ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Do daughters have right to inherit father's self acquired property? | Important Judgment
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ส.ค. 2024
- In this video, we have discussed a recent judgment Arunachala Gounder v. Punnoswamy that clarified the most confusing stand over the daughters right in father’s property. The famous Vineeta Sharma judgment took stand on daughters right on coparcenery property only but this case also provided for daughters right fathers self acquired property.
00:00 Daughters Right to Property
00:30 Vineeta Sharma v Rakesh Sharma 2020
01:40 What is Hindu Succession Act?
02:10 What is self acquired & coparcenary property?
02:56 2005 Hindu Succession Act Amendment
03:50 What happened in Arunachala Gounder v. Ponnuswamy
05:30 Do daughters have right to self acquired property of father?
06:40 Property rights of Hindu Female dying intestate
🥁 My Courses: learn.finology.in
Instagram: / finologylegal
**********************************
JURISPRUDENCE: bit.ly/3dYQ4UT
CONSTITUTION: bit.ly/3nstBm5
INDIAN PENAL CODE: bit.ly/32VgEI1
INDIAN POLITY: bit.ly/3xw4nYE
**********************************
Course on CLAT PG LLM (New Pattern): bit.ly/3sXaUYY
Course on CLAT UG (NEW PATTERN): bit.ly/3vp6A6j
**********************************
Open Your Quick Account: upstox.com/open...
So IF the father has debt and needs to pay, In this case why does only the son has to pay? it must be divided between son and daughter.
Agree... Also she never come to see how they live. They may visit once in 2 or 3 years if asked they used to say we also have our family. If they come, they also take what ever they want like sarees, jewellery collectively and relentlessly of every festival without thinking how brothers family is running. When father died she came for share. Due to sudden death of my father he could not write any will. I want to share you my pain... It took 15 years to me and my wife to close the liability taken for her in the time of her marrage. We sacrificed our 15 years for her marrage liability. We couldnot even eat good food to accumulate money. I regrets to my children I could gave them good education. Now I am old could not work but running around court with my sons hard earn money. Her husband and father in law has more then what we have but also she dragged me to court.
law also imposes liabilities on her in case of coparcenary property
@@raghunath188 who is they?
The real G
Bete dahej bhi le aur property me hak bhi....sbse bda bikhari to son hota hai...
An excellent ruling given by the Supreme Court today. And outstanding explanation, loved it.
*कम समय में अति स्पष्टता से समग्र मुद्दा समझाया आपने।* 😊👍
*धन्यवाद।* 🙏
Very well explained
Even though I'm not a law student but I am still saving this video to my GK playlist.
This channel is literally so helpful for 12th grade students!! Like I only knew the names of the cases and didn't even know what the cases were actually about! Thank you so much!! Awesome work!
Glad you like them!
Hello mam, I have a doubt.
In the situation of second marriage, when husband dies intestate, how the step son (biological son of the lady) can get the part in property of husband
@@Krishnam1219 This situation is about Illegitimate son of Hindu male. In this after the death of husband his legitimate son(that is son from first wife) will get more share and illegitimate son(son from second wife) will get half of it.
I hope it will help you understand!!!
@@akankshaverma2773 thank u so much🙂
@@_FinologyLegal mam kitne judges ke bench thi please bataiye
Excellent video but in the end. I guess in conclusion , there is a lot of scope to improve and explain. It ended in very obscure manner.
true
Even I think the same
Yes i do support this..
Also i want to see equality where a settled girl marrying a jobless/Struggling guy.
@@a1b257 i am ready just find me girl message me I'll DM you my profile.
@@a1b257 because there are no such girls😌🤞
Impossible.. Man not earning stupidity
Never marry a jobless man. Ask him to get settled first, then marry.
@@dreamsdesires exactly
Son and daughter are equal! In that case, she must be equally treated to pay the debt of her father as sons do!!! If I’m wrong, correct me!!!
Sons have no legal duty to pay their father's debts.
@@pinakypaliwal7622 if your dad debt for something and he isn’t able to pay now! And lenders are going hyper over your dad. So what would you do?
@@bantimojiyan In that case I would help him pay his debts as much as I can.
@@pinakypaliwal7622 what if the father dies?
@@pinakypaliwal7622 pls answer I really want to know
Todays women are independent and strong enough so that they can carry half weight of evrything when they could enjoy half assets
New customs should put liability on girl to fund marriage of childrens of there brother
New customs should put pressure on girl to gift tons of items on every occassions
Now girls are strong enough to take care of parents equally they should take parents with her during marriage of daughter itself
Why should boys have all the fun
@@vamshi.indian i mean its not everywhere you’re from a privileged family i guess so its not from women with already rich backgrounds but for opressed women
If the female had sold that property how it will devolve back to father's heirs
Correction- 2005 amendment is not retrospective in nature but retroactive in nature vide Vineeta Sharma case.
Thank you, thank you, thank you soooooo much ma'am for the SUBTITLES, especially like for me who needs to prepare self notes n study and who doesn't understand hindi..
Pls continue to put subtitles in upcoming videos too.. thank you! 😊
Glad it was helpful!
Yes I too need English subtitles very much
Very well explained, God bless you ❤❤😇
You told very well infact fantastic Explanation but I am really missing honorable Priya mam in this video...
@finology legal thank u di for giving these type of cases these are very helpful for me
Thanks for liking
Thanks mam ..
Thanks for sharing valuable knowledge 😊👍
Finology is the best in dealing with case laws
All the supreme court judgement should give clarity like this...which should be followed
This lecture should be covered by Priya mam 😊
Thank you very much Ma'am for this informative video! Ma'am, could you please upload a pdf containing information about this case? It would be really very helpful, Ma'am!
Great analysis of great news 👍
Di amazing just amazing ! ❤️ Thanku so much ❤️
Thanks mam🙏❤️
Thank you
You're welcome
Nice decision but reality main agar koi apni property mangti hai to uski family hi uske against ho jati hai
This is very nice judgment by our courts. Girls are also equal deservers as boys.
EDITED- This is one of very few videos which I have ever shared with my friends.
At present daughters enjoy equal rights in property with their brother. But this law becomes self contradictory and invalid if the daughter is not given equal share in property like her brother in the will made by their father. Patriarchal society takes help of this law to deprive the daughter of her natural right.
@@minatisaha9284 Yup, you may be right. I do not have much knowledge about the laws as I'm a computer science student. But thanks for this useful piece of information.
In India absence of right of survivorship all property acquired by birth.....Thank you so much for instant analysis of latest judgment
Outstanding explanation 🥰
Thank you so much
Ma'am aap ko halala ki practice jo islam me hai voh kya sahi lagti hai...?🤔🤔
Specular explanation didi 🥰
Thank 🌹you
Clean and clear as well
Thanks a lot 😊
My mothers brother grabbed her parent's property on his name, as my grandparents wanted to give their property to my mother but they couldn't coz they died before writing any will
Means you wanna grab your mother property,
If grandparents has not write any will and after that mother's brother just took all their property in his own name then it will be easily challenged in court, it doesn't matter whom this property now belongs IF it was not transferred by grandparents themselves to him before their death...
Court also clear what is responsibility of douthers for family for poor father and mother
I have a question…. How can the self acquired property go to father’s brother’s children(@7:28)in presence of the deceased women’s own children…. Kindly go through section 15 of HSA again… and kindly clarify if possible to take out time from your busy schedule
She died issueless. That is why the property devolved back to the source i.e., to heirs of the father which in this case are brother’s children.
@@nehaagarwal3780 I was having the same question while watching the video. Thankyou for clarifying. By the way did she mention that she died without any children?
@@koushikgorain4302 she did not mention, but implied I guess
@@telugugardenerwitharts yes she died without children
Every girl is happy now 💖
Thanks madam
Very beautifully explained mam
You are very well explained very amazing lawyer you are
Thanku.
These rules are for instate property , whose will has not been made. But i think father or mother should hand over to property to one who take care of them. Be it son or daughter.
Question- Whether the girls are eligible for equal share in the property?
Opinion: No, the girls are not equal share holder in the property in which the owner of the property died before 2005, this is held by Supreme Court recently in the Judgment. Please clarify if some one know.
Thank you so much for the information 🙂🙂🙂😘😘
Thank you so much Madam.. I loved&Enjoyed your Way of Explanation🙏🙏🙏❤❤❤
Thanks for liking
Hlo Mem Thnku thnku thnku ✌️👍🙏❤️💐🌹🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏.. thnkx thnkx thnkx thnkx
Maam, is there any law against the father who don't want to pass his property to his daughter. As the property right is with him so he can give his property to anyone he like..
The case mentioned in this video was of intestate property .. agr vasiyat Bani hui h to property vasiyat ke according hi bati jaegi .. tumhri mrzi tum Kisi ke bhi nam pr vasiyat likh do ..
If daughter has the right to properly , she also has the responsibility to care of her parents. If her husband threatens her parents without any reason, try to defame her family and she supports her husband then I don't think she has any right on the property. Moreover if it's about equality, then in many cases if the daughter's husband has much more property than the son and the son is not rich and has no property, the property only belongs to sons and thus the measure of property should be measured before distribution of property. And why no one talks about daughter in law who leaves her house, property to serve her in laws her whole life and gets nothing in return? In my case... I have been suffering all this from my fufaji side...even his son misbehaves with my grandfather (his nanaji) and ask for our property and he is just 18 years old. Fufaji calls my grandfather "saale buddhe" and Bua has no issues with him. They are 100 times richer than us has soo much property..still they keep on troubling us...and we have nowhere to go and complain.
@Seema Arora your husband takes care of his own parents not yours not a big deal in it.
Instead of focusing on bua ask your mom to bring in half property and then give that half to your Bua problem solved
Bhot acha samjhati h aap 👌👌😇
Thank u so much mam I think people create difference between girl or boy is uneducated people.but day by day all awareness come in mind every person and understand the girl.is very important in every society !!!without girl every home empty !!!
Lot's of love ma'am 👌👌👌👌
Supreme Court ko ye bhi change kr dena cahiye....
Bhut achha samjhaya aapne 🙏🙏
Amazing explaination❤❤
Girls r powerful nd brave..
Give girls opportunities nd education they will change the world ❣️
Go girl 😍🇮🇳🙏
Girls are equal on every front today.
Thank you so much di 😊 for providing amazing videos.
What.a great explanation 🎉
Thanx Sister...
Now a days son and daughter got equal property in many family, but mostly daughter sale their gifted property as they live with their husband. Some they don't think about future. Population can increase rapidly but Property land can't increase.
Okay, so what?
Its their choice dude
Well explained. Would suggest to correct the word 'retrospective' as 'retroactive'.
Thank you well said ❤
Thanks for watching!
A proud and self respect doughter will never deman property from their parents. I denied property from my parents rather it's the husband who should provide their wife
A proud and self respect son would never snatch away the rights of his sister!
A man and woman both should earn equally to make a living
Why only the husband should provide for his wife
How do you see respect in surviving on your husband!?
@@khushislays2305 i also dont see any respect in you becoming a doh taqy ki nauqrani, ghar k andar bhi nauqri ghar k bahir bhi nauqri.
@@razamughal9095 oh come on agar bahar dono kamayenge toh ghar ka kam bhi divideo hoga
R u from afghanistan
Ur thoughts are too narrow
@@razamughal9095 working in a coperate is not 2 takke ki naukrani
Then i think all men are naukare right
@@khushislays2305 rubbish. Tu doh taqy ki nauqrani hain. Tera husband adha adha bartan nai dohta, khana nai banata, ghar ki safai nai karta, adhy kapry nai dohta, bacho ko nai dekhta. Ya ha akar bqwas kar rahi ho. Teri uqaat nai baqwas karny ki, kio k tum doh taqy ki nauqrani ho. Jo aurty ghar meh aram farma rahi hain tum jaisiyo ka boht mazak urati hain.
Thanks for such a useful information
Glad it was helpful!
Amazing way of defining the concept 😇.
Ma'am...
Aapko islam me halala ki practice sahi salti hai...???🤔
thank you so much maam,crystal clear
Thanks ma'am
Thank you too
At present daughters enjoy equal rights in property with their brother. But this law becomes self contradictory and invalid if the daughter is not given equal share in property like her brother in the will made by their father. Patriarchal society takes help of this law to deprive the daughter of her natural right.
very nice lecture mam thank you
Well explained 👍
Thanks very good information maam keep it up
Thanks and welcome
Thanks mam very informative videos mam 👍👍
Thanks for liking
What about self acquired property?what if there is a will &name of successors is not disclosed to the daughter?whether will or not,does a daughter get equal rights?
Exactly...I also have the same question.
Superb analysis
Thanks a ton
Superbbb kakoli ma'am...🙏🙏
Very well explained 👏
Glad it was helpful!
Well explained
Good information
did married women have same responsibility for parents as boys have as boys are suppose to take care of parents' . i believe property should be divided based on who is taking care of parents .
A woman can take care too but most husbands would not like this so change your mindset first
WRONG, then everyone would run to take care of their parents based on greed,
as usual a good video.. but please give us subtitles little difficulty in getting the details.. please
Amazing knowledge 🤗🙈
Thank you so much 😀
Islam has given this right to women 1400 yrs ago ... alhamdulillah..
But one third
We want half🤡
@@khushislays2305 a whole 50% of her brother. Thats not a third. Learn maths.
Absolutely Fantastic
@Finology..please aap is video and isi topic k dusre video pe ek combine PDF provide krdijiye 🙏bhot he helpful hoga
Not cleared the confusion...
If the women have children and she dies without any will then her property will remain with her children ,
Am I right ?
If the property is from the female’s parents then it goes back to the fathers heir ie her siblings, offspring/ if from in-laws side then it goes to her children ie in the case when there is no written will
@@michichen4015 is this true, but i read in 51 page judgement,
They said, if deceased daughter has no issues ( may be children) then it will go back to her father source again.. Am i right, it's really conflicting
@Alok Kumar If she has own self acquired property , instated means (no will made) . Then it will go equally to its husband, son, daughter..
And
she had an equal right of her deceased father instated property,
but she dies instated, (without will) ,
Her part of property will be gone back to father's side source.. Her children can't claim, as what i hv understand but not 100% sure..
And this youtube madam given wrong story of property case,
It's brother of the deceased father,
His one daughter of 5 children, filled case for her Right in property.. Earlier Brother only son got property of his Chacha, his 4 sisters got nothing,
Court given all 5 children equal share 1/5th..
Superbbb 🤩🤩
Thanks for the information !!! If the father make property will only the name of his son & he deprives his daughter than how the daughter challenge the property will ???
The owners wishes are inscribed in the will.
How can someone even think of it ..how to challenge?
This type of thoughts are definitely gonna effect society badly and this will lead to end such a enormous bond and relationship of brothers and sisters.
This is nothing but only a greed for property.
@@LegalJob it isn’t about greed but the status of a woman
If a man gives half property to sister
Even his wife would bring half
But the only difference is that he cannot taunt his wife in future
That you’re living on my expenses and house and you’re a gold digger etc!!!
what is the effect when the dies intestate but has heirs?? According to this Father's self-acquired property after death will be passed on to his daughter, and when she dies intestate, even though she has legal heirs her children cannot enjoy the property rights.
Nice session.... well news
Madam i need ur suggestions we t 3 sisiters and we r married my fathers promised my inlaws that we will give my share of property as my husband bear our marriage expenses. Secretly my younger sister and her husband registered our house on her name madam with our notice so please help us my sister deceived us when we raised this there was a big argument my father told that we r not his daughters mam how can i get my share of property please help me. Me and my husband supported a lot my father financially when he was in need of help mam kindly help me waiting for reply from u..
Wow. Im a law student. And ur videos are very helpful to us.
Hey bhaia.. Can you tell me which clg u are in? I wanna know if i didn't get any nlu then which clg i should opt...
@@livelifewithjassy7216 Iam persuing in PRR law college in Hyderabad. I got a management seat
@@ShivaPrasad-vt2pw bhaia... Clg kaise chhose krte h plz help me out... Mai pehle hi dropper hu... Agr mai koi private me gai to mere career pr koi frk pdega?
Interesting information
thnku mam
Madam super video...Madam if a sister got property then the sister's husband will got the property....
Thank you mam for this information.
Jay hind ❣️🇮🇳
EXCELLENT
Thanks for listening
How are you people this amazing!
Should also be apply to Muslims and Christians too.
Nice
Excellent
Thank you so much 😀
Right to property,,, everyone
Thank u so much...if u could kindly make a video on the new pattern of AILET PG , it will be really helpful...
Aur confuse kar diya apne ..........but priya ma'am explain acha krti hi ...pls take lecture
❤
First 🇮🇳🇮🇳