I really love these reaction videos ❤ and Rozette’s style. As a non singer, her comments help me to appreciate the great singers even more with their intricate techniques and more discerning with others. Very well done and looking forward to see more and more!
Love Rozette's reaction (and insights) videos so far. Piques my interest in the technical side of singing and recording. 👂Can't wait for Rozette's reaction to JJ's 输了你赢了世界又如何. Let's go for a roller coaster ride~ woo hoo~
I think many music videos here in Asia tends to edit a lot, but personally I'm ok with that. The reason I love those videos is that they're always so creative and fun to watch.
It's always fun to hear Henry and the rest of his circle of English speaking kpop celebs get together and have fun (I don't know them all), esp cos they've all had such a difficult time in Korea - most of them having to learn the language from scratch. So, despite how edited it is, I think it's nice to hear Henry, Ailee and any of the others like Amber, Jackson, Eric, etc do music together. I do agree though, that most of Henry's stuff seems to be heavily edited, but i can put that aside because of the creativity he tends to bring. Honestly, he and his friends are quite creative, although not all super popular. It's a pity their schedules don't allow them to get together much, nor do we get to see them messing around musically together. Oh, some live singing things that would be interesting to see would be Korea's Begin Again series. Mostly live singing - cos theyre basically busking in various foreign countries, but very interesting to see the mix of different styles come together.
LOVE Rozette's reactions! Strongly recommand she react to Tan Weiwei's "the night at Ulaanbaatar", she will be amazed, and most importanly want to hear her comments from technical and artistic perspectives! Cheers!
For me, how to enjoy a song is if the sound can hit my heart , I do not know about the technique of vocal , I just follow my feeling to drop me into an magic show 🎉, I love this stage very much, but by the teacher’s introduction can let me know why I love some kind of singer; thank you very much
It's obvious that you haven't heard her live because what you see is what you get, she is a top top South Korean ARTIST and has been for a long time 🇬🇧🔥👌❤️.
There is also such a Korean show "Superbend", it's for the soul) It was attended by so many different talented singers and musicians, who are gathered into temporary groups closer to the final, and their performance is very strong, since all the guys are very talented and professional in playing musical instruments and their voices are much stronger than those of k-pop groups. It seems to me that such musicians remain undervalued, in the shadow of pop music🤔😔
No they are not a duo. They are just friends. And henry had this thing going on on his youtube channel to sing with his singer friends. He is a great artist and a social butterfly too.
thank u so so soooooo so much❤ now i finally know why and what i always so confused about these songs. She is one of my favorite singer,there’s no way she can’t sing well. there are so many great singers and they always have some weird performances. i understand now totally 😢 this is rexxxx editing,I can not agree more.
There is such a Japanese band One ok Rock and the soloist Taka sang the song Adele - Hello, very beautiful, I would like you to listen and tell your professional opinion about this vocalist. And then there is such a singer Dimash, he has a huge range of octaves, he also performed at a Chinese singer show, although he is from Kazakhstan
Cannot agree with you more - the music industry nowadays especially the k-pop industry is so obsessed with “perfection”, “perfect” vocals or perfected vocals …their ears have been so attuned to them without them realising it, and refuse to open their ears and mind to anything else. Even real live singing vocals have usually been backed by a loud backing track (which is okay and totally understandable when you’re dancing and moving). My point is, these smoothed and edited vocals take away all the raw quality of a voice and its beautiful natural resonance, and many listeners don’t realise that and withdraw from what they think are “flaws”. That’s a shame. Our natural voice is a gift and how listeners resonate to it live is such a beautiful thing.
Hi Rozett, since you are reacting to Korean singers, can you please react to Sohyang? In my opinion, she is the best singer in Korea, East Asia, even the best singer alive now
Nowadays, songs are like photos. Many people pursue perfection by editing the sound or photos. I'm a perfectionist, but by perfection I mean 100% natural. Nature is the most real and perfect thing in the world. I very much agree with the teacher's comments on the singers and the subsequent production of the band or producer. I accept both, but I’m more inclined towards natural perfection.
I read all the comments posted and I still have a new question. :-) One thing I have found interesting is that the K-Pop music industry is actually close to the US industry. There has been a lot of interaction. I don't have any real statistics, but it would not surprise me if as much as 20% of K-Pop artists were either born or at least partially raised in North America. In this case, both Ailee and Henry were both foreign born. Ailee was mentioned by someone else born in Colorado(?) and raised in New Jersey, but Henry was born in Canada, just north or where I lived. I think Red Velvet's Wendy was born or raised in Markham too wasn't she? I was wondering if Rozette noticed a difference in their accents. Ailee in particular always sounded a bit "America" even when I heard her singing in Korean. That always makes me smile!
Could you do a reaction video of taeyeon please???? She’s one of the member in girls’ generation, kinda legendary kpop female group, and taeyeon is the main vocal and leader. She’d also launched few solo albums and her voice is amazing, she is famous for her powerful voice. Of course most of her singing clips are edited (cuz korean really loves to do that, idk why) but I guess you may find some of her unedited singing clips.
I LOVE Ailee's voice. She is a big star in South Korea. She was born in Denver, Colorado, and raised in New Jersey.
完全瞞不過老師的專業，老師太厲害了~❤
希望老師可以聽聽看 樂童音樂家 AKMU 的Dinosaur，秀賢的音色也很漂亮
同意，想要老师分析一下AKMU阿童木的歌😍😍😍
推😂
I really love these reaction videos ❤ and Rozette’s style. As a non singer, her comments help me to appreciate the great singers even more with their intricate techniques and more discerning with others. Very well done and looking forward to see more and more!
Did you hear Her at the end of the video..😅😂😂
感謝老師的評論, 每一次的評論/影片中 都可以學到東西. 非常喜歡老師的評語
'No One，Seesthese👌🙏🙏 lonely night view
Love Rozette's reaction (and insights) videos so far. Piques my interest in the technical side of singing and recording. 👂Can't wait for Rozette's reaction to JJ's 输了你赢了世界又如何. Let's go for a roller coaster ride~ woo hoo~
喜歡老師的真性情❤❤
No 週深 nobody sees Chinese around the world number one👌👌👌👌🙏🙏🙏
I think many music videos here in Asia tends to edit a lot, but personally I'm ok with that. The reason I love those videos is that they're always so creative and fun to watch.
It's always fun to hear Henry and the rest of his circle of English speaking kpop celebs get together and have fun (I don't know them all), esp cos they've all had such a difficult time in Korea - most of them having to learn the language from scratch. So, despite how edited it is, I think it's nice to hear Henry, Ailee and any of the others like Amber, Jackson, Eric, etc do music together. I do agree though, that most of Henry's stuff seems to be heavily edited, but i can put that aside because of the creativity he tends to bring. Honestly, he and his friends are quite creative, although not all super popular. It's a pity their schedules don't allow them to get together much, nor do we get to see them messing around musically together.
Oh, some live singing things that would be interesting to see would be Korea's Begin Again series. Mostly live singing - cos theyre basically busking in various foreign countries, but very interesting to see the mix of different styles come together.
乾我只覺得⋯坐著唱這首太強了吧⋯甚至還是坐的很隨性那種⋯⋯
LOVE Rozette's reactions! Strongly recommand she react to Tan Weiwei's "the night at Ulaanbaatar", she will be amazed, and most importanly want to hear her comments from technical and artistic perspectives! Cheers!
nice, thank you for your insight!
For me, how to enjoy a song is if the sound can hit my heart , I do not know about the technique of vocal , I just follow my feeling to drop me into an magic show 🎉, I love this stage very much, but by the teacher’s introduction can let me know why I love some kind of singer; thank you very much
It's obvious that you haven't heard her live because what you see is what you get, she is a top top South Korean ARTIST and has been for a long time 🇬🇧🔥👌❤️.
Teacher, u got a lovely voice…. ❤
這組合真的超讚表演❤超專業公平講評💜👍
劉憲華真是全能，連合音都這麼棒
很高興能看到ailee❤
Henry劉憲華🎻🎹是毕业于伯克利音乐学院，寶藏全能音樂藝術家 ，大華🎻古典音樂注入了青春活力，才華橫溢，真棒👍
希望聽到太妍的點評,因為老師你太公正了,支持
love your vids
Hi voice teacher just keep be yourself and be honest. U r best teacher cheers
There is also such a Korean show "Superbend", it's for the soul) It was attended by so many different talented singers and musicians, who are gathered into temporary groups closer to the final, and their performance is very strong, since all the guys are very talented and professional in playing musical instruments and their voices are much stronger than those of k-pop groups.
It seems to me that such musicians remain undervalued, in the shadow of pop music🤔😔
想看老師評論一些老歌 像是张雨生唱的大海
如果能看到老师点评AILEE的单人曲就好了！她的打歌舞台甚至电台的现场演唱都挺不错的，谢谢老师！
被封殺了
我也覺得粉絲拍的LIVE版本都比這些好
Ailee could be NO1 korea vocalist in pop music IMO
哇哦是我喜欢的人ailee！！！！
Humanize is very important than PREFECT 👍
No they are not a duo. They are just friends. And henry had this thing going on on his youtube channel to sing with his singer friends. He is a great artist and a social butterfly too.
能讓老師聽聽看葉秉桓在天籟之戰唱的 「小半」嗎 拜託了 華人少有的絲滑轉音 個人覺得也不會突兀 感謝你們的影片 希望你們能看到這則留言
thank u so so soooooo so much❤
now i finally know why and what i always so confused about these songs.
She is one of my favorite singer,there’s no way she can’t sing well.
there are so many great singers and they always have some weird performances.
i understand now totally 😢
this is rexxxx editing,I can not agree more.
求韓國節目Begin again season3 或4或korean篇的歌曲🥺🥺🥺
There is such a Japanese band One ok Rock and the soloist Taka sang the song Adele - Hello, very beautiful, I would like you to listen and tell your professional opinion about this vocalist.
And then there is such a singer Dimash, he has a huge range of octaves, he also performed at a Chinese singer show, although he is from Kazakhstan
喜歡在關錄影之後說的真話。😂
Cannot agree with you more - the music industry nowadays especially the k-pop industry is so obsessed with “perfection”, “perfect” vocals or perfected vocals …their ears have been so attuned to them without them realising it, and refuse to open their ears and mind to anything else. Even real live singing vocals have usually been backed by a loud backing track (which is okay and totally understandable when you’re dancing and moving). My point is, these smoothed and edited vocals take away all the raw quality of a voice and its beautiful natural resonance, and many listeners don’t realise that and withdraw from what they think are “flaws”. That’s a shame. Our natural voice is a gift and how listeners resonate to it live is such a beautiful thing.
Hi Rozett, since you are reacting to Korean singers, can you please react to Sohyang? In my opinion, she is the best singer in Korea, East Asia, even the best singer alive now
Nowadays, songs are like photos. Many people pursue perfection by editing the sound or photos. I'm a perfectionist, but by perfection I mean 100% natural. Nature is the most real and perfect thing in the world. I very much agree with the teacher's comments on the singers and the subsequent production of the band or producer. I accept both, but I’m more inclined towards natural perfection.
路one
Strongly recommend Sohyang’s Arirang live. It’s one of the most insane things I’ve ever heard !
Fun fact: Ailee audited for American Idol years ago! 🩵
是的
I read all the comments posted and I still have a new question. :-) One thing I have found interesting is that the K-Pop music industry is actually close to the US industry. There has been a lot of interaction. I don't have any real statistics, but it would not surprise me if as much as 20% of K-Pop artists were either born or at least partially raised in North America. In this case, both Ailee and Henry were both foreign born. Ailee was mentioned by someone else born in Colorado(?) and raised in New Jersey, but Henry was born in Canada, just north or where I lived. I think Red Velvet's Wendy was born or raised in Markham too wasn't she? I was wondering if Rozette noticed a difference in their accents. Ailee in particular always sounded a bit "America" even when I heard her singing in Korean. That always makes me smile!
Could you do a reaction video of taeyeon please???? She’s one of the member in girls’ generation, kinda legendary kpop female group, and taeyeon is the main vocal and leader. She’d also launched few solo albums and her voice is amazing, she is famous for her powerful voice. Of course most of her singing clips are edited (cuz korean really loves to do that, idk why) but I guess you may find some of her unedited singing clips.
Can you do 周菲戈《Simon》, I think he is one of the rising stars in China nowadays that really impress us
希望老師聽JC 陳詠桐❤
Son Seungyeon
Wendy
Sohyang
I recommend you listen to the song 'I Have Nothing' by these three Korean singers~~~
please react to SOHYANG bridge over trouble water. I promise you would be stunned
希望能看到Taeyeon的現場演唱評價❤️❤️❤️
呃，这首歌音乐节Henry有现场演唱过，既然分析唱功为什么不找现场版呢？明明就那个reaction也是，用一个预录的电视节目的表演来评论是否修音，太有意思了，很吸引眼球哈
你的評論很沒必要，唱功有很多部分能看，修音收音準修不掉技巧，henry不是大vocal唱功就算被評論也是當然。大vocal也不見得唱得完全沒瑕疵。只躲在粉絲贊美裡的歌手不會有進步。
他好几个视频都是这样，故意找的后置节目，来批评修音问题，本来不明所以，后来发现这位声乐老师其实是签到频道主旗下的艺人，再看一下频道主旗下其他艺人，就秒懂啦…这种不是常见的野生外网reflection，而是有经营流量的
希望老師講評一下鄭恩地
她也超強的而且她都是現場比較多live沒有修音😂
其實老師說的修音是節目製作組用的，不然LIVE版幾乎沒有的
@@以太佩雲 恩地唱歌真的不錯
哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈
這是近期看下來，除去GEM早期表演片段，這一部影片是最嚴格的了，老師是認真在生氣欸XD
因為修音修到失真了
真的很沒必要，沒修音應該就很好聽了。
修音有時是節目呈現的必要後制,就像Henry這個舞台 : th-cam.com/video/kbFTxFAsFBA/w-d-xo.html 鋼伴清唱《Hall of Fame》高音驚人, 但是協力rap的歌手進錯拍子, 只能修音😅~~請老師點評下這修得如何? 畢竟rap歌手和聲樂老師是同門藝人, 應該很熟悉......
我特別愛聽彩排時，演唱會的現場無修音版本，因為那是我崇拜歌手獨一無二在那場表演的珍貴
Please review stephanie sun
Please react to RADIO by jessi and Henry!🎉❤
推介super junior KRY ❤❤❤❤❤
频道主，什么时候才能出一期黄霄云的啊？黄霄云用的很多技巧都很高超
可以聽艾怡良版本的Rolling in the Deep
沒什麼聽到呼吸聲的基本上都修了
@@Cherrie-zp9ie 不見得，也多的是聽不到呼吸聲的live。但是這有修音也很正常，拍節目是其一，另一個原因是戶外收音很多雜音，不修也不成
recommend ailee killing voice
想听老师评再見深海
會出Gem在NASA唱的“光年之外”嗎？
th-cam.com/video/y_UBPFyuRMA/w-d-xo.html
赞同！敲碗！
希望有更多kpop歌手 iu、太妍…等
可以推荐老师单依纯的别问很可怕吗❤
😂😂既然觉得有修音，那就找找他们现场的视频啊
讓他聽一下張雨生
SOHYANG 노래 리액션부탁드려용
k팝 가수들이네요. 자막이 중국어인거같은데 한국가수라서 한국인들도 보고싶을거같은데 자막이 없네요.
I suggest that to do more reaction for 黃霄雲， she is excellent singer in China, and she is very young, thanks
請這位聲樂老師先點評一下up主首頁的歌手吧....聽下真正的修音😂
Ailee 算是最早的youtuber吧
想看他講評 袁雅維 唱歌 最強女r& b 靈魂女歌手xddd
老师今天有点生气了，不过很委婉的表达了自己的保留意见
I hope you can comment on aespa’s live singing!
推荐老师听听张学友和张国荣（尤其是热情演唱会）的live，虽然可能曲风比较旧了，仍然有很多人喜欢
拜託讓老師看 朴孝信 現場野生花 之類的 ;( 超級好奇老師會說什麼
yessss plssss 🥺 因為隊長後期發聲方式也是SLS（老師推崇的） 超好奇老師的評價
順風耳阿
完全是細節
Teacher plz Hyorin’s song!
单依纯作为当今的新星 请务必让老师欣赏一下 非常感谢🙏❤
希望有林志炫的
老實在這裡其實對節目組過度修音和樂器比人聲大的部份而小生氣吧，希望可以找AILEE校園版本那種的，再好好讓老師聽聽~可惜了
我發不出三連轉音，我是個廢物學生。（哭）
想聽評論張震嶽
我還是聽不出修音，我耳朵太廢了😢
这老师叫什么名字
Rozette
@@ClubZeroMedia沒聽過
@@hawkcanflyhigher269 很正常
就像外國人沒聽過一堆亞洲歌手一樣意思 你當然也沒聽過國外的許多歌手
6.
唉！這老師太難了！
老師 請做您自己想做的事就好，請把一些不重要的雜音、垃圾事情清除,讓愉快的心情好好享受音樂吧！祝福老師。
那你就不要進來這樣的節目受虐嘛！我們是來學習知識點的。
修音！ 😑⋯⋯。
突然發現原來我一直把有修音的機械音當作收音很爛或麥克風很爛（？
用古點聲樂唱法去評流行音樂 恩 緣木求魚
他沒有用古典聲樂唱法呀？
@@cy4195 他只是不懂而已
讓他自己去Google 吧
本来觉得他们很厉害的样子，听了以后感觉，顿时品味就上来了，感觉他们就垃圾了
戶外收音有很多瑕疵，修也正常。就算錄音室錄也是會修，只因為修音就把一個表演當垃圾，你知道現在技術唱live也能實時修音了嗎？將來你聽的live都是垃圾了，什麼也不用聽了
@@jinsha_hk 你在这里骄傲些什么？我说他们垃圾，并不适合因为做了修音，而是老师分析完他们怎么唱的，处理每个细节。你以为我像你心胸狭隘，弄个修音就喷别人垃圾
@@cdeadpooka1642樓主, 如果你真認同這古典妖婆 那以後你只能聽古典音樂的歌 是好事 滅掉全世界的流行音樂 btw lady gaga 不是也是古典出身的嗎？看看她只評亞州的歌手 我想如果她評Taylor 粉們就能滅掉她的channel 😂
這世界在這白人眼中不需要亞州流行歌手 懂嗎？但她需要流量 越爭議越好 這是為什麼 周深不是她的菜但她願意ㄧ直找周深的影片評 但歐美的歌手跳過 怕被罵啊
@@jinsha_hk nonono，戶外的修音可以只針對戶外產生的雜音進行處理而不會影響人聲
你這麼說等於是把後製的修音師都當白癡了
他會生氣是因為很明顯的人聲部分有了不少的「過度修飾」
重點是都決定要在戶外唱了，為什麼還要修飾那麼多，乾脆在室內唱不就好了嗎？
這樣打從一開始就不用修了，不是嗎？
你會這麼說代表你沒聽過厲害到戶外除了室外雜音外，幾乎不用修音的歌手
基本上亞洲「現代的商業歌唱」產業都修得「非常過頭」
說真的，就像我到現在最佩服的臺灣女歌手也就鄧麗君而已
其他的現代女歌手雖然也有唱歌不錯的，但是他們幕後的團隊都給他們修的太過分了
以前美國小甜甜布蘭妮出來很多人罵他，覺得他實力不怎麼樣，唱歌都對嘴跟修音修很大
但是臺灣2000 年後的女歌手，很多都修得比小甜甜布蘭妮更誇張，沒必要修得地方也修了
就是你不知道製作團隊在白癡什麼的那種過度修法
這些年的亞洲歌手很多都是這樣，所以聲音聽起來都很做作（機器毀壞他們原聲的美感）
反而不用修音的神人卻愈來愈乏人問津
這就是全世界的流行音樂悲哀的趨勢之一，只是亞洲人特別明顯罷了
明明有很多歌手我都認為不必修成那樣，製作團隊卻硬要
不是說這影片裡面的兩位k-pop 出身的歌手一定唱不好
而是製作團隊白癡的劇本讓他們在戶外演唱當吸引眼球的策略，卻又把他們修得很誇張
可惜這就是現在的亞洲趨勢，想讓人家覺得自己的藝人很厲害，卻又害怕出一點錯會被放大，就一直修
真的是浪費他們兩人在戶外的演唱
難怪老師要生氣
這種作法只會讓耳朵好的人覺得藝人做作，為什麼故意修音還在戶外唱當賣點
可是他們不懂粉絲就吃這一套，而現代亞洲藝人本身如果沒有國外合作機會，也可能自以為修音就是正常的，畢竟是公司教出來的，不能怪他們，只是西方人不會懂這一點
但我還是要說：鄧麗君在那年代可沒有這種事情
所以才有一句話叫：一代不如有一代
大環境養成的，沒辦法
老師只是聽過很多戶外唱歌也厲害的人才會覺得為什麼要修這樣，不能怪他，他不懂現代亞洲流行音樂產業就是這麼做作，不完全跟藝人有關，但這就是事實
Hi voice teacher just keep be yourself and be honest. U r best teacher cheers