It is so nostalgic coming back to this video. I’ve learned so much since then, and it was thanks to this video tutorial that I learned how to play the arpeggio and other songs I learned on the piano I’ll never forget
Thanks you so much. This is my favorite song on the piano all time and I'm going to play it for the whole school tommorow with my friend. I've learned the whole song with your tutorial; I cannot thank you enough! Cheers from the Netherlands!
AAAHHH this tutorial is SSSOOOO good! It's 2:00 am and my room mate is sleeping. But tomorrow when she's at work, I'm definitely learning this. Thank you! Great job!
i watched this tutorial 2 years ago and i have to say that this is the best tutorial kuz it was my first time were i started making my left hand play the way it plays right now.
To all the people complaining that he teaches fast: fast is good for everyone, both the advanced player, who's not willing to wait hours for him to say obvious stuff AND the beginner player, who should be well aware that the red bar at the bottom allows you to REWIND the video ab libitum.
implementing scales into your playing as opposed to playing just the basic chords has help me improve my left hand abilty dramaticly. i always found it very intimidating to try and expand on the left hand creativity. Thank you for the lessons it has opend up a new ball game in my playing.
Thanks for the great tutorial, you made it simple withought dragging it on to much and explained each part clearly so it is easier to learn. You are also an incredible pianist!
im a guitarist and ive been playing guitar for five years. idk how you guys play piano! it takes amazing talent, i'm trying to learn piano without lessons. not working lol.
This is actually one of the best tutorials on youtube! There is few times where u go so fast that it is hard to understund what to press but if u replay this part 10 times and u watch it closly u can get it!! GOOD TUTORIAL! :)
I must be retarded. I have this awesome video showing me note for note how to play this, and it's taken me hours upon hours, spread out over months, just to make it to part two. How anyone can just play this, furthermore create something like this, is beyond me.
Wilderness Medic well the writer for this song (front woman for evenescence) is classically trained in piano so, this song has a lot of classical elements
KingLucentino you are a great teacher, I started playing piano last summer (alone in home) and I learned River flows in you with your videos and now i'm going to learn this one.. Thank you and keep it up !
It was the best tutorial that I found but: The first part you were teaching great but from the second part it was so confusing and so fast. In the second and third parts, you say something when you're playing with one hand but you change it when you're playing it with both hands and it's just confusing to me!
353 people didn't have anyone to wipe their tears away when they realized this tutorial was too good for them. THANK YOU UPLOADER!!!! I am playing bits and peices now :D
Thank you so much! Your version is the best and the most beautiful one, I'm trying to learn pt2 now..)) thanks to you this is my 1st song after 15 years of not playing ))) you're amazing, Kyle)
you explain the seperate hands really good. But why dont you explain the part with both hands? Now I have learned the seperate hands. But I have no idea how to combine them. :(
This has helped me so much, I know you probably get thousands of comments saying the same thing but honestly when I first saw you play the parts especially the pre chorus part I never thought I'd get it, it's taken me a long time but I kept practicing and I can now play those parts,so Thankyou so much, this is the only my immortal tutorial I've seen, (trust me, I've seen loads) that has been any worth while watching so I'm definitely subscribing!
This is a fantastic tutorial for this song. I was hunting all over for one and like you said in your original video, they were just people playing slowly. I've managed to just about complete this song based purely on your tutorials. I'll be posting myself playing it on here when it's ready and I'll be certain to link to this tutorial. Thank you so much; I'm quite sure there is no way I would have managed this amazing version of this song on my own.
Thanks you Kyle I master this song at the age of 19 in 2009, you took me to another level in music, your skills and teaching ability is amazing, how you meticulous break down complex passages is crazy, I thank you !!
I've watched this video so many times over, and have probably commented on it a million times, but I just can't get over how awesome people are for actually being able to memorize this. Been trying to memorize it on and off for the past 3 years. This is a fantastic tutorial, but my brain is filled with too much stuff already D:
KingL lets start out with you are absolutely amazing, just in case nobody has already told you that . Seriously. I have seen 100s of tutorials for all different kinds of songs and yours was the best explained, presented, and easy to follow (I didnt have to rewind it 10,000 times to say "GAHHH! His hand is blocking what his middle finger is playing!! What is it!? WHAT IS IIIIT?!" haha) And you primed this song to perfection. Please ignore the rude people on your page. Forever your fan -Eotsday
whats wrong with the people that dislike it....seriously....the man can play piano very good and he is teaching very well....there are soo many haters out there ....god....-_-
i was learning this song by another (incomplete) tutorial, now i have yours and im so happy to find the entire song thank you so much, even when this video has a lot of years uploaded
Hello , you are a wonderful teacher. Your tutorials are very helpful. Thank you from breaking the tunes down to every beat, its much easier to co ordinate the hands for a person you learns by listening. :)
Thank you for this! I don't play piano. Never taken any lessons. From time to time pressed some random keys. Thanks to your tutorial I was able to learn this song in about a month, although not perfect I am extremely happy! Thanks! My Immortal Piano Cover
Thank you so much for posting these tutorial videos. I am currently learning how to play this song, and you have been so helpful with the progress that I've made.
I just started playing piano seriously only a week and a half ago and I started learning how to play this song a week ago and I'm already halfway through the song because of you. Thanks a bunch
Honestly, you have the best tutorials on here. You actually walk through each section and repeat it and until it is learned. Great job! (Request...The Chairman's Waltz? Please?) :D
Love this tutorial! You're actually a really great teacher, I feel like I'm getting the flow of the song while I'm learning unlike a lot of other tutorials. ...haven't learnt it all yet but yeah :)
I wanted to say thanks. This is the first song I'm learning and I'm getting it pretty fast. Already know both left and right, just having problems playing both at the same time but I'll get it.
you have my infinite thanks for both the tutorial and the sheet. A girl asked me to learn this song and thanks to you and Phoenix215476 I'll be able to learn the best version. :)
This is the first song I'll be learning for piano; obviously really hard for a newbie, but I love it and you're incredibly clear and helpful, so I think, with a whole lot of practice, I'll do alright :)
@theoutlook989 - I am new to piano, I am a bassist..this is not a easy song to learn in keys..as it required left right hand co ordination... and in order to learn this song you would need some basic theory knowledge... at least you need to knw major minor chords, triads etc.. this is a great tutorial.. it helped me a lot to learn my first song on keys :) i bet if you knw any instruments this is the best tutorial you could ever get..and if you want to learn basics this is not the right place
I am making progress, thanks to your video and clear teachings. :) I can fully play the intro (and I guess outro) and sing along simultaneously and I am almost at two hands for the verse...so close :) Thank you!
When I was 11 I learned the intro all the way through. Then I learned the bridge to the chorus when I was 12. Now I'm 13 and DETERMINED to learn this ALL THE WAY THROUGH. I want to play it for the talent show so bad. For the 8th grade talent show, I WILL be playing and singing this song. And I'm going to spend all year perfecting it since its always at the end of the school year. I aint giving up this time. THANKS SO MUCH!
I loved this song since I was 14. But unfortunately, whenever I seem to play it, it reminds me of my past pain. However, I really wanna learn how to play this because it's such a beautiful song!! You are an excellent teacher!
this sounds so beautiful :') i have dreamed of being able to play he piano part whilst singing it, i will definitely get going and start learning it, thankyou for the tutorial it's brilliant!
ive never played piano in my in my life.. never taken 1 lesson . but ive always wanted to play this song and after this tutorial im proud to say i can play the intro and the first verse. still workin on the chourus :) thanks for the tutorial !
i dont see why people are commenting on your sexuality? this is a tutorial for a song on a piano, it has nothing to do with the video and its none of there business any way! i think this is a great video and i have learnt the first part in 10 minutes, thankyou =]
Thankyou. I think the pre-chorus right hand melody isn't quite right in just the 2nd bit - it includes more than single notes there, but apart from that this video was extremely useful. I didn't realise the left hand chord arpeggios were so extended - that'll take me a while to get right ! Thanks for taking the time to do this - much appreciated.
Thank you so much for doing this song. I love evanescence so much. Could you possibly do a tutorial for their song Going under if you haven't done so? You don't have to if you don't want to :)
never mind! it is a good tutorial!!! I manged to combine both of my hands in chorus! keep it up with ur tutorials! They are really good. and thank you for teaching us this song! Did u learn this song from notes or ear?
King Lucentio (or something like that) !!!! I used this tutorial to learn the beginer part of the song a LONG time ago!!! Hope u doing well, u r a great pianist ;)
This helped a lot! I think I can play this song eventually. You make it look so simple so I'll want to immitate. :) Thank you so much for taking time to make this tutorial!!!!~
To get both hands playing together as frustrating as it is just keep practicing, over and over, fast and slow, until you get it right and notice some kind of pattern that you'll remember :) & Really, thank you for the awesome tutorial
Fantastic tutorial! Much better than many ive seen. Do you listen to Jack's Mannequin at all? I love them, and I havent found many good tutorials. I would love to see your version of some. Thanks again!
It is so nostalgic coming back to this video. I’ve learned so much since then, and it was thanks to this video tutorial that I learned how to play the arpeggio and other songs I learned on the piano I’ll never forget
🥰
Just came back to this video after a decade maybe? This is one of the first songs I learned becoming a keyboardist. Thanks Kyle.
Thanks you so much. This is my favorite song on the piano all time and I'm going to play it for the whole school tommorow with my friend. I've learned the whole song with your tutorial; I cannot thank you enough! Cheers from the Netherlands!
Got the intro,bridge and now im onto the chorus!! This is the most helpful tutorial I have ever watched
AAAHHH this tutorial is SSSOOOO good! It's 2:00 am and my room mate is sleeping. But tomorrow when she's at work, I'm definitely learning this. Thank you! Great job!
i watched this tutorial 2 years ago and i have to say that this is the best tutorial kuz it was my first time were i started making my left hand play the way it plays right now.
To all the people complaining that he teaches fast: fast is good for everyone, both the advanced player, who's not willing to wait hours for him to say obvious stuff AND the beginner player, who should be well aware that the red bar at the bottom allows you to REWIND the video ab libitum.
implementing scales into your playing as opposed to playing just the basic chords has help me improve my left hand abilty dramaticly. i always found it very intimidating to try and expand on the left hand creativity. Thank you for the lessons it has opend up a new ball game in my playing.
This helped me! I know the first part but thanks with the chorus!!
Thanks for the great tutorial, you made it simple withought dragging it on to much and explained each part clearly so it is easier to learn. You are also an incredible pianist!
At the first part I was all like "I got this," and then the second part came up and I was just like -_-
Practice and practice.
im a guitarist and ive been playing guitar for five years. idk how you guys play piano! it takes amazing talent, i'm trying to learn piano without lessons. not working lol.
Hey kyle, is it possible that you could redo this tutorial in a newer 1080p video so it is clearer and the audio sounds better? thanks
This is actually one of the best tutorials on youtube!
There is few times where u go so fast that it is hard to
understund what to press but if u replay this part 10 times
and u watch it closly u can get it!!
GOOD TUTORIAL! :)
So easy to learn, you're good, very simple
I must be retarded. I have this awesome video showing me note for note how to play this, and it's taken me hours upon hours, spread out over months, just to make it to part two. How anyone can just play this, furthermore create something like this, is beyond me.
Wilderness Medic well the writer for this song (front woman for evenescence) is classically trained in piano so, this song has a lot of classical elements
KingLucentino you are a great teacher, I started playing piano last summer (alone in home) and I learned River flows in you with your videos and now i'm going to learn this one.. Thank you and keep it up !
It was the best tutorial that I found but:
The first part you were teaching great but from the second part it was so confusing and so fast.
In the second and third parts, you say something when you're playing with one hand but you change it when you're playing it with both hands and it's just confusing to me!
353 people didn't have anyone to wipe their tears away when they realized this tutorial was too good for them.
THANK YOU UPLOADER!!!! I am playing bits and peices now :D
So cool! ))
Thank you so much! Your version is the best and the most beautiful one, I'm trying to learn pt2 now..)) thanks to you this is my 1st song after 15 years of not playing ))) you're amazing, Kyle)
you explain the seperate hands really good. But why dont you explain the part with both hands? Now I have learned the seperate hands. But I have no idea how to combine them. :(
I agree, I am having difficulty with that :(
i recommend you to play only 3 note by left hand A-C-A and C#-G#-C#
i can make video if u want of my version
same here
This has helped me so much, I know you probably get thousands of comments saying the same thing but honestly when I first saw you play the parts especially the pre chorus part I never thought I'd get it, it's taken me a long time but I kept practicing and I can now play those parts,so Thankyou so much, this is the only my immortal tutorial I've seen, (trust me, I've seen loads) that has been any worth while watching so I'm definitely subscribing!
this is fucking hard but you're made it as easy as possible. Great job man! I'll stick to my guitar though LOL
This is a fantastic tutorial for this song. I was hunting all over for one and like you said in your original video, they were just people playing slowly. I've managed to just about complete this song based purely on your tutorials. I'll be posting myself playing it on here when it's ready and I'll be certain to link to this tutorial. Thank you so much; I'm quite sure there is no way I would have managed this amazing version of this song on my own.
Hey, can you explain it a little bit easier, some of us dont know all the chords And your going a little too fast
Adrian Padilla I learned it perfectly and I was new to piano . Just go back to video an re watch as many times as possible
I don't know notes 😂
Thanks you Kyle I master this song at the age of 19 in 2009, you took me to another level in music, your skills and teaching ability is amazing, how you meticulous break down complex passages is crazy, I thank you !!
Guys if it's too fast you can adjust the SPEED in this video!
This is the best tutorial out of all currently available for this song. Thank you!!!!
I need a piano.
I've watched this video so many times over, and have probably commented on it a million times, but I just can't get over how awesome people are for actually being able to memorize this. Been trying to memorize it on and off for the past 3 years. This is a fantastic tutorial, but my brain is filled with too much stuff already D:
looking for something funny? put it in half speed for a good laugh
This is a great tutorial. Very thorough and easy to follow. You just get straight to the point and explain everything well.
I don't understand the end of the second part :c and I don't speak english...help me
Victoria Araya same. it's like he missed out on telling us the last 5-6 keys at the end of that. -.-
KingL lets start out with you are absolutely amazing, just in case nobody has already told you that . Seriously. I have seen 100s of tutorials for all different kinds of songs and yours was the best explained, presented, and easy to follow (I didnt have to rewind it 10,000 times to say "GAHHH! His hand is blocking what his middle finger is playing!! What is it!? WHAT IS IIIIT?!" haha) And you primed this song to perfection. Please ignore the rude people on your page. Forever your fan -Eotsday
tutorial turn into a cover. 😩
Couldn't have put it better myself!
this was one of the best piano tutorials I´ce ever seen before!
Good job!!!
these wounds wont seem to heal this pain is just too real etc. lol
Jack Wyldeck just too **reeeeeeeal**
whats wrong with the people that dislike it....seriously....the man can play piano very good and he is teaching very well....there are soo many haters out there ....god....-_-
i can't freaking play with both my hands!
Same
i was learning this song by another (incomplete) tutorial, now i have yours and im so happy to find the entire song
thank you so much, even when this video has a lot of years uploaded
Hello , you are a wonderful teacher. Your tutorials are very helpful. Thank you from breaking the tunes down to every beat, its much easier to co ordinate the hands for a person you learns by listening. :)
Great tutorial. Didn't think I would be able to play such beautiful songs so quickly.
I never comment, but you are awesome, dude. I have been playing for 20 years and can't match what you do. keep up the great tutorials!
Loved it! It was an excellent tutorial for me and I'm a beginner. I could understand everything clearly. THANKS!!! :) greetings from Puerto Rico
Thank you for this! I don't play piano. Never taken any lessons. From time to time pressed some random keys. Thanks to your tutorial I was able to learn this song in about a month, although not perfect I am extremely happy! Thanks!
My Immortal Piano Cover
This will be the first song I learn on piano by watching and not having the music infront of me thanks!! U gained a subscriber!!
Thank you so much for posting these tutorial videos. I am currently learning how to play this song, and you have been so helpful with the progress that I've made.
I just started playing piano seriously only a week and a half ago and I started learning how to play this song a week ago and I'm already halfway through the song because of you. Thanks a bunch
Wow... I'm blown away. Thank you! You are a beautiful pianist
Honestly, you have the best tutorials on here. You actually walk through each section and repeat it and until it is learned. Great job!
(Request...The Chairman's Waltz? Please?) :D
Love this tutorial! You're actually a really great teacher, I feel like I'm getting the flow of the song while I'm learning unlike a lot of other tutorials.
...haven't learnt it all yet but yeah :)
You are a fantastic teacher! Now I can play this song flawlessly. Thank you!
I wanted to say thanks. This is the first song I'm learning and I'm getting it pretty fast. Already know both left and right, just having problems playing both at the same time but I'll get it.
AMAZING tutorial! I have the sheet music for it but I was having so much trouble with it until now!
Your play is so realistic and quiet natural!!! keep goin my best wishes!!
you have my infinite thanks for both the tutorial and the sheet. A girl asked me to learn this song and thanks to you and Phoenix215476 I'll be able to learn the best version. :)
Started playing piano last October and now I've finally learnt my first song, which is this piece. Took 8 months but it was totally worth it!
This is the first song I'll be learning for piano; obviously really hard for a newbie, but I love it and you're incredibly clear and helpful, so I think, with a whole lot of practice, I'll do alright :)
@theoutlook989 - I am new to piano, I am a bassist..this is not a easy song to learn in keys..as it required left right hand co ordination... and in order to learn this song you would need some basic theory knowledge... at least you need to knw major minor chords, triads etc..
this is a great tutorial.. it helped me a lot to learn my first song on keys :)
i bet if you knw any instruments this is the best tutorial you could ever get..and if you want to learn basics this is not the right place
I am making progress, thanks to your video and clear teachings. :) I can fully play the intro (and I guess outro) and sing along simultaneously and I am almost at two hands for the verse...so close :) Thank you!
When I was 11 I learned the intro all the way through. Then I learned the bridge to the chorus when I was 12. Now I'm 13 and DETERMINED to learn this ALL THE WAY THROUGH. I want to play it for the talent show so bad. For the 8th grade talent show, I WILL be playing and singing this song. And I'm going to spend all year perfecting it since its always at the end of the school year. I aint giving up this time.
THANKS SO MUCH!
I loved this song since I was 14. But unfortunately, whenever I seem to play it, it reminds me of my past pain. However, I really wanna learn how to play this because it's such a beautiful song!! You are an excellent teacher!
Good day! This is one of the best lessons I've ever seen!! Thanks!
This is a really good tutorial, one of the best ive seen on youtube.
thanks for this.
It took me about ten minutes to learn it, now to master it! Thank you so much for your tutorial!
this sounds so beautiful :') i have dreamed of being able to play he piano part whilst singing it, i will definitely get going and start learning it, thankyou for the tutorial it's brilliant!
You're a major help. You broke it down quick, and easy. Thanks!
Realmente estoy muy agradecido hace 15 años aprendí a tocar esta musica y mi pasion por el piano fue maravillosa. Gracias amigo!😊
Awesome video-Thank you!! I belted this out at a dinner party after practicing with your tutorial for about a month and nailed it!!
ive never played piano in my in my life.. never taken 1 lesson . but ive always wanted to play this song and after this tutorial im proud to say i can play the intro and the first verse. still workin on the chourus :) thanks for the tutorial !
i dont see why people are commenting on your sexuality? this is a tutorial for a song on a piano, it has nothing to do with the video and its none of there business any way! i think this is a great video and i have learnt the first part in 10 minutes, thankyou =]
Thankyou. I think the pre-chorus right hand melody isn't quite right in just the 2nd bit - it includes more than single notes there, but apart from that this video was extremely useful. I didn't realise the left hand chord arpeggios were so extended - that'll take me a while to get right !
Thanks for taking the time to do this - much appreciated.
Such a pretty song! I love you! Thnks evanscence!
I love the part when you say "observe!" It's both cute and sexy in the same way. Lol. Probably the most strange comment you have received :)
Wow its seems so easy when u play it.
thank u for this amazing tutorial.
Hello, I don't want to miss to thank you so much for your tutorials. They are so great. Started last week with this one ;)
It's so easy to learn from kyle sinclaire...he is a good teacher..♥♥♥
You are amazing it's hard for me to play this song but I really become each time I put your video and try again thanks a lot!!
This is about the 7th time im watching this :3 but i still think your really talented!!
Thank you so much for doing this song. I love evanescence so much. Could you possibly do a tutorial for their song Going under if you haven't done so? You don't have to if you don't want to :)
you are flippin awesome dude! a great teacher. supreme respect. thanks for being you. keep it up
excellent .. i ve waiting for years on this lesson !!! very well done , thanx dude
You are by far !!! The best Bro.
You're awesome! thank you for this amazing tutorial! I hope I'll be able to play it, it sounds beautiful!
you are very good in tutorial. keep up the good work... your good.
amazing tutorial. you are also really good at piano. Thank you so much for sharing what you know. :)
You play the piano extremely well sir. I love this song and you killed it :D
You are amazing on the piano. I am not sure I am going to be able to get both hands done there. :) You have done well.
never mind! it is a good tutorial!!! I manged to combine both of my hands in chorus!
keep it up with ur tutorials! They are really good. and thank you for teaching us this song!
Did u learn this song from notes or ear?
Amazing. You play beautifully and make it easy to pick up. You are great. :)
u made this so easy. i caught on so quickly, thankyou!!!
King Lucentio (or something like that) !!!! I used this tutorial to learn the beginer part of the song a LONG time ago!!! Hope u doing well, u r a great pianist ;)
This helped a lot! I think I can play this song eventually. You make it look so simple so I'll want to immitate. :) Thank you so much for taking time to make this tutorial!!!!~
I everI always wanted to put a thumbs up, but had no active account, thanks to this I learned a little bit of music.
Thank you! (:
thank you! especially for sheets. you're the best!
..this is my Favorite Tutorial...
Why must this be so hard?!
Great tutorial, by the way. Very helpful.
This is really good stuff!!! I actually watched this video a long time ago and i learned to play! Nothing else was helpful enough. Thanks a lot!!! :D
To get both hands playing together as frustrating as it is just keep practicing, over and over, fast and slow, until you get it right and notice some kind of pattern that you'll remember :)
& Really, thank you for the awesome tutorial
Fantastic tutorial! Much better than many ive seen. Do you listen to Jack's Mannequin at all? I love them, and I havent found many good tutorials. I would love to see your version of some. Thanks again!