can you really consider what she sings in maybe lines?? idk... for me it's not fair that even now she does not get more lines to sing :C I want to hear more from her :C:C:C:C
Miyeon (main vocal): help me Minnie (main vocal): relay Soojin (main dancer): what’s in your house Soyeon (main rapper): light my fire Yuqi (lead dancer): senorita Shuhua (visual): maybe
Ok before people start saying the same old shit here about "why is it up to her??? make some new excuse" "ooh she gets so few lines, poor her", I recommend you using those same fingers to search more about it. She said she doesn't want many lines till she gets confident. Since the debut, Shuhua gets a lot of hate due to her accent, and on live stages she makes little mistakes as well, which only brings even more hate to her. I want you to think and tell me, would you be confident to sing for more than 10s receiving this much of hate?? Just think for a moment.
It seems more like her stans are using that as an excuse. You can't give us Lion & continue to say that it's okay to not give her lines. At this point it's Cube & her fault. Three years of this nonsense, and where's her solo activities to compensate? I see the other members doing stuff, but never her. She's a visual, right? Let's see some modeling promotion. At least then we can use that as an excuse.
I remember in Hann Era when she was heavy criticised by korean netizens for her vocals and lack of "hard work" in the group :/ she was so down bc of them that when they had their win on music shows she always was afraid to do her part :(
@@hyunjinity7424 Well you don't know that. On her last live stage with another 4th gen maknaes, she got a good amount of line and made some mistakes because she was really nervous. We neverlands understand that, but many people started hating on her again. Would you be confident after all that hate?
people throw hate on soyeon along the lines of shuhua and call her ignorant, shuhua doesn't have much confidence and has few lines in title. she has more prominence in bside (you can compare her in the bsides with soyeon, she only has rap and when she doesn't have it, she only has a singing line and only once)
22.28% The Most 7.68% The Least If this is a line distribution of a single song. It isnt even that bad to be honest. 22.28% is Main Vocalist and 7.68% Is a Sub Vocalist. I dont see anything wrong here.
ehhhhh yeah from a purely numbers standpoint but i mean her actual lines are just pathetic, esp put it straight, what's your name, luv u, relay, maze, senorita, latata, hwaa, etc.
@@stushsheyn5319 it makes up the song in harmonies and melodies.... so yeah pretty deeply layered lol. I would gladly listen to her babble in my ears, it don’t matter what she says
I’m glad that she gets one song that she has second, and I know she’s not that confident in her voice, but she is one of the best singers in Idle besides Miyeon, Minnie, and Yuqi. I hope there’s a day where she sings the most in a song.
Shuhua got so few lines!Hopefully she'd get more lines in the future........ Love you Shuhua!!❤️❤️💖💖 Okay so before some triggered people come insulting me,I want to clarify that I *DID NOT* know before that it's Shuhua's own decision to choose her lines,and now that I know it so *PLEASE STOP REPLYING TO ME WITH POINTING OUT MY MISTAKE AND INSULTING ME*and let's support our girls amd their music!🥰❤️💖
@@chuuchuutrain1715 For me,Shuhua deserves more lines and screentime,that's why I just said what I thought. People can have different opinions,no need to point it out at all!
@@stanateez1755all the music show mention the last hwaa part as [shuhua, all] and she literally mouthing it, I know she doesn't sing that line live but just like yuqi "yu Fu fu" line, Yuqi only sing it live before the senorita dancebreak but people still count all yu Fu fu line. Oh and this vid count shuhua Hwaa line in chorus so...
@@satriaherl yep you are right I guess that counts too she does lead the last chorus she is at the Center, scenes of her in the mv, mouthing it in the mv it’s so obvious it’s her
Y’all remember this is shuhua choice she said herself that she isn’t comfortable Ik we all want her to have more lines but she personally doesn’t so please respect that ❤️
People use the same shitty excuse that she’s not yet confident or she doesn’t want lines or she’s still improving but even after 3 YEARS how tf can she “improve” if cube won’t even give her a chance? The line distribution is ridiculous Shuhua slayed in uh-oh and lion she even got a decent amount of lines in OMG but after that what happened? She doesn’t even get 10 seconds in dumdi2 or hwaa(actual lines not including her hwaa~ part). I love them all so much but this is really unfair Soyeon gets most of the lines and most screen time even though she is a sub-vocal like yuqi,soojin and SHUHUA (on average) Miyeon and Minnie are starting up their acting careers, Soojin basically has the largest fanbase, Yuqi has all her promotions and variety shows, what does shuhua get? Most of the (negative)controversies? I know I am biased because it’s obvious she’s my bias, but literally she could be an actress if given the chance she’s good at acting she took classes for it for God’s sake 🙄 and she has, what koreans perceive to be a pretty face. She could have variety shows like yuqi because I don’t know if y’alls noticed, she’s funny af. The way that shuhua is so under promoted/exposed really makes my blood boil. Note: I am in no way trying to blame Soyeon or any of the other members for her unfair treatment I am solely putting the blame on cube
Shuhua is so confident in variety shows but on stage, she kinda kills the vibes because of her blank facial expressions. At least she did good in Hwaa and hopefully she becomes mores confident in stage to the extent she starts getting better lines. There are so many foreign idols in Korea, including Yuqi and Minnie, so her not being confident in her Korean even years after debut just kinda doesn't look good you know...
But it's the truth. She's not confident enough and the hate comments just don't help her. Besides being a fan and really loving her (please nevies don't hate on me for saying this) she lacks stage presence and charisma, and she's not the best dancer in the group as well. Any of these things would give her some positive scores. But yeah in variety shows and v-lives she's great, she shows her charisma and her personality is gold
Unfortunately, not everyone will have affinity with+be good enough at fluency+pronunciation of foreign languages (even after decades of working in the country/industry), and it's not something that can just be completely fixed with practice. We all know that Shuhua is extremely hardworking and diligent when practicing for (G)I-DLE activities or work in general, so I would say it's just her weakness, similar to many others who struggle with spoken language. There are entertainers who ultimately never master the language of their country of work, but nevertheless work well despite those limitations. Shuhua needs to sing, however, so I can understand why she's being cautious regarding her lines, until she can deliver them satisfactorily. She's a perfectionist, after all. As for her expressions+performance, I saw that opinions are equally divided, so it's really up to personal preference.
For the people who are saying it's unfair for her let me explain you many Korean critics her Korean accent yet it Didn't give her enough confident on herself and G-idle are the one's who choose there parts and it's her who choose to not sing that much in the title tracks but when it comes to the b-sides she sings pretty well for her position like a sub vocalist so when she well became more confident we will see her sing more
Deviam dar uma quantidade de linhas melhor para ela, não precisa dar a música inteira para ela, só dividir como dividiram em Lion Lion ela cantou uma quantidade perfeita de linhas
(G)I-DLE has 6 members Fairest line distribution would be 16.6% Anytime someone passes 16.6+% in a line distribution in this group, gets the proof that she's sure not the last in line distribution. Shuhua surpassed this once.
well Shuhua did not train many years in cube ent to just make a video were she says uoh oh oh oh oh and Latatataatata i mean some other mvs she dont even have lines they need to treat Shuhua better i hope now that soojin is gone she gets more lines in the upcoming videos
FAVE MIYEON:TA CHOA NEGE TO NAGA SOE NEGA TO MINNIE:OH MY GOD(AA AW)SHS THREW ME TO GHE SKY SOOJIN:EVERYDAY LATATA SOYEON:SEGI BARE ME FO DURU DURU YUQI:YU FU FU FU SHUHUA:TURN UP MY SUMMER I want Shuhua more lines than 10s
![(G)I-DLE ~ MIYEON Line Evolution [from LATATA to HWAA]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/P4IYDSu--kU/mqdefault.jpg)
![TWICE ~ Who Writes the Most Songs? [from LIKE OOH-AHH to STRATEGY]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YEsQ01YTKhk/mqdefault.jpg)
Miyeon: Help Me
Minnie: Relay
Soojin: What's In Your House
Soyeon: Light My Fire
Yuqi: Señorita
Shuhua: Maybe
Kinda sad because Yuqi line is senorita is yufufufuufufufufufufu lol
@@chuuchuutrain1715 Exactly what I wanted to say...
Yufufufufufufufufu
but shuhua doesn't even have most lines in maybe
@@pototato9938 lmao in Maybe she No.2
Most of her lines is only 10% below I hope she gets line next comeback she really improved
If she was confident enough
She got a lot of lines in the new album Heat!
Shuhua in Lion is forever Iconic 🔥🔥😍😍
Joke of the century: people thought Shuhua had no lines in Maybe and other fandoms started asking for 'justice'😂😂
Ikr 🤣
can you really consider what she sings in maybe lines?? idk... for me it's not fair that even now she does not get more lines to sing :C I want to hear more from her :C:C:C:C
@@TwistedSoul12 it's literal lines it's just the fact that her vocal is like a chameleon so everyone thought that was minnie
@@karinano1stan still dont think those are lines tho, is just like a voice in the back of the chorus
@@TwistedSoul12 lines are lines
her voice is sooo.... different in every song..... whatta duality
Miyeon (main vocal): help me
Minnie (main vocal): relay
Soojin (main dancer): what’s in your house
Soyeon (main rapper): light my fire
Yuqi (lead dancer): senorita
Shuhua (visual): maybe
Shuhua is Sub-Vocalist and Yuqi is Lead Vocalist
Ok before people start saying the same old shit here about "why is it up to her??? make some new excuse" "ooh she gets so few lines, poor her", I recommend you using those same fingers to search more about it. She said she doesn't want many lines till she gets confident. Since the debut, Shuhua gets a lot of hate due to her accent, and on live stages she makes little mistakes as well, which only brings even more hate to her. I want you to think and tell me, would you be confident to sing for more than 10s receiving this much of hate?? Just think for a moment.
It seems more like her stans are using that as an excuse. You can't give us Lion & continue to say that it's okay to not give her lines. At this point it's Cube & her fault. Three years of this nonsense, and where's her solo activities to compensate? I see the other members doing stuff, but never her. She's a visual, right? Let's see some modeling promotion. At least then we can use that as an excuse.
@@ZeriocTheTank i completely agree, she has proven she can handle more than 10% lines. It is indeed Cube to blame for the lack of representation
Good
I remember in Hann Era when she was heavy criticised by korean netizens for her vocals and lack of "hard work" in the group :/ she was so down bc of them that when they had their win on music shows she always was afraid to do her part :(
Of course you used the same excuse after like 3 years of debuting
PLEASE DO EVERGLOW NEXT
Yassss
yesssssssss
I hope she gets more lines next comeback.
It’s up to her if she wants more lines.
@@chuuchuutrain1715 how is it up to her
@@chuuchuutrain1715 tired of this same old excuse 🥱🥱
Why don't you make a new one??
@@btsismyoxyjin2013 because idle does their line distribution
@@farahdeebah7039 g idle does the line distribution for their songs
Shes slowly getting more lines and im so proud of her! Even if she doesnt have too many lines yet seeing the increase makes me so so happy 😊😊😊
Since Shuhua is not confident, his lines are few. Hope this fixes the problem
Her*
maybe at their debut but she is definitely confident now
@@hyunjinity7424 we don’t know tho . idle does the line distribution themselves so when she wants more lines she can get more.
@@hyunjinity7424 Well you don't know that. On her last live stage with another 4th gen maknaes, she got a good amount of line and made some mistakes because she was really nervous. We neverlands understand that, but many people started hating on her again. Would you be confident after all that hate?
@@irenekrissantosalico7937 Sorry. I'm not English
people throw hate on soyeon along the lines of shuhua and call her ignorant, shuhua doesn't have much confidence and has few lines in title. she has more prominence in bside (you can compare her in the bsides with soyeon, she only has rap and when she doesn't have it, she only has a singing line and only once)
Who bias is SHUHUA?
👇
My bias.
Wow SHUHUA song MAYBE
Miyeon: Help me
Minnie: Relay
Soojin: What's in your house
Soyeon: Light my fire
Yuqi: Senorita
Shuhua: Maybe
I LOVE her voice, I hope I can hear her a little more on new songs. Nice video.
22.28% The Most
7.68% The Least
If this is a line distribution of a single song. It isnt even that bad to be honest. 22.28% is Main Vocalist and 7.68% Is a Sub Vocalist. I dont see anything wrong here.
ehhhhh yeah from a purely numbers standpoint but i mean her actual lines are just pathetic, esp put it straight, what's your name, luv u, relay, maze, senorita, latata, hwaa, etc.
It would be understandable if there are 9 or more members, but there are only 6. 7% is a dishonor :/
7,68% are AVERAGE for all songs - her least is in "Put It Straight" - 1,5%😔
i think you can clearly see after hann where the lines dropped for a while then started to increase from uh-oh
2:08 No one:
Maybe: *Wanna see some REAL speed?* 🙃
in help me, the "woh wah" is shuhua and yuqi
Don't she have more in "Help Me"? She sings the "woo aoh" with Yuqi...
Wow deep lyrics
@@stushsheyn5319 it makes up the song in harmonies and melodies.... so yeah pretty deeply layered lol. I would gladly listen to her babble in my ears, it don’t matter what she says
I’m glad that she gets one song that she has second, and I know she’s not that confident in her voice, but she is one of the best singers in Idle besides Miyeon, Minnie, and Yuqi. I hope there’s a day where she sings the most in a song.
Shuhua got so few lines!Hopefully she'd get more lines in the future........
Love you Shuhua!!❤️❤️💖💖
Okay so before some triggered people come insulting me,I want to clarify that I *DID NOT* know before that it's Shuhua's own decision to choose her lines,and now that I know it so *PLEASE STOP REPLYING TO ME WITH POINTING OUT MY MISTAKE AND INSULTING ME*and let's support our girls amd their music!🥰❤️💖
Idle does the line distribution themselves so she is happy with her lines then it’s fine.
she chooses her lines tho so i dont see how its unfair
@@wonhosblink1470 People's opinions can be different,we should respect them instead of pointing them out.
@@chuuchuutrain1715 For me,Shuhua deserves more lines and screentime,that's why I just said what I thought. People can have different opinions,no need to point it out at all!
@@porrnesianparrapio8886 its not an opinion tho, its facts that she chooses her lines so how is it unfair if its *what she wants*
My Bias❤️
Can u do Loona next?
Please make Loona line evolution lol. I want to see the Haseul's one 😂
Shuhua we love you
The fact Hwaa was in the top half and all she said was bureul jipreada is I-
She lead the last hwaa chorus so...
@@satriaherl no lol. mostly chorus of gidle arent sang by someone. same with hann, senorita
@@stanateez1755all the music show mention the last hwaa part as [shuhua, all] and she literally mouthing it, I know she doesn't sing that line live but just like yuqi "yu Fu fu" line, Yuqi only sing it live before the senorita dancebreak but people still count all yu Fu fu line.
Oh and this vid count shuhua Hwaa line in chorus so...
@@satriaherl yep you are right I guess that counts too she does lead the last chorus she is at the Center, scenes of her in the mv, mouthing it in the mv it’s so obvious it’s her
Y’all remember this is shuhua choice she said herself that she isn’t comfortable Ik we all want her to have more lines but she personally doesn’t so please respect that ❤️
Everyone: maximum: 30%/40%
Shuhua:maximum:20%
Yes shuhua
Can you do everglow
YOUR MARKSHEET WHEN YOU ATTENDED THE EXAM AFTER DRINKING 10 GLASSES OF ALCHOHOL BUT STILL SCORED BETTER IN THE VERY END SECTION IN MORNING
my cute bias shuhua ♥
i love you shuhuaaa ♥
Another reason to love I TRUST 💓💓
And remember : Shuhua choose to get less lines 'cause she's not confident in her Korean
so send me link lol to this
People use the same shitty excuse that she’s not yet confident or she doesn’t want lines or she’s still improving but even after 3 YEARS how tf can she “improve” if cube won’t even give her a chance? The line distribution is ridiculous Shuhua slayed in uh-oh and lion she even got a decent amount of lines in OMG but after that what happened? She doesn’t even get 10 seconds in dumdi2 or hwaa(actual lines not including her hwaa~ part). I love them all so much but this is really unfair Soyeon gets most of the lines and most screen time even though she is a sub-vocal like yuqi,soojin and SHUHUA (on average) Miyeon and Minnie are starting up their acting careers, Soojin basically has the largest fanbase, Yuqi has all her promotions and variety shows, what does shuhua get? Most of the (negative)controversies? I know I am biased because it’s obvious she’s my bias, but literally she could be an actress if given the chance she’s good at acting she took classes for it for God’s sake 🙄 and she has, what koreans perceive to be a pretty face. She could have variety shows like yuqi because I don’t know if y’alls noticed, she’s funny af. The way that shuhua is so under promoted/exposed really makes my blood boil.
Note: I am in no way trying to blame Soyeon or any of the other members for her unfair treatment I am solely putting the blame on cube
maybe just flying up that chart at light speed
In "Help Me" she had most line
Yehey earlyyy
Miyeon:Help Me
Minnie:Relay
Soojin:What's In Your House
Soyeon:Light My Fire
Yuqi:Senõrita
Shuhua:Maybe
Omfg I'm crying
Wtf was I made doing with shuhua 😭
The lines for "HANN(Alone in Winter)" and "MOON" are actually Minnie's, I think? Unless there's some performance showing that Shu sang those.
I love Susan so much S2
put it straight the last? she sings the entire three choruses 😀?
Y’all know the rules. Maybe is Shuhua’s song 💕
I think I am first
Shuhua isn't 1st in I am
@@lachainedestrucsnulle1211 He mean he is the first one who watch this video lol.
@@lachainedestrucsnulle1211 lmao
@@oknumberone8301 😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@oknumberone8301 ah bruh lol
Miyeon 19.42 Minnie 22.28 Soojin 17.67 Soyeon 19.89 Yuqi 13.06 Shuhua 7.68
No one:
Literally No one:
Maybe: Hello there, I arrived!!
Shuhua is so confident in variety shows but on stage, she kinda kills the vibes because of her blank facial expressions. At least she did good in Hwaa and hopefully she becomes mores confident in stage to the extent she starts getting better lines. There are so many foreign idols in Korea, including Yuqi and Minnie, so her not being confident in her Korean even years after debut just kinda doesn't look good you know...
But it's the truth. She's not confident enough and the hate comments just don't help her. Besides being a fan and really loving her (please nevies don't hate on me for saying this) she lacks stage presence and charisma, and she's not the best dancer in the group as well. Any of these things would give her some positive scores. But yeah in variety shows and v-lives she's great, she shows her charisma and her personality is gold
Her cold/blank face is her role in the group that's her stage presence stop trying to make shuhua a clon of other member in the stage.
Unfortunately, not everyone will have affinity with+be good enough at fluency+pronunciation of foreign languages (even after decades of working in the country/industry), and it's not something that can just be completely fixed with practice. We all know that Shuhua is extremely hardworking and diligent when practicing for (G)I-DLE activities or work in general, so I would say it's just her weakness, similar to many others who struggle with spoken language. There are entertainers who ultimately never master the language of their country of work, but nevertheless work well despite those limitations. Shuhua needs to sing, however, so I can understand why she's being cautious regarding her lines, until she can deliver them satisfactorily. She's a perfectionist, after all.
As for her expressions+performance, I saw that opinions are equally divided, so it's really up to personal preference.
she should have twice that amount, but this is her choice
i trust era shuhua was the best
Please dreamcatcher no next
Up
Up
Up
For the people who are saying it's unfair for her let me explain you many Korean critics her Korean accent yet it Didn't give her enough confident on herself and G-idle are the one's who choose there parts and it's her who choose to not sing that much in the title tracks but when it comes to the b-sides she sings pretty well for her position like a sub vocalist so when she well became more confident we will see her sing more
Yes, this.
can u made for stray kids too pls
Deviam dar uma quantidade de linhas melhor para ela, não precisa dar a música inteira para ela, só dividir como dividiram em Lion
Lion ela cantou uma quantidade perfeita de linhas
DREAMCATCHER?
Up
Up
Up
you cut a lot of her lines
Next Stray kids
Maybe: *clear look of superiority*
Do Iz*one pls
Maybe💖
My biasss
She got 11% in dahlia not 6%, yet you still didn't correct it
Maybe is just faster than the lion😂😭
DREAMCATCHER 👁👄👁
Up
Up
Up
Next
RED VELVET
GFRIEND
OH MY GIRL
IZ*ONE
EVERGLOW
I TRUST SUPREMACY
Only one song higher than average
(G)I-DLE has 6 members
Fairest line distribution would be 16.6%
Anytime someone passes 16.6+% in a line distribution in this group, gets the proof that she's sure not the last in line distribution.
Shuhua surpassed this once.
I guess everything about 10% is good for her
well Shuhua did not train many years in cube ent to just make a video were she says uoh oh oh oh oh and Latatataatata i mean some other mvs she dont even have lines they need to treat Shuhua better i hope now that soojin is gone she gets more lines in the upcoming videos
Pls dreamcatcher 💕
Up
DREAMCATCHER please
Up
Up
Up
FAVE
MIYEON:TA CHOA NEGE TO NAGA SOE NEGA TO
MINNIE:OH MY GOD(AA AW)SHS THREW ME TO GHE SKY
SOOJIN:EVERYDAY LATATA
SOYEON:SEGI BARE ME FO DURU DURU
YUQI:YU FU FU FU
SHUHUA:TURN UP MY SUMMER
I want Shuhua more lines than 10s
Next LOONA
shuhua canta tao pouco que nunca consigo dferenciar a voz dela
This is criminal
HWAA 4s ???
4%
DREAMCATCHER PLIS
Up
Up
Up
DREAMCATCHER
Up
Up
Up
wtf i have never seen %1 before
Please give Taiwan girl---------- Shuhua-------------- more lyrics !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
From Taiwanese
Her average is 7%.
7 * 6 = 42%
That’s not even half
She only gets a little lines. She needs more lines....
Cube : sing your line
Shuhua : (breath)....
Cube : oh good. OK next
Gidle are my biais but they have one of bad distribution in group.
The gap between 1st and 5th is not big
I'm neverland
1%
Please everglow
DREAMCATCHER
Up
Up
Up
DREAMCATCHER
Up
Up
Up
DREAMCATCHER
Up
Up
Up
DREAMCATCHER
Up
Up
Up