The New Flesh/Pinion 0:00 Somewhat Damaged 1:05 The Day The World Went Away 5:36 The Frail 12:05 The Wretched 13:50 We’re In This Together 19:23 The Fragile 25:38 Just Like You Imagined (Unparalleled Live Mix) 30:30 Even Deeper 35:17 Pilgrimage* 41:35 No, You Don’t 43:11 La Mer (Unparalleled Live Mix) 46:31 The Great Below 51:11 The Way Out Is Through 56:13 Into the Void 59:56 Metal* 1:04:26 The Mark Has Been Made 1:10:54 Please 1:14:40 Starfuckers, Inc.* 1:18:05 Complication 1:23:50 The Big Come Down 1:25:53 Trent Talks 1* 1:29:54 The Fragile (Version)* 1:31:51 And All That Could Have Been* 1:36:24 The Perfect Drug 1:42:21* Trent Talks 2* 1:48:06 Subterraneans* 1:50:37 *1 Pilgrimage was not performed, but rather played over the PA as an intro in 2007 on multiple dates. I went ahead and included the audio for album flow *2 Metal was subbed in for Where Is Everybody? because WIE has never been played, but Metal was Fragile-Era *3 Starfuckers, Inc. was a weird one, I’ll admit. I couldn’t rip the video from my AATCHB DVD because my disc 2 was too scratched up (in any case, I wanted to break away from using so much “official” Fragile-Era footage). So I used Big Day Out 2000 and Corona Capital 2018 footage instead. It’s a little shaky in places but it’s functional *4 Audio captured from a 2018 IEM feed. I wasn’t able to find footage of that speech so I used placeholder intro footage. Not ideal, but again functional *5 This is my favorite version of The Fragile. Performed at Bridge School Benefit 2006/07 I think. I couldn’t leave it out of this. Sadly the footage is pretty boring, but I kept it anyway *6 Subbed this song in because it was Fragile-era and The New Flesh hasn’t ever been properly performed *7 See above but for Underneath It All *8 again with the not having actual footage of this speech *9 This isn’t *technically* fragile era. Closer to TDS (kinda between the two, though the performance is from 2018) but it fit the vibe perfectly and is a great closer! Recording Info Pinion/The New Flesh Video: AATCHB Audio: I Can Still Feel You & AATCHB Somewhat Damaged Video: Mad Cool Festival 2018, Roskilde Festival, Denmark 7.03.09 Audio: I Can Still Feel You The Day The World Went Away Video: May 09, 2000, New York, NY & Mad Cool Festival 2018 Audio: AATCHB The Frail Video: AATCHB Audio: I Can Still Feel You The Wretched Video: AATCHB Audio: I Can Still Feel You We’re In This Together Audio & Video: April 04, 2007, Frankfurt, Germany th-cam.com/video/mKyxnbjC8KU/w-d-xo.html The Fragile Audio & Video: Adelaide 2.28.09 Just Like You Imagined (Unparallelled Live Mix) Video: LA 9.08.09 Audio: LA 9.08.09 & AATCHB Even Deeper Video & Audio: LA 2013 Pilgrimage Video: Mad Cool Fest 2018, Panorama 2017 Audio: Various 2007 recordings No, You Don’t Video: Sidney Big Day Out 2000 Audio: I Can Still Feel You La Mer (Unparallelled Live Mix) Video: AATCHB Audio: AATCHB & December 15, 2018 & November 24, 2018 The Great Below Video & Audio: AATCHB The Way Out Is Through Video: Japan Fuji Rock Festival 2013 & Audio: & Japan Fuji Rock Festival 2013 Into The Void Video: 10/15/13 & October 11, 2013 Audio: November 28, 1999 & June 11, 2006 th-cam.com/video/TtLHcgDJvzA/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/pYBHoWna8QQ/w-d-xo.html Metal Video: Atlanta 05/10/09, June 12th, 2009, June 9 2009 th-cam.com/video/Xs_DtvF1qaU/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/HMeUOkzXYOI/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/9UCe7Rth0CY/w-d-xo.html The Mark Has Been Made Video & Audio: AATCHB Please Video: 2006-04-30 Audio: 2006-3-13 Starfuckers, Inc. Video: Sydney Big Day Out 2000 & Corona Capital 2018 Audio: I Can Still Feel You, AATCHB Complication Video & Audio: AATCHB The Big Come Down Video: November 08, 2013, Los Angeles, CA, Staples Center & December 07, 2008, Portland, OR, Rose Garden Arena Audio: November 08, 2013, Los Angeles, CA, Staples Center & December 07, 2008, Portland, OR, Rose Garden Aren The Fragile (Version) Video & Audio: October 21, 2006, San Francisco, CA, Shoreline Amphitheater, Bridge School Benefit th-cam.com/video/yGU0lH1NgOw/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/nMe8ObL6Ay8/w-d-xo.html And All That Could Have Been Video & Audio: November 25, 2018 th-cam.com/video/wg2v5vjz_H8/w-d-xo.html The Perfect Drug Video & Audio: November 25, 2018 th-cam.com/video/wg2v5vjz_H8/w-d-xo.html Subterraneans Video & Audio: November 25, 2018 th-cam.com/video/wg2v5vjz_H8/w-d-xo.html
@@Danny-wv8ec right. Did you ever fin the Easter eggs in the dvd? I can’t remember exactly when but you can hit a certain track # at a exact time and get like 3 or 4 more bonus songs. Starfuckers with MM.
@@samgib3623 yup I think I had the printed out. I live in Beirut so I had no way of seeing NIN live, I bought the Closure VHS back in 2000 when I was on vacation in Paris with my parents which was the extent of my NIN live experience back then.
'somewhat damaged' still hits me straight in the sternum every time, even 20 years later. anyway, i remember alot of NIN fans at the time didnt like Fragile a whole lot. as for me, i kept both discs on replay for 3 weeks straight when i first got them. this era saw NIN elevated to a whole new level, imo.
how could I ever think it's funny how everything you swore would never change is different now. All these years later I still scream along to that whole section. What a fucking song. What a fucking album.
I've only been a NIN fan for a short time; but it's amazing to see how creative their fan base are how much the band supports their home-made NIN projects! I've never encountered such high-quality fan-editing projects before AND THERE ARE SO MANY OF THEM. Whoever made this: phenomonal work you did so well. Thank you!
'The Day the World Went Away' and 'Hurt' are 2 of my favs. Probably 'I Want to F U like an Animal' would be the 3rd. ♥ Although really, we can NEVER go wrong with any NIN song. ♥
The gig at the Gorge WA on the tour for, "The Fragile," is one of the best shows and concert highlights of my life. The album is a masterpiece as far as I am concerned. Fantastic music and great memories I have from way back then. It was my 4th NIN show. My 1st was at a club in Portland Oregon that has a capacity of maybe a 1000 people. It was a month after TDWS was released. I was still in highschool and my best friend and I made the 3 hour trip to Portland. We each told our parents we were staying at the others house that night. 😂 It was school night. We drove home after and got home at 4am. Made it to school on time. Anyway the progression Trent and NIN did from small clubs to arenas then on to large amphitheaters was amazing. Each album different from the previous and the intensity was always phenomenal It was just a great time and era to be a part of. I grew up during this time and I am grateful for the times and memories. 🤘
Trent live gives me chills. The raw emotions and roller coasters he goes through with every word and beat is enough to in-trance even the strongest non-believer.
The transition between The Frail and The Wretched always manages to strike a chord in me no matter what recording I'm listening to. Thank you for the hard work in making this :)
Since Pretty HATE machine.....Been an admiring fan of Trent Reznor ...one of a kind he is. May God bless him and those he loves. Great musician and artist.
That’s my favorite part too, well both times they say it!! And Trent’s screaming and palpable energy/anger as he says it the second time!! I always rewatch that!! ❤
As much as I love the current live version of somewhat damaged, I wish Trent would play the original studio version again live cause that build up in the original is something else
Any NIN fan who doesn't like the Fragile isn't a real NIN fan. This is like Trent's version of the Wall its an epic journey getting to experience the many moods of Trent Reznor through music. This and With Teeth are my 2 favs then its a tie between Spiral, Broken and P.H.M. I like the new shit but would really like to see a emotion driven explosive album like the earlier days but you got to let an artist be who they are. Seen NIN live 4 or 5 times and Trent never fails to bring it all, the stage the sound and the revised versions of old mater to fit with the new, its always n amazing show.
*5 This is my favorite version of The Fragile. Performed at Bridge School Benefit 2006/07 I think. I couldn’t leave it out of this. Sadly the footage is pretty boring, but I kept it anyway **** To he who made this video edit..... my mother has been in the hospital for a week and she could be there for another two weeks, leaving her absent from our lives this Thanksgiving. Two days ago I had a suicidal active shooter with an assault rifle walk my street.... My house was a part of the street barricaded in with SWAT & a platoon of army soldiers to keep him from getting out. It wasn't a fun night. I have cried for the last three days over my mother being in the hospital. The suicidal active shooter set off my PTSD from the Army bad. This video, especially, "The Great Below". The Bridge School Benefit version of The Fragile has been my strength to get through these past few weeks. I love this video. I love the song "And All That Could Have Been." -its been giving me peace and solace. JPH
This live version of The Day the Whole World Went Away is one of my favorites. This compilation of NIN live is great, its one of my most played setlists. Thanks for putting this together.
@Pirate Stahlion thank you so much for the time and effort that you've put into editing this together, and uploading! Bloody amazing! Nine Inch Nails for life! Also a huge fucking hello, and much love to all you other people that are here for this! For me music is the most unifying thing in the world. In a time where we seem to becoming more and more divided, it's damn nice to see people from different walks of life unifying, appreciating, just sending positive vibes and shit, purely because of one thing! Love you all! Peace, and respect.
I would never have expected this Just Like You Imagined mix to be any good, for some reason, but wow is it amazing, possibly my favorite version now, massive thanks for this upload
Thank you for this I've been a nine inch nails fan since I was five years old all my schoolmates made fun of me because I liked "weird" music but now that I'm older I realize I was just ahead of my time! I'm a musician now thanks to trent the fragile downward spiral and with teeth have gotten me through alot of crazy shit! Thanks for you hardwork and thank you trent for your talent ✊🏼
Without a doubt the best two hours I’ve spent in absolutely ages, a hell of a lot of hard work obviously went into this so a massive thanks for sharing! 👍♥️🎵
Great tour! My friends and I had a f'n blast! APC opened. First time seeing MJK sing. I missed Downward in '94. This tour felt like Reznor just continued the Downward tour. Marilyn Manson was there and sang The Beautiful People and Starf#@$×÷s Inc. My god was it EPIC.
first time i travelled away from home on an airplane by myself it was me, and this CD. i was waiting alone in the airport for about 12 hours. so i had a few reasons to keep listening to it over and over. i was like 15. come to think of it what the fuck were my parents thinking letting me do that??? glad i had my discman and this album! freakin' great.
I think this version of The Great Below may be my personal all time favorite. I’m currently watching this trying to help stave off some of the sadness from not being able to see them in Louisville this past weekend. La Mar live makes me cry every time and may be my all time favorite live, Also The Big Come Down and Somewhat Damaged are two songs that are on my top list of ones I’ve seen live. I’d absolutely die to hear And all that could have been. I’m done rambling. Lol
Oh yes! My autumn, winter , spring of 1998/1999. Long time ago. But this is like wine, it seems? But with this I can touch my past and industrial soul, once more, again. Great THANKS
You used some of my footage for "Into The Void" and I love it! Thank you so much. Been really into "The Fragile" lately so this was a pleasant surprise. Amazing compilation!
Man this is a legendary upload this is one of my favorite live performance by Nine Inch Nails, currently, and even if anything tops this this is definitely the best performance of The Fragile. They really blew it out of the park with Somewhat Damaged, and The Day The World Went Away, good lord they sound eargasmic in this show, and better then the studio album versions.
This was incredible! I’ve been a huge fan of there work for 30 years. I was at the Auburn Hills MI show of this tour, this brought me right back. Still sounds fuckin great!
Thank you so much for telling us so much of Trend Razor. I always liked his things, but I did not know much about him very, now I have a very different view and thank him for his great things, and look forward for more surprises. he made great music
This is a great video you put together! Lots of cool versions of these songs. And including Trent's speech with the next 3 deep cuts really added to the flow.
First time watching this January 10th 2021, I just happened to be here... Corona Capitol "This is something for our friend David Bowie" Rest in Peace Jan 8, 1947 - Jan 10, 2016
Brilliantly put together compilation of live album footage here across the different incarnations of the band.....but anybody else find it really curious to see female backing vocalists there on stage with NIN?
I saw that tour and thought they detracted from NIN honestly. I didn't like it much. It didn't sound good. I was happy they brought Explosions In the Sky along though.
129:54 that was hollywood last year, last show of the tour. i remember the words "we'll be back... we will be back". that was said to be some kind of farewell tour, so that was comforting.
Wow that 2013 Fuji Rock performance of The Way Out Is Through is one of the best live recordings I've ever hear. Must be from the console. Definitely gonna check that show out. Thanks.
6:00 14, September, 2016. The day my whole world went away. My only child died at 19 years 2 days old from an enlarged heart. Trent was his perfect drug before he was even born. I played N.I.N for him through headphones when I was pregnant. He's been gone 8 years today. I'll never be okay again. I miss you D.W.E. You will always be my world.
Speaking as a big NIN fan, they're not. Not even close but yeah more people should check them out though they aren't anywhere NEAR being the most underrated.
Thank you so very much Trent & Nine Inch Nails-I missed out for over 25 years but am a new fan-listening since August 2021-I love the live shows best & I love his amazing talent-I am still constantly getting pleasantly surprised around 2 months later- that something new to me comes on such as this compilation I have playing while mult-tasking & I am already starting to sing along some verses-On my 1st listen Or I am getting getting tears in eyes during some parts-Or just Loving the music as it's here to be enjoyed- I'm constantly listening to songs in my mind-the ones I first loved In August & still love & those I know all the words to already & singing out in public with or without headphones as I relate so deeply to so much of what he says- Whether it's the same reason he wrote the song or not-But I find out often through watching interviews that my thoughts & emotions were spot on for what he was singing about when he wrote the song at the time & whether it's 1990s or more recent I still feel so much emotion from him in the live shows- Sometimes I cry or laugh & smile but more than anything it has been helping me cope with the suffering-sadness-injustice-problems & things going on in life & sometimes it has been the ONLY THING to ease my mind & help me sleep-As I have insomnia & a list of problems & family issues-health problems-prodigal son-So much more-If I heard & knew this music back during that Woodstock 2 concert I'm sure I'd have enjoyed it but unsure I was old enough to get in if you had to be 21-I did want to go & planned to go but I let other stupid reasons prevent that too Yet anyway the songs wouldn't have affected me the way they do now-A few-Yes- His thoughts & opinions on so much I agree with & what's right but other things; Yes I had dealt with within my family as I had to go to live in foster homes but not so much personally but I'd rather not say more than that on that issue Thank you Trent & Nine Inch Nails-You will Always be relevant & I admit it was from watching thd end of that Black Mirror episode-'Head Like A Hole at the end that brought me to TH-cam back then-it sounded familiar-I was never a fan of hers either but she rocked it too in a punk rock style-if she sang like that & songs like that I'd be into her too- That's another story I'm sure Nine Inch Nails is happy to keep getting new fans from all generations & gave permission to use song I think at least as otherwise WHO KNOWS when I'd discover them as I only started listening to Marilyn Mansons 90smusic in August 2012-Possibly exactly 9 years before this & how ironic when I found out Trent produced an album & sort of discovered him. Back then I believe & he wouldn't have gained that fame if not for Trent-No wonder I immediately related to Trent & I relate to him & all his music much more than aforementioned Artist who has many songs I love & would've loved to see a 90s concert or even now but the 90s concerts were what I would've liked to see much more whereas with Trent I am seeing him in different decades of live shows & I'd LOVE to be at any of them- PLEASE come back to New York As Nine Inch Nails so I can see you Live- Thank you for making this compilation to the person who put it together
I too am a new fan. Of course I liked Closer, March otp, and HLAH. But as far as listening to whole albums, not until 18mos ago. I agree, the live shit is so much better than the albums. So, these "live" albums are great for that. To the uploader, please continue the great work.
Wish I could find the video of nin in Denver in 2000 fragility tour. Best concert I've ever seen, second was when he was in rapid city sd. From 12 years old to current 42, NIN will always be my absolute favorite artist! It's unfortunate new generations will be lost to the change Trent Reznor provided.
I will count myself as one of the lucky few to see A Perfect Circle Mer De Noms tour open for NIN The Fragile. Get goose bumps to this day when i listen to either album! Maynard opening for Trent. Only thing that came close was Fantomos opening for Tool during the Laturalus tour. Mike Patton and MJK in the same show holy shit!
![Faith No More - Download Festival (2009) [Full Show]](/img/n.gif)
The New Flesh/Pinion 0:00
Somewhat Damaged 1:05
The Day The World Went Away 5:36
The Frail 12:05
The Wretched 13:50
We’re In This Together 19:23
The Fragile 25:38
Just Like You Imagined (Unparalleled Live Mix) 30:30
Even Deeper 35:17
Pilgrimage* 41:35
No, You Don’t 43:11
La Mer (Unparalleled Live Mix) 46:31
The Great Below 51:11
The Way Out Is Through 56:13
Into the Void 59:56
Metal* 1:04:26
The Mark Has Been Made 1:10:54
Please 1:14:40
Starfuckers, Inc.* 1:18:05
Complication 1:23:50
The Big Come Down 1:25:53
Trent Talks 1* 1:29:54
The Fragile (Version)* 1:31:51
And All That Could Have Been* 1:36:24
The Perfect Drug 1:42:21*
Trent Talks 2* 1:48:06
Subterraneans* 1:50:37
*1 Pilgrimage was not performed, but rather played over the PA as an intro in 2007 on multiple dates. I went ahead and included the audio for album flow
*2 Metal was subbed in for Where Is Everybody? because WIE has never been played, but Metal was Fragile-Era
*3 Starfuckers, Inc. was a weird one, I’ll admit. I couldn’t rip the video from my AATCHB DVD because my disc 2 was too scratched up (in any case, I wanted to break away from using so much “official” Fragile-Era footage). So I used Big Day Out 2000 and Corona Capital 2018 footage instead. It’s a little shaky in places but it’s functional
*4 Audio captured from a 2018 IEM feed. I wasn’t able to find footage of that speech so I used placeholder intro footage. Not ideal, but again functional
*5 This is my favorite version of The Fragile. Performed at Bridge School Benefit 2006/07 I think. I couldn’t leave it out of this. Sadly the footage is pretty boring, but I kept it anyway
*6 Subbed this song in because it was Fragile-era and The New Flesh hasn’t ever been properly performed
*7 See above but for Underneath It All
*8 again with the not having actual footage of this speech
*9 This isn’t *technically* fragile era. Closer to TDS (kinda between the two, though the performance is from 2018) but it fit the vibe perfectly and is a great closer!
Recording Info
Pinion/The New Flesh
Video: AATCHB
Audio: I Can Still Feel You & AATCHB
Somewhat Damaged
Video: Mad Cool Festival 2018, Roskilde Festival, Denmark 7.03.09
Audio: I Can Still Feel You
The Day The World Went Away
Video: May 09, 2000, New York, NY & Mad Cool Festival 2018
Audio: AATCHB
The Frail
Video: AATCHB
Audio: I Can Still Feel You
The Wretched
Video: AATCHB
Audio: I Can Still Feel You
We’re In This Together
Audio & Video: April 04, 2007, Frankfurt, Germany
th-cam.com/video/mKyxnbjC8KU/w-d-xo.html
The Fragile
Audio & Video: Adelaide 2.28.09
Just Like You Imagined (Unparallelled Live Mix)
Video: LA 9.08.09
Audio: LA 9.08.09 & AATCHB
Even Deeper
Video & Audio: LA 2013
Pilgrimage
Video: Mad Cool Fest 2018, Panorama 2017
Audio: Various 2007 recordings
No, You Don’t
Video: Sidney Big Day Out 2000
Audio: I Can Still Feel You
La Mer (Unparallelled Live Mix)
Video: AATCHB
Audio: AATCHB & December 15, 2018 & November 24, 2018
The Great Below
Video & Audio: AATCHB
The Way Out Is Through
Video: Japan Fuji Rock Festival 2013 &
Audio: & Japan Fuji Rock Festival 2013
Into The Void
Video: 10/15/13 & October 11, 2013
Audio: November 28, 1999 & June 11, 2006
th-cam.com/video/TtLHcgDJvzA/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/pYBHoWna8QQ/w-d-xo.html
Metal
Video: Atlanta 05/10/09, June 12th, 2009, June 9 2009
th-cam.com/video/Xs_DtvF1qaU/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/HMeUOkzXYOI/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/9UCe7Rth0CY/w-d-xo.html
The Mark Has Been Made
Video & Audio: AATCHB
Please
Video: 2006-04-30
Audio: 2006-3-13
Starfuckers, Inc.
Video: Sydney Big Day Out 2000 & Corona Capital 2018
Audio: I Can Still Feel You, AATCHB
Complication
Video & Audio: AATCHB
The Big Come Down
Video: November 08, 2013, Los Angeles, CA, Staples Center & December 07, 2008, Portland, OR, Rose Garden Arena
Audio: November 08, 2013, Los Angeles, CA, Staples Center & December 07, 2008, Portland, OR, Rose Garden Aren
The Fragile (Version)
Video & Audio: October 21, 2006, San Francisco, CA, Shoreline Amphitheater, Bridge School Benefit
th-cam.com/video/yGU0lH1NgOw/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/nMe8ObL6Ay8/w-d-xo.html
And All That Could Have Been
Video & Audio: November 25, 2018
th-cam.com/video/wg2v5vjz_H8/w-d-xo.html
The Perfect Drug
Video & Audio: November 25, 2018
th-cam.com/video/wg2v5vjz_H8/w-d-xo.html
Subterraneans
Video & Audio: November 25, 2018
th-cam.com/video/wg2v5vjz_H8/w-d-xo.html
Thank you so much for this
I feel you mate, my AATCHB dvd is scratched too.
@@Danny-wv8ec right. Did you ever fin the Easter eggs in the dvd? I can’t remember exactly when but you can hit a certain track # at a exact time and get like 3 or 4 more bonus songs. Starfuckers with MM.
@@samgib3623 yup I think I had the printed out. I live in Beirut so I had no way of seeing NIN live, I bought the Closure VHS back in 2000 when I was on vacation in Paris with my parents which was the extent of my NIN live experience back then.
Thank's dude I'm friend's w Brian and Jessika fodera , so I've met him, very reserved quite guy... very cool though.......;€
This is what NIN fans can accomplish with no push back from trent or the record label - only amazing love from trent to NIN fans.
The live version of "The Day the World Went Away" is so fucking good.
That e-bow
'somewhat damaged' still hits me straight in the sternum every time, even 20 years later.
anyway, i remember alot of NIN fans at the time didnt like Fragile a whole lot. as for me, i kept both discs on replay for 3 weeks straight when i first got them. this era saw NIN elevated to a whole new level, imo.
how could I
ever think
it's funny how everything you swore would never change
is different now.
All these years later I still scream along to that whole section. What a fucking song. What a fucking album.
Talking to myself all the way to the station
@@pavelvi6969 all lined up
all the ones that aren't allowed to stay
Can’t understand why it was not received well it’s a great album.
Powerful and poignant!!
The Fragile is a fucking masterpiece.
NIN always have the best drummers playing for them. Jerome Dillon, Chris Vrenna, Josh Freese and Ilan Rubin are all beasts.
Who played here friend?❤
@@MrIgorek13jerome dillon
I've only been a NIN fan for a short time; but it's amazing to see how creative their fan base are how much the band supports their home-made NIN projects! I've never encountered such high-quality fan-editing projects before AND THERE ARE SO MANY OF THEM. Whoever made this: phenomonal work you did so well. Thank you!
This is the difference between NIN fans and other fan bases! Haha
Good work! 👍🏻
NIN fans are not like other fans...our guy is AWESOME
Idk why, but La Mer is in like my top 3 favorite NiN songs personally.
It's the best x)
Same!! Just like you imagined is one of my faves also
It's beautiful. I've cried to it many times.
Its hard for him to play it live cause it takes him to dark places, one of the deepest songs in the album for him, and for most of us...
'The Day the World Went Away' and 'Hurt' are 2 of my favs. Probably 'I Want to F U like an Animal' would be the 3rd. ♥
Although really, we can NEVER go wrong with any NIN song. ♥
The gig at the Gorge WA on the tour for, "The Fragile," is one of the best shows and concert highlights of my life. The album is a masterpiece as far as I am concerned. Fantastic music and great memories I have from way back then. It was my 4th NIN show. My 1st was at a club in Portland Oregon that has a capacity of maybe a 1000 people. It was a month after TDWS was released. I was still in highschool and my best friend and I made the 3 hour trip to Portland. We each told our parents we were staying at the others house that night. 😂 It was school night. We drove home after and got home at 4am. Made it to school on time. Anyway the progression Trent and NIN did from small clubs to arenas then on to large amphitheaters was amazing. Each album different from the previous and the intensity was always phenomenal It was just a great time and era to be a part of. I grew up during this time and I am grateful for the times and memories. 🤘
One of the hardest industrial bands.. Fuck the haters.
Trent live gives me chills. The raw emotions and roller coasters he goes through with every word and beat is enough to in-trance even the strongest non-believer.
I work 5 to 8 that's it
The transition between The Frail and The Wretched always manages to strike a chord in me no matter what recording I'm listening to. Thank you for the hard work in making this :)
They’ve always kinda seemed like a two part song to me kinda like Tool’s parabol and parabola
@@rawchickensandwich maybe even three part if you consider the fragile (song) as part of it. The solo is basically the same notes as in The Frail
Fist time I saw NIN live was June 7th 2000 at the Cow Palace in San Francisco. I was 15 years old. Still one of the best nights of my life.
Since Pretty HATE machine.....Been an admiring fan of Trent Reznor ...one of a kind he is. May God bless him and those he loves. Great musician and artist.
16:15 This part of The Wretched is such a visceral drop. IT DIDN'T TURN OUT QUITE THE WAY THAT YOU WANTED IT. Perfect vocals by Trent and Robin.
You can just feel the energy!
That’s my favorite part too, well both times they say it!! And Trent’s screaming and palpable energy/anger as he says it the second time!! I always rewatch that!! ❤
@@CJod7qhth-cam.com/video/02tL7YymAmc/w-d-xo.html
Thanks for including AATCHB and Perfect Drug. I'm happy those songs may finally start getting some live time. Only took 20 years
Your uploads have better sound than most compilation fan recordings
Saw A Perfect Circle open up for NIN during the Fragile Tour. Greatest show i've ever seen....
Wow lucky
I was there too in Dallas. It was the first concert I saw people crying with emotion and joy. Actually, the last as well.
As much as I love the current live version of somewhat damaged, I wish Trent would play the original studio version again live cause that build up in the original is something else
If I ever see them perform The Perfect Drug, I could just die.
The great below 🖤
The strings in And All That Could Have Been is a welcome addition ♥️
The Great Below might just be their most underrated song and it sounds immaculate here live
Any NIN fan who doesn't like the Fragile isn't a real NIN fan. This is like Trent's version of the Wall its an epic journey getting to experience the many moods of Trent Reznor through music. This and With Teeth are my 2 favs then its a tie between Spiral, Broken and P.H.M. I like the new shit but would really like to see a emotion driven explosive album like the earlier days but you got to let an artist be who they are. Seen NIN live 4 or 5 times and Trent never fails to bring it all, the stage the sound and the revised versions of old mater to fit with the new, its always n amazing show.
The only tour I’ve had the blessing to experience in the flesh
*5 This is my favorite version of The Fragile. Performed at Bridge School Benefit 2006/07 I think. I couldn’t leave it out of this. Sadly the footage is pretty boring, but I kept it anyway
**** To he who made this video edit..... my mother has been in the hospital for a week and she could be there for another two weeks, leaving her absent from our lives this Thanksgiving. Two days ago I had a suicidal active shooter with an assault rifle walk my street.... My house was a part of the street barricaded in with SWAT & a platoon of army soldiers to keep him from getting out. It wasn't a fun night. I have cried for the last three days over my mother being in the hospital. The suicidal active shooter set off my PTSD from the Army bad. This video, especially, "The Great Below". The Bridge School Benefit version of The Fragile has been my strength to get through these past few weeks. I love this video. I love the song "And All That Could Have Been." -its been giving me peace and solace. JPH
Please will never not be badass
This live version of The Day the Whole World Went Away is one of my favorites. This compilation of NIN live is great, its one of my most played setlists. Thanks for putting this together.
@Pirate Stahlion thank you so much for the time and effort that you've put into editing this together, and uploading! Bloody amazing!
Nine Inch Nails for life!
Also a huge fucking hello, and much love to all you other people that are here for this!
For me music is the most unifying thing in the world. In a time where we seem to becoming more and more divided, it's damn nice to see people from different walks of life unifying, appreciating, just sending positive vibes and shit, purely because of one thing!
Love you all! Peace, and respect.
I would never have expected this Just Like You Imagined mix to be any good, for some reason, but wow is it amazing, possibly my favorite version now, massive thanks for this upload
Same
Thank you for this I've been a nine inch nails fan since I was five years old all my schoolmates made fun of me because I liked "weird" music but now that I'm older I realize I was just ahead of my time! I'm a musician now thanks to trent the fragile downward spiral and with teeth have gotten me through alot of crazy shit! Thanks for you hardwork and thank you trent for your talent ✊🏼
Without a doubt the best two hours I’ve spent in absolutely ages, a hell of a lot of hard work obviously went into this so a massive thanks for sharing! 👍♥️🎵
Great tour! My friends and I had a f'n blast! APC opened. First time seeing MJK sing. I missed Downward in '94. This tour felt like Reznor just continued the Downward tour. Marilyn Manson was there and sang The Beautiful People and Starf#@$×÷s Inc. My god was it EPIC.
I hadn't heard this version of the fragile and holy shit youre so right this is my favorite one
Incredible Compilation. Thanks so much for putting this together and for citing/referencing all the clips. So much work. Wish I could buy you a beer.
Ridiculously awesome
This version of Even Deeper is beyond words,
thanks for sharing!
first time i travelled away from home on an airplane by myself it was me, and this CD. i was waiting alone in the airport for about 12 hours. so i had a few reasons to keep listening to it over and over. i was like 15. come to think of it what the fuck were my parents thinking letting me do that??? glad i had my discman and this album! freakin' great.
Discman lol
AMAZING! Never get tired of NIN! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👍
Best part of this: The Perfect Drug 1:42:21
I think this version of The Great Below may be my personal all time favorite. I’m currently watching this trying to help stave off some of the sadness from not being able to see them in Louisville this past weekend.
La Mar live makes me cry every time and may be my all time favorite live, Also The Big Come Down and Somewhat Damaged are two songs that are on my top list of ones I’ve seen live. I’d absolutely die to hear And all that could have been. I’m done rambling. Lol
Love it!
Obsessed with the live version of Even Deeper here with the choir doing backup vocals. It sounds so good!!!!
instant sub
anyone who loves NIN and Trent
Thank you so very much for this.
Oh yes! My autumn, winter , spring of 1998/1999. Long time ago. But this is like wine, it seems? But with this I can touch my past and industrial soul, once more, again. Great THANKS
Amazing! Mike Garson was my favorite part. Dude killed it.
He's also featured on La Mer, though his parts are a little faded in the background. You can hear it if you use good headphones
You used some of my footage for "Into The Void" and I love it! Thank you so much. Been really into "The Fragile" lately so this was a pleasant surprise. Amazing compilation!
Man this is a legendary upload this is one of my favorite live performance by Nine Inch Nails, currently, and even if anything tops this this is definitely the best performance of The Fragile. They really blew it out of the park with Somewhat Damaged, and The Day The World Went Away, good lord they sound eargasmic in this show, and better then the studio album versions.
I wish Trent adds 10 Miles High to the setlist only once.
Same here
it is so good!!!!
That version of even deeper...so smooth, cool take.
Oh baybee
That moment in The Wretched @16:20 did me in
Cheers for making my Saturday night, some great finds here. Always love seeing Metal played.
NIN is far from metal man.
@@Hadouken5150 they played the song Metal in the setlist
This was incredible! I’ve been a huge fan of there work for 30 years. I was at the Auburn Hills MI show of this tour, this brought me right back. Still sounds fuckin great!
This was fucking phenomenal. Thanks for the effort in putting it all together.
whoaaaaaaaa whoever did this! please keep uploading there dvds
Great live version of The Wretched.
Thank you so much for telling us so much of Trend Razor. I always liked his things, but I did not know much about him very, now I have a very different view and thank him for his great things, and look forward for more surprises. he made great music
He’s handsome in all the ways… love … mom and I…
personal fave album xoxo thank you
Thank you for this! Excellent quality and great detail.
cheers
This is a great video you put together! Lots of cool versions of these songs. And including Trent's speech with the next 3 deep cuts really added to the flow.
Wow.
I weep, more than GOOD FABULOUS. I have this CD FRAGILE.
First time watching this January 10th 2021, I just happened to be here...
Corona Capitol
"This is something for our friend David Bowie"
Rest in Peace
Jan 8, 1947 - Jan 10, 2016
Brilliantly put together compilation of live album footage here across the different incarnations of the band.....but anybody else find it really curious to see female backing vocalists there on stage with NIN?
That's from my favorite tour, Tension. They slayed and I had to use that version for Even Deeper and TBCD
I saw that tour and thought they detracted from NIN honestly. I didn't like it much. It didn't sound good. I was happy they brought Explosions In the Sky along though.
@@newnoise81 you need new ears, they're incredible
Trent’s a master of his craft. It’s like he takes the words right out of your mouth.
129:54 that was hollywood last year, last show of the tour. i remember the words "we'll be back... we will be back". that was said to be some kind of farewell tour, so that was comforting.
Robin is a beast!
Wow that 2013 Fuji Rock performance of The Way Out Is Through is one of the best live recordings I've ever hear. Must be from the console. Definitely gonna check that show out. Thanks.
Somewhat Damaged and La Mer are so beautiful
6:00
14, September, 2016.
The day my whole world went away. My only child died at 19 years 2 days old from an enlarged heart. Trent was his perfect drug before he was even born. I played N.I.N for him through headphones when I was pregnant. He's been gone 8 years today.
I'll never be okay again. I miss you D.W.E. You will always be my world.
Yes thank you for posting indeed
This is hands down the best NIN live version.
I saw This tour in Vancouver
Best version of Fragile I’ve seen
Nine inch nails is the most underrated band in history.
Speaking as a big NIN fan, they're not. Not even close but yeah more people should check them out though they aren't anywhere NEAR being the most underrated.
You know who else is underrated? The Beatles.
Congrats Chris you've won the award for the "Stupidest comment of the year". How will you celebrate?
@@omnifuturisticaxaxa love it
They're rated quite well round the world I thought? 🤔 Not really heard any negative views on them, they're quite highly respected.
Surprisingly Good sound quality. Thanks!
Thank you for this compilation. It has some of my favorite footage.
So amazing. I love the energy!
This is elite. Well done.
This is just lovely. Thank you so much.
Thank you so very much Trent & Nine Inch Nails-I missed out for over 25 years but am a new fan-listening since August 2021-I love the live shows best & I love his amazing talent-I am still constantly getting pleasantly surprised around 2 months later- that something new to me comes on such as this compilation I have playing while mult-tasking & I am already starting to sing along some verses-On my 1st listen Or I am getting getting tears in eyes during some parts-Or just Loving the music as it's here to be enjoyed-
I'm constantly listening to songs in my mind-the ones I first loved In August & still love & those I know all the words to already & singing out in public with or without headphones as I relate so deeply to so much of what he says-
Whether it's the same reason he wrote the song or not-But I find out often through watching interviews that my thoughts & emotions were spot on for what he was singing about when he wrote the song at the time & whether it's 1990s or more recent I still feel so much emotion from him in the live shows- Sometimes I cry or laugh & smile but more than anything it has been helping me cope with the suffering-sadness-injustice-problems & things going on in life & sometimes it has been the ONLY THING to ease my mind & help me sleep-As I have insomnia & a list of problems & family issues-health problems-prodigal son-So much more-If I heard & knew this music back during that Woodstock 2 concert I'm sure I'd have enjoyed it but unsure I was old enough to get in if you had to be 21-I did want to go & planned to go but I let other stupid reasons prevent that too
Yet anyway the songs wouldn't have affected me the way they do now-A few-Yes- His thoughts & opinions on so much I agree with & what's right but other things; Yes I had dealt with within my family as I had to go to live in foster homes but not so much personally but I'd rather not say more than that on that issue
Thank you Trent & Nine Inch Nails-You will Always be relevant & I admit it was from watching thd end of that Black Mirror episode-'Head Like A Hole at the end that brought me to TH-cam back then-it sounded familiar-I was never a fan of hers either but she rocked it too in a punk rock style-if she sang like that & songs like that I'd be into her too- That's another story
I'm sure Nine Inch Nails is happy to keep getting new fans from all generations & gave permission to use song I think at least as otherwise WHO KNOWS when I'd discover them as I only started listening to Marilyn Mansons 90smusic in August 2012-Possibly exactly 9 years before this & how ironic when I found out Trent produced an album & sort of discovered him. Back then I believe & he wouldn't have gained that fame if not for Trent-No wonder I immediately related to Trent & I relate to him & all his music much more than aforementioned Artist who has many songs I love & would've loved to see a 90s concert or even now but the 90s concerts were what I would've liked to see much more whereas with Trent I am seeing him in different decades of live shows & I'd LOVE to be at any of them- PLEASE come back to New York As Nine Inch Nails so I can see you Live- Thank you for making this compilation to the person who put it together
I too am a new fan. Of course I liked Closer, March otp, and HLAH. But as far as listening to whole albums, not until 18mos ago. I agree, the live shit is so much better than the albums. So, these "live" albums are great for that. To the uploader, please continue the great work.
Ich liebe diese verdammte Band,
dies ist die beste Band der ganzen verdammten Welt! ❤
Dammit my best album ever is good to listen to it live///Merda el mejor album y mi preferido es tan bueno escucharlo en vivo😥💗
Wish I could find the video of nin in Denver in 2000 fragility tour. Best concert I've ever seen, second was when he was in rapid city sd. From 12 years old to current 42, NIN will always be my absolute favorite artist! It's unfortunate new generations will be lost to the change Trent Reznor provided.
I will count myself as one of the lucky few to see A Perfect Circle Mer De Noms tour open for NIN The Fragile. Get goose bumps to this day when i listen to either album! Maynard opening for Trent. Only thing that came close was Fantomos opening for Tool during the Laturalus tour. Mike Patton and MJK in the same show holy shit!
Saw them at MSG. Marilyn Manson showed up to sing the end of Starfuckers and Beautiful People. Still have the ticket stub
@Vance Oliver best show I’ve ever seen BY FAR!
The guitar in AATCHB is exquisite all throughout.
That live version of TWOIT is awesome
The Great Below ❤️
So creative. @ 1:07:00 this is totally where I'm taking my music too next!
1:02:10 Play That Swanky Music, Hip Boy
This whole thing is pretty fucking great. I love it
God damn Ilan is a fucking beast...!
Dude Michael, I hate you know this. At the same time thank you!
Muchas gracias por este gran trabajo me encanta.
JUST REALIZED THIS NIGHT WAS MY BIRTHDAY!!! NOT THE YEAR BUT THE DAY!! SORRY THAT MADE ME ALL HAPPY FOR A MIN...
Awesome! 😍
That ending is ridiculously good, must have been magical being there in person