It's very meaningful that you are vlogging to let the general public know the challenges that wheelchair users face in their daily activities. This is the 21st century and it's time that society and the general public, including those in both the public and private sectors offering services to the consuming public, be fully aware and empathetic towards the needs of wheelchair users in public spaces.
As far as malls go, K11 Musea's pedestrian navigation is a complete and utter disaster. (This is very unlike most other malls, especially those by Sun Hung Kai and Swire, in Hong Kong which are first rate. ) Sure, everything is the latest and "state of the art" at K11 Musea. But the disaster is in not getting the basics right. Examples: (1). Information booth should be the easiest thing to find in any mall. Not so at K11 Musea. And then when you do find it, you have to queue up like some cinema ticketing line just to ask for simple directions. (2) When you get to the lifts on the ground floor, you struggle to find the lift buttons. Then you find two buttons on a book in a display case which you're not quite sure if it's part of the fancy decor of the mall or actually buttons to hail the lifts. I get it, the mall's concept is, shall we say, "avant garde lite" but surely function should take priority over form? What's the point of getting the form to confuse the function? (3) When you get to the upper floors (example the outdoor parkette area), there's no clear sign to indicate that a short detour gets you to some restaurants. Instead, as soon as you get out from the lifts on that floor, you're greeted by a parkette and a bewilderment over whether there's anything else (i.e. restaurants) besides the parkette. Quite a few people have commented to me that upon reaching the parkette floor and not knowing or seeing any indications of restaurants on that floor, proceeded to turn back and went back down to the ground floor only to be told that there were indeed restaurants on the parkette floor or accessible from the parkette; hence they waited all over again for the lifts and went back up again. What an unfortunate farce customers are put through; not the best scenario if you were tight for time. I could go on and on. This mall, for all the investments and fancy pretensions about it, is a major fail when it comes to user-friendliness and basic navigation intelligence. Some are going to protest that you should have no problems once you get used to it; but if TST and Hong Kong in general are going to be tourist or shopping hubs, malls like K11 Musea had better go light on being fancy and instead improve on getting the basics right first. On my first visit, K11 has been a nightmare.
It's very meaningful that you are vlogging to let the general public know the challenges that wheelchair users face in their daily activities. This is the 21st century and it's time that society and the general public, including those in both the public and private sectors offering services to the consuming public, be fully aware and empathetic towards the needs of wheelchair users in public spaces.
thanks, We appreciatewhat you say
傷健共融社會，才是國際人權公約認可社會
本身K11 musea 都已經係一個大迷宮，又黑又暗。
見到你要係咁推斜路都鄧你辛苦，去一次shopping 手臂應該多左好多肌肉💪
同我第一次見識樓梯機呢樣野，望落真係好恐怖！
多謝你分享輪椅人士既生活方式比我哋了解，如果平時有需要幫忙我相信所有香港人都好願意協助大家嫁！
用電動輪椅比較方便，看到你有一條片講到在英國旅遊的經歷，英國眞的很照顧行動不便及老人家，我都是受益者。
推薦大家睇Chairman椅人，其實台灣都有唔少設計上只會諗健全人
我覺得無論WeTV 無障礙媒體 定 Chairman椅人 片都好好，引起大家關注，當然希望之後會改善設計
而我唔覺得香港人係自私，好像條片咁，雖然度門開唔到，但係其他人見到都會幫手開門
好的設計更加重要, 有時不是每次都可遇到幫上忙的人
輪椅女孩的頻道都不錯
辛苦晒。
沙田廣場無無障礙設施。
沙田好運中心，輪椅人士要走危險的停車場。前陣子，剛翻新商場，也不增建無障礙通道。見過長者經好運中心去街市，在好運中心石級跌倒。
多謝主持分享！妳越來越美麗！
其實k11musea 都要睇新翼定舊翼嗰邊moma係屬於麗晶酒店舊果part 黎即是舊嘅新世界中心，無障礙設施可能未必咁完善，因為麗晶酒店翻新仲未開幕唔知道到時酒店果邊會唔會有電梯可以通到都要等佢12月開幕先知! 港鐵站嘅出口嗰陣時係都係新世界中心舊嘅一part嚟㗎！記唔記得以前崇光同埋亞馬遜熱帶雨林果度係屬於改建既，加上十幾年前KCRC.九鐵對無障礙設施更加冇乜觀念所以都唔怪得晒佢哋既！（雖然我都唔係好鍾意新世界）始終呢個項目雖然係新商場，但係有啲設施仲係沿用番以前新世界中心商場嘅系統翻新未必真係砍掉重建咁浪費都要體諒吓！
而戲院方便,都要睇下floorplan 佈局,通常都係方便消防逃生放第一位所以輪椅位係會安排係近出入口嘅位置,如果佢入口係喺銀幕嗰邊咁多數都係坐第一行㗎喇,較少戲院係由尾入嘅都有嘅,寶琳嘅mcl 新都城戲院, 長沙灣d2 cgv 戲院輪椅位就係最後嗰行!
但係其實真係唔好記雞蛋上挑骨頭既!我睇得出佢哋喺無障礙上面有出過力嘅!呢啲luxury嘅商場,當然無障礙設施會多好多喇!但係傷健人士係咪真係會日日去呢?但係我覺得要鬧就係鬧領展同房署設計嘅商場,咁多年嚟都係咁失敗,無障礙設施係負分嘅!扶手電梯有上冇落,人口老化屋邨設施有賣咗畀領展呢啲孤兒仔先至慘呀嘛!就算領展整返部扶手電梯,都唔想閂咗個商場重整,變咗有扶手電梯都要上幾級樓梯,同埋佢係住喺果度日日都要去呢個商場!甚至一定要繞個商場先至返到屋企先至慘呀!如果你有機會拍嘅我希望你過嚟小西灣商場睇下乜乜叫做負分設計!
仲有呀其實見到坐輪椅好多人都好樂意幫你地嘅但係可能係你興奮得滯啦,人哋被推開度門,你唔好唔好未固定到度門就衝入去,一定係要畀推門嗰個固定咗位置先入呀,同埋都呼籲下啲你哋啲朋友尤其是電動輪椅嘅要特別注意車速同安全!
多謝你咁詳細嘅意見呀！的確好多舊商場嘅無障礙設施慘不忍睹🥲
@@boxxcast無障礙以人為本設計唔單止為輪椅使用，嬰兒車，寵物車，救護車擔架床都可以使用， 現行法例只保障消防通道暢通無阻，冇加入無障礙通道功能， 涉嫌違反歧視殘疾條例， 大陸關口一早有無障礙通道， 香港真係落後過大陸，莫講話英美歐先進國家，影響國際城市形象
辛苦了!歡迎來澎湖體驗無障礙旅遊~
小編我也很喜歡澎湖～
@@wetvhk 在帶您菊島上山下海~
所謂嘅無障礙設施都係比電動或者有人推車，所有設施一啲都唔方便手動輪椅，
設計上充分表現出香港人嘅自私，只會諗健全嘅大部份人。
其實k11 musea 只係一部分係全新㗎咋,好多嘢都係舊新世界中心改建而成㗎!唔好講到香港人咁自私,只係九鐵出口,麗晶酒店同以前尖沙咀崇光亞馬遜森林餐廳嗰個地庫商場都係舊新世界中心嚟!
其實唔係只諗健全嘅人，係錢，好多嘅錢，無障礙設施係要好多錢，所以大部分地產商都只會提供基本嘅設施，現行新鴻基新起嘅商場無障礙會做得比較完善方便
其實佢呢個商場已經算好，係難行唔方便，但佢起碼叫有人幫，好多商場，如果有番咁上下年資係根本去唔到，有d就叫你去搭貨𨋢，又危險又要等，有時真係好無助
不過最大問題正常人好鍾意用係無障礙
霸住商場斜路，𨋢前面已經有自動電梯但一定要搭𨋢
Love you rabi yim
其實現在很多輪椅人士都轉為電動輪椅，一來輕快些，二來手亦沒太累......
這商場是新式商場，無障礙設施咁少，仲想去睇睇...
但同時用手動輪椅較輕便，同埋可以維持身體機能，各有各好～
個通道冇人真系好恐怖
屯門市廣場的嘉禾戲院，輪椅座位是最後一排的，可以享受到成個屏幕
有些影院是安排得好好， 如圓方的影院
多謝介紹
萬水千山，千辛萬苦。太難了。
多謝你支持～
鄭先生需要注意坐輪椅人的需要！
新商場咁樣正路唔會批積.唔符合建築條例
我家人用輪椅，我每次去k11都好怕地底隨道條斜路，真係好難推😢
我又多口一句，好多戲院都係要第一行就係輪椅位，如果睇戲嘉禾黃埔輪椅位就係戲院最後排，這點幾好，而且黃埔站揀啱出口係電梯直上地面，然後入戲院所在那個商場都係有4部電梯直達2樓
不過嘉禾黃埔有係住宅區定位，唔係所有戲都上，k11這類多rooms的戲院就多啲戲嘅選擇，但第一行真係令人卻步
手推輪椅真係一大考驗！
@@samanman8335 諗住新戲院會設計得好啲，點知全部都係第一行😭
@@wetvhk 新戲院間間院都比較細、好多時都係入門口就係螢幕然後向上發展，結果輪椅位就係近門口嘅第一排😢
美女，点解你唔用轮椅向后个方式向前用脚一只脚踏地推地下向前推论椅行去呢？这会更方便轻松好快的，试一下啦。好有帮助架。祝福你🙏🙏🙏
好似無咩指示牌
為何不用電動輪椅呢？ 你很有勇氣柏力
Rabi佢因為唔想依賴電動輪椅令到手部退化，所以一直堅持用普通輪椅訓練雙手力量，真心Respect🥲
@@wetvhk可以分兩部用， 一部用來代步，一步用來跳舞， 多一步後備維修都方便
你這套片是一年前的, 那麼你現在換了電動輪椅未呀?
rabi 暫時考更更換輪椅
在你那套片裡真的是頗疲倦，你考慮更換電動的便對了。
RABI沒有換電動輪椅，用了就不能開車了
@@wetvhk 明白，謝謝您。
招呼周到
補多句，荷里活廣場我又係唔知點由鑽石山地鐵站過到去荷里活廣場？
呢個有機會我地去研究下！
@@wetvhk 我上次推咗兩個不同出口，一個係龍翔道對面，條大馬路晚上睇唔到有無有升降機的天橋
另一個出去咗一個似係房協嘅商場，但原來唔近荷里活廣場
跟住我已推到無力，於是和坐係輪椅的家人死死氣原地鐵離開🥺
@@samanman8335 原來正門旁邊有升降機指示～ 可以參考下面個網址
www.freeguider.com/hk/venues/Hollywood-plaza-disable-shopping
@@wetvhk 啊！可能我發雞盲😅。不過上次面對的難處是我推輪椅由地鐵站乘升降機上地面時，我見到的2個地面出口都唔近荷里活廣場
對不需推輪椅而言，地鐵有個出口係有行人扶手電梯🛗上和落連接荷里活廣場正門。而上咗地面後，以我望住荷里活廣場正門，望住這個正門向右行是有商場內升降機上落各層
@@samanman8335 好多地鐵站都係得一邊有升降機，輪椅要兜大圈先去到目的地🥲🥲
As far as malls go, K11 Musea's pedestrian navigation is a complete and utter disaster. (This is very unlike most other malls, especially those by Sun Hung Kai and Swire, in Hong Kong which are first rate. )
Sure, everything is the latest and "state of the art" at K11 Musea. But the disaster is in not getting the basics right.
Examples:
(1). Information booth should be the easiest thing to find in any mall. Not so at K11 Musea. And then when you do find it, you have to queue up like some cinema ticketing line just to ask for simple directions.
(2) When you get to the lifts on the ground floor, you struggle to find the lift buttons. Then you find two buttons on a book in a display case which you're not quite sure if it's part of the fancy decor of the mall or actually buttons to hail the lifts. I get it, the mall's concept is, shall we say, "avant garde lite" but surely function should take priority over form? What's the point of getting the form to confuse the function?
(3) When you get to the upper floors (example the outdoor parkette area), there's no clear sign to indicate that a short detour gets you to some restaurants. Instead, as soon as you get out from the lifts on that floor, you're greeted by a parkette and a bewilderment over whether there's anything else (i.e. restaurants) besides the parkette. Quite a few people have commented to me that upon reaching the parkette floor and not knowing or seeing any indications of restaurants on that floor, proceeded to turn back and went back down to the ground floor only to be told that there were indeed restaurants on the parkette floor or accessible from the parkette; hence they waited all over again for the lifts and went back up again. What an unfortunate farce customers are put through; not the best scenario if you were tight for time.
I could go on and on. This mall, for all the investments and fancy pretensions about it, is a major fail when it comes to user-friendliness and basic navigation intelligence. Some are going to protest that you should have no problems once you get used to it; but if TST and Hong Kong in general are going to be tourist or shopping hubs, malls like K11 Musea had better go light on being fancy and instead improve on getting the basics right first. On my first visit, K11 has been a nightmare.
Yes, K11 Musea is a nightmare for us, it is a maze!!
your feedback fantastic
即係少一個地方去，講完！
我們會繼續找出無障礙陷阱
@@wetvhk 好在有你哋！👍👍👍
講真現時香港政府從來唔會帮助弱勢社群，富豪除外，如果你係老懵董要去KII，相信24小時內全部有無障礙通道
下屆特首應該選鄧小平個仔鄧樸方做
唔睇都唔知道原來香港在無障礙設施的設施咁落後😢
客觀講，整體無障礙設施近年喺唔同殘疾團體爭取推動下已經進步緊。 我哋都希望拍多啲片， 等更多公共或商業機構可以了解到將來起新嘅設施時， 可以做到咩令殘疾人士無障礙咁使用呢啲設施。
在一個全港最新又最豪華的商場， 看到你咁辛苦上上落落，基本上可以話係唔歡迎長者及傷殘人士。客觀唔到😮💨
@@raymond1501香港貴為國際城市， 唔止追唔上英美，亦追唔上大陸，羅湖關口一早有無障礙通道方便輪椅人士。
舖王個仔為一條通道用多2.2億買個舖打通嚟做。
現行法例只保障消防通道暢通無阻，冇保障埋無障礙通道，冇將歧視殘疾條例同消防條例睇齊平等看待。
建議政府重新審視建築物消防通道要加入無障礙以人為本設計，方便輪椅車，嬰兒車，寵物車， 救護車擔架床......等等都能使用。
冇乜事最好就唔好去這地方，好邪門呀！
要逐個找出有障礙的地方，讓他們改善
此地只係一個偽善又俗不可耐的商業空間,沒必要無需到此地,留返給虛偽人士集中地.
哇，你这么有眼力，一眼就看出这个地方偽善又俗不可耐，那你肯定是天生的商业天才了！
大陸關口都有無障礙通道，莫講話落後於歐英美先進國家，甚至落後大陸，淨識用大陸磚材鋪地板牆身充門面， 有fashion冇function漠視無障礙以人為本設計
幾百萬整电動升降台吾識用普通斜台正垃圾😭🤬💩