro they didn’t have information like we do lol they didn’t have someone from the deserts of Arabia 1400 years ago leave for a long journey which would literally take years and go to China come back and tell people about it lol you are thinking of how the world works today and using that to understand the prophecy.
@@theastronomer5800this is very stupid of you im gonna be VERY honest, the egyptians only cut blocks and mainly used limestone, they didn't physically remove mountains from their place, theres no way you actually misread whst you learned this bad, the first cases of mountains being moved were during the construction of transnational and transcontinental railroads in the 1800's after the growing use of TnT, it was literally impossible to do what you claimed, they either dug around or carved out structures, thats not the same as literally blowing a mountain out of its place and forming something new
@@weknowyou777hes not right dont agree with him, the hadith specifically mentioned mountains and this loser is trying to add extra things to confuse you, yes they cut through verious terrain but they did NOT move mountains out of their former places, carving through a structure is not the same thing as completely rearranging its position
Bro please react to this beautiful recitation by qari Fateh in youtube.
Surah An-Nisa: Qari Fatih Seferagic (English/Arabic Subs)
The biggest prophecy of Muhammad was that if he was a false prophet,his aorta would be cut and behold in sahih Al Bukhari and in many hadith ,Aisha narrated his aorta was cut and he breathe his last
Alhamdulillah,Allah is just ❤❤❤
Utmost stupidity even if your arota cut you'll also do the same 😂😂😂
Persian is a muslim Country today and dominantly muslim population. Persian is called iran today
*there is nothing kept secret that will not come to light
Why not mention many of the prophecies that did NOT come true? For example, in Sahih Muslim 2953a (an authentic hadiths in one of the most important hadith collections, found in several narrations), we read:
Anas b. Malik reported that a person asked Allah's Apostle (ﷺ): When would the Last Hour come? Thereupon Allah's Messenger (way peace be upon him) kept quiet for a while. Then looked at a young boy in his presence belonging to the tribe of Azd Shanu'a and he said: If this boy lives he would not grow very old till the Last Hour would come to you. Anas said that this young boy was of our age during those days.
And, of course the boy died and the end did not come. Ooops.
Surah Al-A'raf (7:187) and Surah Luqman (31:34) contain verses about only Allah knowing when the Day of Judgment will occur, both verses were revealed in Mecca, while Sahih Muslim Hadith 2953a was narrated in Medina, meaning that the Hadith was narrated after the 2 surahs were revealed.
How could the prophet Muhammad PBUH seem to know when the doomsday would occur after the revelation of the 2 verses, if literally the hadith failed to predict the doomsday then it means that the prophet Muhammad PBUH could be wrong, and that is not a new thing, Allah even rebuked the prophet Muhammad PBUH many times in the Quran, but if the hadith had a spiritual meaning then it would not contradict the timing of the revelation of the 2 verses, our common sense would say how could someone with such great dedication do something inconsistent between the revelation of god and his own words unless the hadith had a spiritual meaning.
@@weknowyou777 I agree, Muhammad, being a simple person like you and I, was wrong many times. But did you not watch this video? The Muslim dude claims that EVERYTHING that Muhammad said came to be true. So again, you need to message your Muslim friends and let them know NOT to use these silly hadiths as prophecies that came true. If this one has "spiritual meaning", then why don't all the other ones mentioned in this video also have "spiritual meaning"?
Also, the hadiths is vague - it simply says that it would come before a boy would die, so that does not contradict the Quran. Muhammad never claimed to know the day or hour when he said this, only that it would happen in a not to distant future. Jesus follower have the same issue, because Jesus was an apocalyptic prophet and expected the imminent end, he told his follower that truly the end will come before his follower taste death, and before "this" (his) generation passes. This didn't come true of course, so now Christians, like Muslims, have to perform mental gymnastics to explain this.
You cannot claim that some hadiths are factual/legal/instructive etc, while others (at random, because they cause you problems) are "spiritual". What criteria are you using to distinguish them, other than simply being a Muslim who cannot accept any error in your theology? Be honest.
@@theastronomer5800 You are right, but there is a point where the hadith must have a literal meaning such as the hadith about the rules of worship, fiqh laws and social rules, other than that then the hadith can have a literal and spiritual meaning.
In the time of the prophet Muhammad saw, writing and reading were shameful because it was a sign of a weak memory
Memories ALWAYS fail as we get older, and few had good memories. You can just looks at all the "sahih" hadiths, which have authentic isnads from "reliable" followers, but, they very often disagree on the details. Even Quranic recitations disagree on meaning, as there are ~30 different Arabic Qurans today that people recite/print, which contains different Arabic words and structures that give different meaning (I'm NOT talking about dialects here!). This is well documented by Islamic scholars.
@@theastronomer5800 That's a significant oversimplification of a complex issue. While it's true that memory can decline with age and there may be variations in hadith narrations, those differences don't invalidate the core teachings.
The claim that there are 30 different versions of the Quran is simply unfounded. The Quran has been meticulously preserved throughout history, and any variations you may have heard of are likely related to different dialects, recitations, or translations, not different versions of the actual text.
Watch the meaning of life Muslim spoken words
I think you're friend is not taking it seriously
Right from the beginning you have serious issues and show how anyone can interpret super vague statements to fit almost anything. He said that they will make tall building, not tallest in the world. The Arabs around him were caravan traders who lived in tents or small buildings but they travelled, traded and interacted with other cultures that had cities and tall building. Might it be possible that he simply meant that one day his people will also have such building (thinking of 2, 3, 4 story building....)??? Also, right now the tallest building is in a Muslim country but there are plans to build taller ones in other countries. And, who actually built that tallest building in Dubai? They hired non-Arab non-Muslim engineers - Samsung C&T from South Korea in a joint venture with BESIX from Belgium. Why not mention this?
The problem is that you view Muslims based on the Arab race, Muslims are not about Arabs, in fact the largest Muslim population in the world is non-Arab.
The Hadith was narrated when oil was not so valuable, in fact it is only in this era that oil has become so valuable and made Dubai rich.
You even compare Arab Muslims with non-Arab engineers where they still use Arabic numbers, algorithms and scientific methods, the first scientific method was invented by Arab Muslims and is still used today.
You must read the Seera (history and biography) of the prophet because you've been wrong on the topic of Persia empire
آية: 12
وَلَقَدۡ خَلَقۡنَا ٱلۡإِنسَٰنَ مِن سُلَٰلَةٖ مِّن طِينٖ
12. And indeed We created man (Adam) out of an extract of clay (water and earth).
آية: 13
ثُمَّ جَعَلۡنَٰهُ نُطۡفَةٗ فِي قَرَارٖ مَّكِينٖ
13. Thereafter We made him (the offspring of Adam) as a Nutfah (mixed drops of the male and female sexual discharge and lodged it) in a safe lodging (womb of the woman).
آية: 14
ثُمَّ خَلَقۡنَا ٱلنُّطۡفَةَ عَلَقَةٗ فَخَلَقۡنَا ٱلۡعَلَقَةَ مُضۡغَةٗ فَخَلَقۡنَا ٱلۡمُضۡغَةَ عِظَٰمٗا فَكَسَوۡنَا ٱلۡعِظَٰمَ لَحۡمٗا ثُمَّ أَنشَأۡنَٰهُ خَلۡقًا ءَاخَرَۚ فَتَبَارَكَ ٱللَّهُ أَحۡسَنُ ٱلۡخَٰلِقِينَ
14. Then We made the Nutfah into a clot (a piece of thick coagulated blood), then We made the clot into a little lump of flesh, then We made out of that little lump of flesh bones, then We clothed the bones with flesh, and then We brought it forth as another creation. So Blessed is Allâh, the Best of creators.[1]
(V.23:14) See the footnote of (V.22:5).
آية: 15
ثُمَّ إِنَّكُم بَعۡدَ ذَٰلِكَ لَمَيِّتُونَ
15. After that, surely, you will die.
آية: 16
ثُمَّ إِنَّكُمۡ يَوۡمَ ٱلۡقِيَٰمَةِ تُبۡعَثُونَ
16. Then (again), surely, you will be resurrected on the Day of Resurrection.
Holy Quran ❤
Quran is copy of Torah and Bible (3:3) He has revealed this Book to you, setting forth the truth and confirming the earlier Books, and earlier He revealed the Torah and Gospel (3:4) for the guidance of mankind;2 and He has also revealed the Criterion (to distinguish truth from falsehood).
If Allah is all-knowing, why doesn't he say WHEN exactly the Romans will be defeated? The verse is vague and gives a long time window. Given the fact that they were at war with each other and won battles on opposite sides, how is this an amazing/convincing prediction? You win some and you lose some.
According to Yusuf Ali the Arabic word for "a few years," Bidh'un, signifies a period of three to nine years; yet according to some scholars the victory did not come until nearly twelve years later. The Persians defeated the Byzantines and captured Jerusalem at about A.D. 614 or 615. The Byzantine counter-offensive did not begin until A.D. 622 and the victory was not complete until A.D. 625, making it a period between ten to eleven years, not "a few years" alluded to in the Quran. In fact, the Romans did not become "permanently victorious" until the signing of the peace with Khosrow’s son in 628, since Khosrow rallied his forces in 626 and was defeated and executed in 628. This means that it took the Romans 15-16 years to permanently conquer the Persians.
Read Surah 30. Using the Quran, WHEN were the Romans defeated (so what date can we count 3-9 years), and WHO defeated them? In WHAT land were they defeated, and nearer to WHAT? Then, WHOM will they be victorious over? You take this as a prophecy, but it is a very vague statment that can be fit to numerous instances in history, especially since the Roman Empire lasted for over about 1500 years and has fought and won/lost many battles, but the Empire as a whole was not defeated any time during the early years of Islam. The Roman empire in the East lasted (as the Byzantine Empire) into the 15th century, so what "defeat" is the Quran talking about??? The Quran is supposed to be eternal, but it cannot even mention a precise date to show how "divine" it is supposed to be.
More importantly, when the Quran was initially written it was written as a consonantal text, with no vowel markings. Without these, you can read/translate the texts as "The Romans have conquered, and in a few years they will be defeated".
It's important to understand that the Quran is not a history book that provides specific chronological details like dates, times, and locations. It's a guidebook for life, offering universal messages and miracles as signs of God's greatness.
The Purpose of the Verse:
The verse isn't intended to provide detailed information about the Roman-Persian war, but rather to give good news to Muslims who were facing difficult times.
It's part of a series of verses that explain God's power and His promises to the faithful.
Historical Context:
The period was marked by great upheaval and rapid changes in power. Victory and defeat were common in wars.
It's essential to view the verse in its historical context, as a source of encouragement for Muslims facing significant challenges.
The Meaning of "Bidh'un":
The word "Bidh'un" has a relative meaning and can be interpreted within a specific time frame. There's no need to force a very narrow interpretation.
It's crucial to consider the cultural and linguistic context at the time the verse was revealed.
Permanent Victory:
The verse doesn't speak of permanent victory but of a victory that will occur after a period of defeat.
This victory is part of the dynamics of history and shouldn't be interpreted as a final and total victory.
The Essence of the Quran:
The Quran isn't a history book that provides detailed information about world events.
It's a guidebook for life, offering universal messages about monotheism, ethics, and God's promises to humanity.
@@weknowyou777 You should send you comment not to me but to all the Muslims who make videos and write websites/articles about this particular verse and claim that it is EXACTLY speaking about specific historical events.
@@theastronomer5800 brother, the way the brain works is like that, if someone loves something then their brain will become a lawyer who defends them.
The Quran is last word from God.. practically a continuation from the Bible
And Torah.
9:27 I’m sorry but your brother is a bit skeptical, like the other video also very insane. Obviously he is looking those through the current science lens, but bro, that Quran was revealed 1400 years ago, and you think people at this era could figure out those thing. Au contraire they believed in crazy things, like the earth is maintain by some bulls, the sun is static etc.. And the Quran literally came with stuff we discover now. Trust me Tristan, if you were in this era, or just 1000 years ago, you wouldn’t guess none of this thing, you would just be dumb like everyone 😹
Time to turn to Jesus, we are in the end times
when you learn Islam just from TH-cam maybe there any chance to missguide the understanding. search real moslem educated teacher Islam who follow Sunnah prophet Muhammad SAW like ahlussunah wal jamaah.
Mistakes are possible. It is important that we correct the mistakes of our new Muslim brothers.
No one knows everything, especially religion.
There are Muslim scholars who also make mistakes.
Your brothers comprehension skills ain’t the best I’ll be honest😂😂. I know you want the best for your family but sometimes when your new to Islam it’s hard to explain things just because your not too knowledgeable on the religion.
I suggest you gain more knowledge brother and recommend your bro to watch simple dawah videos such as Muslim lantern or uthman ibn Farooq.
Having little knowledge and saying wrong things can make ppl run away from the deen but I know you want the best ultimately ahki ❤
TBH... You don't explain him well. Example: Persian and Rom. They were not Muslim at that time. Islam just begins. 20 yrs. So young religion compared to Christian 2000 years and Sun worshipper longer than that. OFC, now they are Muslim after Muslim conquered. But not Muslim at the time the prophet prophecy it. No one will believe at that time Islamic State were just less than 10,000 army. Persian and Rom were more than a million army in total. Second... you must bring your friend back to 1400 yrs ago and let him see from that point. Let him feel what would he live at that time. You failed to bring him back to that time. Your friend still putting himself at this time. So, he won't feel that much impact on the prophecies. Just my opinion. Another example: The high-rise buildings on the desert. You failed to explain to him what the condition in Arab was 1400 yrs ago. Poverty and almost no life in the desert. Even to get a water was so difficult and how the prophet can imagine in that condition. Forget about the economy and standard of living the Badwin people compare the life styes of Roman and Persia.
That's what I was trying to explain. The Arabs were great caravan traders at this time and interacted with other more advanced cultures. Muhammad was most likely imagining that one day his people might live in stone buildings just as tall as those that his people would see on their travels to cities.
BTW, Christianity was only ~600 years old at this time, however, Muhammad did not seem to be very familiar with orthodox Christianity given the content of the Quran, which contains many fairy tales told by heretical Christian groups who loved in Arabia, which are found in the Infancy Gospels, Protoevengelium of James, etc.
😂
Interesting thing about orbit stuff.
You are spoiled by technology and information and economic as-well. Makes you think it’s common knowledge.
Even few years ago in my village almost everyone uneducated because economic factors they didn’t know if earth is round or flat. And when astronomical phenomenon happened in the sky they will link it to supernatural stuff.
Almost no one has access to internet. it happened just about 15 years ago.😂
Imagine illiterate civilisations 1500 years ago🙃
Yes, this is true. That's why the Quran contains so many local man-made myths, legends and ideas of its time. It also borrows from pre-Islamic superstitions, things such a jinn, night journey (found in Persian mythology), creation myths like the one in 21:30 and many others. Such religious texts must be viewed in historical context, otherwise one must perform high-level mental gymnastics if they try to relate them to the physical world as we know/understand it today. Most religious people cannot do that and cannot admit that their texts are based on myths and contain mistakes though, because their entire theology would fall apart.