I just finished watching your video and I am so sorry about that article. I love what you guys (the Three Musketeers) and you (Shen Yun) are doing so much! It's powerful and it's good and it's inspiring. Thank you and my prayers will be with you.💜
I have deep respect for the dancers. They are not only masters of their craft, but also convey a message of true beauty, kindness, and courage. This show is exactly what the world needs during these chaotic times. It’s disheartening to see how The New York Times reports on the show with such clear bias and negative intent.
I know Shen Yun dancers with their message of kindness and high morality deliver a message of kindness to people in the world and they are not money-making machines. we all love Shen Yun 🩷🤗
It is wonderful that Shen Yun is reviving traditional Chinese culture. You all are doing an amazing job. I'm practicing my vocals every day, and I hope I can join you very soon!
Firstly, so good to see you guys again!! 🤗… Poor journalism is so common unfortunately! I’ve seen claims about Shen Yun before, but it just doesn’t add up or match up to your vlogs! If people will only take a minute to see your content, I think they will see how warm and kind of a group of people you are! I will only be so fortunate to see a show someday!
Hi 3 Musketeers, we believe you guys!! Please don’t take the negative, I know you guys work very hard with rehearsal. Stay strong, stay positive and give your audience the best performances. We will always be here to support Shen Yun and 3 Musketeers!! ^^
I have watched Shen Yun many times, and the performances are truly exceptional, deeply moving. The messages behind Shen Yun’s presentations are also very powerful. In these extraordinary times, I deeply cherish Shen Yun. Thank you all.
First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win. I stand by Shenyun, nobody in this world can change that. Love you guys ❤❤❤
I’ve watched SY 4 times and worked with the company 2 times.. very professional and compassionate people.. the performance truly awakens people’s hearts.. I believe this is the essence of SY.. to inspire hope and the courage to believe again.. truly a god tier performing arts company ❤
You guys are PHENOMENAL dancers and artists, and, from all I have seen, you are lovely people, as well. I’ve been so impressed by you in your videos that I have thought I would like to know you as friends. I haven’t seen the article, so I don’t know what the criticism was referencing. I hope you can continue to move forward with confidence that you are seen and known for the fine individuals you are. You are endearing, in fact, and I imagine that you are loved by many.
Thanks guys! Great to see you again, despite the circumstances. I'm saddened that the NYT would post an unbalanced article where only one viewpoint is given. In any company or organization, there will always be some that are not happy, complain, and decide to leave. That doesn't make the places themselves are bad--it's just that not everything is for everyone. We all also have our own perspectives through which we view the world. I hope NYT will do a follow-up article in which they present the views of those who have been with Shen Yun for a long time and have benefited as much, or more, as what they feel they have given. If NYT has the journalistic integrity that all fair and unbiased news sources should have, then they will certainly present the other side as well. In the meantime, I think the 3 Musketeers past videos, as you point out, already refute the article's claims. And anyone who has seen Shen Yun, or even knows of someone who has seen and loved Shen Yun, will not be swayed by the negative comments of a handful of disgruntled people. Please keep up the great work, stay focused, and don't let anything sidetrack you from the beauty and goodness you're spreading around the world! Lastly, I hope the NYT article will have the opposite effect that's intended, and will instead serve as free advertising, and pique even more people's curiosity and interest in going to see Shen Yun:}
I know a friend in the company's social group who responded in the group that he knew most of the people who were interviewed in the negative NYT article. And what's in there doesn't reflect the truth. He was sad because one of them was once a very close friend.
@@johannaschwaiger6855 yeah just to let everyone know it's not a good thing that everyone supports. Because in the world there are good people and bad people. And importantly, when receiving information, we also need to consider it to avoid misunderstandings.
Stay strong Shen Yun team! Nothing but, love for y’all! Ignorance and bad media always attempts to bring others down. (They must live sad, miserable lives.) Turn off the bad vibes … keep the good! Y’all bring joy! ❤
How wonderful to see your lovely faces again! As far as the article is concerned, you will never get away from the frightened little people that just don't understand. Stay strong my friends, always here to support you. B xx
I believe all the videos you guys have uploaded so far have already been enough to disprove NYT's article already. Thank you for doing another video specifically explain it! And tbh, it's heartbreaking to think about how hard Shen Yun dancers practice all year round then having an article slandering their career like that😢 please know that your hard works and relentless efforts are never go unoticed! I and many other see, hear, and appreciate you guys!!!🤗☺
And just to add further, the current stage of this world is saddening😢 sacrilegious ugly performances like the Paris Olympic Opening are praised by the medias, while true genuinely beautiful art like Shen Yun's performances and hard-working pure-hearted dancer are condemmed. How concerning😢
The show you guys put up is so smazing I have never seen anything like that! You completly changed my atitude to music, my mind was opened to feel music, only something very harmonious and spiritual and kind can have such strong effect.... I don't know if someone was unhappy at some point but like you said there have to be some proportions... we are still humans after all... I know some people who actualy take part in the school and the show and they are so kind and profesional and they love it!! The goodness you spread is so great I just hope many many more people will have a chance to see you!
Does NY times want to see "Diverse" dancers on the Shenyun stage like Paris2024 opening ceremony? I am one of Shenyun audiences. I like to watch the pure Shenyun proformances on the stage. All famous classical dancing company have only well-trained healthy and beautiful dancers. Highly trained dancers don't have any exceed fat in their body at all. We call this "Professionalism".
Hey, guys... good to see you. Sad to hear about the NY Times article that attempts to disparage Shen Yun. With all the beauty and goodness Shen Yun brings, I can't imagine highlighting the voices of a few who feel that they had a bad experience with the company. It is obvious that you all work very hard and yes--it takes discipline to produce a world-class show like Shen Yun. Your professionalism and dedication exudes from the stage. Keep up the good work!
I feel sorry for the former dancers in the article and for The New York Times for publishing it. What they shared did not come from an objective perspective, nor did they consider others. This makes me think that it’s really hard to be a good person nowadays. When you strive to improve yourself every day, there are still people who criticize and slander you. The members of the Shen Yun Performing Arts are truly courageous and compassionate. You continue to be a role model for me to strive each day, helping me to be a better person and learn to empathize with others. Thank you so much!
My 16 year old son had his MCL, PCL and ACL surgery this summer!! He is walking w/o crutches and going to PT twice a week! The PT helps a lot so do not cancel your appointments!
I believe in Shen Yun. Every time I watch artists perform, I feel like my soul is being cleansed: there is no suffering, resentment,... Shen Yun has opened my worldview a lot, helping my work get better and better. Not only that, since knowing Shen Yun, I have understood what true traditional culture and the meaning of human life are? I appreciate what Shen Yun has done for our world. When epidemics, wars, natural disasters, and human disasters are constantly happening. Shen Yun has given us ultimate faith and hope. That is extremely valuable. It is something we need to cherish and protect. I think that the lies, slander, and distortions of the truth about Shen Yun are like a few dark clouds trying to hide the sun. But no matter what, from past to present, the sun always shines, and the truth is still the truth.
Shen Yun is truly breathtaking - a beautiful display of artistry and dedication. It's inspiring to see how they are reviving traditional Chinese culture with such grace and authenticity. It's sad to see such bias and negativity aimed at bringing down a performance that beautifully revives traditional Chinese culture. Instead of appreciating the artistry and cultural significance, some choose to focus on criticism. Let's value the talent and dedication that went into creating this remarkable show. I see Shen Yun every year and will always continue to support them ❤
judgment.judicial.gov.tw/LAW_Mobile_FJUD/FJUD/data.aspx?ty=JD&id=TPDM%2c99%2c%e8%81%b2%e5%88%a4%2c235%2c20110323%2c1&ot=in li hongzhi has fled to south east asia and ordered falun gong to be disbanded（张清溪败诉）
It is so sad that a highly established company like Shen Yun is being attacked in such a low manner by NYT. First of all, you don't have to look far, look for the money and you find who is behind this. NYT is bowing for the CCP, therefore is not being reliable source of news and doesn't care for the FACTS. Secondly, Shen Yun is a high level performing arts that is to be compared with world top athletes. If you look into the life of an athlete, it is 100% about discipline and the right work attics. Without such discipline, they would never break world records. This is how I see what Shen Yun does, they perform at the world athlete type of a level, not like any ordinary dance company. That is also why they excel and people are so moved by what they do. This work attic is of course not suitable for everyone. Not everyone can become the top 1% in the world at their craft. But it is very sad that the previous workers, are joining in these attacks as it exposes even more how weak they are as human beings and are not fit for greatness. It is fine to be ordinary, but just don't go and complain about those who seek to become extraordinary. NYT is seeking the victim hood people and therefore their article is so poorly written and is almost like empty air to read. Clearly NYT is not seeking to become great at their craft either, but just succumbing to to bullies like the CCP! Shen Yun you are appreciated and are the best at what you do, it would be an honor for anyone to be part of your company!
The Shen Yun saved my life. I used to get paid to post posters in Chinatown of Boston & would always see the Shen Yun posters. I was walking by the Shen Yun performance and at that moment, a woman raised her arm that she had an extra ticket. The message of compassion, love, and integrity spoke to me profoundly. The hate you received in the news article should all the more show you the value of your work. Where hate is given, love is high, all coinciding w the msg of communism suppressing the love in China
Just read the article and so upset with NYTimes. NYT has lost its vibe as a long time and prestigous newspapers. Shenyun is doing so amazing to reset beautiful tradition art. Leave them alone to continue their mission!
The motto of the NY Times is/was "All the News That's Fit to Print." Those of us who see how the NY Times pushes its views say, "All the News that Fits, We Print." Muckraking is a genuine term. They dig for issues and they find people willing to "dish the dirt." You guys are great. Stay strong. Stay beautiful.
Remember how the mainstream media attacked Yale Law School Professor Amy Chua for her Confucius-style parenting of her two young children? She raised two wonderful young ladies, who came forward to defend their mom for applying high standard and strict discipline to their upbringing. Like the U.S. Marine, Shen Yun’s training isn’t for everyone. If some people don’t like to be held against high standard and strict discipline, they should go ahead and enjoy the freedom elsewhere.
In any company and work environment, there are disgruntled people. I’ve encountered many of them throughout my career and listened to their grievances. At times, I sympathized with them-we’re all human and have breaking points. Oftentimes, their concerns were well-founded. Yet, it’s the people who stay, continue working, and strive to make things better that deserve attention. They usually focus on the positive. It’s a different story if the mission isn’t relevant, but your mission is inspiring and needs to carry on!
When I read the article from the NYT, I was really surprised and saddened that they could report on Shen Yun in such a way. The first thing I can say is that looking at the demeanor and aura of the Shen Yun performers, they all exude positive energy. They are friendly and approachable. They train very hard, and I know it is very strenuous and difficult. I see the fatigue on their faces, but above all, they still respond with smiles that, to me, are very warm. Such things cannot be faked. You need to have a pure heart and a positive spirit to always maintain that state. In life, conflict and disagreement are inevitable; they are a given, but they are not everything. We cannot let those negative things overshadow the meaningful and great things. And as the three musketeers shared, Shen Yun has been established for nearly 20 years, and the NYT could only find 25 people who expressed dissatisfaction. This information speaks volumes; Shen Yun has truly done an excellent job. We should all learn from them. We should not become narrow-minded and shallow people. Thank you for the dedication of Shen Yun and the dancers. I wish you all the best.
Thank you guys for speaking up, I'm glad you are treated well. I just have a question: does Shen Yun provide medical insurance for its dancers / employees? You said you were flied out and got surgery quickly, then rehab, which are expensive I assume. What type of insurance did you have through SY (your employer), if any? Did you have to pay high premium / copay out of pocket?
It is disheartening to see supposedly free US media NY Times cooking up negative stories and working hard on influencing people with lies and deception. We love Shen Yun! And we hope there would be more Shen Yun companies traveling with new programs every year! 🥰💞
Hey guys a, as much as attention gave the negative , will gane power . I work in met museum and no one cares about nonsense in media , on the contrary now u guys and shen yun be more famous.❤😅
After NYT bad mouth about SY, I think people are curious if the statement is true, how those dancers preform freely on stage? logic. I encourage you see SY yourself ✨
WE know that Shen Yun artists and performers do practice a spiritual school. And WE know that engaging in a spiritual practice involves sacrifices as well as blessings 🌷WE have seen this in so many spiritual communities like some christians' confréries etc...thus, some things such as thé fact that thé mind state of a person and his physical health are interconnected- are things quite known and common in spiritual communities. What IS saddening IS that most of thé speech of thèse former Shen Yun members IS OUT OF CONTEXT....many things they spoke about simply Shouldn't bé adressed liké that. I believe that they simply didn't understand what they were doing or practiticing. And even in that case, they could have quitely quitted without badmouthing or stirring trouble 🙁
During the Renaissance, I'm sure there were mediocre artists who were jealous of great ones like Michelangelo, Raphael and Da Vinci. During the lifetime of great composers like Mozart, Bach and Beethoven, I'm sure there were mediocre composers who were jealous of them. Whenever there are outstanding artists creating outstanding works, there are petty people trying to bring them down. But as long as the outstanding artists keep producing their beautiful works, people will look for them and be inspired by them.
Shenyun put what happened in China on the stage because their life are really being threatened. They need to show that to people to contribute to stop those things. If not going to that serious step, they will not do so.
When I watched Shen Yun, I noticed the recurring theme of good people being oppressed-whether by communists in modern times, by corrupt individuals in ancient days,but finally justice served… and now, a media jumped out and labeled themselves as “bad”, apart being pathetic, they could also be used into the stories as a different form of “bad guy” and I want to see the justice comes sooner, on the stage.
@Loxinary Thank you for replying. Mostly, you may be right, but I think they will not let people label themselves as bad so easily. About 1999, they also gave the ccp government enough time to know about them that they don't have any hostile and threat to the government, and they're just a group of people who use "truthfulness, compassion, tolerance" as principle to require themselves, but finally ccp still persecuted them even never stopped. I hope NYT can realize that the article is obviously irresponsible, and revocate or apologize as soon as possible.
Being a dancer takes a lot of effort and determination! It's not for everyone. If some dancers left the group, probably they need to find other ways and start a new journey, instead of complaining.
¡¡Toda la gloria para Shen Yun!! 💛✨ Muchas felicidades chicos, por el excelente trabajo que hacen y por lo que representan. Continúen así!! 🙌🏻Tienen el apoyo de mucha gente de todo el mundo. 😃
Thank you guys for all your support! We have read and appreciate all your comments 🙏
Keep doing what you guys are doing. These shorts on your YT really entertaining and show you guys are approachable and not weirdos.🤣🤣
謝謝！
I just finished watching your video and I am so sorry about that article. I love what you guys (the Three Musketeers) and you (Shen Yun) are doing so much! It's powerful and it's good and it's inspiring. Thank you and my prayers will be with you.💜
I have deep respect for the dancers. They are not only masters of their craft, but also convey a message of true beauty, kindness, and courage. This show is exactly what the world needs during these chaotic times. It’s disheartening to see how The New York Times reports on the show with such clear bias and negative intent.
Learned a lot from 3 musketeers about Shen Yun, and still learning ☘️🪷☀️
I know Shen Yun dancers with their message of kindness and high morality deliver a message of kindness to people in the world and they are not money-making machines. we all love Shen Yun 🩷🤗
It is wonderful that Shen Yun is reviving traditional Chinese culture. You all are doing an amazing job. I'm practicing my vocals every day, and I hope I can join you very soon!
Shen Yun has my full support and look forward to watching Shen Yun for the next year!!! 支持神韵，期待下一年的演出
Yay! Welcome back! It’s great to see you guys 😎
Firstly, so good to see you guys again!! 🤗… Poor journalism is so common unfortunately! I’ve seen claims about Shen Yun before, but it just doesn’t add up or match up to your vlogs! If people will only take a minute to see your content, I think they will see how warm and kind of a group of people you are! I will only be so fortunate to see a show someday!
Hi 3 Musketeers, we believe you guys!!
Please don’t take the negative, I know you guys work very hard with rehearsal. Stay strong, stay positive and give your audience the best performances. We will always be here to support Shen Yun and 3 Musketeers!! ^^
I have watched Shen Yun many times, and the performances are truly exceptional, deeply moving. The messages behind Shen Yun’s presentations are also very powerful. In these extraordinary times, I deeply cherish Shen Yun.
Thank you all.
First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win. I stand by Shenyun, nobody in this world can change that. Love you guys ❤❤❤
More things: They find your friends, colleagues or family to betray and accuse you.
I’ve watched SY 4 times and worked with the company 2 times.. very professional and compassionate people.. the performance truly awakens people’s hearts.. I believe this is the essence of SY.. to inspire hope and the courage to believe again.. truly a god tier performing arts company ❤
YOUR BACK!! WELCOME
Shenyun dancers are super powerful and inspiring and beautiful indeed 🎉🎉🎉👍👍👍
You guys are PHENOMENAL dancers and artists, and, from all I have seen, you are lovely people, as well. I’ve been so impressed by you in your videos that I have thought I would like to know you as friends.
I haven’t seen the article, so I don’t know what the criticism was referencing. I hope you can continue to move forward with confidence that you are seen and known for the fine individuals you are. You are endearing, in fact, and I imagine that you are loved by many.
Shen Yun is the best forever! You are the best! WE LOVE SHEN YUN FOREVER!
Thanks guys! Great to see you again, despite the circumstances.
I'm saddened that the NYT would post an unbalanced article where only one viewpoint is given. In any company or organization, there will always be some that are not happy, complain, and decide to leave. That doesn't make the places themselves are bad--it's just that not everything is for everyone. We all also have our own perspectives through which we view the world.
I hope NYT will do a follow-up article in which they present the views of those who have been with Shen Yun for a long time and have benefited as much, or more, as what they feel they have given. If NYT has the journalistic integrity that all fair and unbiased news sources should have, then they will certainly present the other side as well.
In the meantime, I think the 3 Musketeers past videos, as you point out, already refute the article's claims. And anyone who has seen Shen Yun, or even knows of someone who has seen and loved Shen Yun, will not be swayed by the negative comments of a handful of disgruntled people.
Please keep up the great work, stay focused, and don't let anything sidetrack you from the beauty and goodness you're spreading around the world!
Lastly, I hope the NYT article will have the opposite effect that's intended, and will instead serve as free advertising, and pique even more people's curiosity and interest in going to see Shen Yun:}
Love and support from Canada. You guys are the best!
YAY!! I've missed you all! I hope you've all had a good break and are doing well!
Thank you for letting us know about this, Shen Yun is so beautiful in every aspect
I think once people watch your videos, they’ll realize what the New York Times says is not true. Keep it up guys, love the videos.
THANK YOU FOR THIS. I LOVE AND SUPPORT SHEN YUEN
I know a friend in the company's social group who responded in the group that he knew most of the people who were interviewed in the negative NYT article. And what's in there doesn't reflect the truth. He was sad because one of them was once a very close friend.
That makes me very sad. Thank you for sharing!
@@johannaschwaiger6855 yeah just to let everyone know it's not a good thing that everyone supports. Because in the world there are good people and bad people. And importantly, when receiving information, we also need to consider it to avoid misunderstandings.
You three and Shen Yun are SuperGreat !!!!
Stay strong Shen Yun team! Nothing but, love for y’all!
Ignorance and bad media always attempts to bring others down. (They must live sad, miserable lives.)
Turn off the bad vibes … keep the good!
Y’all bring joy! ❤
I will see the show next year.
We will always support ShenYun🙏
Shenyu definitely has my full support.
How wonderful to see your lovely faces again! As far as the article is concerned, you will never get away from the frightened little people that just don't understand. Stay strong my friends, always here to support you. B xx
I watched SY, i love you
So sad for New York Times. But one such article can not make us stop loving Shen Yun and 3 Musketters 😊
I believe all the videos you guys have uploaded so far have already been enough to disprove NYT's article already. Thank you for doing another video specifically explain it!
And tbh, it's heartbreaking to think about how hard Shen Yun dancers practice all year round then having an article slandering their career like that😢 please know that your hard works and relentless efforts are never go unoticed! I and many other see, hear, and appreciate you guys!!!🤗☺
And just to add further, the current stage of this world is saddening😢 sacrilegious ugly performances like the Paris Olympic Opening are praised by the medias, while true genuinely beautiful art like Shen Yun's performances and hard-working pure-hearted dancer are condemmed. How concerning😢
Thanks for posting! Shen Yun is great!
Don’t give up. We support you.
The show you guys put up is so smazing I have never seen anything like that! You completly changed my atitude to music, my mind was opened to feel music, only something very harmonious and spiritual and kind can have such strong effect.... I don't know if someone was unhappy at some point but like you said there have to be some proportions... we are still humans after all... I know some people who actualy take part in the school and the show and they are so kind and profesional and they love it!!
The goodness you spread is so great I just hope many many more people will have a chance to see you!
Great video! Long time no see, guys.
Shen Yun is wonderful!
I belive that Shenyun is one of the best performance in the world now. You are the truth and active artists.
You guys are the best!! Love shenyun! definitely going to watch the show this year！💕
Welcome back guys!
Does NY times want to see "Diverse" dancers on the Shenyun stage like Paris2024 opening ceremony?
I am one of Shenyun audiences. I like to watch the pure Shenyun proformances on the stage.
All famous classical dancing company have only well-trained healthy and beautiful dancers.
Highly trained dancers don't have any exceed fat in their body at all.
We call this "Professionalism".
Hey, guys... good to see you. Sad to hear about the NY Times article that attempts to disparage Shen Yun. With all the beauty and goodness Shen Yun brings, I can't imagine highlighting the voices of a few who feel that they had a bad experience with the company. It is obvious that you all work very hard and yes--it takes discipline to produce a world-class show like Shen Yun. Your professionalism and dedication exudes from the stage.
Keep up the good work!
We stand by side with you guys 🎉
I feel sorry for the former dancers in the article and for The New York Times for publishing it. What they shared did not come from an objective perspective, nor did they consider others. This makes me think that it’s really hard to be a good person nowadays. When you strive to improve yourself every day, there are still people who criticize and slander you. The members of the Shen Yun Performing Arts are truly courageous and compassionate. You continue to be a role model for me to strive each day, helping me to be a better person and learn to empathize with others. Thank you so much!
Shen Yun is fabulous. That is not the truth, everything there is the best. Thanks for the hard work.😊
Are you saying that western media is as corrupt as CCP? So who should any one believe then?
we love shen yun thank you so much
My 16 year old son had his MCL, PCL and ACL surgery this summer!! He is walking w/o crutches and going to PT twice a week! The PT helps a lot so do not cancel your appointments!
I believe in Shen Yun. Every time I watch artists perform, I feel like my soul is being cleansed: there is no suffering, resentment,...
Shen Yun has opened my worldview a lot, helping my work get better and better. Not only that, since knowing Shen Yun, I have understood what true traditional culture and the meaning of human life are? I appreciate what Shen Yun has done for our world. When epidemics, wars, natural disasters, and human disasters are constantly happening. Shen Yun has given us ultimate faith and hope. That is extremely valuable. It is something we need to cherish and protect.
I think that the lies, slander, and distortions of the truth about Shen Yun are like a few dark clouds trying to hide the sun. But no matter what, from past to present, the sun always shines, and the truth is still the truth.
Shen Yun is truly breathtaking - a beautiful display of artistry and dedication. It's inspiring to see how they are reviving traditional Chinese culture with such grace and authenticity. It's sad to see such bias and negativity aimed at bringing down a performance that beautifully revives traditional Chinese culture. Instead of appreciating the artistry and cultural significance, some choose to focus on criticism. Let's value the talent and dedication that went into creating this remarkable show. I see Shen Yun every year and will always continue to support them ❤
Great points, guys! Keep the great work you are doing🎉
I am extremely upset about that non sense article😢, please keep it up Shen Yun and you are the best ❤ you rock ❤ 😊
i love Shenyun ❤❤❤❤, 🎉🎉
We are really love SHEN YUN ❤ THANK YOU 🙏🏻
Shen Yun is wonderful, thank you for bringing back the beautiful culture, good and healthy entertainment and eye catching
Shen Yun is amazing! Thank you all !
I think people don't care about that false article. They won't care about that stupid media company. Everyone knows how wonderful Shen Yun is. 🎉🎉🎉
The New York Times has lost its way. A lot of people in The US no longer read it because of the presumption and bias
So good to see you guys again. I miss your videos. Keep it up with or without videos!
always support Shen Yun and dancers
Don't care about that non sense article. We always support Shen Yun and guys.
你在乎那些孩子的童年吗？你只在乎自己是不是有精彩的演出可以看，对吧？
@@LePassClassiqueRTL 如果你認真看他們的頻道，我覺得你不會有這個留言。我相信每個孩子參加神韻不會被逼迫來參加的，而且成為頂級藝術水平不苦練能行嗎？西方孩子學芭樂舞也是從很小苦練學到成年才成為專業的。
judgment.judicial.gov.tw/LAW_Mobile_FJUD/FJUD/data.aspx?ty=JD&id=TPDM%2c99%2c%e8%81%b2%e5%88%a4%2c235%2c20110323%2c1&ot=in
li hongzhi has fled to south east asia and ordered falun gong to be disbanded（张清溪败诉）
@@AllisonWhiter-e3w 不好意思啊，我的獨立思想是這樣，我覺得你應該多看多聽吧！
@@AllisonWhiter-e3w 沒有人叫我去做好嗎？我已關注Shen Yun很久，每次新聞報導我都看，我可以分辨真假，你不用只看負面報導，我建議你找所有Shen Yun 官方報導從頭到尾看一遍，你會有客觀認識。
You are the best, keep doing good job!!!
It is so sad that a highly established company like Shen Yun is being attacked in such a low manner by NYT. First of all, you don't have to look far, look for the money and you find who is behind this. NYT is bowing for the CCP, therefore is not being reliable source of news and doesn't care for the FACTS. Secondly, Shen Yun is a high level performing arts that is to be compared with world top athletes. If you look into the life of an athlete, it is 100% about discipline and the right work attics. Without such discipline, they would never break world records. This is how I see what Shen Yun does, they perform at the world athlete type of a level, not like any ordinary dance company. That is also why they excel and people are so moved by what they do. This work attic is of course not suitable for everyone. Not everyone can become the top 1% in the world at their craft. But it is very sad that the previous workers, are joining in these attacks as it exposes even more how weak they are as human beings and are not fit for greatness. It is fine to be ordinary, but just don't go and complain about those who seek to become extraordinary. NYT is seeking the victim hood people and therefore their article is so poorly written and is almost like empty air to read. Clearly NYT is not seeking to become great at their craft either, but just succumbing to to bullies like the CCP! Shen Yun you are appreciated and are the best at what you do, it would be an honor for anyone to be part of your company!
The Shen Yun saved my life. I used to get paid to post posters in Chinatown of Boston & would always see the Shen Yun posters. I was walking by the Shen Yun performance and at that moment, a woman raised her arm that she had an extra ticket. The message of compassion, love, and integrity spoke to me profoundly. The hate you received in the news article should all the more show you the value of your work. Where hate is given, love is high, all coinciding w the msg of communism suppressing the love in China
You're back on your channel!!! woohoo!!!
Shen Yun is ❤
thank you for the sharing, and supporting always !!
Just read the article and so upset with NYTimes. NYT has lost its vibe as a long time and prestigous newspapers. Shenyun is doing so amazing to reset beautiful tradition art. Leave them alone to continue their mission!
支持3个优秀，正能量的年轻人
The motto of the NY Times is/was "All the News That's Fit to Print." Those of us who see how the NY Times pushes its views say, "All the News that Fits, We Print." Muckraking is a genuine term. They dig for issues and they find people willing to "dish the dirt." You guys are great. Stay strong. Stay beautiful.
We support you guys ❤
Remember how the mainstream media attacked Yale Law School Professor Amy Chua for her Confucius-style parenting of her two young children? She raised two wonderful young ladies, who came forward to defend their mom for applying high standard and strict discipline to their upbringing. Like the U.S. Marine, Shen Yun’s training isn’t for everyone. If some people don’t like to be held against high standard and strict discipline, they should go ahead and enjoy the freedom elsewhere.
I love Shenyun! ❤❤
In any company and work environment, there are disgruntled people. I’ve encountered many of them throughout my career and listened to their grievances. At times, I sympathized with them-we’re all human and have breaking points. Oftentimes, their concerns were well-founded. Yet, it’s the people who stay, continue working, and strive to make things better that deserve attention. They usually focus on the positive. It’s a different story if the mission isn’t relevant, but your mission is inspiring and needs to carry on!
神韻真的很棒，演出很精彩❤
When I read the article from the NYT, I was really surprised and saddened that they could report on Shen Yun in such a way. The first thing I can say is that looking at the demeanor and aura of the Shen Yun performers, they all exude positive energy. They are friendly and approachable. They train very hard, and I know it is very strenuous and difficult. I see the fatigue on their faces, but above all, they still respond with smiles that, to me, are very warm. Such things cannot be faked. You need to have a pure heart and a positive spirit to always maintain that state.
In life, conflict and disagreement are inevitable; they are a given, but they are not everything. We cannot let those negative things overshadow the meaningful and great things. And as the three musketeers shared, Shen Yun has been established for nearly 20 years, and the NYT could only find 25 people who expressed dissatisfaction. This information speaks volumes; Shen Yun has truly done an excellent job. We should all learn from them. We should not become narrow-minded and shallow people.
Thank you for the dedication of Shen Yun and the dancers. I wish you all the best.
Thank you guys for speaking up, I'm glad you are treated well. I just have a question: does Shen Yun provide medical insurance for its dancers / employees? You said you were flied out and got surgery quickly, then rehab, which are expensive I assume. What type of insurance did you have through SY (your employer), if any? Did you have to pay high premium / copay out of pocket?
Awesome 😎❤
i love Shenyun
It is disheartening to see supposedly free US media NY Times cooking up negative stories and working hard on influencing people with lies and deception. We love Shen Yun! And we hope there would be more Shen Yun companies traveling with new programs every year! 🥰💞
Shen Yun is wonderful
Shen Yun is the best forever~~~💗
神韻是很好的秀，看神韻學習到很多真正的中國傳統文化，很感動🙏🙏
Love Shenyun!
You can get anything written in the NYT with enough money (they probably needed to make payroll.)
Strongly believe in you guys and support you guys 💪💪💪💪💪💪🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🌹🌹🌹
Hey guys a, as much as attention gave the negative , will gane power . I work in met museum and no one cares about nonsense in media , on the contrary now u guys and shen yun be more famous.❤😅
The articles are terrible, but silver lining… THREE MUSKETEERS!!!
Don’t care what they said , they are just jealous
I’ve been watching for few times , I love the show ❤
有一段时间没见到三位了。见到三位很高兴。尽管听不懂三位说什么。
你使用TH-cam的自动翻译器，所以当他们三个说话时你就有中文字幕 🎉
It's funny that an us newspaper work for ccp
After NYT bad mouth about SY, I think people are curious if the statement is true, how those dancers preform freely on stage? logic. I encourage you see SY yourself ✨
WE know that Shen Yun artists and performers do practice a spiritual school. And WE know that engaging in a spiritual practice involves sacrifices as well as blessings 🌷WE have seen this in so many spiritual communities like some christians' confréries etc...thus, some things such as thé fact that thé mind state of a person and his physical health are interconnected- are things quite known and common in spiritual communities. What IS saddening IS that most of thé speech of thèse former Shen Yun members IS OUT OF CONTEXT....many things they spoke about simply Shouldn't bé adressed liké that. I believe that they simply didn't understand what they were doing or practiticing.
And even in that case, they could have quitely quitted without badmouthing or stirring trouble 🙁
love you guys
During the Renaissance, I'm sure there were mediocre artists who were jealous of great ones like Michelangelo, Raphael and Da Vinci. During the lifetime of great composers like Mozart, Bach and Beethoven, I'm sure there were mediocre composers who were jealous of them. Whenever there are outstanding artists creating outstanding works, there are petty people trying to bring them down. But as long as the outstanding artists keep producing their beautiful works, people will look for them and be inspired by them.
See you in the next season.🎉
Shenyun is the best forever
祝你们成功！更上一层楼！
I have an idea, put New York Times on stage next year in the performance, I think they could not wait to be the “bad” guys, 😂😂
We don't need their name on the stage.
Shenyun put what happened in China on the stage because their life are really being threatened. They need to show that to people to contribute to stop those things. If not going to that serious step, they will not do so.
When I watched Shen Yun, I noticed the recurring theme of good people being oppressed-whether by communists in modern times, by corrupt individuals in ancient days,but finally justice served… and now, a media jumped out and labeled themselves as “bad”, apart being pathetic, they could also be used into the stories as a different form of “bad guy” and I want to see the justice comes sooner, on the stage.
I see… but NYT thinks they are powerful and can lie with no cost. That’s not the case.
@Loxinary Thank you for replying. Mostly, you may be right, but I think they will not let people label themselves as bad so easily. About 1999, they also gave the ccp government enough time to know about them that they don't have any hostile and threat to the government, and they're just a group of people who use "truthfulness, compassion, tolerance" as principle to require themselves, but finally ccp still persecuted them even never stopped. I hope NYT can realize that the article is obviously irresponsible, and revocate or apologize as soon as possible.
Being a dancer takes a lot of effort and determination! It's not for everyone. If some dancers left the group, probably they need to find other ways and start a new journey, instead of complaining.
¡¡Toda la gloria para Shen Yun!! 💛✨ Muchas felicidades chicos, por el excelente trabajo que hacen y por lo que representan. Continúen así!! 🙌🏻Tienen el apoyo de mucha gente de todo el mundo. 😃