Modi govt’s DRDO reform: What ails defence research & India’s quest for military-industrial complex
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ก.ย. 2024
- The Modi govt has set up a panel under former Principal Scientific Adviser K. VijayRaghavan to make recommendations on reforming the Defence Research & Development Organisation (DRDO). Reform in India’s premier defence R&D entity - the subject of many withering assessments by the armed forces, parliamentary panels and CAG - has been a long-time coming. In Ep 1297 of Cut The Clutter, Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta analyses what ails the DRDO, what it’s got right, and India’s efforts to build a genuine military-industrial complex.
@kumarakomlakeresortkerala
@pauljohnresortsandhotels
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Modi govt to revamp DRDO, sets up committee with members from services and industry:
theprint.in/de...
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CAG slams DRDO for delays, declaring projects successful despite failure to meet key goals:
theprint.in/de...
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Parliamentary panel recommends DRDO revamp, wants private sector & academic institutions involved:
theprint.in/de...
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Panel suggests DRDO revamp:
archive.indiane...
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Kalam’s banana republic:
theprint.in/op...
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Indian Army prepares to switch to new rifles:
www.indiatoday...
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
After many years of failure, Indian defence scientists claim success with MBT for army:
www.indiatoday...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our TH-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Member benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
th-cam.com/video/dAFEP6CzXqQ/w-d-xo.html
fyi, indigenous is an English word and nothing to do with india. yes, in this context you can use indian but indigenous is more appropriate.
Q
@@aryamishra⁹⁹9⁹😊⁹
@@aryamishra00pp 1 mmkkkkkkikkkkklkjhg
GIus
LeìaieòopKjs
Jz
H
Z
Ad,[>÷>÷
A traditional congress supporter here. Have to say BJP has made me proud to be Indian. Great feeling ! ❤
Buddy, congress doesn’t understand the Indian psyche, it’s native culture & it’s dreams and aspirations anymore. Thoroughly disconnected from ground due to leftist influence & compulsions of keeping their Islamist vote bank happy. Overtime, like most congress supporters, you’ll start supporting BJP for their vision for India, pace of delivery & connection to our civilisational. Good luck :)
These congressman ask how did bjp supporters contributed in Independence struggle I mean they think they are taking a moral groud what they miss to understand is the fact that most bjp supporters were congress supporters or even members in the past . congress lost all its members by not acknowledging what people want.....
@@_kartik_chauhanmost people don't realise that BJP isn't Janasangh. It's the part of the old big-camp Congress that disagreed from within, formed the Janata party, failed at it and then the working parts of it formed the current BJP. It faced selection pressure from the real world and evolved. It's not in power because it's leaders were born in the right families. Being a dynast in BJP does not guarantee anything.
Bs.
Sab Adani ko de dia, sab Adani ko de dia,….Modi Hatao dash bachao….dash ko bach diaa….pura dash ko bach diaa….
Leader with a vision can only take such decisions. No matter what, India needs Modi
What is the modi vision?
India never wanted a hollow vision. Just because it will back fire on long run.
@@missanorajjohnthattil5333what is modis vision- to become self reliant especially in defence it is because of congress that we never invested in indigenous weapons and as a matter of fact we are overly dependent on russia (75% of defence equipment) which is proving to be problematic .
@@Charvakarishi4669 have you heard about the real contract when rafale deal was when the Congress ruled and how the modi government closed it?
@@missanorajjohnthattil5333other visions have backfired in short and long runs...
@@missanorajjohnthattil5333please submit a signed contract link here and submit supreme court as well. How many years you PPL tell this lies .. of no contact is contact
So glad DRDO is being reformed like Ordinance Boards. We need this govt for another 15 years & this country will transformed for the next few centuries. Superpower 🇮🇳 in making 😁
I am praying for drdo and not letting this be another Bad implementation.
I agree modi has the potential to pull off but not to make it effective enough in many areas.
Another 1000 years bolo
At least 3000 years, everything happening first time that too on 10th year 😂
@@sujithkumar2041 no no Amrut kal for 10000000000 years
@@neogenesis_indica you clowns don’t understand Geopolitics. The next 5-10 years are critical since massive reforms are required to ensure companies hedging out of China come to India. Plus, it’s important for us to indigenise and become self sustaining to increase our global role and stature. Modi is ticking all the right boxes and it’s impact will be seen for the next few centuries when India becomes the No 2 possibly No 1 economy in coming decades.
The problem with Indian Defence is they do not continue their program once the thing is built. Continuous improvement is a philosophy everyone should internalize and should be realized.
The question should be: *What has ailed India’s military-industrial complex since successful creation of Islamic Pakistan by Nehru/Congress??!!*
@@rka-truthalwayswins5127 Nehru was against partition. It was Jinnah and Hindu Mahasabha who were supportive of the partition.
@@Nateseun Are you that ignorant or a liar that takes others for fools???!!
WHY would HINDU MAHASABAH ALLOW FOR AN ISLAMIC CALIPHATE instead of a Hindu Rashtra with a Hindu Pakistan??!!
The TRUTH is that Nehru/Congress, British & Muslims voted for creation of Islamic Pakistan! Majority of Muslims also DUMPED Islam/Pakistan to stay in India!!
@@rka-truthalwayswins5127 Partition can be attributed only to Muslim league, Nehru and Patel were against it till as late as 1946 and were even giving in to Jinnah's demands.
@@berserkhorimiya Nehru finally was at the center of mutilation of Indian lands to create Islamic Pakistan!! Else, even MK Gandi said that partition will happen over his dead body & yet!! he didn't die when it happened!!
Congress led by Nehru/Gandi, Muslim voters+Jinnah and British created Islamic Pakistan!! Period!!
Not just DRDO, every single PSU in the defence sector need full top to bottom reform. During My time at one of them i got to see the most skilled “scientists” from elite colleges wasting their time drinking tea and having samosas and sleeping from 8 to 5. They were literally using rtl language from the 80s literally 30 yrs behind the rest of the industry. This really made me run away from govt psu’s and work in private sector.
Bang on! This is True feedback!
✔️✔️✔️👌
Sir, I would like to ask one simple question … When did India’s first, indigenously (Indian, if you like) designed, sedan roll out ? … and when did Tejas undertake its first test flight?… You guessed it right. It was Tejas that undertook its maiden flight at least a year before Indigo was launched by Tatas. It was Tejas that did it first …. Indigo launched in 2002 … first test flight of Tejas was on 4 Jan 2001 … DRDO did it despite many restrictions by other countries. Compare this with private industry who never faced any restrictions …
The country opened up its economy in 1991. Has Indian industry made a world class car even after 30 years of opening up. (compare BHP: Mahindra’s 2.2 liter diesel engine gives 172 bhp whereas BMW’s 2 liter diesel engine gives 188 bhp. Sorry Anand Mahindra sir. Nothing personal here. I know, we as a nation, are weak in engineering) .. And you want to compare DRDO’s Tejas with world class fighters !! … By the way, it is still very much comparable …
Under the pretext of saving government money, do we really want to privatise Indian war industry? … We may very well do so but than we should also be ready to those capitalistic tentacles which force, the so called world’s most powerful country, to keep triggering wars in some part of the globe, whether its Ukraine or Gulf … so that their war Industries keep surviving and so does their governments …
And now this committee. The nation wants to decide DRDO’s fate with Private Industrialist as part of the committee .. who obviously have their own business interests … and surprisingly DRDO doesn’t even find a representation in this committee … Does this mean that the decision has already been made and the committee is just an eyewash …
Think over it please … It’s very easy to criticise anyone as an outsider … Meanwhile, I salute your very limited comprehension of the subject, Sir …
I haven't seen a more comprehensive piece of garbage than what you wrote right here.
What has Indigo got to do with Tata?
And what has launching of Indigo got to do with Tejas?
Almost all of the statements you wrote are not even worth the horse shyte manure.
Absolutely fitting reply
@@shane7329 Nonsense. Almost all statements made by this person are plain lies.
what nonsense ! the two examples you have given show that you don't understand engineering or industry, typical of the arts background leftist
Agree very much with you.
Where are the Tatas Mahindra n L&T TCS Infosys etc. What tech have they developed.
Our psu n drdo has been abused n run down.
The private sector is being glorified
Shekar ji with all your experience show me one Indian private company which is world class with its own technology.
I'll give you my experience:
Simple machinery like press brake n shearing machines have important n critical subsystems which are imported. Check any Indian co. Make list.
Take Tatas n TCS
Tatas milked TCS to strengthen its shareholding in group cos. How much did it invest in developing cutting edge owned technology in software. So goes with Infosys n rest. These are cos with huge turnover n profits. But no worthwhile RnD
Look at L&T it collaborate with Korean co to produce howitzers. Yes howitzers.
It is India's foremost private sector engineering co.
It did not have the guts to say we will develop our howitzers.
Our DRDO n PSUs have done lot better than the private sector.
All they needed was revamping of management system.
The committee is a bunch of jokers where it comes to cutting edge technology.
The DRDO n PSUs are way ahead of the private sector.
This is the harsh reality
Key difference between BJP and Congress is BJP/Modi govt uses power for building nation while Congress used power to ensure Nehru/gandhi family rule. Even today, Congress core goal is to transfer power to the first family even if it requires going against national interests
Modi made the Free Press into Godi Media…. That’s research & development?
@@CP-bu1hcbro nowadays everyone is godi trust me..one side of the media likes to promote the leftist and another side likes to promote the right wings it's upto u who u want to follow
I am sorry I didn't understand yes the gandhis are rich but so is amit shah and to be fair I would say he is richer and he being a full time politician he may also be corrupt too.
@@CP-bu1hc Tell me one country where the media hasn't sold out.
Look around you idiot, the media model has changed all over the world. We need to understand the idea of private media as we know is failing, and needs to be reformed.
@@CP-bu1hcu see if INDIA comes to power the same media will start praising the govt of the day. Also if u see there are lot of media people always criticizing Modi no matter what it does. It is upto u to put some efforts to check the facts..
Highly informative and in depth analysis. I did not expect The Print to praise the bold initiative by Modi government.
😹 true. Print is leftist
That's weird. He did that with farm reforms, ordnance reforms, railway HR reforms, and so many other reforms. I guess people just want to see what they want to see.
The reason I am a paid subscriber of Print and I follow most of their podcasts and articles is bacuse of @ShekharGupta's ability to maintain objectivity..irrespective of his personal beliefs.
Only wish the low IQ, blatantly woke Jyoti Malhotra is kicked off the team 😅
Their Masters in the US and UK have told them to not to rock the boat but to just make sure the mandate for coming LOK Sabah elections should be below 299 so as to weaken the capability of PM MODI passing the bills in the parliament.
Jai Hind
Jai Bharat
@@ImJayrajD The Print is liberal, not leftist(communism). Congress is a right wing party.
No one is happy with DRDO that is irrefutable fact, Many has called for reforms and no one called for privatization and i dont think we ever would do that but I can understand their frustration. I hope MODI Govt would do some much much needed reforms
it would be desirable to retain the baby while throwing out the bath water.
it would be desirable to retain the baby while throwing out the bath water.
Please don't privatise again there is a large set of startups culture coming up for supporting new ideas for long.
The first thing they should do is to make all employees undergo quarterly training on not getting honey trapped, should happen in all sensitive govt institutions TBH.
I think it would better if employees don't use any social media platforms like WhatsApp Twitter,FB etc.
Indian uncle see pussy, Indian uncle chase
That will show them..
Lesson #1: Do not to be thirsty.
All it takes a middle aged Seeman Haider to say " Hi" and the idiot Indian man will sell his mother and country.
Shekharji, it's the personal stories that add such a nice touch to any topic being discussed and make CTC something to look forward to every time 😊.
It's like an old man telling stories to young people.......😃
+1
the more the Modi govt does things, shows how much Congress Govt was delaying, not performing with inefficient 'elite' ministers who have serious disconnect with the masses. Mani Shankar Aiyer is a perfect example of Congress culture and thinking. MSA will not command more than 2 people in TN but he is a Congress leader. Delusion to infinity is anyone thinks 'mohhabat ki dukan' without any experience will take serious ADMIN decisions ( not a BJP supporter but definitely a Congress hater)
Old congress: we will use laws to reform this nation.
New congress: Tear the laws, poetry it is..
And they came 9 years late.
If you ask me, congress led governments were always Corrupt, Divisive and plain Incompetent.
Even today, Congress continues to use the British dictum of divide and Rule.
This tells us that Mr Modi is a safer bet. Ofcourse, he needs to broaden power base and empower his Council of Ministers and promote competence amongst CMs for optimizing performance.
Like son cursing father and mother when he adds a bathroom to the family house in the 10th year. 😂
All the more reason for Modi to come back to power - we can’t let the country suffer similar to the revolving door PMs and Defence Ministers as in the past. 0:01
Prof K Vijay Raghvan is also former scientific advisor to PM. It would be better to mention that Shekhar ji.
This was long waited and much needed reforms.. Kudos to Modi Govt
14:58 Finally finally acceptance that its the political class which had muddled up things and the current one is correcting the course! I know SG was one of the early ones to talk about banning of purchase of items by the armed forces (all 3). Let this also be acceptance that the current govt is taking "make in India" seriously. This is also an attempt by govt to generate jobs. No point just squawking that there is no job. Its now the junta's turn to get educated and get prepared for opportunities.
Bro junta should come forward and get skills
Really Modi Govt is thinking ling term.
Congress wasted crucial year in reforming DRDO.
true
Incorrect statement. I think You meant to say that congress waisted time in NOT reforming DRDO
✔️
The Indian and global IT industry gobbles up all the prime talent in the country: metallurgist, bio technologists, chemical engineers... you name it! They paint and brush all of them into software engineers by sheer money power!
Very true!
So true lol
All my friends complain of very low pay in core.
Lower than IT coolies.
So they go to IT or go abroad to study higher.
I legit heard a DRDO scientist say “we only work with well and long established technology from past” it was never “this can be the future or this is innovative” 😂 hopefully this changes moving forward
Tell me one tech institute, organisation, private or public company in the country which is working on something that has not been done before.
Unfortunately my friend, whether it's IITs, ISRO, PSUs, private companies, Software companies, manufacturing, startups, etc etc etc. We are not doing one thing which has not been done before any where else. I don't find this wrong, what's wrong is not learning and reducing the gap between us vs Western countries. I guess in that sense we are doing quite well.
@@AnilYadav-nt9mf the point is you’ll be 2 generations behind the “proven technology” not very smart is it?
@@AnilYadav-nt9mfour core engineering is poor but that's expected for a country with Gdp.oer Capita under $3000. We will slowly move up the value change, the first step is to build the industrial base and develop R&D cooperation with top indian research institutes & industries
A long time ago, I worked in GTRE during my engineering internship. What i can safely state with my limited experience is that , it was extremely relaxed out there. A far cry from the private MNCs i have been employed since. GTRE was working on making kaveri successful then. We all know how kaveri engine panned out. Possibly , we will use it for our drones today. Defence research organizations should be cutting edge and brimming with new ideas and work. Any reorganisation of DRDO would be a very welcome. Thank you for the video
right from start indians thought of socialism as government employment. efficiency was neither required nor permitted.
cause is the shop keeping culture of the dominant master class, which does not value self respect and equates freedom with enemity.
honesty, sincerity, dilligence, creativity, etc., are difficult when there is neither self respect nor freedom.
reorganisation of drdo will be merely an eyewash unless the dominant indian culture turns away from mere shop keeping.
Gas trouble research establishment 😂
Is kaveri engine a success, because it was supposed to be used in amca or tejas, but it is heavily under power.
They should end this compulsion of giving contract to psu, amazing work pvt defence players are doing like of Kalyani group, Tata, L&T, barring Russia all major defence exporters is driven by pvt sector, turkey revolution in cheap drone making is all lead by pvt sector
Good point!
Makes sense.
Absolutely
Make it in Hindustan has huge potential for scientific minds to get employment and do research here ! Another five years of PM Modi would hopefully change the “face” of the Nation !
We need 50 more years. Infact, if the opposition remains the way it is, then I rather ga e BJp for ever
@@varunsharma5468 CONgress CONs and rest of opportunist opposition vultures aren’t about development of Hindustan but creating fiefdoms to loot ! Just look , have they ever before of after PM Modi’s election talked about development ? Now CON MAN and dumb ass PaaPOO Rani and MAMtaz Begum is vying for PMship ! Do you see any future in these ugly faces ?
DRDO must learn from ISRO 🇮🇳 🇮🇳
It's not a question of learning. ISRO has less autonomy as it is controlled by the PMO by default.
It has more autonomy because it is only controlled by PMO. Not true with DRDO. Only the strategic affairs have more autonomy like the nuclear and the missile program and these are directly under the PMO.@@rutvikrs
@@sadenb 'autonomy' means free to independently take its own decisions. I don't think strategic affairs like nuclear and missile programs have any such luxury to independently take decisions. In fact they are tightly controlled by the PMO.
You can say they have less bureaucratic hurdles to cross because they report directly to PMO.
@@dukhi_aatma372 Every organization have some governmental entity to report in the world. DRDO is free to come up with their own programs as long as they adhere to the national needs or what they need. This is fairly common.
@@sadenb I know that. And I'm not contradicting it.
I'm pointing to the word 'autonomy' you have used for strategic nuclear and missile programs. They are absolutely not autonomous. Nuclear programs are strictly under the control of PMO. They cannot do anything without approval of PMO. Not even any basic research.
DRDO of course can do some non-nuclear research work based on funds allocated to them. But for large initiatives, they again have to get permissions from govt.
DRDO is the only defense organisation where there are more babus (25000) than engineers (5000)
DRDO useless
and 4,999 of those Engr.s are from some second or third rate Engr. College in the South
@@devgupta8815for you kind info ISRO chairman is from TKM Engineering college, Chandrayan 3 director along with 6 other major team members are from College of Engineering Trivandrum (established in 1939). IITians are busy running to Silicon Valleys, while the so called people who graduated from regional government colleges served ISRO and took India to Moon.
So STFU
@@devgupta8815arrogance alert
That's absolutely wrong. DRDO has 7000+ scientist and many more technical staff. Babu constitutes less than 10%.
Modi govt bringing back the lost glory of India
Indian Railways
Infra
Indian Defence
Indian Space program
Digitisation
Once again Prof Shekhar Ji blending nostalgia and current events to weave together rich impression of DRDO strengths and opportunities for development
In Kargil we hear of a Coffin scam.
Imagine we had to import coffins.
Coffins
Exactly. We are under industrialised. My blood boils when some Indians say we have a lot of talent but are restricted by politics. Prove me wrong and hire 15000 talented carpenters.
Great episode! Arunachalam was a legend, although it pains me we weren't able to attract him to head mettalurgy at IITs/IISC and lost him out to carnegie
Tributes to VS Arunachalam sir 🙏🇮🇳 thank you SG for bringing out his story
“I wonder whether those of our political masters who have been put in charge of the defence of the country can distinguish a mortar from a motor; a gun from a howitzer; a guerrilla from a gorilla, although a great many resemble the latter.”
- Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw.
Nice but fact remains - " In a democracy, the government reflects the people "
So I mean to say that if the people are not able to distinguish a guerrilla from a Gorilla, it's very likely that the government is also not able to do so.
Manekshaw was good at waging war but does not make him good at harnessing peace.
@@desibigfoot3874👌👌👌👌
@@desibigfoot3874
"Pade-Likhe ummidvaron ko he vote dena.."
now next question if that person does distinguish what does it tells about that person?@@mg.f.9023 will he perform better? sounds like a 9yr old would believe in that
Employees of ordnance and DRDO are also not ablr to able to distinguish betweeen the above said items.
Day by day i just get more convinced why india needs this government and narendra modi
Me too !
Govt Of India needs to fix the issue of funding for R&D. At the moment, it is very haphazard - CCS determines if something has to be funded on biennial basis and that just creates a lot of stoppages. (I know Permanent R&D fund is coming but we won't see it materialize at least until next year).
The other issue is culture, DRDO labs are too dependent on Govt for everything. Even when they have freedoms they are too eager to submit itself to the Govt. That needs to change. When you go begging to the Govt, Govt decides your priorities - this is how we get DRDO to make masks rather than research.
The other part of this equation is procurement and/or commercialization.
Our procurement are still a bloody mess, our Generals asks too much, demand too many changes but pays too little and then finally dumps the project. They are not invested in a programs success and building real capabilities. It is more about proving the Govt that we are incapable to build things and hence we must import equipment.
Now Every R&D project has a potential for commercialization, if private sector is not allow to commercialize it and is stuck with Defense procurement then I guarantee you this reform will be a huge failure.
Nobody will privatize DRDO. The solution will have to be from within. An open discussion about DRDO's capabilities is necessary. Overpromising and underdelivering has been the norm at DRDO. Young people are needed at DRDO. They must match the high packages of Google and others and retain top talent of IITs and other engineering and science colleges.
"I want to change the outcomes by not changing"
Only salary will increase no performance of DRDO engineers will ever ever increase!
This is not IT SECTOR BABA, CHIT CHATTING and spend time in pub , this is well disciplined research laboratory.
DRDO should do campus selections from IITs and NITs.
Adapt, reform or perish is the mantra, be it in government, personal life, or even in nature. All of India's problems are due to wrong, ineffective, short term gain policies, failure to reform/adapt and sometimes even people opposing reforms. Thankfully, this government is making attempt for reforms. better late than ever.
Looks like DRDO is finally getting on track. The next decade looks promising.
😂😂😂😂😂
Just privatize the whole thing.
@@Apache1970yeah privatize defence🙃
how is reservation helping manufacturing weapons for our nation ?
@@Apache1970 @DRDO ko pvt karo
Accountability of OFB is the best decision of Modi Government… But unable to produce home grown assault rifle is big shame.
We have developed assault rifles.. The general adoption by the armed forces is an issue.
Sss defence.... check bro
Hats off to Shekhar, the stories that are not covered anybody is available here
Spread awareness guys. They r reforming every sector of India within 10 years. Defence education manufacturing finance banking
I know my uncle working at DRDO, Pune telling me how directionless the entire organisation is despite him working as a project manager at Pune branch. Scientists aren’t researching anything substantial and just filling up jobs posts like any other govt organisation. I feel at the centre of innovation is competition. Without knowing what the organisation stands for, how on earth they will deliver anything.
Has he also told for drdo director from rss background is sharing the secret to Pakistani?
@@neogenesis_indica Lol
Only the labs in Hyderabad and Bangalore are performing well and keeping DRDO going. So it's understandable that your scientist uncle from Pune is disappointed with the work culture in his lab. It doesn't mean that everywhere it's like this.
@@mehjabinsnam1381 I mean you do know right, Pune has Heavy Energy Materials Research. Only in India which is linked to DRDO. The organisation lacks innovation, period. Pune also has College of Military Engineering, NDA, DIAT and Engineering Corp. all of them are clients of DRDO. I don’t see Hyderabad or Bangalore delivering anything substantial either.
although drdo don't have the mandate to produce medical items like oxygen generater. but we need to remember it did saved lives. each live saved is a great cause
The higher education system needs reforms. Age barriers and restrictions should be improved for hiring. These are non sense laws that are restricting growth. Performance needs to be rewarded and not seniority.
So basically modi is fixing the mistakes made by congress
We have been trying to build world class products without building world class industries. The focus has to be on industry. Competent companies will develop and deliver competent products.
Great point 👍
Congress never wanted to develop Indian defense industrial complex else they would loose bilk of their commission & funding. Remember the townhall of Rahul Gandhi with HAL & Ordinance factory employees trying to agitate them to stop the reforms in 2018-19. Look at HAL & ordinance factories today more successful than ever.
Wonderful anecdote about Dr APJ....SGji is a master at humanising complicated issues❤
Salutations to Dr Arunachalam
What an inspiring giant
10 Raksha Mantris in 10 years
Amazing
Finally i said 5 months ago if Modi govt reformed DRDO, i will give my vote to BJP, i was very critical as it's my first vote(18yrs old)
I am crying literally, to even hear the news of DRDO reforms, govt employees have fu*ked our armed forces, i use to watch a lot of defence content so i know the shit India is going through.
I hope SG make another video on how INDIAN ARMY, NAVY and AIRFORCE top babus are doing corruption, anything israeli-american they are spreading their legs for that tech, they didn't supported indian startups.
Also if any indian equipment does arrives it needs to have the power as in sci-fi movies shit😢
Seriously, we need to talk about this now, china and even pakistan is ahead in defence.
Thanks for paying Modi a left handed compliment. In his tenure DRDO has become more purposive, more productive and more successful.
Finally.....also.....merit shud be promoted in DRDO rather than letting unmotivated people, getting in based on reservation or otherwise looking to get a cushy sarkari naukri.....
@@DissonantMasternot helping either.
@@DissonantMaster
Read and re read....till u understand.....
Also, reservations are not only based on caste ...
Also, I speak in respect of DRDO
Also, I use the word "otherwise"
And yet .....ur own lack of understanding....
In my opinion DRDO needs to be hived off into separate productive units(like ADA,say) and one research financing unit which examines proposals from private organizations and funds them as per GOI policy in force at that time( akin to the DARPA program in USA). The patents process in India must be strengthened in practice. This will release the forces of India wide innovation.
Shekhar Gupta's command over a wide range of topics is really commendable.
GOVT :Defense Industries should be :
1/Privatised with Top industrial engineering cos.ex; TATAS...L&T, Mahindras, Godrej, Reliance, etc,
Set up State of art Laboratories + All IT majors+
Design cos/Instituions+ iit =
Start with full punch;
Start best models/ designs..
New Technologies; to be integrated.
These reforms are the reason why i give vote to BJP
Thank you for the update. This is one of India's most pressing needs at the moment.
Military Engineering Services MES are also in a dire need of reforms ....hope they are next !!
With all due respect to DRDO, it seems the Iranians and north koreans are doing much better with all the sanctions and limitations they have to face.
IAF is majorly responsible for delays in Tejas. Frequently changing requirements (fuel probe, new radome) is the main one. It could've inducted in 2011 even as air-to-air capability was being tested. If EU nations could induct an A2G only Typhoon, why can't IAF ? Also, India was subjected to sanctions after the 1998 nuke tests which led to our engineers being thrown out of Lockheed's facilities. We completed the testing of FBW in India under Dr. kalam. The flight-tests in 2000s were slow because we were doing it for the first time under sanctions. An unsupportive and uninterested IAF did not help.
Prime Minister of India is doing his job.......We appreciate his work. Reforming and restructuring and updating organizations..........
The main con of Indian National Congress: Still struck in the era of Soviet union.....and anti capitalist talk all the time...(eventhough they're the one who liberlised it)
BJP : playing communal card even in the situations when they can easily win......and supporting corny capitalism....
The Congress you see isn't the Congress that liberalised. Also it wasn't a policy, it was imposed on us.
@@rutvikrs right
Dear Shekhar Gupta,
My sincere compliments to you for an excellent analysis. It brings out the context and the requirements in an absolutely transparent way. Warm regards
Shekhar Gupta... I have commented on many of your videos the same thing. And I think I'm going to keep doing it unless we hear something about it. PLEASE WRITE A BOOK of your such eclectic experiences with such varied, important & fascinating people. We all could learn a lot from it.
I worked on 3 - 4 projects at DRDO Hyderabad. Akash Missile, Pinaka Missile, LCA Tejas and Torpedo projects during 1987-94.The Scientists and Tech team were so slow and lazy, added to that fund crunch, Govt. Disinterest. Govt. Of India held by Congress would always float tenders for import of Defence equipment including Radars etc. got so fed up as I-was a young engineer. I was frustrated as well. Left DRDO to work with SAB’s Gripen Fighter jet development team. Today it is a 180 Degree turn of events. Modi Ji’s Govt. Must start giving decent payouts to the staff that are working on Make in India projects. Per se overall pay packages to Defence and Space equipment design development and mass production community. Else they will fly off. Beware..!!
To all those who ask what bjp has done.
Bjp's contribution in all of this is to make the equipment that was obsolete junk and uncool to use into trendy and nationalistic in the eyes of citizens and armed forces.
They awakened the pride of nation.
There is nothing better anyone could do.
The committee should have had someone from existing DRDO organization key person. There are highly educated and talented people. Their view points may give some difficulty they face. Prioritise the requirement expected of DRDO. Bench mark the laboratory with some of the leading organisations in USA such as DARPA, Israeli defence institute, etc. There is also a need to push for talented people up and procedure to gracefully retire the inefficient professionals from DRDO. Every lab must be mandated to deliver some or the other system relevant to defence departments. Retain people who deliver and sack others. There is also reluctance by armed forces to use DRDO product. It must be a joint prerogative of both DRDO and a wing of armed forces entrusted with delivery of products to armed forces. Give them actionable time bound assignment. Reduce paper work and more on advanced administrative practices.
Great decision to revamp
DRDO. Govt needs to bring similar reforms in PWD and infrastructure sector as there is highly red tapism and incompatible
Shekhar ji, thanks for the usual and wonderful insights. What does DRDE do? And is it a part of DRDO or a parallel establishment (as the name suggests)? I wish you could throw some light on this too!
A division or say lab under DRDO just like ADE RCI CVRDE ARDE etc
@@bhagwat_tech OK. Thanks for the clarification 👍
I listened to your program on DRDO reform. Brilliantly presented and very interesting. A long needed reform is now happening. You might know about DRDL Hyderabad, it was a precursor to DRDO. You mentioned in your talk that the guided missile program was launched in 1980. I believe it was much before that. My father Brig. Aniles Basu, AVSM, was on deputation from the army to DRDL in the guided missile program in the early 60’s.
SEKHAR SIR , YOUR SENSE OF HUMOUR IS TOO GOOD 👍 FOR THAT REASON SG WE ALL LOVE ❤️ YOU .
Someone from DRDO should have been kept in the committee otherwise the committee will not get the true picture of how it functions. Whatever decision the committee takes, without knowing the ground realities, will not be a proper one.
Get rid of old crap. I know few works in DRDO hyderabad who does nothing but go to office on time spend an hour near laptop. Go out have chai bathakani.. go for lunch and spend time roaming around and going back home on time. 60% of employees who doesn’t even have 1 hour work every day.
every developed country has private companies who create advanced weapons, usa, France, uk all have private players, I fail to understand why India is still stuck with these govt agencies. we all know what happens in a govt organisation, no performance reviews, no accountability, people just going to office and waiting for their retirement. India should open its market for private campanies who will compete with each other we can have high quality weapons
All these transformations happen mainly due to the iniatives of the present government, if not for them imagine what could be the scenario . Let them govern for at least a other 20 years and then only we will see new strong and developed Bharat.
Jai Hind. Long live Modiji and hia government
About of contribution made by tam brahms
Unthinkable and insane
Most patriotic community
I wish my community was like that
Modi should be elected back. Hope good sense shall prevail among the voters
Great Move...🙏🙏💪💪❤❤❤
Dhanyavad Sir Ji 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Breakthroghs and Innovations in A.I Technology, X-O Frames & Cybernetics is the Future of Defense Industry.
Wow...the quintessential SG...so much of our own history...feels great to know about the stalwarts and their resolve in making this great Nation stronger everyday
If modi would really be able to reform DRDO like DARPA, i will vote for him for my whole life this one reason is enough for me.
Sir
I have always wondered as to why India lacks rather weak in Research and Development ?
India needs to invest much, much more in R&D .
Hopefully, it will certainly improve NOT in future ~ NOW .
Because we don't have industrial experience in our society. We skipped Industrialisation and went straight to services.
modi hai to mumkin hai. People should not waste their votes on the congress whose only purpose is to protect Gandhi family and make Rahul the prime minister one day who doesn't have any vision for this country.
In most of the research Institutions, the culture of laid back working style has permeated. No body seems to be in a hurry to do any thing. This is not just the defece sector, but also true of research institutions in other fields such as Manufacturing Industry, Power to name two, with which I am familiar. No body sets time-bound goals for them. Their finances are under tight control, much else is laize faire.
Good points 👍
Goes to show how journalism has changed over years. There was a time when journalists held everyone accountable unlike recent times where they are limited to being mouthpiece of the government.
Good your comment was allowed! Well said TRUTH!
With all due respect to you, I'd like to point out a minor error in your reporting, the agency responsible for designing LCA is Aeronautical Development Agency (ADA) and not Aeronautical Development Establishment (ADE).
But, having worked in the setup, all I can say is that, it's in dire need of a top to bottom overhaul. The organisation lacks good leaders, and project management is poor. The admin department should be given proper HR training. Infrastructure is old and scientists sometimes have to struggle for basic amenities like drinking water and food itself. There's no appreciation for the good work and growth and global exposure is also very less. I hope the reforms take into consideration all such things but certainly a step in the right direction. Jai hind
It’s nice to note Shekhar being neutral in politics.
Best decision in the robust our forces and Country, Modi ji great
SG main aapka critic raha hun aur rahunga. DRDO ke reform ke bare mein kahin se bhi badhiya article sunane yah padhne ke liye nahin mila.
Per aapka yah conversation bahut hi authentic aur informative tha.
GE engine aur saffron ke sath Jo karar hue hain Indian technical team ko bahut jaldi jet engine technology mein Maharat hasil karke khud ka jet engine banaa hoga.
Yah bhi ho sakta hai ki DRDO ko defence ke different sector mein divide kar diya jaaye . Jo bhi Ho Jo reform committee bani hai uska outcome bahut hi achcha hoga National interest mein.
Is untouchable subject ko shandar touch dene ke liye aapko shukriya to kahana hi padega .
Transfer of technology(TOT) . Might be a good topic to do an episode on. what it is and its role in indian defense.
We should think in terms of Military-Industrial-Academic complex. That should be the vision.
Your video ɓrings out the frustration being felt by the intelligent people ìn this country
Congress voter to BJP voter
And
Jio to Airtel.
Never regretted.
Free press to Godi Media…
@@CP-bu1hcthat same godi media use to support congress in upa😂😂😂😂 Every media support one political parties be it right wing or liberandu dhruv rathee, deshbhakt,rabish even cnn foxx bbc all support one party😂😂😂😂no media is free
Btw indian government still haven't released funds for AMCA and TEDBF. They have been waiting for funds for more then 1 year and when the project get extended blame would be on DRDO.
Modiji ko Bhagwan be Bharat ki dasha sudharne ko bheja h
Much needed...DRDO needs accountability. They are underperforms.
A stable government can only recommend and execute reformation based on circumstances. Congratulations.🎉
Guptajee, you are among the few rare persons giving the term 'military-industrial complex' a positive spin.
Excellent discussion shekhar sir
I love the way you explain everything so meticulously. You would have been a great teacher actually. Having said that I'm happy you are a genuine journalist.
Nice information, superbly put across. 👍
Question: If after the 1999 Kargil War, the committee composed of the best brains in India had recommended that the DRDO should be reformed, why did it take so much time? Did the then Prime Minister did not listen? 😮