❤ Same!!! I remember this cover more than the original and I love this much more for some reason... His wife is lucky! THAT'S IT! I am buying my husband a keyboard and sending him for piano and voice lessons!!!
+Isojoki I know I remember listening to him years ago and I literally just stumbled onto him videos again while I was looking for Tool covers. What happened to him? I checked his website and that is offline too. As a native North New Jersian as him, I hope he is ok.
Beautiful time when true artists played music with passion for the love of it and didn't care about patreon and monetisation. 14 years later and I still listen to your cover every 6 months or so. Thanks mate!
This is an example of true musicianship and staying true to form. You didn't push your own vocal style on the song like so many others, but you also added your own creative license to the vocals. Truly awesome! The piano in addition is just an added beautiful bonus to it all. This vid may be 12 years old, but it's still fantastic.
I think you should do a new version of this, 13 years later for all of us who have loved this for so long. I'd really dig it man. I'm sure everyone else would too!
Orestes is my favorite track of all time, which means I'm incredibly picky about the covers I hear of it. So when I say this cover rocks, you should know that I am saying that with a great appreciation of your fantastic take of this beautiful, ethereal song. Thank you for sharing your music.
I had completely forgotten about this until today when i was in the mood for tool/APC. FLAWLESS VICTORY STILL THIS MANY YEARS DOWN THE ROAD BRO. NO ONE HAS TOPPED THIS COVER EVVVERRRR
Man i am so obsessed with this song and nearly listen all covers in the youtube. But yours is way beyond amazing and so full of passion. When i wanna listen this song i listen 2 times. it's like a ritual for me: first choice is always stone and echo live (because of Billy's moody guitar solo) after that your version comes. Thanks for all your effort.
Adam, listen to me.. I've been a big fan ever since I was first introduced to your 3 Libras cover, many years ago. And no matter what, I always go back to that song because it calms me. I think you have incredible talent and your passion is undeniably noticeable.. see it in your face and body movement. I know this is your way of expressing your emotions. Please share more and don't ever stop sharing, cause after a long day, you're what keeps us inspired ♡ Your music makes me feel so good after a long stressful day. No words can explain, it just puts me in a beautiful state of mind. You're so addictive, as well. Please keep on ♡
Whenever I see individual covers of songs, I start off skeptical. Usually my skepticism is proven right. This one just blew me away. Absolutely amazing.
Not a bad time in my life, not sleep deprived, nothing wrong at all. I just stumbled upon this, and for the first time since I heard this song as a teen, i'm teared up. This record was my youth, but seeing this and hearing this, just might have helped my adulthood. Thanks monroe, you're an amazing person.
never gets old... and it's been 13 years. as old as my son. but never have I heard any better cover of this song. And not even talking about 3 libras yet.
You are the sexiest most mesmerizing guy on earth all because you played the shit out of this piano and sang this beautiful song!!! Great just absolutely great!!! Well done
Just read a comment on a different channel where someone said that Video was the best piano cover ever.... I beg the differ THIS is the best piano cover.
This is my favorite apc song, and you sir have the voice of an angel and it just goes extremely hard with the piano. Great work man!! just wish there was a studio quality recording
I discovered this rendition nearly a decade ago and still as far as soul wrenching, depressive episode wallowing, oblivion evoking tunes go . . . this one nails the fuck out of it
Man I watched this all those years ago and thought it was so awesome. I still think it is one of my favorite renditions to this day. Hope all is well and your still making music
I was reading things while listening and then your voice hit. I thought,"Sill Maynard, you can't cover your own songs!" But it's this guy!! Good shit, guy. Good shit.
You have my highest compliments, nobody can pull off what you just did... That was amazing, you have a wonderful voice and your piano played off very well with it. Utter harmony, bravo.
It’s still crazy to me that this guy ended up playing in Billy’s side band for a while. I got to see them at The Viper Room and it was a killer show. This is still one of my favorite covers of all time.
God, i can't even explain how I love this song. The best song ever written and you reinterpreted it very well. Loved your beautiful voice. Uff, I can't believe it was 17 years ago :)
This is one of my favorites from APC and man you killed it. Great voice man. I actually wasn't just thinking of Maynard's voice the whole time like most covers I've heard.
Ashes Divide (commonly typeset as ASHES dIVIDE, to fit their logo) is an American rock band formed by guitarist Billy Howerdel, who had also formed A Perfect Circle. Howerdel is the primary songwriter, musician, producer, and vocalist for the band. The touring lineup consists of Jeff Friedl on drums, Matt McJunkins on bass, Andy Gerold on lead guitar and Adam Monroe on piano/keyboards.
15 years later and I still come back to listen to the best cover of this song ever made
Same here !!!!
17 today actually
His wife must be extremely lucky - just imagine hearing that in your living room! Still can't stop listening to this after 14 yrs!!
I what to make happier my wife too.. she is damn tired of my guitar riffs and solos.. I just need to kick my ass for buying and start playing.
Right! Like I always remember this cover!
@@CheerfullyCynical829sad...
Same. I come back and watch this video a few times a year. I miss APC
❤ Same!!! I remember this cover more than the original and I love this much more for some reason... His wife is lucky! THAT'S IT! I am buying my husband a keyboard and sending him for piano and voice lessons!!!
years later and i still find this amazing
i agree
george coggins
10 years and im still here
Hell yeah. Good bumps on the back of the neck good. Vicarious is fucking amazing. I prefer his version to the real version.
I love this version, does not lose to the original
Years later I still come back to find this same comment and feel at ease.
15 years later and this is still the best cover of this song that exists
This is timeless. I still come back to it all the time. This feels like a part of me - my journey, my life, my story. Wild.
Me too
I was 14 when i first heard this. i'm 24 now. Holy shit.
Laura Stephenson I feel that! I was 13 and now I’m 19 and find myself back here again. Wonderful video
@@autumn3341 Now 26 yrs old
ahhhhahah
I was 17, currently 31
I was like 11 or 12. Its a year later and i am 13 now
I remember when I first watched this 10 years ago. That's right, this is over 10 years old. I was 22, now I'm 32. What the FUCK happened???
+Isojoki Wish he'd come back. Can't even seem to find him anymore.
+Isojoki I know I remember listening to him years ago and I literally just stumbled onto him videos again while I was looking for Tool covers. What happened to him? I checked his website and that is offline too. As a native North New Jersian as him, I hope he is ok.
I ask myself same question everyday
I too hope he's ok as well and I too haven't seen this video in years I missed it
oh my god, it's about to be 20 years in a few years
One of the first videos I ever found on here. I'm 30 now. God damn I love this.
IvoninTuretsky same I remember this from 2007, crazy how time Flys
Beautiful time when true artists played music with passion for the love of it and didn't care about patreon and monetisation. 14 years later and I still listen to your cover every 6 months or so. Thanks mate!
So true
Heard this like 15 years ago and came back to it today
This is an example of true musicianship and staying true to form. You didn't push your own vocal style on the song like so many others, but you also added your own creative license to the vocals. Truly awesome! The piano in addition is just an added beautiful bonus to it all. This vid may be 12 years old, but it's still fantastic.
TylerMcLean thank you for the feedback 🙏🏻
I think you should do a new version of this, 13 years later for all of us who have loved this for so long. I'd really dig it man. I'm sure everyone else would too!
man i've listened to this so many times that when i hear that warmup sound on the piano before the song i already feel happy
I've been watching this video for 10 years and I continue to return to it.
Gorgeous! You really do sound like Maynard himself here!
Orestes is my favorite track of all time, which means I'm incredibly picky about the covers I hear of it. So when I say this cover rocks, you should know that I am saying that with a great appreciation of your fantastic take of this beautiful, ethereal song. Thank you for sharing your music.
Adam come back and give us more where did you go this world needs you
pasquale de siervi
He is the Keyboardist for APC
Wow you're right.....
I thought he played keyboard for Ashes Divide for awhile...(Not APC)
Who is this guy? Love and miss him!
17 years have passed... I've lost count of how many times I've listened and watched over those years.
Still The best cover of this I have heard =)
I had completely forgotten about this until today when i was in the mood for tool/APC. FLAWLESS VICTORY STILL THIS MANY YEARS DOWN THE ROAD BRO. NO ONE HAS TOPPED THIS COVER EVVVERRRR
Man i am so obsessed with this song and nearly listen all covers in the youtube. But yours is way beyond amazing and so full of passion. When i wanna listen this song i listen 2 times. it's like a ritual for me: first choice is always stone and echo live (because of Billy's moody guitar solo) after that your version comes. Thanks for all your effort.
💯 % best cover of this song EVER STILL!
Adam, listen to me.. I've been a big fan ever since I was first introduced to your 3 Libras cover, many years ago. And no matter what, I always go back to that song because it calms me.
I think you have incredible talent and your passion is undeniably noticeable.. see it in your face and body movement. I know this is your way of expressing your emotions. Please share more and don't ever stop sharing, cause after a long day, you're what keeps us inspired ♡ Your music makes me feel so good after a long stressful day. No words can explain, it just puts me in a beautiful state of mind. You're so addictive, as well. Please keep on ♡
Don't let anyone tell you "You'll never be as good as Maynard!" because this is your personal perfection.
when you coming back is the question........
Musician of 15+ years and just want to clarify this guy is the real deal.
Seriously great man.
Whenever I see individual covers of songs, I start off skeptical. Usually my skepticism is proven right. This one just blew me away. Absolutely amazing.
10 years and 2 days ago...I would love to hear more covers like this nowadays
Never gets old dude...
Discovered thjs in 2007 maybe...and have come back to this guy literally a few times a week ever since.
Adam, whats up g. A song of yours I really dug, but am unable to find anymore is "Something beautiful". Maybe you still have it in the ole' vault?
September 2020 and still listening to this beautiful track
Eu sou brasileira adoro essa musica, aqui quase ninguém conhece. Ótima interpretação. Adorei!
Wow, this is the best perfect cover of all the time, you left me speechless
he left me weak and powerless *wink wink
Sir, out-fucking-standing. You've humbled a fellow musician with this one.
@@MikeButters-z2r 🙏
Found in 2020 better late than never. This is an amazing cover :) great job !
Not a bad time in my life, not sleep deprived, nothing wrong at all. I just stumbled upon this, and for the first time since I heard this song as a teen, i'm teared up. This record was my youth, but seeing this and hearing this, just might have helped my adulthood. Thanks monroe, you're an amazing person.
Rukx Gaming I’m humbled by your compliment man. Thanks for sharing 🙏🏻
I still can't help loving this cover. Again. And again.
Used to watch all your vids in high school. They still blow my mind at age 30. Keep doing your thing.
Soooo Incredible... All of it
I've watch this almost everyday for almost four years. I'm not tired of it yet.
Your voice was made for this song. Bravo .. wow.
never gets old... and it's been 13 years. as old as my son. but never have I heard any better cover of this song. And not even talking about 3 libras yet.
Haven't found many good APC covers. This this is not good either, it's fcuking excellent!
Well done!
Jason Reamer 👍
2022 and still the best cover there is for this song
Aug 2020 and still loving this!
That power was spot on in that middle/end part
PLEASE COME BACK!!!!!!!!
I’m so glad I am not the only one who has come back to this cover YEARS later! Love it ❤
12 years later and only 61 people were able to snip away and severe the umbilical residue to hit the dislike button.
Such a beautiful voice
Amazing vocal, the best one I've heard aside from Maynard. keep it up man.
I remember finding this back in old school yt days. It's like a remnant of a better time.
so nice song.. hes charming and the voice is so lovely
btw. my real name is oreste..
I must have come back to this countless times.
You are the sexiest most mesmerizing guy on earth all because you played the shit out of this piano and sang this beautiful song!!! Great just absolutely great!!! Well done
I come back to this song every few days. Great cover. Fantastic, really. It's been 3 yrs I've been coming back. I don't plan to stop.
57 dislikes wtf this is fantastic
15ish years later I still come back to this and always love it. Thank you.
5000 of those views have to be me XD
Jordan Stangl I know right
Me too.
And... I'm back! Still killing it. Yall check out his new uploads too!!
Your covers are just too damn good. I come back to them many times every year. This is otherworldly beautiful.
Years upon years later I still listen to this song. Thank you
Still come back to this
Just read a comment on a different channel where someone said that Video was the best piano cover ever.... I beg the differ THIS is the best piano cover.
I've been watching this everyday for at least 3 years.
This is my favorite apc song, and you sir have the voice of an angel and it just goes extremely hard with the piano. Great work man!! just wish there was a studio quality recording
Thank you! 😁🙏
I NEVER hear anyone sing Maynard nearly as well as you do. it was absolutely amazing
not what i was expecting considering maynard's vocal ability. that was very good and i wish i could hear in person. good job
I discovered this rendition nearly a decade ago and still as far as soul wrenching, depressive episode wallowing, oblivion evoking tunes go . . . this one nails the fuck out of it
Man I watched this all those years ago and thought it was so awesome. I still think it is one of my favorite renditions to this day. Hope all is well and your still making music
Discovered your version back in 2007 , still love it just as much!!!!
Still the best APC cover after all these years. Absolutely unmatchable.
I've spent the last hour watching all your tool/APC covers, and my mind is still blown!
I've been listening to this for about 10 years now.
I was reading things while listening and then your voice hit. I thought,"Sill Maynard, you can't cover your own songs!" But it's this guy!! Good shit, guy. Good shit.
You have my highest compliments, nobody can pull off what you just did... That was amazing, you have a wonderful voice and your piano played off very well with it. Utter harmony, bravo.
Whenever I’m in the mood to get instantaneous full-body goosebumps, I watch this video. 🤯👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
You just gave me goosebumps. To be able to cover APC that well... didn't think it could be done.
Pulled you up on the greatest covers of all time list
I saw this probably at least 6 years ago or so. I'm 21 now...damn. Still such an amazing cover. Such an amazing singer. I hope he's doing well now
I watched this when it first came out!! Never gets old!!
🍻
@@monroe12478 Yeah, bro!! It's a beautiful song!! You own it!!
8 years.. and still fascinating as the first time.. well done..
One of the OG greats of TH-cam when it was still a baby.. and still amazing. Amazing.
not only is your piano skills are amazing but you pulled off the vocals too! that's just crazy talented man, well done :]
No words, just no words. I love Maynard, I love A Perfect Circle, and the way that you sing this song is amazing. Thank you for this moment.
This is my favorite APC song. You did it justice and then some. ABSOLUTELY BLOWN AWAY!
Just incredible, man…. Been listening for 15 years so far
You're talent is without a doubt top tier...
Best cover of my favorite A Perfect Circle song.
It’s still crazy to me that this guy ended up playing in Billy’s side band for a while. I got to see them at The Viper Room and it was a killer show. This is still one of my favorite covers of all time.
My friend and I watch this video repeatedly. Beautiful rendition.
AMAZING vocals dude, I never could've believed someone would do this track justice but you have. Keep it up buddy.
Beautiful piano playing, man. Brought me to tears and the original song doesn't do that. Please keep posting content like this.
God, i can't even explain how I love this song. The best song ever written and you reinterpreted it very well. Loved your beautiful voice.
Uff, I can't believe it was 17 years ago :)
😊🙏 different world back then
Been listening to this song for years. ... N it still makes me knees weak. Thanks
I always come back to this. So beautiful.
Nothing makes me as happy as this song, right now. You. Are. Awesome.
This is one of my favorites from APC and man you killed it. Great voice man. I actually wasn't just thinking of Maynard's voice the whole time like most covers I've heard.
the control in your voice in something to admire.
Ashes Divide (commonly typeset as ASHES dIVIDE, to fit their logo) is an American rock band formed by guitarist Billy Howerdel, who had also formed A Perfect Circle. Howerdel is the primary songwriter, musician, producer, and vocalist for the band. The touring lineup consists of Jeff Friedl on drums, Matt McJunkins on bass, Andy Gerold on lead guitar and Adam Monroe on piano/keyboards.
Congratulations. One of the best covers I've ever seen on TH-cam. Maynard would love this.
I am so amazed by the skill of this man. I hope that the band had heard this.