Frrr tho I had 1 wolf that was BIG brain basically I had to transport my dogs threw the nether (like 5 of them) and I had a bunch more so I didn’t really care if they died but the 1 after going threw the portal went straight back to the over world and then after I finished my travel (one of the 4 remaining wolfs lived) it literally tpped to me when I went back to the over world 10k blocks away cuz those portal chunks were loaded 🤣
recently I tamed a wolf and we went into cave, after some minutes he somehow drowned in water, I didn't even know in what water he died, didn't see any. ffs.
tbh all ai absolutley sucks. mobs, animals, villagers are completley dumb and their ai crumbles apart when they have to navigate terrain that's not flat or intact
Stuff should be able to jump. Why can a horse jump 3 blocks when I am on it but get stuck looking at a 2 by 1 hole in front of it like " what do you want from me"
The only AI that isn't completely braindead is Villagers and their cousins after 1.14. But in the same breath, nobody was begging Mojang for "piggy armor" or "moo moo armor" the same way they were begging for "doggy armor". Which means the existence of the armor as a band-aid fix to the Wolves' atrocious survivability AI makes the atrociousness of said AI more apparent. It's the Streisand Effect, nobody would've batted an eye at Wolves being stupid if Mojang didn't explicitly bring them into the forefront again with Armadillos and Wolf Armor.
I can attest to this. I’ve moved my villagers to a three-floored building with the job blocks on the top floor, so they went up the stairs… … and now they can’t go back down to their beds…
the amount of scenarios that make mobs go spin is boggling pathfinding shouldn't break so easily, not to mention all the: trying to go trough a imposible path, or not understanding the state of blocks, how every time mojang adds a block with a new shape mobs start spinning when they try to pathfind through or over it... how is this a recurring problem
I think the idea of wolves having more personality is great, but I definitely wouldn't remove the teleporting ability. No matter how good the AI gets, it likely will never be able to completely avoid dangerous situations, so having that safeguard is nice, for both casual and more hardcore players
I like the option to have the wolf tp to me, but the current system of either permanently sitting or never more than 12 blocks away from the player is garbage. IMO, they should add an enchanted lead or something that allows you to tp your wolf on command rather than the game doing it automatically.
This really is a big problem with *all* mc pets (cats parrots & dogs). Dogs are used as military soldiers, cats are left to sit in the depths of a creeper farm, and parrots simply exist. And if none of those are done then most often the "pets" are left to sit in a room for all eternity.
Tbh, the worst part of wolves is the fact that if they somehow get too far away without teleporting they will never teleport to you unless said chunk is loaded again. Example would be... travel on a boat with a pack of dogs following you, if ghe journey is even moderately long and you dont even revisit the chunk the dogs are essentially gone.
Part of the reason I don't like getting a wolf to follow me is because I don't want it to die while it's following me. I'd like a dog bed that a pet can assign itself to like villagers do with beds, so that when the pet dies it can respawn at the dog bed.
Are you dumb or something? If that's what you want, have your friend wear a wolf skin and make him follow you tada now you have a wolf that respwan when died
@@DarkReaper2597 also solves the other problem by having them be able to roam around also i havent used it with doggytalents before, do they work together
@@Capivaragamer0907 Maybe Mojang are trying to distance the mob vote features from named updates and make them their own thing, kinda like when bees were given their own update with the Buzzy Bees update.
@@infinitydragonoid2655 I dont really mind putting armadillo in 1.20, but i think the dog variants should Be a 1.21 thing. Well, i guess it makes sense to add dog variants with the update that added Dog Armor.
Originally Notch planned all armor to work like that, but it was added with another mechanic instead. Though in beta, the armor bar still doesn't just represent the protection of your armor, it lowers as your armor's durability decreases.
One mod that does the "Mob AI" a lot more interesting is the between lands, almost every mob has survival instincts and interactions that makes watching them feel like a nature documentary and are more natural to encounter to find than the base game
Y'know I remember watching a video about why mojang should make Minecraft 2.0 and idk what he said made a lot of sense to me. Like op said the game is over a decade old, even people like valve are updating counter strike
Yea like i tamed a parrot, and it took me an entire in game day to move him to my house (it was less that a medium village's diameter in distance) and he kept getting off of me. When i finay got him home he wouldnt stop making baby zombie noises. Like without delay. Every second. I just oofed him cause he wasnt even that cool to begin with.
I started getting dogs to protect my chickens from random fox spawns. They've just been quiet sentinels, sitting there, rain or shine, never moving, never doing anything.
@@normanbestboi9117 that's not how it works. you don't respawn because of your bed. pretty sure Notch made you respawn at your bed because it's at your house and that's where you settled when you sleep
@@normanbestboi9117 well it wouldn't be bad. it would be awesome if they could respawn but... you could really exploit that you know. plus it would remove the tension of losing your pet
I really like the idea of wolf personalities, but for your idea of having them roam your base without wandering off… how do you propose they do that? When everyone’s base is a different shape and size, how do you propose the dog knows when it’s in the base or not. Furthermore, though this is probably an easier one, how do you propose a dog know if it’s inside or outside? I really love your concept and I hope they implement it, but I’m just pointing out that a few of your suggestions have glaring holes in them
Add a Dog/Cat bed. Use a lead on your Dog/Cat, then click on the bed. That bed is now assigned to that Dog/Cat, and they have a radius they can explore around the bed.
i mean, how do villagers work? they don't leave their village, but you could say they have a job block and a bed they sleep in at night so fair enough. mojang should probably add like bowls, the treat bowls or whatever. and even so, it's not that hard to program a wolf into it's space, like mobs pathfind unique to their environment, so should wolves.
Same AI as an iron golem for wandering, but preferably with a lot less range, also should decrease range on iron golems because they wander way too far off and get lost as is.
as some smart person from different thread stated, there is a variable called "sky light". It essentially means "how much natural light reaches this block", which could be used to define indoors/shades/caves/whatever else.
New Wolf personalities seem like an amazing idea, I have a few more ideas that mojang could add. Firstly they could add a brand new wolf "movement mode" sort of like the current "follow" and "sit" modes but instead its a "scout" mode where they roam around your base. with this they could add a dog bed where it acts as an indicator of where your base is, you can place it indoors or outdoors. if the dog bed is indoors and the wolf is more of an outdoor wolf the wolf could play sad noises on the door which indicates that the wolf wants to go outside. maybe even add a new pet door? so mobs can't go inside but pets can freely go through. What will make the "scout" feature useful though is if a mob is present, more aggressive wolves would growl and even bite mobs but run away until you actually attack the mob then they would actually acttack them. And more skittish/passive wolves would make whimpering noises and run towards you for protection. Aaaand Maybe another feature they could add is hunger to wolves. that would make players pay more attention to wolves. So for example they a player makes a wolf sit, if the wolf is hungry they would stand up and try to find you and make whimpering noises to let you know they're hungry. if they strave they die (obviously lol)
This is exactly what I was afraid of when I heard the armadillo winning. I knew that in order for the additions to make sense they would need to either entirely rework dogs, fix creepers, or give the dogs plot armor. And knowing Mojang they went predictably for Plot Armor, instead of fixing their game.
Literally. Instead of teleporting, increased movement speed when they start following you would solve the problem. Higher jump and better path finding to avoid hazards as well. Hostile mobs especially creepers are literally better at path finding and avoiding hazards.
I love how we are talking about the stupidity of Minecraft dogs while my camel has been spinning inside the waterfall at my base ever since I brought it home
Most mobs in minecraft uses the same basic AI for navigation which is super easy to break, and mojang is too busy adding "content" like wolf armor to bother fixing the broken general-purpose AI that gets mobs stuck everywhere.
I suppose pathfinding can be fixed a bit for simple things like jumping over chasms. But complex behavior seems programmatically impossible in a game like this - how do you define "indoors"?
maybe the area around the owner's bed, or instead of making them sit, you can define the block that they are standing on as a center of a circumference, which defines an area that the wolf consider as "home"
We kind of already have a mechanic like that in the game....prior to 1.14, villagers worked using doors. For a door to be valid it had to have sky light access on one side. The other side was considered "inside". So it is possible.
Thinking about it, here are other examples of major weaknesses with mobs that involve A.I... • Villager-based farms in general. • Ranged mobs ignoring entities blocking the target, even if it is an End Crystal or cross-fire mob that will retaliate. • Being able to bait slimes(and sometimes skeletons) into hazards. • Skeleton infighting. • Being able to cluster mobs around a creeper, then blocking, one-shotting an entire group of mobs. • Mobs fighting other mobs outnumbered. • The Wither hovering above a player; this makes cheesing the Wither with End Crystals way easier. • Nullifying mobs as hazards using boats. • Bats.
To be fair, skeleton infighting is always fun to witness / initiate. Enemies should have flaws that the player can exploit to their advantage. Although it would make sense come to think of it that the AI should be a *bit* smarter on hard difficulty, sorta like how some enemies in Terraria gain extra abilities in Expert mode. Jellyfish can temporarily shield themselves and reflect melee attacks, zombies can wield their own arm for extra range / damage, skeletons can throw bones at the player, the Eye of Cthulhu goes into phase 2 much earlier and has a rapid dash ability that would catch classic players off guard when switching to expert for the first time, and so on.
Greg: i dropped the dog from 100 blocks. It survivor. Then from 200. It survived. Then i did what any nowmal person would do Me : drop it from 300 blocks? Greg: no. *I built a death cannon*
I really like the personality range idea, and I think it'd be cool if some dog breeds were more likely to have different personalities, such as, just a random example, Forest Wolves more likely to be extroverted (happiest when outside or with other dogs), while Snowy Wolves are more likely to be introverted (happier when inside and by itself)
I think a new addition could be a sniffing mechanic. If you give it an item, it will immediately begin taking you to the nearest mob (within reasonable distance) that drops that item.
I love the slider idea for ai. Applying it to all mobs would be cool but then they have like a baseline or preference depending on the mobs or locked ones depending on mob.
I feel something that could be useful in future updates is a thing that can revive killed pets or animals. If the animal has a special name and dies, you would be able to use lapis to resummon them. Would lean more into the magic side of Minecraft. Also less heartbreak
I- I did not know pandas had a literal "personality" mechanic. Hell I forgot they even existed. Man this is exactly what the problem with MC is, they add cool new things, but still don't update old stuff from the past that should've been fixed already.
When this update was added, i went out at night, splashed my wolf with strength and speed, and a few minutes oater, there were no skeletons around me, and any zombie that dared to attack me would meet the same fate.
@@dexaphobia8085 i dont personally like that because then your dogs are stronger fighters because they basically have more health. But with pet beds if they die, you cant use them until you go back to base.
@@kyleyoung2464 thats fair, it’d be fairly pricey until you get a raid farm though. And you could argue by that point itd be the only thing that makes wolves relevant to the late game.
Spiders are giant and attack you on sight if it's dark but are totally chill if it's light. Dogs have a mystical link to you (the same one that lets you see their death messages). Realism has never been a part of this game. Compaining about "realism" in the fantasy block game is what got the firefly removed.
I… really don’t see the problem with the wolf armor. I’m glad the armor breaks and the damage doesn’t carry over to the dog. It means you get a chance to jump in and save them before they can be killed once the armor breaks. It gives you a warning. And the teleporting isn’t really an issue either. Sure, it’s unrealistic, but who cares? It’s a game.
It's a bit interesting that a wolf can now solo an Iron Golem The main issue is that it doesn't stop death from Lava, and you now need to carry scutes on you, deal with many annoyances like getting into cracks, or just fighting a random mob I don't want to have any risk at all, so I just sit them at home like a normal person does
@@glauberglousger956 I personally don’t really have an issue with the lava. If I use wolves, it’s on the overworld, and lava isn’t too common on the surface. I’m also the kind of player who loves fighting hoards of mobs, so I’m not bothered by the dogs going after them. At the end of the day, I guess it comes down to a difference in preference and play style.
Instead of looking at a single feature and going "Yep, we're adding that!" They should make updates centered around updating entire systems, mobs etc. Imagine if we also got reworked Pet AI (Nothing too extravagant, literally just more wolf-like behaviour, tweaked stats and the ability to not stand still on Magma/Cactus blocks)
An idea I had had a while ago was for the player to craft a "whistle" of some kind that, when used, teleports all standing pets to them. This would allow the animals to wander freely and, when the player loses track of them or needs them for combat, they can summon them.
Worse yet, mods that use wolf AI for custom mobs are garbage. So much garbage. So much garbage and theyre proud of their creation based on a core of poop.
You know what they should’ve added to tamed wolfs? They should’ve added 3 click function on them. Example: Clicked to sit- after a while of just sitting, they lay or do other laying positions, or just sleep. Clicked to follow-Not much different, but at least fix their ai following/direction command. Clicked to roam- A third feature I think would be cool. Like an iron golem mostly roaming around, but still within a village. It would make the dog more dog like to roam around.
@@dalias12Would have added atmosphere to a biome people wanted. Imagine setting some loose in a flower field near your base, especially with optifine's dynamic lighting it would be incredible.
I don't really mind the AI, I think it's ok to have a pet that's just there for decoration. To me, they don't need to be useful, they just need to be fun. And I think they're fun.
the thing is they not only buffed the armor but also the wolf HP itself, making it seem crazily op while in reality it most likely wouldnt be so bad if they stuck to the old hp
I hate these types of content creators, alluding to a genuine “problem” via clickbaity title and or thumbnail, only to just make jokes or complain about an entirely different grievance that is only tangentially related at best. Wolf armor at first didn’t live up to what we wanted, but now it HAS been fixed. You’re just nit picking that fact for engagement now.
The issue is that wolf armor doesn't fix anything, because wolf AI still sucks ass and will still get them killed by the same lava and water situations that always kill them. There's also still no reason to even bother getting a wolf.
It's crazy to think how Much the Minecraft Community "People" wanted Wolf Armor SO BADLY, and Yet once people Actually got it, Everyone is Suddenly against it for Literally every reason in Existance. Crazy.
Mojang: *adds wolf armor Fans: nah that's too weak Also mojang: *buffs up the armor Fans: nah that's too unrealisticly strong Honestly i feel bad for mojang
More like Mojang: *Adds wolf Armor Real Fans: Thats not the problem here, that isnt what we wa--- Mojang: *Buffs the wolf arnor AND the Dog Real Fans: *Sigh Because most of the fans that is saying those doesnt really recognize the problem here especially that most of them are just child who prolly doesnt even know what AI is. And the problem is that those fans are the ones Mojang keeps listening to when it should not be.
Having wolves have slight variations in size, leg length, ears or snout lengths would also be a great change that probably wouldn’t be too hard. Implementing a breeding system similar to horses could allow players to get diverse dogs, and not just base wolves, similar to in real life.
I never got pets in Minecraft and the wolf armour never changed that. The only opportunity I got to get a pet that I actually wanted was in the most recent mob vote…
It’s so stupid that Wolves aren’t programmed first to avoid lava before teleporting. Almost every wolf death I ever had was because they burned
Frrr tho I had 1 wolf that was BIG brain basically I had to transport my dogs threw the nether (like 5 of them) and I had a bunch more so I didn’t really care if they died but the 1 after going threw the portal went straight back to the over world and then after I finished my travel (one of the 4 remaining wolfs lived) it literally tpped to me when I went back to the over world 10k blocks away cuz those portal chunks were loaded 🤣
recently I tamed a wolf and we went into cave, after some minutes he somehow drowned in water, I didn't even know in what water he died, didn't see any. ffs.
@@hardVatsuki 💀
What’s the fun in that? You have to have dangers to care about your loving pet bc if they didn’t then it’ll literally just be ur puppet.
so... now the only use for them is just letting them sit in the base. What's the fun in that?@@Mr_Skeely
tbh all ai absolutley sucks. mobs, animals, villagers are completley dumb and their ai crumbles apart when they have to navigate terrain that's not flat or intact
Stuff should be able to jump. Why can a horse jump 3 blocks when I am on it but get stuck looking at a 2 by 1 hole in front of it like " what do you want from me"
True
The only AI that isn't completely braindead is Villagers and their cousins after 1.14.
But in the same breath, nobody was begging Mojang for "piggy armor" or "moo moo armor" the same way they were begging for "doggy armor". Which means the existence of the armor as a band-aid fix to the Wolves' atrocious survivability AI makes the atrociousness of said AI more apparent.
It's the Streisand Effect, nobody would've batted an eye at Wolves being stupid if Mojang didn't explicitly bring them into the forefront again with Armadillos and Wolf Armor.
I can attest to this.
I’ve moved my villagers to a three-floored building with the job blocks on the top floor, so they went up the stairs…
… and now they can’t go back down to their beds…
the amount of scenarios that make mobs go spin is boggling pathfinding shouldn't break so easily, not to mention all the: trying to go trough a imposible path, or not understanding the state of blocks,
how every time mojang adds a block with a new shape mobs start spinning when they try to pathfind through or over it... how is this a recurring problem
I think the idea of wolves having more personality is great, but I definitely wouldn't remove the teleporting ability. No matter how good the AI gets, it likely will never be able to completely avoid dangerous situations, so having that safeguard is nice, for both casual and more hardcore players
TP should work if your pet is really far. These are wolves, they should run FASTER than player.
@@LordodragonssYeah definitely. Maybe even add a new running mechanic?
Agreed
I like the option to have the wolf tp to me, but the current system of either permanently sitting or never more than 12 blocks away from the player is garbage. IMO, they should add an enchanted lead or something that allows you to tp your wolf on command rather than the game doing it automatically.
@@jimbo1637 They could just do what botw did, special armor that allows you to teleport the wolf
This really is a big problem with *all* mc pets (cats parrots & dogs). Dogs are used as military soldiers, cats are left to sit in the depths of a creeper farm, and parrots simply exist. And if none of those are done then most often the "pets" are left to sit in a room for all eternity.
@@Arackuloser At least he's happy lol
Ark players suffer from this but worse
@@piglin469on ark we can force out “pets” to defecate on command and we beat are soon to be pets in to submission to even tame them
@@randomdudeface oh god
@@jamainwilkins5100 sounds lovely
Tbh, the worst part of wolves is the fact that if they somehow get too far away without teleporting they will never teleport to you unless said chunk is loaded again.
Example would be... travel on a boat with a pack of dogs following you, if ghe journey is even moderately long and you dont even revisit the chunk the dogs are essentially gone.
This video made me realise: We need sleeping dogs. Like foxes, they have a sleeping pose/animation for night time when sitting.
You opened my eyes dawg
Part of the reason I don't like getting a wolf to follow me is because I don't want it to die while it's following me. I'd like a dog bed that a pet can assign itself to like villagers do with beds, so that when the pet dies it can respawn at the dog bed.
there's a mod for that , its called domestic innovation.
(sorry if this wasn't helpful)
Are you dumb or something?
If that's what you want, have your friend wear a wolf skin and make him follow you tada now you have a wolf that respwan when died
@@DarkReaper2597 also solves the other problem by having them be able to roam around
also i havent used it with doggytalents before, do they work together
@@luminousdelight5097 haven't tried doggy talents with it.
sorry.
Unless it’s hardcore mode then yeah might as well make them respawn too
The wolf armor is literally just a totem of undying for wolves.
And that's great
I love that the dog armor neutralizes the new mace onehit KO
Dogs now stronger than wardens
@@_gergAs God intended it
Lol
@@ViviBuchlaw dog spelled backwards IS god so yes but dogs ARE gods
@@mavrikgaming970 No stop worshipping fake idols
So cool that you blasted it with my breeze cannon! 😄 thanks for mention
Mention something Rays did in your video and he'll be there.
That's what YOU should do
5:12 The wolf variants aren't actually for 1.21, but will instead be added alongside armadillos in 1.20.5
I was just abut to say that.
I dont really know why. Come on, 1.21 is not that Far away, is It?
@@Capivaragamer0907 Maybe Mojang are trying to distance the mob vote features from named updates and make them their own thing, kinda like when bees were given their own update with the Buzzy Bees update.
@@infinitydragonoid2655 I dont really mind putting armadillo in 1.20, but i think the dog variants should Be a 1.21 thing. Well, i guess it makes sense to add dog variants with the update that added Dog Armor.
@andryusgustavo9148 this will make both 1.20 and 1.21 bigger. It's much better imo
1:04 Wolf armor doesn’t have a unique system, it acts much like the player’s shield
Thats actually true, didnt think of that!
Originally Notch planned all armor to work like that, but it was added with another mechanic instead. Though in beta, the armor bar still doesn't just represent the protection of your armor, it lowers as your armor's durability decreases.
One mod that does the "Mob AI" a lot more interesting is the between lands, almost every mob has survival instincts and interactions that makes watching them feel like a nature documentary and are more natural to encounter to find than the base game
what's that mod?? i need it in my life NOW
WHATS THE MOD
only mod called 'between lands' I can find is that one swamp mod???
Mod name, please.
for everyone asking yes the mod's name the betweenlands
I think all Minecraft mods need a serious improvement to their AI. Especially now that the game is over 10 years old.
Mobs*
They did get some changes to how they attack hopefully we get some better path finding for all of them
They made them easier and less complex in theur attack behavior..@@herbnfizz4113
Y'know I remember watching a video about why mojang should make Minecraft 2.0 and idk what he said made a lot of sense to me. Like op said the game is over a decade old, even people like valve are updating counter strike
if they don't add it in 1.21, i am 100% writing a mod for this
I would genuinely carry a parrot around on my shoulder if they would actually stay
Yea like i tamed a parrot, and it took me an entire in game day to move him to my house (it was less that a medium village's diameter in distance) and he kept getting off of me. When i finay got him home he wouldnt stop making baby zombie noises. Like without delay. Every second. I just oofed him cause he wasnt even that cool to begin with.
I started getting dogs to protect my chickens from random fox spawns. They've just been quiet sentinels, sitting there, rain or shine, never moving, never doing anything.
Mojang could add a few more mobs that attack farm animals which makes players need a guard dog that protects your farm animals
why not just fence/house your animals in for the same solution?
@@slimedserpent foxes can jump over fences and if the house is not fully sealed foxes can jump into them as well
really cool concept, maybe they can make a dog house you can connect your dog too so he will stay in its vicinity
i loke this idea. maybe there will be different beds and houses for different pets for them to sleep in to heal if they took any damage that day
Dog house = dog bed = dog respawns?
@@normanbestboi9117 that's not how it works. you don't respawn because of your bed. pretty sure Notch made you respawn at your bed because it's at your house and that's where you settled when you sleep
@@WeirdguyKruckly still, would it be bad?
@@normanbestboi9117 well it wouldn't be bad. it would be awesome if they could respawn but... you could really exploit that you know. plus it would remove the tension of losing your pet
If wolves become stronger when wearing armadillo skin, shouldn’t that mean that armadillos should be just as strong?
idk why I wrote this because armadillos are that strong lmao
@@Yackalipsthey’re not though? I was three hit killing them with a stone sword yesterday
In vedrock edition they can stand on cacti infinitely
I really like the idea of wolf personalities, but for your idea of having them roam your base without wandering off… how do you propose they do that? When everyone’s base is a different shape and size, how do you propose the dog knows when it’s in the base or not. Furthermore, though this is probably an easier one, how do you propose a dog know if it’s inside or outside?
I really love your concept and I hope they implement it, but I’m just pointing out that a few of your suggestions have glaring holes in them
Add a Dog/Cat bed. Use a lead on your Dog/Cat, then click on the bed. That bed is now assigned to that Dog/Cat, and they have a radius they can explore around the bed.
i mean, how do villagers work? they don't leave their village, but you could say they have a job block and a bed they sleep in at night so fair enough. mojang should probably add like bowls, the treat bowls or whatever. and even so, it's not that hard to program a wolf into it's space, like mobs pathfind unique to their environment, so should wolves.
Same AI as an iron golem for wandering, but preferably with a lot less range, also should decrease range on iron golems because they wander way too far off and get lost as is.
as some smart person from different thread stated, there is a variable called "sky light". It essentially means "how much natural light reaches this block", which could be used to define indoors/shades/caves/whatever else.
@@Honzik207 that’s… brilliant
"I've tricked you, this video is really about wolf AI"
me: "YES, GOOD"
New Wolf personalities seem like an amazing idea, I have a few more ideas that mojang could add. Firstly they could add a brand new wolf "movement mode" sort of like the current "follow" and "sit" modes but instead its a "scout" mode where they roam around your base. with this they could add a dog bed where it acts as an indicator of where your base is, you can place it indoors or outdoors. if the dog bed is indoors and the wolf is more of an outdoor wolf the wolf could play sad noises on the door which indicates that the wolf wants to go outside. maybe even add a new pet door? so mobs can't go inside but pets can freely go through. What will make the "scout" feature useful though is if a mob is present, more aggressive wolves would growl and even bite mobs but run away until you actually attack the mob then they would actually acttack them. And more skittish/passive wolves would make whimpering noises and run towards you for protection. Aaaand Maybe another feature they could add is hunger to wolves. that would make players pay more attention to wolves. So for example they a player makes a wolf sit, if the wolf is hungry they would stand up and try to find you and make whimpering noises to let you know they're hungry. if they strave they die (obviously lol)
This is exactly what I was afraid of when I heard the armadillo winning.
I knew that in order for the additions to make sense they would need to either entirely rework dogs, fix creepers, or give the dogs plot armor.
And knowing Mojang they went predictably for Plot Armor, instead of fixing their game.
Literally. Instead of teleporting, increased movement speed when they start following you would solve the problem.
Higher jump and better path finding to avoid hazards as well. Hostile mobs especially creepers are literally better at path finding and avoiding hazards.
I love how we are talking about the stupidity of Minecraft dogs while my camel has been spinning inside the waterfall at my base ever since I brought it home
Most mobs in minecraft uses the same basic AI for navigation which is super easy to break, and mojang is too busy adding "content" like wolf armor to bother fixing the broken general-purpose AI that gets mobs stuck everywhere.
Wolf Armour does fixes half of the issue wolves has (They die too easily from mobs) so it allows your cosmetic dog to be a companion to your adventure
And they still deal like no damage
@@mavrikgaming970 Don't tell me wolves can't kill a single skeleton
@@mavrikgaming970they can 1v1 an iron golem...
wolves aren't supposed to be strong tho
@@mavrikgaming970 o lobo já tem uma defesa dessas com armadura e vc quer q ele dê muito dano ???? Vc quer q o lobo vire o quê,um mini warden ????
I suppose pathfinding can be fixed a bit for simple things like jumping over chasms. But complex behavior seems programmatically impossible in a game like this - how do you define "indoors"?
maybe like a certain area without natural blocks on the ground or something like that
maybe the area around the owner's bed, or instead of making them sit, you can define the block that they are standing on as a center of a circumference, which defines an area that the wolf consider as "home"
make it check the sky light possibility like foxes or check for blocks to see if it is in a confined area, there are lots of ways tbh
We kind of already have a mechanic like that in the game....prior to 1.14, villagers worked using doors. For a door to be valid it had to have sky light access on one side. The other side was considered "inside". So it is possible.
a new block called the 'food bowl' and by putting your pets name on that bowl they will not move 15 blocks away from that bowl under any circumstances
Thinking about it, here are other examples of major weaknesses with mobs that involve A.I...
• Villager-based farms in general.
• Ranged mobs ignoring entities blocking the target, even if it is an End Crystal or cross-fire mob that will retaliate.
• Being able to bait slimes(and sometimes skeletons) into hazards.
• Skeleton infighting.
• Being able to cluster mobs around a creeper, then blocking, one-shotting an entire group of mobs.
• Mobs fighting other mobs outnumbered.
• The Wither hovering above a player; this makes cheesing the Wither with End Crystals way easier.
• Nullifying mobs as hazards using boats.
• Bats.
the bats constantly flying into lava how do they even make it without natural selection killing all of them
Avoiding creepers was actually in the beta, but it was very laggy
To be fair, skeleton infighting is always fun to witness / initiate. Enemies should have flaws that the player can exploit to their advantage. Although it would make sense come to think of it that the AI should be a *bit* smarter on hard difficulty, sorta like how some enemies in Terraria gain extra abilities in Expert mode. Jellyfish can temporarily shield themselves and reflect melee attacks, zombies can wield their own arm for extra range / damage, skeletons can throw bones at the player, the Eye of Cthulhu goes into phase 2 much earlier and has a rapid dash ability that would catch classic players off guard when switching to expert for the first time, and so on.
Another one I just realized is a major path-finding weakness... Dripstones.
@@Inspirator_AG112 and also kelp
my dog tried running into the fireplace in my room as soon as i let it stand up, i now have iron bars completely covering the fireplace
This guy just wanted an excuse to kill wolves for ten minutes
Greg: i dropped the dog from 100 blocks. It survivor. Then from 200. It survived. Then i did what any nowmal person would do
Me : drop it from 300 blocks?
Greg: no. *I built a death cannon*
Me: use the new mace
@@leszekryniec7054 good idea lol
gerg needs to go on his villian arc
I think he already is on it
The armor literally allows the wolf to 1 v 1 an iron golem lol
now give it max strength potion and wolf armor see how that goes
I really like the personality range idea, and I think it'd be cool if some dog breeds were more likely to have different personalities, such as, just a random example, Forest Wolves more likely to be extroverted (happiest when outside or with other dogs), while Snowy Wolves are more likely to be introverted (happier when inside and by itself)
Summary of old Wolf Armour: Works like Clash Royale shields.
I think a new addition could be a sniffing mechanic. If you give it an item, it will immediately begin taking you to the nearest mob (within reasonable distance) that drops that item.
Seems cool
I love the slider idea for ai. Applying it to all mobs would be cool but then they have like a baseline or preference depending on the mobs or locked ones depending on mob.
Its actually a great Idea I'd love to see it added aswell
New wolf AI would be nice but if that die than is will be much sadder
Edit: thank you for 42 likes this is my most liked comment ever
I feel something that could be useful in future updates is a thing that can revive killed pets or animals. If the animal has a special name and dies, you would be able to use lapis to resummon them. Would lean more into the magic side of Minecraft. Also less heartbreak
Exactly, they really feel like something worth protecting and being with. They would really be pets. :)
@@netherwarrior6113 Reviving pets wouldn't be useful since you can just breed more anyway
@@EmperorPenguin1217 but they;re not the same pet :(
@@LineOfThy I mean if someone killed your wolf and replaced it with an identical copy, name tag, dye, color and all you wouldn't notice
Adding personality to wolf is quite a valid suggestion i hope to get added.
It doesn't matter how good they make wolf armor, it should've used the turtle scute to begin with
2:05 pov: you’re trying to increase the word count on an essay.
WELL NO SHIT THE ARMOR WONT PROTECT IT FROM DROWNING!!!!
I-
I did not know pandas had a literal "personality" mechanic. Hell I forgot they even existed. Man this is exactly what the problem with MC is, they add cool new things, but still don't update old stuff from the past that should've been fixed already.
I was expecting this to be a giant nitpick but these actually sound like problems that need to be addressed
And I will continue seething!!
S
agreed. I'd play more if pets weren't just glorified statues
7:40 thats wild 💀💀
I thought my dog would be safe with the new dog armour so I took it out caving. It ended up drowning to death...
The damage part of this video is simply a man not understanding shield/damage gating.
When this update was added, i went out at night, splashed my wolf with strength and speed, and a few minutes oater, there were no skeletons around me, and any zombie that dared to attack me would meet the same fate.
Easy solution is pet beds/respawning. They will respawn sat down ofc.
Good idea.
Maybe a collar with a totem of undying
@@dexaphobia8085 i dont personally like that because then your dogs are stronger fighters because they basically have more health. But with pet beds if they die, you cant use them until you go back to base.
@@kyleyoung2464 thats fair, it’d be fairly pricey until you get a raid farm though.
And you could argue by that point itd be the only thing that makes wolves relevant to the late game.
It would have to require some very hard to get item though because 1000 respawning wolfs will cause alot of issues
I am *never* going to recover from hearing the sentence, "It might have just been through the Minecraft equivalent of a plane crash." Hahaha
Yeah, AI issues in all animals need a big fix.
According to my brother they should just have one update where they just polish the current game
While the AI would fix most of the problems with wolves, just being allowed to enchant the armor would make a huge difference.
One thing I would like is for Wolves and dogs to be two different creatures like ocelots and cats
They aren't? How?
They're still wolves after you tame them, they never become dogs. So it's not needed.
This is actually genius, i dont think iv every seen a minecraft idea this good
Spiders are giant and attack you on sight if it's dark but are totally chill if it's light. Dogs have a mystical link to you (the same one that lets you see their death messages). Realism has never been a part of this game. Compaining about "realism" in the fantasy block game is what got the firefly removed.
I don't trust Mojang to do the wolf personalities but I hope a mod developer sees this video and is inspired, I would download that in a heart beat.
Gerg just came up with the best mod / update idea I've ever heard.
No wolves were hurt during the making of this video
You can even enchant the wolf armour with unbreaking 3 to make the durability last longer then default
This personality traits is so much cool.....mojang should add this so every mob...slowly but surely
The most important feature should be the ability to pet the dog
this feels like if magmamusen escaped from a mental hospital and was roaming the streets
I find it funny how the best pet, is also one of the worst pets.
There's only two possible pets and the cats are way worse
2💀?????@@InvalidUser_
Pets in minecraft just feel like trophies or decorations rather than a friend, a rather depressing parallel to the real world.
So, what I should get from this is that...
All sucks, life sucks?
I had no idea pandas have personalities, that's crazy. WOLFS NEEEEED this
if anyone wonders the song at 4:33 is let it happen by tame impala
Me about to make the most utterly diabolical army of wolves known to all of Minecraft:
I… really don’t see the problem with the wolf armor. I’m glad the armor breaks and the damage doesn’t carry over to the dog. It means you get a chance to jump in and save them before they can be killed once the armor breaks. It gives you a warning. And the teleporting isn’t really an issue either. Sure, it’s unrealistic, but who cares? It’s a game.
did you even watch the video?
@@SnoFitzroy I did, yes.
It's a bit interesting that a wolf can now solo an Iron Golem
The main issue is that it doesn't stop death from Lava, and you now need to carry scutes on you, deal with many annoyances like getting into cracks, or just fighting a random mob
I don't want to have any risk at all, so I just sit them at home like a normal person does
@@glauberglousger956 I personally don’t really have an issue with the lava. If I use wolves, it’s on the overworld, and lava isn’t too common on the surface.
I’m also the kind of player who loves fighting hoards of mobs, so I’m not bothered by the dogs going after them.
At the end of the day, I guess it comes down to a difference in preference and play style.
@@SleepySeal121minecraft aint nun play style its all big number axe go brrr
Instead of looking at a single feature and going "Yep, we're adding that!" They should make updates centered around updating entire systems, mobs etc. Imagine if we also got reworked Pet AI (Nothing too extravagant, literally just more wolf-like behaviour, tweaked stats and the ability to not stand still on Magma/Cactus blocks)
Who would pay for thT
The “use in case of IRS” sign got me rolling
An idea I had had a while ago was for the player to craft a "whistle" of some kind that, when used, teleports all standing pets to them. This would allow the animals to wander freely and, when the player loses track of them or needs them for combat, they can summon them.
0:22 WHY DOES BRO HAVE SHOTGUN ROUNDS? 💀💀💀
In case of IRS
(It's literally the sign⭐️)
Local youtuber is mad that wolves are now actually useful
1:55 Actually, Minecraft player max health is 20, meaning you would have 19.998 health ☝️🤓
Man, I want Mojang to see this so much
That's how I always feel when I watch these videos. If I could only force Mojang folks to sit in a room and watch these, because they're just so true
Buckshot roulette refrence
I never knew that pandas had personalities but now that I know I need this for other animals, i want my frog buff.
it's not like frogs are useful for anything else, so yeah, make them pets!
Something tells me he wasn’t a good Wolf owner in Minecraft. Should have been more like Pewdiepie.
Nah this fixes my issue with wolfs dying as fast
Worse yet, mods that use wolf AI for custom mobs are garbage. So much garbage. So much garbage and theyre proud of their creation based on a core of poop.
An ARMORED CORE
I completly agree with you. Wolves definitly NEED better AI!
...Now I want to download ftl again
You know what they should’ve added to tamed wolfs? They should’ve added 3 click function on them. Example:
Clicked to sit- after a while of just sitting, they lay or do other laying positions, or just sleep.
Clicked to follow-Not much different, but at least fix their ai following/direction command.
Clicked to roam- A third feature I think would be cool. Like an iron golem mostly roaming around, but still within a village. It would make the dog more dog like to roam around.
Mojang: doesn’t add fireflies because they are realistic
Wolf armor:
wolf armor was a thing, most clasic exemple is spiked collars but even plated dog armor was a thing
dude why does everyone think 2 random pixels not existing is so bad ITS 2 PIXELS
@@dalias12Would have added atmosphere to a biome people wanted. Imagine setting some loose in a flower field near your base, especially with optifine's dynamic lighting it would be incredible.
fireflies will live in swamps if they were added@@Jenna_Talia
why do everyone talks about fireflies? its just an annoying mob that will only cause more lag
When I have more affection for Stampy's dogs than anyone I find ingame, that's a problem.
I don't really mind the AI, I think it's ok to have a pet that's just there for decoration. To me, they don't need to be useful, they just need to be fun. And I think they're fun.
They are also useful and a fun companion for your adventures and combat.
"SOLDIERS AND CHILDREN, PREPARE YOURSELFS FOR THE CAVES WE GOIN DIAMOND MININ"
So in summary, the wolf has a shield from clash royale, got it
wolf armer? i hardly know her!
explain this please
@@daftish_birdman wolf armer? i hardly know her!
@@soypagain WHAT DOES THAT MEAN
@@soypagain Oh ok i just relized 2 seconds after writing the other one- you want me to wolf some woman named armer. i get it now
the thing is they not only buffed the armor but also the wolf HP itself, making it seem crazily op while in reality it most likely wouldnt be so bad if they stuck to the old hp
I hate these types of content creators, alluding to a genuine “problem” via clickbaity title and or thumbnail, only to just make jokes or complain about an entirely different grievance that is only tangentially related at best.
Wolf armor at first didn’t live up to what we wanted, but now it HAS been fixed. You’re just nit picking that fact for engagement now.
The issue is that wolf armor doesn't fix anything, because wolf AI still sucks ass and will still get them killed by the same lava and water situations that always kill them. There's also still no reason to even bother getting a wolf.
Explain the clickbait
This is actually just a great video with a perfect idea!
Subscribed.
It's crazy to think how Much the Minecraft Community "People" wanted Wolf Armor SO BADLY, and Yet once people Actually got it, Everyone is Suddenly against it for Literally every reason in Existance. Crazy.
having wolfs walk around your base would be so cool
Mojang: *adds wolf armor
Fans: nah that's too weak
Also mojang: *buffs up the armor
Fans: nah that's too unrealisticly strong
Honestly i feel bad for mojang
More like
Mojang: *Adds wolf Armor
Real Fans: Thats not the problem here, that isnt what we wa---
Mojang: *Buffs the wolf arnor AND the Dog
Real Fans: *Sigh
Because most of the fans that is saying those doesnt really recognize the problem here especially that most of them are just child who prolly doesnt even know what AI is.
And the problem is that those fans are the ones Mojang keeps listening to when it should not be.
Having wolves have slight variations in size, leg length, ears or snout lengths would also be a great change that probably wouldn’t be too hard. Implementing a breeding system similar to horses could allow players to get diverse dogs, and not just base wolves, similar to in real life.
So update the scar and temperaturements post by petrified bloom
You are right
I never got pets in Minecraft and the wolf armour never changed that. The only opportunity I got to get a pet that I actually wanted was in the most recent mob vote…
Hi
for higher damage to wolf i think wolf armor is kinda like a totem for wolf
so even if something did 1 billlion damage to wolf it'd still survive