Can’t believe this song was made 2 years ago. Good thing BamBam waited for this day to come. He literally give his all on this song. Deserves every praise it gets. This song is amazing!!!
It’s great that he released this after he left J*P. Almost 2 years that they waisted their time but it’s ok with them now to do all the things they want.
My favorite part about this collab is how Seulgi is really treated like Bambam’s twin persona. They are both embracing the masculine and feminine energy that everyone possesses. I appreciate that neither of them were overly sexualized or treated as an object. Sometimes co-ed collabs can feel male gaze-y. But this is just showcasing their talents in parallel with one another. They’re portrayed as equals. Maybe two sides of the same person?
ever since this released, this had became my standard for collabs, especially those between my faves... so far, the only other collab that has met my standard unironically also has a red velvet member
The choreography is insane. They could have done a typical contemporary duo but neither of them dance typically male/ female steps. They seem to replicate each other's steps at times appearing as the same person, just shadows of each other, the next second they are two people completing each other. Over all it has a romantic gothicism to the dance and it looks incredible. Through the dance it looks like they are singing 'who are you' to themselves or their alter egos instead of a lover.
FINALLY, a real and quality collab that does not feature an artist just for 20 seconds in a song. Did you hear that freaking HARMONIZATION?! Can you see that splendid choreography?! Everything from visuals to music is not only unique but also perfect in every sense
This is what a actual collaboration means. Not just singing a verse in btwn. It's a duet, she is also in the mv, dancing together. They understood the assignment.
The fact that BamBam has this song since last 2 years and he couldn’t find someone who fits with this song to collab with him until he met Seulgi is just woah.Thanks to BamBam for keeping this masterpiece until he found the right person, company and the right time. Who Are You is truly an amazing song
SM really hit the jackpot with Seulgi. An all rounder, a talented woman, an artist, an idol, a singer, a woman. Also, Bambam's voice combined well with Seulgi's hehe
Only Bambam could ever , his mind and Abyss are genius, im glad Seulgi liked and agree this collab but i wont forgive SM for not even promoting Seulgi featuring with bambam. SEULO better happen
I like how majority of the song they sing together instead of one verse one verse. It's really soothing to hear their sweet voices thats meshing together
The ones that didn’t know bammie, wouldn’t ever think with his solo career that he’s from the rap line of a bg… his voice is so unique and so versatile , im so proud of him , this song is as amazing as his first solo album , from the production to the lyrics and the feeling transmitted, GOT7 world domination.. they’re all so talented I’m a proud noona , Seulgi is so beautiful and her voice is so magnificent.. love this !
“My one and only SG of Red Velvet.” -Bambam I love their friendship sm. I hope all idols can interact with other idols without it being a big deal too.
Seulgi's voice is so gorgeous and Bam's singing voice is so soft. Their voice blend together very well and this is so smooth......for dancing, no words need to say.
I just wanna say that they are both brave to try this type of dance that requires a lot of skinship considering they are both idols. They usually do hard hitting dance moves and they are able to showcase a different side of themselves through this. Super proud!
We love their friendship. I wish fans see this as good things since they share their love for music to us. Proud of BamBam cos he's been thriving this year with so many schedule & he's free to do what he loves. No more restriction. There's big difference since got7 departed from their ex-comp & we love to see it.
It's a breath of fresh air sometimes I'm a multi fandom and my usually main is BTS but it's gotten bad with people complaining This song was so beautiful tho
I'm not into kpop but Who Are You trended worldwide so I checked out then wow I'm in awe throughout the whole 3 mins. The concept, the artistry, their dance is so amazing and I'm melting their voice just sound so heavenly. I love the girl especially, she's so beautiful. Amazing artists!
You should listen to their music, she's in a girl group called Red Velvet, they have different concepts in their songs! Her name is SEULGI and is the main dancer!😌💕💕
i think u need to check the teasers of this mv and "riBBon Melody film" on this channel too, i assure u will be mind blown by the level of creativity in it, even as a kpop stan myself i have never seen something like this before. it's just a genius and beautiful experience throughout the whole thing. btw the girl is Seulgi from RedVelvet check out "naughty" or "Psycho" u will like it so much, the boy is BamBam from Got7 check out his album "riBBon" he is a genius with everything he does.
Everyone who are not familiar with bambam Yes he’s a rapper originally, but he’s this good Man I’m so proud Ahgase, Bambam makes such good songs and the whole video aesthetic was sooo cool This is what freedom and being creative and showing their potential looks like
I love that this collab isn't her just singing one verse. It's not just her harmonizing in the background. They both have their own parts -- it's like they're a duo. And they work so well together.
I always thought Ribbon was always going to be BamBam's most legendary comeback but I'm starting to think BamBam is planning on blowing our minds with each comeback he has... boy is a genius.
The first thing i loved about this song/mv is the dancing! Not many idols that I've seen have done a contemporary duet? either that or it wasn't what I expected but they did so well together! It's more attention grabbing and emotional for me--and it pairs with the song so nicely! Bambam's voice also sounds different in this style and I love it with Seulgi's vocals! I'm so happy with this collab! Congrats Seulgi and Bambam! It made my heart so happy to find out you got to collab together!! my favs!!
It's been a long time since I've wanted to see BamBam dance like this, since You Are. BamBam is a really good dancer. His dance is both strong and fluid, like Yin and Yang. The more I saw BamBam dancing to this song, the more I feel that he's awesome. And his voice is so sweet. I admit that I had no expectations about his singing. But he has proven that he can. He has greatly improved his singing skills. He grows in every performance. I'm really proud of him. Also, thank you Seulgi for helping to complete this song even more. Both the vocals and the choreography, I appreciate.
Bambam just showing how collabs should be done. The whole concept, the choreo, the song... It's just something different. got7 members going solo is one of the best things that happened in 2021. But especially Bambam is setting the bar high in music industry.
This really dropped at the perfect time. The days between christmas and new year's eve are kind of weird and stressful because you are looking back on a whole year and at the same time you have the next year approaching & you set all those new goals and stuff...this song just feels like taking a deep breath while making yourself some hot chocolate. It's very calming, i don't know how to explain it.
I'm not even an aghasae or a Red Velvet fan, but this song is simply a masterpiece and a work of art. BamBam and Seulgi's voice just calms me down so much, it's simply beautiful ❤️
This is totally a surprise. I expected a fast beat song but they choose a wonderful melody. I am in love with seulgi voice... I never heard her voice particularly before. But she slayed.
If only Kpop was more open to female and male artists collabing and interacting, we'd get masterpieces like this. This is beautiful from the song to the visuals to the choreo, thank you BamBam and Seulgi
I see a lot of comment saying this isn't just a featuring and it feels like a duo. And I couldn't agree more! This really is such a one of a kind collab! And they both sounds amazing!
Who are you? Heaven given both so sweet n soft n sentmental voice for this song Thank Seulgi so much for this gorgeous work with BamBam Hopefully wait for next wonderful collab Seulgi❤️BamBam soon Love you Both 💞
@@kruti_igot7 can't help it... Bcoz got7 showing different and upgraded skill always hits me .... Whether this is same baby BB i had known from for these many years... The new album is sooo good....
I just love the fact the Suelgi's voice didn't over power BamBam's and it blended so well. I love the choreography and their chemistry. The MV really really looks so elegant! I simply love it!
I really can't find the right words to describe how I feel towards this song, but one thing I know is that it's extremely beautiful. Everything about this comeback was so well executed, from the song itself, to the concept and the visuals, to Bambam and Seulgi voices together. I honestly couldn't be more happy and satisfied about this release. Congrats to everyone worked in this, they really made a flawless job in my opinion.
İ really like the song. Bambam singing "do you even care" and Seulgi answering the line with "İ know it very well" makes me think it's a song about your present self talking to your future self. Bambam represent here your current self who dislikes the present, somewhat unsatisfied with the way you are living your life. "Who are you/Like a labyrinth/But İ like you, like to find you/İ realize someone else in mind" future self is compared to a labyrinth, several irregular and complications before getting there, but overall, Bambam realized that he likes this version of themself in the future, he likes to be this version, all the while realizing that in the present, BB visualises the future differently. Seulgi represent your future self who can't help but just look on to Bambam (current self) with wise words learned along the way (You're the only one who doesn't know, wandering/İ want to wake you and help you/So you don't have to fall in love with the deep illusion of love) "So can you see me now? İf you still love the way İ am, keep in touch; if you don't hate me that's enough" this line is sang in duet because it goes both ways. Current self saying if future self still likes some part of him, keep it in the future; and if they don't, it's okay as long as future self doesn't resent them for being that way. Future self saying that if current self likes what they see in their future, keep striving to get there; and if current self doesn't hate what they would be in the future, the journey to get there (to the future) is still worthwhile.
THIS IS THE MOST RELATABLE THEORY I've read so far. Coz the the way they dance and the yinyang representation also the mirror. Its like one person with two persona. And you explain it well 👏👏👏
@@Okayme8080 yeah! the title of the song is intriguing then the teaser photos came (the aesthetics and styling) and it made it more interesting for me. i've waited for the english ccs and watched it several times coming up with this is ok impression/interpretation! 😂😂
I thought that I was prepared but clearly I wasn't! I thought that seulgi was gonna appear for like 30 sec cuz that's what a normal featuring is but no, IT WAS A FULL ON COLLABORATION! NOT ONLY THAT THE DANCE WAS AMAZING! IT FIT THE SONG PERFECTLY! I SOMEHOW FORGOT THAT GOT7 HAS SUCH GREAT DANCING SKILLS! AND BAMBAM SINGING? THAT WAS THE PART I WAS REALLY SHOCKED ABOUT! NOBODY TOLD THAT HE HAD SUCH A SOOTHUNG VOICE! ADDING THAT TO SEULGI'S HEVEANLY VOICE?! MY EARS WERE BLESSED! THIS TOTALLY EXCEEDED MY EXPECTATIONS! THIS DESERVES A LOT OF RECOGNITION! MUCH LOVE TO THEM!
Bambam is so amazing. He wrote, produced and mixed this song. He also produced the music video. Always going all out to ensure the quality of the things he puts out are top notch. I’m so proud of him. The way this song will lead into BB2 which will explore the possibilities that we’re always inside him and that he wasn’t able to explore during his time at JYPE - according to the press release.
Did everyone watch their iconic performance yesterday? It went viral everywhere. This duo will always be famous 💛 grateful to Bambam for inviting our Seulgi
BamBam really served with this song, and I'm so grateful to Seulgi for collabing with him on this, the result is just fantastic, very unique and beautiful. Seeing BamBam grow as an artist since last year has really been something to see. He's showing his own colours, he's radiating creativity and showing himself as a complete, versatile artist. I can't wait to see what the future holds for him. Really nice work, Bam.
Seulgi dancing in this genre and this kind of costume and in this kind of set is like a scene from my dream. Thank you BamBam for inviting Seulgi. I love how their moves bend together. The color, the transitions, the set, I think abyss has done a great job. The music video is pure art I think. I hope there will be more versions of dance videos. If not, I'll be crying very hard.
This is probably one of the best kpop songs I’ve heard. Like nothing has hit me this HARD since Gotta Go by Chung Ha. BamBam And Seulgi… wow unexpected song and unexpected collab. But they killed it!!! Definitely purchasing this song
I love how this is not like the typical collab where the featured artist only get some parts of the song, instead, Seulgi is included in almost all the verses including her own part as well. Bambam is so creative :(
Bambam has become my biggest inspiration. I am a middle class boy, and I am not famous, but can I get 10K views on my first song? With that money from TH-cam, I will buy a professional mic. Please guys, I want that mic more than anything. Pls help me.
FINALLY SEULGI AND BAMBAM COLLAB VIDEO CONGRATS TO BOTH AMAZING ARTISTS
King and queen slayed like we expected😩🔥
It really is a dream collab!
@@whosleeandwhatdoesheknowhi9098 u again o.o
@@whosleeandwhatdoesheknowhi9098 ahhaha
Yesssssssssssssssssssss .. I'm so happy
This is called ART✨✨✨
yess!!!!
Majestic.
Yessssss
Yeahhhhhhh
Exactly 💯
They understood the assignment PERIOD
what assignment
@@mikhsly2 it's a praise and a way of saying that they nailed this concept and knew what they were doing basically lol
@@mikhsly2 this masterpiece. The assignment was the creation of a masterpiece.
Exactly!!
Okayyyyyyyyy!
I learn a lot of lesson about subconscious mind.Bambam is awekening now❤
Two of the great artists in music and dance... what a combination!!!
omg a fan 🥰
Yeah!
Amazing, just wowwww
Agreed
Agreed
I love u seulgie and bambam♥️♥️♥️당신보다 나은 사람을 찾기가 어렵습니다 😉😝✨
seulgi*
@@heeseungsgf5305 thanks
You love them but you misspelled their name
.....
Love this song love u seulgi and BamBam 💜I so proud of you ❤😢
what makes me even surprised is, their interaction is NO ISSUE, NO DRAMA, NO FANWARS. they literally artist
Because most of the fandom of Got7 & red velvet is non toxic
Aghases and ReVeluv's are the most chill and laid-back fandoms to ever exist
Been saying this since the teaser came out I loved how respectful both fandoms were
Because Luvies and aghases are very good friends!! And this song is such a masterpiece, it naturally descends any chances of fanwar.
exactly! other fandoms should take note
What a vibe.. a collab I did not expect but love.
Seulgi’s voice really compliments BamBam’s here and makes for the perfect duo.
Best collaboration!! Their voice are so soothing
Yes
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro one
Celeb fan omgg
th-cam.com/video/H2nE5hy9F8E/w-d-xo.html .
The wait is over GUYS!!!!
Yes
Yes🤍
Dude you're everywhere
i just came here after watching ur reaction to snowdrop ep 3 lmao-
Finally!
BAMBAM AND SEULGI DANCE WOWWW IN LOVE WITH IT
th-cam.com/video/h5G76FkSVdk/w-d-xo.html
Great work
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro one
𝐁𝐀𝐌𝐁𝐀𝐌 𝐊𝐮𝐧𝐩𝐢𝐦𝐨𝐨𝐤 𝐁𝐡𝐮𝐰𝐚𝐤𝐮𝐥
#뱀뱀 #BamBam 🖤❤️
Can’t believe this song was made 2 years ago. Good thing BamBam waited for this day to come. He literally give his all on this song. Deserves every praise it gets. This song is amazing!!!
It’s great that he released this after he left J*P. Almost 2 years that they waisted their time but it’s ok with them now to do all the things they want.
You mean that the MV was shot 2 years ago ?? Or the song was written 2 years ago ?
@@mathg-3270 song
@@amanokawa3169 agreed- if this song was released under JYP.. It wouldn't have been promoted very well
@@mathg-3270 Written
My favorite part about this collab is how Seulgi is really treated like Bambam’s twin persona. They are both embracing the masculine and feminine energy that everyone possesses. I appreciate that neither of them were overly sexualized or treated as an object. Sometimes co-ed collabs can feel male gaze-y. But this is just showcasing their talents in parallel with one another. They’re portrayed as equals. Maybe two sides of the same person?
I really like this observation!
Not overly sexualized
Just rightfully sexualized lol
THIS!
yes i agree! the song itself is about being aware of your “other self”. bambam’s other self in this mv is seulgi herself
agree 100 %
I hope BamBam and Seulgi will have a chance to perform this masterpiece together.
Yes, pls
yes, pls!!
OHMYGOODNESS YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
Your wish came true during BamBam's concert!
ever since this released, this had became my standard for collabs, especially those between my faves...
so far, the only other collab that has met my standard unironically also has a red velvet member
True fact: Everyone agrees that Bambam and Seulgi is melting everyone’s heart with their songs
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro remix
No one can deny the fact that Bammie's singing voice is so soft and Seulgi's voice is so pretty. Their voice together can melt our heart.
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro remix
BamBam is so freaking amazing
bam is seriously establishing himself as a remarkable soloist, i'm immensely proud of him
He really is
The choreography is insane. They could have done a typical contemporary duo but neither of them dance typically male/ female steps. They seem to replicate each other's steps at times appearing as the same person, just shadows of each other, the next second they are two people completing each other. Over all it has a romantic gothicism to the dance and it looks incredible.
Through the dance it looks like they are singing 'who are you' to themselves or their alter egos instead of a lover.
I can't see their dance clearly on few angles it's actually driving me crazy.
Well said 😭 and everytime they held each other it made my heart flutters. Even their duo dance have a good chemistry
So true
@rice cooker ikr😆
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro remix
Omg Seulgi is just stunning, great collab
Bambam too
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro remix
Who are here back after their live performance 🎉❤😊
Me 😊
Me❤
FINALLY, a real and quality collab that does not feature an artist just for 20 seconds in a song. Did you hear that freaking HARMONIZATION?! Can you see that splendid choreography?! Everything from visuals to music is not only unique but also perfect in every sense
Yessss I was so sick of the purely commercial sound that seems to be everywhere these days, this is QUALITY
We need more male-female kpop collaborations!!! This just shows how they both are equal in talent and skills. We love to see it
yes please!
@Blink Lisaaa yes they are
i wish they could.. but not all fandoms are NOT TOXIC as ahgases and reveluv
@Blink Lisaaa yes they are💚💚💚
This is what a actual collaboration means. Not just singing a verse in btwn. It's a duet, she is also in the mv, dancing together. They understood the assignment.
well its all up to the pay
Really though, this is what I like, a real collab on the music
@@gretchensacpa4943 this definitely seems like bam bam wanted her to be a part of the song. Not like a collab that is only because labels wanted money
Good Morning Handsome man GOT7 BamBam 🐍💚
The fact that BamBam has this song since last 2 years and he couldn’t find someone who fits with this song to collab with him until he met Seulgi is just woah.Thanks to BamBam for keeping this masterpiece until he found the right person, company and the right time. Who Are You is truly an amazing song
2 YEARS????
seulgi perfect choice great job bammie
@@halaasham3671 YES
뱀뱀 (BamBam)
Slow Mo MV
2022.01.18 6PM (KST)
SM really hit the jackpot with Seulgi. An all rounder, a talented woman, an artist, an idol, a singer, a woman. Also, Bambam's voice combined well with Seulgi's hehe
Only Bambam could ever , his mind and Abyss are genius, im glad Seulgi liked and agree this collab but i wont forgive SM for not even promoting Seulgi featuring with bambam. SEULO better happen
If SM really cares about Seulgi they’d give her a solo debut. She deserves her own album.
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro remix
@@ma.kynepagay3831า
I like how majority of the song they sing together instead of one verse one verse. It's really soothing to hear their sweet voices thats meshing together
แค่ได้คิดว่าจะเห็นเสตจนี้จริงๆก็ตื่นเต้นแล้ว ❤
Bambam King 100%
Bambam Visual 100%
Bambam Vocal 100%
Bambam Rap 100%
Bambam Outfits 100%
Bambam Dancing 100%
Bambam Acting 100%
Bambam Sweetness 100%
Bambam Handsome 100%
Bambam MV 100%
Everything About Bambam Is Just Perfect.
Yeeeaaahhh
100%
Right right
Correct
Exactly
The ones that didn’t know bammie, wouldn’t ever think with his solo career that he’s from the rap line of a bg… his voice is so unique and so versatile , im so proud of him , this song is as amazing as his first solo album , from the production to the lyrics and the feeling transmitted, GOT7 world domination.. they’re all so talented I’m a proud noona , Seulgi is so beautiful and her voice is so magnificent.. love this !
.......
th-cam.com/video/h5G76FkSVdk/w-d-xo.html
Great work
'BAMBAM' + 'SEULGI' = 'PERFECTION'
ยังไม่กลับจากคอนราชมัง พี่หมวยหมวยกับแบมแบมโชว์ดีมากๆบ่งบอกถึงความโปรความระดับท็อปของทั้งคู่จริงๆ แบมมี่คนนี้ปลื้มปริ่มมากคือกรี๊ดเพลงพี่หมวยหมวยจนเจ็บคอ เสียงดีเต้นเก่งมาก ส่วนแบมแบมคือไม่มีที่ติเลย นอกจากน้ำที่ฉีดมันไม่ถึงเราค่ะร้อนมาก555แล้วห่อหุ้มทุกอย่างด้วยพลาสติกด้วยนะ
“My one and only SG of Red Velvet.” -Bambam
I love their friendship sm. I hope all idols can interact with other idols without it being a big deal too.
I know right! Their friendship is so wholesome 💚
Seulgi's voice is so gorgeous and Bam's singing voice is so soft. Their voice blend together very well and this is so smooth......for dancing, no words need to say.
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro remix
I just wanna say that they are both brave to try this type of dance that requires a lot of skinship considering they are both idols. They usually do hard hitting dance moves and they are able to showcase a different side of themselves through this. Super proud!
Right! I'm proud of them!! Now I need a dance practice :")
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro one
We love their friendship. I wish fans see this as good things since they share their love for music to us. Proud of BamBam cos he's been thriving this year with so many schedule & he's free to do what he loves. No more restriction.
There's big difference since got7 departed from their ex-comp & we love to see it.
Yeah I'm freaking proud too and
Just wishing fans won't get toxic 😂
Indeed
My handsome prince ❤🖤and my gorgeous queen
True fact: Seulgi and Bambam vocals aren’t joke. Their vocals so soft and healing.
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro remix
This is what you get when your fandom is not toxic 👏🏻👏🏻
INDEED
exactly!!!
ahgases and reveluv besties
It's a breath of fresh air sometimes I'm a multi fandom and my usually main is BTS but it's gotten bad with people complaining This song was so beautiful tho
TRUE
I'm not into kpop but Who Are You trended worldwide so I checked out then wow I'm in awe throughout the whole 3 mins. The concept, the artistry, their dance is so amazing and I'm melting their voice just sound so heavenly. I love the girl especially, she's so beautiful. Amazing artists!
You should listen to their music, she's in a girl group called Red Velvet, they have different concepts in their songs! Her name is SEULGI and is the main dancer!😌💕💕
I’m also not into kpop but Got7 have a very unique rnb vibe, I can recommend some songs like « I am », « Out », Bambam’s « Air »..
she is our lead vocal from Red velvet. other idols always ask her to do a collab with them since she is a great dancer with strong vocal!
She is amazing! I found this other song th-cam.com/video/GZeILCFk9w0/w-d-xo.html and I have no words for her voice and dance
i think u need to check the teasers of this mv and "riBBon Melody film" on this channel too, i assure u will be mind blown by the level of creativity in it, even as a kpop stan myself i have never seen something like this before. it's just a genius and beautiful experience throughout the whole thing.
btw the girl is Seulgi from RedVelvet check out "naughty" or "Psycho" u will like it so much, the boy is BamBam from Got7 check out his album "riBBon" he is a genius with everything he does.
BamBam is so handsome
Everyone who are not familiar with bambam
Yes he’s a rapper originally, but he’s this good
Man I’m so proud Ahgase, Bambam makes such good songs and the whole video aesthetic was sooo cool
This is what freedom and being creative and showing their potential looks like
Cannot agree more.
and seulgi as a main dancer originally
Same, Proud Ahgase Forever. I truly believe this is just the start of so many great things for the boys, now that they have all the creative freedom
Bambam's tone is so soft and delicate, when it mixes to Seulgi's voice it's just *WOW*
ภูมิใจในตัวแบมมากๆ ตั้งแต่ตามแบมมา 6 ปี เห็นการฝึก การเติบโต และการพัฒนาตัวเองอยู่ตลอด ไม่ง่ายจริงๆที่จะมาถึงจุดนี้ แบมอดทนและเก่งมากๆ ภูมิใจในตัวเองให้มากๆนะ ทุกอย่างมันพิสูจน์ให้เห็นแล้วว่า แบมแบม Got7 มีความสามารถขนาดไหน การได้เห็นผลงานดีๆแบบนี้ เราตื้นตันจนร้องไห้ มันดีมากๆเลยค่ะ ขอบคุณแบมแบมที่ไม่ย่อท้อและพัฒนาอยู่เสมอ ขอบคุณGot7ทุกคนที่ดูแลและหล่อหลอมให้น้องเป็นคนที่น่าภูมิใจ ขอบคุณออบิส💖
เห็นด้วยครับและนี่ก็เป็นงานศิลป์ที่สวยงามมากอีกหนึ่งงาน ภูมิใจกับน้องด้วยครับ
เห็นด้วยค่ะขอบคุณมากค่ะสำหรับคนที่รักน้อง
พูดดีมากค่ะ
ขอบคุณที่แบมอดทน ขอบคุณAbyss ที่เห็นความสามารถในตัวแบมจริงๆ😭
อ่อย คุณคะ 😭
Came here after watching their first "Who Are You" live stage. This song remain the best collab, best song, best performance!
This is the type of song that gets better and better if you repeat it religiously ~ hope we can see them in a dance practice ^^.
Me too!! It would be AWESOME to see them dance clearly :´)
@@jenni8841 Yes ^^...or the performance video. I hope they did one together ~
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro remix
I love that this collab isn't her just singing one verse. It's not just her harmonizing in the background. They both have their own parts -- it's like they're a duo. And they work so well together.
Yeah it really seemed like a duet, and their vocals really complimented eachother
bambam picked he right artist seulgi gave justice to this song they both sound and danced beautifully together
Right
You speaking facts!
yes absolutely!
Her voice, her clothing, her personality, her songs are perfect in every way.
I M IN LOVE WITH THIS SONG HEARING THIS AGAIN AND AGAIN
Me too
Aren't we all?
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro one
I always thought Ribbon was always going to be BamBam's most legendary comeback but I'm starting to think BamBam is planning on blowing our minds with each comeback he has... boy is a genius.
EXACTLY
The first thing i loved about this song/mv is the dancing! Not many idols that I've seen have done a contemporary duet? either that or it wasn't what I expected but they did so well together! It's more attention grabbing and emotional for me--and it pairs with the song so nicely! Bambam's voice also sounds different in this style and I love it with Seulgi's vocals! I'm so happy with this collab! Congrats Seulgi and Bambam! It made my heart so happy to find out you got to collab together!! my favs!!
Naughty and this
Naughty is her identity crisis era💞
Who are you is her straight era😔
Who are you~~🖤❤️
does anyone won' t talk abt their VOCALS and DANCE ???? like it' s CHEF kiss.
yesss their harmonies! it's giving PERFECTION ;-;
It's been a long time since I've wanted to see BamBam dance like this, since You Are. BamBam is a really good dancer. His dance is both strong and fluid, like Yin and Yang. The more I saw BamBam dancing to this song, the more I feel that he's awesome. And his voice is so sweet. I admit that I had no expectations about his singing. But he has proven that he can. He has greatly improved his singing skills. He grows in every performance. I'm really proud of him.
Also, thank you Seulgi for helping to complete this song even more. Both the vocals and the choreography, I appreciate.
Same, I feel like we can finally see what an incredible dancer he is. I hope they will upload une dance video
same
So true
Beautiful 🥺❤️
Can you remember the movie, "Passengers" a few years back? This song should be the OST.
so much
I love your videos and you💖
LOL SHARM YES✨✨
หาให้เจอคะ ศิลปินที่รักและใจดี กับแฟนคลับขนาดนี้ 1ใน one a in Million ที่จะมีศิลปินคุณภาพ มารักและ จริงใจกับ แฟนคลับ แบมแบม คือ ศิลปินคุณภาพ
It doesn't feel like a collab at all. It feels like they've always been a duo. Such a great song and great performance. Both of them slayed hard.
Exactly! They blended so well together 😩
RIGHT i need a dance practice :')))))
Bambam just showing how collabs should be done. The whole concept, the choreo, the song... It's just something different. got7 members going solo is one of the best things that happened in 2021. But especially Bambam is setting the bar high in music industry.
Bambam King=100%
Bambam Seulgi =100%
Bambam Who Are You =100%
Bambam Outfits =100%
Bambam Vocals =100%
Bambam Hair =100%
BamBam Charming =100%
Bambam Pretty=100%
Bambam Beautiful =100%
Bambam Sexy =100%
Bambam Handsome =100%
Bambam Dance =100%
Bambam Perfect =100%
Bambam Voice =100%
Bambam Song =100%
Bambam Visuals =100%
Bambam MV =100%
Seulgi queen = 100%
PERFECT
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro remix
Happy New year GOT7 BamBam 🐍💚
This really dropped at the perfect time. The days between christmas and new year's eve are kind of weird and stressful because you are looking back on a whole year and at the same time you have the next year approaching & you set all those new goals and stuff...this song just feels like taking a deep breath while making yourself some hot chocolate. It's very calming, i don't know how to explain it.
Ikr....its very artistic yet somewhat gentle...
You capture it perfectly:)
@@mochimo93 DVD
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro remix
Can’t stop listening to this song, really. Just love these two voices and the melody too.
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro remix
I'm not even an aghasae or a Red Velvet fan, but this song is simply a masterpiece and a work of art. BamBam and Seulgi's voice just calms me down so much, it's simply beautiful ❤️
Welcome :)
You're definitely a fan
Funnily enough, they are even better at dancing imo! They did such a great job!
yeah me too. but i keep coming here 😅😅
5월 태국에 콘서트를 진짜 보고싶다 ~ 봐야지 다들!!
This is totally a surprise. I expected a fast beat song but they choose a wonderful melody. I am in love with seulgi voice... I never heard her voice particularly before. But she slayed.
Check out her crafts she has tons of collaborations with male idols and rappers.
Shes the kpop's ace afterall
Same here
@@leahcabudocdorosa6651 yes
OMG! This is SM Ent's fault. They don't promote Seulgi properly. Seulgi is like a Main Vocalist though. Well, she's the Lead Vocalist in her group.
She has a very beautiful n versatile voice , all of the members of RV also . U can listen to their bsides , one of the bests in kpop..
If only Kpop was more open to female and male artists collabing and interacting, we'd get masterpieces like this.
This is beautiful from the song to the visuals to the choreo, thank you BamBam and Seulgi
@Ann Yes definitely. Looking at the likes of SNSD, EXO, 2PM just to name a few, co-ed interactions and collabs were welcomed
Tell me I’m not the only who haven’t gotten over this hauntingly beautiful song and this masterpiece of a mv
i'm with you
Youre not alone
im with youuuu
I'm with u bro
I WANT TO SEE THEM ON STAGE PERFORM 'WHO ARE YOU' TOGETHER AGAIN
I see a lot of comment saying this isn't just a featuring and it feels like a duo. And I couldn't agree more! This really is such a one of a kind collab! And they both sounds amazing!
I thought the same thing!! 🥺 It definitely feels like a duo/unit
@@EhyWisdom we should ask abyss and sm to debut them as an official duo lols they sound great together and doesn't look awkward at all.
Who are you? Heaven
given both so sweet n soft n sentmental voice
for this song
Thank Seulgi so much
for this gorgeous work
with BamBam
Hopefully wait for next wonderful collab
Seulgi❤️BamBam soon
Love you Both 💞
they just started a new era for kpop. this kind of collab is not seen at all and bambam and seulgi is paving the way
그들은 단지 kpop에 대한 새로운 시대를 시작했다. 이 그들은 단지 kpop에 대한 새로운 시대를 시작했다.
Exactly
ประทับใจจัง เพลงดีมาก ร้องดีทั้งแบมและซิลกิเลย เสียงเข้ากันมาก เต้นก็ดี เป็นการดูmv ที่มีความสุขมาก ขอบคุณแบมแบม ซึลกิ และออบิส ที่สร้างสรรค์ผลงานที่มีคุณค่าและงดงามออกมาแบบนี้ ให้เราได้ชมกัน
ดีใจด้วยนะคะน้องที่ได้ทำอะไรไหม่ๆขอไห้ประสพความสำเร็จทุกอย่างนะลุก
21แล้วดีไจด้วยนะคสเก่ง
ดูกี่รอบก็ประทับใืจ พี่กิน้องแบมเก่งมาก เต้นดีสุดเห้อจะอวยไงดีมันเริ่ดแฮงงงง🎉
This guy nailed it... And harmony with seulgi is soo good ... Her voice is beautiful ... I always loved BB singing voice...
Before seeing your dp i was like, ah do they not know BB, (cause of this guy nailed it) 🤣
@@kruti_igot7 can't help it... Bcoz got7 showing different and upgraded skill always hits me .... Whether this is same baby BB i had known from for these many years... The new album is sooo good....
I just love the fact the Suelgi's voice didn't over power BamBam's and it blended so well. I love the choreography and their chemistry. The MV really really looks so elegant! I simply love it!
so proud of Bambam for everything he did this year, he really puts all his love in what he does :))
เขาทำงานหนักมาก ภูมิใจแบมจริงๆ😭
this song is so good man
I really can't find the right words to describe how I feel towards this song, but one thing I know is that it's extremely beautiful. Everything about this comeback was so well executed, from the song itself, to the concept and the visuals, to Bambam and Seulgi voices together. I honestly couldn't be more happy and satisfied about this release. Congrats to everyone worked in this, they really made a flawless job in my opinion.
I never expected a song like this..it's so soothing..I'm on verge of crying
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro remix
İ really like the song. Bambam singing "do you even care" and Seulgi answering the line with "İ know it very well" makes me think it's a song about your present self talking to your future self.
Bambam represent here your current self who dislikes the present, somewhat unsatisfied with the way you are living your life.
"Who are you/Like a labyrinth/But İ like you, like to find you/İ realize someone else in mind" future self is compared to a labyrinth, several irregular and complications before getting there, but overall, Bambam realized that he likes this version of themself in the future, he likes to be this version, all the while realizing that in the present, BB visualises the future differently.
Seulgi represent your future self who can't help but just look on to Bambam (current self) with wise words learned along the way (You're the only one who doesn't know, wandering/İ want to wake you and help you/So you don't have to fall in love with the deep illusion of love)
"So can you see me now? İf you still love the way İ am, keep in touch; if you don't hate me that's enough" this line is sang in duet because it goes both ways.
Current self saying if future self still likes some part of him, keep it in the future; and if they don't, it's okay as long as future self doesn't resent them for being that way.
Future self saying that if current self likes what they see in their future, keep striving to get there; and if current self doesn't hate what they would be in the future, the journey to get there (to the future) is still worthwhile.
Thks
Good analogy 🙌
Nice interpretation
THIS IS THE MOST RELATABLE THEORY I've read so far. Coz the the way they dance and the yinyang representation also the mirror. Its like one person with two persona. And you explain it well 👏👏👏
@@Okayme8080 yeah! the title of the song is intriguing then the teaser photos came (the aesthetics and styling) and it made it more interesting for me. i've waited for the english ccs and watched it several times coming up with this is ok impression/interpretation! 😂😂
I thought that I was prepared but clearly I wasn't! I thought that seulgi was gonna appear for like 30 sec cuz that's what a normal featuring is but no, IT WAS A FULL ON COLLABORATION! NOT ONLY THAT THE DANCE WAS AMAZING! IT FIT THE SONG PERFECTLY! I SOMEHOW FORGOT THAT GOT7 HAS SUCH GREAT DANCING SKILLS! AND BAMBAM SINGING? THAT WAS THE PART I WAS REALLY SHOCKED ABOUT! NOBODY TOLD THAT HE HAD SUCH A SOOTHUNG VOICE! ADDING THAT TO SEULGI'S HEVEANLY VOICE?! MY EARS WERE BLESSED! THIS TOTALLY EXCEEDED MY EXPECTATIONS! THIS DESERVES A LOT OF RECOGNITION! MUCH LOVE TO THEM!
เขาไม่เคยได้รับการโปรโมท เต้น ร้อง จากที่เก่า มันน่าเศร้า
ขอบคุณAbyss แบมแบมพิสูจน์แล้ว
Have you listen to to his riBBon , its amazing th-cam.com/video/_MrTIPwHTH8/w-d-xo.html
Good Morning GOT7 BamBam 🐍💚🐦
Bambam is so amazing. He wrote, produced and mixed this song. He also produced the music video. Always going all out to ensure the quality of the things he puts out are top notch. I’m so proud of him. The way this song will lead into BB2 which will explore the possibilities that we’re always inside him and that he wasn’t able to explore during his time at JYPE - according to the press release.
th-cam.com/video/PQRuhSrus48/w-d-xo.html best afro remix
Said this elsewhere, but I've never heard a song quite like this. It's superbly unique. It's also gorgeous in every way.
JUS2 - Focus on Me has the same vibes if you want to hear more music like this..
@@advenavictoria1301 For me not so much, BUT I do love it. lol. :)
Couldn’t agree more
It sort of reminded me of a few Clazziquai songs if you ever want to listen to them!
@@darknessoolala thanks for the recommendation!
BAMBAM + SEULGI = PERFECTION
Did everyone watch their iconic performance yesterday? It went viral everywhere. This duo will always be famous 💛 grateful to Bambam for inviting our Seulgi
This is literal art. The vocals, the visuals, the choreography, just everything about this was amazing. Song of the year.
BamBam really served with this song, and I'm so grateful to Seulgi for collabing with him on this, the result is just fantastic, very unique and beautiful. Seeing BamBam grow as an artist since last year has really been something to see. He's showing his own colours, he's radiating creativity and showing himself as a complete, versatile artist. I can't wait to see what the future holds for him. Really nice work, Bam.
Lets stay to see n support next from Bam together 🙂
Seulgi dancing in this genre and this kind of costume and in this kind of set is like a scene from my dream. Thank you BamBam for inviting Seulgi. I love how their moves bend together. The color, the transitions, the set, I think abyss has done a great job. The music video is pure art I think. I hope there will be more versions of dance videos. If not, I'll be crying very hard.
รักนะ JAY B 💚🥰🥰
I hope they’ll give us live performance or even just the dance practice. This is SO SO good!
KEEP STREAM AHGASE 💚🐣
Seulgi is one of the most talented and well-rounded artists in kpop. She is not know for being ace for nothing!
This is probably one of the best kpop songs I’ve heard. Like nothing has hit me this HARD since Gotta Go by Chung Ha. BamBam And Seulgi… wow unexpected song and unexpected collab. But they killed it!!! Definitely purchasing this song
Finally a who are you live stage with bambam and seulgi is happening soon and it's gonna be in thailand's biggest stadium!!🥳
And we are say thank u to bambam for invite our seulgi , for his encore concert' 😇
Can't wait
@@areakpop2437yup😇
Finally
Seulgi: cantik, body goals, suara merdu, dancer, model, bisa masak & ngegambar, pekerja keras sungguh luar biasa 👀
Don't forget she is a clumsy bear as well as a Pringles lover. She is also one of the sweetest people on Earth.
Please give my boi a little credit too
@@ayumihumaira5305 I most definitely did...just not in this thread.
Can we talk about how this is what we call a REAL COLLAB, like Bambam And Seulgi could debut as a real unit or duo.
I love how this is not like the typical collab where the featured artist only get some parts of the song, instead, Seulgi is included in almost all the verses including her own part as well. Bambam is so creative :(
I agree. It's actually a collaboration. Not a "featuring". Seulgi is incorporated into the dance, rhythm, and song. This is a masterpiece
The first time the featured artist has a meaningful purpose to the song right?
@@elsak325 not te first time. you just dont listen to duets enough
@@eeeh9693 lol I’m talking about between famous 3rd generation kpop idols of the opposite sexes
@@elsak325 look past SM entertainment and you’ll find at least 400
I'm really glad he has creative freedom and produce songs as long as he wanted!
Bambam has become my biggest inspiration. I am a middle class boy, and I am not famous, but can I get 10K views on my first song? With that money from TH-cam, I will buy a professional mic. Please guys, I want that mic more than anything. Pls help me.
This is such a beautiful song
Seriously, This song is such a Masterpiece.