Akshat Srivastava was one of the finfluencer who said large cap mutual funds can't outperform the benchmark as they can't do anything different than the Index, he even said things which put down Saurabh Mukherjee (managing 10,00+ crores) and claimed himself (youtuber) better than him
I don’t track either. But i am basing my views on what i see on SM as a public discourse. It is not based on individual opinions of which there are dime a dozen.
Regarding Large Cap funds beating the bench mark 2 year's data does not matter. May 1-2/10 fund managers are sincere honest and dedicated but almost majority are not efficient That's why index fund is best who does not have the medium knowledge about stock market
For fifteen years , I have done the best fund research, picked funds that beat the hell out of the benchmarks and continue to have fun doing it. And here I'm talking to a group of guys I must not even be bothering to speak to those who know nothing and yet confidently talk on the subject. எனக்கு இதுவும் வேணும் ! இன்னமும் வேணும்.😱
@@ShyamSekhar-ithought Sir First of all apologize if my view is communicated in another way! I will have a detailed one here. Pre Note: I was also one of the followers of that group who simply believed index investing is the only best and peaceful but I had changed my opinion on that after seeing your views or videos but Newbies like me or someone who is into MF with the help of advisors are majorly deploying the money either in over valued fund or cyclical funds when it's not supposed to be or thematic. I just connected randomly across my family and friend's circle who does not know anything other than word SIP They are not getting correct advice to invest in right funds at the Right time and exit it at the time. So seeing the above things I felt better to go with index funds than actively managed funds. Also I mean majority only sir and I don't have any intent to hurt you or go harsh against you! And I am also investing in active large Cap funds and starting in debt funds too and not investing in Index funds:) And as you know how many fund managers are deploying money in Zomato swiggy Honda etc etc IPO s at peak valuation with out being responsible. Responsible persons like you are very less sir and public fail to identify them. So sorry again if I had hurted you or conveyed the thing in the other way
@ShyamSekhar-ithought sir hypothetical question let me assume that on a day of sell off I participate by buying a lump sum and simultaneously another fellow investor decides to sell his position off. Does the amc allocate his units to me and transfer my money to him. In other words I am not buying new position but taking over his loss. Can you tell us how this works from a fund manager perspective
I'am also believing active funds instead of index for generating alphas. But comparing for one or two years of mid cap and small cap will not give true results. Particularly small cap active funds beats its index in SIP investments for longer periods (5 yrs and above) in huge margin...
@@ShyamSekhar-ithought Thanks for your reply, Hope your warning is because of its valuations. I agree. I have maintained small cap allocation in my portfolio 10-15%. But recent rally increased to in excess of 20%. I have to rebalance it. Active small cap fund manager has a room to select only 65% from small cap space. Rest 35% can put in large and mid cap stocks. This gave stability to the fund and to beat the index in long term. Better example of this is SBI Small cap fund. It beats index by 2% in 10year SIP investment.
Hi sir you were bullish on banks for past 6 months but they are bleeding and you were bearish on IT stocks but they are rocking. How you are seeing this ?
Sir, 6 months is a short duration contratian style... It takes time, currently the deposit levels are low, micro finance loans are not doing good... It takes some time to change...
Selective use of data doesn't really help convey the differences between active and passive funds. The only point that I can agree is in the last 30 seconds: if one doesn't know enough about active investing, then they should avoid it. Rest of the video was a strawman.
@@ShyamSekhar-ithought Small correction in your perspective. Passive funds will always pass the exam by achieving the benchmark whereas active funds can fail in the exam 😅
அரசியல் வேண்டாம் 👍..... யாருக்கு மெசேஜ் 👌.. நன்றி இருவருக்கும்
Sir pls cover more Mutual funds related topics/analysis/research like today video
அருமையான விளக்கம்.
Thank you sir 👍👍👍
❤ நன்றி 🎉
Vanakkam sir 🎉
Thank you sir HAPPY SIR
Very nice ❤❤❤
Thank you sir
Yes they did.😊
Will axis index fund also be in trouble due to this front running scam?
😊😊😊😊😊
Akshat Srivastava was one of the finfluencer who said large cap mutual funds can't outperform the benchmark as they can't do anything different than the Index, he even said things which put down Saurabh Mukherjee (managing 10,00+ crores) and claimed himself (youtuber) better than him
I don’t track either. But i am basing my views on what i see on SM as a public discourse. It is not based on individual opinions of which there are dime a dozen.
Agreed sir…
Has anyone bought TATA STEEL JAN 110 PE and holding ??
Regarding Large Cap funds beating the bench mark
2 year's data does not matter.
May 1-2/10 fund managers are sincere honest and dedicated but almost majority are not efficient
That's why index fund is best who does not have the medium knowledge about stock market
For fifteen years , I have done the best fund research, picked funds that beat the hell out of the benchmarks and continue to have fun doing it. And here I'm talking to a group of guys I must not even be bothering to speak to those who know nothing and yet confidently talk on the subject. எனக்கு இதுவும் வேணும் ! இன்னமும் வேணும்.😱
@@ShyamSekhar-ithought
Sir First of all apologize if my view is communicated in another way!
I will have a detailed one here.
Pre Note:
I was also one of the followers of that group who simply believed index investing is the only best and peaceful but I had changed my opinion on that after seeing your views or videos but
Newbies like me or someone who is into MF with the help of advisors are majorly deploying the money either in over valued fund or cyclical funds when it's not supposed to be or thematic.
I just connected randomly across my family and friend's circle who does not know anything other than word SIP
They are not getting correct advice to invest in right funds at the Right time and exit it at the time.
So seeing the above things I felt better to go with index funds than actively managed funds.
Also I mean majority only sir and I don't have any intent to hurt you or go harsh against you!
And I am also investing in active large Cap funds and starting in debt funds too and not investing in Index funds:)
And as you know how many fund managers are deploying money in Zomato swiggy Honda etc etc IPO s at peak valuation with out being responsible.
Responsible persons like you are very less sir and public fail to identify them.
So sorry again if I had hurted you or conveyed the thing in the other way
@@ShyamSekhar-ithoughthow do you have so much patience lol
@ShyamSekhar-ithought sir hypothetical question let me assume that on a day of sell off I participate by buying a lump sum and simultaneously another fellow investor decides to sell his position off. Does the amc allocate his units to me and transfer my money to him. In other words I am not buying new position but taking over his loss. Can you tell us how this works from a fund manager perspective
Not really. He books his loss and you book in separately.
❤❤❤❤
Is it 1 year return or 10 years rolling returns?
I'am also believing active funds instead of index for generating alphas. But comparing for one or two years of mid cap and small cap will not give true results. Particularly small cap active funds beats its index in SIP investments for longer periods (5 yrs and above) in huge margin...
I am warning you on smallcaps. They will be underperforming as a category. But the reasons are different.
@@ShyamSekhar-ithought Thanks for your reply, Hope your warning is because of its valuations. I agree. I have maintained small cap allocation in my portfolio 10-15%. But recent rally increased to in excess of 20%. I have to rebalance it. Active small cap fund manager has a room to select only 65% from small cap space. Rest 35% can put in large and mid cap stocks. This gave stability to the fund and to beat the index in long term. Better example of this is SBI Small cap fund. It beats index by 2% in 10year SIP investment.
Hi sir you were bullish on banks for past 6 months but they are bleeding and you were bearish on IT stocks but they are rocking. How you are seeing this ?
Sir, 6 months is a short duration contratian style... It takes time, currently the deposit levels are low, micro finance loans are not doing good... It takes some time to change...
Never be arrogant. The market will teach you tough lessons.
Sir shubman gilla solraru pola 😂😂😂 boland balla yeri vandhu suthi out aanan
Selective use of data doesn't really help convey the differences between active and passive funds. The only point that I can agree is in the last 30 seconds: if one doesn't know enough about active investing, then they should avoid it. Rest of the video was a strawman.
Your only consolation is passive funds won't under perform the benchmark. Like the student who comes second in a two man race. Cling onto that straw.
@@ShyamSekhar-ithought Small correction in your perspective. Passive funds will always pass the exam by achieving the benchmark whereas active funds can fail in the exam 😅
Thank you sir
❤