These 3 „so called judges“ i doubt if they have enough music knowledge and experience to criticize Amber. She sings internationally more than 10 years. For sure she understood the Song and interpreted in her own way. Personally love to see her more in china‘s stage but not in this kind of show and get downgraded by them.
If she were to continue going to show like this where there are "judge" to judge you. I don't think its a good choice for her. Hopefully she get to shine at better stage
where did they find these "judges"? is so embarrassing! 1st judge) 冯晓荔, tried to be a singer, but never won any competitions, no records, no songs... so daring, claiming Amber can't sing as well as other "judges". 2nd judge) won't even show his face or name, goodness me, he should really stay at home, he is in the wrong industry. 3rd judge) 王茗 released 2 songs... um... I think Amber should be judging him instead... I'm confused. 张学友 did say before, he is not sure where these "judges" come from, and if they know music at all.
It's so weird to see Amber on such huge stages after seeing her live in Salt Lake City on a small stage close up. She is the most humble, sweet, and funny person. I loved her in F(X) and I love her still.
I don't know who are they who are judging her! But I can relate with that yellow shirt guy, If I meet Amber and want to explain how much she affected on me, I would definitely cry
Who are these ppl to judge amber lmao, they are NOTHING compared to her Amber’s message is really sincere and I hope she doesn’t care about the criticism because A LOT of people supports her
Stop judging Amber Liu, even you trying to that We still like Amber more and protect her for whatever she does. Only stupid person don't understand that.😤
Why did you Zhejiang tv take away her singing of singing 爱情错过 ??? You had it uploaded last night and now u replace with the criticism video only !!!! Why ?????
![Amber刘逸云专访：最想合作的导师是？五官挑战不敢相信自己的眼睛 | 乐见大牌[20210508] | 腾讯音乐TME | 2021音乐流行](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/F-o6VboA0zU/mqdefault.jpg)
![Amber刘逸云专访：最想合作的导师是？五官挑战不敢相信自己的眼睛 | 乐见大牌[20210508] | 腾讯音乐TME | 2021音乐流行](/img/tr.png)
好贊同那位小胖和他隔壁的女生說的!Amber真的很棒很帥 每一次的舞台都是很棒👍🏼👍🏼
不明白这节目请这些路人评委来做什么，说质疑Amber老师的业务能力，说蛮多瑕疵，又没有说瑕疵在哪里。真的希望这节目早点结束糊糊算了！
@UCbUIDvxrE_ODOZdfhvpZ1SQ 查了查他们好像是网红来的🤔网红点评专业歌手
Pro trick: you can watch series at Kaldrostream. Been using them for watching loads of movies lately.
@Enrique Armani yea, I've been using kaldroStream for months myself :)
那個說覺得表演太開心了跟歌不符合我覺得沒問題，畢竟每個人解讀歌曲的方式都不一樣，amber的表演不合那位評委的口味那是業界內很常見的事，但其他那些批評她專業性的傢伙是在逗我嗎???說什麼沒有在座的音樂創作者唱的好，別給其他人挖坑好嗎。還有說瑕疵滿多的那位，也不具體說說哪裡沒唱好就來批評我愛豆，出來跟我單挑吧🤬
@@isagi93315 人家想要走丁太升郭导路线嘛~
好可愛啊~~
說的真好~
雖然當初公司沒有好好的力捧~
但人氣跟銷量還有實力都比現在想紅的人高太多了
真的很可惜了團體
根本就是键盘侠来到幕前直diss爱豆，不理解这个节目为什么找这些人来，二代的amber让他们说成这样真是无语
Amber不需向不懂她的人證明自己😉
妳一直都做的很好~~❤
Amber&Kelly!!!雙廚狂喜🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
Amber詮釋的很棒，尤其搭配他後面的介紹詞說的，我認為那些不喜歡他這次表演的，應該是被原本的意境限制住了，詮釋方式很多種，有人會不喜歡也是能理解～
Omg Amber好酷 表达出来的东西也好酷 proud of this cutie!
You did great, Amber. You’re the best!
These 3 „so called judges“ i doubt if they have enough music knowledge and experience to criticize Amber. She sings internationally more than 10 years. For sure she understood the Song and interpreted in her own way. Personally love to see her more in china‘s stage but not in this kind of show and get downgraded by them.
If she were to continue going to show like this where there are "judge" to judge you. I don't think its a good choice for her. Hopefully she get to shine at better stage
Calm down buddy, they are arranged to criticise Amber to catch your eyes. By the way, they are not judges, just some celebrities on tiktok.
@@amberliu6163 the show named 為歌而贊, an be watched in you tube.
@@amberliu6163 sorry , no eng sub
where did they find these "judges"? is so embarrassing!
1st judge) 冯晓荔, tried to be a singer, but never won any competitions, no records, no songs... so daring, claiming Amber can't sing as well as other "judges".
2nd judge) won't even show his face or name, goodness me, he should really stay at home, he is in the wrong industry.
3rd judge) 王茗 released 2 songs... um... I think Amber should be judging him instead... I'm confused.
张学友 did say before, he is not sure where these "judges" come from, and if they know music at all.
很好很有感情的歌聲，
聽出了濃濃的感情寄托在歌曲裡面，
聽一次就感動一次。
Amber你真的非常棒！
节目为了流量也是拼了，就把前辈往坏里说…
It's so weird to see Amber on such huge stages after seeing her live in Salt Lake City on a small stage close up. She is the most humble, sweet, and funny person. I loved her in
F(X) and I love her still.
好感人
I like your voice amber, we love you 💜
0:55 “还没有在座的很多音乐创作者唱得好” ？？ “还没有”，您是说音乐创作者本来就唱得不行？另外Amber也是创作者谢谢。我搜了一下名字还是不知道你是谁
对啊 现在音乐创作者本来就唱的都很好
这些网红不懂音乐就不要乱说话😒艺术家和网红是不同的level
只不过是在厕所唱歌罢了吗🤣
I don't know who are they who are judging her!
But I can relate with that yellow shirt guy, If I meet Amber and want to explain how much she affected on me, I would definitely cry
Who are these ppl to judge amber lmao, they are NOTHING compared to her
Amber’s message is really sincere and I hope she doesn’t care about the criticism because A LOT of people supports her
I love.... BORDERS...
I don't understand anything except the part that she sang the 'borders', but i love Amber so I'm here...😊
❤ you did well
韩国那个时代的唱跳偶像，竟然业务能力问题？？？不懂瞎说
喜欢你👍👍👍💕💕💕
She sings well, love her
有實力就看的出來。加油。
少女時代 Kara f(x) 2ne1 真的都是時代的眼淚...😭
Amberrrrrrrr Liu yiyun
💜💜💜💜💜
路人到底憑什麼批評Amber，你有看過她的表演和她背後付出的的努力嗎?
不要糟蹋Amber這麼優秀的實力好嗎
Who the heck are these tiktok people thinking they are that they can judge Amber??
exactly!
好感動！但是＇場上有些張口就批評的人，讓我只覺得這是幾個根本聽不懂這前衛音樂人＇Amber在海外初回，聽到這些言論想必是很失望的。希望節目組以後請的評論人可以水平高些嗎？聽歌的範圍可以普及到全球嗎？
請問這些人有哪個開過演唱會？誰出國世界級銷量的專輯？批評指教都可以，但是請你真的站到那個可以評論的高度再來
網紅就是網紅滾回網路去 真的
amber 12年舞台經驗, 根本不用懷疑, 路人點評只是做一個話題性而已
Go amber go 💜
Why deleted the video of Amber singing? We love her singing!!
Probably because of copyright issue
Stop judging Amber Liu, even you trying to that We still like Amber more and protect her for whatever she does. Only stupid person don't understand that.😤
Who are those 3 people?? Did the first woman say Amber doesnt know the lyrics?!?!?
喜欢龚琳娜老师
Amber已經不需要別人的評論，
不只是因為這些人沒有資格，
更是因為她已經唱得動人心弦了。
这个节目请的嘉宾真的都很奇怪 之前THE9也是这样 Amber也是这样🙄🙄这个节目真的可以糊了
Yeah, there had no eng subtitle😞
第一次特別點開為歌而讚，感覺批評劉逸云的評委很沒水準（因為說不出重點感覺很貧乏），跟在末日飛船時批評唐漢霄與周深那個有的拼，節目找的歌星這麼好為啥再花錢找這種低端評委來拉低節目水平?
她其实声音很好
Amber上这个节目真的是可惜了
點名「馮曉荔」非常沒有水準，批評Amber不好，但是感覺她自己言而無物表現非常低端，她憑什麼出現在這個舞台?
Why did you Zhejiang tv take away her singing of singing 爱情错过 ??? You had it uploaded last night and now u replace with the criticism video only !!!! Why ?????
i think it's because of the copyright
copyright. most likely~
老实说剧本很明显，但是这样的剧本真的很low。
Amber唱那首爱人错过都把我给唱哭了！！！而且我当时是一边听一边开车，压根没有认真听。那些说她唱得太开心的人到底懂不懂啊？！
What happened to her video ????? She sang so well and you took it away ?????
why deleted the amber singing part?
别再想别人的想法
What show is this?
MDS algum BR aqui?! Queria tanto saber onde tem legendado 🤡🤧❣️
節目搞D咁嘅野刺激收視
內地應該稱没素質吧
百里挑一先可以成為韓國團體成員
呢D素人有咩專業性可以評價amber呢
Will there b more episodes with Amber??
這個說話令人感覺非常低端的「馮曉荔」女士之大名在TH-cam 上竟然搜尋不到，哈哈哈！這種咖還敢這樣大言不慚好丟人喔～
說Amber唱的太開心？這評審真的有聽過原唱嗎？
妈诶这些评委真的
這個節目的某些人真的不知道他們在想什麼🥲
瞎评🙄
路人也能當評委？
栏目请来的是什么所谓的评审，尽说一下气人的话。
我靠，一群不懂的瞎讲
MD 给你个超级巨星也给毁了
这不是犀利 是有病
“评委”们是觉得黑红也算红吗，那个叫王茗的抖音视频，弹唱都是假弹可搞笑了😅😅