Song is written and composed by Hyunsik. Not sure about a meaning prior but recently Eunkwang (later this month) and Minhyuk (next month) revealed that they will be leaving on their military enlistment. So to Melody (BTOB fans) the lyrics mean something different than perhaps intended before the news. Or they could have known all along and Hyunsik wrote them with that in mind. At least to me. BTW I was told that note was Sungjae, the youngest member. He's the one with the bread lol
the song has been written way, way back. Maybe 2015. i doubt it has any meaning specifically pertaining to enlistment but Hyunsik said everyone, from groupmates, to managers to CUBE higher-ups liked the song. that's why they kept it. :-) it's worth the wait though!
Agnes Lee EDIT: I went and rewatched lol I actually did think it was Eunkwang. The second one you mentioned is the one I was told was Sungjae that I didnt recognize
Eunkwang is 90% of the time doing the crazy high notes/head voice, other than their upcoming concert this is Eunkwang’s last activity before he goes to the military
At around 3:11 thats Eunkwang falsetto. At around 4:34 that's Sungjae's octave where changsub over lap then Eunkwang comes to overlap that part as well.
You're right, BTOB-BLUE is the vocal subunit! They've recorded and performed as a unit a few times, including on Immortal Songs 2, and typically sing ballads. And this song, no surprise, was written by Hyunsik! The man is a wealth of musical genius, seriously.
That first highnote belongs to Eunkwang while the second one, that dolphin like note is Sungjae. There's a lot of fancam vids during their recent concert, if you have time you could check it out. 😂
This comeback is kind of a goodbye gift from eunkwang as he is enlisting in a few days, it means a lot to me as a long time melody and I really hope you'll enjoy the song and continue btob even when the members start enlisting.
I really thought that you'll never react to thus video...so bless you PD!! You're right the leader is Eunkwang. Its great that your a BTOB fan now. And you should watch BTOB BLUE debut song....'Stand By Me'. This song is great but l love stand by me more than this song. And BTOB vocal line is undeniably one of the best vocal I've ever heard in kpop.
Thank you for reacting to our boys 💙. I can understand why you did laugh when ( Eunkwang and Changsub ) scene came out bcz we ( melody ) did laugh too in the midst of our feeling of being affected by their passionate and sensuous voices ㅋㅋ. As you said, BtoB Blue is the vocal line unit. BtoB as usual, always impress me with their voices, taste of music. Also, they are so hilarious that they really can make you laugh whenever you feel sad and always positive .. aaah sorry I wrote a lot but thank u again ~
BTOB BLUE is a vocal sub-unit. When it rains was written by hyunsik 3 years ago but they only recently release this. That crazy high note (dolphin sound hahaha) is sungjae.
I totally didn't shriek when I got the notification that this was uploaded. I had the EXACT same reaction when Changsub came in at the chorus. ♡ YAAAAAS the high notes and the harmonies are what drew me into BTOB a few years ago.
Thank you for your reaction.... And yes i agree that btob vocal line has gilden vocals and to think that my bias sungjae also went out of his comfortzone and did an amazing high notes is just 😍
thank you for reacting ^^ glad you react to them, and glad you enjoyed it. yup btob blue is their sub unit group for their vocal line. beside this song they have release another song "Stand By Me", yes it is another ballad song. and Peniel co-direct the MV too if you want to check their japanesse songs, for ballad i recommend L.U.V, their live version much.. much.. better than the MV. but you can check it both ^^
the high note you pointed out at 3:12 is eunkwang. the especially high note at 4:40 is sungjae. the music video is pretty boring lol even tho im an avid mello i have to admit they tend to have considerably uneventful and emotionally-driven music videos, like in its okay, missing you, and the two btob blue songs. btob blue is the vocal unit. i know u really dig btobs rap unit so i was expecting u to be particularly disappointed but im glad you gave this a chance!!
This will be my first time leaving a comment to any reaction videos of BTOB. THANK YOU SO MUCH PD! For being a fan of our Boys. 💙 Please do feel free to call yourself a MELODUDE 💙
I LOVE THEM SOOO MUCH!!! and THIS SONG TOOOO! yes they are so hilarious and their team spirit is one of the BEST!!!!! and yes BTOB BLUE is to show off their vocals because they are treasures❤️
I also don’t like korean songs at first. I tried but I cannot force myself to love even if I listen to it multiple times (famous girl/boy groups). But I accidentally came across one of btob and i fell in love!! No joke, i love 2nd confession even on the first few notes! It lit up my spirit and wanted to be in love something like that feeling! And explored their music and deeply appreciated Korean music now 💙
Same here. I dnt watch any kgrp cz of their hiphp dnce & songs bt whn i strtd to watch ths grp, i startd to love their songs, their mmbrs and their funny moments and brotherhood. I bcame addictd to their songs until i end up searching all their videos and their songs in spotify.
Love your very objective and truthful reaction. Thank you so much!! Yes BTOB BLUE is BTOB's Vocal Line. 💙💙💙💙 their alternate name is BTOB BLEB 😂 their debut song was Stand By Me back in 2016. You dont need to do a reaction video for it. Just watch it. :) i think you might enjoy the MV more because it has no sappy story line.. its just them singing. ^D^) (*coughs* wishing BTOB RED debuts *coughs* RAP LINE *coughs*)
yes, PD! BTOB blue is BTOB vocal line. They debuted last September 2016, they made their first comeback with this song. Thank you for your postive comments. please love btob more 💙
I'm happy to know that I'm not the only person who laugh at eunkwang and changsub's scene😂 and let me tell you something. there's a new genre of ballad, there is BTOB!💙 I love to see your expressions everytime you hear BTOB's voice. You are a melody, PD-nim ㅎㅎ
Okie he is a certified melodude 🤣 Welcome to the family This song means a lot to Melody who send the first memeber to serve the nation The rains are just like Btob and melodies tears for that month When the first announcement came out. Thanks pd for reviewing.
You seemed so relaxed and i laughed so many times during this.. what a nice video 👏 and i totally get what u said abt the mv, kinda just meh. Won't re-watch, but definitely re-listen a hundred times
Well that part IS pretty hilarious because Eunkwang WAS trying to look serious and that’s why Changsub look at him weirdly and look out the window with questions BTOB styled ballad video p.s. Sungjae so sweet give his hyung a normal picture
For some reason I think this is the funnniest Video of him...like what is his mood ? xD He is kinda funny and crazy, yet super cute...I want to see him more often like this ^^
I git so happy when you started your video with a line from only one for me. Hihihi part of ilhoon's line. Anyway, yes btob-blue is a sub unit composed ob btob vocals. You might get confused if someone will write it as BTOB-BLEB hahaha it is because when they spelled "blue" (one letter per member), they mispelled it as BLEB hehehe
Eunkwang is the one who always nailed a high note. Yeah theres a deeper meaning about the songs, ( Seo Eunkwang is inlist in military). BtoB blues represent all the vocalist. ❤
I would just Choke to death with those High notes and Those High plus Low keys . That's Actually one And Only reason Why many Idols Don't Cover their Songs. They produce the Hardest songs In the Entire K-pop Industry. They are the King of that. No need Any Argument. Many will agree. Well Thanks for Reacting This.😇😇
I have the same reaction with you when changsubie approach Eunkwang hyung in that window scene. Like what? I’m expecting this to be sad but why I’m smiling right now? Lol. 😅 well that’s our btob, makes everything serious turns to comedy scene. 😂💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
I know its late but loving that pink hair PDNim. TBH i though i love When it Rains, their first official single as BTOB BLUE which is STAND BY ME is seriously me fave. Hope u can also react to it. Suju and BTOB are the craziest groups ever and yes. You're right his name is Eunkwang.
The mv i guess was simple cuz eunkwang is going to military in three days and they had to use their last days tô promote before the concert.. everything was so sudden.. but yes btob blue is the vocal line... the story behind is just simple jokes like the maknae is the boss... the waiter is the leader.. hyunsik is perfeccionist and i guess that he was making the food to show that this Song is actually written and composed by him... changsub is changsub the beautysleep in every day normal.. also addicted to coffee indeed.. oh.. eunkwang actually owns a coffee shop with his brother in korea so that's another joke about being the waiter... but as i Said.. they released the song 2 weeks before he enlisting to military and it's beautiful
everytime i hear someone is enlisting, seo in guk - bebe comes into my mind 😂😂 he also dropped it before he went to military and i didnt know he came from singing casting show
BtoB-Blue is the vocal unit, I don't know if that is legit but I got to know them as the "Ballad-Unit" because they mostly do ballads. To be honest I liked Stand By Me more than When It Rains. I am very picky about ballads because as you said, they often sound the same. But I love the ballads of BtoB Blue, especially Stand By Me. I think it's their voices and just the atmosphere in general. Idk, I just love it ^-^
us and you you and we BTOB and Melody sorry I think I said that a bit weird, I was wondering whether the „Ballad-Unit“ part is legit 🙈 sorry for the misunderstanding
I can distinguish between a honest reaction and a fake reaction, and I LOVE how you're always honest about how you feel towards something, and you're always said a meaningful comment, not just any comment that will pleased so your audience And I remember you said you like Ravi, have you check his solo work BOMB?
BTOB Blue they have the best vocals in kpop and thats A FACT
Can't argue with that. BTOB have the best vocal line ever.
Even their rap line is so so good💙
Some kpop groups i find cringe rap line >.< and unnecessary in some songs..but not in btob
Song is written and composed by Hyunsik. Not sure about a meaning prior but recently Eunkwang (later this month) and Minhyuk (next month) revealed that they will be leaving on their military enlistment. So to Melody (BTOB fans) the lyrics mean something different than perhaps intended before the news. Or they could have known all along and Hyunsik wrote them with that in mind. At least to me. BTW I was told that note was Sungjae, the youngest member. He's the one with the bread lol
Mind Of Mando Hey bro I just watch your 2ne1 reaction XD
the song has been written way, way back. Maybe 2015. i doubt it has any meaning specifically pertaining to enlistment but Hyunsik said everyone, from groupmates, to managers to CUBE higher-ups liked the song. that's why they kept it. :-) it's worth the wait though!
The song was produced at song camp with Killing Me (b-side from remember that) in 2015
Agnes Lee EDIT: I went and rewatched lol I actually did think it was Eunkwang. The second one you mentioned is the one I was told was Sungjae that I didnt recognize
aisyah gotcha gotcha 👌🏽
Eunkwang is 90% of the time doing the crazy high notes/head voice, other than their upcoming concert this is Eunkwang’s last activity before he goes to the military
WellDressedGypsy
when does he enlist?
losersayshi August 21st!
WellDressedGypsy I’m still crying
actually in this song it was Sungjae who sang the high notes. He told us in vlive almost 2 weeks ago
At around 3:11 thats Eunkwang falsetto. At around 4:34 that's Sungjae's octave where changsub over lap then Eunkwang comes to overlap that part as well.
You're right, BTOB-BLUE is the vocal subunit! They've recorded and performed as a unit a few times, including on Immortal Songs 2, and typically sing ballads. And this song, no surprise, was written by Hyunsik! The man is a wealth of musical genius, seriously.
That first highnote belongs to Eunkwang while the second one, that dolphin like note is Sungjae. There's a lot of fancam vids during their recent concert, if you have time you could check it out. 😂
Btw Sungjae and Peniel hyped the arena with Hypnotized that day, you should watch it Pd-nim 💙
Wait holy crap that second one was Sungjae?? I need to go watch some live performance vids lol
Sabs yes its him, our baby Sungjae. 💙💙💙
Sabs yes yes its him, the forever maknae hahahaha 💙💙
Liked already when you said that you are a huge BTOB fan.
This comeback is kind of a goodbye gift from eunkwang as he is enlisting in a few days, it means a lot to me as a long time melody and I really hope you'll enjoy the song and continue btob even when the members start enlisting.
I really thought that you'll never react to thus video...so bless you PD!! You're right the leader is Eunkwang.
Its great that your a BTOB fan now. And you should watch BTOB BLUE debut song....'Stand By Me'. This song is great but l love stand by me more than this song. And BTOB vocal line is undeniably one of the best vocal I've ever heard in kpop.
Ya. Agreed with bryama, do check the previous debut song for BTOB-Blue.
bryama 212 agree with you
PD: 3:12 who tf was that high note?
me: wait until the dolphin.
Milky Tea sadly he didnt notice the dolphin near the end. Hahaha or he did but didnt get to react to it much. ^D^
Yeah im waiting for his reaction too but nahhhh tsk
Thank you for reacting to our boys 💙. I can understand why you did laugh when ( Eunkwang and Changsub ) scene came out bcz we ( melody ) did laugh too in the midst of our feeling of being affected by their passionate and sensuous voices ㅋㅋ. As you said, BtoB Blue is the vocal line unit. BtoB as usual, always impress me with their voices, taste of music. Also, they are so hilarious that they really can make you laugh whenever you feel sad and always positive .. aaah sorry I wrote a lot but thank u again ~
Suddenly jumping into Ilhoon's rap on OOFM. Omg PD you're just like me, you've become a Melody...
BTOB BLUE is a vocal sub-unit. When it rains was written by hyunsik 3 years ago but they only recently release this.
That crazy high note (dolphin sound hahaha) is sungjae.
this was Eunkwangs last song before he enlists in the army which is this month
Xyn's Lounge 😭😭
Kkkk, don't worry, they said even the staff started to laugh just by looking at them, they truly are the funniest group xD
"This boy group is hilarious" lol BTOB really 😂
6:49! Exactly! Btob never dissapoints!!!
The crazy high note at the end was Yook Sungjae, the maknae!
Thank you for your reaction! Eunkwang is enlisting soon so we will miss him dearly. Thanks for supporting BTOB!!!!!
I totally didn't shriek when I got the notification that this was uploaded.
I had the EXACT same reaction when Changsub came in at the chorus. ♡ YAAAAAS the high notes and the harmonies are what drew me into BTOB a few years ago.
Thank you for your reaction.... And yes i agree that btob vocal line has gilden vocals and to think that my bias sungjae also went out of his comfortzone and did an amazing high notes is just 😍
thank you for reacting ^^
glad you react to them, and glad you enjoyed it. yup btob blue is their sub unit group for their vocal line. beside this song they have release another song "Stand By Me", yes it is another ballad song. and Peniel co-direct the MV too
if you want to check their japanesse songs, for ballad i recommend L.U.V, their live version much.. much.. better than the MV. but you can check it both ^^
I was surprised you reacted to a ballad! Anyway thank you PD!
Yeah they’re one of the most hilarious group ever lol
best vocal line in k-pop
Hi thanks for an honest reaction and analysis. I hope you can do more reactions of btob in the future.😍
Yeah BTOB Blue is the vocal lines sub unit and the person that did those crazy high note in this song is eunkwang the leader :)
İ love your BTOB reactionss..
the high note you pointed out at 3:12 is eunkwang. the especially high note at 4:40 is sungjae.
the music video is pretty boring lol even tho im an avid mello i have to admit they tend to have considerably uneventful and emotionally-driven music videos, like in its okay, missing you, and the two btob blue songs.
btob blue is the vocal unit. i know u really dig btobs rap unit so i was expecting u to be particularly disappointed but im glad you gave this a chance!!
I mean didn’t we ALL laugh 😂😂
This will be my first time leaving a comment to any reaction videos of BTOB. THANK YOU SO MUCH PD! For being a fan of our Boys. 💙 Please do feel free to call yourself a MELODUDE 💙
That one person with crazy high note in second chorus is Eunkwang, the leader of BTOB. 💙 and thank you for reacting this mv.
React to BTOB Blue- Stand by me
My favorite!💙
Ah i'm glad Btob has increasing love nowadays
I've been waiting for yoir reaction ti thus song. Finally.
Same! I was almost crying during the MV, but Eunkwang made me laugh in the end! You’re being a fan now! 😂😂😂
I love your btob's reaction 😍
he keeps pronouncing btob blue wrong it is btob bleb!! this is a reference dont @ me
Omg 🤣🤣🤣
"B-L-E-B BTOB BLUE IMIDAAAA" 😂😂
I LOVE THEM SOOO MUCH!!! and THIS SONG TOOOO! yes they are so hilarious and their team spirit is one of the BEST!!!!! and yes BTOB BLUE is to show off their vocals because they are treasures❤️
13 nov 2022.. comes here couse i missing BTOB Blue n i feel the same beautiful just like the first i hear BTOB
Thanks for the reaction bro
I am even happier when you appreciated their sense of humour.
I'm really happy seeing non-melody reacting like this on Btob's song!!! Keep it up!! They are the best vocalists korea ever have!!!
i love BTOB! !!!
Btob are the kings of melody ❤️
I also don’t like korean songs at first. I tried but I cannot force myself to love even if I listen to it multiple times (famous girl/boy groups). But I accidentally came across one of btob and i fell in love!! No joke, i love 2nd confession even on the first few notes! It lit up my spirit and wanted to be in love something like that feeling! And explored their music and deeply appreciated Korean music now 💙
Same here. I dnt watch any kgrp cz of their hiphp dnce & songs bt whn i strtd to watch ths grp, i startd to love their songs, their mmbrs and their funny moments and brotherhood. I bcame addictd to their songs until i end up searching all their videos and their songs in spotify.
Btob spectacular and fabulous group
Yess changsub’s voice is my fav’s voice too TT
Love your very objective and truthful reaction. Thank you so much!!
Yes BTOB BLUE is BTOB's Vocal Line. 💙💙💙💙 their alternate name is BTOB BLEB 😂 their debut song was Stand By Me back in 2016. You dont need to do a reaction video for it. Just watch it. :) i think you might enjoy the MV more because it has no sappy story line.. its just them singing. ^D^)
(*coughs* wishing BTOB RED debuts *coughs* RAP LINE *coughs*)
yes, PD! BTOB blue is BTOB vocal line. They debuted last September 2016, they made their first comeback with this song. Thank you for your postive comments. please love btob more 💙
내가 영어만 잘했더라도....
무튼 좋은 말씀이신 것 같으니 감사합니당💙
Yes!!!! I was hoping you’d react to this!!!
I'm happy to know that I'm not the only person who laugh at eunkwang and changsub's scene😂 and let me tell you something. there's a new genre of ballad, there is BTOB!💙 I love to see your expressions everytime you hear BTOB's voice. You are a melody, PD-nim ㅎㅎ
BTOB is great!
Oh don't worry Iam a Melody and I laugh too cuz we just not used to see his serious expression.
It's because eunkwang enlistment that's why sub unit comeback just after group comeback.
It's okay. Almost all of us laughed at the last part. Hahaha
Melody here!!! I def laughed too when eunkwang was just staring at out the window lmao
thanks for ur react to btob blue ... 🙆
theyre going to go to the army later.. im happy they choose this and sad.
Thank you for loving BTOB ❤❤❤
Okie he is a certified melodude 🤣
Welcome to the family
This song means a lot to Melody who send the first memeber to serve the nation
The rains are just like Btob and melodies tears for that month
When the first announcement came out.
Thanks pd for reviewing.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR REACTION!!! ❤❤
0:50 is such a mood!!! I've done the same thing for Ilhoon's rap for OOFM so many times HAHAHA
"It's that sad sht already. Fck" I cracked 😂
Thank you for react btob 💙💙💙💙
thanks for your reaction!! And I want you to notice this song was picked by bilboard usa to attention!!!
Thanks to watch and listen this song
may de that high voice is Eunkwang.
Thank you so much
As far as I know, that second high note is Sungjae's.
Yesss! BTOB blue is vocal line ^^ and i also laugh at Eunkwang and Changsub scene hahaha.
You seemed so relaxed and i laughed so many times during this.. what a nice video 👏 and i totally get what u said abt the mv, kinda just meh. Won't re-watch, but definitely re-listen a hundred times
New song release out now ...need to see you reaction to btob😁
Well that part IS pretty hilarious because Eunkwang WAS trying to look serious
and that’s why Changsub look at him weirdly and look out the window with questions
BTOB styled ballad video
p.s. Sungjae so sweet give his hyung a normal picture
that high note before 2nd chorus was eunkwang.
You NEED to watch other BtoB-blue song, stand by me, and they have a few covers on inmortal song and that's aaaaaaaaawesome
Thanks for doing this.
For some reason I think this is the funnniest Video of him...like what is his mood ? xD
He is kinda funny and crazy, yet super cute...I want to see him more often like this ^^
you should watch BTOB BLUE debut song 'Stand by me'
I git so happy when you started your video with a line from only one for me. Hihihi part of ilhoon's line. Anyway, yes btob-blue is a sub unit composed ob btob vocals. You might get confused if someone will write it as BTOB-BLEB hahaha it is because when they spelled "blue" (one letter per member), they mispelled it as BLEB hehehe
Eunkwang is the one who always nailed a high note. Yeah theres a deeper meaning about the songs, ( Seo Eunkwang is inlist in military). BtoB blues represent all the vocalist. ❤
I would just Choke to death with those High notes and Those High plus Low keys . That's Actually one And Only reason Why many Idols Don't Cover their Songs. They produce the Hardest songs In the Entire K-pop Industry. They are the King of that. No need Any Argument. Many will agree.
Well Thanks for Reacting This.😇😇
I have the same reaction with you when changsubie approach Eunkwang hyung in that window scene. Like what? I’m expecting this to be sad but why I’m smiling right now? Lol. 😅 well that’s our btob, makes everything serious turns to comedy scene. 😂💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
Please react to (G)I-dle's Comeback HANN!!
This was a really great release from them before Eunkwang leaves for enlistment.
Live stage has come out ...if can explain agian as well..
I was waiting for that
BTOB BLUE is the vocal line yes :)
Hope you will react BTOB This is us concert(Someday,I'll be your man, Blue moon)& sungjae & penial duet song too.
I know its late but loving that pink hair PDNim. TBH i though i love When it Rains, their first official single as BTOB BLUE which is STAND BY ME is seriously me fave. Hope u can also react to it. Suju and BTOB are the craziest groups ever and yes. You're right his name is Eunkwang.
I really love this song.
this song is very beautiful 😢
Listen to Icebreaker it's a song by the rap line of BtoB
Try watching btob luv. It’s their japanese song but 👌🏽
The mv i guess was simple cuz eunkwang is going to military in three days and they had to use their last days tô promote before the concert.. everything was so sudden.. but yes btob blue is the vocal line... the story behind is just simple jokes like the maknae is the boss... the waiter is the leader.. hyunsik is perfeccionist and i guess that he was making the food to show that this Song is actually written and composed by him... changsub is changsub the beautysleep in every day normal.. also addicted to coffee indeed.. oh.. eunkwang actually owns a coffee shop with his brother in korea so that's another joke about being the waiter... but as i Said.. they released the song 2 weeks before he enlisting to military and it's beautiful
everytime i hear someone is enlisting, seo in guk - bebe comes into my mind 😂😂 he also dropped it before he went to military and i didnt know he came from singing casting show
YOU DID IT KING YOU REACTED TO IT
Love the song , btw those subtitles are killing me 😂
BtoB-Blue is the vocal unit, I don't know if that is legit but I got to know them as the "Ballad-Unit" because they mostly do ballads. To be honest I liked Stand By Me more than When It Rains. I am very picky about ballads because as you said, they often sound the same. But I love the ballads of BtoB Blue, especially Stand By Me. I think it's their voices and just the atmosphere in general. Idk, I just love it ^-^
Aqua Chan yes, its legit that BTOB BLUE is a sub unit of BTOB's vocal line..
us and you you and we BTOB and Melody sorry I think I said that a bit weird, I was wondering whether the „Ballad-Unit“ part is legit 🙈 sorry for the misunderstanding
Aqua Chan owh i see. Thats fine, don't be sorry.. 😇😇💙💙💙
Ps. For those still trying to uncover who did the dolphin high note in 4.40 and didnt see the recent concert, it was Sungjae. 😂
OOooHH BTOB
I can distinguish between a honest reaction and a fake reaction, and I LOVE how you're always honest about how you feel towards something, and you're always said a meaningful comment, not just any comment that will pleased so your audience
And I remember you said you like Ravi, have you check his solo work BOMB?