If any one would like to follow/ support me along my journey you can look at some handmade things I have for sale on my Instagram @scatteredelements and @scatteredelementals I also post music that isn’t on here on my SoundCloud.com/ginasunrae Thank you to ALL OF YOU, old time viewers, new viewers and the in betweeners for your support and feedback! 🙏
I can remember when I was 15 . I found your channel. I listen to this song at least once a day. I'm now 25. And your voice still gives the chill. By the way your a goddess of beauty too. Please keep it going!!!!!
Sweet thing you did not mess up nothing. Been a tool fan from 89. Seen alot of covers, none of them can hold up to your work. Thankyou. Watch you're work makes me smile!
It has been many years since a song left me literally speechless... Wow, just absolutely wow! Beautiful voice, excellent spin on an amazing song and just wow!
I don't even know what to say! I had to reset my email password so I could sign into my TH-cam account just to tell you how much I like this cover! You took an already great song and put your own style into it! Thank you!
GIRL, I'VE BEEN YOUR FAN since you came out with this cover 10 years ago. Can't believe I found this video again. I was unable to remember your name. I'm so happy that you're still doing music!
When I come back to your music a decade and whatever later I notice how much the feel of how you sing influenced or meshed with what my future voice likes to sing. Timeless.
I watch this several times a week I wish I actually had a professionally recorded version of this for my play list. You are very talented and this is one of my favorite APC songs
I was here 13 years ago. Stumbled on an old song I'd forgotten, Stumbled on this cover I'd forgotten. - Fantastic. Living and breathing 13 years later.
Hacia tiempo que no escuchaba cantar con tanta pasión, y sinceramente, hacia mucho tiempo que no veía tanto arte y talento. Increíble, un saludo de tu seguidor desde España.
I love to duet with you! Well I just did but I wish I could make a video or something. I have been singing my whole life and just now finally did it with a female! I loved it...^__^
40 people haven't listened to it and they got the wrong click... A piano cover is always beautiful but this one is even better than that. congratulations and thank you
You have a great voice and harmonic choice which is amazing to sing along with and create new harmonizations and emotion. Doing so gives me a deep connective feel for the emotion you give to the song.
Mad props! APC and Tool songs can be hard to cover when it comes to vocals. Even harder for females. I have tried covering The Noose in the past, but no matter what I just can't swing the vocals. My problem is that I try to get as close as possible to sounding like Maynard, and that is just not going to happen haha. Anyway, awesome jams! Glad I found this.
I have never been able to sit through an APC cover prior to this video because I thought no one could compare to Maynard, but you are definitely up there along with Maynard. You are so talented. Please never stop singing! (:
i seriously wish this song was in hd, it's perfect, it makes me want to dance to it, so many ideas are popping into my head. absoulutly beutiful honestly
Damn you're killing this in a way that I never would have expected extremely great job like I would have never thought the song could sound like that. I'm truly glad I looked up women covering A Perfect Circle. The reason why I did that is because apparently A Perfect Circle was supposed to have a woman for a lead singer but this particular woman wasn't available so they went with Maynard instead
How are you able to transcribe such an awesome song without equal, put your own twist on it, and have it just as awesome? Really, it just awes me how you're able to able to add your own interpretation of what it would sound like on piano and make it so natural. As an aspiring pianist myself, I have been trying to do something similar with existing songs only to fail and butcher the song. How do you do it so perfectly? :O (Subscribed XP)
If any one would like to follow/ support me along my journey you can look at some handmade things I have for sale on my Instagram @scatteredelements and @scatteredelementals
I also post music that isn’t on here on my SoundCloud.com/ginasunrae
Thank you to ALL OF YOU, old time viewers, new viewers and the in betweeners for your support and feedback! 🙏
I can remember when I was 15 . I found your channel. I listen to this song at least once a day. I'm now 25. And your voice still gives the chill. By the way your a goddess of beauty too. Please keep it going!!!!!
Phenomenal. Such a beautiful voice. This was so long ago too…hope you’re still out there making music.
I need your Maynard covers on Spotify so I can listen to them and hopefully one day learn to repeat them. These are amazing!
I generally can't stand the covers that people do of APC, TOOL, or Puscifer, but my dear... This is beautiful. Bravo!
A very late reply but thank you for the kind words!
@@Ginaraecan you please redo this cover in a higher quality? It's legitimately the best noose cover their is
I watched this when you first put it out. Im back in 2019 and still blows me away. It flows so well. I envy your talent. Thanks for this cover.
Great cover! You really captured the emotion of the original song. I'm truly impressed.
Sweet thing you did not mess up nothing. Been a tool fan from 89. Seen alot of covers, none of them can hold up to your work. Thankyou. Watch you're work makes me smile!
Your voice is absolutely beautiful.
I would say it sounds like an angel, but that would be a terrible pun.
"with your halo slippin down"
Can't stop listening to your cover! Gorgeous.
That was incredibly beautiful. *Goosebumps*
So simple. So raw. So beautiful! Thank you!
After al those years, I'm still a fan.
AWESOME.
Same
This album means so much to me and so does your cover. Thanks.
beautiful or as we would say in ol Mexico where I first saw you play this performance piece hermosa
I'm a huge APC and Tool fan, and I have to say, you do them proud. Keep it up! Love your stuff :D
I've already listened to this over 20 times, and I can't get enough. Thanks for inspiring me.
It has been many years since a song left me literally speechless... Wow, just absolutely wow! Beautiful voice, excellent spin on an amazing song and just wow!
Absolutely amazing! Good voice...
Listening this version in 2017.... and crying.
I love this song great to hear someone doing it this well. Awesome job
Man, I can never get over how dope your covers are. I love them so much
I don't even know what to say! I had to reset my email password so I could sign into my TH-cam account just to tell you how much I like this cover! You took an already great song and put your own style into it! Thank you!
DicklinINC. Oh stop it. It’s good but it’s not THAT good.
My heart is melting hearing this cover you’ve went above and beyond my expectations definitely a lifelong subscriber now thank you this is beautiful ❤
You are awesome! I really like all your tool and apc's cover songs ❤
That was chilling. I loved that. It truly is my favourite somg by them. And you nailed it. There is a tear in my eye. *bows*
Just found you. The best I've heard from you so far. This is great
I know I'm late as hell but you are AMAZING! I love all of Keenan's work.
GIRL, I'VE BEEN YOUR FAN since you came out with this cover 10 years ago. Can't believe I found this video again. I was unable to remember your name. I'm so happy that you're still doing music!
Thank you for coming back to check in and sending those sweet words :D
When I come back to your music a decade and whatever later I notice how much the feel of how you sing influenced or meshed with what my future voice likes to sing. Timeless.
@@Ginarae loved the covers when I was in middle school and now I'm a grown ass adult coming back now.
Words cant describe how awesome this cover is! Thank you so much for sharing this. Please dont hesitate to make more of these. You are amazing 10/10
I watch this several times a week I wish I actually had a professionally recorded version of this for my play list. You are very talented and this is one of my favorite APC songs
your voice is amazing, your take on this song is amazing! Hands down the best covers ever! I'm looking forward to hearing more!
I was here 13 years ago. Stumbled on an old song I'd forgotten, Stumbled on this cover I'd forgotten. - Fantastic. Living and breathing 13 years later.
Hacia tiempo que no escuchaba cantar con tanta pasión, y sinceramente, hacia mucho tiempo que no veía tanto arte y talento. Increíble, un saludo de tu seguidor desde España.
Please perform this at my funeral. Its so beatiful and sad.
How you structure your rhythm is absolutely singular.
If not erroneous, a gift. Great yob!
I love to duet with you! Well I just did but I wish I could make a video or something. I have been singing my whole life and just now finally did it with a female! I loved it...^__^
Oh my god that's not supposed to be creepy!!! I H8 being a dude sometimes!
Withour a doubt the best APC cover I've ever heard. Great Job
40 people haven't listened to it and they got the wrong click...
A piano cover is always beautiful but this one is even better than that.
congratulations and thank you
You have a great voice and harmonic choice which is amazing to sing along with and create new harmonizations and emotion. Doing so gives me a deep connective feel for the emotion you give to the song.
Mad props! APC and Tool songs can be hard to cover when it comes to vocals. Even harder for females. I have tried covering The Noose in the past, but no matter what I just can't swing the vocals. My problem is that I try to get as close as possible to sounding like Maynard, and that is just not going to happen haha. Anyway, awesome jams! Glad I found this.
A very late reply but thank you tons for the words! :)
Ginarae oh well, only 4 years
I have those feels too.
I wish you distributed a downloadable version of this song. It's a GREAT cover!
Been following you for years and had missed this one. Wow, just wow wow wow! ❤️ as always.
Thank you for amazing cover of great song!
This is my favorite Maynard song. Again a very emotion filled doing and I felt every ounce of it. And you made it your own at the same time.
Love how you totally transformed the feel of the song!!! Beautiful voice 🤘🏼
your voice is hauntingly beautiful. it tears at me, you show so much emotion
I love this song so much. It's meaning is so real. Thank you for covering it
incredibly beautiful and original.
this cover gives me goosebumps... it infects my soul
+ginarae18 thanks very much Gina, I've been watching your stuff now for years. You are one of my favorite cover artists. keep it up girl :-)
I have never been able to sit through an APC cover prior to this video because I thought no one could compare to Maynard, but you are definitely up there along with Maynard. You are so talented. Please never stop singing! (:
One of my fav songs good job
Beautiful. Voice, playing. Great work
my goodness.. !
2:17 to 2:48 was beautiful.. stunning dynamic you played and sang in that interlude
thank you for playing this song
R.
Absolutely incredible. You are so unbelievably talented.
I love this song!!! Because in my mind “MY ANGEL” is serenading me. To of quoted myself just now. Copping skills.
Thank you ma’am for making this you know you’ll never know how much it helps me
So once again 1000 thanks, to yuz.
:* that was the most beautiful cover i have ever heard.
Love your version of it. Amazing voice and flourishes on the keys
Your voice is so amazingly beautiful. I got goosebumps when I listened to your cover. Such a beautiful song.
I've never left a comment on TH-cam and have never felt compelled to. I really enjoyed what you did with this song. Amazingly enjoyable.
One of my favorite covers on youtube. Great job.
Huge tool, apc, and puscifer fan, I just like Maynard in General. Great softer cover approach I like it!
Thank you for sharing your talents. I'm very glad to have stumbled across your videos and will help share.
gOd damn it. Again. Why ya gotta make me cry? Beautiful.
I listen to this more than the actual APC version. Much love.
Beautiful cover!
Thank you for making my day. My favorite song ever written.
To call this beautiful is an understatement. So original yet loyal to the original.
i seriously wish this song was in hd, it's perfect, it makes me want to dance to it, so many ideas are popping into my head.
absoulutly beutiful honestly
you're an amazing artist, voice, etc. goosebumps!!!
you have a pretty voice, you hit notes in the eulogy video that tells me someone with a voice this pretty has room for style crafting :)
Thanks for singing me to sleep. Lost my dad 5 years ago and this song always reminds me of what I shouldn't of said and didn't say before he died.
Muy bonito cover, me gustó mucho..TOOL es mi banda favorita and of course APC too
Damn you're killing this in a way that I never would have expected extremely great job like I would have never thought the song could sound like that. I'm truly glad I looked up women covering A Perfect Circle. The reason why I did that is because apparently A Perfect Circle was supposed to have a woman for a lead singer but this particular woman wasn't available so they went with Maynard instead
My god I saved this video 10 years ago! Beautiful cover!
The piano gives me tingles thank you ma’am.
i miss watching your videos back when i was in HS (2010-11ish). You inspired me to get into practicing guitar/piano more.
Im speechless... you made an already amazing song even more beautiful. you need to cover A Perfect Circle more often. xD
this is stunning, I really love your voice on this
Gina I just had to say, this is beautiful. keep making this good music. Love!
This is the vid that made me click that sub button. You're amazing.
what an amazing cover! what an amazing voice girl! you rules!
Incredible work. Subbed in a heartbeat.
IM BACK HERE AGAIN. THINKING ABOUT LIFE, TRYING TO KEEP GOING.
THAT COVER IS TIMELESS
thank you for sharing your talent with us...it's inspiring...all the best to you Ginerae
absolutely f*kn beautiful!!!!
My favorite of your covers so far..Forever Sorrow..
hard to watch and not cry lol, amazing.
that was a beautiful cover, great job
awesome job...love this song
Heartbreakingly beautiful, thank you
I watch you singing every single day... Your voice goes right throug my soul... Makes me fell even better...Besides, you´re sweet. God bless you.
not even going to lie, this is an amazing cover i keep playing over.
liked and subscribed. I dont know anything about you, but but i love what im seeing and hearing. thank you.
You made me cry!
You are AWESOME!
Amazing voice... i got goosebumps hearing this
such great taste in music, and hair color!!!
Tu estabas haciendo este cover hace 10 anios y yo apenas lo estoy viendo! viajaste en mi futuro
Very beautiful well done
When are you gonna drop that album on us? I am just in love with your voice.
How are you able to transcribe such an awesome song without equal, put your own twist on it, and have it just as awesome? Really, it just awes me how you're able to able to add your own interpretation of what it would sound like on piano and make it so natural. As an aspiring pianist myself, I have been trying to do something similar with existing songs only to fail and butcher the song. How do you do it so perfectly? :O
(Subscribed XP)