I can watch this one again and again. I was fortunate to attend several performances of this wall tour but the final show in Quebec City on the plains of Abraham was is and probably always will be the greatest concert experience of my life, and I have been to over a thousand different shows.
I was standing 10feet from the soundboard. I had some of the best seats for this show. I was not disappointed. I seen them at 13 in the 80s. Became a Gilmour fan and started to learn the guitar.
I have a feeling that they might have transposed the song down from a D minor scale to a C minor scale for this performance, and that's why the guitar sounds off. I don't know, though. I kinda like it
@@Octanetwisted1983 and it was done because Roger can’t sing as high as he used to. I mean it’s not bad but you can tell he can’t belt it out as high as he used too
Why does the guitar sound like a synthesizer? It should be meatier. I'm more of a Roger fan than Gilmour's version of Floyd, but this version makes me want to see them all back together as opposed to apart. Nice visuals, though.
Much more Pink Floyd than Gilmour could ever hope to be. However, we should all wish them two would resolve their issues n get on with a new real Pink Floyd album not just any diversionary bell side project branded as Floyd.
roger obviously has a lot to say for the best of the floyd sound but to be honest, i think how the other members perhaps tempered roger's desire to get his messages across was a good thing, and when they werent here such as on this tour, you just end up getting it rammed down your throat. I'm actually all for the majority of what he says but first and foremost I think most people like floyd for the music rather than message in the lyrics. must have been a bloody nightmare for the rest of them to have to work with him all those years lol
motherfuckers be like "wow when did these songs about raging against machines and having a party in the desert get political" because the extent of their problems was latchkey parents not giving them hot topic money
+Mitch Farkas I saw Pink Floyd in 1988 and 1994. If Roger Waters isn't singing it ... it REALLY doesn't sound right! Gilmour and Scott Page made a mockery of the lyrics. It felt "campy". This is the best version that's ever been done, IMO. It was already fantastic in the 80/81 concerts, but this is yet better. Aaand . . . It was DAVID GILMOUR's people, not Roger Waters's, who filed copyright-infringement complaints to TH-cam, Vimeo, and everywhere else, repeatedly. www.chillingeffects.org/faceted_search?sender_name=One+Fifteen *"On behalf of One Fifteen who represent the IPR over image, music and performance of 'David Gilmour'. We are the authorised agent of the copyright owner and authorised to act on their behalf."* I'm never arguing about it again: David Gilmour is evil. This is it. I'm done. End of story.
I agree, but Rogers is suppost to be different he uses a C cord to make the song seen more Erie. the normal run like Hell uses a D cord to sound more Stressful. If that makes since.
@@BenCulture Scott Page was the saxophone player. It was David Gilmour and bassist Guy Pratt who sang that song. How in the world did they make that song campy?
I think the exact oposite. Waters is a rebel, this is rebelious music. Gilmour is a nice guy, he is not a rebel. Thats why Animals and The Wall I prefer coming from Waters.
I absolutely agree. I think David Gilmour is a much better musician, live performer, and human being than Roger Waters will ever be. Then again, just my opinion.
![เจ็บที่ยังฮัก - ม่อน วรวิทย์ [ Official Mv ] จอนนี่มิวสิค](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KALIGSRSjFs/mqdefault.jpg)
I can watch this one again and again. I was fortunate to attend several performances of this wall tour but the final show in Quebec City on the plains of Abraham was is and probably always will be the greatest concert experience of my life, and I have been to over a thousand different shows.
When Roger Waters plays at Ball Arena in Denver in 2022, this is the song I look forward to him playing.
and another brick in the wall of course
I really hope he does
He cancelled the show mate
@@BernyMusica he did?
@@josh2k606 Not to my knowledge. Must the show go on ...
Another Masterpiece of hardworking Genius Roger Waters.
I was standing 10feet from the soundboard. I had some of the best seats for this show. I was not disappointed. I seen them at 13 in the 80s. Became a Gilmour fan and started to learn the guitar.
My favorite version. It is so crazy, sometimes I think that I am listening to Ummagumma.
Was this how Roger first pictured The Wall?
Yes, cause he's a visionary
That's my love Roger Waters he has been my babe since the early 60s I love all his music he has the best songs
Me e perdido 2 veces a Roger waters en chile ojalá pase el puto covid para poder verlo y cumplir mi sueño
0:23
*THANK YOOOOOOOOOUUU!!!*
I was surprised to see Steve Bannon up there!
The cool voice.
I have a feeling that they might have transposed the song down from a D minor scale to a C minor scale for this performance, and that's why the guitar sounds off. I don't know, though. I kinda like it
Yes you are correct they lowered it a whole step down to C.
@@Octanetwisted1983 and it was done because Roger can’t sing as high as he used to. I mean it’s not bad but you can tell he can’t belt it out as high as he used too
Why does the guitar sound like a synthesizer? It should be meatier. I'm more of a Roger fan than Gilmour's version of Floyd, but this version makes me want to see them all back together as opposed to apart. Nice visuals, though.
It is a synthesizer.
It's no synth. It's in drop C (CGCFAD) . Sadly the bass is not.
I like Gilmour’s live version of this song much better
Enjoy yourselves ...
Pottente!
PC correct version. RLH lite.
Much more Pink Floyd than Gilmour could ever hope to be.
However, we should all wish them two would resolve their issues n get on with a new real Pink Floyd album not just any diversionary bell side project branded as Floyd.
You mean much more lipsynching than Gilmour *
@@flamingored960 no, that's not what I mean
#blacklivesmatter
Yo no creo en Dios creo en Roger Waters creador de The Wall
roger obviously has a lot to say for the best of the floyd sound but to be honest, i think how the other members perhaps tempered roger's desire to get his messages across was a good thing, and when they werent here such as on this tour, you just end up getting it rammed down your throat. I'm actually all for the majority of what he says but first and foremost I think most people like floyd for the music rather than message in the lyrics. must have been a bloody nightmare for the rest of them to have to work with him all those years lol
motherfuckers be like "wow when did these songs about raging against machines and having a party in the desert get political" because the extent of their problems was latchkey parents not giving them hot topic money
You can name them all Putin and so on! You can count them on your fingers!
If Gilmour is not playing it....It dont sound right
+Mitch Farkas I saw Pink Floyd in 1988 and 1994.
If Roger Waters isn't singing it ... it REALLY doesn't sound right! Gilmour and Scott Page made a mockery of the lyrics. It felt "campy".
This is the best version that's ever been done, IMO. It was already fantastic in the 80/81 concerts, but this is yet better.
Aaand . . . It was DAVID GILMOUR's people, not Roger Waters's, who filed copyright-infringement complaints to TH-cam, Vimeo, and everywhere else, repeatedly.
www.chillingeffects.org/faceted_search?sender_name=One+Fifteen
*"On behalf of One Fifteen who represent the IPR over image, music and performance of 'David Gilmour'. We are the authorised agent of the copyright owner and authorised to act on their behalf."*
I'm never arguing about it again: David Gilmour is evil. This is it. I'm done. End of story.
I agree, but Rogers is suppost to be different he uses a C cord to make the song seen more Erie. the normal run like Hell uses a D cord to sound more Stressful.
If that makes since.
@@BenCulture ?
@@BenCulture Scott Page was the saxophone player. It was David Gilmour and bassist Guy Pratt who sang that song. How in the world did they make that song campy?
@R M I like Gilmours version than Rodger version of the track run like hell
PF RW never was classic rock this aint no sammy hagar this aint no freebird
I see what your saying. PF/RW donsnt sound old, and dusty. Its always fresh, and new. Talking about being ahead of your time
+uh0oo Have any other concept albums remained as socially relevant as PF/RW's?
operationmind crime and rage for order by queenryche?
+Billybob Dipper I've heard good things about those records, but it was a million years ago; are people still INTO Queensryche?
they suck now imo but those two albums and empire were pretty good I think my fav concept album tho is RW's pros and cons of hitchicking
It lacks the excitement of when Pink Floyd do it.
I think the exact oposite. Waters is a rebel, this is rebelious music. Gilmour is a nice guy, he is not a rebel. Thats why Animals and The Wall I prefer coming from Waters.
This sucks compare to every one of David Gilmour's performances. Not even close. I listen for the master guitar work. Just my opinion.
I absolutely agree. I think David Gilmour is a much better musician, live performer, and human being than Roger Waters will ever be. Then again, just my opinion.
Boludos y sordos hay en todos lados..Hacete ver loco..