Hey guys. I'm from Brazil. I was born in São Paulo. Now, i'm student of Library Sciences in the north of Brazil. Now, more than never, i can see that what Chomsky says. The information industries is the guide of the mass, and his power is underestimated. Please, help us. Most of population here is much more ignorant than we can imagine. My english ins't so good but war is coming in here and we have to powered our connections to other countries. USA sabotaged our space program and nuclear program, and of course the US government is behind some aspects of the Bolsonaro's election and the media interference. Most of people don'r now what to do and the right wing here keep rising and practicing acts of violence of any kind. #tearsfrombrazil
I will weep the day Noam dies and go into mourning for quite some time. It is interesting that this great man is ignored by academia and main stream media. As Jesus said a prophet is not acknowledged in his home town. In fact they are hated, scorned, mocked and ridiculed. I love this man and all he stands for. Another great man is Ralph Nader and the same treatment is meted out to him as well.
Chomsky is so generous with his time. The fact that he's also the most sane and rational person, when speaking about politics, nationally is a gigantic added bonus. He'll be 90 in a month. We have to somehow hope we can save his brain and sacrifice Jared Kushner to keep Chomsky alive for another 90 years. At least.
@@lsobrien Brazil has been mired in corruption and violence for decades. Over 60,000 people murdered each year, more than were killed in the entire Vietnam war. Corruption at every level of government, municipal, state, and federal. All this growing violence and corruption under Lula's party, the PT (workers party). Lule himself enjoyed the highest approval level in the polls ever seen in a modern democracy. He could have joined together others of goodwill and tackled the corruption head on. Instead, he became the centre of it. Chomsky calls the downfall of the PT a "soft coup". Couldn't be further from the truth. Dilma Rousseff, (Lula's prodigy and the last President) was impeached with a 2/3 senate majority. Senators from a variety of political backgrounds voted in a clearly democratic process. To call that a "coup" is a grave insult to the Brazilian government and its Constitution. Brazil needs a strong leader right now or it is finished. The economy has been in a tailspin. Inflation rampant. Interest rates soaring. The currency, the Brazilian Real is worth less than 25 cents to the US Dollar. Bolsonaro has made many comments that have been taken out of context. Yes there are many concerns, especially concerning the Amazon. I hope he doesn't go through with that. But on the balance, Bolsonaro is just what Brazil needs right now. Chomsky sees it all through his far Left lenses, and sees none of the nuance.
During the times of slavery in Brazil, there used to a powerful landowner in the Northeast. He was a Field Marshal and held the title of Baron. One day, he had a guest over for a feast. As the man entered his house, he complimented a female slave, saying she had beautiful breasts. After the feast was over, it was time for the guest to leave, but the Baron had a surprise for him: the slave's severed breasts on a silver plate. The Brazilian elite has always been vicious, ruthless, heartless and sadistic. Slaves were buried alive and rich farmer's wives sharpened the teeth of female slaves using knives so the Master couldn't use them for oral sex anymore. Quartering poor people could be a national sport. The rich in Brazil would rather kill everyone than to give up their land, and the vicious cycle of income inequality continues (2% of landowners own half of the country's land).
Doodle. ........depressing but all too understandable. The political "debate" especially amongst the American working classes is controlled by the likes of the Murdoch Media Machine through the propaganda outlets of fxnews.
@@72marshflower15 yes, and it was Chomsky's life which taught me this fact. I don't want to be like him, a deep geopolitical genius without the ability or willingness to lead movements. Better to be less knowledgeable and active, than a genius with no force.
Doodelay Explains touché... however, and to the contrary, Chomsky has helped entire generations figure out things no one else could. hes given the chance to millions to help effect positive change for humanity and life over all. true collectives only work where no one individual nature is predominant over the collective whole. per laws of the universe, he's effectively forbidden to project the information he understands... he can only share it. and for the record, id prefer to walk with others, and not necessarily lead all the time.. alpha/omega need not always lead.. reflect it.. dont project it 😘 p.s. ..i helped write/create the blue wave and more... no one will ever know who or what i am.. no one will ever come forward to gain recognition for what is at hand. you may be grateful for it later, so never underestimate the power of anyone trying.. aroha from fissure 8, Havvaii... 🌊🌊🌊🌴🌴🌋🌴🌴🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊 🤗
@@johnmulligan455 Ex-president Lula, made the biggest corruption scandal in the world's histoy. Criminality growed up, pooverty too, corruption, inneficience, lies, scandals, support to dictatorships, Marxism in schools, compromised freedom of speech and press. Used mooney to buy congress and the supreme court and used gramscism to fuck all
Have a wealthy friend in Brazil he says that there is no middle class. Just rich and poor. Let that sink in... cause that is what trump is doing.... and because of this forced and greedy disparately people can’t drive down streets with windows open because mistreated and deprived people tend to want and need to stay alive are forced into stealing to remain alive... good quality of life actually not good for either. Greed is a deadly sin. For rich and poor
I agree, . people are forced to become criminals , to kill and Rob in order to eat, under socialism there is no crime , because there is no property, listen to Chomsky he is a Professor at MIT and the top intellectual in the US. I bet you right wingers have never been to university and learnt about socialism
I am thankful, that my age results in the reality that I likely have fewer years ahead of me than I have decades behind. I really don't want to see the new world corporacratic order that is being built come to fruition. The world will soon to be far more frightening than anything we have ever imagined in our worst nightmares, and the advent of its dystopia will be cheered on by the very people who will be most hurt by the compassion's demise.
So Brazilian citizens have some difficult years ahead of them. When right-wing economic policies are implemented, things go bad pretty quickly. As a bonus, they will regress socially too.
@@VictorSilva-qf2tu So that's your hunch I guess. You could also just look at actual economic stats. Look at economic growth between 2000 and 2012. That's what progressive policies result in. The reason is obvious; if more people have money, aggregate demand increases.
@@gustav4539 the problem is socialism always works in the beginning. Until the money runs out. The government distributed money in social programs in a unsustainable rate for years plus all the mega corruption scandals resulted in huge debts and unemployment. It's always like this.
At the three minute mark you can see, to the left of Paulo Guedes, the judge (and future justice minister) Sergio Moro who jailed Bolsonaro's chief rival before the election, thus practically guaranteeing Bolsonaro's win.
Claro que vai destruir... Aliás, quantos porcento ainda existe da floresta pra ele destruir? Porque o pico de desflorestamento foi justamente nos últimos anos do Lula e nos primeiros da Dilma...
Tem um monte de estrangeiros esquerdistas querendo opinar sobre o Brasil , sempre com os mesmos argumentos , ain fascista e bla bla bla , na moral isso já ta me enchendo o saco .
Lula was first place in surveys, the first in popularity, and loved by the people but the fascist rigthwinged buy judges, police and media and with persecution and Lawfare stopped Lula from politics fabricating false corruption against Lula, so the second and only option was Bolsonaro and obviously won without Lula who is suppressed on false corruption. Actually this modus operandi strategy the Lawfare is being applied all over South and Central America.
I also have no idea. I have to hear stuff from his supporters that “he is the savior”, “he is the messiah sent from god”. It looks like a complete brainwash!
It didn't worked, if you read our news you'll see it. ( not fake news, actually is better you interview the people who live here, we dont want to be another Venezuela or Bolivia, the socialists wanted to transform all the south America in a communist block, and thanks God, the people awake).
Chomsky's disapearance in the Venezuelan dicatorship humanitarian catastrophe is very sad. He should and had an obligation to come out publicly condemning it.
You are out of your mind Zack Sherman!!! Brazil is bankrupt and was on the edge of the communism deep, slippery and dark precipice. Most of the media is infiltrated by gays, lesbians and communists (personally I got nothing against anyone's sexual fettiches, but this ridiculous apologies for the LGBT's to the point of forcing the "public schools" to indocrinate children as early as 6 years of age, is just fucking pathetic!!!). Bolsonaro is a Christian and a family man who has enough balls to do what needs to be done!!! I suggest that you should try to learn what is really going on before you open your mouth.
I don't like and don't agree with Bolsonaro, but he got the majority of the votes, so unless he does something unconstitutional, why should people stop him? In a democracy sometimes the most voted is not the one that represent us. We have to give whoever wins, the benefit of the doubt, if we can. I don't like Trump either but he won the elections and as a citizen in a democratic society, I have to accept him even if I can't stand him. Now if he does something unconstitutional, then I will rise up.
@@Thinkingisallowed, Brazil is a country where an "acessorista" (elevator driver), yes! They still exist in some government buildings, make 4 times as much as a teacher, also any Senator, ministry or judge chauffeur will earn outrageous salaries (they have to be well paid and they do keep their mouths shut), I live in Brasilia, "the corruption capital of the planet" and I know how it is!!! What drives me nuts are people that have never set foot in Brazil, don't know it's culture and "feel like" writing down their clever opinion here.
Respectfully, and yet you don't seem to ask why Brazilians voted for the candidate who made it to the runoff opposite PT's candidate. Lula is not a political prisoner. Anyone who says so is greatly misinformed. One should acknowledge the role of Lula and his allies in the very rise of such a controversial character. It's hard to believe someone like Chomsky would choose to be fed his 'facts' from only one side of the political spectrum. I suspect Brazilians would have elected any candidate, had they made it to the second round. We just wanted out of anything to do with Lula and PT. Their unsustainable policies have not reduced poverty or inequality. They did not invest in basic education. They were and have been ahead of and behind the greatest corruption scheme ever conducted in Brazil. I did not vote for Bolsonaro, but I refuse to adhere to naysayers and I chose to believe that some good will come out of the next 4 years. Unlike Lula, the president elect has no intention to run for a second term. I also wonder how you all react when people who have never lived in your country express their opinions as if they really could know what is best for you.
Let's keep any potential racism out of this. That is one of Amy's divide and conquer tactics. HOWEVER; paedophiles and rapists are fair game (what's up John Podesta and B.Clinton? )
Criminoso para quem? Criminoso para a Globo; herói para o povo. De que lado da História você gostaria de ficar? De milhares de intelectuais de todas as áreas, dos movimentos sociais, ou de um bando de entreguistas, corruptos e mentirosos? Do lado do governante que tirou 40 milhões da pobreza ou de quem perpetua a miséria no Brasil? Escolha difícil? Acho que não, para qualquer pessoa sensata ou minimamente decente.
@@demonioamarelo1064 Demonio Amarelo Criminoso para a Justiça. Os únicos que saíram da pobreza foi a família do Lula, nossa economia foi pro ralo e nossa moeda quase não vale o papel que está impressa. O Brasil votou e mostrou que está cansado , chora mais que seu líder tá preso e os aliados dele ao redor do mundo estão mortos ou num buraco igual ele. Ninguém mais quer comunismo não, se quiser foge pra Cuba ou Coreia do Norte, os paraísos da Terra em liberdade, saúde, economia e qualidade de vida.
@Aline Santos É pena que você não aprecie uma boa cachaça. Quanto à corrupção, o governo que está aí e o eleito são recordistas nisso. Sobre o Lula: diga quanto ele roubou ou quanto ele entregou a ditaduras "comunistas". Você deveria saber que não houve comunismo no mundo (e não defendo o comunismo, diga-se de passagem). Eric Hobsbawn demonstra que, se você troca uma elite empresarial por uma de burocratas, o privilégio permanece. O que você chama, sem base alguma, comunismo, ele chama capitalismo de Estado. E Lula não foi entreguista, os fatos desmentem você: A Petrobrás deu tanto lucro, e estatal, que se pôde separar uma vultuosa parte desse lucro para investimento em educação. O Brasil se livrou do FMI e guardou reservas. As empresas e os bancos nunca faturaram tanto, e 40 milhões de pessoas esquecidas por todos os governos saíram da miséria. Brasileiro ou brasileira que ofende quem fez bem ao país e protege bandidos e entreguistas, pior, com argumento caquético de guerra fria de "comunistas", não sabe o que está falando, repete ladainha de propaganda sem base factual. E a sua fala tem só ódio e preconceito pesadões.
@@JatVik Ok. Vamos começar, selecionando cada uma das partes da sua sopa de loucura. 1) Lula vivia uma vida modesta para um ex-presidente, ainda no mesmo apartamento em que vivia no ABC. Diferente de outros, com os quais você não parece preocupado. 2) Nossa economia não foi para o ralo, ao contrário: com a presidente Rousseff o Brasil chegou a ser a sexta economia do planeta, ultrapassando a Grã-Bretanha, e quando Rousseff sofreu o golpe de Estado em 2016 o Brasil tinha reservas de mais de 300 bilhões de dólares. Por favor, informe-se melhor. 3) Os aliados de Lula não estão nem mortos nem num buraco como o dele, porque outros países ainda têm o que se chama (talvez você desconheça o termo) civilização. Pepe Mujica, que foi preso por uma ditadura, está livre e é um herói no Uruguai; François Hollande (ex-presidente da França), Rodriguez Zapatero (ex-presidente da Espanha) e três ex-primeiros ministros da Itália, todos livres, porque honestos como Lula, o defendem contra a (in)justiça brasileira; Noam Chomsky, um dos maiores intelectuais vivos, defende Lula; Luigi Ferrajoli, grande jurista italiano, criticou o processo de Lula e a Lava Jato; Chico Buarque e mais milhares de intelectuais e artistas o defendem; o papa Francisco o defende; três prêmios Nobel da Paz o defendem; milhares e milhares de cartas de brasileiros continuam chegando à Polícia Federal. Você está REDONDAMENTE errado sobre o que fala, e não parece entender os fatos do que é uma prisão política. Você já ouviu falar de Martin Luther King? De Nelson Mandela? Das injutiças históricascontraesses líderes populares reverenciados, hoje, no mundo todo? Talvez você esteja fazendo o mesmo no Brasil. Eu acho que sim. 4) O que Lula fez, assim como Dilma Rousseff, se chama capitalismo. Comunismo é quando privilégios não existem, especulação financeira não existe, e o que se produz é dividido igualmente por todo o povo, com um governo rigorosamente popular. Nos anos de governo do PT as empresas tiveram lucro, variaram suas atividades, os bancos privados tiveram grandes lucros, havia competição no mercado, especulação financeira na bolsa de valores, e o país era governado por uma coalizão de partidos de centro-esquerda, democraticamente, com a direita fazendo oposição dentro do Congresso. Não diga bobagem. Você claramente não tem idéia do que é comunismo, e, pior, não tem nem um iota de idéia do que é capitalismo, que você, suponho, pretende defender. 5) Não há paraísos na Terra: há esforços de civilização. Cuba e Coréia do Norte, sobre o que você também demonstra saber nada, são dois tipos de governo completamente diferentes, com resultados também diversos. Governos não são puros de bem e mal, e devem ser criticados e apoiados, igualmente, quando fazem besteira ou algo bom. De modo demonstrável, os anos de governo do PT foram os melhores que o país já teve: democráticos, estabilizadores da economia, com diplomacia independente e forte, marcando o Brasil como potência da América do Sul no equilíbrio de questões internacionais, guardaram reservas vultuosas, livraram o Brasil do FMI, tiraram mais de 40 milhões de pessoas da miséria, etc. Você não gosta nem aprova nada disso? Não tem problema: Agora você tem o governo que pediu aos céus: governo que entrega todas as riquezas naturais do Brasil para empresas estrangeiras, e a preço de banana; governo que atrela sua diplomacia como escrava de potência estrangeira, para ajudar a espalhar violência pelo mundo; governo que destrói os direitos de carteira assinada do trabalhador e doa seu trabalho escravo para os ricos; governo que congela investimento social por 20 anos, produzindo caos em um país emergente, que lutava contra as desigualdades e injustiças; que leva o desemprego ao mais alto ponto em dez anos, e produzirá ainda mais desempregados; que joga o povo brasileiro na miséria de novo, com a quantidade de mendigos crescendo três vezes nas regiões metropolitanas, e devolvendo o Brasil ao mapa da fome; que já entrega bases militares para potência estrangeira, e a Amazônia ao desmatamento das madeireiras, produzindo a pior situação já vista no meio ambiente. Preconceituoso, violento, ignorante, entreguista. Aí está. Fique feliz, seu governo é esse aí, meus parabéns.
@@demonioamarelo1064 Textão legal, mas o Lula e a Dilma estão cagando pra você, é impressionante ver que você acredita nisso, mas enfim, a Justiça deu sua palavra e o povo também. Brasil acima de tudo, Deus de todos e Lula no colo do Capeta.
Good reporting. One interesting thing is that when Americans speaks about Brazil, always put Latin America, connecting to Nicaragua, Chile, Bolivia... etc.. Brazil is like an own continent and it has a completely different size, culture, language, politics, history and economy in comparison with our neighbors. So I think when analyse Brazil and Brazilian in general, cannot include in this Latin America, Latino basket, but as Brazil/Brazilians only.
Bozo, as he is called by his oppositors, once was invited to talk to an audience in a club for jews. When he arrived he was booed by protestors in the outside. When he was in there talking, he said "Have you ever seen a japanese begging? They are a people who have self-respect. One people who has no self-respect is those people who were out there booing me". Once an brazilian indigenous leader went to the capital to protest against some actions from him and he said "He says he is an indian. If he were really an indian he wouldn't be here, he would be in the woods, eating grass.".
I really like Chomsky's analyses in general, and I think, as a Brazilian also, that Bolsonaro is abominable, but this time Chomsky committed the sin the left wing accuses the right of committing so often. His analysis of Brazil is mainly coming from the most dubious source of all, the instance's political victim. He's even buying into the fairy tale Lula tells about his appartment; of course, it's not registered as his, because, as his crooked ingenuity had planned, all of Lula's wealth is spread among his relatives and friends. Lula was the overseer of a corruption industry never before seen here nor anywhere else; at the very least, he should be in prison for life for being an accomplice. As for Dilma, the so-called coup d'état, though questionable, was mostly legit, as she did in fact distort numbers to achieve her goals, and there is a law that forbids the president of doing so. The problem was that no other president had been charged with that law, as it is so broad. Anyway, in my opinion, she should have been impeached from sheer incompetence; it's a pity there is no law against this surely useless trait -- she is also the author of the legendary quote: "we should (*literally*) store the wind, it would be valuable technology". Lastly, the sin that bugs me the most about this whole analysis is the blind idealization of the years the PT party was in power. Truthfully, we experienced a lot of progress and I think that the demonization of that era which spreading like an epidemy will be most regrattable for us. But the PT party built a country on sand: the investments would be severely cut off due to corruption (in some cases, we could have built twice the infrastructure, do you know what 2 schools or 2 hospitals instead of 1 mean?); the education and poverty indexes would get distorted make-ups; and a party who supposedly deffended the workers and the poor would allocate the biggest development bank's fund mostly for giant corporations which didn't need any of the money at all. Now, tell me, as a journalist or political scientist, will you ever hear the full story by going into the prison cell of the overseer of the biggest, most publicly institutionalized corruption industry of Brazil's history and arguably the world?
1st US and now Brazil, it's really fascinating but also a shame that a country's majority elects someone that troughout the whole campaign has shown no sign of being able to even control their mouth. I mean, these guys may be smart (or not, you decide) but a guy who speaks and acts like an angry teen should not run for office.
Chomsky isnt even a Political Scientist. He is a linguist. How the hell is he so knowledgeable on worldwide government and history. americans would never even consider voting for him for any office.
Media once more prioritizing the spectacle rather than the truth. As a brazilian, I urge for news makers to dive a little bit deeper on what is really going in Brazil before uttering their vision of the apocalyptic future of my country, when even the renowned Noam Chomsky has no idea of what is going on you can see how far we’ve gone. It‘s only naive to think that a socialistic reform, Noam Chomsky rule of thumb, seems appropriate regardless of the country‘s context, unfortunately in Brazil no political class has shown integrity to preserve power and we fall back to institutions like the military, a cheap shot indeed but definitely better than betting on the workers party who has sabotaged the country for over a decade! Using an american saying to quote an american flaw: „It’s easy to see without looking to far“
Lula Livre!Free Lula!🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹-Lula é PRESO POLÍTICO e sofre BRUTAL caçada policial e judicial e condenação política e é preso político!Lula Livre!❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
but also what can you expect from an evangelical? the more religion in government, the greater the atrocities against people, rights and the environment, even if this is what they (religious fanatics) do best. The misery of Brazil is that it has always been considered a marginal child, for first world countries like the USA. but you have always preferred to help and negotiate with europe, australia, canada, japan. This is a fact The United States only remembered Brazil at the time to take advantage of releasing credit cards here. United States has always seen Brazil as an unwanted South American, an unfit country, a colony to be exploited. I fully accept that he is a madman swept away that naod everia be there, but is it that the United States is not at fault in this? this son tries to mirror his father, and this father (United States) is by the way given very bad examples. And a country with great social differences, it is a racist country, it is a country that has no interest in changing its philosophy of war, it is a country that was once a country scientifically evolved but now it is a factory of negationists, the forests of you exist still? How are the deposits gone, are they over? or have they started mining Alaska as well? see I'm not saying that this new government is correct, far from it, I'd rather have a thousand times see a right as the candidate of the "new" party Joao amoedo in government, but to do what? the influence of the united states is not limited to the politicians here, you have badly influenced an entire nation, and the bolsonaro was the result. unfortunately, we hope that they do not destroy everything until the next elections. if you want changes in your children, you should start cleaning your own house.
Actually fascism is socialism because in. Fascism the state control on private company CEO and that why socialism lead to to dictator ship as a matter of fact the nazi were socialist and Stalin was socialist ,every dictator ship in world was socialist . Capitalism mean freedom of economy and state can't control the economy which make government only job is to protect the people right , when government cannot control the economy it become week and president cannot be dictatorship. When government control the Economy as what happen in socialism it become strong and that lead to dictatorship like in Venezuela
S Falck worker control over the means of production is communism ,because when we say worker it's misleading word you mean government, I'm from Iraq the same sentence your are using said by albath party which the party of Saddam Hussein ,and it was socialist party even its name was albath Arabian socialist party , and when they gain power they control over country recourses and oil and every private company because in in order for worker to control over the mean of production the government in the name of worker control over private company and oil this lead to Saddam dicatorship and poverty ,by the why the nazi party was socialist part and when they gain power lead to hitler dictatorship and that why in the binging of ww2 they were in agreement with the communist which were also socialist, the nazis fund a some car companies and convert them into military companies , they didn't allow them to work because they believe in free market ,they allow they to work because they deliver them with weapons they need for wars ,you forget to mention that under the nazis the people were gathering in long line for breads because in the name of farmers the government control on farms and on food which lead to massive starvation and farmer being slave for state ,basher alasad of Syria is socialist and his party which also name albath party like Iraq albath party is also socialist,the same for mao of china ,and most of tyranny of world . Fascism mean state private company but control on their manger , in capitalism which mean free economy which mean the state cannot control economy it impossible to have fascism or dictator ship because state cannot control economy and the only job for state is protecting freedom and rights of individual ,the founding father of united state know that ,thats why the establish the united state based on capitalism and that what make us rich country ,that why you see the wealthy county in world are capitalist state like Singapore and Luxembourg and Switzerland and hong Kung which have little recourses and great economy ,and contrast to that the poorest countries in world with huge recesses like Iraq which has huge reserve of oil but its poor country because of socialism, also Venezuela,and most countries of Africa and any country who adopted socialism end up either dictator ship of poverty or even worst it could end up in killing millions of people like what happen in ussr or china under mao rule , the socialism has destroy my country , be aware usa you are living in mixed economy and their is more and more socialism are coming . Sadly to see that USA this great country which was capitalist now turning into mixed economy and turning more and more into socialism
He is so wrong about Chile. Sorry Progres. but im chilean and the "chicago boys" saved our economy, we didnt have the tools to industrilize ourselfs (yes, thank u colonialism) and we HAD to privatize most of our economy to run the machine.
Not used to this, when it comes from Noam Chomsky. The brazilian problem is very complex, PT had 14 years on power, the judicial cases of Oderbrecht, lavajato and Petrobras have incarcerated tons of PT elements for high level corruption, to an extent that it is virtually Impossible that the former leaders Lula and Dilma couldnt know of it. Lula had an astonishing social success in his first mandate, it was a good mandate but then PT robbed the country blind, the level of corruption is absolutely incredible, a communist party that have tons of people in Jail, from ministers to secretaries to treausry department...its unbelievable. Combine this with a economic disgrace for years and 60.000 homicidas/year...its ready to burst. Bolsonaro wont solve anything, he's an opportunistic ignorant and a moron, but that's the present legacy of todays democratic parties, they get tons of years in power and they leave a residue of corruption, ill gotten gains and economic decline, an increase between the 1% and the others and a feeling of perpetuation of the same bullshit and THEN they feel surprised when people vote in despair because they are sick of it. Note: The brazilian regions where the more cultured and literate people live voted massively in Bolsonaro, this election cant be pinned on the "less culturally formed". Love to hear Prof. Chomsky but this subject is far more complex than these 14 min told, it paints a very misleading picture.
YET BRAZILIANS VOTED FOR BOLSONARO, (AS IS COSTUMERY TO VOTE FOR CHANGE, WHICH IS LABELED PROGRESS). WHEN IN FACT THE ONLY PROGRESS EVIDENT IS IN MILITARY ESTABLISHMENTS SPENDING AND THE PARTNERSHIP BETWEEN THE WEALTHY POLITICIANS AND THE OLIGHARCS.
the most Malicious and vicius creatures in the current range of ugly characters that we seen around the world.. Is an accurate description by professor Chomsky
Interesting that he does not mention about the corruption and how PT almost broke the country. The agro-business is in Amazon area for decades and it had increased its presence during the last 15 years. Bolsonaro was a terrible option, but he represented the population response to PT. Unfortunately, better options could not be elected.
Thing is with the likes of Bolsonaro, Duterte etc they differ from the compliant fascist juntas America backed in the Cold War, which basically amounted to Bourgeois Republics rather than fascist regimes. Such Juntas represented no international threat, they were just in the business of preserving capitalism on behalf of themselves and their American backers. So de facto fascism represents something new in developing countries, and something unpredictable. Something akin to the growth of nationalism in Germany, Italy and Japan in the early 20th century. Nationalism that will err toward militarism and expansion. Basically, the kind of reactionary capitalism that will inevitably come into conflict with the established capitalist powers.
Social Media as Noam mentioned briefly is a powerful tool for manipulating the popular vote in every nation....people need to really diversify their information resources for a rounded understanding and sadly this failure results in group think and tragic outcomes
Dear Mr. Chomsky, never in the history of Brazil , the Amazon was as much destroyed as during Lulas and Dilmas regime. If you are consequent you would criticize them too. The debt is also because of Lulas corruption. The Chicago Boys did not teach Lula to steal
so sad to hear a linguist stuttering so much to say a phrase... Mr. Chomsky, just admit you don't understand what''s happening here in Brasil. In fact, I must say it, without being superb, that no one outside Brasil is able to understand whats's going on here. Because it's a hard situation and also because it's difficult to find an honest source of information.
Lula is just a criminal character. All due process of law was followed in his JudgmentS. He was unanimously condemned in two instances of Brazilian justice, by at least 4 judges, simple like that. It is odd how the 'interviewer' tries to conduct the interview demonizing her opposite beliefs.
It's really hard to have hope in times like this. And I think this is exactly the sort of mindset that allows people like Jair Bolsonaro to rise to power. As a Brazilian I'm terrified but also lacking any resemblance of hope for better times.
The thing is a lot of humans hate poor people. Rich people hate the poor, the middle class hate the poor and the poor hate the poor. I was once in the airport and there were a lot of people there. I heard one guy saying that brazilian airports had turned into a buss station ever since the plane tickets had been popularized... People are happier to earn $7 when everybody else is earning $5 instead of every single one earning $9.
And this Noam Chomsky is a college professor? Ask for your money back kids!!! All the information he got from the criminal. So maybe you should go to the prisons in the US and talk to the criminals, if they say they are innocent you let them go.
Chicago school economics transfers wealth upwards - to people who own stocks and bonds. The rich will get richer and the poor will get poorer. A crystal ball is not needed to know this outcome. The results are the same in every country that Chicago school economics is implemented.
I am Brazilian, I love and admire Mr.Chomsky and I agree that Bolsonaro will be a catastrophe, but, in this case, Bolsonaro will be only following the steps of Lula who was also a catastrophe. There is still time to learn that Left and Right are two hands of the same sick body.
Hey guys. I'm from Brazil. I was born in São Paulo. Now, i'm student of Library Sciences in the north of Brazil. Now, more than never, i can see that what Chomsky says. The information industries is the guide of the mass, and his power is underestimated. Please, help us. Most of population here is much more ignorant than we can imagine. My english ins't so good but war is coming in here and we have to powered our connections to other countries. USA sabotaged our space program and nuclear program, and of course the US government is behind some aspects of the Bolsonaro's election and the media interference. Most of people don'r now what to do and the right wing here keep rising and practicing acts of violence of any kind. #tearsfrombrazil
In just over a couple of weeks this man will turn 90. What a lucid mind he possesses. Long may he live.
I will weep the day Noam dies and go into mourning for quite some time. It is interesting that this great man is ignored by academia and main stream media. As Jesus said a prophet is not acknowledged in his home town. In fact they are hated, scorned, mocked and ridiculed. I love this man and all he stands for. Another great man is Ralph Nader and the same treatment is meted out to him as well.
@d birkin how so?
Wooord. Ma man👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Ameen!
No, he has scum in his head because he loves the prisioner Lula, who promoted the worse things to Brazil
Thank you for this. Rare voices of sanity in the media.
Chomsky is so generous with his time. The fact that he's also the most sane and rational person, when speaking about politics, nationally is a gigantic added bonus. He'll be 90 in a month. We have to somehow hope we can save his brain and sacrifice Jared Kushner to keep Chomsky alive for another 90 years. At least.
He has been blacklisted from regular media outlets for decades. Speaking truth to power gets that done quickly.
He is completely out of touch with reality. There are so many dimensions to the topic under discussion, and Chomsky doesn't see them.
@@TropicalCoder Such as...?
@@lsobrien Brazil has been mired in corruption and violence for decades. Over 60,000 people murdered each year, more than were killed in the entire Vietnam war. Corruption at every level of government, municipal, state, and federal. All this growing violence and corruption under Lula's party, the PT (workers party). Lule himself enjoyed the highest approval level in the polls ever seen in a modern democracy. He could have joined together others of goodwill and tackled the corruption head on. Instead, he became the centre of it. Chomsky calls the downfall of the PT a "soft coup". Couldn't be further from the truth. Dilma Rousseff, (Lula's prodigy and the last President) was impeached with a 2/3 senate majority. Senators from a variety of political backgrounds voted in a clearly democratic process. To call that a "coup" is a grave insult to the Brazilian government and its Constitution. Brazil needs a strong leader right now or it is finished. The economy has been in a tailspin. Inflation rampant. Interest rates soaring. The currency, the Brazilian Real is worth less than 25 cents to the US Dollar. Bolsonaro has made many comments that have been taken out of context. Yes there are many concerns, especially concerning the Amazon. I hope he doesn't go through with that. But on the balance, Bolsonaro is just what Brazil needs right now. Chomsky sees it all through his far Left lenses, and sees none of the nuance.
During the times of slavery in Brazil, there used to a powerful landowner in the Northeast. He was a Field Marshal and held the title of Baron. One day, he had a guest over for a feast. As the man entered his house, he complimented a female slave, saying she had beautiful breasts. After the feast was over, it was time for the guest to leave, but the Baron had a surprise for him: the slave's severed breasts on a silver plate.
The Brazilian elite has always been vicious, ruthless, heartless and sadistic. Slaves were buried alive and rich farmer's wives sharpened the teeth of female slaves using knives so the Master couldn't use them for oral sex anymore. Quartering poor people could be a national sport. The rich in Brazil would rather kill everyone than to give up their land, and the vicious cycle of income inequality continues (2% of landowners own half of the country's land).
Something need to be done about that
Yes, those are TRUE stories as I saw in another video about slavery.
@Ares Vicious Idiota, burro
Slavery is over. And give up their land to who? MTST? hahahah Yes, they should kill indeed, that's their property.
You are generalizing the rich. But you cry when the right generalizes muslims.
This program is priceless! Keep up the good work. ❤️
@d birkin yikes Nazi
I'm from Brazil and they said shit.
It's almost as bad as CNN focusing on the no no words he's said rather than his actions.
It's depressing that no administration has ever hired him as an advisor
Only fake news did/do it.
Doodelay Explains you can have all the answers to what ails humanity, but it means little if no one listens..
Doodle.
........depressing but all too understandable.
The political "debate" especially amongst the American working classes is controlled by the likes of the Murdoch Media Machine through the propaganda outlets of fxnews.
@@72marshflower15 yes, and it was Chomsky's life which taught me this fact. I don't want to be like him, a deep geopolitical genius without the ability or willingness to lead movements. Better to be less knowledgeable and active, than a genius with no force.
Doodelay Explains touché... however, and to the contrary, Chomsky has helped entire generations figure out things no one else could. hes given the chance to millions to help effect positive change for humanity and life over all.
true collectives only work where no one individual nature is predominant over the collective whole. per laws of the universe, he's effectively forbidden to project the information he understands... he can only share it. and for the record, id prefer to walk with others, and not necessarily lead all the time..
alpha/omega need not always lead..
reflect it.. dont project it
😘
p.s. ..i helped write/create the blue wave and more... no one will ever know who or what i am.. no one will ever come forward to gain recognition for what is at hand. you may be grateful for it later, so never underestimate the power of anyone trying..
aroha from fissure 8, Havvaii... 🌊🌊🌊🌴🌴🌋🌴🌴🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊
🤗
Noam Chomsky is a national treasure.
International treasure
@d birkin Soros is a neo-liberal pos. Chomsky is a brilliant free thinker. You child.
@d birkinYou simpleton. He is NOT a communist. Feeble mind. Sad.
No, he likes the biggest criminal in Brazil's history, this man is a fraud. Need to get religion, too much lier
@@johnmulligan455 Ex-president Lula, made the biggest corruption scandal in the world's histoy. Criminality growed up, pooverty too, corruption, inneficience, lies, scandals, support to dictatorships, Marxism in schools, compromised freedom of speech and press. Used mooney to buy congress and the supreme court and used gramscism to fuck all
Have a wealthy friend in Brazil he says that there is no middle class. Just rich and poor. Let that sink in... cause that is what trump is doing.... and because of this forced and greedy disparately people can’t drive down streets with windows open because mistreated and deprived people tend to want and need to stay alive are forced into stealing to remain alive... good quality of life actually not good for either. Greed is a deadly sin. For rich and poor
I am middle class. I'm Brazilian.
I am middle class. I'm Brazilian
Cry more leftist worm!
I agree, . people are forced to become criminals , to kill and Rob in order to eat, under socialism there is no crime , because there is no property, listen to Chomsky he is a Professor at MIT and the top intellectual in the US. I bet you right wingers have never been to university and learnt about socialism
Bartô N How would you describe the Brazilian Middle Class ? And in Comparison to Americas ?
I am thankful, that my age results in the reality that I likely have fewer years ahead of me than I have decades behind. I really don't want to see the new world corporacratic order that is being built come to fruition.
The world will soon to be far more frightening than anything we have ever imagined in our worst nightmares, and the advent of its dystopia will be cheered on by the very people who will be most hurt by the compassion's demise.
So Brazilian citizens have some difficult years ahead of them. When right-wing economic policies are implemented, things go bad pretty quickly. As a bonus, they will regress socially too.
Oh yes because the 16 years of leftist economy have been great so far ! It's not even the worst recession in Brazilian economic history !
@@VictorSilva-qf2tu vc é de esquerda ou direita?
@@nlin6864 direita. B17 😎👉👉
@@VictorSilva-qf2tu So that's your hunch I guess. You could also just look at actual economic stats. Look at economic growth between 2000 and 2012. That's what progressive policies result in. The reason is obvious; if more people have money, aggregate demand increases.
@@gustav4539 the problem is socialism always works in the beginning. Until the money runs out. The government distributed money in social programs in a unsustainable rate for years plus all the mega corruption scandals resulted in huge debts and unemployment. It's always like this.
At the three minute mark you can see, to the left of Paulo Guedes, the judge (and future justice minister) Sergio Moro who jailed Bolsonaro's chief rival before the election, thus practically guaranteeing Bolsonaro's win.
He is literally going to destroy the planet by destroying the Amazon.
No seu mundo imaginário né coração
@@seuamiguinho4497
que você não acredita em mudanças climáticas
Claro que vai destruir... Aliás, quantos porcento ainda existe da floresta pra ele destruir? Porque o pico de desflorestamento foi justamente nos últimos anos do Lula e nos primeiros da Dilma...
Tem um monte de estrangeiros esquerdistas querendo opinar sobre o Brasil , sempre com os mesmos argumentos , ain fascista e bla bla bla , na moral isso já ta me enchendo o saco .
@Bartô N Hahahaha eu q digo isso , se a sua opinião e as dos gringos valessem alguma coisa , o Bolsonaro não seria eleito , agora chora huehuehuehue !
This guy legitimately looks evil in every picture Ive seen of him. How are these guys actually elected by the populace?
Lula was first place in surveys, the first in popularity, and loved by the people but the fascist rigthwinged buy judges, police and media and with persecution and Lawfare stopped Lula from politics fabricating false corruption against Lula, so the second and only option was Bolsonaro and obviously won without Lula who is suppressed on false corruption. Actually this modus operandi strategy the Lawfare is being applied all over South and Central America.
I also have no idea. I have to hear stuff from his supporters that “he is the savior”, “he is the messiah sent from god”.
It looks like a complete brainwash!
Ben Does Dabs- How old are you? 5 years old? Hahaha Brazilians voted in him, because we are tired of the socialism in our country.
It didn't worked, if you read our news you'll see it. ( not fake news, actually is better you interview the people who live here, we dont want to be another Venezuela or Bolivia, the socialists wanted to transform all the south America in a communist block, and thanks God, the people awake).
@@nlin6864 all you can do is attack the left that doesn't mean what bolsonaro is offering is good. Lol smh nice try tho
Very well said. And here in Brazil they accuse me of being misinformed for not informing me only through the local media.
One wonders what planet that these people plan to move to.
The rise of stupidity all around the world is alarming.
Maybe it's just you who is stupid enough to support socialism.
thanks noam and dn
Time to stop warning and start bracing.
Disaster is inevitable.
We aren't all going to get out of it alive.
Fear. Fear! You guys are hilarious. Go outside.
@@p0llenp0ny hope it's nice & painful for ya ;)
Chomsky's disapearance in the Venezuelan dicatorship humanitarian catastrophe is very sad. He should and had an obligation to come out publicly condemning it.
Noam Chomsky answers emails, so never let anyone tell you they were too busy to reply.
Dictators and investors oh my!!!
US servants for sure. USA was the boss in the time of military coup d'etat in Brazil.
I consider this just as one of the many symptoms of the American foreign policy.
Very reductionist of you.
As the world burns ....
In a free market system you vote with your dollar.
Boycott all Brazilian products that come from the Amazon.
HE COME ALONG WHEN BRAZILIAN PEOPLE`S ANGRY INCREASED HIGHER LEVEL IN ALL TIME.
Brazil is disgraced by Bolsonaro, Guedes and Moro.
#lulaisapoliticalprisoner
#lulaconvictedandarrestedthiefitsfact
Vai ler o processo analfabeta funcional.
❤Bolsonaro❤Trump❤Salvini❤
#FREELULA NOW
O LULA TÁ PRESO, BABACA!
Pau no cu do Lula now and forever
LULA É TEU CU CRIA VERGONHA NESSA CARA
Lendo as respostas hidrófobas ao seu comentário percebe-se o nível mental e moral dos eleitores do Führer tupiniquim. Free Lula Now.
@@demonioamarelo1064 É ne, o ídolo do Bolsonaro tá mais para o Ronald Reagan e o do Haddad é o Stálin
Chomsky's manner of speaking has this magical, and maddening, effect of lulling the listner to distraction with it's inflectioness, gravelly murmur.
We are going to see martial law in Brazil if the people rise up and try to stop bolsanaro
" try to stop"?? I mean they just elected him with a huge margin
You are out of your mind Zack Sherman!!! Brazil is bankrupt and was on the edge of the communism deep, slippery and dark precipice. Most of the media is infiltrated by gays, lesbians and communists (personally I got nothing against anyone's sexual fettiches, but this ridiculous apologies for the LGBT's to the point of forcing the "public schools" to indocrinate children as early as 6 years of age, is just fucking pathetic!!!).
Bolsonaro is a Christian and a family man who has enough balls to do what needs to be done!!!
I suggest that you should try to learn what is really going on before you open your mouth.
I don't like and don't agree with Bolsonaro, but he got the majority of the votes, so unless he does something unconstitutional, why should people stop him? In a democracy sometimes the most voted is not the one that represent us. We have to give whoever wins, the benefit of the doubt, if we can. I don't like Trump either but he won the elections and as a citizen in a democratic society, I have to accept him even if I can't stand him. Now if he does something unconstitutional, then I will rise up.
@@Thinkingisallowed, Brazil is a country where an "acessorista" (elevator driver), yes! They still exist in some government buildings, make 4 times as much as a teacher, also any Senator, ministry or judge chauffeur will earn outrageous salaries (they have to be well paid and they do keep their mouths shut), I live in Brasilia, "the corruption capital of the planet" and I know how it is!!! What drives me nuts are people that have never set foot in Brazil, don't know it's culture and "feel like" writing down their clever opinion here.
Sigh, wat happened Brazil...?
Take care of yrself, Prof Chomsky Sir.
Chomsky is almost 90 and he can still do two chicks at once.
Gross.
@@p0llenp0ny Sense of humor, no?
Respectfully, and yet you don't seem to ask why Brazilians voted for the candidate who made it to the runoff opposite PT's candidate. Lula is not a political prisoner. Anyone who says so is greatly misinformed. One should acknowledge the role of Lula and his allies in the very rise of such a controversial character. It's hard to believe someone like Chomsky would choose to be fed his 'facts' from only one side of the political spectrum. I suspect Brazilians would have elected any candidate, had they made it to the second round. We just wanted out of anything to do with Lula and PT. Their unsustainable policies have not reduced poverty or inequality. They did not invest in basic education. They were and have been ahead of and behind the greatest corruption scheme ever conducted in Brazil. I did not vote for Bolsonaro, but I refuse to adhere to naysayers and I chose to believe that some good will come out of the next 4 years. Unlike Lula, the president elect has no intention to run for a second term. I also wonder how you all react when people who have never lived in your country express their opinions as if they really could know what is best for you.
Congratulations! Lula is a fraud.
Orange Man Bad
😡 🚶 👎
Let's keep any potential racism out of this. That is one of Amy's divide and conquer tactics. HOWEVER; paedophiles and rapists are fair game (what's up John Podesta and B.Clinton? )
Thank you, Prof. Chomsky! Thank you, Democracy Now! Speaking truth to power and to the world may be the only way left against global fascism...
Foi visitar um criminoso condenado ok..mas temos que temer o Bolsonaro?kkk
Criminoso para quem?
Criminoso para a Globo; herói para o povo. De que lado da História você gostaria de ficar? De milhares de intelectuais de todas as áreas, dos movimentos sociais, ou de um bando de entreguistas, corruptos e mentirosos? Do lado do governante que tirou 40 milhões da pobreza ou de quem perpetua a miséria no Brasil?
Escolha difícil? Acho que não, para qualquer pessoa sensata ou minimamente decente.
@@demonioamarelo1064 Demonio Amarelo Criminoso para a Justiça. Os únicos que saíram da pobreza foi a família do Lula, nossa economia foi pro ralo e nossa moeda quase não vale o papel que está impressa. O Brasil votou e mostrou que está cansado , chora mais que seu líder tá preso e os aliados dele ao redor do mundo estão mortos ou num buraco igual ele. Ninguém mais quer comunismo não, se quiser foge pra Cuba ou Coreia do Norte, os paraísos da Terra em liberdade, saúde, economia e qualidade de vida.
@Aline Santos É pena que você não aprecie uma boa cachaça. Quanto à corrupção, o governo que está aí e o eleito são recordistas nisso. Sobre o Lula: diga quanto ele roubou ou quanto ele entregou a ditaduras "comunistas".
Você deveria saber que não houve comunismo no mundo (e não defendo o comunismo, diga-se de passagem). Eric Hobsbawn demonstra que, se você troca uma elite empresarial por uma de burocratas, o privilégio permanece. O que você chama, sem base alguma, comunismo, ele chama capitalismo de Estado.
E Lula não foi entreguista, os fatos desmentem você: A Petrobrás deu tanto lucro, e estatal, que se pôde separar uma vultuosa parte desse lucro para investimento em educação. O Brasil se livrou do FMI e guardou reservas. As empresas e os bancos nunca faturaram tanto, e 40 milhões de pessoas esquecidas por todos os governos saíram da miséria.
Brasileiro ou brasileira que ofende quem fez bem ao país e protege bandidos e entreguistas, pior, com argumento caquético de guerra fria de "comunistas", não sabe o que está falando, repete ladainha de propaganda sem base factual. E a sua fala tem só ódio e preconceito pesadões.
@@JatVik Ok. Vamos começar, selecionando cada uma das partes da sua sopa de loucura.
1) Lula vivia uma vida modesta para um ex-presidente, ainda no mesmo apartamento em que vivia no ABC. Diferente de outros, com os quais você não parece preocupado.
2) Nossa economia não foi para o ralo, ao contrário: com a presidente Rousseff o Brasil chegou a ser a sexta economia do planeta, ultrapassando a Grã-Bretanha, e quando Rousseff sofreu o golpe de Estado em 2016 o Brasil tinha reservas de mais de 300 bilhões de dólares. Por favor, informe-se melhor.
3) Os aliados de Lula não estão nem mortos nem num buraco como o dele, porque outros países ainda têm o que se chama (talvez você desconheça o termo) civilização. Pepe Mujica, que foi preso por uma ditadura, está livre e é um herói no Uruguai; François Hollande (ex-presidente da França), Rodriguez Zapatero (ex-presidente da Espanha) e três ex-primeiros ministros da Itália, todos livres, porque honestos como Lula, o defendem contra a (in)justiça brasileira; Noam Chomsky, um dos maiores intelectuais vivos, defende Lula; Luigi Ferrajoli, grande jurista italiano, criticou o processo de Lula e a Lava Jato; Chico Buarque e mais milhares de intelectuais e artistas o defendem; o papa Francisco o defende; três prêmios Nobel da Paz o defendem; milhares e milhares de cartas de brasileiros continuam chegando à Polícia Federal. Você está REDONDAMENTE errado sobre o que fala, e não parece entender os fatos do que é uma prisão política.
Você já ouviu falar de Martin Luther King? De Nelson Mandela? Das injutiças históricascontraesses líderes populares reverenciados, hoje, no mundo todo? Talvez você esteja fazendo o mesmo no Brasil. Eu acho que sim.
4) O que Lula fez, assim como Dilma Rousseff, se chama capitalismo. Comunismo é quando privilégios não existem, especulação financeira não existe, e o que se produz é dividido igualmente por todo o povo, com um governo rigorosamente popular.
Nos anos de governo do PT as empresas tiveram lucro, variaram suas atividades, os bancos privados tiveram grandes lucros, havia competição no mercado, especulação financeira na bolsa de valores, e o país era governado por uma coalizão de partidos de centro-esquerda, democraticamente, com a direita fazendo oposição dentro do Congresso.
Não diga bobagem. Você claramente não tem idéia do que é comunismo, e, pior, não tem nem um iota de idéia do que é capitalismo, que você, suponho, pretende defender.
5) Não há paraísos na Terra: há esforços de civilização. Cuba e Coréia do Norte, sobre o que você também demonstra saber nada, são dois tipos de governo completamente diferentes, com resultados também diversos. Governos não são puros de bem e mal, e devem ser criticados e apoiados, igualmente, quando fazem besteira ou algo bom.
De modo demonstrável, os anos de governo do PT foram os melhores que o país já teve: democráticos, estabilizadores da economia, com diplomacia independente e forte, marcando o Brasil como potência da América do Sul no equilíbrio de questões internacionais, guardaram reservas vultuosas, livraram o Brasil do FMI, tiraram mais de 40 milhões de pessoas da miséria, etc.
Você não gosta nem aprova nada disso?
Não tem problema:
Agora você tem o governo que pediu aos céus: governo que entrega todas as riquezas naturais do Brasil para empresas estrangeiras, e a preço de banana; governo que atrela sua diplomacia como escrava de potência estrangeira, para ajudar a espalhar violência pelo mundo; governo que destrói os direitos de carteira assinada do trabalhador e doa seu trabalho escravo para os ricos; governo que congela investimento social por 20 anos, produzindo caos em um país emergente, que lutava contra as desigualdades e injustiças; que leva o desemprego ao mais alto ponto em dez anos, e produzirá ainda mais desempregados; que joga o povo brasileiro na miséria de novo, com a quantidade de mendigos crescendo três vezes nas regiões metropolitanas, e devolvendo o Brasil ao mapa da fome; que já entrega bases militares para potência estrangeira, e a Amazônia ao desmatamento das madeireiras, produzindo a pior situação já vista no meio ambiente.
Preconceituoso, violento, ignorante, entreguista. Aí está. Fique feliz, seu governo é esse aí, meus parabéns.
@@demonioamarelo1064 Textão legal, mas o Lula e a Dilma estão cagando pra você, é impressionante ver que você acredita nisso, mas enfim, a Justiça deu sua palavra e o povo também. Brasil acima de tudo, Deus de todos e Lula no colo do Capeta.
This is the kind of Captain America I could also call a hero.
Good reporting. One interesting thing is that when Americans speaks about Brazil, always put Latin America, connecting to Nicaragua, Chile, Bolivia... etc.. Brazil is like an own continent and it has a completely different size, culture, language, politics, history and economy in comparison with our neighbors. So I think when analyse Brazil and Brazilian in general, cannot include in this Latin America, Latino basket, but as Brazil/Brazilians only.
Bozo, as he is called by his oppositors, once was invited to talk to an audience in a club for jews. When he arrived he was booed by protestors in the outside.
When he was in there talking, he said "Have you ever seen a japanese begging? They are a people who have self-respect. One people who has no self-respect is those people who were out there booing me".
Once an brazilian indigenous leader went to the capital to protest against some actions from him and he said "He says he is an indian. If he were really an indian he wouldn't be here, he would be in the woods, eating grass.".
I really like Chomsky's analyses in general, and I think, as a Brazilian also, that Bolsonaro is abominable, but this time Chomsky committed the sin the left wing accuses the right of committing so often. His analysis of Brazil is mainly coming from the most dubious source of all, the instance's political victim.
He's even buying into the fairy tale Lula tells about his appartment; of course, it's not registered as his, because, as his crooked ingenuity had planned, all of Lula's wealth is spread among his relatives and friends. Lula was the overseer of a corruption industry never before seen here nor anywhere else; at the very least, he should be in prison for life for being an accomplice.
As for Dilma, the so-called coup d'état, though questionable, was mostly legit, as she did in fact distort numbers to achieve her goals, and there is a law that forbids the president of doing so. The problem was that no other president had been charged with that law, as it is so broad. Anyway, in my opinion, she should have been impeached from sheer incompetence; it's a pity there is no law against this surely useless trait -- she is also the author of the legendary quote: "we should (*literally*) store the wind, it would be valuable technology".
Lastly, the sin that bugs me the most about this whole analysis is the blind idealization of the years the PT party was in power. Truthfully, we experienced a lot of progress and I think that the demonization of that era which spreading like an epidemy will be most regrattable for us. But the PT party built a country on sand: the investments would be severely cut off due to corruption (in some cases, we could have built twice the infrastructure, do you know what 2 schools or 2 hospitals instead of 1 mean?); the education and poverty indexes would get distorted make-ups; and a party who supposedly deffended the workers and the poor would allocate the biggest development bank's fund mostly for giant corporations which didn't need any of the money at all.
Now, tell me, as a journalist or political scientist, will you ever hear the full story by going into the prison cell of the overseer of the biggest, most publicly institutionalized corruption industry of Brazil's history and arguably the world?
1st US and now Brazil, it's really fascinating but also a shame that a country's majority elects someone that troughout the whole campaign has shown no sign of being able to even control their mouth. I mean, these guys may be smart (or not, you decide) but a guy who speaks and acts like an angry teen should not run for office.
Acho que a REDE GLOBO não vai jamais entrevistar este Americano. Só uma teoria!
A Rede Globo gostava é de entrevistar Lula e vários outros que estão presos. Ah, a "impeachmentada" também.
Chomsky isnt even a Political Scientist. He is a linguist. How the hell is he so knowledgeable on worldwide government and history. americans would never even consider voting for him for any office.
Media once more prioritizing the spectacle rather than the truth. As a brazilian, I urge for news makers to dive a little bit deeper on what is really going in Brazil before uttering their vision of the apocalyptic future of my country, when even the renowned Noam Chomsky has no idea of what is going on you can see how far we’ve gone. It‘s only naive to think that a socialistic reform, Noam Chomsky rule of thumb, seems appropriate regardless of the country‘s context, unfortunately in Brazil no political class has shown integrity to preserve power and we fall back to institutions like the military, a cheap shot indeed but definitely better than betting on the workers party who has sabotaged the country for over a decade!
Using an american saying to quote an american flaw:
„It’s easy to see without looking to far“
Lula Livre!Free Lula!🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹-Lula é
PRESO POLÍTICO e sofre BRUTAL caçada policial e judicial e condenação política e é preso político!Lula Livre!❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
but also what can you expect from an evangelical?
the more religion in government, the greater the atrocities against people, rights and the environment, even if this is what they (religious fanatics) do best.
The misery of Brazil is that it has always been considered a marginal child, for first world countries like the USA. but you have always preferred to help and negotiate with europe, australia, canada, japan. This is a fact
The United States only remembered Brazil at the time to take advantage of releasing credit cards here.
United States has always seen Brazil as an unwanted South American, an unfit country, a colony to be exploited.
I fully accept that he is a madman swept away that naod everia be there, but is it that the United States is not at fault in this? this son tries to mirror his father, and this father (United States) is by the way given very bad examples.
And a country with great social differences, it is a racist country, it is a country that has no interest in changing its philosophy of war, it is a country that was once a country scientifically evolved but now it is a factory of negationists, the forests of you exist still? How are the deposits gone, are they over? or have they started mining Alaska as well?
see I'm not saying that this new government is correct, far from it, I'd rather have a thousand times see a right as the candidate of the "new" party Joao amoedo in government, but to do what? the influence of the united states is not limited to the politicians here, you have badly influenced an entire nation, and the bolsonaro was the result. unfortunately, we hope that they do not destroy everything until the next elections. if you want changes in your children, you should start cleaning your own house.
GREAT Chomsky!!!
Chomsky is like that, gets lost in fallacies.
As a brazilian I can't wait to suffer the effects of Bolsonaro's actions, imagine that everybody starving because rain stopped years ago....
Actually fascism is socialism because in. Fascism the state control on private company CEO and that why socialism lead to to dictator ship as a matter of fact the nazi were socialist and Stalin was socialist ,every dictator ship in world was socialist . Capitalism mean freedom of economy and state can't control the economy which make government only job is to protect the people right , when government cannot control the economy it become week and president cannot be dictatorship. When government control the Economy as what happen in socialism it become strong and that lead to dictatorship like in Venezuela
S Falck worker control over the means of production is communism ,because when we say worker it's misleading word you mean government, I'm from Iraq the same sentence your are using said by albath party which the party of Saddam Hussein ,and it was socialist party even its name was albath Arabian socialist party , and when they gain power they control over country recourses and oil and every private company because in in order for worker to control over the mean of production the government in the name of worker control over private company and oil this lead to Saddam dicatorship and poverty ,by the why the nazi party was socialist part and when they gain power lead to hitler dictatorship and that why in the binging of ww2 they were in agreement with the communist which were also socialist, the nazis fund a some car companies and convert them into military companies , they didn't allow them to work because they believe in free market ,they allow they to work because they deliver them with weapons they need for wars ,you forget to mention that under the nazis the people were gathering in long line for breads because in the name of farmers the government control on farms and on food which lead to massive starvation and farmer being slave for state ,basher alasad of Syria is socialist and his party which also name albath party like Iraq albath party is also socialist,the same for mao of china ,and most of tyranny of world . Fascism mean state private company but control on their manger , in capitalism which mean free economy which mean the state cannot control economy it impossible to have fascism or dictator ship because state cannot control economy and the only job for state is protecting freedom and rights of individual ,the founding father of united state know that ,thats why the establish the united state based on capitalism and that what make us rich country ,that why you see the wealthy county in world are capitalist state like Singapore and Luxembourg and Switzerland and hong Kung which have little recourses and great economy ,and contrast to that the poorest countries in world with huge recesses like Iraq which has huge reserve of oil but its poor country because of socialism, also Venezuela,and most countries of Africa and any country who adopted socialism end up either dictator ship of poverty or even worst it could end up in killing millions of people like what happen in ussr or china under mao rule , the socialism has destroy my country , be aware usa you are living in mixed economy and their is more and more socialism are coming . Sadly to see that USA this great country which was capitalist now turning into mixed economy and turning more and more into socialism
He is so wrong about Chile. Sorry Progres. but im chilean and the "chicago boys" saved our economy, we didnt have the tools to industrilize ourselfs (yes, thank u colonialism) and we HAD to privatize most of our economy to run the machine.
Not used to this, when it comes from Noam Chomsky.
The brazilian problem is very complex, PT had 14 years on power, the judicial cases of Oderbrecht, lavajato and Petrobras have incarcerated tons of PT elements for high level corruption, to an extent that it is virtually Impossible that the former leaders Lula and Dilma couldnt know of it.
Lula had an astonishing social success in his first mandate, it was a good mandate but then PT robbed the country blind, the level of corruption is absolutely incredible, a communist party that have tons of people in Jail, from ministers to secretaries to treausry department...its unbelievable.
Combine this with a economic disgrace for years and 60.000 homicidas/year...its ready to burst.
Bolsonaro wont solve anything, he's an opportunistic ignorant and a moron, but that's the present legacy of todays democratic parties, they get tons of years in power and they leave a residue of corruption, ill gotten gains and economic decline, an increase between the 1% and the others and a feeling of perpetuation of the same bullshit and THEN they feel surprised when people vote in despair because they are sick of it.
Note: The brazilian regions where the more cultured and literate people live voted massively in Bolsonaro, this election cant be pinned on the "less culturally formed".
Love to hear Prof. Chomsky but this subject is far more complex than these 14 min told, it paints a very misleading picture.
YET BRAZILIANS VOTED FOR BOLSONARO, (AS IS COSTUMERY TO VOTE FOR CHANGE, WHICH IS LABELED PROGRESS).
WHEN IN FACT THE ONLY PROGRESS EVIDENT IS IN MILITARY ESTABLISHMENTS SPENDING AND THE PARTNERSHIP BETWEEN THE WEALTHY POLITICIANS AND THE OLIGHARCS.
I love when Amy says "talk about".
The most important prisoner in the world is Julian Assange, Lula second. You losing your touch my beloved hero Chomsky
Profeta.
the most Malicious and vicius creatures in the current range of ugly characters that we seen around the world.. Is an accurate description by professor Chomsky
Interesting that he does not mention about the corruption and how PT almost broke the country. The agro-business is in Amazon area for decades and it had increased its presence during the last 15 years. Bolsonaro was a terrible option, but he represented the population response to PT. Unfortunately, better options could not be elected.
That's a sad thing to see.
Can you get Chomsky to go on the Jimmy Dore show please , show support for your fellow progressive indi media.
This is hard to watch. Not just depressing. It's hard to listen to soft spoken, Noam Chomsky, being yelled at by an interviewer who assumes he's deaf.
Thing is with the likes of Bolsonaro, Duterte etc they differ from the compliant fascist juntas America backed in the Cold War, which basically amounted to Bourgeois Republics rather than fascist regimes.
Such Juntas represented no international threat, they were just in the business of preserving capitalism on behalf of themselves and their American backers.
So de facto fascism represents something new in developing countries, and something unpredictable. Something akin to the growth of nationalism in Germany, Italy and Japan in the early 20th century. Nationalism that will err toward militarism and expansion.
Basically, the kind of reactionary capitalism that will inevitably come into conflict with the established capitalist powers.
Oh look, 14 months ago. :(
Amazonia never more..
And what has the pseudo Left and Chomsky in particular done in the last 50 years? They haven’t done shit.
Always a crazy party when Noam stops by
They were all toetured by their fathers to become what we see and hear today
Visited LULA in prison?????
Marxist love and support their fellow comrades
Social Media as Noam mentioned briefly is a powerful tool for manipulating the popular vote in every nation....people need to really diversify their information resources for a rounded understanding and sadly this failure results in group think and tragic outcomes
LIve watching Democracy Now? aka "Leftist propaganda"
Dear Mr. Chomsky, never in the history of Brazil , the Amazon was as much destroyed as during Lulas and Dilmas regime. If you are consequent you would criticize them too. The debt is also because of Lulas corruption. The Chicago Boys did not teach Lula to steal
Bolsonaro is the worst that could happen to Brazil. These are really scary times.
I’m no huge Lula fan but he must be freed Brazil must end this coop
When you visit Lula you lose all credibility! !
Bolsonaro is very smart, as smart as a door knob.
It would be very nice if you would be as critical with Maduro and the Havanna boys
Communists and criminals go hand in hand,
so sad to hear a linguist stuttering so much to say a phrase...
Mr. Chomsky, just admit you don't understand what''s happening here in Brasil. In fact, I must say it, without being superb, that no one outside Brasil is able to understand whats's going on here. Because it's a hard situation and also because it's difficult to find an honest source of information.
Do you guys believe in Lula!?
Do you believe in Bolsonaro?
There is more then enough evidence to conclude that he is innocent.
Lula is just a criminal character. All due process of law was followed in his JudgmentS.
He was unanimously condemned in two instances of Brazilian justice, by at least 4 judges, simple like that.
It is odd how the 'interviewer' tries to conduct the interview demonizing her opposite beliefs.
The amazons are the lungs of the earth once they get chopped down we’re all doomed
Damnit. I actually really want to listen to this, but Chomsky is talking so painstakingly slow
It's really hard to have hope in times like this. And I think this is exactly the sort of mindset that allows people like Jair Bolsonaro to rise to power. As a Brazilian I'm terrified but also lacking any resemblance of hope for better times.
Well, you got your fascist back. You made your bed(grave), lie in it.
Germans have an electric car 18k$? Sion ..ha
I don’t know if Bolsonaro is good or bad, but his face reflects a lot of anger and hate.
He's not only bad, he's EVIL.
Noam Chomsky, my favorite communist!
Fidel Castro is my favorite communist, or maybe El Che.
@d birkin I thought he was your favorite communist, buttercup.
The thing is a lot of humans hate poor people. Rich people hate the poor, the middle class hate the poor and the poor hate the poor. I was once in the airport and there were a lot of people there. I heard one guy saying that brazilian airports had turned into a buss station ever since the plane tickets had been popularized... People are happier to earn $7 when everybody else is earning $5 instead of every single one earning $9.
Tell me this guy isn't a template for Trump!!!😒
You did your hair!
dissident LOL google a film BRAZIL IS NOT COPACABANA and watch it = only 20 min. saves you the trip and the drivel
Bolsonaro will accelerate demise of capitalism. "Thanks man" Young Marx 😂
Last time a country listened to Marx, more people died then Hiroshima and Nagasaki combined
A marxist that lives on capitalism. You are pathetic.
@Sázhe M. Epifanne Communism by far, but if you think capitalism is so mean then run away to North Korea
@Sázhe M. Epifanne It's so pathetic to complain about capitalism on a capitalist platform through a capitalist device
@Sázhe M. Epifanne "Poor me, what an evil world, I'm a victim of an oppressive system, pity me, bla bla bla ..."
Now I understando how media can be deceiving, even it means not to be.
And this Noam Chomsky is a college professor? Ask for your money back kids!!! All the information he got from the criminal. So maybe you should go to the prisons in the US and talk to the criminals, if they say they are innocent you let them go.
guys remember this video and the comments in this section because in a few months or years you'll see how much Brazil will grow. just wait for it
Chicago school economics transfers wealth upwards - to people who own stocks and bonds. The rich will get richer and the poor will get poorer. A crystal ball is not needed to know this outcome. The results are the same in every country that Chicago school economics is implemented.
Who are the Chicago boys ?
There's a lot of stupid people in the comments section. I feel sorry for them. (And they vote, that's the problem)
I am Brazilian, I love and admire Mr.Chomsky and I agree that Bolsonaro will be a catastrophe, but, in this case, Bolsonaro will be only following the steps of Lula who was also a catastrophe. There is still time to learn that Left and Right are two hands of the same sick body.
Not true. Bolsonaro is a tragedy, Lula's was the best period of Brazilian life and democracy.
@knowledge share Wrong on both accounts. Next.
@@demonioamarelo1064 you forgot about the Empire.
@@felipedesaxe-coburgogotha7669 You are really insane - which is a good excuse for your ridiculous nonsense - or simply a funny troll.
What a joke!
This is fucking insane. Free lula
You dont know what Lula did, you just repeat what Lula tells you, thats not very professional
Antichrist!