I always love when people remember Smudge! The idea of him joining the Clans always intrigues me, and I loce the direction you took him in! (Dustpaw going to apologize is also really cute)
I love this AU! I feel that Smudge is often times forgotten after a couple of books, and I've seen lots of AU's of him being evil, joining Tiny, being jealous of Rusty, or just... Lonely and depressed. I love that this shakes it up where he still has his own story that blends well with canon events, without him turning evil, annoying or just being super sad. He has his own adventure at his own pace and gets to ask himself what he truly wants in life, rather than taking the word of others and letting it scare him, like believing the forest was full of cats that would eat him, or that his friend abandoned him. That said I was wondering to myself why I had never seen this and how old it was, and I realized it was posted on my bday earlier this year and that the TH-cam algorithm failed me. Curse you, TH-cam, for hiding a wonderful video with pretty art!
@@SmudgeWC Well I'd love to see it if you make and release it! From memory (It's been many, many years since I read a book with Smudge in it, lol.) he was a really sweet character, honestly worried about his friend's choice to live with the wild cats. I remember him always being excited when Fireheart rolled around, and it's not that he wasn't supportive, it just seems like he had that "Are you SURE?" approach just because he didn't want Rusty/Fireheart to hurt. I love this timid yet careful approach as he tries to do what's right. ;3; It's a pretty big contrast to Fireheart who was always a bit gung-ho for adventure and fearless. They're both doing similar things but in their own ways. (I loved the detail with Dustpaw too, considering he and Firepaw REALLY didn't get along, lol.)
You're the only one talking about that! I made that detail in his design remembering that Fire and Scourge are half-brothers, so I'm glad you mentioned it 💖
I LOVE THIS AHAGHAGHAHGH Also I'm so glad he saw Spottedleaf as a mother rather than a crush! I mean, SHE WAS OLD ENOUGH TO BE FIREPAW'S GRANDMOTHER---
I bet when Fireheart and Graystripe kicked out Brokenstar and rescued Cinder, Thorn, Bracken and Bright and were named warriors earlier, Spotpaw must have been *really* jealous
two things I realy like about this. First: I like this au Idea and what it could tern into. Second: I like how your youtuber name is just smudge. I like it alot.
Spot and Ravenpaw never had romantic feelings (if that's what you mean). What's more, although they trained together, they did not form a friendship (they talked to each other and got along well, but not to the point of considering themselves friends)
Great work!! This PMV is very well put together, I do have a few questions related to the AU. 1. So, does Firepaw (Rusty) come with Smudge (Spotpaw) to Thunderclan? Or is Smudge replacing Rusty in this situation? 2. Are they both apart of the prophecy and if so, what roles do they play in it? Does Firepaw still become leader? 3. Is Firepaw an antagonist? I'm asking because his face seemed to be blackened around 0:33. Or is that just Smudge feeling like Firepaw wouldn't understand, or doesn't care what he's going through? (And yes, for that one commenter, I did see the description explaining this AU, I just didn't understand it all that much)
1- Smudge and Rusty go to Thunderclan together 2-They are both part of the prophecy, and yes, Fireheart becomes the leader 3- It is the second option, because as time went by they began to distance themselves, Smudge began to feel many negative emotions towards Firepaw/heart (envy, jealousy,) and he no longer knew anything about him due to the lack of communication, you could say that Fire became a stranger in Smudge's eyes
Your au is gorgeous! It will be interesting to observe its development. I would be interested in what the prophecy about these two would sound like. More precisely, about: Fire alone can save our Clan. But already with Smudge/Spotpaw. Оr has it not changed?
I love how Tiger looks like a Arcanine lmao
WAIT HE DOES
@@localdragonpuppeteer I’ve noticed this with many designs lmao and it’s so funny, I love it. I love this PMV. Beautiful art and I love the song
He does lol
HEHWHEWHHEHWHEWHHEHWHEH
I read "Arcane"
I always love when people remember Smudge! The idea of him joining the Clans always intrigues me, and I loce the direction you took him in!
(Dustpaw going to apologize is also really cute)
Pretty sure this is SwiftPaw, not Smudge
@@ThatCraftyCornerRead description.
@@ThatCraftyCorner lol this is smudge
@@Liz66.how do u read description
I love this AU! I feel that Smudge is often times forgotten after a couple of books, and I've seen lots of AU's of him being evil, joining Tiny, being jealous of Rusty, or just... Lonely and depressed. I love that this shakes it up where he still has his own story that blends well with canon events, without him turning evil, annoying or just being super sad. He has his own adventure at his own pace and gets to ask himself what he truly wants in life, rather than taking the word of others and letting it scare him, like believing the forest was full of cats that would eat him, or that his friend abandoned him.
That said I was wondering to myself why I had never seen this and how old it was, and I realized it was posted on my bday earlier this year and that the TH-cam algorithm failed me. Curse you, TH-cam, for hiding a wonderful video with pretty art!
I really appreciate your comment
@@SmudgeWC Well I'd love to see it if you make and release it! From memory (It's been many, many years since I read a book with Smudge in it, lol.) he was a really sweet character, honestly worried about his friend's choice to live with the wild cats. I remember him always being excited when Fireheart rolled around, and it's not that he wasn't supportive, it just seems like he had that "Are you SURE?" approach just because he didn't want Rusty/Fireheart to hurt. I love this timid yet careful approach as he tries to do what's right. ;3; It's a pretty big contrast to Fireheart who was always a bit gung-ho for adventure and fearless. They're both doing similar things but in their own ways. (I loved the detail with Dustpaw too, considering he and Firepaw REALLY didn't get along, lol.)
I LOVE FIRES WHITE PAW cool design!
You're the only one talking about that! I made that detail in his design remembering that Fire and Scourge are half-brothers, so I'm glad you mentioned it 💖
Squilf also has a white paw I think, this ties in rather well!
Also I luv his little fire shoulder
WAIT WAIT I DIDNT REALIZE THAT FIRE SHOULDER WAS IMPORTANT one of the most recent vids showed meh
I LOVE THIS AHAGHAGHAHGH
Also I'm so glad he saw Spottedleaf as a mother rather than a crush! I mean, SHE WAS OLD ENOUGH TO BE FIREPAW'S GRANDMOTHER---
I LOVE THIS AU!! ITS SO DIFFERENT FROM THE ONES IVE SEEN
*Chefs kiss* 👌
YES OMG IM A SUCKER FOR SMUDGE AUS THANK YOU FOR MAKING THIS 😭
I bet when Fireheart and Graystripe kicked out Brokenstar and rescued Cinder, Thorn, Bracken and Bright and were named warriors earlier, Spotpaw must have been *really* jealous
Yep
My friend loves warrior cats shes cosplaying bluestar im gonna show her this she will love it
This was really really good. I really wish Smuge could have gone with him or at least Fireheart going to tell him that he's happy and ok
two things I realy like about this.
First: I like this au Idea and what it could tern into.
Second: I like how your youtuber name is just smudge. I like it alot.
Wait, what if RavenPaw went with Smudge instead of Barley? I feel like RavenPaw would appear way more in the earlier books if this was the case
Spot and Ravenpaw never had romantic feelings (if that's what you mean). What's more, although they trained together, they did not form a friendship (they talked to each other and got along well, but not to the point of considering themselves friends)
@@SmudgeWCI believe they are trying to say, what if Ravenpaw went with Smudge in the original books instead of living on the farm with Barley
I love this au, and your art is on point
Spotpaw isn't a dreamer
Spotpaw is a dremer
I thought no one else noticed that spelling mistake lol
More Smudge content 🎉
And it is really great!
I’ve never seen an au with smudge like this! Very creative! Also I really like your art style^^
Great work!! This PMV is very well put together, I do have a few questions related to the AU.
1. So, does Firepaw (Rusty) come with Smudge (Spotpaw) to Thunderclan? Or is Smudge replacing Rusty in this situation?
2. Are they both apart of the prophecy and if so, what roles do they play in it? Does Firepaw still become leader?
3. Is Firepaw an antagonist? I'm asking because his face seemed to be blackened around 0:33. Or is that just Smudge feeling like Firepaw wouldn't understand, or doesn't care what he's going through?
(And yes, for that one commenter, I did see the description explaining this AU, I just didn't understand it all that much)
1- Smudge and Rusty go to Thunderclan together
2-They are both part of the prophecy, and yes, Fireheart becomes the leader
3- It is the second option, because as time went by they began to distance themselves, Smudge began to feel many negative emotions towards Firepaw/heart (envy, jealousy,) and he no longer knew anything about him due to the lack of communication, you could say that Fire became a stranger in Smudge's eyes
New sub! I love the idea of smudge joining just like firestar :D
i love your art and style so much! this is so cute and you can feel the emotion in every scene!
good work 🤩😊
Your au is gorgeous! It will be interesting to observe its development. I would be interested in what the prophecy about these two would sound like. More precisely, about: Fire alone can save our Clan. But already with Smudge/Spotpaw. Оr has it not changed?
Just found you randomly recommended to me and I'm so invested!! Your art is lovely, im excited to see your story unfold!💖
THAT'S SO DAMN GREAT!
I absolutely Love Smudge AU's.
[Just a quiestion: Where do you animate?]
i love this sm !! your art style and character designs are absolutely stunning
SMUDGE AU SMUDGE AU OMG!! Amazing art!!
Which app did you use?
Gorgeous animation!
Your so underrated 😭
Now I wanne know his full warrior name
This au is amazing
yooo this is amazing!!
LOVE IT SM
I thought this was SwiftPaw...
THIS IS GREAT DUDE OUAGHH 💓💖💞💖💓💖💞💥💥💪🔥💪🔥🔥💯💪🔥💪‼️
Is it swift paw or smudge bc in the vid it said "swift paw is a dreamer" but the description says smudge
It’s smudge
also it says Spotpaw because in the AU his warrior name is spotpaw
@@Lykoywhiskerr oh ok
I love this
Can I read this au somewhere?
Check description
Dreamer*
What is au?
Alternate universe
0:20 Dreamer is spelt wrong.
What the f#@k
???
What the fuck?
@@Micasky9285 what the fuck to what?
@@Lykoywhiskerr sexy toothless x light fury pee
It’s a warrior cat animation, don’t judge this beautiful animation just because you don’t understand it. Just click off.