Katyal: ‘Trump’s Argument Got Nowhere’ In Supreme Court Case To Repeal ACA | The Last Word | MSNBC
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 พ.ย. 2020
- Neal Katyal, the former Acting Solicitor General, joins Lawrence O’Donnell to discuss “Trump’s failure” in the Supreme Court when two conservative Justices, John Roberts and Brett Kavanaugh, signaled their openness to uphold the Affordable Care Act. Aired on 11/10/2020.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: on.msnbc.com/SubscribeTomsnbc
About The Last Word with Lawrence O'Donnell:
Drawing upon his experience as a former chief of staff on the Senate Finance Committee and as an Emmy-winning executive producer and writer of "The West Wing," Lawrence O'Donnell examines the compelling and impactful political stories of the day. O'Donnell convenes diverse panels of guests, including a variety of politicians and cultural voices, to offer unique viewpoints and perspective. In his signature style, O'Donnell highlights the latest news developments and offers his take on the political stories driving the national conversation.
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, Meet the Press Daily, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House with Nicolle Wallace, Hardball, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and more.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: on.msnbc.com/Readmsnbc
Subscribe to MSNBC Newsletter: MSNBC.com/NewslettersTH-cam
Find MSNBC on Facebook: on.msnbc.com/Likemsnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: on.msnbc.com/Followmsnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: on.msnbc.com/Instamsnbc
#DonaldTrump #NealKatyal #MSNBC
Katyal: ‘Trump’s Argument Got Nowhere’ In Supreme Court Case To Repeal ACA | The Last Word | MSNBC
![Verdict post-mortem: '[The defense] allowed Trump to call the shots and that really hurt their case'](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ol3Nr7-Nqyo/mqdefault.jpg)
Lock him UP before he done more damage.
Roberts is literally sick of this nonsense from Trump.
who isn't?
Very True!
@@willtellall638 Shut up man.
@@willtellall638 《《《 *ignore the disinformation troll* 》》》
Dave has shamed every Dave out there. So sad
Just waste of taxpayer’s money and legal resources for one person’s narcissistic interest..
Interesting you brought up 'where the $ is coming from', Randy.........
Every attempt to knock down the ACA has come from the insurance lobbyists, who have not been happy since the ACA was first passed that the govt subsidy they used to get has now been passed on to individuals. That cut the premium for a decent policy in half....gee, what a tragedy for corporate insurance companies!
@@andyrosen381 : *The money is coming out of your pocket to pay for trumps debt.* He had already raised over 10 million dollars yesterday by begging from his voters like the broke hobo he is. By tomorrow I'm guessing he; will have doubled that easy.
The real losers here are the struggling rural Americans who actually need that money.
A Narcissist in office...very very very dangerouse
I'm so broke
@@marylousherman5471 😂were ok with it
I love watching Neal. He tells it like it is 😂 thanks for telling the people the truth.
the fact that this is being discussed during a pandemic that's worsening is too frightening
Fear is a means of control.
@Jay Ess It isn't that he is deranged. He enjoys causing harm to people and seeing them suffer, both physically and mentally. It's part of his being a narcissist.
Smh🤬
That's because there is 'obama' in it .. that orange clown is so obsessed with Obama
i know right....sheesh...the spotlight needs to be trump dont you know...sickening
I wish you the best my Americans friends.
Thank you Canada 🇨🇦!! We need it! Hi from Milwaukee Wisconsin 🇺🇸🧀
@@Mark.G475 thanks for your answer. I wish you the best from Europe. Always the best. Always loved your country. And Canada also. But I am speaking from Europe.
Lord knows we will need it
@Epic Story I hope not. I hope that your great democracy lives forever. It is up to you all.
Thank you for not giving up on us, goodness knows it's been hard not to. Now our real work begins, making America respectable again. 😑
Trump 2020 - The Story of a Loser
Trump birth to present - the story of a loser. he didnt just start being a loser been doing it all his life, thats why he is so good at it. Good title for a book.
Roberts is sick of putting up with Trump's BS. He's not going to overturn the ACA because he knows the public backlash would be too much for him to handle.
Bingo !!!
Right on ..... Cannot wait for Chump to be OUT in Jan/21 and sounds like the Supreme Court feels the same way.
Time for Trump to practice his perp walk in front of the media
Bet they have to carry him out in a straight jacket💥🍊🤡=💩🧠
@ : I'd settle for handcuffs.
Part of Trump's legacy will be that his administration can only try and tear things down and never offers improvements or better alternatives.
All the more reason why Trump and his Administration need to Go!!! If he has to be removed Kicking and Screaming in January, then so be it. His Pettiness and Vindictiveness will only get worst as the time gets closer for his removal.
Well their goes our Jobs again
China Wins WTO Wins UN Iran More Cash
No MORE travel Bans so Many Terrorist are on There Way
OPEN Borders More Illegals UNKNOWN DISEASES
Thanks DNC Media Democrats Pedophile Joe Tax tax tax
I am really going to Miss Trump USA America is GONE
Just Wonder how I will Pay the Mortgage and feed the Kids ?
DARK WINTER and War is Coming Thanks Democrats
@@dougeisenberg7148 so,..irans money was irans money, we kept it after we did not turn over airplanes they bought...after losing in court USA had to give back money...terrorist ..they live here, you call them white nationalist...or militia groups...borders are irrelivent air travel is how people get here...still coming...every day...
@@dougeisenberg7148 No Problem with the Home Grown Terrorist that are here, you know---the ones that are American born ? The names of the Groups are different but they pretty much do the same, attack other US citizens, burn down places of worship, plan kidnappings, etc....no problem with them? As far as China goes it's not a Free For All For them so why don't you just settle down and come out of panic mode. As far as the Travel Ban (s), they will be Approached with restrictions, that was already stated. Come out of Trump mode, do some Legitimate Research regarding Biden's Plans before clutching your Pearls. I'm not trying to be malicious or Ugly but you guys take the Lies that Trump Spews and run with it and it needs to stop.
From a Conservative who has and will continue to do "My" research regarding other Conservatives, Liberals, Independents, Moderates, and so on before jumping the or Embracing False Information.
@@dougeisenberg7148 Also Thank the Democrats, Conservatives, Independents and the rest for Finally Getting this Criminal, Lying, Racist, Wanna be Dictator /Authoritarian, Narcissistic Walking Disaster out of Office so we can move Forward and Start Healing as a Nation.
@@dougeisenberg7148 if you were paying your mortgage and feeding your kids during Trump, I'm sure you'll be able to do the same unlike many others who haven't been able to.
It all boils down to whenever donny loses, America wins.
@MY LOVE Please read the comment again as you just agreed with me.
@MY LOVE As in every time.
You bring your best argument to the Supreme Court. That was the best argument they could make?
Love Neal!!!!
Why is Donald Trump so pre occupied with going to court to fight a case when he’s losing so many of them? For a guy who doesn’t like losing, he sure is losing quite a lot.. including the election.
Imagine the Justices laughing uncontrollably behind closed doors... "And when he answered a non-zero number..."
I saw that and laughed my butt off, what is he in his attempts to subvert the will of the American people - wins 0 lose 16 last time I looked
It is the American democracy on trial here.
Well after today by the very definition of treason Mike Pompeo and others all committed treason on live TV. They need to be arrested, tried, and if found guilty executed.
@Epic Story they cant let him go he mows to much along with his Family Treason it is or jail cells for life their only real choice they cant be trusted
NOPE...YOUR Lack of KNOWLEDGE..is truly SHOCKING....
Thank the Lord for people like Katyal!
This is Delaying Tactics of TRUMP..
Is harris good on her knees??
@@randycouch2769 not as good as your mother
To maintain court credibility even Trump sycophants will not side with him.
I know, because they know that if they strike down the affordable care act, they are literally killing themselves and their families
@@ileancoleman4072 And killing their party.
@@MG-ot2yr Here is what is going to happen in a nutshell you foolish dems: This is going to the Supreme Court. Where they will rule that the election is invalid due to fraud or mistakes on a country wide scale. It will go one of two ways; either they will rule that all the unconstitutional mail in ballots will be removed and the states ordered to recount without them or they will simply rule the election is invalid due to mass voter fraud and at that point it will be sent to congress and senate for a vote. This is where it gets good. The house/congress votes on who the president will be. It has nothing to do with what party has power. Every state gets one vote and 30 States are held by Republicans and 19 by Democrats. They have to vote down party lines, they have no choice due to the 12th Amendment of the Constitution and the Senate votes for the Vice President where a similar event will take place. This is the law. This is why the Democrats are so mad at Nancy Pelosi. This will all happen in January. The only way President Trump won’t be president is if he concedes the election and that will never happen. So stop watching the fake news and don’t let your heart be troubled and live your life knowing this will all work out. President Trump will remain President. I have researched all of this and it is factual!
Another fun fact, they called Gore the President Elect for 30 days in 2000 until the courts ruled against him and declared Bush the winner. And two people that were part of that decision was none other than new Supreme Court Justices, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett. Why do you think the Democrats tried so hard to keep them from being confirmed?
And the sound of victory when Trump is re-elected th-cam.com/video/GGU1P6lBW6Q/w-d-xo.html
P.S. and no I am not sorry for breaking the hearts of you commie dems
@@MG-ot2yr 🤞
@@andyrosen381, Smoke another one, pal.
Bye Trump
Why do Republicans want to get rid of Obamacare? Is it the cost? Or is it the Obama name?
It's all about private premium prices which benefits filthy rich that's it.
They seek health care as just another product on the market and subject to the forces of the market, rather than being a fundamental right.
Also, socialism.
I think trump has a vendetta against Obama. trump is threatened by him. trump has actually tried to take credit for something Obama accomplished.
trump is ill..a narsistic sadist.
(I purposely did not capitalize trumps name..he is unworthy)
ANYTHING OBAMA DID HE HAS TRIED AN TURNED OVER.,...............
Its because they are the most evil people on the face of this earth!
He know he's going to the big house
Orange Raccoon is throwing all his diapers to the wall hoping some of it stick.
😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄
Neil knows his stuff. What a super smart man with a super sharp mind. Keep him on the air he knows what he’s talking about
🇨🇦
they never say WHY anyone wants to repeal the A C A ? does anyone know?
their corprate donors "insurance companies"and"big pharma"..don't like it...the majority of americans 72% want single payer health system...
Your fired!
Georgia January 5th!
Send him straight to Jail!
Thank you Jesus 😊 we need Obama care !! He's trying to hurt as many people as possible before heading out it's so sad that we all have to pay for his loss😔
Well their goes our Jobs again
China Wins WTO Wins UN Iran More Cash
No MORE travel Bans so Many Terrorist are on There Way
OPEN Borders More Illegals UNKNOWN DISEASES
Thanks DNC Media Democrats Pedophile Joe Tax tax tax
I am really going to Miss Trump USA America is GONE
Just Wonder how I will Pay the Mortgage and feed the Kids ?
DARK WINTER and War is Coming Thanks Democrats
Trump failed? I'm shocked. Shocked, I say!
@@willtellall638 please just stop 🤦 BIDEN WON fair and square move on !!! We all had to deal with it when trump won it's your turn now sorry
You don't say?
@@PP-mz4hv I do say! My jaw has hit the floor
LOLOL!!!!!
Well their goes our Jobs again
China Wins WTO Wins UN Iran More Cash
No MORE travel Bans so Many Terrorist are on There Way
OPEN Borders More Illegals UNKNOWN DISEASES
Thanks DNC Media Democrats Pedophile Joe Tax tax tax
I am really going to Miss Trump USA America is GONE
Just Wonder how I will Pay the Mortgage and feed the Kids ?
DARK WINTER and War is Coming Thanks Democrats
JUST GO AWAY.....
LOL!
WHAAAAAT? Even TRUMPS Pride & Joy Supreme Court pick KAVANAGH didn't pass this one either!!
The liberal judges on SCOTUS promised him a beer if he voted no.
@@thomasjohansson5045 They offered a keg.
Comon.. the man really likes beer.
@@thomasjohansson5045 3 beer
Well their goes our Jobs again
China Wins WTO Wins UN Iran More Cash
No MORE travel Bans so Many Terrorist are on There Way
OPEN Borders More Illegals UNKNOWN DISEASES
Thanks DNC Media Democrats Pedophile Joe Tax tax tax
I am really going to Miss Trump USA America is GONE
Just Wonder how I will Pay the Mortgage and feed the Kids ?
DARK WINTER and War is Coming Thanks Democrats
Hey lawrence always enjoy listening to the wonderful Neal, very entertaining and we don't hear enough from him paula in uk
Is this trumps version of payback for all the “bother” he thinks democrats gave him during his one and only term as president...
What is happening? Is this still The USA? What President does this?
So if its gained no traction..then why are we going to hear about it on the news for another week...
It's so hard to build a house, but so terribly easy to burn it down.
...Hear, Hear! : - )
Trump: Do so because I'm the Richest President.
SCOTUS: Sorry, but you can't fail our democracy like you did to your private businesses.
Well their goes our Jobs again
China Wins WTO Wins UN Iran More Cash
No MORE travel Bans so Many Terrorist are on There Way
OPEN Borders More Illegals UNKNOWN DISEASES
Thanks DNC Media Democrats Pedophile Joe Tax tax tax
I am really going to Miss Trump USA America is GONE
Just Wonder how I will Pay the Mortgage and feed the Kids ?
DARK WINTER and War is Coming Thanks Democrats
@@dougeisenberg7148 shame on you. Bush is a Republican. When did The Sep 11 occur?
A scary thought to me is when Trump leaves office, he knows all the secrets and could sell those to America's enemies if he wanted.
IT will be kinda difficult to do that FROM a JAIL-cell ..."know-it-all". YOUR lack of intelligence IS scarier.
You are Fired. Bye Bye DT Enough is Enough.👎🏿👎🏿👎🏿👎🏿👎🏿👎🏿
Waiting to see. When listening, some stuff goes over my head.
This is very good news for the people of the USA!
Neal did a great job! Super.
So much winning!!!!!!!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
It's just infuriating how tRump has wasted so many resources throughout our government. Wasting the Supreme Court's valuable time while so many other issues are paramount.
FAIL!
Thank God! Americans win.
Let them recount ... there's nothing to be afraid
Katyal is the Best, he should be a Supreme Court nominee. I would trust him.
I've got a crush on Neal Katyal. A sane voice ringing loud and clear.
How about that.. some great news for a change!
e th-cam.com/video/hN8q7sGCivY/w-d-xo.html
@@anthonydao5211 Blah blah blah, just another angry white millionaire in a position of power pointing his hypocritical finger at everyone else. The system is clearly broken, isn't it obvious? But the ones who allowed it to crumble into lawlessness are not the ones to fix it. Donald did was God needed him to do-- to show us how dangerous the republican party and their support system /cronies are. He also showed us that "Caligula" could potentially be reelected by 70 million adoring Americans cultists. A new era is beginning if the maga folks don't destroy us. Biden/Harris have been chosen and they will take on the heavy responsibility of doing the hard work of what needs to be done. Blessings.
Should Stop all wrong things
Why is he fighting in court in failing at the same time , when his time as president is up in 40 days .
Good call by SC 👍
Just an insult to "regular" people
Because the penalty for not taking health insurance was dropped to $0 it's more like "Affordable Care Act to Those who Want It". Why should it be repealed?
The judges nailed it I was so into their arguments
💙💙🙏💙love your show
Criminal.
They don't have a replacement?????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Where's the Affordable Care Act replacement????!!!!!
Neil is likely going to be the next Attorney general. very intelligent and smart guy. He is no 1 on the list for sure
sO mUcH WiNniNg!
I wish our country could just unitify. At this point, its the only thing that's going to save us. Please people, we must love and unite or we'll destroy ourselves.
but, half of the people, claim to follow that fairytale book, that specifically says to "love thy neighbor." where are those people now? or do they really not believe what that book says...hypocrites...all of them...
@@kenadams4877 Also in that book, Jesus says "Do not resist evil." I don't know any Christian who follows that commandment.
You are being too kind about the lawyers arguing for the Republican side, since they made the ineffective arguments presented. If they are good lawyers, they should have made a better argument. They could not but wasted the SCOTUSs time anyway.
you don't need propellers on a jet.
Hamilton poster 👍👍
Yay
Do no harm.
I thought I was done caring about politics.
they are supreme court judges. They know that people need health care and they know it is do able and can be repaired with a different way of supplementing it.
TRUMP ON COVID: I don’t know maybe I’m immune
TRUMP ON DEMOCRACY: I don’t know maybe I’m immune
ME ON TRUMPS LIES: I don’t know maybe I’m immune .... nothing he says surprises me he’s got to go...... goodbye 👋
Great airplane analogy!!! Bravo Justice Samuel Alito!!
Kenneth Copeland laugh: HAAHAAHAA HAAHAAHAA!
I am annoyed that Neal's name has not come up for Biden's AG. He is a smart and good guy.
Good. This is why he has gots to go...
Thank you God
Turns out Character & the Truth Matters!
Some basic essential factors that make us human, & something Spanky, MIni Mitts, Bone Spurs never possessed
Well their goes our Jobs again
China Wins WTO Wins UN Iran More Cash
No MORE travel Bans so Many Terrorist are on There Way
OPEN Borders More Illegals UNKNOWN DISEASES
Thanks DNC Media Democrats Pedophile Joe Tax tax tax
I am really going to Miss Trump USA America is GONE
Just Wonder how I will Pay the Mortgage and feed the Kids ?
DARK WINTER and War is Coming Thanks Democrats
@@dougeisenberg7148 ANYTHING is better than the INSANITY, CHAOS, CORRUPTION, MADNESS, & LIES of the last four years!!! Turns out Character & the Truth DO MATTER!!
I've worked in the fed govt. If a legislative act needs a change or updating, or something just is not working well, the act is simply "amended". Not a problem.
I was a bit shocked that the conservative Justices are being sane.
Feels so Empire Strikes Back
Trump’s argument, “I don’t like that I am losing, you must do something.”
Judge, “uh, no.”
The Executive Branch is attempting to overrule the Legislative, via the Judicial.
It's the true Devil's Triangle.
Millions of American families depend on the ACA for health care. If this law gets overturned, which it won't, millions of families will lose their health care and that would be a tragedy.
I am wondering if Vegas has a line on whether or not Trump will leave the WH on Jan 20, 2021 at noon in a helicopter or a paddy wagon.
Wow Trumpeters....are you sick of winning yet?
Amy Amy Amy come and rescue meeeee now . Supreme Court. hahahaha.
How can it not be the fault of the advocates but be the fault of the position they developed? I'm not following that line of reasoning. If the advocates developed the position, are they not to blame for it's failure?
just another tick in the Trump's long list of "nothing done"
Joe should give Katyal a White House position. These political judges should be discussed everyday.
He’s failed again.
STOP the 🎪🤡🐘🎪🤡🐘
It's nice they keep the penalty out
I owe my life to the ACA....I had a life threatening hernia in 2014. Without surgery, I may have died. People need healthcare!
Easy way to sort this mess out would be to put it to a vote.
I can't play the video!
They sure like those airplane analogies, don't they?
Trump - "Come on... I've been saying repeal and replace, and I haven't been able to come up with a replace!!! Give me a win... please!!!!
Court - "No"
Trump- "Waaaaahhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"
BABY TRUMP.......HUHUHUHU...
Joe Biden should appoint Neal as attorney general he has the guts to do the right thing and he isn't scared of Trump
Well done, Supreme Court, you are the only body that keep sanity and common sense live.