Transsexual prostitutes in Paris face increasing violence
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 ต.ค. 2024
- Subscribe to France 24 now:
f24.my/youtubeEN
FRANCE 24 live news stream: all the latest news 24/7
f24.my/YTliveEN
Last year, France passed a law making it illegal to pay for sex - but not to sell it. The legislation was aimed partly at protecting sex workers from prosecution, but many of them say it is simply driving them further underground and exposing them to far more danger. Transsexual prostitutes who work in Paris's Bois de Boulogne, a large park just west of the capital, are disproportionately affected. FRANCE 24 went to meet some of them and listened to their harrowing stories of violence.
A programme prepared by Patrick Lovett and Christopher Davis.
www.france24.co...
Visit our website:
www.france24.com
Subscribe to our TH-cam channel:
f24.my/youtubeEN
Like us on Facebook:
/ france24.english
Follow us on Twitter:
/ france24_en
" its okay to prostitute ..... but its illegal to purchase sex "
how does this make sense ?
lmao
Worldwide half the laws are ignorant. We need a United world to love and help each other
These are laws meant to Punish men only. Leaving the female and transexuals prostitutes unaccountable.
There are drug laws like that too.
My thing is how is she allowed to work, knowing she has HIV.
@@walterhines6148 United world, are you in your senses ?
She knows she's HIV positive yet she does work? Do you have no conscience?
Get out of here with that privileged craps. She lives in France, a first world country. She chose that life.
@@moyettemorgan7102 nope... id die before doing this... beg on the corner...
Haven't you thought of how many clients have HIV? and maybe that is the way she got infected...
It is true she chose that life... but maybe she wasn't able to see more options for herself.... That's one of the main reasons support groups are for...
Fruitster how do you know she chose? i know many latin girls first hand that are transported to EU countries with lies and hopes of a better life and then they find theirselves trapped, exploitated, blackmailed with no chance of return.
It’s better not to give an opinion without taking into account the harsh realities these persons live.
@@moyettemorgan7102 what if the condom will broke?4 %from 10% of condoms have the most probability to broke
Prostitution is dangerous for biological women. So I can only imagine the levels of brutality there is towards someone who is trans.
RJ Angus they were born with a vagina. Cis is a made up term
D N hey kiddo cool down and better do your homework
Jeff mcclure he's referring to real women
RJ Angus nah guys, hit them where it hurts. Not a biological woman, a NATURAL woman. 😋😋😋😍😍😍😘😘😘 we will never get tired of y'all we promise. 😘😘
It's man to man fight! Truth
What about all the people who got infected with HIV?
NoUsernameFoundException ...yea and posibly guys with wives and families🤔..i hope they root in hell.
NoUsernameFoundException Are you really that stupid?
Musicalfactory Kaernten Yes I'm stupid in seeing this situation in another prospective.
Prostitute with STD shouldn't be allowed to work!
NoUsernameFoundException that's what I'm saying.. smh
antonia antonia how about they don’t cheat on their wives? There wouldn’t be a supply if there wasn’t a demand
hiv and still working the streets could be a death sentence if his clients found out .....scary life these people live
His?????
@@ninarainbow condoms aren't 100 percent effective
Nina Rainbow well you got lucky, that’s all !! No thanks! I still maintain my stance. I’ve had condoms break on me before but luckily the other person was clean so yes they aren’t 100% effective. I’m glad you never got it but Tell that to people who have caught something even when using a jimmy hat.
Ew
This is exactly my thoughts, alot if these women/people going to other countries spreading diseases. I'll never support violence. This is a deep concern not only in france, I see this in many Caribbean Countries I've travelled to. People be aware of your surroundings.
1.- I didn't knew whole France was a prostitute place... I thought only that park that is being pointed at the video... 2.-All of the clients?... yes... and not only spreading it there between prostitutes... but more close than you can imagine... where you don't imagine that to happen...
They leave there country because where they come from the living conditions are terrible. The housing conditions are better in paris . Spreading diseases girl stop . you have to treat every human like a disease there is no face for std and sti honey . it could be anyone
The roughest 37 I've ever seen
Hopefully someone says nice things about you too one day. ^-^
Hahaha!!!
Aylbdr Madison *honest*
D. Hayes Or that's probably because he's a man playing dress up...
what's the point of saying that seriously? Apart from being mean and bad, she's living in hell, she's been stabbed and you're mean towards her just to demonstrate us your insecurities by bashing someone, no people who are happy in their life talk like you talk poor sad thing
So we’re still in France right? I keep forgetting because of all the Spanish
My mouth dropped when they said she was hiv positive
Why do ppl feel the need to abuse them? So sick. Why hurt another human being like that? Soooo terrible.
An illegal job, has HIV and is not really a women. Maybe I can understand why some people might be frustrated.
nobody should ever be working this kind of job, it is just beyond outrageous. Give these women normal jobs.
That's why transgender women need better civil rights, they get fired from other jobs far too often and this is the only way they're left with to make an income.
That's why I hate Caitlyn Jenner, or more specifically, I hate people calling her a trans advocate and role model when she's never had to deal with those issues and doesn't even try to support the trans people going through that, just parading around in her palace with documentary after documentary deluding everyone into thinking life is just that easy for transgender people, completely glossing over major concerns like violence, human rights, healthcare, job security just so she and several others can whinge about pronouns and pretend they're somehow a bigger issue than the aforementioned list of problems.
It pays to little, well at least for this... wish people knew that only the worthwhile stuff is worth doing!
Some women rather prostitute themselves than working a job. Not all.
Most chose this job because they prefer it lol, like my aunt.
What women? The article is about shemales
New law makes no sense. You can sell something but you can't buy it. How the FK?
I heard you can buy sex but law they can’t sell. Kind of saying don’t make it so publicity.
Denny Don't comment if you don't know what you're talking about and don't have even a basic grasp of English
It disables the whole scenario but somehow it protects prostitutes from police harassment by allowing to sell sex. In short, the law wants you to leave prostitution and have a normal job
women privilege. men get arrested for soliciting but women walk free
I think it’s their way of protecting the prostitutes but it’s kind of hurting them
I would have never guessed that selling yourself to strangers for sex in a park at night could be dangerous.
😂 👍
I don’t understand how they can get in to France that easy? A person hold a US green card wants to visit Netherland the embassy asks millions questions and other even denied visa.
Denny they go there because they can make money there
Denny the same the other way around.
France is in EU, these girls are also from EU. You don't need visa to travel inside EU.
Maria They are from South America, you idiot. They have pimps who take them to France, there is a whole mafia here.
These countries - Peru, Chile. etc are in South American which is NOT part of the EU
What a dangerous job!
Speak Truth yeah it's true
The priest is a sainte, very kind of him to care for these women who are in a dangerous place. Thank you for your compassion, friendship, and assistance for those who have no one to turn to stay safe. Merci!
they're not women. they are men
agreed
Even if we were talking about "men" they dont deserve aggression but compassion. Not even a man deserves violent attacks
Buying sex is illegal? But selling it is not? Wtf! That doesn’t make any sense.
It's dangerous because they are deceiving.
Shes hiv positive and still work what if she infect her costumer
What are the consuming
Hailey Brown oh shut up
@@scarleyscattering it's a him
The 2K KING she is neither an it, nor a he. use her proper pronouns which are “she/her” if not I assume that you are a little boy who still needs some time to mature and grow up.
@@scarleyscattering No, shes a he. Not neither.
And french citizens are facing increasing violence as well.
..
Probably foreigners which I’m not gonna say which country
This guy is infecting hundreds of guys every year
Sucks to be them... but they put themselves in such a predicament.
Prostitution is itself a crime , so what if crime's happens with criminals
HIV positive and still working?
Yup she has to survive and I’m sure she caught it from a client .. so she’s clearly the victim here
Escort girls save some money and start a new life. That isnt life for nowbody. Kisses from portugal
Love you
Andreia Alves Alves drug addiction keep them in the business
Hi how are you I love trans♥
@@Taz690 where are you from
@@Taz690 send me message in whatsap 00212658158318
HIV through 🎈 🥜 ? Arrest Her!
Please arrest him/her as soon as possible!!!!☎da police...NOW!!!!
I can't pay for my treatment and now I am a prostitute.
I don't believe these sex workers deserve to be treated violently, but the only way to ensure their safety is to get out of the sex work industry. And yes, they have a choice to do so.
That sociologist knows what the real problem is and never talks about it.
This brings weight to the old saying "gay Paree".
😁😂😃😃😄😅 Fer sure
It always make me laugh how people from other countries come to someone's else country and start demanding things
As if we can't
Yep, really makes me wonder their ulterior motives.
She need to be arrested 😳
Here's an idea, get a skill and job that isn't selling your body. Just because you are transsexual doesn't mean you can't find any other type of employment.
Lol, you know nothing.
Actually yes, being trans does mean that they can’t find any other type of employment easily. Trans people often resort to sex work due to not getting hired at most places and the discrimination they face on a daily basis
You are not trans so shut your hole
I'm all for compassion for others but when are grown people going to start taking responsibility for their actions
Nobody like that job . I'll pray for them
Hmmm I wonder why. Could they be hiding something like I don't know the fact they are males.
Celste Connoly By whom?
All this old women should go and take care of their grandchildren and not to disgrace themselves in prostitution.
Why the government leave her with HIV and work
That doesn’t make any sense! You can sell it but it’s illegal to buy it😳
😔😔😔 Dear Lord please protect them with your holy spirit.. Help find a better way of living
"They treat us like men" DUH!!!!
when you order a taco and get a hot dog
LMAO
Why would they even do prostitution are there no jobs for them like people in my country do this only due to joblessness
With all means no one should be getting hurt of any kind of work they are doing what whether you are a woman or man no one should be getting brutally hurt.
This is why I never have sex except my wife
Hmmm they seem to be proud of their jobs , and who is a serial murder here, one with HIV or one who does revenge after infection
*pulls over*
Me:Hey
Prostitute: hey (deep voice)
Me:oh crap I’m out skrrrr
Buying sex is illegal but selling it is legal. If that is the case , where should sex workers sell it to make it legal. I don’t get the logic of this law. Sex work should be completely decriminalized. Are they implying that it should be free
I don't agree with violence at all but you guys choose that profession...assume the risk..
I’m my country Sudan 🇸🇩 people how it HIV positive they kept away from Society
That is why Sudan is dead last and trails in Africa in every aspect of socio-economics. How can you isolate people from society because they are HIV? I respect you and your country but you just shocked me.
Damn, i undesrstand why ir could be kinda hard to feel sorry or empathy for them, but in the end of the day, if two adults have a agreement to have sex, no one should get hurt.
These trans should be able to fight back because there dude's.
That is one of the many perks associated with NOT being upfront honest with an actual client🤨
preach
@@monicasanchez8438 Dont assume love BECAUSE IN PARIS TRANS WOMEN have their side and women have their SIDE TO WORK . STOP USING THAT AS AWAY TO JUSTIFY KILLING TRANS WOMEN
That priest probably seeing them on the low
It is worse, you get a lot of young Muslim men and when you finish they can get very angry and aggressive.
Im a trans but I dont agree to this kind of job. If we’re wanting to be protected from violence change what you do first. Just my opinion. Spread the love.
My heart goes out to all people that sell the most precious thing that they have. Godspeed to all ladies and trans women who have to put themselves into harms way.
But they are not women.. they are men
These are not women they are lady boys.
Thank you!
RuPaul - Lady Boy
RuPaul looks disgusting.
They're
Ladyboys are from Thailand, Dumb
What's going on in this world???
The end
Strong people don't put others down, they left them up, but they're many evils around the world 😎
That's right, only weak insecure fools fall victim to bigotry. I'm glad i'm not so weak that I openly attack those more vulnerable than myself.
Unfortunately, only way to stop the voilance is regulate it, and only way to regulate is to legalise it. Let us know if there's a better option
These people will do anything for money.....
beside a respectable job
There are no respectable jobs for trans people, it's not our fault
How sad.
Humans can be very simple & vicious.
:-(
The suffering 😔
g sun what a world we’ve created fir ourselves where hatred and confusion of ones self is now normal these men who think themselves women need help
Ascanius please shut up
I was in Paris over 40 years ago and this was going on then. Transvestites then. Truly awful to see. Suffering yes.
annettel Lathan can you explain to me? Are you saying being trans is not real? or men can't take the blame of sexual harassment stories that are erupting?
Filipe Cunha you do have a point there at the same time who knows what people go through so they do what they do. 🤔
She would be in jail if she was in the land of the free.
All the negative comments about trans women from insecure people about themselves on here just proves to show how 'toxic' personalities they are!!
Those are men
Selling is legal but buying is illegal.. Wtf
I'm sorry that the devil is damaging the world. I pity this transgenders.their life is terrible. If only I could help them.💗💗
@ungratefulmetalpansy u are one of them
Why did they *legalized* selling sex if sex *workers* have to deal with these kind of abuse and cruelty?
Somethings *ain't right* with their gov't system.
Go fill out some job applications.
Truth Teller will you hire them? Trans women are discriminated against and not protected by the law.
@@javis3059 That doesn't mean they shouldn't try to look for a more respectable job. Thinking they have no options when that's not true will keep them where they are. There are employeers who don't discriminate, and there are even agencies that help people like them find jobs.
@@javis3059 it's a he
Nothing is perfect in this world. We can't pretend to be holier than thou. but someone knowing fully well he/she is HIV Positive but still indulge in unsafe sex with total disregard for others life. that is unacceptable. that is psychopathic .
Where is Mujerón???
onceinfashion She lives in Marseille now.
Buying sex is illegal but selling is not!!! What an irony is lols
If it's so dangerous and you feel so degraded, then quit living the way you live. Anyone would suggest that to people in bad situations.
buying sex is illegal but selling it isn't... would anyone explain that crap to me please?
Culture of a developed nation ..
There immigrants lmao
Don’t do prostitute period .
This is really sad and what upsets me just as much as these poor women is all the hateful and transphobic comments here. This is someones child your talking about. It's not a choice being transgender, it's your identity, it's the same as your race, skin colour, sexuality. If you can't sympathise with these women I feel truly sorry for you.
Amelie Rosser - lol,
"It's not a choice being transgender, it's your identity, it's the same as your race, skin colour,"
Wrong. There is no "transgender" gene anywhere, except in a miniscule number who have an actual birth defect.
A forensic pathologist can determine a murder victim's skeletal remains to be a particular (or dominant) mixture of races, along with actual sex. They cannot determine the victim's preference of genitalia to touch, nor can they find what sex they wanted to be (let's pretend that gender equals sex, like all the propagandists do).
Gene? Gender is in your head. Your right that theres probably no physical gene that determines whether someone is born transgender. But there doesn't need to be because it's how you feel and identity.
I don't expect you to understand, it's not easy for people who aren't trans. But there's still no need for discrimination for people who are (such as myself)
Feels are hard to understand. Genetics, easy.
XX = Female
XY = Male
Any other configuration = birth defect
"Gender is in your head."
That's why it is not immutable, unlike race and sex. Also, that's why propagandists equate gender and sex; they wish to confuse the hoi polloi into believing your can be "born transgender" (which you can't).
Being "born transgender" is a conclusion you can only make if you believe the implicit pedophilia in Alfred Kinsey's publications.
You've been hilarious once again in stating mutually exclusive positions and not grasping the irony therein. LOL!
Stop having sex GUYS!
Why do most of them come from latin america?
I know somebody who know a woman from Colombia who work as a prostitute at that park and she said she like that job cause her self esteem is down and she need man to up her self esteem.
THAT'S A MAN BABY!!!!!
Don't fall into ignorance by saying that... ...I think you must inform yourself about what gender is... (I am not telling you to review your BELIEFS but to INFORM yoursef with SCIENCE FACTS... HISTORY.... even RELIGIONS.... homofobia and transfobia is modern stuff that will disappear over time if LOVE PEACE RESPECT HONESTY and TOLERANCE spreads and prevails between people...)
These people have no rights, especially being illegal and not a citizen of Paris. This is out of hand how homosexuality is being exposed.
Wtf how could they continue with the story when you basically showed us they are both at fault Her for exposing them to HIV and them for beating them up for it...
There representative should clean house first then clean the streets
I KNOW WHY PEOPLE HAVE PROBLEMS UNDERSTANDING THIS SEX WORKERS , IS THE OLDEST PROFESION IN THE WORLD , NOT ALL MEN ARE MARRIED GIVE THEM A BREAK !, AND RESPECT THEM!!
How easy is it to get into France? Got to love people going to a country that isn’t theirs and demanding things. I could care less if they’re transgender but if you come to a new country then contribute. Don’t be a leach or criminal.
Buying sex is illegal but selling isnt? Wtf? That makes no sense.
So when you buy a prostitute, only the buyer is gonna be imprisoned while the prostitute will just walk free? Cn someone explain
This world needs prayer and repentance..."Yeshua (Jesus Christ) is the way"
Is this consider false advertisement ?
i'm transgender. but,i'm not prostitute.i'm always studying hard and working.but,everybody think i'm prostitute.it's not fair.always depressed always think about suicide.
Stay strong darling, I feel your pain. Try to surround yourself with positive and accepting people that lift you up.
You are brave for choosing to live in your own truth. But one cannot be brave without hardships, and no one can be heroic without the struggle for freedom.
I applaud your will to live. To live in truth. ^-^
But for the record, there is nothing wrong with prostitution. Besides the fact that most modern day humans look down on it. But people look down on prostitution, that's _their own personal problem._ Perhaps one day they will learn the value of introspection.
So I wouldn't worry about what those people think of you anyway. They are the ones with the issue, not you.
I have thought about why so many transgender’s think about suicide. I’m no expert on any of this, just trying to make sense of it. When a Transgender is going through all of the changes, it has to take a toll on them. Their bodies are changing when taking female hormones or male hormones. They should reach out and find someone they can talk to, help them a difficult time in their life. I myself would think of other options rather than suicide.
Why would you care what other people think? I do think about suicide to, but i don't do it. (i am not trans btw)
Marianne you need to love yourself unconditionally and act out your self-love.That can change things.
Don't be a prostitute, it's too dangerous. Either you face dangerous people or diseases. So find safer ways to get income.
Q vida tan dura pobres mujeres q Dios las proteja
😂
Why so much hate to these womans if they only offer a service in order to cover a need! The need of sex which customers pay with money!!
Slay these insidious beasts
I didn't know Paris is not safe after 10 pm!!!
these men have a lot of muscles. They should beat back their johns.
you're cruel and disgusting
80% are trans? So solicitation there is not illegal, and the clients only get a fine?
WOW
Yep your justice system is broken.
80% are transgender?? Really? That is surreal in my life her in Minnesota.
They should be able to fight back, man to man
I’ll see myself out. 🚪🚶🏾♂️
Best advice: not looking for risk sex , period.
DUH , with France being now Islamic what do you expect
You win the most insipid comment of the month!