Bhenchod chutiyagiri band kar. Santana Dharma kabhi kabhi hume kisi bhi masoom jeev ko maarna paap mana jata hai. Aur Vegetarian/Vegan log apne saare non-veg khane waale dost/relatives ko bhi non-veg chodne ki request karte hai. Aur itna he pasand hai tujhe non-veg khana, toh beef bhi khaa le na madarchod. Woh bhi toh ek non-veg he hai (sarcasm 😏😏). Abhi tune jo shastra padh ke dikhaye, woh sab tere he chutiya purvajonne likhe hai. Hamare bhagwan aisa kabhi nahi kehte. Modern are not at all vegetarians. Modern Hindus woh hote hai, jo khud beef khate hai, aur beef ko apni persnal choice. Vegetarian Hindus are the real Sanatani Hindus who are still attached to their roots. And most importantly, no matter which religion you belong, Christian, Muslim, Parsi or anyone, you should never eat any animal. No human being has any right to kill/eat/torture any animal.
As simple as that Shaktas are generally warriors. If you see the history Rajputs, Marathas, Dogras, Ahoms, Gujjars etc all are celebrated warrior clans even Guru Gobind Singh Ji metaphorically used the great battle of Durga Maa and Mahishasura to inject veer ras in his Sikhs as “Chandi Di Vaar”. All these warriors has performed balis on various stages and got blessings of Maa. If they haven't done that then all Hindus were surely converted to Islam. Jai Maa Bhavani 🙏🏻
@@greaterbharat4175 search on Wikipedia Umayyad Campaigns in India you will get to know who the Rajputs were. And by the way Bhonsle Clan himself claim that they are the descendants of Sisodiya Clan
@@shraddha.b. bali is what the devi/devata demands, ergo is NOT wrong by ANY standards; eating non veg at KFC is mere consumerism. Did you not watch the video or are you dense? The video explains everything very clearly, seems like you just can't accept the scriptures because christian-protestant education has made you impenetrable.
Cuz in our hinduism we love all creatures!!! In our relegion its already written to not sacrifise any innocent soul for our own greed Its not in thiers Thats why we are called sanatani's for a reason!!!
@@Beauty_bunny that is just one school of thought. and if u want to forcefully impose what you follow on everyone, then you are no different from Christianity and Islam who forcefully convert people of other relegion.
@@adityabhattacharyya8727😂😂 sach bolne se Darr lagta hai kya?? Poore India mei sabko zabardasti convert kiya tha tumhare Uresian Brahmano ne, jo Maan Gaya usko galam banaya jo na maana usko ya toh maar deya ya fir Achoot Shudr bana rakha hai tum logo ne.... Ambedkar ne bhi 6 lakh Hinduo ko zabardasti convert kiya tha Buddhists banaya tha na 6 lakh Hinduo ko,, zabardasti 22 pratigya leya tha unlogo ne Ambedkar k saat...
#Goodnews The Pashubali, which was stopped by the order of Tripura HC, has been restarted by the BJP Govt. Now Pashubali is taking place in all the concerned temples of Tripura including Tripura Sundari Temple (Tripureshwari Temple), Durga Bari Temple, Chaturdash Devata Bari Temple etc.
Please re-start sati too. Because everything which goes well with "customs" should be protected without saying. And I hope you revive back to Nar-bali too, where you will offer your bali to Maa (as per Shastras) and then your beloved wife will jump to fire for uplifting womanhood. :) How easy it is to justify you taamsik traits under garb of devi? How can a devi, who is so karuna-mayi even think of taking life of an innocent animal? I criticize killing of animals without exception. Be it a mulla ro Hindus. Nobody gives you right to take right of an innocent. If maa wants their bali, by natural selection, she can very well take them. The scriptures forbid the tantra maarg statistically in Kaliyug. How much blind you need to be? Actually you are not blind, you simply want to chew non-veg and justify your sinful acts. I have seen people offering alocohol to bhairav baba. Hijde saale.
We have Mari Puja ,Tambila and Kola ,although am not comfortable around it i still respect it cause it's been the rituals of my ancestors am proud of my history belonging to the martial race .
The stupidity displayed in this video and in the comments is mind boggling. And for the librandu presenter, anyone these days comes up claiming to read and mention shastras and puranas and justify what they've been doing since childhood (meat eating). Just reading the shastras is not enough, there is a book called 'Science'. Multitude of pathogenesis are associated with flesh eating. But NVM, everyone is free to practice their beliefs, even if it's to kill an innocent animal.
अनुमन्ता विशसिता निहन्ता क्रयविक्रयी संस्कर्ता चोपहर्ता च खादकश्चेति घातकाः मनुस्मृति ५।५१ मारने की आज्ञा देने वाला, पशु को मारने के लिए लेने वाला, बेचने वाला, पशु को मारने वाला, मांस को खरीदने और बेचने वाला, मांस को पकाने वाला और मांस खाने वाला यह सभी हत्यारे हैं |
य आमं मांसमदन्ति पौरुषेयं च ये क्रविः गर्भान् खादन्ति केशवास्तानितो नाशयामसि अथर्ववेद ८। ६।२३ वह लोग जो नर और मादा, भ्रूण और अंड़ों के नाश से उपलब्ध हुए मांस को कच्चा या पकाकर खातें हैं, हमें उन्हें नष्ट कर देना चाहिए |
Great video thanks ! Nobody has problem with eating meat or Bakri-Eid but everyone wants to avoid PashuBali as if the entire country is vegan except for these regressive shakta Hindus.
regressive shakta hindus u say huh.. quite the unwise and instigating word u have used... its just different people having different mindset how is it regressive u say?
@@_Z0ZO_ - I used the word from the perspective of the ones opposing - Courts, Indian State, many Hindus, Jains especially. They see pashubali as regressive despite enjoying a meat industry and ignoring sacrifices in other faiths. Several Shakta Peeths and Temples have Pashubali banned by the Govt.
Wtf? Progressive means leave milk and other animal products can you? Stop forcing your culture on us. We are saving a section of shakta culture through this.
what an insight. Moral of the video : Let the Devata and Devi decide about their offerings, let's deal with mindless consumerism, it is not a sin to do hinsa if ordered by Shastras. Meat as prasad is an issue for people like PETA, but not as a mindless consumption. Very pinpoint video, thanks.
Phir to kisi ki bhi chadhane me kya samasya hai, mera tera kya karna, baki bali aur hatya me fark hota hai. Paap punya nahi ban jaate shastro ke adhaar pe. Bali galat hai kisi ki bhi ho, aur hamesha hogi aapse kamzor ki hi, aur kisi din aap bhi kamzor honge.
@@vine2341 Aapka tark uchit hai parantu aapki aagya se mai kuchh tathya aapke samaksh prastut karta hu, jinke dwaara aapko dharm-adharm athva bali-hatya ka antar spasht ho jaega. 1. Narbali keval yuddh ke samay dee jaati hai, weh bhi keval Rannchandika athva Kaalbhehrav ko. Hatya ka koi samay nahi hota. 2. Narbali sadyav uss shatru ki dee jaati hai jo ranbhoomi me sa-shastra prastut ho aur jiska Kshatriya dharma ke anusaar vadh kiya gaya ho. Aashanvit hun ki aapko hatya ve vadh ka antar gyaat hoga. 3. Brahmin, Stree, Balak, Gau athva yuddh me Nishastra vyakti ki bali kadapi nahi dee jaati. Isske paschaat, Narbali me balwaan ve nirbal vyakti me antar nahi kiya jaata. Yadi weh vyakti yuddh me aapke viruddh shastra liye prastut hai, itna paryaapt hai. Mai samajhta hu ki aap Narbali ko aaj ke samaaj ke sandarbh me dekh rahe hain, jiske kaaran aapko yeh vishay aapattijanak prateet ho raha hai. Parantu vichaar keejiye, ki samaaj me koi niyam na ho, aisi sthiti ho ki pratyek manushya apni pashu-pravarti se jeevan jeene lage, aisi stithi me ek sabhya samaj ki sthapna karne ke liye ek bhaag ko hinsa ko apna dharma banana padta hai, kyonki yadi woh bhag hinsa nahi karega toh koi ananya samuhik hinsa karega. Bal athva hinsa ke bhay se hee ek sabhya samaaj ki sthapna sambhav hoti hai.
@@Gandivpani Mai aapke kuch tarkon se sehmat hu dharma ki sthapna ke liye hinsa galat nahi hai parantu isse pehle dharm hai kya yah jaanna bohot aavashyak hai. Mai hinsa ka viroodhi nahi hu, magar akaaran ki gayi hinsa se bura kuch ho bhi nahi sakta. Udharan ke liye kisi ashwa ko apne aham ke liye saare desh me ghumana aur phir us ashwa ki bali de dena mere samaksh uchit karya nahi hai. Dharma ki samajh tabhi sambhav hai jab aham ka lop ho, aham dharm ko bhi adharm banane ki kshamta rakhta hai. Agar keeval usi adhaar pe bali di jaye jis adhaar pe aapne kaha to wah uchit hogi, parantu jaise hi bali aham aur ichchaon ko sadhne ka ek yantr ban jaati hai wah galat ho jaati hai (phir wo chahe kisi devta ko prasann karne ke liye ho athwa kisi aur karanvash), iska hame dhyaan rakhna chahiye.
To all those pseudo Hindus, he just gave you all a middle finger, agree with him, Peta is silent during ramzan & christmas but active when it is a Hindu festival
I am a Garhwali. My grandparents got Bali mutton as prasadam when they were kids. Pashu Bali is most important to keep the urga element of Hinduism alive. Else we become too soft. Yes, we can be extracting and penetrative. Pashu Bali should survive anyhow.
As far as I know in Uttarakhand there are villages following Vegetarianism compared to the rest of India even better than some parts on Rajasthan and Gujarat ! Hence Sir don't know which religion you belong to or what cult but *your grandparents attending pashu balis is nowhere related to the scriptures advocating pashu bali - which is non existent in the texts* .
@@TheB657 lol He is totally Hindu and Hindu scriptures have pashubali even Madhawacharya and other vaishnavacharys in there bhasyas have supported Pashubali. Vedas also supports pashubali You are might be some crypto Christian larping as Hindus and making them feel guilty about following there rituals
@@blazeofsea6843 Could you kindly provide the link to any of the pages of the books hallmarked for circulation to teach the Vedas in Universities or any such institutions or Gurukulas ? I would love to learn from you ( *whom seems to be more of a blind keyboard warrior lest a degree holder in Indian scriptures* ) - *exactly which line or stanza justifies and advocated Pashu bali ?!* Could you kindly please link the books and quote the verses ?
Yes It Keeps the warrior culture alive In us . Also in The place We live in the mountains Where growing Food is hard and Yeild is less eating grians Isn't enough that'swhy even mountainous Brahmins have meat except certain periods during the year
Someone claiming kalikapuran does not mention bali. Totally wrong. It has a segment called rudhiradhyaya describing details of various balis from chapter 67 onwards. Regarding yogini tantra the original tantra was always used in eastern kamakhya and bengal where vamacara and kaulacara is norm. Chagabalitustha is the right description matches with the anecdotal story of the King who got his kingdom back post chagbali in kamakhya pitha. Other versions of the stotra were created later by those who tamper texts because they are uncomfortable with shastra vakya.
@@amurarka7876 the so called concept of atmabal has only lead to afghanistan converted , vasts parts of current pakistan had jain influence , what happened, all were brutally converted . When u have concepts of non violence and sainthood as ideals of life , dharma cannot be defended .Pashubali is essential for shakta rituals . Else you cannot complain about your opponent being brutal.
@@Apex1008 Swami Samarth Ramdas( Guru of Shivaji maharaj), Acharya Raghvendra( Guru of Maharana Pratap), Banda bairagi, Guru govind singh ji, these people are examples what atmbal can do, they made their disciples to fight against Adharm.
@@amurarka7876 Vaishnav school of thought is not hinduism alone . Bhagwatam , bhagwad geeta , has had a lot of influence, interference , changes of medival bhakti movement of vaishnavs . Original texts of hinduism had bali . The overaching influence of Vaishnavism , jainism , gandhism has ruined the spirit of kshatra dharma out of hinduism . If you see too much of Ramanand sagar serials or babas from vrindavan , your world view of hinduism will be localized .
The grandeur of Sanatana Dharma is that those who favour pashubali and those who are against it, both come under the umbrella of Sanatana. This is the diversity that it promises, not a seeming rational external person who imposes some admittedly questionable practices upon the entire framework of Sanatana criticizing it loudly enough to delude half-informed or uninformed Hindus.
Hi Namaste 🙏🏻 I'm from Kerala. The land of saktheya(sakthism ) tantrika tradition. I'm a hindu too, my family belongs to Nair community having tantrika upasana for generations. From that knowledge, meat including beef is not sinful in Hinduism.💯 Lord sri raman conducted aswa meda yagam. That itself was a horse sacrificing yagam. His father king Dasaratha Maharaj conducted putrakameshti Yagam before the birth of Sri Ram. That also was a horse sacrificial Yagam conducted by brahmins and the animal fat called "vamam" in Samskritham deposit to the yaga agni (holy fire) & the rest of the meat is prepared as the prasadam(divine food ) for Suryavamshi family members including sri raman. The King randi Devan conducted agni hotri yagam for his moksham, which is a cow, goat and horse sacrificial yagam,(trikarams in Samskritham, which means 3 different animals for sacrifice )the leather of the animals which are slotted for Yagam where get deposit into the river. Latterly the same river get called as charmanvati river which is in today's U. P or charmatha nadi( the nadi(river) which is dumped by charmam(skin/leather)). Not only in vedic-tantrik rituals,If you look at the case of ayurvedic medicines several medicines are prepared from several meat. Even the gorjana pills are prepared from cow meat. The colloidal meat inside cows intestine called "gorochanam" is the main ingredient for preparing Gorochana pills, like that aja mamsa rasayanam is prepared from goat meat. If you look deep and deep you can see several things related to ithihasa, purana,tantrika, vaidehika(vedic),mandrika, ayurveda, sidda vaidya sculptures shows the usage of meats in rituals and daily diet too. So my fellow northies, try to study vedic, tantrika, Upanishads from proper gurus those having mandra deeksha or upasana parambaryam. Not from so called religious political parties and fake demi gods.it's a request. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻Because We malayalis don't want to get " 'bh'ucked" like Kashmiri pandits, those who were knowingly avoided the authentic kashmiri shaiva tantrika upasana padhathi for so called vegetarian Supremacy .💯 For us,Their tragedy is our moral story.❤️🙏🏻
@Warrrrr452 I'm from Travancore(specifically from Pathanamthitta district ) The actual "para devatha kshetram" or "kula devatha kshetram" of Travancore dynasty and travancore royal family is "Kollampuzha thiruarattu badrakali devi temple" situated in the place called Attingal of Thiruvananthapuram district. The Travancore king self declined as "padmanabha dasar" at the time of "Marthanda Varamman maharajan" as the ritual called "Thrippadi Danam" ( it was a promise or oath that taken by marthanda Varma,which means, "what ever he conquered including land,kingdoms and wealth should be offered to the feet of lord sri Padmanabhan") he was the same king who renovated the decayed krishna Swamy temple in 18th century. Actually before the time of marthanda Varma Maharajan, the temple don't have that much connection with the Travancore royal family. There was a common folklore which is still existing in southern Kerala, About the story of "Divakaran Muni" and the "lost child of Anandhan Kadu" ( The Lost child of Anandan forest is Lord Sri Padmanabha swamy in the form of a child ) Diwakaran rishi is the one who conjured the sri padmanabha swami in desired size of his "yoga dandh". And build a small Krishna temple as a "krishna peedam" even several centuries before the Travancore and adhi pandiya vamsham. King marthanda Varma Mahajan was a saktheyan by birth and a hard core mahavishnu upasakan at the same time, (sakrheyam by his traditional upasana parambaryam and vaishavam by his personal desire).and one more thing even in vaishana upasana lord narasimha swamy, parashu raman, chathur bahu narayana moorthis, yudha swaroopa raman, maha sudarshana moorthy, are devoted in the same tantrika aspects including panchamakaram (malsya, mamsa, madhu, mudra, maidhunam ) in Kerala. So don't be mistaken about only saktheyar have the panchamakara sadhana parambaryam in Kerala. Veera Vaishavar (excluding bhramin community ), veera saiva sadhakar, saktheyar have common method of tantrika devotion based on panchamakara Sadhana. 🙏🏻
@Warrrrr452so as in the east and particularly in Bengal where Kali Kula Shakta Sampradaya is prevelant . Yet there is no reference and mention of bull sacrifice or consumption of beef amongst Hindus anywhere . I see the Hindus in kerela justifies beef eating as part of ritual which is no where written in any tantra texts .
@@vishaldasgupta4573 adipoli👏🏻👏🏻😂😂😂I already mentioned that, the use of so called divine beef (gorochanam) in the field of Ayurvedam. Bhai, it's not about justifying using Vedantham or tantrikam it's about your people's mind set. You people can't accept that💯 that's the fact.👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 In saktheya sampridayam, devi durga is devoted as ugra Mahishasura Mardini", "The black healthy bull" is the bali mrigam for that ritual of Panchamakara Sadhana. The musical instrument called Nadha Damru or udukk which is hold by Lord Shivan is manufactured from leather not from chicken feather. He and whole gurus including saptha rishis are meditated on leather mat. Not on khadi mat. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻kaula shaiva aradhana, dhakshina and uthara kalika sampridayam (whole vama margam)and veera vaishana upasana like lord narasimha swamy upasana are considered as "guptha vidyas"💯💯💯💯 which means form of divine secret upasana padhathis, So it's methods and rituals mandras, sookthams won't get published in Hindu newspaper or Indian Express. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
@@BharathChandrasenan give me one reference where it is written . We too are from Kali Kula Shakta Sampradaya . I come from Assam and Goddesses Kamakhya who is adorned as the primary Adi Shakti peethaswari is our Mula poojita Devi . No where in our ancestors in the past or present have I heard of Cow slaughter or Cow Bali . We follow kaula Ugrachanda Rajrajashree and Bhairava upasana where we have pancha Bali Vidhan of offering five animals . There is a buffalo , goat , ducks , pigeons and cat fish offered . Buffalo not cow . All shaktipeethas in the east , to northeast , to Nepal , Kashmiri Shaivism there is sacrifice of a buffalo not cow . Never was cow in the past nor in present . I know places in Bengal and Assam where we had Nara Bali(human sacrifice) done in the past centuries never had cow been sacrificed . Stop justifying ur beef eating and cow killing liking to Shakta Sampradaya . One of the primary belief of being a Hindu is protection of cows within all 6 major sampradayas no question of malification or modification in it. Yes the leather used in most instrumental music so as damru are all made of buffalo leather . Leather of only tiger skin or mriga deer skin is allowed for asana else it's made of kusha. We have panchamundi asana Pooja vidhan of 5 animal skulls are set underneath the mula vigraha but never ever again i stand it's cow . Buffalo sacrifice is permitted under the pretext of the black healthy bull don't mix it with cow killing 🙏
Thank god for this video, dada In my patriarchal home Durga Puja is being done from past 400 years and somehow the current generations have resorted to chaalkumdo pratikatmak bali I don't know why but I was really sad coz we should not change what she is being offered for traditions.
I have great reverence for Sir Rajarshi Nandy. He is the one (among others) who is single handedly bringing forward the Shakta Parampara to common people like us and making us learnt of our very own texts. Thank you Sir and Jai Maa Kamakhaya
I am from Rajasthan and have seen many people who do bali and eat that meat but the bali is given in proper shastriya form and that meat is not cooked with onion or garlic so it's won't take द्विजत्व even if a dwij eats it. There is a whole antyaja jaati is there named Khateek who used to supply Jhatka meat to the Hindus in past times Now most of them have abondoned there traditional work as the ambedkerite propaganda started and they lived there traditions for government jobs and other. and that is one of the reason Halal industry getting stronger in Meat Industry, Now in Rajasthan mostly Rajputs are doing this Jhatka meat business and in some places khateek to have retained there traditions.
@@rk-is3cw क्रव्य दा - क्रव्य (वध से प्राप्त मांस ) + अदा (खानेवाला) = मांस भक्षक | पिशाच - पिशित (मांस) +अस (खानेवाला) = मांस खाने वाला | असुत्रपा - असू (प्राण )+त्रपा(पर तृप्त होने वाला) = अपने भोजन के लिए दूसरों के प्राण हरने वाला | | गर्भ दा और अंड़ दा = भूर्ण और अंड़े खाने वाले | मांस दा = मांस खाने वाले | वैदिक साहित्य में मांस भक्षकों को अत्यंत तिरस्कृत किया गया है | उन्हें राक्षस, पिशाच आदि की संज्ञा दी गई है जो दरिन्दे और हैवान माने गए हैं तथा जिन्हें सभ्य मानव समाज से बहिष्कृत समझा गया है | ऊर्जं नो धेहि द्विपदे चतुष्पदे यजुर्वेद ११।८३ सभी दो पाए और चौपाए प्राणियों को बल और पोषण प्राप्त हो | हिन्दुओं द्वारा भोजन ग्रहण करने से पूर्व बोले जाने वाले इस मंत्र में प्रत्येक जीव के लिए पोषण उपलब्ध होने की कामना की गई है | जो दर्शन प्रत्येक प्राणी के लिए जीवन के हर क्षण में कल्याण ही चाहता हो, वह पशुओं के वध को मान्यता कैसे देगा ?
Absolutely man, these (far leftists ) continuously targeting (Sanatan Dharma) its rituals & texts, while defending evil texts like (Quran & Hadith) ,but we have to do the same with these non- Hindus expose these evils.👍
@@rk-is3cw they don't have knowledge of dharm i guess , in sastra s told that it is good eat own flesh rather eat other. It is only restricted to bramhan.
@@deviprasadpadhy8840 No. There are even traditional brahmins who eat meat and sacrifice animals during festivals. Especially Maithali and Bengali Brahmins.
Sir one of your favourite said "Sri Aurobindo - What about the sacrifice of harmless animals to Kali? Useless and therefore inadvisable. External sacrifices of this kind have no longer any meaning - as so many saints have said, sacrifice ego, anger, lust etc. to Kali, not goats or chickens.'"
Actually weak to wo log hote hain jo khud ko bali nhi dete Because khud ki bali dene ka sahash na hone ke karan dusro ki jindagi khatam karna chahte hain Yahi sabse badi weakness hai Nirdosh jaanwaro ko markar kon sa bada kaam karte hain hum aaj ke mahishasur ban gaye hain hum sab to Agar bali deni hai to kisi phal ke jaise naariyal kathal etc ki de do Kisne kaha weak hote hain warrior nhi hote Satya aur dharm ki raksha ke liye yuddh karna sikhna chahiye na ki in anjaan bejuban jaanwaro ke saath yuddh karna chahiye
There is pashubali performed at many Sri Urga Narasimha temples. Although the Sri Vaishnava sampradaya won’t agree to that, the common people bring goats and offer them as Bali to the lord.
Vaishnavs sampradaya emphasizes on satvik offerings. Also these things became anti-tamsik during bhakti movement where hardcore vaishnavism/satvik lifestyle was emphasized in Gangetic plains. Idk if vaishnavs in orrisa are hardcore vegetarians, but for sure the offerings are satvik.
There are only a handful of "Ugra Narasingha" temples . Can you provide an example of such a temple where such a ritual takes place (as you claim that there are "many" such temples) ?. The one I know of is that in Ahobila . But people make the mistake of thinking that the Mahalakhsmi temple , i.e. the Chenchu Lakshmi temple as a Narasingha or a Vaishnav temple. It is clearly due to the tribal influence in that area that this practice takes place and has nothing to do with Vaishnavism . Animal sacrifice in Mahalakshmi temple is not uncommon as I know of another one in Maharashtra. Ultimately the point is that it cannot be regarded as a Vaishnav temple as the worship is done by Shakta means. This is not uncommon. Take the Jagannath Temple for example. Inside the temple complex , the Bimala Temple is a shakti pith and animal sacrifice takes place once a year during durga puja.
Yeah. I'm sure the warriors would face goats in the battlefield who would allow them to decapitate them without resistance. It's a violent and dark practice and anyone who disagrees have got to be either disillusioned or have to agree that the god/goddess they are praying to are not "benevolent" and they must hate those animals . I am talking about Hindus, Muslims Jews and any "civilized" non tribal culture which tolerates animal sacrifice.
Aithreya brahmana of rigveda and other brahmanas has entire chapters dedicated to animal sacrifice...including type of animal, mantras to be told during scarifice, preparing animal, ways the meat should be chopped and which part of body should be offered into fire with what mantra etc...only idiots who never read scriptures deny it.
There need to restore (Gurukula System, Vedas Bhagvad geeta Path should be made compulsory for every Hindu to read daily) .Hindus don't know their granthas so anti-Hindus take benefit of this.👍
@ola_uber6631😁😁 lol . have you read samkhya karika yourself? pls read karika 2 of samkhya karika. the adi Shankaracharya mentioned in bramha sutra vasya that main opponent(pradhan malla) of advaita vedanta in samkhya. Without knowledge , don't blabber.
We in the Mountains do Pashu bali, When I was 18 I did bali of 11 goats, It's just Our culture, In olden times when Agriculture was not possible in the Mountains, People ate Meat to survive, Like the people in the Plains offer what they eat to their God's, We do the same.
This isnt culture buddy, u got the wrong idea mate... Culture is reflected in ur personality ur ways of treating others ur devotion and ur manners and love towards all of creation
Offering bali to Devi and eating prasad meat was a community building activity for Kshatriyas which boosted their tamasic tendencies to fight and provided them with enough protein to build muscles.
@@कश्परैना That's just a part of cultural practice nowadays to assume that our heros were vegetarian, Maharana Pratap Ji literally died hunting an animal what was it for? Also contrary to many people's belief even Bhagwan Ram wasn't vegitarian, Ramayan has several mentions of mansand/gosht in it; but yeah if given a choice vegetarian is definitely better according to modern sensibilities.
Nice to see so many snowflake meltdowns in the comments. Pashubali is an integral part of Shakta traditions and shall continue to be. Cope. If you dont't like it, don't partake/ participate in it. Simple. Nobody has given you the authority to take away my rights of worship. Just as I should not shove meat prasad on your plate, you also should not take away my Khadga.
Indeed! No wonder the Hindu society has become impotent and devoid of Kshatriya spirit. One who cannot behead an animal without blinking a eye, what will such a person do on the battlefield.
Wine, fish, honey, meat, alcohol, and preparations of rice and sesame seeds, have been introduced by knaves. The use of these (in sacrifices) is not laid down in the Vedas. The hankering after these arises from pride, error of judgment, and cupidity. Mahabharat, Shanti Parva, chapter 265. Hit something that fights back, Puranic cults wont save you in the end
@@tusharsharma8952kuch ni jab hum log bajrang dal wale ka ya karni sena wale inko thokna start krenge to ye apni aukat mai a jaenge jain ho ya buddh apni aukaat mai rahe. They can't intervene in our religion
As always a wonderful episode I completely support bali pratha I believe apart from worshipping our gods it invokes masculinity in men (for those who offer bali to the mother goddess).
You are out of your mind if you think killing the indefensible invokes some kind of deranged masculinity. Paurush is defending the indefensible not killing them. How ironic is that you said "mother" goddess requires bali. Does a mother ever want that? Think.
@@vaibhavyadav9912 That question is what he address in the video. It has been prescribed in by our Gurus & Siddhas. Why should we always disagree and demand logic from our rituals which we don;t completely understand. Read more before being critic.
@@pangolinkumar2329 Please make me understand what good comes from killing an innocent animal. I admit I haven't read enough but if you or anyone has, please explain. Because Sri Nandy's only justification is "it's written hence it is true". How's that any different from those abrahamics who consider book before brain. We are the civilization which had developed the concept of "tark" buddhi when others didn't even know what tark was. Please do not sideline logic/tark as a foreign concept. We must understand that it wasn't like before the invasions we were living in a utopia. Yes We were much much better than the others but still not perfect. That's why Sri Adi Shankaracharya made his life goal to restore Dharma. Anything written in Sanskrit is not be considered as Dharma, it should be thought and discussed upon. Tark is also considered one of the Rishis. If any Devi "maa" demands we kill other animals to please her is she really a maa then? I am having a hard time understanding it. Even Lord Shiva the king of tamas doesn't demand to kill. Not even Kali maa demands it. We assume she does.
@@VigneshV-lo6fi Agree and also I am not against total Total annihilation of violence since it is needed to stop the ones who destroy Dharma. But how does meat and pashubali has anything to do with it. Haryana contains highest number of vegetarian people in India and it's not like they lack anything physically. Even the pehelwans there are vegetarian and complete Bajrang bhakt.
Then see this Valmiki Ramayan Bala Kanda 1, Sarga 14, Verses 33-38 “With great delight coming on her Queen Kausalya reverently made circumambulations to the horse, and symbolically killed the horse with three knives. Queen Kausalya desiring the results of ritual disconcertedly resided one night with that horse that flew away like a bird…Then the priest, one with controlled senses and rich in scriptural wealth, took up the omentum [fat] of the horse and cooked it as per scriptures while dropping into the altar of fire to bake as a food to the celestials…Those remaining body parts that horse are there, the sixteen officiating priests have procedurally oblated all of them into fire.” Rig Veda 1.162.3--This goat, the portion of Pu+ṣan fit for all the gods, is brought first with the fleet courser, to that Tvaṣṭā may prepare him along with the horse, as an acceptable preliminary offering for the (sacrificial) food.” This whole chapter talks about sacrificing and slaughtering in the name of God. Atharva Veda, book7, hymn 5--.....With dog the Gods, perplexed, have paid oblation, and with cow's limbs in sundry sacrifices. Vishnu Puran 5.1.86 सुरामांसोपहरैश्च भक्ष्यभोज्यैश्च पूजिता । Propitiated with offerings flesh and various viands Bhagwat Puran 10.2.10 अर्चिष्यन्ति मनुष्यास्त्वां सर्वकामवरेश्वरीम् । धूपोपहारबलिभि: सर्वकामवरप्रदाम् ॥ By sacrifices of animals, dhup, ordinary human beings will worship you, because you are supreme in fulfilling all desires of everyone. Devi Bhagwat 3.26.34 also says:- देव्यग्रे निहता यान्ति पशवः स्वर्गमव्ययम् । न हिंसा पशुजा तत्र निघ्नतां तत्कृतेऽनघ ॥ O sinless one! The goats, etc.,
i think if we sacrifice animals, mother will give them a meaningful life like human being. My lovely mother not only destroys but also creates and transforms. I am interested in Vamachara
अनुमन्ता विशसिता निहन्ता क्रयविक्रयी संस्कर्ता चोपहर्ता च खादकश्चेति घातकाः मनुस्मृति ५।५१ मारने की आज्ञा देने वाला, पशु को मारने के लिए लेने वाला, बेचने वाला, पशु को मारने वाला, मांस को खरीदने और बेचने वाला, मांस को पकाने वाला और मांस खाने वाला यह सभी हत्यारे हैं |
Forget about y 'bali'. The north Indian vegetarians are on denial mode about their god Ram been a non-vegetarian according to the Valmiki Ramayan Which is more than 2000 yr old. For them, 500 yrs old Ramacharitramanas is more holier than the valmiki Ramayan.
There are three types of worship by hindus based on their gunas, people with satva guna are the ones who are too sensitive and they feel the pain of others and their form of worship is even in that way, there are people who donot pluck flowers or pick fruits from trees for food or pooja, they just eat the fruits that fall off and use flowers that fall off from trees. The second way is Rajasic type of worship by building large temples and offer large amounts of financial offerings. The thamasic way of worship is they offer meat and alchol as prasad for devas. Mostly kings and some trades people used do pasu bali in olden days. Pasu bali used to be offered before going to wars.
Yes bro that is the main reason, as many times tamsik guna is seen as a negetive attribute , but people tend to forget that tamsik people are also very good warriors because of there agressive attitude. Thus people belonging to tamsik guna are more leaned towards worshipping maa kali and kalbhairav roop of Mahadev. Thus sacrifices are performed for only them as they are the only deities that accept it , this is actually the beauty of Sanatan Dharma where a person can choose a way of worship rather than follow something mindlessly written in a single book , this creates the diversity which is absolutely necessary for a functioning society.
@@dhruvkapri3601 but anger and violent attitude belongs to tamas guna right, rajas Guna has this excessive benevolence type of attitude isn't it? 🤔. Well may be i am wrong, idk 😅✌️
@@arkadeepchanda9524 no actually benevolence is satva guna as it forgives and keeps our mind cool and happy rajas is basically when a person feels too much energized and raw masculinity are all rajasic a soldier must be brave that comes from rajas meanwhile Tamas makes us lazy and irritated over small things that's all what I know about these 3 gunas
Myself earlier had a strong view against Pasu Bali, but this video has made me rethink on 2 points. 1. There isn't a way to formally educate Hindus on sanatan dharma and it's practices. 2. Consumerism has been acceptable to us, I myself have been a non-vegetarian but was against the Pasu Bali in temples as I find it against the spirit of the holy place but I now agree that offering must be according to the liking of deity and not that we approve.
We Bengalis and other Indians are too much knowledgeable and ignorant when it comes to Bali...Modern Bengalis can consume meat , eat chiken biriyani but when comes to bali pratha they suddenly became extra knowledgeable . And what happened for this ?? We became vulnerable to invaders.
Great video as always!! In today’s time bali pradha is even more important. Decimation of dharma is because hindus have left all hardcore prathas. Muslims don’t fear blood as they are used to it now. Hindus can’t even hold a knife well,leave alone to slaughter. Remember kanhaiya lal how did they slaughtered him. We as Bhumihar brahmin regularly kept our relation with blood good. In result mahadev blessed us with sacred land of kashi, huge amount lands in bihar.
Spot on! Look at most upper caste people. It's laughable. Bags of rice 🍚 and atta. Eating boondi ladoos as prasadam. Where is the purusha/masculine element? Why are Indian men butt of all jokes globally? Look at the over safe parenting? Where is the risk affinity?
Brahimdev, as a Kshatriya, I completely agree with you! It’s a shame that today you wouldn’t find a single shastra in a Kshatriya’s house. Kshatriya giving up weapons is adharma of the highest order!
I’m a huge animal lover and I’m actually traumatised by pashubali. But I somehow swallowed the fact that it’s a necessary evil to pacify fierce gods and goddesses. Ma is way too practical for our sentiments. Edit: one of the reasons I’ve chosen to be a vaishnava. I used to eat lot of meat but now I’m a vegetarian after seeing the bloodshed caused by meat consumption. I even use cruelty free products.
Human activities like agriculture, industry etc leads to deforestation and climate change. Going by your logic people should live a primitive hunter gatherer life in order to not adversely impact the world, as deformation is a horrible thing.
@@binodkumarbharat3277 Uhh…. First of all I did not bring the topic of climate change here. . And btw, climate change is a hoax. Do some research on its sinister agenda to implement the new world order. Edit: I wrote that comment because personally I’m very sensitive to animal suffering. I myself have no choice but to support this practice because my opinions actually don’t matter when it comes to shastras.
Even I stay away from any kind of violence since I'm an ardent follower of Goswami Tulsidas ji and Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, but still I believe pashu bali in accordance to shastras.
In such a detailed exposition, I thought the question of why does the diety like the 'pashubali' or the meat as an offering would be answered? For example, there is a reason why Lord Vishnu likes Tulsi and why Lord Shiva likes Bilva-patra as offering. If anyone can explain, please do so.
For slow purification of a devotee who is in tamsik/rajsik guna. If u eat un-offered meat, it's not prasad. But if u eat meat that is offered as prasad, it eventually is prasad so helps in spiritual elevation. Also, there are many dos and don't while doing bali. A way of restricting meat consumption among tamsik followers. Like in a rehab, they give small dose of drugs, not to make u a druggie but to slowly mauke you stop. This is spiritual rehab. Hope I didn't confuse u.
@@bundilster Beautiful name 'Tryambak'. Now, Tulsi was one of the foremost devotees of Lord Vishnu and as far as I remember, she took a promise from Vishnu that nothing should happen to her husband in a certain context, which he granted. But, her husband died leaving the promise broken and widowing her. To show his grace, Lord Vishnu granted moksha to her and promised her that she would be worshipped equally with the Lord himself, would be a symbol for prosperity and would be the most beloved offering in the worship. Lord Shiva chooses the most underrated things and discredited things for worship. That's His benevolence and also a sign of how easy it is to please him. If you read about Bilva, from Wiki - " It has a reputation in India for being able to grow in places that other trees cannot. It copes with a wide range of soil conditions (pH range 5-10), is tolerant of waterlogging and has an unusually wide temperature tolerance from −7-48 °C." And so, Shiva chose that as being an essential for his worship, because it is found in abundance and also, where most trees don't grow, to show inclusivity. Hope this is helpful, although I would highly recommend you to check other versions of the story.
@@nishakanchan7682 Okay, so if a non-vegetarian is on a path to become a satwik (vegetarian), your reasoning completely make sense. But, such practices are attended by people who already follow a satwik lifestyle and may not be able to take part in the offering. The closest explanation I once got was, it was a symbolism and a lesson to teach us that, mortality and complete submission to the Goddess from whom we all came from, is inevitable. I wasn't quite satisfied with the explanation as it lacked a concrete moral narrative as in the case of Tulsi/Bilva (read my other comment).
For all those who are placing sentiment and namby pamby emotions above scripture , here are one of the two greatest seers, Ramanujacharya and Madhavacharya have to say about Bali Vidhan. here is what Ramanujacharya says in the Sri Bhashya, his commentary on the Brahma Sutras: ‘It is not so, on account of scriptural statement. For Scripture declares that the killing of sacrificial animals makes them to go up to the heavenly world, and therefore is not of the nature of harm. This is declared in the text, 'The animal killed at the sacrifice having assumed a divine body goes to the heavenly world'; 'with a golden body it ascends to the heavenly world.' An action which is the means of supreme exaltation is not of the nature of harm, even if it involves some little pain; it rather is of beneficial nature.--With this the mantra also agrees: 'Thou dost not die, thou goest to the gods on easy paths; where virtuous men go, not evil-doers, there the divine Savitri may lead thee.' An act which has a healing tendency, although it may cause a transitory pain, men of insight declare to be preservative and beneficial.’’ And here's what Madhvacharya says in this excerpt from his Dvaita commentary on the Brahma Sutras: ‘’It may be said that sacrificial work involves injury to life, and as such it is productive of sin and consequently of misery, and that, therefore, it is not to be performed. But this objection is to be refuted on the ground that the injury to life involved in holy duties is permitted by the word (scripture); for the Varahapurana says, "To do harm to any life except as enjoined by scripture is really productive of sin and evil consequences; on the other hand, no evil consequences possibly arise from the act of killing permitted by the Vedas."
Pashubali seems like a contested topic. Vaishnavas seem to acknowledge it’s existence but only approve of it under very exceptional circumstances. Whereas shaktas consider it to be a central part of their tradition . I’m curious to know what the shaiva and smartha point of view on this is. I know Karpatri ji didn’t favour banning it but never participated in the practice himself. What is Upword’s opinion on replacing goats with pumpkins as is being done in Bengal nowadays under the influence of a Gaudiya Vaishnavism and the Ramakrishna mission ?
Swami Vivekananda Wanted to do anushthanas that were going include bali . But he was opposed by Maa sarada . But it is known that Ramakrishna used to participate in Balis himself.
I always knew Bengalis will be forefront of bali tradition. I used to debate with my north Indian friends. Rajarshi is exacting saying what I used to say. Good dada
Bali is integral part and parcel of Hinduism. Kamakhya temple in Guwahati, bali is done. One must become part of it. The whole environ goes to another level.
Meat/fish can be consumed only if it's offered to the deity 🙏 even our Ramakrishna used to consume only if the meat is slaughtered in front of the supreme power SHAKTI 🙏
अघ्न्या यजमानस्य पशून्पाहि यजुर्वेद १।१ हे मनुष्यों ! पशु अघ्न्य हैं - कभी न मारने योग्य, पशुओं की रक्षा करो | द्विपादव चतुष्पात् पाहि यजुर्वेद १४।८ हे मनुष्य ! दो पैर वाले की रक्षा कर और चार पैर वाले की भी रक्षा कर |
Many of my non-bengali friends from bihar, up, delhi, punjab & gujrat always asks me why we বাঙালিরা eat non-veg during durga pujo while they fast & eat veg !!? Why is Our Durga Pujo different from their Navratri?!! I am never able to give a satisfying answer. 😢 This had always been their biggest question!! 😂
Absolutely! I am a vegetarian and a staunch believer that the marginalisation / modification of the ritual of bali is what lead to the downfall of Indian society- first to the mogals and then to the english and portugese. Devatas span the entire gamut from the saumya to the raudra. It is foolishly self deluding to expect the raudra devatas to accept what is normal for a saumya devata. Even in the army today soldiers are trained to live on a diet of foraged reptiles and animals which includes lizards and other creepy crawlies. Here, the objective is more important than the individual's sensibilities. It is more important for a soldier to survive in barren terrain and achieve military objectives which encompass individual and collective dharma. So also every devata has a list of parivara devatas who manage the "thin edge of the wedge" so to speak.....and propitiation cannot be done here with substitutes like some mishra and dakshinacaris recommend. Proper worship involves following shastra to the letter. Wherever there is a SJW attitude on matters of ritual, the "phala" / fruit will also go pear shaped.
Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam (11.5.41): devarṣi-bhūtāpta-nṛṇāṁ pitṟṇāṁ na kiṅkaro nāyam ṛṇī ca rājan sarvātmanā yaḥ śaraṇaṁ śaraṇyaṁ gato mukundaṁ parihṛtya kartam Everyone is indebted to the demigods, to living entities in general, to his family, to the pitās and so on, but if one fully surrenders to Kṛṣṇa, Mukunda, who can give one liberation, even if one performs no yajñas, one is freed from all debts.
ऊर्जं नो धेहि द्विपदे चतुष्पदे यजुर्वेद ११।८३ सभी दो पाए और चौपाए प्राणियों को बल और पोषण प्राप्त हो | हिन्दुओं द्वारा भोजन ग्रहण करने से पूर्व बोले जाने वाले इस मंत्र में प्रत्येक जीव के लिए पोषण उपलब्ध होने की कामना की गई है | जो दर्शन प्रत्येक प्राणी के लिए जीवन के हर क्षण में कल्याण ही चाहता हो, वह पशुओं के वध को मान्यता कैसे देगा ?
Respected Rajarshi We has ordinary people want to know how to seek blessings from normal pooja for our endless demands from god? From Ganesha, Mahalaxmi or other gods which mantras should we chant?
Just Namavali (Chanting the name of God is enough). Most scholars and pandits emphasize the importance of Rama Naama since that involves both Bhagwan Narayana and Bhagwan Shiva 🔱Chanting the name of the deities is greatest in Kali Yuga. However as someone who chants mantras and stotras every day I can recommend some. Start with chanting *Sri Aditya Hrudaya Stotram* - learn it by heart and chant it every day morning especially on Sundays by rising up prior to sunrise, taking bath, performing puja and in process chant this. Will give you resplendency and radiance throughout the day as you will be brimming with energy throughout the day. Chant *Hanuman Chalisa everyday morning and evening* - will give you strength and bountifulness. If possible throughout the day in your mind keep chanting (Raama Raama Raama Raama ......) - Once you do this verbally in isolation, slowly your brain will get adapted to the sound and rechant it itself several times without your knowledge subconsciously. Nothing else is actually required for Kali Yuga as this Yuga is based on Karma Yoga. Whatever good Karma you do and offer it to God that itself is a Yagya offering to the Lord. The best thing to have in mind is - *We are only there for some time on Earth and shall make this Life useful by dedicating it and all activities and thoughts to the Shree Charan of (your Ishta Devata whomsoever it is Durga, Ganesha, Shiva/Mahadeva, Kali, Hanuman ji, Sri Mahavishnu/Narayana etc.).* Just do this and you shall see the benefits. Also learnt that in morning you can chant *Aum Namo Bhagvathe Vasudevay* which is the moola mantra for Sri Mahavishnu and in the evening *Aum Namah Shivay* - however I gave you just Sri Rama Mantra (also called Rama Taraka Mantra) because *One Naama chanting throughout the day is more effective than chanting many.* 🙏🕉 Can give you many more Mantras which you yourself can go to any Giri Book Store an purchase and learn but some require initiation by Guru so I cannot tell you here. *If nothing is possible just this : "Hare Rama Hare Rama, Rama Rama Hare Hare, Hare Krishna Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna Hare Hare"* this you chant ! Anywhere anytime - this is a Maha mantra for Kali Yuga 🙏🕉🔱
I am chanting Om nama shivay 3 malas Gurudev data 3 malas Om namo Narayana 3 malas Shrim 1 mala Hanuman Chalisa 2 times on daily basis To get quick results Rama is enough?
Seek a Shrotriya Brahmanisth guru any Shankaracharya or any Dandi Swami and he'll guide you.........such questions aren't meant to be put on TH-cam, it should be discussed with Guru in secrecy.....😅
क्रव्य दा - क्रव्य (वध से प्राप्त मांस ) + अदा (खानेवाला) = मांस भक्षक | पिशाच - पिशित (मांस) +अस (खानेवाला) = मांस खाने वाला | असुत्रपा - असू (प्राण )+त्रपा(पर तृप्त होने वाला) = अपने भोजन के लिए दूसरों के प्राण हरने वाला | | गर्भ दा और अंड़ दा = भूर्ण और अंड़े खाने वाले | मांस दा = मांस खाने वाले | वैदिक साहित्य में मांस भक्षकों को अत्यंत तिरस्कृत किया गया है | उन्हें राक्षस, पिशाच आदि की संज्ञा दी गई है जो दरिन्दे और हैवान माने गए हैं तथा जिन्हें सभ्य मानव समाज से बहिष्कृत समझा गया है | ऊर्जं नो धेहि द्विपदे चतुष्पदे यजुर्वेद ११।८३ सभी दो पाए और चौपाए प्राणियों को बल और पोषण प्राप्त हो | हिन्दुओं द्वारा भोजन ग्रहण करने से पूर्व बोले जाने वाले इस मंत्र में प्रत्येक जीव के लिए पोषण उपलब्ध होने की कामना की गई है | जो दर्शन प्रत्येक प्राणी के लिए जीवन के हर क्षण में कल्याण ही चाहता हो, वह पशुओं के वध को मान्यता कैसे देगा ?
I find it absurd that killing an innocent animal will keep aggression alive. Want to fight? Then fight like men. Not by slaughtering an innocent animal. Show this bravado to a gang or a mafia. Courage comes from confronting difficult situations, not just unquestionable obedient slaughter of innocent beings. Get up in the morning and do training of martial arts. Do mock killings of a target but not killing living animals.
Your arguments are very much right. But remember, every practice or rite is prescribed in the shastras for a particular period of time and a particular type of people. Not everyone can carry out the instructions of shastras perfectly. This practice was limited to the mid- Dwapara Yuga only. After that, in the later years of Dwapara and in this age of Kali, such Brahmanas barely exist or perhaps they don't exist. Such exalted and qualified priests who possess the calibre to promise an elevated life for the sacrificed creature are literally nowhere. Nevertheless many are well versed in the Shastras and know their essence , it is a strenuous task to find such perfect Brahmins. Hence the best way to worship the lord for the humans of this degraded age of kaliyuga is Bhakti Yoga - Surrender unto the lotus feet of the lord and developing devotion. That alone is the best and most fruitful 'sacrifice' for us! Be blessed!!
@@xripz6899 No brother These things don't contribute to spiritual elevation in any way. These are meant only for the fulfilment of the desires of humans . Real path for liberation in the Kaliyuga is only DEVOTION towards lord in the form of your Ishta. Think of the lord always, everytime, that's the best option ;)
Shastras don't touch on animal sacrifice..... God am tired telling this to our own countrymen. Almost 99% in the comments section are perhaps either Abrahamics or hard core non - vegetarians.
Can we start restaurant which serve pashubali meat offered to devtas and u have respect and pray to the agni and devta to eat at restaurant ? We can put images of explaining what it is at restaurant walls like painting. How does that sound ?
Yes , In Tamasic restaurants.. The jhatka methods of adoption should be followed... Where a prathishtith Murthy of Devi Bhagavathi should be there... If there is a sacrifice of the poultry animal... That too under a Shaktha Practisionier... Bhagavathi Saranam 🕉️ Namaśthe 🕉️🌺
As a Devi upasakar & an animal lover, I feel torn about this.. I understand that this is part of our ancient culture, but I will never participate in such a ritual, I can't bear to see the suffering of an innocent animal.. There are better ways, mantras, kriyas, to connect with Shakti..
Dimasa and Karbi jatis of Assam perform bali with age-old standard operating systems. They are Hindu. Rest all the jatis that came under exclusive region got converted to Xtianity. Thanks to Nehru et al.
I thought food we eat should first be offered as Prasad. In any case animals are butchered in the market. Better sacrifice it and then eat. If you can't stop butchery why stop occasional sacrifices.
Arya samaj is a modern dumbed down cult mostly filled with specific groups ....have no intellectual heft. Appropriating holy books of people they don't really like...
Rajarshi, I have a question regarding the method of Balividhan done in the Tulja Bhavani temple. I was under the impression the slaughter must be done in one swift stroke/strike. The manner in which they do the bali is by striking the belly of the goat numerous times. Your view on this?
Ay ! I have her as my kuldevi and the baki partha in such temples (shaktipeeths) has been done since time immemorial so the practices that are done now are likely done since long ago. Bali has A LOT OF variations. Every diety has different techniques infact Bali is also given to lower gods and demigods in large scales.
This is actually fascinating or idk what word to use actually cause even I've heard it for the first time Even in my family when we offer bali it has to be one in one stroke Obv since our family sword is not very old so we do the things as quick as possible but it's rule to be done in one stroke so idk
Thank you for this insightful take. Till date I was reeling under this conflict of non vegetarianism and pashu Bali. I can’t stand any kind of animal killing for any purpose but was unsure of our religion’s point of view. I stay in a state where as per data 100% people are non veg. Which means people like me are not even part of 1%.
Point is humans didnt reach that level where they really care for world/ nature thats why if sanatan dharm didnt give space for non veg then 70 percent of hindus would have accepted abhrahmic religion
@@mylord8105 they will not leave because in their religion it wil result in hell, whereas hinduism doesnt have such harsh punishment related to religious practice, hindus have freedom which they dont care, just how today for fullfilment of wish i.e greed hindus go to churches, mosque because most of people in world follow religion just for greed and fullfilling their wish
@@COCSensai video ka point hai hamesa kuch achhi cheeje hongi par ohir bhi kuch log hamesha honge jo khud ke rule pe chalenge, meat avoid kar sako to achha hai kyonki human body meat ke liye nahi bani hai acc to science par kiso pe force nahi karna chahiye veg ko
Well the "vast majority of hindus are non veg" part is misleading. While it is true, shouldnt you be worried about how this change took place? There was a time when over 60% of the country was veg. After centuries of ABrahamic subjugation, hindus came to consume such a high amount of meat
A Kumaoni here bali is still prevalent in ancestral worship ceremony that we do in my part of bharat , not just prevalent its mandotary for some specific deity. We offer animals to the deitys even a baby chick is offered to a specific deity. And yes it is considered as a prashad.
Kabhi apne bacche ko daan de. Aur humein devi ka prashaad dena tab. Devi issey bhi zyada prasann hongi. Aur haan itna hi dam ho naa, toh jo hindu maare ja rahe hain, jaa unko west bengal mein bacha le. Vahan dikhaa power. Nirdosh jeewon par nahi. Aur ye ghatiya kaam devi par mat udhaa.
Wine, fish, honey, meat, alcohol, and preparations of rice and sesame seeds, have been introduced by knaves. The use of these (in sacrifices) is not laid down in the Vedas. The hankering after these arises from pride, error of judgment, and cupidity. Mahabharat, Shanti Parva, Chapter 265.
thankgod somebody said this. i was wondering if now people would call pashubali right. being an outright and absolute hindu, i cannot understand how one says that pashubali is right. yes, tantrika vidyas use them, but one must remember that tantrika vidya was a very secretive and hidden knowledge, used only during critical situations. if pashubali is right, then so should narabali be. is it? no. hence, calling the sacrifice of animals correct is actually going against the very core of hindutva
@@ankeetabose2059 tantra was created for those animalistic people who had absolutely no interest in spirituality. It makes zero sense to quote tantra books to justify pashubali. Upword is wrong here.
@@kanhaibhatt913 Nope , it's not wrong.. Of great Gurudev like Sri Adi Shankaracharya ji accepted it Who is Vedantian Then it can't be discarded.. We support Pashubali for Devi Bhagavathi 🌸 Namaśthe
(putting it here for anyone who might e interested) Each deity can have their own specific reason to like a specific type of meat. To understand what meat really is offered to the god you must observe what the animal consumes as food, and where that food in turn comes from. We can most definitely know their body composition of being made up of many green plants which grow on the earth and are a critical part of the entire cycle of life and death. Ultimately if a goat is being sacrificed, it is the vegetarian food which has transformed into the energy and form of the goat which is being sacrificed. Through scientific study it is common knowledge that plants also have emotions and life, in one perspective Bali looks at animal sacrifice as equalising that value of life in all beings including humans. Bali is a great method to wipe out ignorance that we are this body.
I agree with you that secularist who says Bali should be banned first stop eating meat and encourage its followers too but I don't agree with the continuation of Bali because Upanishads refuse the only mention of pashu Bali is ASHWA MEDHA YAGYA but the word Medha literally has several translations including kill and ending the consious so the have some dis agreement with you but i can understand your overall idea but still i would request my hindu brothers to slowly stop practising it in few temples
And Upanishads are but part of Vedas which contain hymns upon hymns in praise of Nature, Universe, the Divine, preceding Gods/deities etc. Nowhere about _Bali_ written anywhere. *Tyaaga or Yagya* yes is written but in respect to one's own wishes, feelings, negative thoughts & emotions etc. and also sacrifice of materialism. That is the very reason this is called Vedic Civilization. Mlecchha Dharma ascribes to Asuric practices, Vaidiga Dharma ascribes to Daiviga practices which involves Ahimsa and Karuna.
@Neil Bajwa Ever learnt the Vedas or the Upanishads or the Shastras ? Or does thou art know Sanskrutam ? Before spluttering out anything remember : *YOU are talking with a degree holder in Sanskrutam from a recognized University.*
@Neil Bajwa Narbali is also existed and was practiced in some part of India even up to 20th century . Those practices are now stopped . Just because something existed in past must remain in present .
@Neil Bajwa Read it : *Bali - Pujam Tatha Krutam..* - has different meanings with respect to the context. The word "Bali" in Sanskrutam refers to multitudes of things offered in Yagya or Puja which includes : Mano Bali (Sacrifice of wishes in the Mind) , Deha Bali (Sacrifice of one's body itself - metaphorically to the divine - dissolution), Phala Bali (Sacrifice of Fruits and Vegetables) etc. As per Vedic rituals bali is almost always in reference to "emotions, negativity, anger, lust etc." and the rest ascribe to offerings anointed ther term "Naivedya" like Coconut (Nalikera) , Ghee etc. *Would suggest you to kindly learn Sanskrit and our scriptures first. No one is forbidding you to do it.* Watching a TH-cam video and getting to conclusions is *completely unacademic and non sensical.*
I second Rajashri ji . I come from guwahati and Goddessses Kamakhya is our kshetra palini devi . She is one off tge three Adi Shakti peethas and as part of Kali Kula Shakta Sampradaya and Dasa Mahavidya pooja vidhi we have pancha bali vidhan , sacrificing 5 animals that include Buffalo, goat , ducks, pigions and cat fish . No mattet how far these physo frenzy libis cry to stop bali , bali will not stop there in for one single day .
Pashubali saare Dunia me hoti thi, hinduon ne symbolic Bali start ki kunki unko animal ko kill karne ka dil nahi kiya lekin Christian and Muslim bahut achi tarzh se Christmas or Bakra rid ko bahut badi Bali karte hsi
Please don't defame Tantra 🙏🏼 No scripture allows Animal killing. Animal killing is as foolish as some self proclaimed Tantrik talking about it. Bali should be given of our Shadripu, our bad habbits. Shadripu are Lobh, Kaam, Krodh, Moh, Maya & Matsarya. And Animal sacrifice actually means sacrificing the animal nature and not an external innocent being who has nothing to do with our internal mind.
Im hindu, and Im against animal slaughter without exception, be it religious or for commerical consumptions. I believe in god, and the symbolism of sacrificing animals as expelling our own darkness is frankly , sad. Rather than doing deeds of goodwill, people seem to have no objection in killing a living being after performing hateful acts. Be it pashubali, bakrid, thanksgiving, etc, all of it is wrong.
There are A LOT of theories behind Bali pratha.. the thing u mentioned as to cleaning our sins and all maybe ONE reason of it. There can be countless reasons one of them being that The GANA of the dieties eat the Bali or the bali is elevated to a next lifeform WE DONT KNOW THE EXACT TRUTH. Exactly like everything!! U may be a vaishnav but if the shaktivites know the culture of bali is extremely important. In some areas not only gods but also demigods exist who make contracts with ancestors of current human beings to accept Bali every year. The demigods protect or do any task as per the contract. Bali pratha is necessary, unstoppable, inevitable and will last till eternity as some people are also bound by contracts..
You said that animal sacrifice was told in Vedas, so tell me in which Vedas animal sacrifice was told. Do you even know the meaning of Bali? Don't defame Sanatan Dharma by making this kind of video. What animals are being killed in the world, you are promoting animal sacrifice by making such videos. Nothing like this is written in the Vedas, if it was written like this in the Vedas, then it would not have been written in the Manusmriti that killing/sacrificing an innocent creature/human is a sin.
They create explanations made of half baked understanding of the sacred scriptures. This is a propaganda video, Upword may have been taken over by anti Hindu elements.
@@Upword "Adi Shankara mentioned pashubali ..... ?!" I challenge you to come to Sringeri Mutt and in front of the respectful Acharyas for a straight debate. What stupidity you people are mentioning ?
@@TheB657 Hello This is Shaktha Dharma.. Go to any Shaktha Tantric Temples.. You can see Pashubali for Devi Chandika Our Sanatana Dharma is not just Vaishnavism...
Upword needs your support to produce more such content. Donate generously at www.upword.co/donate UPI address: upword@upi
Nah. Don't wanna shell a single penny on sanghis. U can shove ur begging bowl where the sun don't shine 😁
Very sorry but cannot support this video because the entire conclusion is from a muddled understanding of the scriptures.
Bhenchod chutiyagiri band kar. Santana Dharma kabhi kabhi hume kisi bhi masoom jeev ko maarna paap mana jata hai. Aur Vegetarian/Vegan log apne saare non-veg khane waale dost/relatives ko bhi non-veg chodne ki request karte hai. Aur itna he pasand hai tujhe non-veg khana, toh beef bhi khaa le na madarchod. Woh bhi toh ek non-veg he hai (sarcasm 😏😏). Abhi tune jo shastra padh ke dikhaye, woh sab tere he chutiya purvajonne likhe hai. Hamare bhagwan aisa kabhi nahi kehte. Modern are not at all vegetarians. Modern Hindus woh hote hai, jo khud beef khate hai, aur beef ko apni persnal choice. Vegetarian Hindus are the real Sanatani Hindus who are still attached to their roots. And most importantly, no matter which religion you belong, Christian, Muslim, Parsi or anyone, you should never eat any animal. No human being has any right to kill/eat/torture any animal.
@@TheB657 Snowflake! For the sake of society, I just hope you’re not a Kshatriya.
what kind of rubbish is this this is against the doctrane of vadanta
As simple as that Shaktas are generally warriors. If you see the history Rajputs, Marathas, Dogras, Ahoms, Gujjars etc all are celebrated warrior clans even Guru Gobind Singh Ji metaphorically used the great battle of Durga Maa and Mahishasura to inject veer ras in his Sikhs as “Chandi Di Vaar”. All these warriors has performed balis on various stages and got blessings of Maa. If they haven't done that then all Hindus were surely converted to Islam.
Jai Maa Bhavani 🙏🏻
Dude... Marathas seriously?? Rajput I can understand but marathas?? Ig ur mistaken
@@legends_gaming19who famous the slogan jai shivaji jai bhavani ?
Maratha did better job than even so called royal kshatriya
@@greaterbharat4175 I know that bro... But still jai bhawani dosent always mean cutting up animals
@@greaterbharat4175 search on Wikipedia Umayyad Campaigns in India you will get to know who the Rajputs were.
And by the way Bhonsle Clan himself claim that they are the descendants of Sisodiya Clan
@@legends_gaming19 Yes marathas give bali. There are TH-cam videos of kolhapur maratha king who sacrifice goats every year in Vijaya dashami.
People have no problem with KFC but object to occasionally performed pashubali.
Both are cruel
so.. two wrongs dont make it right anyway
@@HinduPhoenix so u don't do it then. Don't impose it on others
@@shraddha.b. bali is what the devi/devata demands, ergo is NOT wrong by ANY standards; eating non veg at KFC is mere consumerism. Did you not watch the video or are you dense? The video explains everything very clearly, seems like you just can't accept the scriptures because christian-protestant education has made you impenetrable.
@@khushiparmar1843 exactly. Why do people not understand this? Khud mat karo. Hume toh humare dharm ki paribhasha pe khade utarne do.
Easter turkey roast is fashionable, bakri eid sacrifices are valid
Hindu pashubali "how dare you "
I didn't know that conscience acts choosy 🤔🙄🤔
Exactly !!
Cuz in our hinduism we love all creatures!!!
In our relegion its already written to not sacrifise any innocent soul for our own greed
Its not in thiers
Thats why we are called sanatani's for a reason!!!
@@Beauty_bunnywho we?
Me and my ancestors all offered Bali to the gods
@@Beauty_bunny that is just one school of thought. and if u want to forcefully impose what you follow on everyone, then you are no different from Christianity and Islam who forcefully convert people of other relegion.
@@adityabhattacharyya8727😂😂 sach bolne se Darr lagta hai kya??
Poore India mei sabko zabardasti convert kiya tha tumhare Uresian Brahmano ne, jo Maan Gaya usko galam banaya jo na maana usko ya toh maar deya ya fir Achoot Shudr bana rakha hai tum logo ne....
Ambedkar ne bhi 6 lakh Hinduo ko zabardasti convert kiya tha Buddhists banaya tha na 6 lakh Hinduo ko,, zabardasti 22 pratigya leya tha unlogo ne Ambedkar k saat...
#Goodnews
The Pashubali, which was stopped by the order of Tripura HC, has been restarted by the BJP Govt. Now Pashubali is taking place in all the concerned temples of Tripura including Tripura Sundari Temple (Tripureshwari Temple), Durga Bari Temple, Chaturdash Devata Bari Temple etc.
Bjp must suffer, becz in future Kalki is coming.
Please sign this petition to support Bali Pratha:
www.change.org/bali-pratha
Please re-start sati too. Because everything which goes well with "customs" should be protected without saying. And I hope you revive back to Nar-bali too, where you will offer your bali to Maa (as per Shastras) and then your beloved wife will jump to fire for uplifting womanhood. :)
How easy it is to justify you taamsik traits under garb of devi? How can a devi, who is so karuna-mayi even think of taking life of an innocent animal? I criticize killing of animals without exception. Be it a mulla ro Hindus. Nobody gives you right to take right of an innocent. If maa wants their bali, by natural selection, she can very well take them.
The scriptures forbid the tantra maarg statistically in Kaliyug. How much blind you need to be? Actually you are not blind, you simply want to chew non-veg and justify your sinful acts. I have seen people offering alocohol to bhairav baba. Hijde saale.
Most of the offended people here eat meat everyday .
Lol ,kings went for hunting,
Is it any wrong?
Wrong. I eat meat every day and I am not offended.
Bro i eat bali meat only,,, 2-3 times in a year.,, and other days of the year without onion garlic.,, jay kali
We have Mari Puja ,Tambila and Kola ,although am not comfortable around it i still respect it cause it's been the rituals of my ancestors am proud of my history belonging to the martial race .
Nice, we are not currently in a position to question our ancestors.
The stupidity displayed in this video and in the comments is mind boggling. And for the librandu presenter, anyone these days comes up claiming to read and mention shastras and puranas and justify what they've been doing since childhood (meat eating). Just reading the shastras is not enough, there is a book called 'Science'. Multitude of pathogenesis are associated with flesh eating. But NVM, everyone is free to practice their beliefs, even if it's to kill an innocent animal.
During Mari, Bali is offered to the Mari godess. During Tambila and Kola, sacrifices are made for daiva. Not gods.
अनुमन्ता विशसिता निहन्ता क्रयविक्रयी
संस्कर्ता चोपहर्ता च खादकश्चेति घातकाः
मनुस्मृति ५।५१
मारने की आज्ञा देने वाला, पशु को मारने के लिए लेने वाला, बेचने वाला, पशु को मारने वाला,
मांस को खरीदने और बेचने वाला, मांस को पकाने वाला और मांस खाने वाला यह सभी हत्यारे हैं |
य आमं मांसमदन्ति पौरुषेयं च ये क्रविः
गर्भान् खादन्ति केशवास्तानितो नाशयामसि
अथर्ववेद ८। ६।२३
वह लोग जो नर और मादा, भ्रूण और अंड़ों के नाश से उपलब्ध हुए मांस को कच्चा या पकाकर खातें हैं, हमें उन्हें नष्ट कर देना चाहिए |
Great video thanks ! Nobody has problem with eating meat or Bakri-Eid but everyone wants to avoid PashuBali as if the entire country is vegan except for these regressive shakta Hindus.
Bali bandh karke toh dikha...
Jo bandh kaarne ayega , Usiko Baali Chada denge.
regressive shakta hindus u say huh.. quite the unwise and instigating word u have used... its just different people having different mindset how is it regressive u say?
@@_Z0ZO_ - I used the word from the perspective of the ones opposing - Courts, Indian State, many Hindus, Jains especially. They see pashubali as regressive despite enjoying a meat industry and ignoring sacrifices in other faiths. Several Shakta Peeths and Temples have Pashubali banned by the Govt.
Wtf? Progressive means leave milk and other animal products can you? Stop forcing your culture on us. We are saving a section of shakta culture through this.
@@_Z0ZO_ these are all racists ppl.
what an insight. Moral of the video : Let the Devata and Devi decide about their offerings, let's deal with mindless consumerism, it is not a sin to do hinsa if ordered by Shastras. Meat as prasad is an issue for people like PETA, but not as a mindless consumption. Very pinpoint video, thanks.
Pandit ji nar Bali ka bhi vidhaan hair bolo to chadhwane lagen.
@@vine2341 Mahoday, jab mlecchho se yuddh hoga toh nar bali bhi chadhaenge.
Phir to kisi ki bhi chadhane me kya samasya hai, mera tera kya karna, baki bali aur hatya me fark hota hai. Paap punya nahi ban jaate shastro ke adhaar pe. Bali galat hai kisi ki bhi ho, aur hamesha hogi aapse kamzor ki hi, aur kisi din aap bhi kamzor honge.
@@vine2341 Aapka tark uchit hai parantu aapki aagya se mai kuchh tathya aapke samaksh prastut karta hu, jinke dwaara aapko dharm-adharm athva bali-hatya ka antar spasht ho jaega.
1. Narbali keval yuddh ke samay dee jaati hai, weh bhi keval Rannchandika athva Kaalbhehrav ko. Hatya ka koi samay nahi hota.
2. Narbali sadyav uss shatru ki dee jaati hai jo ranbhoomi me sa-shastra prastut ho aur jiska Kshatriya dharma ke anusaar vadh kiya gaya ho. Aashanvit hun ki aapko hatya ve vadh ka antar gyaat hoga.
3. Brahmin, Stree, Balak, Gau athva yuddh me Nishastra vyakti ki bali kadapi nahi dee jaati. Isske paschaat, Narbali me balwaan ve nirbal vyakti me antar nahi kiya jaata. Yadi weh vyakti yuddh me aapke viruddh shastra liye prastut hai, itna paryaapt hai.
Mai samajhta hu ki aap Narbali ko aaj ke samaaj ke sandarbh me dekh rahe hain, jiske kaaran aapko yeh vishay aapattijanak prateet ho raha hai. Parantu vichaar keejiye, ki samaaj me koi niyam na ho, aisi sthiti ho ki pratyek manushya apni pashu-pravarti se jeevan jeene lage, aisi stithi me ek sabhya samaj ki sthapna karne ke liye ek bhaag ko hinsa ko apna dharma banana padta hai, kyonki yadi woh bhag hinsa nahi karega toh koi ananya samuhik hinsa karega. Bal athva hinsa ke bhay se hee ek sabhya samaaj ki sthapna sambhav hoti hai.
@@Gandivpani Mai aapke kuch tarkon se sehmat hu dharma ki sthapna ke liye hinsa galat nahi hai parantu isse pehle dharm hai kya yah jaanna bohot aavashyak hai. Mai hinsa ka viroodhi nahi hu, magar akaaran ki gayi hinsa se bura kuch ho bhi nahi sakta. Udharan ke liye kisi ashwa ko apne aham ke liye saare desh me ghumana aur phir us ashwa ki bali de dena mere samaksh uchit karya nahi hai.
Dharma ki samajh tabhi sambhav hai jab aham ka lop ho, aham dharm ko bhi adharm banane ki kshamta rakhta hai. Agar keeval usi adhaar pe bali di jaye jis adhaar pe aapne kaha to wah uchit hogi, parantu jaise hi bali aham aur ichchaon ko sadhne ka ek yantr ban jaati hai wah galat ho jaati hai (phir wo chahe kisi devta ko prasann karne ke liye ho athwa kisi aur karanvash), iska hame dhyaan rakhna chahiye.
To all those pseudo Hindus, he just gave you all a middle finger, agree with him, Peta is silent during ramzan & christmas but active when it is a Hindu festival
I am a Garhwali. My grandparents got Bali mutton as prasadam when they were kids. Pashu Bali is most important to keep the urga element of Hinduism alive. Else we become too soft. Yes, we can be extracting and penetrative. Pashu Bali should survive anyhow.
As far as I know in Uttarakhand there are villages following Vegetarianism compared to the rest of India even better than some parts on Rajasthan and Gujarat ! Hence Sir don't know which religion you belong to or what cult but *your grandparents attending pashu balis is nowhere related to the scriptures advocating pashu bali - which is non existent in the texts* .
@@TheB657 lol He is totally Hindu and Hindu scriptures have pashubali even Madhawacharya and other vaishnavacharys in there bhasyas have supported Pashubali.
Vedas also supports pashubali
You are might be some crypto Christian larping as Hindus and making them feel guilty about following there rituals
@@blazeofsea6843 Could you kindly provide the link to any of the pages of the books hallmarked for circulation to teach the Vedas in Universities or any such institutions or Gurukulas ? I would love to learn from you ( *whom seems to be more of a blind keyboard warrior lest a degree holder in Indian scriptures* ) - *exactly which line or stanza justifies and advocated Pashu bali ?!* Could you kindly please link the books and quote the verses ?
Yes It Keeps the warrior culture alive In us .
Also in The place We live in the mountains Where growing Food is hard and Yeild is less eating grians Isn't enough that'swhy even mountainous Brahmins have meat except certain periods during the year
@@TheB657 I am from Uttrakhand even Brhamins eat meat here So do all native Hill Brahmins from Kashmir to Arunanchal Pradesh
Someone claiming kalikapuran does not mention bali. Totally wrong. It has a segment called rudhiradhyaya describing details of various balis from chapter 67 onwards.
Regarding yogini tantra the original tantra was always used in eastern kamakhya and bengal where vamacara and kaulacara is norm. Chagabalitustha is the right description matches with the anecdotal story of the King who got his kingdom back post chagbali in kamakhya pitha.
Other versions of the stotra were created later by those who tamper texts because they are uncomfortable with shastra vakya.
Even in Odisha tantra was prevalent before converting to Jainism and Buddhism 😢
I'm jain bt for me if we want to defeat our enemy we need to keep our aggression alive..else kashmir Pakistan Bangladesh etc will repeat
You don't have to eat meat to defeat enemy. Always remember "aatm bal" comes from inside.
@@amurarka7876 the so called concept of atmabal has only lead to afghanistan converted , vasts parts of current pakistan had jain influence , what happened, all were brutally converted . When u have concepts of non violence and sainthood as ideals of life , dharma cannot be defended .Pashubali is essential for shakta rituals . Else you cannot complain about your opponent being brutal.
@@Apex1008 read Geeta, What Shree Krishna bagwan has said to Arjun. He told Arjun to fight against Adharm, but never told to do animal sacrifice.
@@Apex1008 Swami Samarth Ramdas( Guru of Shivaji maharaj), Acharya Raghvendra( Guru of Maharana Pratap), Banda bairagi, Guru govind singh ji, these people are examples what atmbal can do, they made their disciples to fight against Adharm.
@@amurarka7876 Vaishnav school of thought is not hinduism alone . Bhagwatam , bhagwad geeta , has had a lot of influence, interference , changes of medival bhakti movement of vaishnavs . Original texts of hinduism had bali . The overaching influence of Vaishnavism , jainism , gandhism has ruined the spirit of kshatra dharma out of hinduism .
If you see too much of Ramanand sagar serials or babas from vrindavan , your world view of hinduism will be localized .
I am from Mithla , Pashubali is very common here during Durga puja & kalipuja 🙏 Jai maa chamunde 🙏🙏
😂😂😂😂lindu
@@Owner.of.omniverse says a Terrorist with 5 fathers who born after a revolutionary process of Halala 😂😂
Chup chakke @@Owner.of.omniverse
@@INFINITY-X- chup andhbhakt
@@Owner.of.omniverse chup Kati lulli
The grandeur of Sanatana Dharma is that those who favour pashubali and those who are against it, both come under the umbrella of Sanatana. This is the diversity that it promises, not a seeming rational external person who imposes some admittedly questionable practices upon the entire framework of Sanatana criticizing it loudly enough to delude half-informed or uninformed Hindus.
Hi Namaste 🙏🏻 I'm from Kerala. The land of saktheya(sakthism ) tantrika tradition. I'm a hindu too, my family belongs to Nair community having tantrika upasana for generations. From that knowledge, meat including beef is not sinful in Hinduism.💯 Lord sri raman conducted aswa meda yagam. That itself was a horse sacrificing yagam. His father king Dasaratha Maharaj conducted putrakameshti Yagam before the birth of Sri Ram. That also was a horse sacrificial Yagam conducted by brahmins and the animal fat called "vamam" in Samskritham deposit to the yaga agni (holy fire) & the rest of the meat is prepared as the prasadam(divine food ) for Suryavamshi family members including sri raman. The King randi Devan conducted agni hotri yagam for his moksham, which is a cow, goat and horse sacrificial yagam,(trikarams in Samskritham, which means 3 different animals for sacrifice )the leather of the animals which are slotted for Yagam where get deposit into the river. Latterly the same river get called as charmanvati river which is in today's U. P or charmatha nadi( the nadi(river) which is dumped by charmam(skin/leather)). Not only in vedic-tantrik rituals,If you look at the case of ayurvedic medicines several medicines are prepared from several meat. Even the gorjana pills are prepared from cow meat. The colloidal meat inside cows intestine called "gorochanam" is the main ingredient for preparing Gorochana pills, like that aja mamsa rasayanam is prepared from goat meat. If you look deep and deep you can see several things related to ithihasa, purana,tantrika, vaidehika(vedic),mandrika, ayurveda, sidda vaidya sculptures shows the usage of meats in rituals and daily diet too. So my fellow northies, try to study vedic, tantrika, Upanishads from proper gurus those having mandra deeksha or upasana parambaryam. Not from so called religious political parties and fake demi gods.it's a request. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻Because We malayalis don't want to get " 'bh'ucked" like Kashmiri pandits, those who were knowingly avoided the authentic kashmiri shaiva tantrika upasana padhathi for so called vegetarian Supremacy .💯 For us,Their tragedy is our moral story.❤️🙏🏻
@Warrrrr452 I'm from Travancore(specifically from Pathanamthitta district ) The actual "para devatha kshetram" or "kula devatha kshetram" of Travancore dynasty and travancore royal family is "Kollampuzha thiruarattu badrakali devi temple" situated in the place called Attingal of Thiruvananthapuram district. The Travancore king self declined as "padmanabha dasar" at the time of "Marthanda Varamman maharajan" as the ritual called "Thrippadi Danam" ( it was a promise or oath that taken by marthanda Varma,which means, "what ever he conquered including land,kingdoms and wealth should be offered to the feet of lord sri Padmanabhan") he was the same king who renovated the decayed krishna Swamy temple in 18th century. Actually before the time of marthanda Varma Maharajan, the temple don't have that much connection with the Travancore royal family. There was a common folklore which is still existing in southern Kerala, About the story of "Divakaran Muni" and the "lost child of Anandhan Kadu" ( The Lost child of Anandan forest is Lord Sri Padmanabha swamy in the form of a child ) Diwakaran rishi is the one who conjured the sri padmanabha swami in desired size of his "yoga dandh". And build a small Krishna temple as a "krishna peedam" even several centuries before the Travancore and adhi pandiya vamsham. King marthanda Varma Mahajan was a saktheyan by birth and a hard core mahavishnu upasakan at the same time, (sakrheyam by his traditional upasana parambaryam and vaishavam by his personal desire).and one more thing even in vaishana upasana lord narasimha swamy, parashu raman, chathur bahu narayana moorthis, yudha swaroopa raman, maha sudarshana moorthy, are devoted in the same tantrika aspects including panchamakaram (malsya, mamsa, madhu, mudra, maidhunam ) in Kerala. So don't be mistaken about only saktheyar have the panchamakara sadhana parambaryam in Kerala. Veera Vaishavar (excluding bhramin community ), veera saiva sadhakar, saktheyar have common method of tantrika devotion based on panchamakara Sadhana. 🙏🏻
@Warrrrr452 basically Kali worshippers are high in Kerala.
@Warrrrr452so as in the east and particularly in Bengal where Kali Kula Shakta Sampradaya is prevelant . Yet there is no reference and mention of bull sacrifice or consumption of beef amongst Hindus anywhere . I see the Hindus in kerela justifies beef eating as part of ritual which is no where written in any tantra texts .
@@vishaldasgupta4573 adipoli👏🏻👏🏻😂😂😂I already mentioned that, the use of so called divine beef (gorochanam) in the field of Ayurvedam. Bhai, it's not about justifying using Vedantham or tantrikam it's about your people's mind set. You people can't accept that💯 that's the fact.👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 In saktheya sampridayam, devi durga is devoted as ugra Mahishasura Mardini", "The black healthy bull" is the bali mrigam for that ritual of Panchamakara Sadhana. The musical instrument called Nadha Damru or udukk which is hold by Lord Shivan is manufactured from leather not from chicken feather. He and whole gurus including saptha rishis are meditated on leather mat. Not on khadi mat. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻kaula shaiva aradhana, dhakshina and uthara kalika sampridayam (whole vama margam)and veera vaishana upasana like lord narasimha swamy upasana are considered as "guptha vidyas"💯💯💯💯 which means form of divine secret upasana padhathis, So it's methods and rituals mandras, sookthams won't get published in Hindu newspaper or Indian Express. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
@@BharathChandrasenan give me one reference where it is written . We too are from Kali Kula Shakta Sampradaya . I come from Assam and Goddesses Kamakhya who is adorned as the primary Adi Shakti peethaswari is our Mula poojita Devi . No where in our ancestors in the past or present have I heard of Cow slaughter or Cow Bali . We follow kaula Ugrachanda Rajrajashree and Bhairava upasana where we have pancha Bali Vidhan of offering five animals . There is a buffalo , goat , ducks , pigeons and cat fish offered . Buffalo not cow . All shaktipeethas in the east , to northeast , to Nepal , Kashmiri Shaivism there is sacrifice of a buffalo not cow . Never was cow in the past nor in present . I know places in Bengal and Assam where we had Nara Bali(human sacrifice) done in the past centuries never had cow been sacrificed . Stop justifying ur beef eating and cow killing liking to Shakta Sampradaya . One of the primary belief of being a Hindu is protection of cows within all 6 major sampradayas no question of malification or modification in it. Yes the leather used in most instrumental music so as damru are all made of buffalo leather . Leather of only tiger skin or mriga deer skin is allowed for asana else it's made of kusha. We have panchamundi asana Pooja vidhan of 5 animal skulls are set underneath the mula vigraha but never ever again i stand it's cow . Buffalo sacrifice is permitted under the pretext of the black healthy bull don't mix it with cow killing 🙏
Our Owner is a Great Accountant. So those who enjoy Bali please do so. When the time comes you too shall be called to account.
Thank god for this video, dada
In my patriarchal home Durga Puja is being done from past 400 years and somehow the current generations have resorted to chaalkumdo pratikatmak bali I don't know why but I was really sad coz we should not change what she is being offered for traditions.
I have great reverence for Sir Rajarshi Nandy. He is the one (among others) who is single handedly bringing forward the Shakta Parampara to common people like us and making us learnt of our very own texts. Thank you Sir and Jai Maa Kamakhaya
I am from Rajasthan and have seen many people who do bali and eat that meat but the bali is given in proper shastriya form and that meat is not cooked with onion or garlic so it's won't take द्विजत्व even if a dwij eats it.
There is a whole antyaja jaati is there named Khateek who used to supply Jhatka meat to the Hindus in past times Now most of them have abondoned there traditional work as the ambedkerite propaganda started and they lived there traditions for government jobs and other. and that is one of the reason Halal industry getting stronger in Meat Industry, Now in Rajasthan mostly Rajputs are doing this Jhatka meat business and in some places khateek to have retained there traditions.
I know many brahmins who eat meat. What the the issue now?
@@rk-is3cw क्रव्य दा - क्रव्य (वध से प्राप्त मांस ) + अदा (खानेवाला) = मांस भक्षक |
पिशाच - पिशित (मांस) +अस (खानेवाला) = मांस खाने वाला |
असुत्रपा - असू (प्राण )+त्रपा(पर तृप्त होने वाला) = अपने भोजन के लिए दूसरों के प्राण हरने वाला | |
गर्भ दा और अंड़ दा = भूर्ण और अंड़े खाने वाले |
मांस दा = मांस खाने वाले |
वैदिक साहित्य में मांस भक्षकों को अत्यंत तिरस्कृत किया गया है | उन्हें राक्षस, पिशाच आदि की संज्ञा दी गई है जो दरिन्दे और हैवान माने गए हैं तथा जिन्हें सभ्य मानव समाज से बहिष्कृत समझा गया है |
ऊर्जं नो धेहि द्विपदे चतुष्पदे
यजुर्वेद ११।८३
सभी दो पाए और चौपाए प्राणियों को बल और पोषण प्राप्त हो | हिन्दुओं द्वारा भोजन ग्रहण करने से पूर्व बोले जाने वाले इस मंत्र में प्रत्येक जीव के लिए पोषण उपलब्ध होने की कामना की गई है | जो दर्शन प्रत्येक प्राणी के लिए जीवन के हर क्षण में कल्याण ही चाहता हो, वह पशुओं के वध को मान्यता कैसे देगा ?
Absolutely man, these (far leftists ) continuously targeting (Sanatan Dharma) its rituals & texts, while defending evil texts like (Quran & Hadith) ,but we have to do the same with these non- Hindus expose these evils.👍
@@rk-is3cw they don't have knowledge of dharm i guess , in sastra s told that it is good eat own flesh rather eat other. It is only restricted to bramhan.
@@deviprasadpadhy8840 No. There are even traditional brahmins who eat meat and sacrifice animals during festivals. Especially Maithali and Bengali Brahmins.
Sir one of your favourite said "Sri Aurobindo - What about the sacrifice of harmless animals to Kali? Useless and therefore inadvisable. External sacrifices of this kind have no longer any meaning - as so many saints have said, sacrifice ego, anger, lust etc. to Kali, not goats or chickens.'"
Anyone who is against bali is weak and he can not fight wars.
As legends say "Veer bhogya vasundhara" only brave shall inherit earth.
Actually weak to wo log hote hain jo khud ko bali nhi dete
Because khud ki bali dene ka sahash na hone ke karan dusro ki jindagi khatam karna chahte hain
Yahi sabse badi weakness hai
Nirdosh jaanwaro ko markar kon sa bada kaam karte hain hum aaj ke mahishasur ban gaye hain hum sab to
Agar bali deni hai to kisi phal ke jaise naariyal kathal etc ki de do
Kisne kaha weak hote hain warrior nhi hote
Satya aur dharm ki raksha ke liye yuddh karna sikhna chahiye na ki in anjaan bejuban jaanwaro ke saath yuddh karna chahiye
@@rashmisatpathy5127haaaaa😢
@@rashmisatpathy5127aap bhagwan ho
There is pashubali performed at many Sri Urga Narasimha temples. Although the Sri Vaishnava sampradaya won’t agree to that, the common people bring goats and offer them as Bali to the lord.
Vaishnavs sampradaya emphasizes on satvik offerings. Also these things became anti-tamsik during bhakti movement where hardcore vaishnavism/satvik lifestyle was emphasized in Gangetic plains.
Idk if vaishnavs in orrisa are hardcore vegetarians, but for sure the offerings are satvik.
जय ही नरसिंह देवता🙏🙏🙏
There are only a handful of "Ugra Narasingha" temples . Can you provide an example of such a temple where such a ritual takes place (as you claim that there are "many" such temples) ?. The one I know of is that in Ahobila . But people make the mistake of thinking that the Mahalakhsmi temple , i.e. the Chenchu Lakshmi temple as a Narasingha or a Vaishnav temple. It is clearly due to the tribal influence in that area that this practice takes place and has nothing to do with Vaishnavism . Animal sacrifice in Mahalakshmi temple is not uncommon as I know of another one in Maharashtra. Ultimately the point is that it cannot be regarded as a Vaishnav temple as the worship is done by Shakta means. This is not uncommon. Take the Jagannath Temple for example. Inside the temple complex , the Bimala Temple is a shakti pith and animal sacrifice takes place once a year during durga puja.
It's a warrior practice it's very very needful.
Yeah. I'm sure the warriors would face goats in the battlefield who would allow them to decapitate them without resistance. It's a violent and dark practice and anyone who disagrees have got to be either disillusioned or have to agree that the god/goddess they are praying to are not "benevolent" and they must hate those animals . I am talking about Hindus, Muslims Jews and any "civilized" non tribal culture which tolerates animal sacrifice.
Aithreya brahmana of rigveda and other brahmanas has entire chapters dedicated to animal sacrifice...including type of animal, mantras to be told during scarifice, preparing animal, ways the meat should be chopped and which part of body should be offered into fire with what mantra etc...only idiots who never read scriptures deny it.
There need to restore (Gurukula System, Vedas Bhagvad geeta Path should be made compulsory for every Hindu to read daily) .Hindus don't know their granthas so anti-Hindus take benefit of this.👍
@@VVVedic why only vedas and bhagawat gita. there are many sect who don't consider bhagawat gita or veda as their main scripture.
@ola_uber6631 then shaivism, samkhya is not hindus by your logic. read samkhya karika, shiva sutra of vasugupta.
@ola_uber6631😁😁 lol . have you read samkhya karika yourself? pls read karika 2 of samkhya karika. the adi Shankaracharya mentioned in bramha sutra vasya that main opponent(pradhan malla) of advaita vedanta in samkhya. Without knowledge , don't blabber.
@ola_uber6631 then shaivism is not hindu by you logic. Beacuse its not based on veda. Its based on agamas.
We in the Mountains do Pashu bali, When I was 18 I did bali of 11 goats,
It's just Our culture,
In olden times when Agriculture was not possible in the Mountains, People ate Meat to survive,
Like the people in the Plains offer what they eat to their God's,
We do the same.
This isnt culture buddy, u got the wrong idea mate... Culture is reflected in ur personality ur ways of treating others ur devotion and ur manners and love towards all of creation
@@legends_gaming19 shastras over feelings anyday
@@tusharsharma8952 oh yeah really??
@@legends_gaming19 yup, whatever is written in shastras, we follow that. Shastras gave us this culture.
@@tusharsharma8952 well...the shastras aren't the same as they were originally are they?
Offering bali to Devi and eating prasad meat was a community building activity for Kshatriyas which boosted their tamasic tendencies to fight and provided them with enough protein to build muscles.
Not necessary...Maharana Pratap Singh Ji was Vegetarian..just saying✌️🙏
@@कश्परैना That's just a part of cultural practice nowadays to assume that our heros were vegetarian, Maharana Pratap Ji literally died hunting an animal what was it for? Also contrary to many people's belief even Bhagwan Ram wasn't vegitarian, Ramayan has several mentions of mansand/gosht in it; but yeah if given a choice vegetarian is definitely better according to modern sensibilities.
@@shikharverma1661 No, vegetarism is superstition
@@कश्परैना no lol .
And I think you're a Kashmiri, even you guys are non-veg people .
Nowhere it's written in scriptures
Nice to see so many snowflake meltdowns in the comments. Pashubali is an integral part of Shakta traditions and shall continue to be. Cope. If you dont't like it, don't partake/ participate in it. Simple. Nobody has given you the authority to take away my rights of worship. Just as I should not shove meat prasad on your plate, you also should not take away my Khadga.
Indeed! No wonder the Hindu society has become impotent and devoid of Kshatriya spirit. One who cannot behead an animal without blinking a eye, what will such a person do on the battlefield.
Wine, fish, honey, meat, alcohol, and preparations of rice and sesame seeds, have been introduced by knaves. The use of these (in sacrifices) is not laid down in the Vedas. The hankering after these arises from pride, error of judgment, and cupidity.
Mahabharat, Shanti Parva, chapter 265.
Hit something that fights back, Puranic cults wont save you in the end
@@vuser456 in Rajasthan Gujrat, Jain Baniya, Vaishnava, Swaminathan influence has made people vegetarian
@@rajatchakraborty1661 budh jain influence was probably the worst thing to happen to vedic religion.
@@tusharsharma8952kuch ni jab hum log bajrang dal wale ka ya karni sena wale inko thokna start krenge to ye apni aukat mai a jaenge jain ho ya buddh apni aukaat mai rahe.
They can't intervene in our religion
As always a wonderful episode
I completely support bali pratha
I believe apart from worshipping our gods it invokes masculinity in men (for those who offer bali to the mother goddess).
You are out of your mind if you think killing the indefensible invokes some kind of deranged masculinity. Paurush is defending the indefensible not killing them.
How ironic is that you said "mother" goddess requires bali. Does a mother ever want that? Think.
@@vaibhavyadav9912 That question is what he address in the video. It has been prescribed in by our Gurus & Siddhas. Why should we always disagree and demand logic from our rituals which we don;t completely understand. Read more before being critic.
@@vaibhavyadav9912 nen traditionally were hunters. A small level of barbaric mindset is ingrained in all men.
@@pangolinkumar2329 Please make me understand what good comes from killing an innocent animal. I admit I haven't read enough but if you or anyone has, please explain. Because Sri Nandy's only justification is "it's written hence it is true". How's that any different from those abrahamics who consider book before brain.
We are the civilization which had developed the concept of "tark" buddhi when others didn't even know what tark was. Please do not sideline logic/tark as a foreign concept.
We must understand that it wasn't like before the invasions we were living in a utopia. Yes We were much much better than the others but still not perfect. That's why Sri Adi Shankaracharya made his life goal to restore Dharma. Anything written in Sanskrit is not be considered as Dharma, it should be thought and discussed upon. Tark is also considered one of the Rishis.
If any Devi "maa" demands we kill other animals to please her is she really a maa then? I am having a hard time understanding it. Even Lord Shiva the king of tamas doesn't demand to kill. Not even Kali maa demands it. We assume she does.
@@VigneshV-lo6fi Agree and also I am not against total Total annihilation of violence since it is needed to stop the ones who destroy Dharma. But how does meat and pashubali has anything to do with it.
Haryana contains highest number of vegetarian people in India and it's not like they lack anything physically. Even the pehelwans there are vegetarian and complete Bajrang bhakt.
Very true yaar . Pashubali is a big no no.
But Hyderabadi biriyani is famous. 😂
Pashubali is not a part of Hinduism. I am saying it with all confirmation.
@@amurarka7876 😂
Then see this
Valmiki Ramayan Bala Kanda 1, Sarga 14, Verses 33-38 “With great delight coming on her Queen Kausalya reverently made circumambulations to the horse, and symbolically killed the horse with three knives. Queen Kausalya desiring the results of ritual disconcertedly resided one night with that horse that flew away like a bird…Then the priest, one with controlled senses and rich in scriptural wealth, took up the omentum [fat] of the horse and cooked it as per scriptures while dropping into the altar of fire to bake as a food to the celestials…Those remaining body parts that horse are there, the sixteen officiating priests have procedurally oblated all of them into fire.”
Rig Veda 1.162.3--This goat, the portion of Pu+ṣan fit for all the gods, is brought first with the fleet courser, to that Tvaṣṭā may prepare him along with the horse, as an acceptable preliminary offering for the (sacrificial) food.” This whole chapter talks about sacrificing and slaughtering in the name of God.
Atharva Veda, book7, hymn 5--.....With dog the Gods, perplexed, have paid oblation, and with cow's limbs in sundry sacrifices.
Vishnu Puran 5.1.86 सुरामांसोपहरैश्च भक्ष्यभोज्यैश्च पूजिता । Propitiated with offerings flesh and various viands
Bhagwat Puran 10.2.10 अर्चिष्यन्ति मनुष्यास्त्वां सर्वकामवरेश्वरीम् । धूपोपहारबलिभि: सर्वकामवरप्रदाम् ॥ By sacrifices of animals, dhup, ordinary human beings will worship you, because you are supreme in fulfilling all desires of everyone.
Devi Bhagwat 3.26.34 also says:- देव्यग्रे निहता यान्ति पशवः स्वर्गमव्ययम् । न हिंसा पशुजा तत्र निघ्नतां तत्कृतेऽनघ ॥ O sinless one! The goats, etc.,
@@amurarka7876 he made a damn video saying that pashubali is not wrong and you are saying that pashubali is not part of hinduism ?!
@@Rajveer-q3t6c yes. Pashubali is not a part of Hinduism.
i think if we sacrifice animals, mother will give them a meaningful life like human being. My lovely mother not only destroys but also creates and transforms. I am interested in Vamachara
Rajarshi Bro! You have changed my life in past few months! Thanks bro.. big fan! Yo!
Very informative...
You successfully influenced one more "secular" Hindu.
अनुमन्ता विशसिता निहन्ता क्रयविक्रयी
संस्कर्ता चोपहर्ता च खादकश्चेति घातकाः
मनुस्मृति ५।५१
मारने की आज्ञा देने वाला, पशु को मारने के लिए लेने वाला, बेचने वाला, पशु को मारने वाला,
मांस को खरीदने और बेचने वाला, मांस को पकाने वाला और मांस खाने वाला यह सभी हत्यारे हैं |
@@abra3647 How does this even matter in this context ?
We must save animal sacrifice and make it mainstream 🙏 long live Shakti 🙇
It should be stopped at any cost
Forget about y 'bali'.
The north Indian vegetarians are on denial mode about their god Ram been a non-vegetarian according to the Valmiki Ramayan Which is more than 2000 yr old.
For them, 500 yrs old Ramacharitramanas is more holier than the valmiki Ramayan.
There are three types of worship by hindus based on their gunas, people with satva guna are the ones who are too sensitive and they feel the pain of others and their form of worship is even in that way, there are people who donot pluck flowers or pick fruits from trees for food or pooja, they just eat the fruits that fall off and use flowers that fall off from trees.
The second way is Rajasic type of worship by building large temples and offer large amounts of financial offerings.
The thamasic way of worship is they offer meat and alchol as prasad for devas.
Mostly kings and some trades people used do pasu bali in olden days.
Pasu bali used to be offered before going to wars.
True..... actually yes ......this should have been the ending of this video. 👍
Yes bro that is the main reason, as many times tamsik guna is seen as a negetive attribute , but people tend to forget that tamsik people are also very good warriors because of there agressive attitude. Thus people belonging to tamsik guna are more leaned towards worshipping maa kali and kalbhairav roop of Mahadev. Thus sacrifices are performed for only them as they are the only deities that accept it , this is actually the beauty of Sanatan Dharma where a person can choose a way of worship rather than follow something mindlessly written in a single book , this creates the diversity which is absolutely necessary for a functioning society.
@@arkadeepchanda9524 you are confusing rajas with Tamas aggression comes from rajas
@@dhruvkapri3601 but anger and violent attitude belongs to tamas guna right, rajas Guna has this excessive benevolence type of attitude isn't it? 🤔. Well may be i am wrong, idk 😅✌️
@@arkadeepchanda9524 no actually benevolence is satva guna as it forgives and keeps our mind cool and happy rajas is basically when a person feels too much energized and raw masculinity are all rajasic a soldier must be brave that comes from rajas meanwhile Tamas makes us lazy and irritated over small things that's all what I know about these 3 gunas
Myself earlier had a strong view against Pasu Bali, but this video has made me rethink on 2 points.
1. There isn't a way to formally educate Hindus on sanatan dharma and it's practices.
2. Consumerism has been acceptable to us, I myself have been a non-vegetarian but was against the Pasu Bali in temples as I find it against the spirit of the holy place but I now agree that offering must be according to the liking of deity and not that we approve.
Pashubali is not in Hinduism. It is a wrong practice.
In tulunadu (tulu speaking area's i.e mangalore, udupi etc), daivaradhana took place, where people sacrifice chicken to daiva's as 'agel seve'
isn't chicken considered "impure" to be offered to deities? I thought only goats etc. were allowed.
@@Ankitwriter812 no it's not considered to be impure, even every year chicken should be offered to the deities
It's a contract that was likely taken by ur ancestors to the diety
We Bengalis and other Indians are too much knowledgeable and ignorant when it comes to Bali...Modern Bengalis can consume meat , eat chiken biriyani but when comes to bali pratha they suddenly became extra knowledgeable . And what happened for this ?? We became vulnerable to invaders.
why is the Teeka red in Hinduism ......also tell how rituals were modified to make us cowrds who stand the sight of blood
Great video as always!!
In today’s time bali pradha is even more important.
Decimation of dharma is because hindus have left all hardcore prathas.
Muslims don’t fear blood as they are used to it now.
Hindus can’t even hold a knife well,leave alone to slaughter.
Remember kanhaiya lal how did they slaughtered him.
We as Bhumihar brahmin regularly kept our relation with blood good. In result mahadev blessed us with sacred land of kashi, huge amount lands in bihar.
❤
Spot on! Look at most upper caste people. It's laughable. Bags of rice 🍚 and atta. Eating boondi ladoos as prasadam. Where is the purusha/masculine element? Why are Indian men butt of all jokes globally? Look at the over safe parenting? Where is the risk affinity?
How come you become a Brahmin while having Singh in surname , just asking?
Except for Bhumihar part agree to the rest of the msg. Just get over this caste hysteria
Brahimdev, as a Kshatriya, I completely agree with you! It’s a shame that today you wouldn’t find a single shastra in a Kshatriya’s house. Kshatriya giving up weapons is adharma of the highest order!
I’m a huge animal lover and I’m actually traumatised by pashubali. But I somehow swallowed the fact that it’s a necessary evil to pacify fierce gods and goddesses.
Ma is way too practical for our sentiments.
Edit: one of the reasons I’ve chosen to be a vaishnava. I used to eat lot of meat but now I’m a vegetarian after seeing the bloodshed caused by meat consumption. I even use cruelty free products.
Human activities like agriculture, industry etc leads to deforestation and climate change. Going by your logic people should live a primitive hunter gatherer life in order to not adversely impact the world, as deformation is a horrible thing.
@@binodkumarbharat3277 Uhh…. First of all I did not bring the topic of climate change here. . And btw, climate change is a hoax. Do some research on its sinister agenda to implement the new world order.
Edit: I wrote that comment because personally I’m very sensitive to animal suffering. I myself have no choice but to support this practice because my opinions actually don’t matter when it comes to shastras.
@@pranithamurali8926 wake up
Even I stay away from any kind of violence since I'm an ardent follower of Goswami Tulsidas ji and Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, but still I believe pashu bali in accordance to shastras.
Wake Up bro. You're a victim of Vegan propoganda
Ixlmic halal is also ritual involving god. But entire system is ok with it.
Only hindu Bali pratha is human cruality
Thanks to the Secular Bengalis.
exactly
In such a detailed exposition, I thought the question of why does the diety like the 'pashubali' or the meat as an offering would be answered? For example, there is a reason why Lord Vishnu likes Tulsi and why Lord Shiva likes Bilva-patra as offering.
If anyone can explain, please do so.
Good question, just being curious to know the reason for Tulsi and Bilva patra
For slow purification of a devotee who is in tamsik/rajsik guna. If u eat un-offered meat, it's not prasad. But if u eat meat that is offered as prasad, it eventually is prasad so helps in spiritual elevation. Also, there are many dos and don't while doing bali. A way of restricting meat consumption among tamsik followers. Like in a rehab, they give small dose of drugs, not to make u a druggie but to slowly mauke you stop. This is spiritual rehab. Hope I didn't confuse u.
@@bundilster Beautiful name 'Tryambak'.
Now, Tulsi was one of the foremost devotees of Lord Vishnu and as far as I remember, she took a promise from Vishnu that nothing should happen to her husband in a certain context, which he granted. But, her husband died leaving the promise broken and widowing her. To show his grace, Lord Vishnu granted moksha to her and promised her that she would be worshipped equally with the Lord himself, would be a symbol for prosperity and would be the most beloved offering in the worship.
Lord Shiva chooses the most underrated things and discredited things for worship. That's His benevolence and also a sign of how easy it is to please him. If you read about Bilva, from Wiki - " It has a reputation in India for being able to grow in places that other trees cannot. It copes with a wide range of soil conditions (pH range 5-10), is tolerant of waterlogging and has an unusually wide temperature tolerance from −7-48 °C." And so, Shiva chose that as being an essential for his worship, because it is found in abundance and also, where most trees don't grow, to show inclusivity.
Hope this is helpful, although I would highly recommend you to check other versions of the story.
@@nishakanchan7682 Okay, so if a non-vegetarian is on a path to become a satwik (vegetarian), your reasoning completely make sense. But, such practices are attended by people who already follow a satwik lifestyle and may not be able to take part in the offering.
The closest explanation I once got was, it was a symbolism and a lesson to teach us that, mortality and complete submission to the Goddess from whom we all came from, is inevitable. I wasn't quite satisfied with the explanation as it lacked a concrete moral narrative as in the case of Tulsi/Bilva (read my other comment).
@@nishakanchan7682 nowhere written in scriptures..only personal interpretation
Bali is an integral part of Shaktism. If shakt people don't interfere about Satvik practices why should they oppose shakt rituals.
Why are you interfering with the animal’s life?
@@jarvistech112 bcs we are not prohibited from doing so
In Mahavidya upasana in shaktachara, validan is must, and it is our culture.
For all those who are placing sentiment and namby pamby emotions above scripture , here are one of the two greatest seers, Ramanujacharya and Madhavacharya have to say about Bali Vidhan.
here is what Ramanujacharya says in the Sri Bhashya, his commentary on the Brahma Sutras:
‘It is not so, on account of scriptural statement. For Scripture declares that the killing of sacrificial animals makes them to go up to the heavenly world, and therefore is not of the nature of harm. This is declared in the text, 'The animal killed at the sacrifice having assumed a divine body goes to the heavenly world'; 'with a golden body it ascends to the heavenly world.' An action which is the means of supreme exaltation is not of the nature of harm, even if it involves some little pain; it rather is of beneficial nature.--With this the mantra also agrees: 'Thou dost not die, thou goest to the gods on easy paths; where virtuous men go, not evil-doers, there the divine Savitri may lead thee.' An act which has a healing tendency, although it may cause a transitory pain, men of insight declare to be preservative and beneficial.’’
And here's what Madhvacharya says in this excerpt from his Dvaita commentary on the Brahma Sutras:
‘’It may be said that sacrificial work involves injury to life, and as such it is productive of sin and consequently of misery, and that, therefore, it is not to be performed. But this objection is to be refuted on the ground that the injury to life involved in holy duties is permitted by the word (scripture); for the Varahapurana says, "To do harm to any life except as enjoined by scripture is really productive of sin and evil consequences; on the other hand, no evil consequences possibly arise from the act of killing permitted by the Vedas."
Pashubali seems like a contested topic. Vaishnavas seem to acknowledge it’s existence but only approve of it under very exceptional circumstances. Whereas shaktas consider it to be a central part of their tradition . I’m curious to know what the shaiva and smartha point of view on this is. I know Karpatri ji didn’t favour banning it but never participated in the practice himself.
What is Upword’s opinion on replacing goats with pumpkins as is being done in Bengal nowadays under the influence of a Gaudiya Vaishnavism and the Ramakrishna mission ?
Swami Vivekananda Wanted to do anushthanas that were going include bali . But he was opposed by Maa sarada . But it is known that Ramakrishna used to participate in Balis himself.
Noone could have explained it better. A very needed Adhyaya to be learnt in the present time.
I always knew Bengalis will be forefront of bali tradition.
I used to debate with my north Indian friends. Rajarshi is exacting saying what I used to say.
Good dada
Entire video was great, but the closing lines hits the bulls eye 🐂. Great work upword.
Bali is integral part and parcel of Hinduism. Kamakhya temple in Guwahati, bali is done. One must become part of it. The whole environ goes to another level.
folk hinduisim only
Meat/fish can be consumed only if it's offered to the deity 🙏 even our Ramakrishna used to consume only if the meat is slaughtered in front of the supreme power SHAKTI 🙏
Har Har Mahadev🕉️
I am a vegetarian and I agree that banning animal sacrifice in temples is absurd but I personally don't feel too good about it.
Feelings of mortals are irrelevant in the matters of Devatas and Devis.
Then start eating meat
@@rk-is3cw 😂😂
@@samarthlonar9874 Why laughing.?. Vegetarism is superstition
It is not about your and my preferences and 'feelings' but the deity.
अघ्न्या यजमानस्य पशून्पाहि
यजुर्वेद १।१
हे मनुष्यों ! पशु अघ्न्य हैं - कभी न मारने योग्य, पशुओं की रक्षा करो |
द्विपादव चतुष्पात् पाहि
यजुर्वेद १४।८
हे मनुष्य ! दो पैर वाले की रक्षा कर और चार पैर वाले की भी रक्षा कर |
th-cam.com/video/RB56Yo8H1P4/w-d-xo.html
Thank you very much, you made the subject very clear, this kind of information can save people from prejudice.
Many of my non-bengali friends from bihar, up, delhi, punjab & gujrat always asks me why we বাঙালিরা eat non-veg during durga pujo while they fast & eat veg !!?
Why is Our Durga Pujo different from their Navratri?!! I am never able to give a satisfying answer. 😢
This had always been their biggest question!! 😂
Absolutely! I am a vegetarian and a staunch believer that the marginalisation / modification of the ritual of bali is what lead to the downfall of Indian society- first to the mogals and then to the english and portugese. Devatas span the entire gamut from the saumya to the raudra. It is foolishly self deluding to expect the raudra devatas to accept what is normal for a saumya devata. Even in the army today soldiers are trained to live on a diet of foraged reptiles and animals which includes lizards and other creepy crawlies. Here, the objective is more important than the individual's sensibilities. It is more important for a soldier to survive in barren terrain and achieve military objectives which encompass individual and collective dharma. So also every devata has a list of parivara devatas who manage the "thin edge of the wedge" so to speak.....and propitiation cannot be done here with substitutes like some mishra and dakshinacaris recommend. Proper worship involves following shastra to the letter. Wherever there is a SJW attitude on matters of ritual, the "phala" / fruit will also go pear shaped.
Srsly ? Pulling self made theories over actual facts ? U all are worshipping urselves not the gods..
Listening to conscious makes my upasana complete, nothing else ! Anyways, good content .
Your conscience is under a lot of propaganda lady.
@@apotk95 as if u personally know me well enough to make such judgements .
@@vishakhasharma2209 your comment here on this issue is quite reflective of that.
Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam (11.5.41):
devarṣi-bhūtāpta-nṛṇāṁ pitṟṇāṁ
na kiṅkaro nāyam ṛṇī ca rājan
sarvātmanā yaḥ śaraṇaṁ śaraṇyaṁ
gato mukundaṁ parihṛtya kartam
Everyone is indebted to the demigods, to living entities in general, to his family, to the pitās and so on, but if one fully surrenders to Kṛṣṇa, Mukunda, who can give one liberation, even if one performs no yajñas, one is freed from all debts.
LOL ISKCON
@@tusharrao6265लौडा
Tu gita galat manata hai😂
@@tusharrao6265aur shastro me नरबलि भी hai
Teri gand me दम hai to Dee न वो भी
great detailing video ... but it will be good if @upword provide these videos in Hindi language also..
Sir can please name all the source where it is written on what is the process and the reason to give bali
ऊर्जं नो धेहि द्विपदे चतुष्पदे
यजुर्वेद ११।८३
सभी दो पाए और चौपाए प्राणियों को बल और पोषण प्राप्त हो | हिन्दुओं द्वारा भोजन ग्रहण करने से पूर्व बोले जाने वाले इस मंत्र में प्रत्येक जीव के लिए पोषण उपलब्ध होने की कामना की गई है | जो दर्शन प्रत्येक प्राणी के लिए जीवन के हर क्षण में कल्याण ही चाहता हो, वह पशुओं के वध को मान्यता कैसे देगा ?
I know its cruel ....but thinking of people who can have meat fish eggs milk etc in...and exploiting animals in regular basis but can't accept bali
Hey plz improve your sound quality!!!
Yes thier audio sucks
Respected Rajarshi
We has ordinary people want to know how to seek blessings from normal pooja for our endless demands from god?
From Ganesha, Mahalaxmi or other gods which mantras should we chant?
Just Namavali (Chanting the name of God is enough). Most scholars and pandits emphasize the importance of Rama Naama since that involves both Bhagwan Narayana and Bhagwan Shiva 🔱Chanting the name of the deities is greatest in Kali Yuga. However as someone who chants mantras and stotras every day I can recommend some. Start with chanting *Sri Aditya Hrudaya Stotram* - learn it by heart and chant it every day morning especially on Sundays by rising up prior to sunrise, taking bath, performing puja and in process chant this. Will give you resplendency and radiance throughout the day as you will be brimming with energy throughout the day. Chant *Hanuman Chalisa everyday morning and evening* - will give you strength and bountifulness. If possible throughout the day in your mind keep chanting (Raama Raama Raama Raama ......) - Once you do this verbally in isolation, slowly your brain will get adapted to the sound and rechant it itself several times without your knowledge subconsciously. Nothing else is actually required for Kali Yuga as this Yuga is based on Karma Yoga. Whatever good Karma you do and offer it to God that itself is a Yagya offering to the Lord. The best thing to have in mind is - *We are only there for some time on Earth and shall make this Life useful by dedicating it and all activities and thoughts to the Shree Charan of (your Ishta Devata whomsoever it is Durga, Ganesha, Shiva/Mahadeva, Kali, Hanuman ji, Sri Mahavishnu/Narayana etc.).* Just do this and you shall see the benefits. Also learnt that in morning you can chant *Aum Namo Bhagvathe Vasudevay* which is the moola mantra for Sri Mahavishnu and in the evening *Aum Namah Shivay* - however I gave you just Sri Rama Mantra (also called Rama Taraka Mantra) because *One Naama chanting throughout the day is more effective than chanting many.* 🙏🕉 Can give you many more Mantras which you yourself can go to any Giri Book Store an purchase and learn but some require initiation by Guru so I cannot tell you here. *If nothing is possible just this : "Hare Rama Hare Rama, Rama Rama Hare Hare, Hare Krishna Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna Hare Hare"* this you chant ! Anywhere anytime - this is a Maha mantra for Kali Yuga 🙏🕉🔱
I am chanting
Om nama shivay 3 malas
Gurudev data 3 malas
Om namo Narayana 3 malas
Shrim 1 mala
Hanuman Chalisa 2 times
on daily basis
To get quick results Rama is enough?
Seek a Shrotriya Brahmanisth guru any Shankaracharya or any Dandi Swami and he'll guide you.........such questions aren't meant to be put on TH-cam, it should be discussed with Guru in secrecy.....😅
Taantrik khud bali ke piche lga hua hai tera kya kalyan karega ...
I am agnostic about Bali, due to I am vegetarian and influence of Vaishnavism. But I appose modernist ban on pashubali.
ya vashnav don't do it as a vashnav i can confirm and you have to be theist jn order to be a hindu
क्रव्य दा - क्रव्य (वध से प्राप्त मांस ) + अदा (खानेवाला) = मांस भक्षक |
पिशाच - पिशित (मांस) +अस (खानेवाला) = मांस खाने वाला |
असुत्रपा - असू (प्राण )+त्रपा(पर तृप्त होने वाला) = अपने भोजन के लिए दूसरों के प्राण हरने वाला | |
गर्भ दा और अंड़ दा = भूर्ण और अंड़े खाने वाले |
मांस दा = मांस खाने वाले |
वैदिक साहित्य में मांस भक्षकों को अत्यंत तिरस्कृत किया गया है | उन्हें राक्षस, पिशाच आदि की संज्ञा दी गई है जो दरिन्दे और हैवान माने गए हैं तथा जिन्हें सभ्य मानव समाज से बहिष्कृत समझा गया है |
ऊर्जं नो धेहि द्विपदे चतुष्पदे
यजुर्वेद ११।८३
सभी दो पाए और चौपाए प्राणियों को बल और पोषण प्राप्त हो | हिन्दुओं द्वारा भोजन ग्रहण करने से पूर्व बोले जाने वाले इस मंत्र में प्रत्येक जीव के लिए पोषण उपलब्ध होने की कामना की गई है | जो दर्शन प्रत्येक प्राणी के लिए जीवन के हर क्षण में कल्याण ही चाहता हो, वह पशुओं के वध को मान्यता कैसे देगा ?
I find it absurd that killing an innocent animal will keep aggression alive. Want to fight? Then fight like men. Not by slaughtering an innocent animal. Show this bravado to a gang or a mafia. Courage comes from confronting difficult situations, not just unquestionable obedient slaughter of innocent beings. Get up in the morning and do training of martial arts. Do mock killings of a target but not killing living animals.
Your arguments are very much right. But remember, every practice or rite is prescribed in the shastras for a particular period of time and a particular type of people. Not everyone can carry out the instructions of shastras perfectly.
This practice was limited to the mid- Dwapara Yuga only. After that, in the later years of Dwapara and in this age of Kali, such Brahmanas barely exist or perhaps they don't exist. Such exalted and qualified priests who possess the calibre to promise an elevated life for the sacrificed creature are literally nowhere. Nevertheless many are well versed in the Shastras and know their essence , it is a strenuous task to find such perfect Brahmins.
Hence the best way to worship the lord for the humans of this degraded age of kaliyuga is Bhakti Yoga - Surrender unto the lotus feet of the lord and developing devotion. That alone is the best and most fruitful 'sacrifice' for us!
Be blessed!!
Some ppl saying tantra is the only way in kali yuga
@@xripz6899 No brother
These things don't contribute to spiritual elevation in any way. These are meant only for the fulfilment of the desires of humans .
Real path for liberation in the Kaliyuga is only DEVOTION towards lord in the form of your Ishta. Think of the lord always, everytime, that's the best option ;)
Shastras don't touch on animal sacrifice..... God am tired telling this to our own countrymen. Almost 99% in the comments section are perhaps either Abrahamics or hard core non - vegetarians.
Average vaishnavite thinking hinduism revolves around vaishnavism
Can we start restaurant which serve pashubali meat offered to devtas and u have respect and pray to the agni and devta to eat at restaurant ? We can put images of explaining what it is at restaurant walls like painting. How does that sound ?
Yes , In Tamasic restaurants..
The jhatka methods of adoption should be followed...
Where a prathishtith Murthy of Devi Bhagavathi should be there...
If there is a sacrifice of the poultry animal...
That too under a Shaktha Practisionier...
Bhagavathi Saranam 🕉️
Namaśthe 🕉️🌺
You can start selling human meat no problems.....
@@TheB657 Na it will affect 👍🏻
As a Devi upasakar & an animal lover, I feel torn about this.. I understand that this is part of our ancient culture, but I will never participate in such a ritual, I can't bear to see the suffering of an innocent animal.. There are better ways, mantras, kriyas, to connect with Shakti..
Right
Exactly!!! I stopped going to my village for this reason.
Dakshinachara is for u
Dimasa and Karbi jatis of Assam perform bali with age-old standard operating systems. They are Hindu. Rest all the jatis that came under exclusive region got converted to Xtianity. Thanks to Nehru et al.
Beautifully explained 🙏🏻
I thought food we eat should first be offered as Prasad. In any case animals are butchered in the market. Better sacrifice it and then eat. If you can't stop butchery why stop occasional sacrifices.
Tell this to the Arya samaj, you'll see how much Passive agressive they can get.
Arya samaj is a modern dumbed down cult mostly filled with specific groups ....have no intellectual heft. Appropriating holy books of people they don't really like...
Rajarshi, I have a question regarding the method of Balividhan done in the Tulja Bhavani temple. I was under the impression the slaughter must be done in one swift stroke/strike. The manner in which they do the bali is by striking the belly of the goat numerous times. Your view on this?
Ay ! I have her as my kuldevi and the baki partha in such temples (shaktipeeths) has been done since time immemorial so the practices that are done now are likely done since long ago. Bali has A LOT OF variations. Every diety has different techniques infact Bali is also given to lower gods and demigods in large scales.
This is actually fascinating or idk what word to use actually cause even I've heard it for the first time
Even in my family when we offer bali it has to be one in one stroke
Obv since our family sword is not very old so we do the things as quick as possible but it's rule to be done in one stroke so idk
Thank you for this insightful take. Till date I was reeling under this conflict of non vegetarianism and pashu Bali. I can’t stand any kind of animal killing for any purpose but was unsure of our religion’s point of view. I stay in a state where as per data 100% people are non veg. Which means people like me are not even part of 1%.
Point is humans didnt reach that level where they really care for world/ nature thats why if sanatan dharm didnt give space for non veg then 70 percent of hindus would have accepted abhrahmic religion
@@prabhatsingh5234 Even entertainment is Haram. How many Muslims do you see leaving Islam coz of this reason?
@@mylord8105 they will not leave because in their religion it wil result in hell, whereas hinduism doesnt have such harsh punishment related to religious practice, hindus have freedom which they dont care, just how today for fullfilment of wish i.e greed hindus go to churches, mosque because most of people in world follow religion just for greed and fullfilling their wish
@@prabhatsingh5234 is video ka point kya Banta he meat khana he ya nahi ?
@@COCSensai video ka point hai hamesa kuch achhi cheeje hongi par ohir bhi kuch log hamesha honge jo khud ke rule pe chalenge, meat avoid kar sako to achha hai kyonki human body meat ke liye nahi bani hai acc to science par kiso pe force nahi karna chahiye veg ko
Show where this ( bali ) written in veda
Do some hardwork.
Well the "vast majority of hindus are non veg" part is misleading. While it is true, shouldnt you be worried about how this change took place? There was a time when over 60% of the country was veg. After centuries of ABrahamic subjugation, hindus came to consume such a high amount of meat
🙏 bas kar bhai . Kahi aur jake hag . Please. Yeh same dna rss arya samaji logic kahi aur jake pel bhai . Please 🙏
Vegetarism is superstition
These people are idiots targetting hindus
60% of the country was Vegetarian is a propoganda.
@@allinoneodia243 they don't even know the total population but calculate percentage lol
Why mother Parvati became so furious when her son Ganesha was beheaded by Lord Shiva ???
Very Nicely Explained. Thank you. 🚩🕯🙏.
Thank you so much Rajshri Shaib..we Shakti Ishta Devi Bhakts really need some gurus and guidance..
Hindus from Bengal, Assam, Mithila, Nepal, Uttarakhand do Bali and eat Bali meat. That's tradition.
"Opposes Pashu bali and later heads to KFC" plight of the so called woke folk
What happens agter6 the bail is the "Pashu" is cooked and guven as prasad??
Based plus approve 👍
Sir, would please add research texts and other things
Hindu scriptures also says that Chāndāls (Dalit) shouldn't be allowed to enter Temples
this is because of vaishnav influence. in our village pasubali stopped because of some vaishnavite.
A Kumaoni here bali is still prevalent in ancestral worship ceremony that we do in my part of bharat , not just prevalent its mandotary for some specific deity.
We offer animals to the deitys even a baby chick is offered to a specific deity.
And yes it is considered as a prashad.
Kabhi apne bacche ko daan de. Aur humein devi ka prashaad dena tab.
Devi issey bhi zyada prasann hongi.
Aur haan itna hi dam ho naa, toh jo hindu maare ja rahe hain, jaa unko west bengal mein bacha le. Vahan dikhaa power. Nirdosh jeewon par nahi. Aur ye ghatiya kaam devi par mat udhaa.
Wine, fish, honey, meat, alcohol, and preparations of rice and sesame seeds, have been introduced by knaves. The use of these (in sacrifices) is not laid down in the Vedas. The hankering after these arises from pride, error of judgment, and cupidity.
Mahabharat, Shanti Parva, Chapter 265.
thankgod somebody said this. i was wondering if now people would call pashubali right. being an outright and absolute hindu, i cannot understand how one says that pashubali is right. yes, tantrika vidyas use them, but one must remember that tantrika vidya was a very secretive and hidden knowledge, used only during critical situations. if pashubali is right, then so should narabali be. is it? no. hence, calling the sacrifice of animals correct is actually going against the very core of hindutva
@@ankeetabose2059 tantra was created for those animalistic people who had absolutely no interest in spirituality. It makes zero sense to quote tantra books to justify pashubali. Upword is wrong here.
@@kanhaibhatt913 absolutely right. i have shared a link in the comment section here. that video will clear this misunderstanding about bali
@@kanhaibhatt913 Nope , it's not wrong..
Of great Gurudev like Sri Adi Shankaracharya ji accepted it
Who is Vedantian
Then it can't be discarded..
We support Pashubali for Devi Bhagavathi 🌸
Namaśthe
@@aadithyanc.koccupyandcolon6792 So his opinion is more important to you than Mahabharat ?
(putting it here for anyone who might e interested) Each deity can have their own specific reason to like a specific type of meat.
To understand what meat really is offered to the god you must observe what the animal consumes as food, and where that food in turn comes from.
We can most definitely know their body composition of being made up of many green plants which grow on the earth and are a critical part of the entire cycle of life and death. Ultimately if a goat is being sacrificed, it is the vegetarian food which has transformed into the energy and form of the goat which is being sacrificed.
Through scientific study it is common knowledge that plants also have emotions and life, in one perspective Bali looks at animal sacrifice as equalising that value of life in all beings including humans. Bali is a great method to wipe out ignorance that we are this body.
I agree with you that secularist who says Bali should be banned first stop eating meat and encourage its followers too but I don't agree with the continuation of Bali because Upanishads refuse the only mention of pashu Bali is ASHWA MEDHA YAGYA but the word Medha literally has several translations including kill and ending the consious so the have some dis agreement with you but i can understand your overall idea but still i would request my hindu brothers to slowly stop practising it in few temples
Yes u are correct
And Upanishads are but part of Vedas which contain hymns upon hymns in praise of Nature, Universe, the Divine, preceding Gods/deities etc. Nowhere about _Bali_ written anywhere. *Tyaaga or Yagya* yes is written but in respect to one's own wishes, feelings, negative thoughts & emotions etc. and also sacrifice of materialism. That is the very reason this is called Vedic Civilization. Mlecchha Dharma ascribes to Asuric practices, Vaidiga Dharma ascribes to Daiviga practices which involves Ahimsa and Karuna.
@Neil Bajwa Ever learnt the Vedas or the Upanishads or the Shastras ? Or does thou art know Sanskrutam ? Before spluttering out anything remember : *YOU are talking with a degree holder in Sanskrutam from a recognized University.*
@Neil Bajwa Narbali is also existed and was practiced in some part of India even up to 20th century .
Those practices are now stopped .
Just because something existed in past must remain in present .
@Neil Bajwa Read it : *Bali - Pujam Tatha Krutam..* - has different meanings with respect to the context. The word "Bali" in Sanskrutam refers to multitudes of things offered in Yagya or Puja which includes : Mano Bali (Sacrifice of wishes in the Mind) , Deha Bali (Sacrifice of one's body itself - metaphorically to the divine - dissolution), Phala Bali (Sacrifice of Fruits and Vegetables) etc. As per Vedic rituals bali is almost always in reference to "emotions, negativity, anger, lust etc." and the rest ascribe to offerings anointed ther term "Naivedya" like Coconut (Nalikera) , Ghee etc. *Would suggest you to kindly learn Sanskrit and our scriptures first. No one is forbidding you to do it.* Watching a TH-cam video and getting to conclusions is *completely unacademic and non sensical.*
How can you call it madness? Explain pls
I second Rajashri ji . I come from guwahati and Goddessses Kamakhya is our kshetra palini devi . She is one off tge three Adi Shakti peethas and as part of Kali Kula Shakta Sampradaya and Dasa Mahavidya pooja vidhi we have pancha bali vidhan , sacrificing 5 animals that include Buffalo, goat , ducks, pigions and cat fish . No mattet how far these physo frenzy libis cry to stop bali , bali will not stop there in for one single day .
💯❤️👍🏻
Whatever you can do it's your choice but be prepare for consequences
Pashubali saare Dunia me hoti thi, hinduon ne symbolic Bali start ki kunki unko animal ko kill karne ka dil nahi kiya lekin Christian and Muslim bahut achi tarzh se Christmas or Bakra rid ko bahut badi Bali karte hsi
Please don't defame Tantra 🙏🏼
No scripture allows Animal killing. Animal killing is as foolish as some self proclaimed Tantrik talking about it.
Bali should be given of our Shadripu, our bad habbits. Shadripu are Lobh, Kaam, Krodh, Moh, Maya & Matsarya. And Animal sacrifice actually means sacrificing the animal nature and not an external innocent being who has nothing to do with our internal mind.
Go read tantra shastras
Ghanta
This can be a written form of the language. One does not speak like this. Otherwise, the content is rich.
Im hindu, and Im against animal slaughter without exception, be it religious or for commerical consumptions. I believe in god, and the symbolism of sacrificing animals as expelling our own darkness is frankly , sad. Rather than doing deeds of goodwill, people seem to have no objection in killing a living being after performing hateful acts. Be it pashubali, bakrid, thanksgiving, etc, all of it is wrong.
There are A LOT of theories behind Bali pratha.. the thing u mentioned as to cleaning our sins and all maybe ONE reason of it.
There can be countless reasons one of them being that The GANA of the dieties eat the Bali or the bali is elevated to a next lifeform
WE DONT KNOW THE EXACT TRUTH. Exactly like everything!!
U may be a vaishnav but if the shaktivites know the culture of bali is extremely important.
In some areas not only gods but also demigods exist who make contracts with ancestors of current human beings to accept Bali every year. The demigods protect or do any task as per the contract.
Bali pratha is necessary, unstoppable, inevitable and will last till eternity as some people are also bound by contracts..
Does your TH-cam video has reach in EU and USA 🇺🇸 Canada 🇨🇦 country???
I think this is ban
You said that animal sacrifice was told in Vedas, so tell me in which Vedas animal sacrifice was told. Do you even know the meaning of Bali?
Don't defame Sanatan Dharma by making this kind of video.
What animals are being killed in the world, you are promoting animal sacrifice by making such videos.
Nothing like this is written in the Vedas, if it was written like this in the Vedas, then it would not have been written in the Manusmriti that killing/sacrificing an innocent creature/human is a sin.
You can write a bhashya to prove Adishankaracharya and Ramanujacharya wrong about Pashubali in Veda. We will look forward to reading it. Thank you.
Sure
They create explanations made of half baked understanding of the sacred scriptures. This is a propaganda video, Upword may have been taken over by anti Hindu elements.
@@Upword "Adi Shankara mentioned pashubali ..... ?!" I challenge you to come to Sringeri Mutt and in front of the respectful Acharyas for a straight debate. What stupidity you people are mentioning ?
@@TheB657 Hello
This is Shaktha Dharma..
Go to any Shaktha Tantric Temples..
You can see Pashubali for Devi Chandika
Our Sanatana Dharma is not just Vaishnavism...