I was 16 at the time! Thank you for reminding me of my youth. There wasn't a girl who wasn't head over heels in love with Robin! Thank you, you gave me beautiful moments!
Thank you for your music, and your words Robin. Thank you for everything. You may have left us, but your music will live forever. And the sun will shine.
Robin was 19 when he sang this song - just incredible! What a voice - I think it matured into something more polished and confident, but the way he sings this song is so touching... thank you and bless you, Robin.
Esse acidente de trem, quase tirou sua vida, 49 pessoas, morreram naquele terrível acidente, ele, tinha dezessete anos , aconteceu em novembro de 1967, a Molly, sua primeira esposa, acho que estava também nesse dia , do acidente. Meses depois no ano de 1968, eles se casaram. Tão novinho, quando cantou essa música.! Casou- se muito jovem, com apenas 18 anos , recem completados. Que saudades de Robin e Maurice, fazem muita falta! Grandes artistas, taletosos, geniais, brilhantes. Que voz , cristalina, única a do Robin. Deus, abençoe vocês. Descansem em paz! Beijos 💋 💋 💋 .
A voice from heaven. A gift from God for all of us...I think that „Saved by the bell” and „For whom the bell tolls” are the most beautiful songs of the 20th century...And „There`s a heart like mine”, „Massachusetts” too...
Hermoso de mi vida que dulce y fantástica voz escucharte es un deleite y verte tan hermoso es una fantasia mi amor eterno Robin gibb❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Певчая Птичка, любимая. Эта песня сложная к исполнению,но Робин прекрасно справился. Какой завораживающий, магнетический голос,редкость. Всех братьев нежно люблю.
Una de las mejores voces de todos los tiempos. Bella en el tono, con variedad de registros, un vibrato inigualable y además,con los años, acabó modulando la más. Te echo de menos Robin
This video is great. I've watched Robin sing this song through the years and even though each one is different, from this early one to the late 90's, it is and always will be a beautiful song!!
I like reading the compliments and praises to the amazing Bee Gees when I come across these old videos. I knew back then they would grow and become the legends they are❤
Hauntingly beautiful one of kind voice, I know Berry said Andy and Mo were like little red lights behind all the UFO'S. I think Robin is the UFO. We love you Robin. Heaven thank you for the loan!!!!!
Thank you, Robin, for blessing us with your talents. Thank you for being a part of my life growing up. I hope you and Maurice are catching up with each other...
“Written, sung and recorded in a seedy, little-known, broken-down old studio off _Denmark Street in London_. This track, believe it or not, was put down and sung purely adlib, one of many cases where the demo actually became the record. The raw intensity of the original pilot vocal proved to be more moving than anything we could achieve on the finished product- not only that, it was cheaper.” -Robin Gibb from 'Tales From the Brothers Gibb'
Robin had an excellent distinctive voice. Emily doesn't mind making a fool of herself while trying to champion Maurice Gibb. If Maurice wasn't dead, he'd be getting stalked by Emily today.
Cette voix est tout simplement "céleste", "venue du ciel". Je n'en trouve aucune de comparable. Je découvre le commentaire d'Alia après avoir mis le mien. Effectivement nous sommes d'accord pour dire qu'elle était "Heavenly" et n'a pas de semblable.
@@sking6662 WATCH THE OSCARS IM A BIG MUSIC LOVER SO I'M READY TO SEE QUEEN PERFORM AND BOHEMIAN RHAPSODY RAMI MALEK WIN🤗 THEY SHOULD DO A MOVIE ON THE BEE GEES TO
Jeff beck played guitar, and Paul McCartney the drums, on the record. It was Peter Asher's first production. He (of 'Pete and Gordon' fame, and brother to Macca's girlfriend, Jane) later produced James Taylor and others.
tiff Curtis Don't you want to be my friend, awe come in, I really a nice person, I really am. So why don't you what you want to me my friend, bahahaha....
Seems they were just lip syncing here to the recording. This performance was on the Smoothers Brothers. Robin and Maurice were only a month and half past turning 18 and Barry was 21.
He's definitely lip syncing here. It sounds exactly like the album version. That's the most amazing version and can't be reproduced! He's doing the lip syncing very well here, though. I've seen him do another lip sync many years later, and it didn't always match the singing, like he'd finish singing, but the singing recording was still going on.
You can see for example how the bass and electric guitar have no cord and the drummer is keeping it simpler than what is heard. (And is the string section hidden?) Granted, It could be that Robin is singing along to the recording, but it's just the record we are hearing. This is not a criticism of the performers. It was very common for shows to feature lip sync'ing. More an issue of sound quality than the ability of the performers. Famous shows like Top of the Pops for example always had lip sync. At any rate, it's a great song and a great group. Still sad that we lost a great singer/songwriter like ❤Robin
There is a marvelous live performance of this song in their 1974 Melbourne Concert (you can find it on TH-cam). Robin's voice is as flawless as the studio recording.@@marccoderre
Robin had the most horrible voice ever. How can you say he had a good Voice!! The one who had a beautiful loving voice was Maurice!! He should had been the Leader period!!!
Wat een prachtige stem dat Robin een gouden stem love and miss you❤❤❤
I love this. ❤❤
I was 16 at the time! Thank you for reminding me of my youth. There wasn't a girl who wasn't head over heels in love with Robin! Thank you, you gave me beautiful moments!
Thank you for your music, and your words Robin. Thank you for everything. You may have left us, but your music will live forever. And the sun will shine.
Robin was 19 when he sang this song - just incredible! What a voice - I think it matured into something more polished and confident, but the way he sings this song is so touching... thank you and bless you, Robin.
Dear Dear Robin had just turned 18 here (and he had just survived Hither Green train crash at 17 yrs old)....
Robin and molly 🎉
@dorothytrinh8334 He certainly wrote a lot of lyrics about trains and dying after that horrific scare.
Esse acidente de trem, quase tirou sua vida, 49 pessoas, morreram naquele terrível acidente, ele, tinha dezessete anos , aconteceu em novembro de 1967, a Molly, sua primeira esposa, acho que estava também nesse dia , do acidente. Meses depois no ano de 1968, eles se casaram. Tão novinho, quando cantou essa música.! Casou- se muito jovem, com apenas 18 anos , recem completados. Que saudades de Robin e Maurice, fazem muita falta! Grandes artistas, taletosos, geniais, brilhantes. Que voz , cristalina, única a do Robin. Deus, abençoe vocês. Descansem em paz! Beijos 💋 💋 💋 .
Que @@alliehamilton-calhoun162
Those beautiful, sad lyrics along with Robin's unique voice bring tears to my eyes every time.
This is just an incredible, incredible song. And to think he was only 18 or 19 years old. Incredible....
Tiff Tiff don' you want to be friends, bahahaha in...
There will be no one with a voice like that. My heart is breaking. RIP Robin. Say hi to Andy and Maurice for us.
Oh, that voice...... AMAZING!!! Gives me chills and brings tears to my eyes... no one can sing like Robin. What a gift!
YES ABSOLUTELY AGREE
I also agree
Pure and simple marvelous! Robin always was the best! Wonderful Robin!
A voice from heaven. A gift from God for all of us...I think that „Saved by the bell” and „For whom the bell tolls” are the most beautiful songs of the 20th century...And „There`s a heart like mine”, „Massachusetts” too...
Robin is just unbelievable!!!!!!!!!!!. his voice is so breathtaking . .....
Hermoso de mi vida que dulce y fantástica voz escucharte es un deleite y verte tan hermoso es una fantasia mi amor eterno Robin gibb❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Певчая Птичка, любимая. Эта песня сложная к исполнению,но Робин прекрасно справился. Какой завораживающий, магнетический голос,редкость. Всех братьев нежно люблю.
So have I. Last time I heard him sing this live was One Night Only in Vegas, and he still nailed it perfectly. Robin has always had the best voice.
Linda música. Robin meu Rei ♥️
Robin Gibb has alwyas been in a category of one, and that will never change.
Beautiful song. What a voice. Robin.
Una de las mejores voces de todos los tiempos. Bella en el tono, con variedad de registros, un vibrato inigualable y además,con los años, acabó modulando la más. Te echo de menos Robin
Y yo no sabia cuanto me mas que veo sus videos me gusyaria que estuvieses aqui pero commo era un angel lo mañaron pronto al cielo te querre siempre❤❤❤
This video is great. I've watched Robin sing this song through the years and even though each one is different, from this early one to the late 90's, it is and always will be a beautiful song!!
Robin hatte eine magische Stimme. Gänsehaut pur. Phantastisch. 😃🥰👍❣ Er hat alles richtig gemacht in seinem Leben. 😳
È Bellissima questa canzone. Amo Robin e la sua Meravigliosa voce!
I just love Robin's voice, it has so much emotion, I love his 1974 Melbourne rendition of this song.
This will be my favourite song forever!
There is a good cover by José Feliciano
José Feliciano - And the Sun Will Shine (1968)
I like reading the compliments and praises to the amazing Bee Gees when I come across these old videos. I knew back then they would grow and become the legends they are❤
random fact; my grandad was best man at Huwie Gibb's wedding. Met them once, nice guys. Nice one Robin, you were magnificent.
Great Robin Gibb!
All these three brothers have good voice!!! different but unique for each one!! that makes their harmony so perfect!!
Barry .voice is the best
For me the real unique voice was Robin's. Even Barry said people could copy his voice but not Robin's.
Tão jovem e que voz maravilhosa ainda ia nos trazer muitas emoções AMO ROBIN GIBB ALÉM DA VIDA SAUDADES INFINITA.
Robin was amazing
Hauntingly beautiful one of kind voice, I know Berry said Andy and Mo were like little red lights behind all the UFO'S. I think Robin is the UFO. We love you Robin. Heaven thank you for the loan!!!!!
Barry not Berry, respect please.....
Robin was just adorable.
Love this to bits.Romantic,moving and the best vocal ever
what a great melody. The vocals appear to be live. Impressive.
May 20th, 2012. The angels received a new lead for their choir.
Inimitabile Robin, meraviglia..
RIP Robin. Your voice lives on...
I cry 4 You Robin!!!! I love you so much. You are the best 4ever!!!
Love it!Miss you Robin
His voice was so amazing
He has the best EVER!!!!!!
Thank you, Robin, for blessing us with your talents. Thank you for being a part of my life growing up. I hope you and Maurice are catching up with each other...
I love every Bee Gees song but this one is probably my very favorite one..... I listen to it at least 3 or 4 times a day...
Is this great or what? I was always a fan, but the passing of time reveals the depth of their talent and body of work.
Auf Wiedersehen, lieber Robin. Danke für deine schöne Musik und deine wunderbare Stimme, die uns so glücklich gemacht hat.
This is the most beautiful song sung by the best singer in the world. I miss him every day. Annie morobinbarrystories
Essa música é tudo! Linda! ❤❤👍👍🇧🇷
Just gorgeous!
nuestro querido y grandioso Robin GiBB!!!💔😢
through the years they sure were cute in the 60's and even in the 70's
Pretty song. I love it when I hear songs by the Bee Gees I've never heard before. Thanks You Tube!
They recorded this as a demo in Denmark, and couldn't improve over the original concepts. so here it stays. What a beautiful and haunting melody!
great distinctive voice - enjoyed and impressed a whole generation
There will never be another voice like this : (
THE BEE GEES💖🕺👬🧑🤝🧑🌟🤩
Great!🎼🎵🎹🎸🥁🎤📀👍👏
From Hong Kong🙋♀️🌏💝🌺🥰
I love jour Voice - Robin!
Danke an die Bee Gees - for the wonderful Musik!
The very greatest forever !!!
What a beautiful song and sung by the beautiful and angelic voice, and always sung it perfect.
“Written, sung and recorded in a seedy, little-known, broken-down old studio off _Denmark Street in London_. This track, believe it or not, was put down and sung purely adlib, one of many cases where the demo actually became the record. The raw intensity of the original pilot vocal proved to be more moving than anything we could achieve on the finished product- not only that, it was cheaper.” -Robin Gibb from 'Tales From the Brothers Gibb'
a conversation in the post office would sound beautiful in the 60s ,such an angelic time.
What you hear is the first take Robin made for this song. He did another on that same night, but they chose this one.
always makes me cry, from the outset til the end ... bloody marvelous emotional song ...
This Song it is very very good.
All love Robin. Missing you.
🎶🎶🎶🎵🎵💜💜💜💜
Robin💝💝💝
love those vocals , man , . . .
Robin, voz angelical.!!!!!
More one real music. Great voice, harmonies, melody and real musical instruments..It´s a eternal song.
incredible talent most people dont realize!
2:18 "Cause love to me is life, and I live you..."
I totally agree. Simply the best voice ever!
no one to arque all of them are d best ofthe best their amazing
BRILLIANT
Love the way he says "Rain" @ 0:01
Brilliant!
Csodálatos ez a hang, ilyen nem lesz soha többé!!!
sublime
Robin had an excellent distinctive voice. Emily doesn't mind making a fool of herself while trying to champion Maurice Gibb. If Maurice wasn't dead, he'd be getting stalked by Emily today.
Cette voix est tout simplement "céleste", "venue du ciel". Je n'en trouve aucune de comparable.
Je découvre le commentaire d'Alia après avoir mis le mien. Effectivement nous sommes d'accord pour dire qu'elle était "Heavenly" et n'a pas de semblable.
Yep, they did! (good for them, sad for us)
TIFF TIFF HERE LEADING THE BEE GEE ARMY HAPPY 2019 TO ALL THE BEE GEE ARMY 🎊🥂🍾🎉✊🏾
tiffany curtis Tiff Tiff what you do'in.. just wondinging, bahahaha....
@@sking6662 WATCH THE OSCARS IM A BIG MUSIC LOVER SO I'M READY TO SEE QUEEN PERFORM AND BOHEMIAN RHAPSODY RAMI MALEK WIN🤗 THEY SHOULD DO A MOVIE ON THE BEE GEES TO
Jeff beck played guitar, and Paul McCartney the drums, on the record. It was Peter Asher's first production. He (of 'Pete and Gordon' fame, and brother to Macca's girlfriend, Jane) later produced James Taylor and others.
❤️❤️❤️
PERSONALLY I THINK ROBIN HAD BETTER VOCALS THAN BARRY DON'T GET ME WRONG BARRY'S FALSETTO WAS AMAZING BUT ROB IS JUST THE WHOLE PACKAGE 🤗
tiff Curtis Don't you want to be my friend, awe come in, I really a nice person, I really am. So why don't you what you want to me my friend, bahahaha....
Don't you want to come out and play... It would be fun to don't...
tiffany curtis we could play mud pies and I a could throw them at you....
tiffany curtis oh you think, Tiff Tiff....
🖤🖤🖤
Yeah, okay!
👏👏👏💖💖🇪🇦
not the greatest but love em all. R.I.P Robin! XX
Seems they were just lip syncing here to the recording. This performance was on the Smoothers Brothers. Robin and Maurice were only a month and half past turning 18 and Barry was 21.
They were not lip syncing, you can watch their eyes and you can tell they are not lip syncing.....
He's definitely lip syncing here. It sounds exactly like the album version. That's the most amazing version and can't be reproduced! He's doing the lip syncing very well here, though. I've seen him do another lip sync many years later, and it didn't always match the singing, like he'd finish singing, but the singing recording was still going on.
You can see for example how the bass and electric guitar have no cord and the drummer is keeping it simpler than what is heard. (And is the string section hidden?) Granted, It could be that Robin is singing along to the recording, but it's just the record we are hearing. This is not a criticism of the performers. It was very common for shows to feature lip sync'ing. More an issue of sound quality than the ability of the performers. Famous shows like Top of the Pops for example always had lip sync. At any rate, it's a great song and a great group. Still sad that we lost a great singer/songwriter like ❤Robin
There is a marvelous live performance of this song in their 1974 Melbourne Concert (you can find it on TH-cam). Robin's voice is as flawless as the studio recording.@@marccoderre
Emily is obsessive about Maurice to the point of lunacy.
Does anyone know which TV programme this is from?
Robin had the most horrible voice ever. How can you say he had a good Voice!! The one who had a beautiful loving voice was Maurice!! He should had been the Leader period!!!
Emily Ortiz u're deaf
Emily Ortiz hello enlmll. En Emily ♡♡♡☆♡☆
U sound ridiculous asf. Even Barry said Robin had a beautiful unique voice so with that said stfu
Robin the best off Bee Gees ever!!!
Robbin 》》》 Barry. No comparsion.
What a beautiful song and sung by the beautiful and angelic voice, and always sung it perfect.