This is so good that no other conductors in many generations to come can surpass Karajan not only because of his impeccable technique but also because of that genius is genius therefore they can't be replaced.
Beethoven /wielki geniusz/ stracił słuch przez własnego ojca ten go bił strasznie po głowie jak był dzieckiem. Przeżył koszmar. Ojciec Beethovena chciał kasy za koncerty takiej jak miał Mozart i lał chłopca. Polecam film ,,Beethoven,,...Karajan to arcymistrz
I was amazed by his conducting movements like a swan or a butterfly! Completely fascinated by his graceful posture and movement. 😊🤍 He is a Godsend! Just Unspeakably and Stunningly Beautiful. 😘It was so wonderful that I was moved to tears! 😿
When I watched this, I didn't fast forward or skip a second, I used full screen mode and watched the whole video with complete concentration! ONLY YOU can make me do this, Karajan! 🤗❤His body movement just like freaking CNC Machine or Kuka's Robotic Arm!😯
Dear Mr Liang, thank you, for sharing this magnificent film! I simply can't find the precise word to describe how much I enjoyed it. To say I love it would be to say the very least !
Ah, the 'old' Berlin Philharmonic... though today they are great, they do not sound as good as this. It was from here until the middle/late 1970's when they were at their greatest. I heard them live in the 70's and I will not forget it, ever. At least in this film we get to see the players... in later times, in these films, we only ever got to see Karajan, and nothing of the players... most of these guys had probably played for Furtwangler. Thank you so much for posting.
@@herbertstrenn1635 I did not say they were soldiers but just may be some of them were conscripted like the other young men in the nation .. Why not , we all were conscripted in the army for a time after the graduation , before we look for a job !
@@makyhsmakyhs6766You said: "And many of them were also soldiers in the German army in ww2" And I said they were not. They were freed from conscript. Like Karajan himself and Furtwängler and many other artists. And by the way I do not see any reasonable connection between this video and probably being a soldier at ww2.
Remark on the wonderful timpanist.... see how he plays in a fully German military style... as I recall when I saw the BPO in the early 70's the timpanist played exactly like this. He played so loudly in the storm in the pastoral symphony that the Times newspaper of London wrote a front page article on him.
That was Werner Thärichen, Aristocrat of timpanists. BPO was (and is perhaps still) a Prussian orchestra with a very distinctive and refined sound. How I miss that bass driven sound and hard playing of the old BPO... Most orchestras of today have no character at all.
@@navigator1074 Indeed Sir I do recall Herr Tharichen... I remember an interview with him on the BBC... like you I do miss the sound of the 'old' BPO.. I have him playing of course on so many CD performances of this orchestra.... as we say in England..."they don't make them like that any more" - being an expression of respect.
Nos estamos ouvindo a pg mais linda da musica classica composta pelo seu maior genio, nao tenho a menor duvida,sem desrespeitar os demais compositores!
Un son un peu étroit, et quelques distorsions aux cuivres et au bois, mais cela doit tenir aux différents transferts. Pour le reste , sublime, pas d'autre mot. On dira ce que l'on veut de Karajan, de sa mégalomanie, de son égotisme, de son culte de la personnalité, de son star système, même de sa coiffure autant en emporte le vent, et de sa direction "en aveugle", on dira tout ce qu'on voudra, le voir diriger est toujours une expérience enivrante: cette manière qu'il avait d'extraire le son de la terre, comme de la matière qu'il extirpait , prenait à bras le corps, de ses grands gestes amples, pétrissait de ses mains, portait au ciel, comme s'il était maître d'une éruption volcanique ! Grand merci pour le partage.
This is a tremendous achievement. Note that the dates of the Clouzot-Karajan project were 1965-67 and this one was filmed in '66. I have been enjoying the 1963 Karajan BPO Beethoven symphony recordings but the 5th simply doesn't share the same masterful intensity found here. Still, for sheer brilliant nuance, the Kleiber 5th reigns supreme in my heart, although for dramatic power on the podium, no one, not even Bernstein tops von K. (A chacun etc.)
Kleiber's performance is as powerful as Karajan's one until 6:55 when Karajan got the right tempo, sound, intensity and wrath (at least for my ears) and Kleiber's performance was left behind... Until they met again at the end of the first movement...
Herbert von Karajan conduzido a Berliner Philharmoniker é um prazer estético que se inscreve entre os mais privilegiados! Herbert von Karajan vor den Berliner Philharmonikern ist ein ästhetisches Vergnügen, das eines der privilegiertesten ist! Herbert von Karajan in front of the Berliner Philharmoniker is an aesthetic pleasure that is one of the most privileged!
La perfezzione assoluta... Non più orchestre del genere e un direttore che ammiro e stimo, per la bravura e la perfezzione sia musicale che dirigenziale....
I grew up watching Karajan. His executions are personally irreplaceable. The sound of the orchestra, of the Berlin Philharmonic, has not been until now that I write similar. Because he was unique in what he did. From the direction of the presence to the last sound from each family of musical instruments. At that time, women were not allowed in the orchestras or in this particular one due to the statute.
DIVINAMENTE SOBERBO E ECANTADORAMENTE SUBLIME, É ESSE PRINCIPE, HERBERT VON KARAJAN!!... Destilando magia na Regência,ELE é único, imortal e eterno!!... Duque de Caxias--RJ Brasil 05/01/2021
Estuve buscándote por mucho y me apareces por recomendación de arte conciert. Maravilloso y solo tengo 15 años de edad para decidirme por el piano o violín. Son más que estremecedores la chispa del alma.
Wunderkinder Herbert Ritter Von "Wunder Karajan" 1908-1989 Niño prodigio del Piano Hombre prodigio del vuelo! Volaba como director de orquesta Dirigía la orquesta como volaba! Suave aterrizaje! Pensaba reencarnar en águila y volar sobre los Alpes Dicen que en una oportunidad Herbert von Karajan tomó un taxi y el conductor le preguntó "¿A dónde le llevo?". "A donde quiera, en todas partes quieren verme", respondió. www.karajan.co.uk/flying.html www.elmundo.com/portal/pagina.general.impresion.php?idx=82195
Ok, $50,000 question. One of the double-bass players (you can see him around 1:50 in the video) looks very young. Anyone know if he's still playing today? Who was the youngest musician (of any instrument) to play with the Berlin Philharmonic?
my best guess is Klaus Stoll, looks a bit similar. th-cam.com/video/XNcXRys0Lq4/w-d-xo.html it's the link where he gives a masterclass, try compare and see
That is Klaus Stoll , retired since a couple of years. His successor was his Venezuelan apprentice Edicson Ruiz I believe (who joined the orchestra at age of 17!, youngest ever). The other two young bass players in the front right row were the legends Friedrich Witt and Rainer Zepperitz.
베토벤... 클래식 음악을 가장 클래식답게 이룬 전인미답의 악성. 운명 교향곡... 클래식 음악을 모든 음악의 최고봉에 올려놓은 전대미문의 명작. 카라얀... 클래식 음악을 범접할 수 없는 경지로 세운 유일무이한 최상의 지휘자. (이것을 제공하신 분께 감사와 축복을~ )
Karajan wasn't a German conductor....he had born at Saltsburg, Austria and the great-grandfather of his grandfather,George John Karajannis,was Greek ( born in Kozani). He took the title of "von ", in 1792.
Beethoven was virtually deaf when he composed this. and Karajan conducted it with his eyes closed..imagined the piece in his head..he said looking at the orchestra would have been distracting..I wonder if Beethoven would have composed any differently if his hearing was intact..
It is such a uniquely powerful performance, as if capturing that the composer was an emotional, angry, deaf artist, desperate to get his talent registered for posterity. Unfortunately, for me, having grown up listening to only this version for ten years in the 1980s, I cannot warm to any performance currently offered. None capture the sheer weight, the colossal gravitas of this conductor, this orchestra, this performance, where every note is given a reverence.
Fred, give a try to Giulini in the 5th with LA Philharmonic.....the video - poor quality - gives you an idea of the energy, expression and sound ... For better sound quality, DG recording is there on YT.
It is a art? It is a philosophy? It is a Idea? It is a spirtual world? Or all of the total of the fate? It is a deepest profound inner world. and going into God in himility.
There is only one conductor for this masterpiece. There is only one orchestra to perform it. That’s called PERFECTION.
This is so good that no other conductors in many generations to come can surpass Karajan not only because of his impeccable technique but also because of that genius is genius therefore they can't be replaced.
The best composer of all time, the best conductor of all time, the best symphony ....absolute bliss!
Mejor imposible
Karajan and the Berlin Philharmonic were born to produce the sound that Ludwig heard in his deafness.
Beethoven /wielki geniusz/ stracił słuch przez własnego ojca ten go bił strasznie po głowie jak był dzieckiem. Przeżył koszmar. Ojciec Beethovena chciał kasy za koncerty takiej jak miał Mozart i lał chłopca. Polecam film ,,Beethoven,,...Karajan to arcymistrz
Maybe sounds silly, but even if you mute it, Karajan's body language is a master piece musical itself.
you could say that about almost any great musician. the body language produces the music.
Its not silly at all, and its precisely why he is my favorite.
Un genio de la dirección
Un genio de la dirección...Vida eterna al maestro
I completely agree. It is a masterpiece of precision, timing ... and choregraphy.
Karajan is immortal!
The very superb icon of conducting!
Definitely it's one of the best videos on TH-cam
These are gems. Never lose these. I have studied these for years. As a classical bassist, I have respect for the Berliner Philharmoniker
Beethoven + Karajan + Berlin Philharmonic = German Perfection
William White and no estrogen in sight. Von Karajan was Austrian also.
William White, thanks, you are sooo correct. THIS is GERMAN PERFECTION. INCREDIBLE! PURE GREATNESS !
@@jamesm.3967And the Karagian was the son of a family of Greek descent from Salzburg
Πορτοκαλί Τσουκνίδα what? Are you kidding he is Armenian KARAJAN is Armenian name
Listen closely to the very first notes : that's not what I would call perfection
Imposible superar esta dirección de Karajan. Creo que la aplaudiría Beethoven de estar vivo y oyendo.
Tremenda grabación también.
I was amazed by his conducting movements like a swan or a butterfly! Completely fascinated by his graceful posture and movement. 😊🤍
He is a Godsend! Just Unspeakably and Stunningly Beautiful. 😘It was so wonderful that I was moved to tears! 😿
When I watched this, I didn't fast forward or skip a second, I used full screen mode and watched the whole video with complete concentration!
ONLY YOU can make me do this, Karajan! 🤗❤His body movement just like freaking CNC Machine or Kuka's Robotic Arm!😯
Thank you so much: one of the greatest performances of all times.
Dear Mr Liang, thank you, for sharing this magnificent film! I simply can't find the precise word to describe how much I enjoyed it. To say I love it would be to say the very least !
Not only the beautiful sound, the camera shots as well. Its great cinema.
The Master at work.
Dios!! Ya 250 años de este majestuoso gigante y de las manos de Karajan una locura, saludos desde México
Beautifully performed, beautifully conducted, beautifully filmed!!
I. Allegro con brio 0:40
II. Andante con moto 7:55
III. Scherzo: Allegro 17:34
IV. Allegro 22:16
Beethoven's 5th is also called: This is how destiny (fate) knocks on your door. A sublime Masterpiece!
Karajan AMAZING!!!!
Jeden z największych dyrygentów XX wieku
la conducción de kalajan es divino, exquisito, inigualable como se le extraña.
Lamentablemente uno solo lo puede ver por medio de estos videos. Saludos.
Ah, the 'old' Berlin Philharmonic... though today they are great, they do not sound as good as this. It was from here until the middle/late 1970's when they were at their greatest. I heard them live in the 70's and I will not forget it, ever. At least in this film we get to see the players... in later times, in these films, we only ever got to see Karajan, and nothing of the players... most of these guys had probably played for Furtwangler. Thank you so much for posting.
And many of them were also soldiers in the German army in w w 2
@@makyhsmakyhs6766 This orchestra was still performing until neary the end of the war. They definitely were not soldiers.
@@herbertstrenn1635 I did not say they were soldiers but just may be
some of them were conscripted like the other young men in the nation .. Why not , we all were conscripted in the army for a time after the graduation , before we look for a job !
@@makyhsmakyhs6766You said: "And many of them were also soldiers in the German army in ww2" And I said they were not. They were freed from conscript. Like Karajan himself and Furtwängler and many other artists. And by the way I do not see any reasonable connection between this video and probably being a soldier at ww2.
@@herbertstrenn1635 OK may be,
any way its not a shame for anybody to serve in his national army .. its an honor !
Saludos y felicitaciones desde Lima (ju17/VI/2021)-Perú-América.
This is like witnessing the first second of the Big Bang in person.
So true. Your comment best describes the scene.
Magnificat Karajan.. 💖💖💖🙏👍😍
The best composer of all time.
Always a great pleasure to listen to when doing house chores or just sitting by the window with a cup of coffee and a plate of biscuits.
Los cellos están en dos disposiciones diversas. Escalados y en una fila.. depende la cámara.. bello
Remark on the wonderful timpanist.... see how he plays in a fully German military style... as I recall when I saw the BPO in the early 70's the timpanist played exactly like this. He played so loudly in the storm in the pastoral symphony that the Times newspaper of London wrote a front page article on him.
That was Werner Thärichen, Aristocrat of timpanists. BPO was (and is perhaps still) a Prussian orchestra with a very distinctive and refined sound. How I miss that bass driven sound and hard playing of the old BPO... Most orchestras of today have no character at all.
@@navigator1074 Indeed Sir I do recall Herr Tharichen... I remember an interview with him on the BBC... like you I do miss the sound of the 'old' BPO.. I have him playing of course on so many CD performances of this orchestra.... as we say in England..."they don't make them like that any more" - being an expression of respect.
El mejor músico de la historia de la humanidad dirigido por el magno Herbert Von Karajan jamás se ha escuchado una música que exalta al alma
*El mejor músico de la Historia*... no nos olvidemos de Vivaldi, Bach, Hendel..., Dios tiene muchos intrumentos para expresarse.
@@rafaelgarciarodriguez3081 Cierto... pero este sitio es para fans de Beethoven y Karajan... No arruines el momento, jajajaja...
@@juanuceda401 jaja..., saludos.
Todo a la perfección.
What a space in time that can be replicated!
Nos estamos ouvindo a pg mais linda da musica classica composta pelo seu maior genio, nao tenho a menor duvida,sem desrespeitar os demais compositores!
It's like he is conducting a battle!
Great conductor in the world
Wellington indeed was more frightened of Beethoven than of Napoleon before Waterloo
Karajan inmortal!!
Finally!!! I'm so grateful for this video
Karajan Fantastic Virtuoso 👍Beethoven 4Ever
Thank you Will. Thank you very much.
Excelente vídeo de un genio de la música ...
Un son un peu étroit, et quelques distorsions aux cuivres et au bois, mais cela doit tenir aux différents transferts. Pour le reste , sublime, pas d'autre mot. On dira ce que l'on veut de Karajan, de sa mégalomanie, de son égotisme, de son culte de la personnalité, de son star système, même de sa coiffure autant en emporte le vent, et de sa direction "en aveugle", on dira tout ce qu'on voudra, le voir diriger est toujours une expérience enivrante: cette manière qu'il avait d'extraire le son de la terre, comme de la matière qu'il extirpait , prenait à bras le corps, de ses grands gestes amples, pétrissait de ses mains, portait au ciel, comme s'il était maître d'une éruption volcanique !
Grand merci pour le partage.
This is a tremendous achievement. Note that the dates of the Clouzot-Karajan project were 1965-67 and this one was filmed in '66. I have been enjoying the 1963 Karajan BPO Beethoven symphony recordings but the 5th simply doesn't share the same masterful intensity found here. Still, for sheer brilliant nuance, the Kleiber 5th reigns supreme in my heart, although for dramatic power on the podium, no one, not even Bernstein tops von K. (A chacun etc.)
Kleiber's performance is as powerful as Karajan's one until 6:55 when Karajan got the right tempo, sound, intensity and wrath (at least for my ears) and Kleiber's performance was left behind... Until they met again at the end of the first movement...
simply fabulous
Gracias a quien puso esta pieza, gracias al autor (el sordo alemán) y gracias a los músicos y a Karajan. Gracias de todo corazón.
Herbert, the greatest! thanks to Clouzot!
Wooooh qué gran genio y qué hermosa orquesta!!!! 🥰😍
マジで素晴らしい！これは貴重！
Immortal Beloved Beethoven, 100% rocking Band…such power and feeling! and Karajan in the driving seat. … this old rocker bows to Genius! Thanks Will!!
Great Karajan.
30:24 Karajan was so so so so so excited!!!!!!!
Kinda cute😅😊
to organize such flawless sound requires preparation and passion, incredible attention to detail. but that is just an expressive way to say, gj.
Karajan has his eyes open for just 14 frames. This guy.
HAHAHAHA
Karajan is a legend like Beethoven....❤❤❤
UNA MARAVILLA
7:58 2nd movement
THE BEST!!!
Bravo !
Herbert von Karajan conduzido a Berliner Philharmoniker é um prazer estético que se inscreve entre os mais privilegiados!
Herbert von Karajan vor den Berliner Philharmonikern ist ein ästhetisches Vergnügen, das eines der privilegiertesten ist!
Herbert von Karajan in front of the Berliner Philharmoniker is an aesthetic pleasure that is one of the most privileged!
凄い…ド迫力
I have seen once another performance with much the same musicians which was marvelous. It disappeared from you tube.
2024 and still a masterpiece 👌
Amazing🖤
Exellent,thanks a lot.
La perfezzione assoluta... Non più orchestre del genere e un direttore che ammiro e stimo, per la bravura e la perfezzione sia musicale che dirigenziale....
やっぱりカラヤンベルリンフィルはなんか凄みが違うなぁ、重厚感があってほんとに素晴らしい‼︎
I grew up watching Karajan. His executions are personally irreplaceable. The sound of the orchestra, of the Berlin Philharmonic, has not been until now that I write similar. Because he was unique in what he did. From the direction of the presence to the last sound from each family of musical instruments. At that time, women were not allowed in the orchestras or in this particular one due to the statute.
and it's a very masculine performance
WOW !!!
DIVINAMENTE SOBERBO E ECANTADORAMENTE SUBLIME, É ESSE PRINCIPE, HERBERT VON KARAJAN!!... Destilando magia na Regência,ELE é único, imortal e eterno!!... Duque de Caxias--RJ Brasil 05/01/2021
Espetacular!!!!!!
Stunning 🎉
Estuve buscándote por mucho y me apareces por recomendación de arte conciert. Maravilloso y solo tengo 15 años de edad para decidirme por el piano o violín. Son más que estremecedores la chispa del alma.
Sin palabras...
Grandiose..
Camera man was a time traveller
Wunderkinder
Herbert Ritter
Von
"Wunder Karajan"
1908-1989
Niño prodigio del Piano
Hombre prodigio del vuelo!
Volaba como director de orquesta
Dirigía la orquesta como volaba!
Suave aterrizaje!
Pensaba reencarnar en águila y volar sobre los Alpes
Dicen que en una oportunidad Herbert von Karajan tomó un taxi y el conductor le preguntó "¿A dónde le llevo?". "A donde quiera, en todas partes quieren verme", respondió.
www.karajan.co.uk/flying.html
www.elmundo.com/portal/pagina.general.impresion.php?idx=82195
The Berlin Philharmonic Orchester is the best orchestra for Beethoven in the whole World.
Happy birthday Beethoven ❤
Ok, $50,000 question. One of the double-bass players (you can see him around 1:50 in the video) looks very young. Anyone know if he's still playing today? Who was the youngest musician (of any instrument) to play with the Berlin Philharmonic?
my best guess is Klaus Stoll, looks a bit similar.
th-cam.com/video/XNcXRys0Lq4/w-d-xo.html
it's the link where he gives a masterclass, try compare and see
That is Klaus Stoll , retired since a couple of years. His successor was his Venezuelan apprentice Edicson Ruiz I believe (who joined the orchestra at age of 17!, youngest ever). The other two young bass players in the front right row were the legends Friedrich Witt and Rainer Zepperitz.
Karajan il più grande!
Karajan Sugoi !!!!!!
Wow! 8 Hörner! Das hat schon was, obschon das eher eine Bruckner-Besetzung wäre!
THE BEST, KARAJAN
Intemporal, magnífico....
Soberbo!!!
Assisti hoje mais uma vez! Espetáculo.
베토벤...
클래식 음악을 가장 클래식답게 이룬 전인미답의 악성.
운명 교향곡...
클래식 음악을 모든 음악의 최고봉에 올려놓은 전대미문의 명작.
카라얀...
클래식 음악을 범접할 수 없는 경지로 세운 유일무이한 최상의 지휘자.
(이것을 제공하신 분께 감사와 축복을~ )
Beethovens 5 Symphonie in c moll sehr gut eingespielt von den berliner Philharmonikern mit karajan mit vollem Orchester so klingt beethoven
Karajan wasn't a German conductor....he had born at Saltsburg, Austria and the great-grandfather of his grandfather,George John Karajannis,was Greek ( born in Kozani). He took the title of "von ", in 1792.
Salt's burg 😂 yeah salt is salz anyway
¡Perfecto!
Beethoven was virtually deaf when he composed this. and Karajan conducted it with his eyes closed..imagined the piece in his head..he said looking at the orchestra would have been distracting..I wonder if Beethoven would have composed any differently if his hearing was intact..
thats 9th not 5th
It is such a uniquely powerful performance, as if capturing that the composer was an emotional, angry, deaf artist, desperate to get his talent registered for posterity.
Unfortunately, for me, having grown up listening to only this version for ten years in the 1980s, I cannot warm to any performance currently offered.
None capture the sheer weight, the colossal gravitas of this conductor, this orchestra, this performance, where every note is given a reverence.
אינטרגלקטי מוסמך!🌹
Next to Toscanini, Karajan is the greatest of our time. By the way, I'm 76, so I got to enjoy both.
Fred, give a try to Giulini in the 5th with LA Philharmonic.....the video - poor quality - gives you an idea of the energy, expression and sound ... For better sound quality, DG recording is there on YT.
He's one of my favorites including toscanini, furthwangler and Bohm.
He plorat un altre cop! (I cried again!)
Glad the tempo isn't slow on this one. The rest play Beethoven like it's Bruckner. Just wrong!
This video I couldn’t find for a few years so I had to pirate this, but hey it’s back!
Please karajan 9 .. 1968 ? 720p
It is a art?
It is a philosophy?
It is a Idea?
It is a spirtual world?
Or all of the total of the fate?
It is a deepest profound inner world.
and going into God in himility.
this is as well as i've heard the Berlin Phil -- or for that matter any orchestra -- ever play.
👍👍👍👍👍👍❤️❤️🌹🌹🌹🔥🔥🔥❤️
💖
Какой же это кайф!!!Кайф, кайф,кайф!!
Genialny arcymistrz dyrygent von Karajan- Austriak