Don’t underestimate how much so many fans want to win a trophy. It’s huge! I’d happily take 6th/7th next season but win Carabao Cup/ FA Cup. If we nothing under Emery with this squad it would be absolutely criminal. The likes of McGinn, Mings, Martinez, Konsa, Watkins etc deserve it so much.
If we finish 6th/7th and lose lucrative ucl revenue,we will have to sell players and downgrade again. I'd definitely choose finish top 4 and get into ucl for that revenue and grow the club first. once we are top 4 consistently,our revenue will increase and can afford better player to solidify top 4 and maybe win ucl in the next few season.
league position every time for me ,like dan has said you need to attract the players ,and the kudos for the club . all players want champions league if we collect a cup along the way then great .
Also, as a side comment, I think Villa have very much disturbed the peace within the PL this last year to the point that I, someone that lives in Texas, has seen more and more people recognise the Villa when I wear shirts/workout gear. UTV
That's the point. Once we can get top 4 consistently,our fanbase and revenue will grow and we can afford better player and then challenge to win something for real
I think maintaining our position in the league is more important than trophies right now. By the time Emery leaves, we will have multiple trophies but, for now, it’s about stability at the top.
I didn't realise that my handle was still the one from when I was 13, lmfao. What I was implying with my comment was that Matt has gotten more optimistic over the last year to the point where sometimes you can see genuine excitement now, compared to how he used to look at Villa. I don't think John is pessimistic, just that Matt has turned optimistic now!
Europa league at a minimum and knock out stages of champions league should be a must for this season. Get the profile up. Need to be consistently top 6. The trophies will come.
Felix probably the missing link to unlock low block team. We struggled against team that park the bus. Buendia can do that but he was injured last season.
I do think Hermoso comes in if when we sell digne or moreno - with Pau being more naturally comfortable on the right and having played there a lot for Villarreal it’s a good move for all. Konsa I’d expect to play rb or third CB with 3 at the back. Good times
Enjoyed that episode, thanks very much fellas. Why do you think there are so few players and managers from Birmingham and the Black Country? It's a large geographical area with a big population and football is the no. 1 sport, but for the 30+ years I've been following football there seems to have been very few Brummie/Black Country players. For comparison, there never seems to be a lack of players from the north-east, which must be similar or smaller in population. Would really appreciate your views! Get well soon, Dan.
For me, the Felix situation is best solved (from our end) with a "loan with obligation to buy (if certain conditions are met)". These certain conditions are basically ensuring that we are in a financially safe position to invest in him having had a season of assumed good performances. Let's say the conditions are, appearance, goal contributions and CL depth and requalification. Assuming that all these are met, we'd probably be in a position to sign him permanently as we could put his purchase onto the next year of financials. I think he'd be absolutely amazing for us, go back and watch him for Chelsea in the prem, he was probably their best player during a time where they were pretty poor. Emery wants him and if he can get back to his level when he joined Atletico, it'd be more than worth it.
I am not sure about felix I am losing count of clubs he has been at , and he has already had a spell in the Premier at Chelsea and that didn't work Something ain't quite right , maybe the fire in his belly has gone out because of the money he has earned, someone else springs to mind now on loan in Brazil
I think we have a Pau Torres issue. He was so crucial to they way we played last season and the dip in form seemed to start when he got injured but some of his defending cost us dearly as well. No club has finished in a champions league spot and conceeded as many goals. Does he persist with him as a centre back? And we need a decent sub keeper.
Onana wearing the number 24 scares me for Duran’s future with us. Although if someone spends an abundance of money on him I could be persuaded. I think Duran is gonna be special
Can't see Felix with his wages. Feels like a massive risk. I also feel like he doesn't want to come here which would comcern me. He's talented but hasn't been impactful at his last 3 clubs
Apparently Felix took a big wage cut to Barca and willing to take paycut in order to play for villa. Hopefully we don't need to spend big on his transfer and salary 😅
Think John might be wrong about Archer and the 4 club trained players for UCL "How many homegrown players are needed in a Champions League squad? Out of the 25, eight places are reserved exclusively for "locally trained players" or homegrown players. Out of the eight, not more than four can be "association-trained players" and the rest must be "club-trained" I read this as we NEED 4 club trained? So JJ, Bidace, Archer and Kiesler-Hayden?
@@andyvilla4489 yeah would seem silly to only have a 23 man squad when we are allowed 25, with the amount of football we are going to have surely we use the full squad.
@@samuelloification2749 but we had to sell them for PSR...this year we sold Luiz and Kellyman. I do think Emery has learned the lesson and knows we need bodies. I see Archer sticking around
Can’t help but think that in the cup win v UCL qualification is an easy one to decide. You lose good players if they want to at least have “something” to show at the end of their career. So at least winning a cup comp resolves that? Look at Kane leaving to at least fill up one spot on his pre made trophy wall (bad example 😊)
Dont need Felix - too many Countinho vibes. Get a 2nd striker to mold into an Ollie replacement in 3 years... Buendia & Rogers can be the support striker.
Losing Dougie was a loss. I keep an eye on Everton n while I like Onana n Barkley, Dougie made game changing plays. It's a starter loss n back up improvement. Onana is good just n a different way. But with psr we didn't have a choice. We gotta trust Unai n his team. They know what they're doing.
If Duran goes I hope we get an actual striker. Not just someone who’s plays just behind.. we have enough of those kind of players already. Still a big worry if Watkins gets injured
Completely disagree,claret and blue are good,but podcasts like the up the villa and heart of the hole throw loads of content out all of high quality, they are better yet claret and blue are basically Birmingham live ,it should be doing better imo, doesn't mean I don't enjoy it though.utv
What? Lack of episodes? We’ve done 13 TH-cam videos and 16 uploads on podcast platforms with Kendrick’s voicenotes. 16 uploads in 24 days is pretty good going. During the season we can sometimes have an episode every single day 😂
@@ClaretBluePod why be disrespectful with your laughing emoji,I'm aloud an opinion without be laughed at surly, I've been looking for new content for days always seems the other podcasts always have more and I don't see how that's possible tbh,anyway I won't laugh back I'm an adult you see.utv
@@deansimcox1273 Of course you're allowed an opinion, I just find it funny that we're not doing enough and being 'kicked into touch' I find that more disrespectful. We had an episode go out on Monday, Tuesday and today. Not much more we can do. We will not be posting content for the sake of it, and to be honest I'm not at all bothered what the other podcasts do.
It's strange how there's no noise around that...we basically have 3 Cbs but about 8 forward players for 3 positions and as things stand 3 strikers for 1 position
Felix will be Coutinho 2.0 that's my prediction, he done absolutely nothing for Chelsea apart from getting sent off in quick time, yes Uni can bring out the best in players but I think we should look elsewhere, Felix is currently training alone which is not a good thing .
i swear Dan is always ill. does he eat enough nutrients? i'm really not keen on Felix. The risks outweigh the positives for me. Put Ramsey on the wing and put Rogers as attacking midfielder.
Without hesitation, I’d take Beier over Felix. Beier can cover Watkins and play in behind or on the wing. Felix can’t cover for Watkins. Felix has been crap at Chelsea and not played well for a while now - it just isn’t worth the risk for the wages / transfer fee. It could cripple us financially and isn’t worth the gamble in my opinion.
Nah I know how this sounds but if I’m sat down to play it/record it, that is ‘work’ and then I’ve got to find time to edit it. So I can’t do that in work hours so I’ll be ‘working’ on my own time. Where I already have very little free time as is
Don’t underestimate how much so many fans want to win a trophy. It’s huge! I’d happily take 6th/7th next season but win Carabao Cup/ FA Cup. If we nothing under Emery with this squad it would be absolutely criminal. The likes of McGinn, Mings, Martinez, Konsa, Watkins etc deserve it so much.
If we finish 6th/7th and lose lucrative ucl revenue,we will have to sell players and downgrade again.
I'd definitely choose finish top 4 and get into ucl for that revenue and grow the club first. once we are top 4 consistently,our revenue will increase and can afford better player to solidify top 4 and maybe win ucl in the next few season.
league position every time for me ,like dan has said you need to attract the players ,and the kudos for the club . all players want champions league if we collect a cup along the way then great .
Also, as a side comment, I think Villa have very much disturbed the peace within the PL this last year to the point that I, someone that lives in Texas, has seen more and more people recognise the Villa when I wear shirts/workout gear. UTV
That's the point. Once we can get top 4 consistently,our fanbase and revenue will grow and we can afford better player and then challenge to win something for real
I think maintaining our position in the league is more important than trophies right now. By the time Emery leaves, we will have multiple trophies but, for now, it’s about stability at the top.
I didn't realise that my handle was still the one from when I was 13, lmfao. What I was implying with my comment was that Matt has gotten more optimistic over the last year to the point where sometimes you can see genuine excitement now, compared to how he used to look at Villa. I don't think John is pessimistic, just that Matt has turned optimistic now!
Good clarification, thanks Big Head 🤪
@@ClaretBluePod Name changed now, thanks for the push to do so
Europa league at a minimum and knock out stages of champions league should be a must for this season. Get the profile up. Need to be consistently top 6. The trophies will come.
Get well soon, Danos
I'm not sure about Felix, are we changing one problem, with another problem?
Felix probably the missing link to unlock low block team. We struggled against team that park the bus. Buendia can do that but he was injured last season.
Rogers can cover Watkins because there are plenty to cover Rogers if he moves upfront.
Plus Joao Felix can play upfront as well 😋💪
I do think Hermoso comes in if when we sell digne or moreno - with Pau being more naturally comfortable on the right and having played there a lot for Villarreal it’s a good move for all. Konsa I’d expect to play rb or third CB with 3 at the back. Good times
With our squad, we are more than capable of finishing top 4 and winning a domestic cup.
Other teams do that all the time.
Yupz,once we have a good full team this season,it's possible. Last season we didn't have enough player to last the distance with that many injuries 😅
Enjoyed that episode, thanks very much fellas.
Why do you think there are so few players and managers from Birmingham and the Black Country?
It's a large geographical area with a big population and football is the no. 1 sport, but for the 30+ years I've been following football there seems to have been very few Brummie/Black Country players. For comparison, there never seems to be a lack of players from the north-east, which must be similar or smaller in population.
Would really appreciate your views!
Get well soon, Dan.
Top priority has to be top 4 again for me.
We can’t be making it in one year and not the year after. Otherwise we won’t grow and people will leave.
Interesting that Onana was wearing the number 24 in training😎
Re: Trophy vs ECL qualification:
The solution is to win the ECLnthen youve done both!
Felix would turn out to be another Coutinho, I 1000% guarantee that within a season we'd be looking to move him on, leave this WELL ALONE
For me, the Felix situation is best solved (from our end) with a "loan with obligation to buy (if certain conditions are met)".
These certain conditions are basically ensuring that we are in a financially safe position to invest in him having had a season of assumed good performances. Let's say the conditions are, appearance, goal contributions and CL depth and requalification. Assuming that all these are met, we'd probably be in a position to sign him permanently as we could put his purchase onto the next year of financials.
I think he'd be absolutely amazing for us, go back and watch him for Chelsea in the prem, he was probably their best player during a time where they were pretty poor. Emery wants him and if he can get back to his level when he joined Atletico, it'd be more than worth it.
felix doesn’t cover the watkins role at all , if duran goes we need an out and out ST not some hybrid that doesn’t really work in either position
I am not sure about felix I am losing count of clubs he has been at , and he has already had a spell in the Premier at Chelsea and that didn't work
Something ain't quite right , maybe the fire in his belly has gone out because of the money he has earned, someone else springs to mind now on loan in Brazil
Solanki also gives set piece protection
Love the podcast lads!!! Greetings from California and UTFV!!!💪🏾
I hope we still are looking for free signings like Kamara. Game changers that help the books. I hope they don't lose sight of that.
I think we have a Pau Torres issue. He was so crucial to they way we played last season and the dip in form seemed to start when he got injured but some of his defending cost us dearly as well. No club has finished in a champions league spot and conceeded as many goals. Does he persist with him as a centre back? And we need a decent sub keeper.
Mostly because we were missing Kamara who protect the back 4 when we started shipping goals in 😅
Keep up the good work lads
Joao Felix just strikes me as *Coutinho 2.0*
Onana wearing the number 24 scares me for Duran’s future with us. Although if someone spends an abundance of money on him I could be persuaded. I think Duran is gonna be special
But I also feel if/when Duran hits his potential, he is going to create drama and immediately push to be moved
to Spain
I agree. Think he is the next Drogba.
Dominic Solanke is prem ready and can play with Watkins or share the load with him
We should keep Archer what does he have to do to get a start with Villa ? I buy into giving him a chance.
QUESTION for Poddymoor next week: Are Villa in for Beier?
Hi guys,
Do we know if there is a sell on clause in place with the Diaby deal?
UTV.
Welsh Villan.
Can't see Felix with his wages. Feels like a massive risk. I also feel like he doesn't want to come here which would comcern me. He's talented but hasn't been impactful at his last 3 clubs
Apparently Felix took a big wage cut to Barca and willing to take paycut in order to play for villa. Hopefully we don't need to spend big on his transfer and salary 😅
Think John might be wrong about Archer and the 4 club trained players for UCL "How many homegrown players are needed in a Champions League squad? Out of the 25, eight places are reserved exclusively for "locally trained players" or homegrown players. Out of the eight, not more than four can be "association-trained players" and the rest must be "club-trained"
I read this as we NEED 4 club trained? So JJ, Bidace, Archer and Kiesler-Hayden?
Spot on mate. Otherwise we have blank spaces in our 25 euro squad.
@@andyvilla4489 yeah would seem silly to only have a 23 man squad when we are allowed 25, with the amount of football we are going to have surely we use the full squad.
@@andyvilla4489 We did that last year though, just didn't fill the places
@@samuelloification2749 but we had to sell them for PSR...this year we sold Luiz and Kellyman. I do think Emery has learned the lesson and knows we need bodies. I see Archer sticking around
Can’t help but think that in the cup win v UCL qualification is an easy one to decide. You lose good players if they want to at least have “something” to show at the end of their career. So at least winning a cup comp resolves that? Look at Kane leaving to at least fill up one spot on his pre made trophy wall (bad example 😊)
Depends on the cup. Would Kane be happy and stay in spurs if he only win carabao cup? 😅
Was hoping for Hause redemption season... but not even in the US squad. Feel sorry for him.
Dont need Felix - too many Countinho vibes. Get a 2nd striker to mold into an Ollie replacement in 3 years... Buendia & Rogers can be the support striker.
Do you not think that Rogers could play the Watkins role?
Rogers can but he is more threatening with his forward run with the ball and he can assist well
Losing Dougie was a loss. I keep an eye on Everton n while I like Onana n Barkley, Dougie made game changing plays. It's a starter loss n back up improvement. Onana is good just n a different way. But with psr we didn't have a choice. We gotta trust Unai n his team. They know what they're doing.
If Duran goes I hope we get an actual striker.
Not just someone who’s plays just behind.. we have enough of those kind of players already.
Still a big worry if Watkins gets injured
Archer?
What's going on with the lack of episodes,other villa podcasts casts are proper kicking you in to touch ? Utv
Quality over quantity
Completely disagree,claret and blue are good,but podcasts like the up the villa and heart of the hole throw loads of content out all of high quality, they are better yet claret and blue are basically Birmingham live ,it should be doing better imo, doesn't mean I don't enjoy it though.utv
What? Lack of episodes? We’ve done 13 TH-cam videos and 16 uploads on podcast platforms with Kendrick’s voicenotes. 16 uploads in 24 days is pretty good going. During the season we can sometimes have an episode every single day 😂
@@ClaretBluePod why be disrespectful with your laughing emoji,I'm aloud an opinion without be laughed at surly, I've been looking for new content for days always seems the other podcasts always have more and I don't see how that's possible tbh,anyway I won't laugh back I'm an adult you see.utv
@@deansimcox1273 Of course you're allowed an opinion, I just find it funny that we're not doing enough and being 'kicked into touch' I find that more disrespectful. We had an episode go out on Monday, Tuesday and today. Not much more we can do. We will not be posting content for the sake of it, and to be honest I'm not at all bothered what the other podcasts do.
Hi guys 💜💙💜
Afternoon Michelle 👋🏻
New CB and SS needed
We 100% need another CB, regardless of mings of Carlos
It's strange how there's no noise around that...we basically have 3 Cbs but about 8 forward players for 3 positions and as things stand 3 strikers for 1 position
hello Dan, can I ask mate how come
you're always ill? (just curious) sorry to hear
Having a child in nursery I’m pretty sure. Never used to be this ill before he was born
Felix will be Coutinho 2.0 that's my prediction, he done absolutely nothing for Chelsea apart from getting sent off in quick time, yes Uni can bring out the best in players but I think we should look elsewhere, Felix is currently training alone which is not a good thing .
Tonsilitis is horrible. Get better soon Dan.
Antibiotics are doing the trick thankfully
i swear Dan is always ill. does he eat enough nutrients?
i'm really not keen on Felix. The risks outweigh the positives for me. Put Ramsey on the wing and put Rogers as attacking midfielder.
Eat enough nutrients? 😂 I think it’s because of having a toddler in nursery. Germ central
@@ClaretBluePod yeah thought more likely the case. been there done that ha.
Seems to have bought back some new germ every time!
Go for Baena
We need a "but" counter for Townley
Duran scored 0.98 goals per 90….. Ollie only 0.5……
Without hesitation, I’d take Beier over Felix. Beier can cover Watkins and play in behind or on the wing. Felix can’t cover for Watkins. Felix has been crap at Chelsea and not played well for a while now - it just isn’t worth the risk for the wages / transfer fee. It could cripple us financially and isn’t worth the gamble in my opinion.
“I will have to play fm in my own time” - how else is it played? If you are getting paid to play fm then you have completed life 😂
Nah I know how this sounds but if I’m sat down to play it/record it, that is ‘work’ and then I’ve got to find time to edit it. So I can’t do that in work hours so I’ll be ‘working’ on my own time. Where I already have very little free time as is
"Selling Kamara" take is absolutely dreadful
Glad I wasn’t alone on that
Champions league over cup 100% massive financial reward 😊
T a
I really hope these links with Felix come to nothing, buying expensive players who clubs want shot of seldom if ever works out well.