Morocco gardens are food for the soul, I wish Morocco people would have show their gardens... they have the real spirit, the happy garden... I celebrate European people enjoy and keep them, but the real spirit is with the Morocco people
It's a european show of course they will try to put the European falaire into everything. This tradition and know-how is purely Moroccan and there is plenty of Moroccan owned and built gardens. These are just the few that had European investors, the builders are Moroccan anyway. The investors just brought money ...
@@denzelsmashsymptom4264 @aminaibanez5288 I’m glad you’re bringing this up! See my latest comment on this post. What a gross Eurocentric colonial view of something that isn’t even theirs.
Wonderful and magnificent Moroccan gardens! Although some of the wording is quite misleading. Gardens and breathtaking architecture is a very special part of Moroccan culture and it is great that people from the European continent come and appreciate this and design their own, but these gardens origins are very much rooted in Moroccan culture and civilisation. There are thousands more beautiful gardens and riads designed, built and maintained by Moroccans across Morocco that should also be showcased!
Omg this pissed me off because some ignorant french lady used this documentary as a proof to win the argument that europeans CREATED these gardens. We let them they take everything from Moroccan gardens to Palestinian lands
I am always amazed how gardens are so much apart of the lives of all cultures, lands and people. No, matter where you are or where you go you can find a garden and people that love them. Thank you for sharing these stunning Moroccan, Moorish styled gardens. I loved see them all.
@@Ameer-dj5gj medieval was European go do some studies about the Moor's who builds Andalusia in Spain are the Muslim Moroccans in your information Islam was the biggest Civilization's if it wasn't for Islam you wouldn't have Computer's, and a lot of other thing's!
@@SilenceaboutthetruthisamuteDev what's wrong with you brother? I'm Muslim myself. It was just about your typo( evil instead of medieval) that's all.☮️
You have shown tremendous ignorance, prejudice and sheer stupidity! Only a brainwashed and ignorante perosn could make just a comment. Now ask yourself this; what and who cause this so called "darkness"?
These are so much more than stunning gardens, a beautiful fragrant lifestyle, this surely is the finest way to live, in serenity, wonder and appreciation. . . Top production all round. . . Many thanks. . . Blessings. . .
I have been enjoying the whole series. This one to me is special in that lots of foreigners came to build gardens, bringing not only plants of various of types to Morroco, but also their cultures and personal dreams. Good stories indeed.
Thank you for sharing with all of us TH-camrs in the US and the world. An outstanding country the Kingdom of Morocco and the the lush gardens preserved by Europeans and others.
Thank you for this Amazing project! You are helping this community n sane world of ours by showing the true value and dedication and potential that can be achieved with love of nature. Thank you to each and everyone who participated in this experience. There are those critics of anything they can’t have been a part of or jealous of others who sought their Sanctuary and were led to their own adventure and life in a their adopted country. One can see first hand how the amazing peoples of Morocco and the hand of God and yes, wealthy artists, entrepreneurs and writers and half-casts from Europe and elsewhere came to these magical lands as toddlers and children…they were shown so much love and respect for their home away from home that they many moons later found themselves called to return. Can we not be grateful for what has been achieved instead of being critical! Humility is demonstrated by those interviewed…and love of people and land and peace and respect for what has been given to them. REJOICE, BE GLAD 🙏🏼🩵💛
Beautiful… but I challenge titling a video “The Gardens of Morocco…”, then EXCLUSIVELY showcasing gardens designed by Europeans. I find that problematic.
@@rosemallia5252 Well… Yes, and no. You’re missing the point about agency, representation, and cultural appropriation. And I thought your presentation posited that the best and most noteworthy Moroccan gardens are those designed by Europeans, which is untrue. The gardens were certainly beautiful, but I found the conversation slightly lacking.
These gardens are created by Moroccan hands, with there marks. The only thing Europeans have created is problems of borders between African countries and stolen the furtune of people. I wonderful if the Europeans know who build ALHMBARA with its gardens?
Did you know that Morocco is the best place in the world to see the sunset? In Arabic, Morocco is known as (المغرب) Maghrib, which means the land where the sun sets.
Beautiful what he says at 45mins Islamic culture has always regarded gardens as places of contemplation and also of clear perception, they are high quality energy inputs that bring us back into harmony the way a piano tune does. Gardens are for peace offering. Peaceful interaction and a chance to breathe deeply.
Its not Islamic heaven is of different levels and every level of heaven have gardens & orchards in it Thats why islamic rulers were obsessed with the gardens. For them, its like creating a heaven on earth You can see that in persia, central asia, india and wherever they ruled
سبحان الله فجاة اصبح الاوروبيين هم من بنوا حدايق وبساتين الوداية والرباط وحدائق الرياضات في فاس ومراكش في الوقت الذي تتهافت فيها دول على المهندسين والحرفيين المغاربة لبناء حدايق وعمارة على الطراز المغربي الاندلسي. قد يكون مهندس اوروبي مثلا قام بتصميم ولكن البناء تم ويتم على يد مغاربة. الاندلسيين في الاندلس كانوا امازيغ وعرب او مسلمين بصفة عامة ولم يكونوا اوروبيين. يالله واحلين مع الجيران وطلعتو لينا نتما من جنب. هل يعلم الاوروبيين ان اجدادهم سرقوا من تراثنا وتاريخنا ومن كل بلدان افريقيا الكثير من الاشياء التي ينسبونها اليوم اليهم.
Lovely documentary but I'm not sure it is Islamic. I think this is more about traditional gardens than religious gardens. As an African, the gardens look very familiar to the beautiful gardens I saw as a child. It just shows that we are all connected by a common thread.
@@Alinorosso2003 Look around and you will see. Every region which was under the Islamic empire followed the same pattern and symbols. Anyone can recognize an Islamic heritage no matter where it is. Iran, Iraq, Turkey, India or Spain, look for yourself. This channel also made videos about those areas.
An enchanting look at the Berber past & the Islamic influence welded on it resulting on the rich mélange we se today. This comment is coming from the far southern tip of Africa also washed by the cold Atlantic ocean and instead of the Mediterranean the warm waters of the Indian ocean, the Cape of Good Hope, also with its Islamic influences mainly from Java Indonesia Malaysia & the Middle east, richly contributing to our shared culture. One word of criticism is the non offensive wording used to encapsulate the ex Andalusians living in Morocco described as having being expelled by the Christian conquerors. Technically of course it was the reconquest of a previously Christian territory conquered by the Muslims. All details are on the Internet for the historically minded. This was the spark which resulted in the Latin America, Mexico which we see today.
I am wondering why the government do not take steps to import the necessary machinery to automate / simplify some of these art works without compromising the originality of them. These people are still living the same very simple and poor life they had centuries ago. Is this fare?
You missed the point. The garden is the output of the process of gardening and cultivating the land and living that process. Plus as these people have emerged themselves in the culture. They are doing it the Moroccan way. 😊.
Agreed with the previous comment. It was off kilter all along for that reason, when it could have simply made a different claim. Then ending on a note of "dreams of the orient" or "oriental hospitality" was not in good taste. Although the gardeners themselves had some balanced perspectives. And the series is well done.
Lady don’t talk about my country s gardens left and right.There ia no such thing as islamic.Architecture especially the moroccan architecture has nothing to do with the religion pr islam.Not everything is islamic 😤😤😤😤
I had reminded them of this many times, but you know how British are, creating hostility and conflicts and stereotyping. None of the gardens in their clips have anything to do with Islam. British Christian Royal Garden. Elizabeth II Islamic and Chrisitan Garden, Prince Charles Islamic Garden, Sean Connery Islamic Garden. Salaman Rushdi's Chrisian Garden....that's their garden :)
Many of these gardens look exactly like what you find in Mexican and Mexican American homes with bougainvillea, cactus, agaves, and cannas! I don't think spiny cactus is something usually implemented in an Islamic garden because they look harsh/dangerous and it's not representative of Paradise? I'm not sure if we see lots of spiny cactus here because these gardens are designed by Europeans. The last garden was amazing.
This left a bad taste in my mouth. It feels like the narrator is trying to overplay european influences on arts and styles that were already there. Though I admire the one garden, I don't really care for these kinds of gardens. There are far more beautiful traditional gardens in Morocco than this Chop suey garden decor of european eccentricity.
The German's fantasy Garden lovely as it is with its Yoruba like ceramics show the difficulty Some, Europeans have in comprehending that the African continent has huge ranges of ethnic groups as diverse as does the Euro Asiatic continent with its blonde Caucasians in the west to the Mongoloid Asians of the east.
المغرب ارض اجتمع فيها كل شيء تحت اسم مغربة التراث والمعمار والطبخ والفن والمغاربة صنعوا حضارتهم بايديهم ولم تاتيهم من اي مكان. اين حضارة المور المغاربة؟ طمسها الاوروبيين ونسبوها الى الرومان وما تبقى نسب الى الغير .
Well, right from the beginning this presenter should have said (at the very least) that this garden was a collaboration between Moroccans and Europeans. Obviously, ALL the motifs, designs, fountains, and structures are Moroccan, Islamic/&/or Arabic, North African/& Middle Eastern-inspired art forms.
SALaM, SHLAMa, SHLOMo, SHALoM, NAMASTe, PEACe. Image A Mountain: GOD ANGeLS PRoPHETs ALL CREATiON God Almighty Sits On His Golden Throne Alone, He Shares His Throne With No Kinship, Partners, With No Desires Or Needs, With No Beginning Or End, At The Very Peak Of The Mountain.Image A Mountain: Hinduism = Vaishnavism, Shaivism, Shaktism, and Smartism. Four Vedas Are Still Mainly Monotheistic, But The Multiple Guru Books Have The Trinity & Multiple Gods. Zoroastrian = Zoroaster & Parsi. The Avesta Is Monotheistic, But They Have Added Verses Of The Trinity. Buddhist = Theravada, Mahayana and Vajrayana. Cannon Is Monotheistic, But Altered Verses State There Is A Trinity, But No God. Jewish: Hasidic Judaism, Lithuanian (Lita'im), Post-Enlightenment movements. Migration, Zionists (Datim-leumi), Anti-Zionists, Pressures of assimilation. Beta Israel (Haymanot), Crimean Karaites. The Rabbi's Added The Talmud, Applying The Jews To Many Unnecessary Rules & Regulations. They Also Amended Many Torah Verses, Like Stating The Earth Is Flat, Held By Four Angels, On Each Corner. Christian: Adamites, Arianism, Ebionites, Collyridianism, Elcesaites, Marcionism Montanism, Nazarenes, Novatianism, Ophites, Bardaisanites, Basilideans Carpocratianism, Nicolaitans, Sethianism, Simonians (sometimes considered Proto-Gnostic), Valentinianism, Agonoclita, Apostolic Brethren Beguines and Beghards, Bogomilism, Patarines, Bosnian Church Brethren of the Free Spirit, Catharism, Celtic Christianity, Donatism, Dulcinians Euchites, Fraticelli, Friends of God, Henricans, Heresy of the Judaizers, Lollardy Neo-Adamites, Paulicianism, Petrobrusians, Strigolniki, Tondrakians Constantinople Orthodox Church, Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of Italy and Malta Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America, Albanian Orthodox Diocese of America Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of Canada, Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of UK Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of Australia, Vicariate for Palestine and Jordan in the USA, Finnish Orthodox Church, Greek Orthodox Church of Crete, Monastic Community of Mount Athos, Korean Orthodox Church, Estonian Apostolic Orthodox Church, Ukrainian Orthodox Church of the USA, Ukrainian Orthodox Church of Canada, Orthodox Metropolitanate of Hong Kong, Exarchate of the Philippines, Orthodox Metropolitanate of Singapore, American Carpatho-Russian Orthodox Diocese, Greek Orthodox Church of Alexandria, Greek Orthodox Church of Antioch, Antiochian Orthodox Archdiocese of North America, Antiochian Orthodox Archdiocese of Australia, Antiochian Orthodox Archdiocese of Mexico Antiochian Orthodox Mission in the Philippines, Antiochian Orthodox Archdiocese of Chile, Greek Orthodox Church of Jerusalem, Greek Orthodox Church of Sinai, Russian Orthodox Church, Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia, Russian Orthodox Church in Finland, Japanese Orthodox Church Chinese Orthodox Church, Estonian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate) Moldovan Orthodox Church, Belarusian Orthodox Church, Philippine Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate), Patriarchal Exarchate in South-East Asia Patriarchal Exarchate in Western Europe, Patriarchal Parishes in the USA Patriarchal Parishes in Canada, Georgian Orthodox and Apostolic Church Serbian Orthodox Church, Serbian Orthodox Ohrid Archbishopric Archdiocese of Belgrade and Karlovci, Serbian Metropolitanate of Skopje Serbian Metropolitanate of Dabar, Serbian Metropolitanate of Montenegro Serbian Metropolitanate of Zagreb, Serbian Metropolitanate of Australia Romanian Orthodox Church, Romanian Metropolis of Bessarabia Romanian Metropolia of the Americas, Bulgarian Orthodox Church Diocese of North America and Australia, Cypriot Orthodox Church Orthodox Church of Greece, Albanian Orthodox Church Polish Orthodox Church, Czech and Slovak Orthodox Church Orthodox Church in America, Archdiocese of Canada, Romanian Orthodox Episcopate of America, Albanian Orthodox Archdiocese in America Exarchate of Mexico, Orthodox Church of Ukraine, Macedonian Orthodox Church The Gospel Has Had More Updates, Than Apple IOS. Islam: Sunnīsm, Shīʿīsm, Ibadism, Quranism, Non-denominational Muslims, Mahdavia, Ahmadiyya, Nation of Islam, and Sufism, Hanbali, Maliki, Hanafi, Shafi'i, Twelvers, Ismāʿīlīs, and Zaydīs. Remember None Of God's Prophets Belonged To Any Sect. Neither Did Prophet Muhammad Bring 1 Million Hadith Books, With Separate Shia & Sunni Volumes. The Ummah Has Been Lead Away By Iblis [Satan], Away From The Quran. Iblis [Satan] Has Diluted Islam [Hinduism, Zoroastrianism, Buddhism, Judaism & Christianity], With Extra Books, Which Are Not From God...
Correction. Islam dictates every facet of existence, lifestyle food, clothing, dress codes, hygiene, architecture, politics & religion . Why can't Westerners bend their minds outside of their liberal bubble culture. Oy, oy. so simple.😈 Btw way the turreted walls are eerily reminiscent of the crusader castle structures erected during their attempts 1095 - 1291, to wrest the holy city of Jerusalem back from the Muslim occupiers
Im shocjed by the opening sentences here, who ever wrote this needs to do some research into moorish , and islamic culture from which the aesthetics of these gardens emerge.
These are Moroccan gardens commissioned by Europeans and not what is implied by the countless references to "Europeans" by the narrator. Sad the effort to appropriate and deny the very people and traditions that have actually inspired you to actually create the gardens. Ofcourse the owners are Europeans and there is in some of the cases European input , flowers,etc, but the commentary spoilt to some extent of what is a beautiful video of Moroccan gardens.
Morocco gardens are food for the soul, I wish Morocco people would have show their gardens... they have the real spirit, the happy garden... I celebrate European people enjoy and keep them, but the real spirit is with the Morocco people
It's a european show of course they will try to put the European falaire into everything. This tradition and know-how is purely Moroccan and there is plenty of Moroccan owned and built gardens. These are just the few that had European investors, the builders are Moroccan anyway. The investors just brought money ...
@@denzelsmashsymptom4264 @aminaibanez5288 I’m glad you’re bringing this up! See my latest comment on this post. What a gross Eurocentric colonial view of something that isn’t even theirs.
Wonderful and magnificent Moroccan gardens! Although some of the wording is quite misleading. Gardens and breathtaking architecture is a very special part of Moroccan culture and it is great that people from the European continent come and appreciate this and design their own, but these gardens origins are very much rooted in Moroccan culture and civilisation. There are thousands more beautiful gardens and riads designed, built and maintained by Moroccans across Morocco that should also be showcased!
Omg this pissed me off because some ignorant french lady used this documentary as a proof to win the argument that europeans CREATED these gardens. We let them they take everything from Moroccan gardens to Palestinian lands
I am always amazed how gardens are so much apart of the lives of all cultures, lands and people. No, matter where you are or where you go you can find a garden and people that love them. Thank you for sharing these stunning Moroccan, Moorish styled gardens. I loved see them all.
I have never seen something this beautiful.
Thank you for sharing this spectacular garden🎉
God Almighty first created a garden... And it is the purest of all human pleasures... I love every leaf and am very passionate about the gardens.
Well said
Moroccan people have been doing beautiful Gardening in Spain called Andalusia when Europe was living in the medieval and darkness!
Mid what? Rofl..you meant medieval
@@Ameer-dj5gj medieval was European go do some studies about the Moor's who builds Andalusia in Spain are the Muslim Moroccans in your information Islam was the biggest Civilization's if it wasn't for Islam you wouldn't have Computer's, and a lot of other thing's!
@@SilenceaboutthetruthisamuteDev what's wrong with you brother?
I'm Muslim myself.
It was just about your typo( evil instead of medieval) that's all.☮️
@@Ameer-dj5gj Iam very sorry my friend I misunderstood you my English is not my first language! 🫢
You have shown tremendous ignorance, prejudice and sheer stupidity! Only a brainwashed and ignorante perosn could make just a comment. Now ask yourself this; what and who cause this so called "darkness"?
The video is enjoyable & lovely to see the gardens. The history & heritage of Morocco is wonderful.
Africa still is the center for al to visit and come share their creativity, beautiful work by tge gardners.
Grettings from morroco brother and my country morroco is one of the best countries in Africa and the world too 👳🇲🇦
These are so much more than stunning gardens, a beautiful fragrant lifestyle, this surely is the finest way to live, in serenity, wonder and appreciation. . . Top production all round. . . Many thanks. . . Blessings. . .
It is interesting to see the different styles of gardening around the world. Thank you.
The writing for his production waxes poetic. So nice...
I have been enjoying the whole series. This one to me is special in that lots of foreigners came to build gardens, bringing not only plants of various of types to Morroco, but also their cultures and personal dreams. Good stories indeed.
How wonderful. I must visit Morocco ... I must... it is clear to me now....❤
That last courtyard is an unparalleled masterpiece. 😯
so is being able to spell unparalleled correctly 😂🎉
Beautiful.Europeans created gardens on Morocco? What? Everyone knows Andalusians have the most amazing gardens, and they are not European
True!!!
😂😂 I can’t believe Europeans. This is a comedy not a documentary
Exactly
this documentary focuses on gardens created by europeans(mostly french) in morocco
That’s what I thought, but than they only mentioned those created by foreigners and only one native moroccans.
Love and light always radiates from this weekly message, and I thank Sterling, Linda, and team for this gift.
I agree the importance of gardens look at japan as well Food for the soul
Easily the best commercial I’ve ever seen.
4rabet ke events hamesha se amazing the, Finch ke saath ab aur bhi awesome ho gaye hai
Stunning
Im addicted to ur videos very therapeutic
4ra ke events Finch ke saath aur bhi dhamakedar ho gaye hain, can’t wait to join in
I love mosaic tile or just decorative tile. I would love to buy an older home that someone had put their heart and soul into the tile work.
Thank you for sharing with all of us TH-camrs in the US and the world. An outstanding country the Kingdom of Morocco and the the lush gardens preserved by Europeans and others.
artistic views
it looks very nice all the best.
4ra ke events bohot entertaining hote hain, friend ki recommendation bilkul sahi thi
Thank you for this Amazing project!
You are helping this community n sane world of ours by showing the true value and dedication and potential that can be achieved with love of nature. Thank you to each and everyone who participated in this experience.
There are those critics of anything they can’t have been a part of or jealous of others who sought their Sanctuary and were led to their own adventure and life in a their adopted country. One can see first hand how the amazing peoples of Morocco and the hand of God and yes, wealthy artists, entrepreneurs and writers and half-casts from Europe and elsewhere came to these magical lands as toddlers and children…they were shown so much love and respect for their home away from home that they many moons later found themselves called to return.
Can we not be grateful for what has been achieved instead of being critical! Humility is demonstrated by those interviewed…and love of people and land and peace and respect for what has been given to them. REJOICE, BE GLAD 🙏🏼🩵💛
Extraordinary beauty.
Bravo. Excellent documentary. Loved it. ❤❤❤
Fabulous video which I thoroughly enjoyed.
Beautiful… but I challenge titling a video “The Gardens of Morocco…”, then EXCLUSIVELY showcasing gardens designed by Europeans. I find that problematic.
No difference. A beautiful garden is not reliant on nationality.
Totally disagree with you @@rosemallia5252
😂😂 The Moroccans have beautiful gardens they created inside the traditional homes called Riad because women cover they brought outside inside.
@@rosemallia5252 Well… Yes, and no. You’re missing the point about agency, representation, and cultural appropriation. And I thought your presentation posited that the best and most noteworthy Moroccan gardens are those designed by Europeans, which is untrue. The gardens were certainly beautiful, but I found the conversation slightly lacking.
A riad is based on sacred geometry and orientation from within where you will find focus on the fountain of life .
How amazing!
Beautiful
These gardens are created by Moroccan hands, with there marks.
The only thing Europeans have created is problems of borders between African countries and stolen the furtune of people.
I wonderful if the Europeans know who build ALHMBARA with its gardens?
Loved it!😍👍👌
going to use this video for design inspiration. working with concrete is hard work, but very rewarding when its done :)
I love 😘😘😘❤❤❤
4RA ka interface aur Finch ka participation, dono milke events ko next level pe le gaye hai
4rabet pe Finch ke saath events aur bhi bright ho gaye hai, real fun
4RA pe games aur events ka maza hi alag hai, dost ki recommendation pe khela tha pehli baar
Mujhe 4RA ke events pehle bhi pasand the, ab Finch ke saath aur bhi maza aayega
How did they keep the water clean?
Did you know that Morocco is the best place in the world to see the sunset? In Arabic, Morocco is known as (المغرب) Maghrib, which means the land where the sun sets.
what do you mean by oriental Morocco ?
Morocco is in extream west
Geographically, yes. Culturally, Morocco is as oriental as it gets.
This is a comedy about wishful thinking not a documentary. FYI Jardin Majorelle is Yves St. Laurent Villa Garden .
Finch ke saath 4RA ka experience aur bhi zabardast ho gaya hai, full paisa vasool
Finch ke saath 4rabet pe events aur bhi badiya lagte hain, full on maza aayega
Beautiful what he says at 45mins Islamic culture has always regarded gardens as places of contemplation and also of clear perception, they are high quality energy inputs that bring us back into harmony the way a piano tune does. Gardens are for peace offering. Peaceful interaction and a chance to breathe deeply.
Its not
Islamic heaven is of different levels and every level of heaven have gardens & orchards in it
Thats why islamic rulers were obsessed with the gardens. For them, its like creating a heaven on earth
You can see that in persia, central asia, india and wherever they ruled
When will you tour Sean Connary's Chrisitan Garden in the heart of London, Salam Rushdi's Self-Inflicted-Chrisian Garden? Can't wait
Those bird sounds are added. Its not one bird in those palm trees
Also, the contry name is not spelled correctly.
Bhai ne 4ra ke baare me bataya tha, interface bohot easy aur user-friendly hai
سبحان الله فجاة اصبح الاوروبيين هم من بنوا حدايق وبساتين الوداية والرباط وحدائق الرياضات في فاس ومراكش في الوقت الذي تتهافت فيها دول على المهندسين والحرفيين المغاربة لبناء حدايق وعمارة على الطراز المغربي الاندلسي.
قد يكون مهندس اوروبي مثلا قام بتصميم ولكن البناء تم ويتم على يد مغاربة.
الاندلسيين في الاندلس كانوا امازيغ وعرب او مسلمين بصفة عامة ولم يكونوا اوروبيين.
يالله واحلين مع الجيران وطلعتو لينا نتما من جنب.
هل يعلم الاوروبيين ان اجدادهم سرقوا من تراثنا وتاريخنا ومن كل بلدان افريقيا الكثير من الاشياء التي ينسبونها اليوم اليهم.
Lovely documentary but I'm not sure it is Islamic. I think this is more about traditional gardens than religious gardens. As an African, the gardens look very familiar to the beautiful gardens I saw as a child. It just shows that we are all connected by a common thread.
Yaar, Aaron Finch ke 4ra ambassador banne se pura 4ra experience bright ho gaya hai
Yaar Aaron Finch ka 4rabet pe aana bohot badiya baat hai, ab aur confidence se bet karenge
Bhai Aaron Finch ke 4ra ambassador banne se pura 4ra experience hi badal gaya hai
Perhaps the blue be renamed Touareg Blue :)
The gardens are beautiful, the commentary is extremely offensive!!!!
Brilliant. Thanks to Europeans for adapting and nurturing the heritages of this land. Very good example.
Yes I totally agree with you! It is thanks to the Islamic traditions !!! Incredible so, the garden isn’t European it is an Islamic garden!
@@ZobeidaWoodhouse Of course it is Islamic tradition. But those guys deserve appreciation for their good work.
@@ZobeidaWoodhouse moroccan traditions . u do not see this is saudi arabia or any other arab country . so it is purely moroccan
@user-no4um7cz3f
Not an Islamic tradition. It's a Moroccan tradition. Islam is a religion not a botanical school
@@Alinorosso2003 Look around and you will see. Every region which was under the Islamic empire followed the same pattern and symbols. Anyone can recognize an Islamic heritage no matter where it is. Iran, Iraq, Turkey, India or Spain, look for yourself. This channel also made videos about those areas.
Aaron Finch toh sports legend hai, uska 4ra ke saath hona quality aur reliability ka sign hai
Yup.
I've watched several episodes of this series, and while the visuals are stunning, I could do without the commentary that can idiotic at times.
An enchanting look at the Berber past & the Islamic influence welded on it resulting on the rich mélange we se today. This comment is coming from the far southern tip of Africa also washed by the cold Atlantic ocean and instead of the Mediterranean the warm waters of the Indian ocean, the Cape of Good Hope, also with its Islamic influences mainly from Java Indonesia Malaysia & the Middle east, richly contributing to our shared culture.
One word of criticism is the non offensive wording used to encapsulate the ex Andalusians living in Morocco described as having being expelled by the Christian conquerors. Technically of course it was the reconquest of a previously Christian territory conquered by the Muslims. All details are on the Internet for the historically minded. This was the spark which resulted in the Latin America, Mexico which we see today.
4RA pe Aaron Finch ka hona quality aur reliability ka saboot hai, ab aur bhi fun
I am wondering why the government do not take steps to import the necessary machinery to automate / simplify some of these art works without compromising the originality of them. These people are still living the same very simple and poor life they had centuries ago. Is this fare?
You missed the point. The garden is the output of the process of gardening and cultivating the land and living that process. Plus as these people have emerged themselves in the culture. They are doing it the Moroccan way. 😊.
What ? You want to Europeanise Morocco? All these Europeans left their homeland to live like Moroccans. 😊
40:33 This is amazing. Creating pottery the way it has been done for millennia ! No machine can make this !😊
Beautiful gardens, totally trash script tho.
Agreed with the previous comment. It was off kilter all along for that reason, when it could have simply made a different claim. Then ending on a note of "dreams of the orient" or "oriental hospitality" was not in good taste.
Although the gardeners themselves had some balanced perspectives. And the series is well done.
😮
The narrator keeps mentioning the orient however Morocco is definitely not eastern ..puzzling..plenty of Islamic countries are not eastern
Love the gardens, but for me the blue and yellow is distracting.
Lady don’t talk about my country s gardens left and right.There ia no such thing as islamic.Architecture especially the moroccan architecture has nothing to do with the religion pr islam.Not everything is islamic 😤😤😤😤
I had reminded them of this many times, but you know how British are, creating hostility and conflicts and stereotyping. None of the gardens in their clips have anything to do with Islam. British Christian Royal Garden. Elizabeth II Islamic and Chrisitan Garden, Prince Charles Islamic Garden, Sean Connery Islamic Garden. Salaman Rushdi's Chrisian Garden....that's their garden :)
Who told you that trees from Europe؟ are you crazy ?😅😅😅😅
4ra pe games aur betting ka experience amazing hai, friend ki recommendation thi
Another Divisive documentary aimed at dividing the people of Morocco 🇲🇦
jardin majorelle is anything BUT A PUBLIC GARDEN.
According to this documentary all the garden are designed by Europeans, what about those in Andalucia Spain?
Don’t see cats anywhere around…how do they control cats?
From my experience in Morocco, there are delightfully a lot of cats
I was thinking the same thing! Where are all the cats? A garden without a cat is a sad garden. 😸
Catfish???🤣🤣🤣 Same reason perhaps that street dogs in Spain all walk on 3 legs 😶🤔
Many of these gardens look exactly like what you find in Mexican and Mexican American homes with bougainvillea, cactus, agaves, and cannas! I don't think spiny cactus is something usually implemented in an Islamic garden because they look harsh/dangerous and it's not representative of Paradise? I'm not sure if we see lots of spiny cactus here because these gardens are designed by Europeans. The last garden was amazing.
This left a bad taste in my mouth. It feels like the narrator is trying to overplay european influences on arts and styles that were already there. Though I admire the one garden, I don't really care for these kinds of gardens. There are far more beautiful traditional gardens in Morocco than this Chop suey garden decor of european eccentricity.
The German's fantasy Garden lovely as it is with its Yoruba like ceramics show the difficulty Some, Europeans have in comprehending that the African continent has huge ranges of ethnic groups as diverse as does the Euro Asiatic continent with its blonde Caucasians in the west to the Mongoloid Asians of the east.
Aaron Finch ke achievements dekh ke lagta hai 4rabet pe khelna sahi decision hai
Anyone else who finds this whole thing offensive 😮
Oh, yeah. I've watched several episodes of this series and all was wishing for is for that narrator to shut up and let me enjoy the gardens.
4ra pe live betting ka thrill hi kuch aur hai, friend ne suggest kiya tha, real fun
المغرب ارض اجتمع فيها كل شيء تحت اسم مغربة التراث والمعمار والطبخ والفن والمغاربة صنعوا حضارتهم بايديهم ولم تاتيهم من اي مكان.
اين حضارة المور المغاربة؟ طمسها الاوروبيين ونسبوها الى الرومان وما تبقى نسب الى الغير .
Well, right from the beginning this presenter should have said (at the very least) that this garden was a collaboration between Moroccans and Europeans. Obviously, ALL the motifs, designs, fountains, and structures are Moroccan, Islamic/&/or Arabic, North African/& Middle Eastern-inspired art forms.
I think this was stated & restated later ...but first impressions are lasting. 🤔
There is no harm to say the morocco ruled Spain for 500 years
Its Moroccan by the Moroccans from the Moroccans. Its Moroccan garden not Islamic Islam is a religion not a style of architecture.
SALaM, SHLAMa, SHLOMo, SHALoM, NAMASTe, PEACe.
Image A Mountain:
GOD
ANGeLS
PRoPHETs
ALL CREATiON
God Almighty Sits On His Golden Throne Alone, He Shares His Throne With No Kinship, Partners, With No Desires Or Needs, With No Beginning Or End, At The Very Peak Of The Mountain.Image A Mountain:
Hinduism = Vaishnavism, Shaivism, Shaktism, and Smartism.
Four Vedas Are Still Mainly Monotheistic, But The Multiple Guru Books Have The Trinity & Multiple Gods.
Zoroastrian = Zoroaster & Parsi.
The Avesta Is Monotheistic, But They Have Added Verses Of The Trinity.
Buddhist = Theravada, Mahayana and Vajrayana.
Cannon Is Monotheistic, But Altered Verses State There Is A Trinity, But No God.
Jewish:
Hasidic Judaism, Lithuanian (Lita'im), Post-Enlightenment movements.
Migration, Zionists (Datim-leumi), Anti-Zionists, Pressures of assimilation.
Beta Israel (Haymanot), Crimean Karaites.
The Rabbi's Added The Talmud, Applying The Jews To Many Unnecessary Rules & Regulations. They Also Amended Many Torah Verses, Like Stating The Earth Is Flat, Held By Four Angels, On Each Corner.
Christian:
Adamites, Arianism, Ebionites, Collyridianism, Elcesaites, Marcionism
Montanism, Nazarenes, Novatianism, Ophites, Bardaisanites, Basilideans
Carpocratianism, Nicolaitans, Sethianism, Simonians (sometimes considered Proto-Gnostic), Valentinianism, Agonoclita, Apostolic Brethren
Beguines and Beghards, Bogomilism, Patarines, Bosnian Church
Brethren of the Free Spirit, Catharism, Celtic Christianity, Donatism, Dulcinians
Euchites, Fraticelli, Friends of God, Henricans, Heresy of the Judaizers, Lollardy
Neo-Adamites, Paulicianism, Petrobrusians, Strigolniki, Tondrakians
Constantinople Orthodox Church, Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of Italy and Malta
Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America, Albanian Orthodox Diocese of America
Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of Canada, Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of UK
Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of Australia, Vicariate for Palestine and Jordan in the USA, Finnish Orthodox Church, Greek Orthodox Church of Crete, Monastic Community of Mount Athos, Korean Orthodox Church, Estonian Apostolic Orthodox Church, Ukrainian Orthodox Church of the USA, Ukrainian Orthodox Church of Canada, Orthodox Metropolitanate of Hong Kong, Exarchate of the Philippines, Orthodox Metropolitanate of Singapore, American Carpatho-Russian Orthodox Diocese, Greek Orthodox Church of Alexandria, Greek Orthodox Church of Antioch, Antiochian Orthodox Archdiocese of North America, Antiochian Orthodox Archdiocese of Australia, Antiochian Orthodox Archdiocese of Mexico
Antiochian Orthodox Mission in the Philippines, Antiochian Orthodox Archdiocese of Chile, Greek Orthodox Church of Jerusalem, Greek Orthodox Church of Sinai, Russian Orthodox Church, Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia, Russian Orthodox Church in Finland, Japanese Orthodox Church
Chinese Orthodox Church, Estonian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate)
Moldovan Orthodox Church, Belarusian Orthodox Church, Philippine Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate), Patriarchal Exarchate in South-East Asia
Patriarchal Exarchate in Western Europe, Patriarchal Parishes in the USA
Patriarchal Parishes in Canada, Georgian Orthodox and Apostolic Church
Serbian Orthodox Church, Serbian Orthodox Ohrid Archbishopric
Archdiocese of Belgrade and Karlovci, Serbian Metropolitanate of Skopje
Serbian Metropolitanate of Dabar, Serbian Metropolitanate of Montenegro
Serbian Metropolitanate of Zagreb, Serbian Metropolitanate of Australia
Romanian Orthodox Church, Romanian Metropolis of Bessarabia
Romanian Metropolia of the Americas, Bulgarian Orthodox Church
Diocese of North America and Australia, Cypriot Orthodox Church
Orthodox Church of Greece, Albanian Orthodox Church
Polish Orthodox Church, Czech and Slovak Orthodox Church
Orthodox Church in America, Archdiocese of Canada, Romanian Orthodox Episcopate of America, Albanian Orthodox Archdiocese in America
Exarchate of Mexico, Orthodox Church of Ukraine, Macedonian Orthodox Church
The Gospel Has Had More Updates, Than Apple IOS.
Islam:
Sunnīsm, Shīʿīsm, Ibadism, Quranism, Non-denominational Muslims, Mahdavia, Ahmadiyya, Nation of Islam, and Sufism, Hanbali, Maliki, Hanafi, Shafi'i, Twelvers, Ismāʿīlīs, and Zaydīs.
Remember None Of God's Prophets Belonged To Any Sect.
Neither Did Prophet Muhammad Bring 1 Million Hadith Books, With Separate Shia & Sunni Volumes.
The Ummah Has Been Lead Away By Iblis [Satan], Away From The Quran.
Iblis [Satan] Has Diluted Islam [Hinduism, Zoroastrianism, Buddhism, Judaism & Christianity], With Extra Books, Which Are Not From God...
Correction. Islam dictates every facet of existence, lifestyle food, clothing, dress codes, hygiene, architecture, politics & religion . Why can't Westerners bend their minds outside of their liberal bubble culture. Oy, oy. so simple.😈
Btw way the turreted walls are eerily reminiscent of the crusader castle structures erected during their attempts 1095 - 1291, to wrest the holy city of Jerusalem back from the Muslim occupiers
Im shocjed by the opening sentences here, who ever wrote this needs to do some research into moorish , and islamic culture from which the aesthetics of these gardens emerge.
Beautiful visuals, thank you for showing these gardens, but Idk about this narration guys 😅😅😅 goes past ‘out of touch’ into ‘hard to listen to’.
sadece ingilizce alt yazı neden
These are Moroccan gardens commissioned by Europeans and not what is implied by the countless references to "Europeans" by the narrator. Sad the effort to appropriate and deny the very people and traditions that have actually inspired you to actually create the gardens. Ofcourse the owners are Europeans and there is in some of the cases European input , flowers,etc, but the commentary spoilt to some extent of what is a beautiful video of Moroccan gardens.
Agreed, I had trouble finishing due to the revisionist history 😢
I understand that, almost did the same thing.
I think the implication was that it is largely thanks to Europeans that these gardens still exist as locals are less interested in modern times
the intonation of every sentence is exactly the same. AI is not a good narrator and makes this a terrible thing to watch.
موجود الحدايق والقصور قبل توتجد الاروبيين تندما كانت اروبا في العصور الوسطي الاروبيين الذين ياتون للمغرب ينشاون حدايق علي الطريقة المغربية العربية
This style of gardens are only MOROCCAN not europeen , not islamic and not arabic 🇲🇦
Sorry, but it sucks so badly that this channel cannot spell MOROCCO. 😐
Bhai 4rabet pe Finch ke saath betting karna alag hi thrill hai, pura maza aayega
4RA pe jitni bhi baar bet kiya, hamesha kuch na kuch jeeta, friend ne kaha tha try karne ko
i cant
The architecture doesn't have the religion, everything is in Morocco is Moroccan or as called in English moorish architecture nothing else.