Question Time: Malema's Indian comments, 02 August 2017
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ส.ค. 2017
- The comments made by Economic Freedom Fighters leader Julius Malema when celebrating the party's fourth Anniversary in Durban have caused a stir. Malema waged a scathing attack on the Indian community for their treatment of black workers. EFF says it is fully behind its Commander-In-Chief's comments, and would
never apologise for condemning oppression. The remarks have attracted a lot of interest, given sporadic incidents of racial tensions and attacks in some parts of the country. Malema made some controversial comments about the Indian community in 2011, but later apologised. He was the leader of the ANC Youth League at the time. Meanwhile, the South African Minority Rights Equality Movement has laid criminal charges against the EFF leader.
For more news, visit: www.sabc.co.za/news
I've been with Indians almost all my life went to Indians lived around them and what Malema said is nothing but the truth...
He doesn't know the Chinese well enough. You don't get any race that wouldn't care about it's own race first and foremost.
Nothing new, they have a different culture and like to socialize with their own.
So what?, they're a different culture.
Ya u probably jealous of 🇮🇳 like everyone
@@melanitex1089 because china's news is censored by CCP
Again Malema is Right, some Indians believe their more human than blacks... right from the time of Mahatma Gandhi. Gandhi believed that. And some of us who worked with them in corporate business, we know what we are writing about. Put one Indian as a head of a division, come after 3 months it will be Indians all over
Malema is correct
I will rather tolerate a white oppression than an indian oppression,their skin is next to me,they should automatically respect blacks.but anyway Mahat Magandhii sold black people to whites.
does Internet Solutions rings a bell...
it's not just Indians who believe they are better than blacks. some blacks or some African tribes also believe they are better than other blacks. as for employing your kind, all groups of people do for whatever reasons.
True about Mahatma Gandhi
Simple fact is africa is for africa. Africans meaning u have to be black, in every continent the natives are the ones on top well except for America. Go to Europe who's on top, go Asia who's on top? So y should foreigners be on top in Africa n ill treating them? If they are not careful n keep up this attitude they il find themselves in a similar situation that Idi Amin carried out, I'm just saying.
South Africa's a volatile volcano waiting to erupt ferociously because the underlying issues weren't addressed when they gained independence n the natives are becoming increasingly agitated by the inequalities they have to endure everyday.
+joe black Bingo and it ain't gunna be pretty.....
The Hindus are mostly black as well, so they can stay?.
Oh so north africa is not part of africa? Since they are white?
I am Indian and Malema and the EFF is completely correct 🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦. Viva EFF, Viva Dali Mpho
Raheem Razak 😂😂😂😂😂
Daniel not stupid but realistic one.. the sooner the issue is dealt with the sooner it could be resolved. Remember EFF mainly represents the poorest who have no voice nor platform to voice the way their treated. E.g. I know of one ☝️Indian family who have their nanny to sleep in a garage where they also park their cars.
raheem razak : You're an Indian running scared. Fact remains that one or a thousand Indians won't really change Malema's mindset.
You're a scared Indian. No?.
Raheem Razak thanks for telling the truth. No one hates Indians just the abusive ones ❤️ of any race
i don't understand why when Malema speaks the truth about Indians it is suddenly an issue.
It's not the truth, it's racism.
It is funny that when a Black African says something racist, it's fine.
He attacks Indians coz they're are the brains behind everything, and Indian ppl don't support him or his party, there's ethnic problems amongst the blacks why dsnt he shout Racism to
@@mrc9040 Calling out racism is not racist - I don't know where you get that absurd idea from. If you are Indian, you must know that the majority of your people are racists. Anti-African racists to be more specific. Deny it all you want, you know it's true. Indians look down on Africans, see them as second class citizens. Fix that issue within your own community and quit being a denialist. You're actually the racist for denying that racism exists.
Indians own this kuntry. They run everything behind the scenes. They will always prevail😂
I KNOW SOMEONE WHO WORKS FOR AN INDIAN FAMILY IN LIMPOPO
SHE ALWAYS CALL US CRYING BECAUSE OF THE WAY THEY MISTREAT HER
SHE IS POOR THATS WHY SHE CONTINUES TO WORK FOR THEM
THANKS MALEMA FOR CONFRONTING THE TRUE
Why can't black people take responsibility for their own government and political failures rather than blaming a 2% minority?
@@marlannaicker1533 go back to India your time is up
@@nqobiledewa1398 who said this country is yrls, this place belongs to the Khoisan ppl stop stealing their land looter
@@nqobiledewa1398 send all the backs to Africa from America, it's not your country. Their time is up
@@yoliswa6309 You're probably a either bought stooge or a confused white person masquerading as a Khoi-San. 😂
what malema was talking was not his words but the people of kzn so juju was talking on our behalf
Ju Ju lives in the lap of luxury, so how can he speak for the poor?.
@@Daniel-zw4jo very stupid you mean the rich cannot talk for the poor? Then have you ever seen a special member of perliament for poor? and what is the purpose of political leaders
@@africamwebaze4941 that's the game of a politician score votes and breed racism
Nothin wrong with Malema comments. He is correct i have proof of that. Should it be needed i am more than willing to provide evidence
Amen to that,
How is it racist. Nigerians royal don’t marry white but all of a sudden it’s racist Indian don’t marry blacks.
Evidence like how the land was obtained from the blacks?.
His proof is invalid!
And I am sure yours is just as stupid as his!
RACIST PEOPLE
When someone finds fault on something it's is nothing but jealousy envious and bitterness raging inside of them so they cry Racism at its highest
Mbongeni Ngema was right...
The thruth is,Malema talking thruth,my wife she's a Indians worker,she get nothing there,she get peanuts,no uif
What Ngema said comrade?
yes we shall go the Zimbabwe way first before we recover.the land will be in our hands.
The guy is not listening the example made by Mpho is that the areas he specified are Lens but the guy answering on the other side is making it a general answerable question.
People hate the truth
erragent Indian dude, this dude just proved malema is right
"erragent" ?.
Well said CIC, we see this act almost every day
Africa first for Africans. Indians out of Africa.
Africa must be restored
Why the part where Malema said "if the shoe fit...then wear it" omitted. Media though !!!
Dont worry about this Indian, He is one of the Indians like the other Indians.
this is being blown out of propotion now...the CIC issued a warning to indians ill treating Africans thats that ....if you are indian and ill treat blacks we are on your case
Stupid idiot walked off halfway through the conversation!
Hold their feet to the fire of truth
This Sighn guy is so rude and angry because he knows this is the truth and he doesn't want it to stop.
Well he put facts out and the guy from the EFF just gave his opinion without backing it up with facts .... so your comment is just pointless
@@1999deshan what facts?
@@kenford4550 he talks about only 2% of the population being indian which even includes babies, children, OAPS etc. therefore how can around half a million indians really be a threat to a country of 60 million?
Also BEE supports black people regarding quotas for employment and education despite the fact that coloured people and indians also suffered during apartheid.
Black people are the majority in South Africa and have control of the government, it's about time that they stopped blaming minorities for their own political failures. Especially indians, whites are more understandable as they actually ruled there for decades and benefitted during apartheid
Great Malema, sharing is the way to go.
This Indian guy cannot make his point, where is the problem on Julius speech, which part is racism??
That he is stereotyping and black South africans don't take responsibility for their own political failures but instead have attacked other minorities like indians, whites and other South africans
If the shoe fits wear it. The EFF make the comfortable uncomfortable and the uncomfortable comfortable. Truth to Power. #TheTruthTeam CIC touches the nerve.
Why are yrl not talking about ethnic division amongst your very own yet yrl are very quick to attack the other race groups,
Im very disapointment to have an Advocade who is falling to answer some questions from chairperson Adv Mpofu
Iqiniso Mr Malema leli owawulisho, @ my work place we still fighting in equality between blacks and Indian.
How I wish Malema is a Ghanaian.... my prayer is that EFF wins and set the pace for other African countries like Ghana.
What juju said was only the truth, just do your own research and you will get the truth. in KZN, cleaning companies are owned by Indians and blacks are the workers, the majority of cleaners receive R1000 after two weeks of working meaning that they earn a monthly salary of just R2000 per month. secondly, it is an undeniable truth that Indian people dominate in Durban suburbs such as umhlanga, La lucia etc, and it is our fellow black Africans that work in those suburbs as domestic workers and are being paid peanuts. lastly, i find it annoying that there are people that condemn Malema's comment about Indians yet they are being bias by misquoting the actual comment. Juju's comment was not criticizing any fellow Indian, but it was meant precisely to all Indians who are ill-treating our fellow black African who work as domestic workers.
Is that really the fault of the indians? Who sets the law and political order? The government who are BLACK not indian.
Also Indians make up around 2% of the total population of South Africa, black South africans make up around 80% of the total population as well as the government so if indians are dominating then that's an issue on their side not the indians side. Indians are just trying to survive. The government needs to focus on educating black people.
Yes black people can condemn racist whites and indians. Meanwhile indians can condemn racist BEE policies and racism towards them eg the durban riots 1949
Then y do u work for Indians? Go to your black brothers see were its better
Why don't you Africans work for your money 😠
Go and work for Black Africans then - tell me where you prefer?
Then its simple, if you are treated harshly quit your job. I don't get what's the problem
diz indian guy is not answering questions dat r being asked
Have a Trial and let the witnesses speak.
we vote EFF!!!
It's so true one does not need too qualified a researcher to prove that just ask a few people who work for or with Indians. Painful to know like any truth.
Stop working for Indians, get your own ppl to employ yrl problem sorted
did the guy just say cheap supporters??
Go to Lenasia and Laudium Azaadville you will see how black people are treated
Malema is correct, this must be confronted head on.
Where’s Idi Amin when you need him!!!
Yeah, to kill .5 millions africans. He killed his own people. Your Idi Amin was cannibal too, killed his own wife.
Yugandan economy collasped when indians left.
15k indians still give 60% of yuganda tax.
You are a chutiya.
@@rahulrai3938 Lies lies as usual ,Idi Amin was a great man . May Allah receive him in paradise .
Idi Amin did what he did because of what the Indians were doing in Uganda. Lesson here for South African Indians.However, I don’t support violence against them or kicking them out like Idi Amin did. We need dialogue and education and there are many issues that Indians have brought with them culturally from India which need to change so that they can fit in with a new South Africa. Number 1 the cast system is a form of racism unacceptable in Mzansi. Number 2 Indian only communities should be banned and they should integrate. Number 3 Nepotism, so no businesses should operate with only Indians Number 4 marrying your sisters and cousins is incest should be banned. But ultimately we should ALL just get along.
Was there an assessment of the truth in the statements said by the EFF leader or a quick judgement or labeling of the statement as inciting racial prejudice? Or have we become race-cautious so much that we can not surface matters secluded to a particular race?? Then we may not find the so longed "non-racial South Africa"
I am happy that the EFF has raised this issue and Ghandi himself who is known as an activist uttered racist statements and that was never addressed. I am disappointed in South Africa by people who when issues are raised they become defensive, even if they know the truth. May EFF live longer to expose these kind of maladies.
when he said white monopoly they thought his finished the man is straight forward. he tell the truth you like it or not that's juju I know
That Singh guy looks and talk like those Indians who undermine Blacks
THE TRUTH HATE TOO BAD
This guy is emotional
That's the truth Mr.Malema at my workplace at the HR they recruited all Indians and our salaries doesn't last even 5 days after pay day,baya re loya.
Maybe u not worth it a passenger
EFF can put racism to a rest
i'm so disappointed by the so called advocate who is representing the Indians who does not have listening skill. he should relax and listen attentively before he can comment or respond. i doubt is an advocate.
mapolanka madisha 😂 he never addressed the question lol smh
After centuries of exploitation a nation should use all of its resources to rebuild and heal itself instead of sharing these resources with ungrateful guests and lost tourists with an appetite... EFF is the truth. If you are a guest, know your place and if you are the host, don't shy away from your sovereignty and use it whenever you feel a line has been crossed.
Indian govt need to intervene now.
He is not answering the questions
Why are u hating indians
This Indian advocate is unprofessional. This interview was not about ADV Dali Mpofu's private life.
If someone mistreats others or breaks the law, it’s that individual who does it not an entire community or race. Why everything in SA is about race? Keep saying Afrikaans this, blacks that, Indians that...who are these people?!
EFF
EFFs rhetoric reminds me of the vision Idi Amin had for Uganda.
He is the best representative. Sorry your argument didn't stand much.
Pho Tshedu is taking side
some Indians business owners also even harass the customers
Indians ill treat African in Durban and KwaZulu Natal that is a truth. Truee
Mr. Mpofu is already correct he doesnt need to concede any points. Its a balanced defense nonetheless
Just a simple example, try to investigate Durban Municipality and see how much nepotism happening and which group is mostly implicated.
Does Internet Solutions rings a bell...
I trust in you Advocate Dali Mpofu, you will deal with this guy
Advocate Dali Mpofu is a thick guy. He is too dumb to answer this question.
WELL PUT ADVOCATE
ADV MPOFU THAT IS
NOT THIS IRRELEVANT FOOL
@SABC digital
My goodness! This Adv is even worse than Mgxithama
Indians were in the struggle as well
those folks (indian) are some funny acting people even in the usa towards black people. ( the eff is right)
The issue is thoroughly explained by the Adv Mpofu, I agree with the EFF
Have no idea why people are catching feelings cause if I recall correctly Malema did say, "If the shoe fits, then wear it". It's not all Indians who are implicated to be mistreating Africans they employ but those who are just need to stop it. It's simple.
I AGREE
this indian guy though is dizzy, cant even answer simple questions he just attacking..signs of guilt
He gave facts tbh
Africans are most racist people in the world
you are defending Indians as though they guilty ? So Indians are saints and they treat as equal to others ?
Everyone is guilty
Internet Solutions rings a bell... little Bombay
malema alwys
What saddens me is that all indians are being painted the same when it comes to domestic workers I have a domestic worker who lives out and I pay her R3000 for 8 days a month and she is part of my family. My kids would rather be with her than me. We love her and she brings her kids over during the saturdays she works. please dont paint us all with the same brush.
anjeli Naidoo. Unfortunately the Indian comunity has an unhealthy attitude towards black people. The work place abuse. Nefarious business activities. Acting clanish, residential arrears and in business dealings. But the major problem lies with us black people, we never act selfishly in business or daily dealings. We should only buy black and deal with black in business. Basically put ourselves first and think only for our own benefit.
Mbulelo Zulu, what happens if we all thought the way you do. I could say the same for the attitude of blacks towards indians....keep to our own? would that assist the cause or bring on more conflict? Are we not at a deadlock in this instance?.
anjeli Naidoo. South African Indians need to change fast, not all are a problem but the majority still put themselves above blacks
My 13 year old son wants us to leave Amerikkka and move to a area where the EFF is located in Africa so that he can join the EFF and where their cool red uniforms and hat and work on changes for our people like Julius Malema ❣️❣️❣️✊🏿✊🏾✊🏽
And loot peoples money
than you EFF, plz investigate Phoenix!!!
Investigate amouti
He speaks the truth why people hate the truth there are many people suffering in hand of Indians it very true we experienced it on daily basis it the naked truth
Adv Singh lost this debate - his arguments were emotional and had no logical flow whatsoever!! What a waste of time coming to studio.
Come to Stellenbosch Farm pls EFF
that indian fellow is actually saying nothing..you can tell he gets angry.
I am not an EFF supporter but this guy is just being ridiculous, He failed to focus on the issue at hand and went for insults. the show was not about Dali Mpofu and what he has done in the past the show was about indian people who feel offended when it is said some indian people abuse their domestics, He argues that its wrong to say they are worse then afrikaaners because it is generalization and Afrikaaners are worse which is in itself generalizing. I have lived and studied in Durban UKZN westville campus and rented in indian dominated area of reservior hills I know how racist some indian people are and how badly they treat their employees, ive experienced it when working in an indian owned franchise restuarant. moreoever you can talk about crime and classify that majority if people who do it are african no african would feel offended and white people everyday in SA are told about White monopoly capital no white person goes to HRCSA so why do indians feel aggrieved when the same is said about them
Adv. Singh just wants to vent, hide behind the thumb... they should have called someone else.
The problem is this People like to judge Malema but they don't listening him very well when he talk or say something that's the biggest problem to people who have no listening skills that's what I'm saying.
Never met any workers working harder than an Indian...and I am white! They deserve their money and position!
Colrob Baird idiot
Colrob Baird legend. That's how we went from slaves to land owners.
Obviously! What white man can say about something that is positive about black person! Y'all are enemies .
Just to say this moderator and his program is shamelessly biased. He gave the remote guest no time to speak, no opportunity to reply and he allowed that guest's questions and challenges to go unanswered. The even cut the mans sound feed because they did not like what he was saying. The person in studio was talking a lot of bollocks and should have been challenged but the moderator protected him. Dont think I have taken sides in this - I am pointing out that the program has taken sides and thus has deprived us of listening to the arguments, just dished out propaganda.
Ulomfana thank you
true
Ulomfana HE WASNT ANSWERING THE QUESTION, HE WANTED TO TAKE CHEAP JABS AT THE EFF LAWYER REPRESENTATIVE, so the host shouldn’t let that happen. And the host has personal cases. ..Answer the question Indian guy?? We are still waiting 👂🏾
Well said
Hahaha this guy is not answering the question he is running around it.
Talking truth is criminally in south africa?
There's African people in india as citizens, do they have the kind of opportunities you guys are enjoying in S.A? Blacks in india are the most poorest people on earth, they were isolated in india by the govt of india, alot of black kids in thousands were denied education in india till date.
We can just quote the most tolerant Mahatma Gandhi on his thoughts of Africans in South Africa. So let us drop the hypocrisy and solve problems.
This advocate Singh is an epitome of arrogance!
Like u
This presenter is very biased and unprofessional
Trueth but true man you need to be trueth come on eff keep it like that,amandla.
S.a.this is a big disgrace to Africa.in your own country you will be begging to live this is a shame whoever sold you people out did a terrible job.
Test
Research and you will find truth on the ground don't just defend yourselves
juju my leader
How did he become advocate Singh? He is an epitome of arrogance.
Is Malema lying ?
NO
this man does not answer questions
Well said Advocate
Usa divha Hu fana na ufa
Is Indian a race???? Waw
However, the worst abuse of domestics that I have witnessed, is black on black. The worst worst is blacks to Zimbabweans. This is a fact. The Indian issue is just highlighted, I dont know why, but it seems like one of Julius tactics as we know he does. I can take him to black people who are working for black eole and jell have a shock of his life if he has not seen it uet,which I highly doubt.
Malema I like u so much am Ugandan leaving in here I surport u so much thanks for loving our Africa en all Africans but one thing I saw on our brothers here south Africans blacks but their don't have land no business no houses I can't blame them the government left them behind their don't even know how to do business just beer's en ladies it's wat their know most