What if you buy a stock and appreciates 10%, but the next year decrease 20% in value, but you already paid for the last year, it's just stupid man. Love this country, but I just don't get this. Realized gains is fair, not fictitious gains that in a month can go under.
"Great video! Please make more videos in English. You are correct about the tax treaty; the French/Dutch treaty explains it clearly. It’s actually not bad to live in the Netherlands and own properties in France..."
Great video! 1. Do you have any information about how foreign real estates will be taxed in the new system? 2. Currently, you have to list them at Box 3, and they will only be taxed in the source country (another EU country), right? Is it obligatory to list them? What if the real estate is worth more than the exemption amount (57K or 114K with a fiscal partner this year)? Thank you!
I just watched the youtube video. It is ridiculous that tax authority considered unrealized gain from stock as realized gain. It makes no sense. If they charge tax on realized capital gains, then it is understandable. The tax on that will force people to liquidate their stock to pay tax (to realize the unrealized gain/loss). This will give more work for the tax accountants and make everything more complicated. It is such a weird movement from the government.
Not fully true. It made sense from a practical point of view: It is much easier to give all people the same rate rather than assess each person's capital gains. But yes they assumed high returns which few achieved which was wrong. They should have chosen a different system of levying tax.
thanks for sharing, interesting to learn that the Dutch government potentially is considering taxing on gains from stock investments. Do you expect that they would consider making a distinction based on different volatility profiles? Would be quite painful if the value of your portfolio drops with ~20-30% 1-2 months later after paying taxes at year's end. Perhaps a more balanced approach that would take into account the fluctuations over a year's time would make more sense.
Als je nou naar Spanje emigreert om de aankomende box 3 veranderingen voor te zijn, is dat dan de oplossing? Worden huurinkomsten die gegenereerd worden in Nederland box 3 dan belast in Spanje als inkomstenbelasting of vermogenswinstbelasting?
Brilliant video thank you for doing videos in English as well. I understand that until 2027 if you sell your investment property with a profit you are not obliged to pay any taxes, however if this bill passes your proceeds from a sale of investment property will be taxed (vermogenswinst) what is the tax %? 31%? Thanks for clarifying.
Will there be fix rates for interest calculating on the savings ? Asking because in Netherlands the % on saving account are max 0,5-1% while in some overseas countries are more than 5%
This is a fiscal related question so best to also check with an advisor. My answer would be: It depends. One of the first places to look at is whether there is a Tax treaty. NL has a tax treaty with many countries. So there should be guidelines on how it taxes the properties.
Download the box 3 documents here:
realestatemasterclass.nl/en/download-box-3/
A ridiculous tax system for a developped country.
What if you buy a stock and appreciates 10%, but the next year decrease 20% in value, but you already paid for the last year, it's just stupid man. Love this country, but I just don't get this. Realized gains is fair, not fictitious gains that in a month can go under.
is this the (insane) law that was blocked by the supreme court in the Nederland cause it violates another EU right to hold assets?
"Great video! Please make more videos in English. You are correct about the tax treaty; the French/Dutch treaty explains it clearly. It’s actually not bad to live in the Netherlands and own properties in France..."
Thank you! We have been working on more content in English and have already published some as well.
Great video!
1. Do you have any information about how foreign real estates will be taxed in the new system?
2. Currently, you have to list them at Box 3, and they will only be taxed in the source country (another EU country), right? Is it obligatory to list them?
What if the real estate is worth more than the exemption amount (57K or 114K with a fiscal partner this year)?
Thank you!
Very informative! Thank you.
I just watched the youtube video. It is ridiculous that tax authority considered unrealized gain from stock as realized gain. It makes no sense. If they charge tax on realized capital gains, then it is understandable. The tax on that will force people to liquidate their stock to pay tax (to realize the unrealized gain/loss). This will give more work for the tax accountants and make everything more complicated. It is such a weird movement from the government.
Not fully true. It made sense from a practical point of view: It is much easier to give all people the same rate rather than assess each person's capital gains. But yes they assumed high returns which few achieved which was wrong. They should have chosen a different system of levying tax.
thanks for sharing, interesting to learn that the Dutch government potentially is considering taxing on gains from stock investments. Do you expect that they would consider making a distinction based on different volatility profiles? Would be quite painful if the value of your portfolio drops with ~20-30% 1-2 months later after paying taxes at year's end. Perhaps a more balanced approach that would take into account the fluctuations over a year's time would make more sense.
Really useful! Thanks!
Als je nou naar Spanje emigreert om de aankomende box 3 veranderingen voor te zijn, is dat dan de oplossing? Worden huurinkomsten die gegenereerd worden in Nederland box 3 dan belast in Spanje als inkomstenbelasting of vermogenswinstbelasting?
Brilliant video thank you for doing videos in English as well. I understand that until 2027 if you sell your investment property with a profit you are not obliged to pay any taxes, however if this bill passes your proceeds from a sale of investment property will be taxed (vermogenswinst) what is the tax %? 31%? Thanks for clarifying.
Will there be fix rates for interest calculating on the savings ?
Asking because in Netherlands the % on saving account are max 0,5-1% while in some overseas countries are more than 5%
What is inluded in Property maintenance costs?
thank you for making this in english
Kan ook in Nl taal?
Dat is deze video: th-cam.com/video/x_kTA3Po-M0/w-d-xo.html :)
Will income from properties outside Netherlands also be taxed under box 3?
This is a fiscal related question so best to also check with an advisor. My answer would be: It depends. One of the first places to look at is whether there is a Tax treaty. NL has a tax treaty with many countries. So there should be guidelines on how it taxes the properties.
What are the type of expenses we may deduct?
Hi the list of expenses are not definitive yet. So we have to wait.
Wauw super helpful!!!
Thanks
No correction for inflation?! So we will be paying unrealised capital gains tax each year as stock price go up with inflation.
Seems to be a conflict of interest for the government. Print more money, receive more tax
This currently seems to be the case. Are you mainly invested in stocks?
100% stocks. I may need to put the capital somewhere else from 2027.
Time to change the Netherlands for Dubai
Good luck with all those Moslims
Ha yes that is an option. Depending on your finances, there are many options to pay lower taxes
@@RealEstateMasterclassdo you have a video about this? Most of the people with wealth will be looking for this far and wide.