ghamdi sb ki interpretations bahut strong hoti he. un ka observation bhi bahut strong he. we can dis agree with him but he has resolved hundreds of muslim confusions with relevance to quraano sunnah. to me he is best among available scholars. he is an asset of this ummah.
The guy is confused and biased , he is likely to support mysticism, while Ghamdi rejects mysticism in the light of the Quran and Sunnah. Ghamdi requires to be studied and assimilated holistically NOT superficially by going through his collected works .
اعجاز صاحب کا غامدی صاحب پر تاثر ، جسے شدت تاثر کہنا شاید زیادہ موزوں ہے ، سن کر فیض کا شعر بے اختیار یاد آ گیا : وہ بات سارےفسانے میں جس کا ذکر نہ تھا وہ بات ان کو بہت ناگوار گزری ہے
اہل علم خود فیصلہ فرمائیں صاحب نے کتنی مدلل گفتگو فرمائی ہے میں ایک ناقص رائے کی جسارت کرونگا اولاًجب ایک عالم یا کسی بھی شعبے سے تعلق رکھنے والا ہو اس شخص کے زیب نہیں دیتا کہ وہ ذات پر تنقید تنقیص یا تحکیر کرے اگر کسی سے شخص سے کسی بھی معاملے پر اختلاف ہو تو دلائل کی روشنی میں استدلال کے ساتھ عقائد و نظریات و فکر پر گھنٹوں گفتگو کرے ٫لکھے۔لوگوں کو مخالف خریف کی غلط بات یا رائے سے باور کرائے دین کا اصل اصول یہی تقاضا کرتاہے جہاں تک ان صاحب نے گفتگو فرمائی تو مجھے لگتا کسی معاملے پرگفتگوفرمارہےہیں بار بار سوال کرنے کے باوجود اپنی بات کو واضع نہیں فرما سکے معذرت
Very disappointed with his response. No example of any objection. Just based on common disagreement of many laymen he said Ghamidi studies a lot but is not right. I wanted to see some criticism on Ghamidi sb but in my view he praised Ghamidi sb instead of establishing any fact against him. When Ghamidi sb himself says a different opinion than what majority believes then definitely majority will not like or agree with it. Now what's the point in saying that I and my friends didn't like what Ghamidi said. Is this the way of commenting on such issues? Really disappointed. Ghamidi sb this man in fact defended you with his unprepared and lame points.
Aap nay Kaha unhon nay koi baat ghalat kahee, jis ko aap Kay mushtariq dost nay bhi ghalat Kaha, lekin aap nay audience say Woh baat share Nahin ki. Mujhay naahin maloom keh konsee baat ko ghalat interpret Kia Ghamidi sahib nay. I would suggest, you should speak the whole talk.
Alqa, Ilham, and other imaginary methods to get guidence directly from God are not possible after the last prophet Muhammad (peace be up on him). These claims have misguided a huge number of muslim community. Quran alway invites His audience to use reason and wisdom. All sahaba never claimed Ilham or kashf or any other means like this to find guidence on religion. Wasif ali wasif and other sufi's like him are poking a hole in the finality of the prophethood of Muhammad (peace be upon him) by claiming that God talks to them.
معذرت کے ساتھ کہنا پڑ رہا ہے کہ ان صاحب کو ماہر نفسیات کی ضرورت ہے۔ اور یہ بھی ممکن ہے کہ میری عقلی صلاحیت اتنی محدود ہے کہ ان کے اقوال زریں کو سمجھنے کے لئے کسی اور سے عقل ادھار لینی پڑے گی
What are you talking about? You think by talking in what sounds intellectual reasoning will make people agree with you. You talked no sense, gave no answers and no logicl reasoning. Sounds like a bitter man. Get over yourself.
O bhai Shukar hy jo taray m aqal hy tu Ghamdi sahh se disagree krta hy, tera unse agree krna banta hi ni, yeh Ghamdi sahb ki aik bartari hy k us k followers m koi jahil ni, bahot ziada parhay likhay log hain
Ghamdi sahb ne ye bt thk nhi ki. Ye apki apni smjh h ye koi daleel nhi h. Ghamdi sahb bat ko uljhate nhi hn 7.39 minute me apni ap kuch nhi bol pye ghamdi itna time.me daleel ki line lga dete..
How would you know that , this interpretation is by God , and this is by human ,! Such irrelevant, incoherent and baseless talk .... What is tje " mushidaaa" of knowledge ???
Ohh chacha baatein ghuma rahe ho. Logical baat kyo nahi kar rahe? Ghamidi saheb se aap ittefaq nahi rakhte to wo kya baatein hain unme jo fasaad feel ho rahi hai aapko? Ya fir in other words aap religious based politics publicity par focus kar rahe hain...? Kisi se sunkar kuch kehna ya bolna baat alag hai aapne unki books se kya observe kiya? Wo clear kijiye..
Allah TA says in Quran " Laqad Yessernal Quran lilzikre" Indeed Quraan is easy to understand....OR ye janab Kah rahe Aqal nahi samjh Sakta...Ghamdi ne apna samjha hai aap apna smjho...per khud padho to Shahi...
jo ilm insaan ki aqal pe nhi utarta woh insaan ke lie kese hoo sakta ha? Ilhami qalaam poori tarha insaan ki aqal per hi utarta ha. aur utarta haa tub hi to phir insaan ussay qabool kerta ha...
This person does not have any clue what he is talking about. Either he is lying or he never had listen to Ghamidi. Ghamidi does not mix up religion with society.
How to talk for 7 mins and not say anything!! If you are going to claim to differ with someone at least have the courtesy to read one book of theirs. Very disappointing!
"دنیا میں اس سےبڑی کوئی ذلالت نہیں کہ انسان ایسے موضوع پر گفتگو کرے جسکا علم نہیں رکھتا"
-سقراط
He himself is short if knowledge
Actual point of objection keya hay aspka ghami sb se
GHAMDI SAHAB MEETHI BATEN KER KE MIRZAAIYON KO PROMOTE KER RAHE HAIN. USS SE AAP LOG BACH KE RAHEN. USS KE DAJJUL AUR FAREB SE.
💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚
Sir ap confused nazar arahy Han or mujy ap ke bataien logical Nahi lag rahi
yes you are right
Extremely illogical answer.he never explained any objection whatsoever.kindly tell me your objection please?
ھم غامدی صاحب سے اتفاق کرتے ہیں
This man is not clear. He contradicts to him self
tell me Mr what is your Islamic line.
اس سے زیادہ غیر علمی گفتگو میں نے کبھی نہیں سنی.
100% Agree
بالکل ٹھیک کہا آپ نے
100% true
He couldn't give a specific point or could explain anything.
AASMAAN PER THOOKNEY SEY APNEY MOON PER HI AATII HAI SIRR
ALLAH WUSAAT E ZARF ATAA FARMAEY AMEEEN
Kindly explain with examples !!!
Kehna kia chahtay hain uncle ????
Criticism is good but please review Ghamdi sahib first before giving any statement.
ghamdi sb ki interpretations bahut strong hoti he. un ka observation bhi bahut strong he. we can dis agree with him but he has resolved hundreds of muslim confusions with relevance to quraano sunnah. to me he is best among available scholars. he is an asset of this ummah.
Ghamidi is need of our time.
Apko sun ky lgta h apne Ghamdi Shb Sb ko nhi Sunna...
Ghamidi is our proud. Simply he is logical man
Ye to batai wo ghalat kahan hai ,kaunsa interpretation ghalat hai
Apka matbal (matlab)he k kesee naye paghambar ke zaroorat he
انسان کے پاس 1 عقل ھی ھے جو اسے ممتاز کرتی ھے باقی مخلوق سے اور عقل ھی سوچنے سمجھنے کا واحد راستہ ھے اور الحامی کتابیں انسانوں کے لئے ھیں
The guy is confused and biased , he is likely to support mysticism, while Ghamdi rejects mysticism in the light of the Quran and Sunnah. Ghamdi requires to be studied and assimilated holistically NOT superficially by going through his collected works .
Bak raha hun junoo me kya kya kuchh..
Kuchh na samjhe khuda kare koyi😁😁
Ghamdi sb k asol hi ghalat bta rahy hay ap ap nay inko suna hi nahi janb ...
Ap in ka wo masala btaye dalill k sath
After listening this guy, it is evident that he has never listened Ghamadi Sahib
Comments padhne ke baad maine video dekhna zaroori nahi samjha😂😂
اعجاز صاحب کا غامدی صاحب پر تاثر ، جسے شدت تاثر کہنا شاید زیادہ موزوں ہے ، سن کر فیض کا شعر بے اختیار یاد آ گیا :
وہ بات سارےفسانے میں جس کا ذکر نہ تھا
وہ بات ان کو بہت ناگوار گزری ہے
Lol 😂 tusi great ho sir g bs krdo” apke bs ki baat nhi” 🙏😝
اہل علم خود فیصلہ فرمائیں صاحب نے کتنی مدلل گفتگو فرمائی ہے
میں ایک ناقص رائے کی جسارت کرونگا
اولاًجب ایک عالم یا کسی بھی شعبے سے تعلق رکھنے والا ہو اس شخص کے زیب نہیں دیتا کہ وہ ذات پر تنقید تنقیص یا تحکیر کرے
اگر کسی سے شخص سے کسی بھی معاملے پر اختلاف ہو تو دلائل کی روشنی میں استدلال کے ساتھ عقائد و نظریات و فکر پر گھنٹوں گفتگو کرے ٫لکھے۔لوگوں کو مخالف خریف کی غلط بات یا رائے سے باور کرائے
دین کا اصل اصول یہی تقاضا کرتاہے
جہاں تک ان صاحب نے گفتگو فرمائی تو مجھے لگتا کسی معاملے پرگفتگوفرمارہےہیں بار بار سوال کرنے کے باوجود اپنی بات کو واضع نہیں فرما سکے معذرت
I think, this respected personality is not even familiar with the basic principles of Javed Ahmed Ghamidi SB on which Ghamidi's arguments are based.
Very disappointed with his response. No example of any objection. Just based on common disagreement of many laymen he said Ghamidi studies a lot but is not right. I wanted to see some criticism on Ghamidi sb but in my view he praised Ghamidi sb instead of establishing any fact against him. When Ghamidi sb himself says a different opinion than what majority believes then definitely majority will not like or agree with it. Now what's the point in saying that I and my friends didn't like what Ghamidi said. Is this the way of commenting on such issues? Really disappointed. Ghamidi sb this man in fact defended you with his unprepared and lame points.
Aap nay Kaha unhon nay koi baat ghalat kahee, jis ko aap Kay mushtariq dost nay bhi ghalat Kaha, lekin aap nay audience say Woh baat share Nahin ki. Mujhay naahin maloom keh konsee baat ko ghalat interpret Kia Ghamidi sahib nay. I would suggest, you should speak the whole talk.
Who is he ??
This poor soul doesn't even understand Ghamidi sahab reasoning and not even able to give 1 example where he disagrees.
Uncle pahle moo saf karo per jinab javed ahmad ghamdi sahab ka nam lo
Who is this person? No introduction. Started bickering on Ghamdi Sb straight away. To me he is not focussed on any thing.
ye baaten har bande ki samjh nhi ayengi kyun inhon ne history ko sahi study kiya hai
Alqa, Ilham, and other imaginary methods to get guidence directly from God are not possible after the last prophet Muhammad (peace be up on him). These claims have misguided a huge number of muslim community. Quran alway invites His audience to use reason and wisdom. All sahaba never claimed Ilham or kashf or any other means like this to find guidence on religion. Wasif ali wasif and other sufi's like him are poking a hole in the finality of the prophethood of Muhammad (peace be upon him) by claiming that God talks to them.
Ye moun aur masoor ki daal. Ye tho sochna chahiye banday ko k vo jis per bath kar rahay han aya vo us ko samajtey b han ya samaj b saktey han.
معذرت کے ساتھ کہنا پڑ رہا ہے کہ ان صاحب کو ماہر نفسیات کی ضرورت ہے۔ اور یہ بھی ممکن ہے کہ میری عقلی صلاحیت اتنی محدود ہے کہ ان کے اقوال زریں کو سمجھنے کے لئے کسی اور سے عقل ادھار لینی پڑے گی
this kind of people even know ghamidi shab.
App ghoma phira kar baat kar rahe hai exact un Ki baat point kar ke bataye
Waiting for this uncle......RIP
آپ جناب کی باتیں اختلاف برائے اختلاف نظر آتی ھیں۔ بے سروپا باتیں۔ یہ تک ذکر نہیں کہ اختلاف کس بات سے ھے۔ اختلاف کرنے کی وجہ اور دلیل۔
Interpretation ki example to do...
Ye sufio se mutasir h...
What are you talking about? You think by talking in what sounds intellectual reasoning will make people agree with you. You talked no sense, gave no answers and no logicl reasoning. Sounds like a bitter man. Get over yourself.
I am simply shocked. Kaise kaise jahil log Ghamidi jaise scholar pe bina kisi istadlaal k tanqeed kar rahe hain.
O bhai Shukar hy jo taray m aqal hy tu Ghamdi sahh se disagree krta hy, tera unse agree krna banta hi ni, yeh Ghamdi sahb ki aik bartari hy k us k followers m koi jahil ni, bahot ziada parhay likhay log hain
کوئ نئ تشریح نہیں کی ہے اصل کو واضح کیا ہے۔ سننے کے لیۓ تحمل چاہیے۔
جزاک اللہ خیراً
Ghamdi sahb ne ye bt thk nhi ki. Ye apki apni smjh h ye koi daleel nhi h. Ghamdi sahb bat ko uljhate nhi hn 7.39 minute me apni ap kuch nhi bol pye ghamdi itna time.me daleel ki line lga dete..
Ghamedi is a great scholar of present time
I was waiting for something meaningful........video finished😂
How would you know that , this interpretation is by God , and this is by human ,!
Such irrelevant, incoherent and baseless talk ....
What is tje " mushidaaa" of knowledge ???
I'm sure even he doesn't know what he's talking about haha. These people are known as charlatans.
Allah k bandy khaamoosh raho bs agr kisi cheez ka nahi pata....
اس سے زیادہ مضحکہ خیز تبصرہ نہیں سنا۔ یہ مسخرہ کون ہے ۔۔اس غبی شخص نے کبھی زندگی میں مطالعہ نہیں کیا۔ اس سے زیادہ سمجھ تو میرے خانساماں میں ہے
Haha so funny
Hawai fire only :)
بے ربط گفتگو بے ربط بات یہ
بھی نہیں پتا کہ موصوف کہنا کیا چاہتے ہیں بس غامدی صاحب پر اعتراض
haaan jiiii wo bsssss thek hy lakinwo theek nh....☺️
Hahahahaha Sir apni recorded guftugu khud bhi sun lain ap Kya kehna chah rahey Han hahahahahaha
This guy totally blank
Ohh chacha baatein ghuma rahe ho. Logical baat kyo nahi kar rahe? Ghamidi saheb se aap ittefaq nahi rakhte to wo kya baatein hain unme jo fasaad feel ho rahi hai aapko? Ya fir in other words aap religious based politics publicity par focus kar rahe hain...? Kisi se sunkar kuch kehna ya bolna baat alag hai aapne unki books se kya observe kiya? Wo clear kijiye..
Allah TA says in Quran " Laqad Yessernal Quran lilzikre" Indeed Quraan is easy to understand....OR ye janab Kah rahe Aqal nahi samjh Sakta...Ghamdi ne apna samjha hai aap apna smjho...per khud padho to Shahi...
یار۔۔اس سے زیادہ فضول گفتگو کبھی نہیں سنی
jo ilm insaan ki aqal pe nhi utarta woh insaan ke lie kese hoo sakta ha? Ilhami qalaam poori tarha insaan ki aqal per hi utarta ha. aur utarta haa tub hi to phir insaan ussay qabool kerta ha...
Couldnt make a single point. Not making any sense at all.
Complete ignorant from the fiker of Ghamdi Sb where the Quran is Furkan.
Mainay Comments per K apna time Bacha liya.......
This person does not have any clue what he is talking about. Either he is lying or he never had listen to Ghamidi. Ghamidi does not mix up religion with society.
Sorry to say hard fact , an Islamic scholar can never be open and impartial minded.
From:- India.
I strongly suggest you, to listen Javed Ghamidi Sahab. Though I do not understand what do you mean by open .
6:00
قرآن کو قرآن سے سمجھو...
How to talk for 7 mins and not say anything!! If you are going to claim to differ with someone at least have the courtesy to read one book of theirs. Very disappointing!
He knows nothing about Ghamdi sb..
Rubbish
Is bandy ko khud nahi pata k ma kya bol raha hon
This guy has no knowledge as it is very evident in his non coherent talk
Hasad eeeee hasad. In logon be tamasha lava rakha hay.in besharmon ko sharm naheen hay.
Rip logic
Jahal e mutlaq, Kahan raam bhoj khan kangoo teli
Allah apko Sache Talib Ilm banae_
Hahaha! Serious joke
Hahaha Bhed chal wale log hai ye...
Waste of time
No sense at all
Total nonsense
Dislikes > Likes (Deservingly) 😂😂😂
بهایی صاحب کچ اور کام شرو کرو شاید بهتر هوگی
Disagree
Jahiliyat... koi bhi alima deen ban jaata hai ajj kl.
Apko sahi ghalat ki hi tameez nhi hy
Wrong
Intahaee fazool admi
Pagal