Also turned 60 a few months ago . Whatever other genres of music I have explored over the course of time, tend to return to Joy Division. I know that New Order took a while to play Joy Division songs live, but they certainly did well whilst performing 'Atmosphere' in 1998.
@@steve261brown I don't think Barney ruined it at all. Sure it's not as good as Ian, but when I hear other sings this song, I don't think they are any better than Barney. At least with Barney he's part of the creation of this song.
Agreed, I chose Atmosphere to play to my 6th form class,my project /speech was on the evolution of Warsaw - Joy Division - New Order, the year was around 1982 - 85, having trouble remembering.... lol. Most passionate public speech I ever gave.
Sad in it,...bastard trick really...its like me,..I am a mechanic...good at it...I feel a responsability to my customers and friends to keep them on the road,..tested and happy and safe...I dont just fk em off sulking and throwing my dummy out cot because someone,s not cleaned my big snap on bar after borrowing it...best "similie!" I can come up with..but you know what I mean , REALLY? COME ON LADS ...SORT IT OUT...BIG...BIG PAY DAY IF YOU BOXED CLEVER AND DID THE RIGHT GIGS IN THE RIGHT PLACES...PLUS YOU,DE LOVE IT...CAUSE WE ALL WOULD.... FUCKIN HELL...SULKY TWATS
I've just read Mayflies by Andrew O'Hagan. Fabulous book and this is part of the soundtrack.... though in the book it's Joy Division but I think having spent all evening listening to various versions... this is right up there as chuffing brilliant!
when i was in college in the 80s i made a video for this in black and white. i only remember shots of an olde new england cemetery and me in black with bleached hair looking depressed and smoking cigarettes in the dark #goodtimes new order is still the best.
Wow belle reprise, si on peut appeler ça une reprise, car ils ont participés à sa création ;) la voix de Ian Curtis me manquera toujours :( merci a new order d'avoir continué dans la musique et d'avoir marqué les années 80/90 ✨✨✨
Memories I was in The Holiday inn Reading , New Order had the top floor . The foyer & the rest of the Hotel was full of Mancs , sleeping on chairs etc in The Foyer it rocked backstage . My mate Tony was asked by Rob Gretton to go up the telescopic fireman’s ladders to take some photos . Rob told me he only asked Tony to go up there to get rid of him for a bit - memories . Rob was quite heavy fat even then in 1993 ish or was it 98 I can’t remember ? 😍🌈😍🌈😍🌈😍🌈😍🌈😍
True order....doesnt even try to remember words...anything will do... that was the menu back then...what,s e avin,...I,ll take two of those....and a half of bitter...I,me driving!!! Chuckle...
This early version has different lyrics - which personally I prefer. th-cam.com/video/ywBnAW8w76Y/w-d-xo.html Would be interesting to know what other people think.
He's doing a world tour in 2022 playing the 2 JD albums. This may well be the encore. No better ex-JD member to play these songs IMO. Hook was their signature sound. Curtis their vibe.
@@HughRogers609 Yes PH and the Light are close to original New Order live sound as they were back in the 80s and 90s. Always a great gig and crowd singalong.
@@ChrisSmith-mu1we Did I stutter? haha. Just joking - he did the same kind of thing Guns and Roses singer did - and David Lee Roth....etc. Made himself more important than the audience. That is the day - the music died. Well - not died...I still have their albums. but seriously folks - it was 1989. Look at the trajectory - that is the year(s) they started to get less popular while others surrounding them got bigger.
I'm 60 years old and I still listen to these guys. They are quite simply amazing, sounds as fresh as the day I heard it when I was 20 years old.
You would love Mayflies by Andrew O'Hagan. Wonderful book
Anything by Bukowski.
Also turned 60 a few months ago . Whatever other genres of music I have explored over the course of time, tend to return to Joy Division. I know that New Order took a while to play Joy Division songs live, but they certainly did well whilst performing 'Atmosphere' in 1998.
I do believe , Peter Hook, is touring right now doing Joy Division songs.
Peter Hook and the light, will be touring September and October 2022. It will be a tribute to Joy Division
This has to be one of the most powerful and beautiful songs ever created.Great performance too.
Darryl Stubbs Shame Barney ruined it. He just can’t sing! Thank God for Hooky and Morris.
Spastic.
Well - it is good, anyhow.
@@steve261brown I don't think Barney ruined it at all. Sure it's not as good as Ian, but when I hear other sings this song, I don't think they are any better than Barney. At least with Barney he's part of the creation of this song.
So emotional. Cannot listen to this song without breaking down. Too much. Too perfect.
Agreed, I chose Atmosphere to play to my 6th form class,my project /speech was on the evolution of Warsaw - Joy Division - New Order, the year was around 1982 - 85, having trouble remembering.... lol. Most passionate public speech I ever gave.
That's nick moynihan from NZ not the UK.
Great choice. Such a wonderful song that will live on forever.
I want this at my funeral. So strong and soooo me
Thank you Ian Curtis for this masterpiece of art big big big thank you and the rest of jd/no rip Ian always remembered never forgotten 🙏🇬🇧👍
I wish Hooky and Sumner would put their issues behind them
Agreed!!
More sounds like Bernard wants to be in complete control
Sad in it,...bastard trick really...its like me,..I am a mechanic...good at it...I feel a responsability to my customers and friends to keep them on the road,..tested and happy and safe...I dont just fk em off sulking and throwing my dummy out cot because someone,s not cleaned my big snap on bar after borrowing it...best "similie!" I can come up with..but you know what I mean , REALLY? COME ON LADS ...SORT IT OUT...BIG...BIG PAY DAY IF YOU BOXED CLEVER AND DID THE RIGHT GIGS IN THE RIGHT PLACES...PLUS YOU,DE LOVE IT...CAUSE WE ALL WOULD.... FUCKIN HELL...SULKY TWATS
@@7428marcus i agree,, i'm on Hooky's side..
We need a final tour witb the 4 together
L’un des morceaux les plus puissants qu’il soit en émotion malgré l’absence de la la voix de curtis, elle est interprétée de façon magistral ❤️
My favorite Joy Division song.............. greetings of Perú...
Such a beautiful song. I cry every time i hear it. ❤️❤️
Was there to see this !
Just gets me, want it played at my funeral 😢
One of their best gigs.
Sends the tingles every time down to my toes
This was my first festival :) I was 18
This is a hymn with bass guitar.
and the drums
DZIEKUJE
Que Fenómenos!!
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐👋👋
Y Grande Ian Y R.I.P...🙏🙏
This is just simply superb, thank you for posting this piece of beauty
I'm 60 , saw there first us tour after Ian , incredible , still is ,
I've just read Mayflies by Andrew O'Hagan. Fabulous book and this is part of the soundtrack.... though in the book it's Joy Division but I think having spent all evening listening to various versions... this is right up there as chuffing brilliant!
What a bass player.
Shame about the vocals.. Only one Ian Curtis.
@@steve261brown yeah but it's better him singing than some other bloke with no history w/ both bands.
Agreed. And every NO /JD fan knows Bernard is not that singer... Compare him to Ian is absurd.
The bass is sublime the whole track is built around the bass line.
@@richardholdsworth4386 Absolument, comme beaucoup d'autres titres. C'est l'un des rares groupes qui fonctionne ainsi
It was my last year at University in 98 and New Order gave me this...
Stephen Morris is my favorite drummer ever 💕
Great bassline thanks moz. Moz,was watching this in 1998.
I love the way Stephen Morris plays the drum😎
when i was in college in the 80s i made a video for this in black and white. i only remember shots of an olde new england cemetery and me in black with bleached hair looking depressed and smoking cigarettes in the dark #goodtimes
new order is still the best.
Ian was depressed , you cant reproduce that emotion ... I live with it
cool story bro
Fantástico....excelente ...very good..
Beautiful performance
I guess you can play this at my funeral. I love NO
Wow belle reprise, si on peut appeler ça une reprise, car ils ont participés à sa création ;) la voix de Ian Curtis me manquera toujours :( merci a new order d'avoir continué dans la musique et d'avoir marqué les années 80/90 ✨✨✨
Que buena!!!!
Memories I was in The Holiday inn Reading , New Order had the top floor . The foyer & the rest of the Hotel was full of Mancs , sleeping on chairs etc in The Foyer it rocked backstage . My mate Tony was asked by Rob Gretton to go up the telescopic fireman’s ladders to take some photos . Rob told me he only asked Tony to go up there to get rid of him for a bit - memories . Rob was quite heavy fat even then in 1993 ish or was it 98 I can’t remember ? 😍🌈😍🌈😍🌈😍🌈😍🌈😍
Wonderful.
Likewise
Splendid
great peace!!
Wish I'd managed to get to Reading it seems. Only 24yrs late. phah. Still here Ian though, sorry.
Very good Ian Curtis \0/
So beautiful ❤️
💯
Йен Кертис 🙏🙏🙏😭
I wish bid Ian was still around
Ain’t no stoppin’ us now.
why does the drummer not age? Still?
True order....doesnt even try to remember words...anything will do... that was the menu back then...what,s e avin,...I,ll take two of those....and a half of bitter...I,me driving!!! Chuckle...
Fucking Brilliant
Don’t walk away
Cute Guys! 😎🌎🔥
Dr who's favourite time travel
This song is all about studio production which they have never been able to recreated live.
This early version has different lyrics - which personally I prefer. th-cam.com/video/ywBnAW8w76Y/w-d-xo.html
Would be interesting to know what other people think.
NO culmination gig? Fade-out Technique
Ir must be singed by Hook
lol
clöse büt knöt blööDiyy
Completely owned by Hooky if you ask me
He's doing a world tour in 2022 playing the 2 JD albums. This may well be the encore. No better ex-JD member to play these songs IMO. Hook was their signature sound. Curtis their vibe.
@@HughRogers609 Yes PH and the Light are close to original New Order live sound as they were back in the 80s and 90s. Always a great gig and crowd singalong.
Sumner isnt a very good singer Hook the same, even curtis couldnt sing very well but with him it was all about the lyrics and Hannett's production.
this guy wrecked New Order's career with his big fat ego.
Who? What a shit comment!
The singer..
Etc.
Wtf?!
@@ChrisSmith-mu1we Did I stutter? haha.
Just joking - he did the same kind of thing Guns and Roses singer did - and David Lee Roth....etc. Made himself more important than the audience. That is the day - the music died. Well - not died...I still have their albums. but seriously folks - it was 1989.
Look at the trajectory - that is the year(s) they started to get less popular while others surrounding them got bigger.
@@ziraprod6090 Who are those surrounded them that got bigger?
Just could never match those vocals.
terrible lead singing...............music is great