I did a similar decision process of Hamilton field watches a couple of months ago & landed on the [42mm] Murph which I’m very happy with. With another brand’s field watch (Vaer) I had found having the somewhat traditional 12/24 hour markers was redundant & therefore took away some of its appeal. The Murph’s simplicity is part of why it resonates with me.
I adore Hamilton... I have four (the Murph being my favourite)! I agree with your selection, but my personal presence would be black or green. I am still catching up on my missed TH-cam videos, so am looking forward to watch your review of the Hammy!
Great video. Thanks. This is helping me decide myself. Which size to go for is a really tough choice for me. I did like the day date at 12 o’clock but you’ve definitely talked me out of it.
@@adventureswithtime I’m between the one you chose and the basic field mechanical. Edit: I surprised myself And went for the Khaki Field Mechanical. My usual style is a large diver or racing watch.
you remind me of my godfather with how methodical you are, and how you process things (one of my favorite people). Great video, and I hope you're enjoying your Hammy field!
I am ready to pull the trigger on one. But why do people complain about the water resistance/ damage? Are these watches allergic to water? Is the lack of screw down a problem? A field watch that survives a war, survives water?
I think it is all psychology. I for one will probably never go in the water deeper than 5 meters (about 15 feet). So certainly a 100m watch is more than I need. But its that fear, not a rational fear, that we shouldn't subject a non-diver to any water. In fact, I only use certain watches in the water; not even some of my divers. Perhaps it's a fear of scratching the watch on something; or that I might not have fully secured the crown. I'm not saying this is logical; rather the theory of "why take the chance" during those infrequent times I go swimming. I do tend to baby most of my watches except for what I consider my beater watches. Its something I'm trying to get over.
@@adventureswithtime Thanks, very rational thinking. Even for dive watches, the promaster for example, Citizen states that it should be serviced yearly to maintain it's 200m divers rating. At the end, everything can leak when not taking care of.
Interesting choice. I went for the blue version myself. I was kind of interested in the brown but I couldn't really imagine what other straps would go well with it and what clothes it would suit. What's your personal experience?
I wanted brown since I thought it more appropriate for a field watch. BTW, I've since passed this watch on to a new home in an effort to reduce my collection. My 2020 SOTC video talks about that.
@@adventureswithtime The Khaki Field Auto as it has a date function. I’m just scared to ruin its looks with scratches all over the place. I also like the Murph, which also has no date…
@@Prof.SchulzeSternberg I understand your concern for scratches. Watch my video on scratching my BB58 th-cam.com/video/XmRFnM41-ZE/w-d-xo.html Also, I made an complete review of Hamilton's field watches th-cam.com/video/KD1vpg2yA8E/w-d-xo.html
@@adventureswithtime both excellent videos, thanks. I had seen the overview about Hamilton models before. Scratches still bother me massively. 😉 on the other hand I do think that the khaki field Auto is easier to dress up with a suit or a blazer, what do you think. I’ll be going to Berlin tomorrow to see all the models at once…
To truly go old school you would want one with no day date complications. That being said that was then and this is now. My favorites are the Khaki King in black or champagne or the manual wind in black. I own three Hamiltons and black in any version gives you tons more strap options. All said and done they are all great watches including the quartz models. I can’t seem to take them off my wrist leaving my others gathering dust. Whatever you decide will be a great choice. Enjoy
Great insight. Thanks. I've come to respect Hamilton in greater light. Sorry for the delayed response. I need to get into the practice of responding to viewers in a more timely manner. Viewers deserve that from me. Thank you
Bob, I understand the size factor for you in selection. But exclusion of mechanical? I enjoy winding a watch in the morning before I put it on. (It was a factor in my choice of Stowa Fleiger which I think is near the most perfect of watches.)
Great video and great choice of brand in the Hamilton. I prefer the Khaki Field Mechanical because I prefer the hand wound movement and it fits my 7 inch wrist perfect.
Thanks for watching. I was really considering that mechanical. It's size just didn't look right on my wrist. BTW, I picked up a brown leather NATO for the Hamilton (you can see it in my latest video). But I think I like the two piece from this video much better. Thanks for watching.
Nice analysis. I agree with your final choice; however, for me, I think the brown dial is a little harder to quickly tell the time vs. the blue dial. I'd op for blue but either would be a very nice looking field watch.
I enjoyed this. I hope you like your watch. Personally I think the numerals are too crammed into the centre of your choice. I plan on buying the Hamilton Khaki H69439931 all mechanical in black. Of course it's all personal preference. Isn't that the great part of watch buying? Everyone has different taste. All the best.
I used a similar deduction for me and my final two were the 42mm auto and the 38mm mechanical. I went with the mech bc one of my colleagues got pulled the trigger on the auto and I felt awkward about wearing the same watch
lol. No problem having the same watch as others. Especially if you have a collection where the chances you both wear the same watch on the same day would be lowered. But good choice on the 38mm mechanical. I wish they would come out with a 40mm mechanical. Thanks for watching.
I bought the khaki king. Your negatives were positives for me . I gravitate towards classic designs with a little modern flair . A little panache if you will . Great video I like your style .
From the pictures I think I would have gone for the green or the blue, purely based on clarity and contrast of hands and numerals against the dial background. Perhaps this difference is less in real-life.
Thanks for your work. Although I don’t understand English well, your opinion helped me determine my choice of Hamilton. Just in the selection of watches of this brand.
Excellent review - Like the side by side comparison using Excel. I often make comparisons using Excel myself, when I consider many different options for watches (or other items). After watching this review, I'm considering a 38 mm Hamilton Field Khaki (the 80 hour reserve H70455533).
I really like your side by side comparison. I mostly agree with your style. Less is more for me. I am gearing up for retirement and don't need the day or date anymore. I plan on unplugging from this train wreck of society. My choice ended up being the Bulova VWI Hack. Fits my wrist.
I've got a H70515137 42mm on steel bracelet, ETA 2824-2. Bought new in 2006. It started out as a H70555533 for the first few years until I wore out the leather strap. It's my only EDC.
@@adventureswithtime I've got a modest Hamilton Collection of 6. Do you want a Great Swiss made ETA movement? Do you want Great Quality build? Do you want Awesome, timeless Designs? Do you want a Brand with a Great Heritage and History. Do you want Great Bang for your Buck, aka Great Value? Do you want Great Service, by SWATCHGROUP international warreny service? One word................."Hamilton" I buy the best and stare at the rest. 😎
Hey Steven Do you still have the watch? I wonder how the PVD coating is after 2 years of wear and tear. Love the model, but as an everyday watch, the PVD sways me away a little. Much appreciated.
@@dvon0134 Still good no visible scratches or dings, plus I think titanium is darker than stainless so scratches probably wouldn't show much anyway, even if they were visible, I just consider them patina or character! 🙂👍
I have never heard of Weiss but will definitely give them a looksee. Thanks for the recommendation. Sorry for the delayed response. I need to get into the practice of responding to viewers in a more timely manner. Viewers deserve that from me. Thank you
Thank you for watching and hopefully you've subscribed 😉. And keep providing me feedback. It's through these exchanges that I learn more about the hobby and what people like/dislike about my channel so I can improve my content.
I totally agree. I tried it on in a different color and then ordered the one I wanted. By doing this I discovered that I didn’t like the Murph on my wrist. Thanks for watching and your insight
Great video, I’ve been trying to decide on which one myself between the 38m Mechanical with the black face, the Murph and an auto with the day date. I need to just stumble on like 3 grand so I can get all of them😒
Hamilton is lovely, but get the real deal :-). Go for an IWC Mark XVI at 39mm with the legendary ETA 2892-A2 movement. Three hand movement with date complication. In my opinion the perfect field watch. Buy it secondhand so the depreciation is already baked in. Whatever you choose I'm sure it'll be great so enjoy!
Lorus lumibrite, beats the khaki king field and day. Everything is better on the lorus and its about 380€ cheaper 😀 these Hamilton's are over hyped and overpriced.
I have a new Hamilton khaki field automatic 38 mm . I love it .
David Coleman thanks for watching my video(s). Happy watch wearing
I love how methodical you are in deciding on the watch.
Comes from my computer science background.
I did a similar decision process of Hamilton field watches a couple of months ago & landed on the [42mm] Murph which I’m very happy with. With another brand’s field watch (Vaer) I had found having the somewhat traditional 12/24 hour markers was redundant & therefore took away some of its appeal. The Murph’s simplicity is part of why it resonates with me.
Did you see my recent video where I cover all of Hamilton’s field watches?
@@adventureswithtime
I watched it last night actually.
I adore Hamilton... I have four (the Murph being my favourite)! I agree with your selection, but my personal presence would be black or green. I am still catching up on my missed TH-cam videos, so am looking forward to watch your review of the Hammy!
4 Hamiltons! That's great.
I'm thinking about purchasing the khaki mechanical 38mm in white
Good luck with you selection. I’m sure you will enjoy whatever you select
I totally agree with the choice. The brown dial watch looks much more 'field' than any of the others.
It was a good choice for this field watch. But I did sell it later to make room in my collection for a vintage WW2 watch.
I have the green 40mm and it's fantastic.
Which model?
I nearly went with the King but ended up on the Murph. I love the king day date position.
The Murph certainly has it's place as a watch/movie crossover item. I think the little touch of morse code was cool.
The best of the bunch was the Field King Auto, with 80 hours of power reserve.
It's a nice watch. I just didn't like to positioning of the day and date on this model.
Great video. Thanks. This is helping me decide myself. Which size to go for is a really tough choice for me. I did like the day date at 12 o’clock but you’ve definitely talked me out of it.
Did you buy one?
@@adventureswithtime I’m between the one you chose and the basic field mechanical. Edit: I surprised myself And went for the Khaki Field Mechanical. My usual style is a large diver or racing watch.
Chose literally the first reference you crossed out. Found this video immensely helpful though, thank you.
Glad it was helpful. I'm sure you'll enjoy the watch. Tell your friends about my channel so I can continue to make content.
you remind me of my godfather with how methodical you are, and how you process things (one of my favorite people). Great video, and I hope you're enjoying your Hammy field!
Thanks. Maybe it's my age or my career that makes me methodical in my thinking.
Best Hamilton Field Watch video ever , hands down . Thank You .
Wow. Thank you
I love this style of video. I’m also trying to figure out what Hamilton to buy. Either Khaki, jazzmaster or is I’m really daring the Ventura.
There are lots of watches from which to choose. And you may find that you loose interest in some watches after you've had them for a while. Good luck.
I am ready to pull the trigger on one. But why do people complain about the water resistance/ damage? Are these watches allergic to water? Is the lack of screw down a problem? A field watch that survives a war, survives water?
I think it is all psychology. I for one will probably never go in the water deeper than 5 meters (about 15 feet). So certainly a 100m watch is more than I need. But its that fear, not a rational fear, that we shouldn't subject a non-diver to any water. In fact, I only use certain watches in the water; not even some of my divers. Perhaps it's a fear of scratching the watch on something; or that I might not have fully secured the crown. I'm not saying this is logical; rather the theory of "why take the chance" during those infrequent times I go swimming. I do tend to baby most of my watches except for what I consider my beater watches. Its something I'm trying to get over.
@@adventureswithtime Thanks, very rational thinking. Even for dive watches, the promaster for example, Citizen states that it should be serviced yearly to maintain it's 200m divers rating. At the end, everything can leak when not taking care of.
Interesting choice. I went for the blue version myself. I was kind of interested in the brown but I couldn't really imagine what other straps would go well with it and what clothes it would suit. What's your personal experience?
I wanted brown since I thought it more appropriate for a field watch. BTW, I've since passed this watch on to a new home in an effort to reduce my collection. My 2020 SOTC video talks about that.
Sand-blasted mechanical vs polished Auto, which one would y´all think is more scratch resistant?
Clearly sand blasted. But which look do you like better?
@@adventureswithtime The Khaki Field Auto as it has a date function. I’m just scared to ruin its looks with scratches all over the place. I also like the Murph, which also has no date…
@@Prof.SchulzeSternberg I understand your concern for scratches. Watch my video on scratching my BB58 th-cam.com/video/XmRFnM41-ZE/w-d-xo.html Also, I made an complete review of Hamilton's field watches th-cam.com/video/KD1vpg2yA8E/w-d-xo.html
@@adventureswithtime both excellent videos, thanks. I had seen the overview about Hamilton models before. Scratches still bother me massively. 😉 on the other hand I do think that the khaki field Auto is easier to dress up with a suit or a blazer, what do you think. I’ll be going to Berlin tomorrow to see all the models at once…
@@Prof.SchulzeSternberg I agree about dressing up the Khaki field auto. Good luck on your watch hunting.
To truly go old school you would want one with no day date complications. That being said that was then and this is now. My favorites are the Khaki King in black or champagne or the manual wind in black. I own three Hamiltons and black in any version gives you tons more strap options. All said and done they are all great watches including the quartz models. I can’t seem to take them off my wrist leaving my others gathering dust. Whatever you decide will be a great choice. Enjoy
Great insight. Thanks. I've come to respect Hamilton in greater light.
Sorry for the delayed response. I need to get into the practice of responding to viewers in a more timely manner. Viewers deserve that from me. Thank you
Bob, I understand the size factor for you in selection. But exclusion of mechanical? I enjoy winding a watch in the morning before I put it on. (It was a factor in my choice of Stowa Fleiger which I think is near the most perfect of watches.)
I’ve come to appreciate non-automatic watches more. Being an automatic is not a criteria for me anymore
Great video and great choice of brand in the Hamilton. I prefer the Khaki Field Mechanical because I prefer the hand wound movement and it fits my 7 inch wrist perfect.
Thanks for watching. I was really considering that mechanical. It's size just didn't look right on my wrist. BTW, I picked up a brown leather NATO for the Hamilton (you can see it in my latest video). But I think I like the two piece from this video much better. Thanks for watching.
Nice analysis. I agree with your final choice; however, for me, I think the brown dial is a little harder to quickly tell the time vs. the blue dial. I'd op for blue but either would be a very nice looking field watch.
Bryce thanks for providing your input. I really like to hear other opinions
This is one of the most helpful videos I have ever seen on TH-cam! Thank you!
Thank you. Tell your friends so we can get my channel viewed by more people and I can make even more great videos.
I enjoyed this. I hope you like your watch. Personally I think the numerals are too crammed into the centre of your choice. I plan on buying the Hamilton Khaki H69439931 all mechanical in black. Of course it's all personal preference. Isn't that the great part of watch buying? Everyone has different taste. All the best.
BTW, I have another video coming out in mid-Jan where I cover all of the Hamilton Khaki Field watches.
I used a similar deduction for me and my final two were the 42mm auto and the 38mm mechanical. I went with the mech bc one of my colleagues got pulled the trigger on the auto and I felt awkward about wearing the same watch
lol. No problem having the same watch as others. Especially if you have a collection where the chances you both wear the same watch on the same day would be lowered. But good choice on the 38mm mechanical. I wish they would come out with a 40mm mechanical. Thanks for watching.
I bought the khaki king. Your negatives were positives for me . I gravitate towards classic designs with a little modern flair . A little panache if you will . Great video I like your style .
Thanks for watching. And thanks for injecting your thoughts. I love hearing what other people are doing.
From the pictures I think I would have gone for the green or the blue, purely based on clarity and contrast of hands and numerals against the dial background. Perhaps this difference is less in real-life.
I felt green matched the field watch style best.
Thanks for your work. Although I don’t understand English well, your opinion helped me determine my choice of Hamilton. Just in the selection of watches of this brand.
Glad I could help.
Excellent review - Like the side by side comparison using Excel. I often make comparisons using Excel myself, when I consider many different options for watches (or other items). After watching this review, I'm considering a 38 mm Hamilton Field Khaki (the 80 hour reserve H70455533).
TaswcmT not a bad choice. I always try to see the watch in person and on my wrist before making a decision. Good luck
Nice vid! What is your wrist size?
Thanks. 7 7/8 inches. Have you seen my recent video that shows ALL Hamilton field watches?
@@adventureswithtime thanks and yes, I have!
I really like your side by side comparison. I mostly agree with your style. Less is more for me. I am gearing up for retirement and don't need the day or date anymore. I plan on unplugging from this train wreck of society. My choice ended up being the Bulova VWI Hack. Fits my wrist.
I recently uploaded a review of all of Hamilton’s field watch collection
May I ask your thoughts on the Titanium models? Why did you not include them in your list?
Because I was looking for a basic steal watch.
I've got a H70515137 42mm on steel bracelet, ETA 2824-2. Bought new in 2006. It started out as a H70555533 for the first few years until I wore out the leather strap. It's my only EDC.
Hamilton-Juan sounds like you are a real fan of Hamilton
@@adventureswithtime I've got a modest Hamilton Collection of 6. Do you want a Great Swiss made ETA movement? Do you want Great Quality build? Do you want Awesome, timeless Designs? Do you want a Brand with a Great Heritage and History. Do you want Great Bang for your Buck, aka Great Value? Do you want Great Service, by SWATCHGROUP international warreny service? One word................."Hamilton" I buy the best and stare at the rest. 😎
Hamilton-Juan nicely stated. They should make you a representative:)
I bought this watch on Amazon for 349. The next day it's selling for 549. I'm glad I grabbed it when I did
Good catch. Enjoy
I like you deductive process. Never been a fan of Hamiltion, but I'll give them a second look now. Thanks.
Thanks for watching. I find I often change my mind about watches and brands. But everyone has different tastes.
i have a Khaki, wish it had more of a dome and way less glare. Casio and Timex can do it why cant. Hamilton?
It’s a design choice. What about a dome crystal do you like?
that's a great way to deduce choices
Tippy Kaffu it comes from my analytical background. Glad you enjoyed it and thanks for watching.
Yep good choice, I went with the black pvd titanium version about 2 years ago I really like it, good content and vids!
Steven thank you for the nice comment
Hey Steven
Do you still have the watch? I wonder how the PVD coating is after 2 years of wear and tear. Love the model, but as an everyday watch, the PVD sways me away a little. Much appreciated.
@@dvon0134 Still good no visible scratches or dings, plus I think titanium is darker than stainless so scratches probably wouldn't show much anyway, even if they were visible, I just consider them patina or character! 🙂👍
@@steven3379 that's lovely to hear. Really appreciate the reply.
Wowwww. Thank you
Thank you. Glad it helped
some owners say, water resistance sucks. is that true???
I couldn't tell you what the actual water resistance is on this watch. I only go in water with a true diver like my Seiko Samurai.
Great video! I’m also debating which to buy.
1J1A tough decision. Good luck and let us know what you buy and why. Always nice to hear other people’s thoughts
Great review
Thank you. I appreciate you watching and your feedback.
Did you look at Weiss? A microbrand from Los Angeles with some really interesting field watches (though not your preferred size..).
I have never heard of Weiss but will definitely give them a looksee. Thanks for the recommendation.
Sorry for the delayed response. I need to get into the practice of responding to viewers in a more timely manner. Viewers deserve that from me. Thank you
This is a very late post BUT…the Long Island Watch company in NJ has an outstanding option!!!!! $199
You mean Marc at Long Island Watch? He is not in NJ.
Great video and selection
Thank you for watching and hopefully you've subscribed 😉. And keep providing me feedback. It's through these exchanges that I learn more about the hobby and what people like/dislike about my channel so I can improve my content.
From your final choice your forgot the Old Paper one! Such a pity
Wow, you are correct. A very nice dial.
why you dont have the H60455833??? is my watch and is Perfect
Very Nice
Great reviews, thank you.
Martin Smith thanks for the kind words. Next video hopefully going up this weekend.
Hamilton khaki field automatic 38mm
I'm still considering it.
You have to buy it at the store where you tried all the watches on your wrist. Simple.
I totally agree. I tried it on in a different color and then ordered the one I wanted. By doing this I discovered that I didn’t like the Murph on my wrist.
Thanks for watching and your insight
Great video, I’ve been trying to decide on which one myself between the 38m Mechanical with the black face, the Murph and an auto with the day date. I need to just stumble on like 3 grand so I can get all of them😒
Bigaletto good luck. Maybe one at a time.
Hamilton is lovely, but get the real deal :-). Go for an IWC Mark XVI at 39mm with the legendary ETA 2892-A2 movement. Three hand movement with date complication. In my opinion the perfect field watch. Buy it secondhand so the depreciation is already baked in. Whatever you choose I'm sure it'll be great so enjoy!
mike jones yup that is a nice watch
Hi
Kevin Horne hi to you
Lorus lumibrite, beats the khaki king field and day. Everything is better on the lorus and its about 380€ cheaper 😀 these Hamilton's are over hyped and overpriced.
Not my cup of tea; but thanks.
Black face, 38mm, date, auto for me. $695.